Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 25th February 2026
+
MAC.APP. 911/2013
NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Manoj Ranjan Sinha & Mr.
Vishal Agrawal, Advocates
versus
RAJESH & ORS
.....Respondents
Through:
Mr. Navneet Goyal, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has filed challenging the award dated 01 st August 2013
passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Saket, New Delhi
[“Tribunal”] in MAC Suit No. 110/2011, where by the Tribunal awarded
compensation to the tune of Rs.22,84,500/- along with interest @ 9% p.a.
Incident
2.
The accident occurred on 25th February 2011, when the injured, a
student of Class V, aged 11 years, was going to his school along with his
brother, when he was hit by a car bearing No. DL-9CM-5027 [offending
vehicle] and sustained grievous injuries. The said offending vehicle was
being driven by Rajesh, respondent no.1.
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 911/2013
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:30
3.
The compensation has been challenged by the appellant/Insurance
Company, inter alia, on the following grounds:
a. Multiplier of ‘18’ was applied, which is on higher side, and same
ought to have been ‘15’;
b. Tribunal awarded higher amount towards attendant charges as well
as interest on future medical expenses; and
c. Tribunal erred in awarding an excessive amount of Rs.5,25,000/under non-pecuniary heads by treating loss of earning capacity at
100%.
4.
Mr. Manoj Ranjan Sinha, Counsel for appellant/Insurance Company,
has placed reliance on decision Divya v. National Insurance Company Ltd.
Civil Appeal No.7605/2022 and Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar (2011) 1 SCC
343.
Analysis
5.
Injured was only 11 years school going child who suffered cord injury
D10 to D12 with paraplegia, fracture shaft to right femur, traumatic
paraplegia with BB involvement, fracture of middle 3rd right femur, fracture
undisplaced (right Tibia), and fracture medial condyle left femur. Injuries
resulted in traumatic paraplegia with neurogenic bowel and bladder, and he
has suffered 100 % permanent disability as certified by the Medical Board
of Safdarjung Hospital.
6.
This Court has already taken a view in Tata AIG General Insurance
Company v. Mukesh Kumar & Ors. 2026:DHC:756, relying on a previous
decision of this Court National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sanju & Ors.
2025:DHC:11781, which assessed the decisions of the Supreme Court,
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 911/2013
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:30
including Divya v. National Insurance Company Ltd. (supra), holding that
a multiplier of ‘18’ should be applied while computing compensation for a
minor below ‘15’ years. The Court is not inclined to differ with the same.
7.
The relevant observations made by this Court in National Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Sanju & Ors (supra) are extracted as under:
“26. In my view, the argument, at least before this
Court, is foreclosed by the judgments in Pooja,
Rakesh Sharma, and Bhupan Paswan, where the
multiplier 18 has been adopted after considering the
judgments in Sarla Verma, Kajal, Master Ayush, and
Sakshi Greola. The discussion on this aspect in
Bhupan Paswan reads as follows:
“31. The learned Tribunal has computed the
compensation by applying a multiplier of 15, by
considering the age of the deceased.
32. The calculation of Multiplier has been laid
down in the case of Sarla Varma (Supra) as
under:“21. We therefore hold that the multiplier to
be used should be as mentioned in column (4)
of the Table above (prepared by applying
Susamma Thomas, Trilok Chandra and
Charlie), which starts with an operative
multiplier of 18 (for the age groups of 15 to
20 and 21 to 25 years), reduced by one unit
for every five years, that is M-17 for 26 to 30
years, M-16 for 31 to 35 years, M-15 for 36
to 40 years, M-14 for 41 to 45 years, and M13 for 46 to 50 years, then reduced by two
units for every five years, that is, M-11 for 51
to 55 years, M-9 for 56 to 60 years, M-7 for
61 to 65 years and M-5 for 66 to 70 years.”
33. Evidently, the Judgment is silent on the multiplier
to be used for the victims under 15 years of age. This
incongruity in the matter of selection of multiplier in
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 911/2013
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:30
the case of persons in the age group up to 15 years
was noted in by the Apex the case of Divya vs.
