Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision: 24th February 2026
+
MAC.APP. 37/2017
NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.
Through:
Mr. Prakhar
Advocate.
Appellant
Mani
Tripathi,
versus
KUSUM KUMARI & ORS.
Through:
.....Respondents
Ms. Aruna Mehta, Mr. Lakshay
Mehta, Advocates for R-1 to R-4.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has been filed by the Insurance Company assailing the
Award dated 8th November 2016 passed by the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, North East District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi [8Tribunal] in
MACT No.385/2012 and MACT New No.14755/2015.
Incident
2.
Accident occurred on 26th June 2012 at about 3:20 A.M. near the
Shastri Park red light, within the jurisdiction of Police Station New Usman
Pur. Deceased, Late Shri Ram Nath, was travelling towards Ghaziabad in
truck bearing registration no. HR-38G-1331 along with its driver, Babu
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:02:55
MAC.APP. 37/2017
Ram. The said vehicle, allegedly being driven in a rash and negligent
manner, collided with a stationary truck bearing registration no. HR-38J1575 stationed ahead at the traffic signal, resulting in grievous injuries to
the deceased and the driver. Both were removed to Jag Pravesh Hospital,
where deceased succumbed to the injuries during the course of treatment.
FIR No.173/2012 under Sections 279/337/304-A of the Indian Penal
Code 1860 [IPC] was registered in respect of the accident. The offending
vehicle was insured for the relevant period. Legal representatives [8LRs9]
of the deceased filed a claim petition on 31st October 2012 seeking
compensation of Rs. 20,00,000/-, stating that deceased was employed as a
conductor/helper with M/s. Kuber Enterprises.
Impugned Award
3.
The Tribunal, upon consideration of the pleadings and evidence,
returned a finding that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent
driving of the offending truck. In arriving at this conclusion, the Tribunal
relied upon the testimony of the eye-witness [driver of the stationary
truck], the Detailed Accident Report [DAR], FIR, site plan, post-mortem
report and mechanical inspection report.
4.
The Tribunal observed that these materials constituted sufficient
proof of negligence in motor accident claim proceedings, which are to be
decided on the touchstone of preponderance of probabilities and not strict
rules of evidence. The driver of the offending vehicle did not enter the
witness box to rebut the claim, and no contrary evidence was led on behalf
of the respondents.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:02:55
MAC.APP. 37/2017
5.
For assessment of compensation, the Tribunal considered the
evidence of Smt. Kusum Kumari, wife of deceased [PW-1], who stated
that the deceased was employed as a conductor/helper. However, in the
absence of proof from the employer, the Tribunal assessed the income on
the basis of minimum wages applicable to an 8unskilled9 worker at the
time of the accident, i.e. Rs. 7,020/- per month. The age of the deceased
was taken in the bracket of 41–45 years based on the post-mortem report
and documentary record, and the multiplier of 8149 was applied in terms
of Sarla Verma v. DTC (2009) 6 SCC 121. Considering that the deceased
was survived by four dependants, one-fourth of the income was deducted
towards personal expenses, and future prospects at the rate of 30% were
added. The Tribunal accordingly computed the loss of dependency.
6.
The Tribunal further held that the offending vehicle was duly
insured and, there being no proof of policy violation or that the deceased
was a gratuitous passenger, the insurer was liable to satisfy the award.
Compensation awarded
7.
On the basis of the above assessment, the Tribunal awarded a total
compensation of Rs. 13,84,876/- in favour of the LRs of deceased,
comprising Rs. 11,49,876/- towards loss of dependency and amounts
under conventional heads, namely Rs. 1,00,000/- towards loss of love and
affection, Rs. 1,00,000/- towards loss of consortium, Rs. 10,000/- towards
loss of estate and Rs. 25,000/- towards funeral expenses. The award was
directed to carry interest @ 9% per annum from the date of filing of the
petition till realization, payable by the insurer.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:02:55
MAC.APP. 37/2017
8.
The compensation awarded by the Tribunal is summarised as under:
S.NO
HEADS
AWARDED BY
TRIBUNAL
1.
Loss of Dependency
Rs. 11,49,876/-
2.
