Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision: 16th March 2026
+
MAC.APP. 709/2013
NATIONAL INSURANCE CO LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Pankaj Seth, Ms. Vijay Laxmi,
Advocates.
versus
MRS MUNNI & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Kishlay Kumar, Advocate for
Respondent no.1.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has been filed challenging the Award dated 5 th June
2013 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Tis Hazari Courts,
Delhi (‘MACT’) in Suit No.141/2012, whereby compensation of
Rs.6,16,350/- along with interest @ 9% per annum in respect of an
accident which occurred on 24th February 2010 within the jurisdiction of
P.S. Kashmere Gate.
2.
On the day of the accident, claimant was deboarding the bus
No.DL-1PB-4949, offending vehicle, driven by respondent no.2/ driver,
who suddenly moved the bus in a rash and negligent manner. As a result
of which, the injured fell from the bus and sustained grievous injuries.
The injured was taken to hospital where MLC was prepared and FIR no.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:01:38
MAC.APP. 709/2013
229 was subsequently registered under section 279/337 Indian Penal
Code, 1860.
3.
Mr. Pankaj Seth, counsel for Insurance Company, draws attention
of the Court to the fact that initially the FIR was not lodged, and the
same was lodged only on the directions of the higher authority, as stated
in the MACT’s award. He states, therefore, that the issue of negligence
would hang in balance, as far as the accident is concerned.
4.
The MACT, however, while determining issue no.1, has relied
upon the testimony of PW1 (the injured/claimant) as well as PW3, who
was accompanying the claimant on the day of the accident. Considering
that there was an eye-witness, the MACT concluded that there was a
uniformity in the testimonies of the witnesses. Also, the injured/claimant
was taken to Bara Hindu Rao Hospital and MLC was prepared, which
records that the injuries were sustained due to the road traffic accident.
5.
It is well settled by a catena of judgments of the Supreme Court
that claims under the Motor Vehicles Act are to be established on the
touchstone of preponderance of probabilities and not beyond reasonable
doubt. Where the evidence renders one version more probable than not,
the claimant’s burden stands discharged. Reliance in this regard may be
be placed on the judgment of Bimla Devi v. Himachal RTC, (2009) 13
SCC 530, which was subsequently followed in Geeta Dubey v. United
India Insurance Co. Ltd., 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3779. The relevant
paragraph of Bimla Devi (supra) is extracted as below:
“15. In a situation of this nature, the Tribunal has
rightly taken a holistic view of the matter. It was
necessary to be borne in mind that strict proof of an
accident caused by a particular bus in a particular
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:01:38
MAC.APP. 709/2013
manner may not be possible to be done by the
claimants. The claimants were merely to establish their
case on the touchstone of preponderance of
probability. The standard of proof beyond reasonable
doubt could not have been applied. For the said
purpose, the High Court should have taken into
consideration the respective stories set forth by both
the parties.”
(emphasis supplied)
6.
In the present case, this Court is of the opinion that the contention
of Insurance Company regarding delay in registering the FIR does not
dislodge the finding of negligence by the MACT. Applying the principle
laid down in Bimla Devi (supra), the standard of proof in motor accident
claims is that of preponderance of probabilities and not proof beyond
reasonable doubt. The consistent testimonies of PW1 and PW3, coupled
with the MLC prepared at Bara Hindu Rao Hospital recording injuries
arising out of a road traffic accident, render the claimant’s version more
probable. Accordingly, the finding of negligence arrived at by the
MACT warrants no interference.
7.
The disability as per the Disability Certificate was assessed at 40%
in relation to the left lower limb. It was also noted by the MACT that the
period of treatment continued for about 10 months and, therefore,
awarded amounts for special diet, conveyance and loss of income. The
injured claimant was employed in the Municipal Corporation of Delhi
(‘MCD’) but had taken voluntary retirement on her own because of the
disability. On this account, the loss future income was awarded at a lump
sum of Rs.2,00,000/-.
8.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:01:38
The Court has perused the MACT award, which records that there
MAC.APP. 709/2013
was fracture of neck of fibula bone and fracture of 4th & 5th metatarsal of
left leg with advice of daily dressing, limb elevation and medications.
The various dates on which the medical review had to be allocated, and
treatment continued has been noted in paragraph no.10 of the MACT’s
award; Disability Certificate assessing 40% disability in relation to left
lower limb has been filed on record.
9.
Mr. Pankaj Seth, counsel for appellant, assails award of loss of
future income granted at lump sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- on account of
voluntary retirement.
10.
The salary of the claimant was Rs.19,440/- in December 2010. On
the assumption that she would suffer financial loss in terms of reemployment, a lump sum was amount awarded.
11.