National Insurance Company Ltd., Civil Appeal No.
7605/2022.
34. In the most recent judgment of the Supreme Court
in Baby Sakshi Greola vs. Manzoor Ahmad Simon &
Anr., SLP (C) No. 10996/2018, while referring to the
judgments of Kajal (supra) and Master Ayush
(supra), the Apex Court has applied the multiplier of
18 for a minor.
35. Thus, in light of the above judgments, this Court
deems it appropriate to ascertain the Multiplier as
‘18’ to calculate the loss of dependency is calculated
accordingly.”
As noted above, the Supreme Court declined special
leave to appeal against this judgment.
27. Having regard to the binding judgment of the
Coordinate Bench, which considers Sarla Verma, I
am of the view that the applicable multiplier in such
cases would be 18.”
(emphasis added)
8.
Taking a similar view, this Court in Tata AIG General Insurance
Company v. Mukesh Kumar & Ors (supra), while dealing with an appeal
filed by the Insurance Company on the ground that the Tribunal while
assessing loss of dependency in case of death of a minor child had erred
by taking the multiplier of ‘18’, instead of ‘15’, and that income of the
deceased should either be determined on the basis of notional income or
that of an unskilled worker, dismissed the said appeal and held as under:
“22.6 Analysing all these decisions, this Court in
Sanju (supra) held the view, as extracted above in
paragraph 14, that the applicable multiplier would be
18 and that minimum wages of a skilled worker of the
concerned State would be applicable.
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 911/2013
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:30
23. In view of the above discussion, contention of
appellant cannot be accepted.”
(emphasis added)
9.
As regards the issue of attendant charges, the Tribunal has taken
Rs.150/- per day as charges i.e. Rs.4,500/- per month. This is much lower,
as stated by Mr. Goyal, in light of decision of the Supreme Court in Kajal v.
Jagdish Chand and Ors. (2020) 4 SCC 413, where Rs.10,000/- per month
for two attendants for 18 years was awarded. Relevant paragraph of
impugned award is extracted as under:
“18. The victim as per medical record, in accident has
suffered traumatic paraplegia (fracture DIO with
neurogenic bowel & bladder. It is emphatically stated by
doctor that presently petitioner is wheelchair bound and
dependent on the caregiver for some of his activities of
daily living like bathing, toileting, dressing of lower limbs.
He also stated that petitioner requires a permanent
attendant to help him in day to day activities. It is clear
from aforesaid deposition that petitioner will require an
attendant to assist him in his daily activities for 24 hours.
The claimant's age as on date of accident was 11 years old.
The life expectancy of petitioner can be presumed to be at
least 55 years. The claimant as on date of accident was 11
years old which means that remaining period of live
expectancy i.e. 44 years he require service of attendance.
Average cost of keeping a home attendant is taken at Rs.
150 per day. Accordingly, the monthly expenses on an
attendant works out to be Rs. 4,500/- and annual expenses
comes out to be Rs.54,000/- adopting multiplier method i.e.
18, the total amount comes to Rs. 9,72,000/.”
10.
The Tribunal returned a categorical finding, based on the
uncontroverted medical evidence, that the injured suffered traumatic
paraplegia and is permanently wheelchair-bound. PW1/Dr. Srikumar,
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 911/2013
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:30
stated that injured is dependent on a caregiver for essential activities of daily
day to day activities.
11.
Considering the age of the injured (11 years at the time of accident),
the Tribunal reasonably assessed the remaining life expectancy and
computed attendant charges at a modest rate of Rs.150/- per day, applying
the multiplier of ‘18’, arriving at Rs.9,72,000/-.
12.
The issue of attendant charges in cases of permanent disability has
been considered by the Supreme Court in Kajal v. Jagdish Chand (supra),
wherein the Supreme Court underscored that in cases of permanent
disability of a minor resulting in lifelong dependency, provision for
continuous attendant care is integral to the award of “just compensation”.