Loss of Love and Affection to Children
Rs. 1,00,000/-
3.
Funeral Expenses
Rs.25,000/-
4.
Loss of Estate
Rs.10,000/-
5.
Loss of Consortium
Rs.1,00,000/-
TOTAL
Rs. 13,84,876/-
INTEREST
9%
Analysis
9.
Mr. Prakhar Mani Tripathi, counsel for appellant/Insurance
Company, contends that the deceased was a <gratuitous passenger=
travelling in the truck bearing registration no.HR-38G-1331, which struck
a stationary truck bearing registration no.HR-38J-1575 on 26th June 2012
at about 03:20 a.m., resulting in the death of Sh. Ram Nath [deceased].
10.
The appellant/Insurance Company raised a plea before the Tribunal
that deceased was travelling as a <gratuitous passenger= in a truck which
was owned by M/s Pushpa Trading Corporation, and that the deceased
was an employee of M/s Kuber Enterprises.
11.
The Tribunal undertook the assessment in paragraph nos.6 & 7 of
the impugned award. It noted the statement of Smt. Kusum Kumari, wife
of deceased [PW1], who stated in her affidavit exhibited as Ex.PW1/A
that the deceased was working as a <conductor/helper= with M/s Kuber
Enterprises and was earning a salary of Rs.7,748/- per month. The
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:02:55
MAC.APP. 37/2017
Insurance Company, therefore, stated that the deceased was a <gratuitous
passenger= and unrelated to M/s Pushpa Trading Corporation and,
therefore, was not covered under the insurance policy for the goodscarrying.
12.
The Tribunal, however, noted that there was no evidence to show
that the deceased was travelling as a <gratuitous passenger=, and no such
suggestion was even given to the witness that the deceased was a
<gratuitous passenger=. On the contrary, it was argued by the claimant
that he was transporting the goods of M/s Kuber Enterprises in the truck
and was travelling as the owner of the goods in the offending vehicle and,
therefore, was covered under insurance policy in terms of Section 147(1)
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 [8MV Act9].
13.
In the opinion of this Court, the plea of the insurer that the deceased
was travelling as a <gratuitous passenger= is liable to be rejected, for the
reasons that follow.
14.
The term <gratuitous passenger= though not defined by the MV
Act, means an individual who travels in a vehicle without paying a fare or
providing any economic benefit to the driver or owner, often riding by
invitation, or having been given a lift. However, Section 147 (1) (b) (ii) of
the MV Act expressly exempts the case of a <gratuitous passenger= in a
goods vehicle in a public place.
15.
Section 147 of the MV Act provides for the requirements of an
insurance policy and limits of liability. For ease of reference said section
is extracted as under:
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:02:55
MAC.APP. 37/2017
<147. Requirement of policies and limits of liability.4(1)
In order to comply with the requirements of this Chapter,
a policy of insurance must be a policy which4
(a) is issued by a person who is an authorised insurer; and
(b) insures the person or classes of persons specified in the
policy to the extent specified in sub-section (2)4
(i) against any liability which may be incurred by him
in respect of the death of or bodily injury to any
person including owner of the goods or his authorised
representative carried in the motor vehicle or damage
to any property of a third party caused by or arising
out of the use of the motor vehicle in a public place;
(ii) against the death of or bodily injury to any
passenger of a transport vehicle, except gratuitous
passengers of a goods vehicle, caused by or arising
out of the use of the motor vehicle in a public place.
Explanation.4For the removal of doubts, it is hereby
clarified that the death of or bodily injury to any person or
damage to any property of a third party shall be deemed to
have been caused by or to have arisen out of, the use of a
vehicle in a public place, notwithstanding that the person
who is dead or injured or the property which is damaged
was not in a public place at the time of the accident, if the
act or omission which led to the accident occurred in a
public place.
………
(6) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law
for the time being in force, an insurer issuing a policy of
insurance under this section shall be liable to indemnify
the person or classes of persons specified in the policy in
respect of any liability which the policy purports to cover
in the case of that person or those classes of persons.=
(emphasis added)
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:02:55
MAC.APP. 37/2017
16.