The Court is not inclined to accept the argument of counsel for
appellant in this regard. Reliance can be placed on decision Govind
Singh Mauni v Tej Bhan & Ors. 2026: DHC:1020 wherein the decision
of Ball v. William Hunts and Sons Ltd. (1912) A.C 496 was cited as
regards the issue of potentiality of losing income. The Court recorded as
under:
“18. The essential principle follows from the House of
Lords’ decision in Ball v. William Hunts and Sons
(supra) which is highlighted in the following extract in
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Rajbir Singh & Ors
(supra):
“There is also an opinion of the House of lords
that may be relevant to understand this concept.
Ball v. William Hunts and Sons Limited, (1912) AC
496, was the case of a workman, who was blinded
in one eye. The defect was not visible and he was
to have appearance as two-eyed man. He had come
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:01:38
MAC.APP. 709/2013
to such a disability status when he had sustained
an employment injury in which the defective eye
had to be removed with the consequences that he
could not get employment though physically he was
as well as before. The House of Lords held that the
incapacity of work included inability to work, or in
other words, there is incapacity for work when a
man has physical defect which makes his working
unsaleable in any market reasonably accessible to
him. Applying the same logic, a person who has
suffered an injury may not come by immediate loss
if he is retained in the same employment and does
not lose his job, but in his own saleability
elsewhere as a fresh recruit to a new employer, he
may come by a serious handicap. That shall come
by a serious handicap. That shall be a justification
enough to provide for compensation in such types
of cases.”
… 28. In Ball v. William Hunt & Sons Ltd. (supra), the
focus was placed on ‘marketability of labour’ rather
than mere wage continuity. This reasoning was
expressly approved by the United States Supreme
Court in New York Central Railroad Co. v. Bianc;
American Knife Co. v. Sweeting, 1919 SCC OnLine US
SC 210, while upholding the validity of compensation
for serious disfigurement under the New York
Workmen’s Compensation Law. The U.S. Supreme
Court observed that serious physical disfigurement
may reasonably and adversely affect a person’s ability
to obtain or retain employment, and relied upon the
reasoning in Ball v. William Hunt & Sons Ltd., (supra),
to underscore that diminished employability constitutes
a legitimate basis for compensation, independent of
immediate loss of earning power.
29. Although Ball v. William Hunt & Sons Ltd. (supra),
and the American Knife Co. (supra) decision arose in
the context of workmen’s compensation statutes, the
underlying principle is fully consonant with Indian
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:01:38
MAC.APP. 709/2013
Supreme Court jurisprudence under the Motor
Vehicles Act. The Act mandates the award of “just
compensation” under Section 168, which, as
emphasised in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay
Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680 and Sarla Verma v. DTC,
(2009) 6 SCC 121, must be fair, realistic and
proximate to the actual loss suffered. Once functional
disability affecting earning capacity is established,
compensation must be assessed using the multiplier
method, irrespective of the fact that the claimant may
have continued in service or received increments postaccident.
30. The denial of compensation for loss of future
earning capacity solely on the ground that the claimant
continues in employment or has not suffered immediate
wage loss would be inconsistent with settled Supreme
Court jurisprudence. The law recognises that economic
vulnerability, reduced employability, and diminished
labour-market acceptability and inability to secure
employment are real and compensable consequences of
permanent disability. Comparative jurisprudence,
including Ball v. William Hunt & Sons Ltd. (supra) as
approved by the U.S. Supreme Court, reinforces this
understanding and supports a principled, forwardlooking assessment of loss of earning capacity in motor
accident claims.”
(emphasis supplied)
12.
In the present case, this Court finds that the principle laid down in
Ball v. William Hunt & Sons Ltd.(supra) is squarely applicable, wherein
the emphasis is on the “marketability of labour”. Though the claimant
was employed with MCD and took voluntary retirement, the 40%
permanent disability in the left lower limb would affect her ability to
secure employment in any market reasonably accessible to her.
Accordingly, even in case of voluntary retirement the diminished
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:01:38
MAC.APP. 709/2013
employability and reduced saleability in the labour market justify the
lumpsum grant of Rs. 2,00,000/- towards loss of future income.
13.
The Court does not see any reason to interfere in this award, which
awarded just and reasonable compensation, taking into account principle
of preponderance of probabilities and marketability of labour.
Direction
14.
Vide order dated 13th August 2013, this Court stayed the impugned
award subject to the deposit of entire awarded amount along with up-todate interest accrued with the Registrar General of This Court. Further,
release of 70% of the awarded amount was directed in favour of the
claimant as per the terms and conditions fixed by the Tribunal and the
remaining amount was to be kept in Fixed Deposit Receipts with auto
renewal mode.
15.
The Registrar General of this Court is directed that the balance
amount with accrued interest shall be released in favour of the claimant
as per the terms and conditions fixed by the Tribunal.
16.
Therefore, in view of above, appeal stands dismissed.
17.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
18.
Statutory deposit, if any, be refunded to the appellant.
19.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
MARCH 16, 2026/ak/zb
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:01:38
MAC.APP. 709/2013
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review