For ease of reference relevant paragraphs are extracted as under:
“22. The attendant charges have been awarded by the
High Court @ Rs 2500 per month for 44 years, which
works out to Rs 13,20,000. Unfortunately, this system is
not a proper system. Multiplier system is used to balance
out various factors. When compensation is awarded in
lump sum, various factors are taken into consideration.
When compensation is paid in lump sum, this Court has
always followed the multiplier system. The multiplier
system should be followed not only for determining the
compensation on account of loss of income but also for
determining the attendant charges, etc. This system was
recognised by this Court in Gobald Motor Service Ltd.
v. R.M.K. Veluswami [Gobald Motor Service Ltd. v.
R.M.K. Veluswami, AIR 1962 SC 1]. The multiplier
system factors in the inflation rate, the rate of interest
payable on the lump sum award, the longevity of the
claimant, and also other issues such as the uncertainties
of life. Out of all the various alternative methods, the
multiplier method has been recognised as the most
realistic and reasonable method. It ensures better
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 911/2013
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:30
justice between the parties and thus results in award of
“just compensation” within the meaning of the Act.
23. It would be apposite at this stage to refer to the
observation of Lord Reid in Taylor v. O'Connor [Taylor
v. O'Connor, 1971 AC 115 : (1970) 2 WLR 472 (HL)] :
(AC p. 128)
“Damages to make good the loss of dependency
over a period of years must be awarded as a lump
sum and that sum is generally calculated by
applying a multiplier to the amount of one year's
dependency. That is a perfectly good method in the
ordinary case but it conceals the fact that there are
two quite separate matters involved — the present
value of the series of future payments, and the
discounting of that present value to allow for the
fact that for one reason or another the person
receiving the damages might never have enjoyed
the whole of the benefit of the dependency. It is
quite unnecessary in the ordinary case to deal with
these matters separately. Judges and counsel have
a wealth of experience which is an adequate guide
to the selection of the multiplier and any expert
evidence is rightly discouraged. But in a case
where the facts are special I think that these
matters must have separate consideration if even
rough justice is to be done and expert evidence may
be valuable or even almost essential. The special
factor in the present case is the incidence of income
tax and, it may be, surtax.”
24. This Court has reaffirmed the multiplier method in
various cases like MCD v. Subhagwanti [MCD v.
Subhagwanti, AIR 1966 SC 1750 : 1966 ACJ 57] , U.P.
SRTC v. Trilok Chandra [U.P. SRTC v. Trilok Chandra,
(1996) 4 SCC 362] , Sandeep Khanuja v. Atul Dande
[Sandeep Khanuja v. Atul Dande, (2017) 3 SCC 351 :
(2017) 2 SCC (Civ) 276 : (2017) 2 SCC (Cri) 178] . This
Court has also recognised that Schedule II of the Act
can be used as a guide for the multiplier to be applied
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 911/2013
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:30
in each case. Keeping the claimant's age in mind, the
multiplier in this case should be 18 as opposed to 44
taken by the High Court.
25. Having held so, we are clearly of the view that the
basic amount taken for determining the attendant
charges is very much on the lower side. We must
remember that this little girl is severely suffering from
incontinence, meaning that she does not have control
over her bodily functions like passing urine and faeces.
As she grows older, she will not be able to handle her
periods. She requires an attendant virtually 24 hours a
day. She requires an attendant who though may not be
medically trained but must be capable of handling a
child who is bedridden. She would require an attendant
who would ensure that she does not suffer from
bedsores. The claimant has placed before us a
notification of the State of Haryana of the year 2010,
wherein the wages for skilled labourer is Rs 4846 per
month. We, therefore, assess the cost of one attendant at
Rs 5000 and she will require two attendants which
works out to Rs 10,000 per month, which comes to Rs
1,20,000 p.a., and using the multiplier of 18, it works
out to Rs 21,60,000 for the attendant charges for her
entire life. This takes care of all the pecuniary
damages.”
(emphasis added)
13.
It is well settled that the duty of the Claims Tribunal and the Appellate
Court under Section 168 of the MV Act is to award “just compensation” on
the basis of the evidence placed on record. The determination of
compensation cannot be circumscribed merely by the amount claimed or by
the absence of a cross-appeal or cross-objections by the claimant. In
Nagappa v. Gurudayal Singh (2003) 2 SCC 274, the Supreme Court
categorically held that there is no restriction under the Motor Vehicles Act
that the Tribunal or Court cannot award compensation exceeding the amount
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 911/2013
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:30
claimed, so long as the compensation awarded is just, reasonable and
supported by the evidence on record. Relevant paragraph is extracted as
under:
“21. For the reasons discussed above, in our view, under
the MV Act, there is no restriction that the
Tribunal/court cannot award compensation amount
exceeding the claimed amount. The function of the
Tribunal/court is to award “just” compensation which
is reasonable on the basis of evidence produced on
record. Further, in such cases there is no question of
claim becoming time-barred or it cannot be contended
that by enhancing the claim there would be change of
cause of action. It is also to be stated that as provided
under sub-section (4) to Section 166, even the report
submitted to the Claims Tribunal under sub-section (6)
of Section 158 can be treated as an application for
compensation under the MV Act. If required, in
appropriate cases, the court may permit amendment to
the claim petition.”
14.
Further, the appellate court, while exercising powers under Order XLI
Rule 33 CPC, is empowered to mould the relief and enhance compensation
where the circumstances so warrant, even in the absence of a cross-appeal
by the claimant. The guiding principle remains that the Court must ensure
that the victim receives fair and adequate compensation in accordance with
the mandate of the statute. In view of the above legal position and the
medical evidence on record establishing the requirement of a permanent
attendant, the attendant charges awarded by the Tribunal warrant
reconsideration.
15.
This Court as per the decision of the Supreme Court finds it apposite
to enhance the attendant charges, as the attendant charges given by the
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 911/2013
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:30
Tribunal seemed conservative in nature. The notification issued by the
Government of NCT of Delhi, Labour Department on 26 th July 2011,
showed that minimum wages of a ‘skilled’ person shall be counted at
Rs.7,826/- per month. Accordingly, the enhanced attendant charges shall be
at Rs.93,912/- annually and applying the multiplier of ‘18’ would bring it to
Rs.16,90,416/-.
16.
As regards the non-pecuniary heads, this Court finds that, considering
the age of injured i.e. 11 years, and the fact that he sustained 100% disability
in the accident, the amounts as granted by the Tribunal are not exaggerated
in any manner and ought to be sustained.
17.
With respect to future medical expenses, the Tribunal’s finding in this
regard appears to be justified.
18.
Argument
by
Mr.
Manoj
Ranjan
Sinha,
Counsel
for
appellant/Insurance Company that interest cannot be granted on elements
relating to future prospects and future medical expenses, has now been
considered by the Supreme Court in Oriental Insurance Company v. Niru
@ Niharika (2025) INSC 822, where the Court while deliberating on the
concept of interest on future prospects, stated as under:
“9. A very relevant issue agitated by the Insurance
Company is the illegality in awarding interest for future
prospects, which in any event is an amount received in
advance, normally inuring to the benefit of the claimants
only in future. This is the only contention taken in the
connected appeal bearing SLP(C) No.22136 of 2024.
We find absolutely no reason to accept this argument. In
SLP(C) No.11340 of 2020, the multiplier applied
looking at the life span of the deceased and the
claimants is 13. Before the Tribunal itself, the case was
pending for 12 years and the only amount received by
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 911/2013
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:30
the claimants was Rs.50,000/-. Hence though amounts
are awarded for future prospects taking the multiplier
of 13; in effect, the money is received only after the
period for which the multiplier is adopted. Similar is the
case in SLP(C) No.22136 of 2024 where the accident
occurred in 2018, the multiplier applied is 17 and we
are seven years from the date of accident.
………
11. In fact, it is due to the repudiation of or refusal to
consider the claim that the claimants are driven to the
Tribunal. When the matter is pending before the
Tribunal or in appeal before the higher forums, the
claimants are deprived of the compensation for future
prospects. If they are paid in time, it could be utilized by
the claimants and on failure, the loss of dependency
would force the claimants to source their livelihood
from elsewhere. This is sought to be compensated at
least minimally by award of interest, which oftener them
ever is nominal also since only simple interest is
awarded. If the amounts were disbursed to the claimants
on a rough calculation, on intimation of the accident to
the Insurance Company, subject to the award of the
Tribunal, necessarily there would not have been any
interest liability atleast to the extent of the disbursement
made. Hence, we reject the contention and direct that
the entire award amounts would be paid with interest at
the rate of 9% from the date of filing of the claim till the
date of disbursement, deducting only Rs.50,000/granted as interim compensation, in SLP(C) No.11340
of 2020 and 6% in SLP(C) No.22136 of 2024 as
awarded by the High Court; deduction to be made for
the amounts already paid.”
(emphasis added)
19.
The same reasoning would apply to compensation for future medical
expenses. The compensation awarded is an amount provided for various
aspects of deprivation from a regular life which would have been lived had
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 911/2013
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:30
the injured not met with the accident. The interest component is for the
period during which the claimants ought to have received the said
compensation, until the same was adjudicated, awarded and paid/deposited.
20.
Therefore, this ground also does not subsist.
21.
Accordingly, compensation is re-computed as under:
Sr. No.
Heads
Awarded By The
Tribunal
Awarded by
this Court
PECUNIARY LOSS
Expenditure on treatment (A)
Rs.49,500/Expenditure on conveyance (B)
Rs. 50,000/Expenditure on special diet (C)
Rs.40,000/Cost of nursing / attendant (D)
Rs.9,72,000/[Rs.4500 x 18]
Rs.49,500/Rs. 50,000/Rs.40,000/Rs.16,90,416/-.
[Rs.7826 x 18]
Loss of earning capacity (E)
Rs.6,48,000/Loss of income (F)
Rs.36,000/Any other loss which may
Nil
require any special treatment or
aid to the injured for the rest of
his life (G)
Future Medical Expenses
Rs.75,000/NON PECUNIARY LOSS
Compensation for mental and
Nil
physical shock (H)
Pain and suffering (I)
Rs.3,00,000/Loss of amenities of life (J)
Rs.50,000/Disfiguration (K)
Nil
Loss of marriage prospects (L)
Rs.1,00,000/Loss of earning,
Nil
inconvenience, hardships,
disappointment, frustration,
mental stress, dejectment and
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 911/2013
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:30
Rs.6,48,000/Rs.36,000/Nil
Rs.75,000/Nil
Rs.3,00,000/Rs.50,000/Nil
Rs.1,00,000/Nil
unhappiness in future life etc.
(M)
DISABILITY RESULTING IN LOSS OF EARNING CAPACITY
Percentage of disability
100% permanent 100% permanent
assessed and nature of
disability
disability
disability as permanent or
temporary
Loss of amenities or loss of
Assessed above
Assessed above
expectation of life span on
account of disability
Percentage of loss of earning
45%
45%
capacity in relation to disability
Loss of future income (Income
Rs.6,48,000/Rs.6,48,000/X% Earning capacity x
[Rs.3000 x 12 x
[Rs.3000 x 12 x
Multiplier)
18]
18]
TOTAL COMPENSATION
Rs. 22,84,500/Rs. 30,02,916/INTEREST AWARDED
9%
9%
22.
For the aforesaid reasons, the impugned award is modified. The
compensation is enhanced by a sum of Rs. 7,18,416/-, as computed
hereinabove.
23.
By order dated 9th October 2013, 80% of the amount had been directed
to be deposited and 60% was directed to be released.
24.
The appeal is accordingly disposed of.
25.
Since the appeal stands disposed of in above terms, it is directed that
enhanced amount be deposited by the appellant/Insurance Company before
the Registry of this Court within a period of four weeks from today.
Disbursement of the amounts so deposited shall be made in terms of
impugned award.
26.
A copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned Tribunal.
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 911/2013
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:30
27.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
28.
Statutory deposit (if any) shall be refunded to appellant.
29.
Judgement be uploaded on the website of this Court.
ANISH DAYAL, J
FEBRUARY 25, 2026/sm/tk
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 911/2013
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:30
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review