In New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Asha Rani (2003) 2 SCC 223,
the Supreme Court clarified that a goods vehicle is not meant for carrying
passengers and <gratuitous passengers= are not covered under the
statutory policy. However, the statutory scheme underwent a material
change with the 1994 amendment to Section 147 of the MV Act, whereby
the policy is required to cover the owner of goods or his authorised
representative travelling in the vehicle. Relevant paragraphs are extracted
as under:
<25. Section 147 of the 1988 Act, inter alia, prescribes
compulsory coverage against the death of or bodily injury
to any passenger of <public service vehicle=. Proviso
appended thereto categorically states that compulsory
coverage in respect of drivers and conductors of public
service vehicle and employees carried in a goods vehicle
would be limited to the liability under the Workmen's
Compensation Act. It does not speak of any passenger in a
<goods carriage=.
26. In view of the changes in the relevant provisions in the
1988 Act vis-à-vis the 1939 Act, we are of the opinion that
the meaning of the words <any person= must also be
attributed having regard to the context in which they have
been used i.e. <a third party=. Keeping in view the
provisions of the 1988 Act, we are of the opinion that as
the provisions thereof do not enjoin any statutory liability
on the owner of a vehicle to get his vehicle insured for any
passenger travelling in a goods vehicle, the insurers would
not be liable therefor.
27. Furthermore, sub-clause (i) of clause (b) of sub-section
(1) of Section 147 speaks of liability which may be incurred
by the owner of a vehicle in respect of death of or bodily
injury to any person or damage to any property of a third
party caused by or arising out of the use of the vehicle in a
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:02:55
MAC.APP. 37/2017
public place, whereas sub-clause (ii) thereof deals with
liability which may be incurred by the owner of a vehicle
against the death of or bodily injury to any passenger of a
public service vehicle caused by or arising out of the use
of the vehicle in a public place.=
(emphasis added)
17.
This position was further explained in National Insurance Co. Ltd.
v. Baljit Kaur (2004) 2 SCC 1, wherein the Supreme Court recognized
that, after the amendment, the risk of the owner of goods or his authorised
representative carried in a goods vehicle stands statutorily covered, though
<gratuitous passengers= remain excluded. Thus, the determinative
question is whether the occupant had a nexus with the goods or the
business purpose of the vehicle. Relevant paragraphs are extracted as
under:
<12. We find ourselves unable, furthermore, to
countenance the contention of the respondents that the
words <any person= as used in Section 147 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, would be rendered otiose by an
interpretation that removed gratuitous passengers from
the ambit of the same. It was observed by this Court in the
case concerning New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Asha
Rani [(2003) 2 SCC 223 : 2003 SCC (Cri) 493] that the
true purport of the words <any person= is to be found in
the liability of the insurer for third-party risk, which was
sought to be provided for by the enactment.
………
17. By reason of the 1994 amendment what was added is
<including owner of the goods or his authorised
representative carried in the vehicle=. The liability of the
owner of the vehicle to insure it compulsorily, thus, by
reason of the aforementioned amendment included only
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:02:55
MAC.APP. 37/2017
the owner of the goods or his authorised representative
carried in the vehicle besides the third parties. The
intention of Parliament, therefore, could not have been
that the words <any person= occurring in Section 147
would cover all persons who were travelling in a goods
carriage in any capacity whatsoever. If such was the
intention, there was no necessity of Parliament to carry out
an amendment inasmuch as the expression <any person=
contained in sub-clause (i) of clause (b) of sub-section (1)
of Section 147 would have included the owner of the goods
or his authorised representative besides the passengers
who are gratuitous or otherwise.
……..
20. It is, therefore, manifest that in spite of the amendment
of 1994, the effect of the provision contained in Section 147
with respect to persons other than the owner of the goods
or his authorized representative remains the same.
Although the owner of the goods or his authorized
representative would now be covered by the policy of
insurance in respect of a goods vehicle, it was not the
intention of the legislature to provide for the liability of the
insurer with respect to passengers, especially gratuitous
passengers, who were neither contemplated at the time the
contract of insurance was entered into, nor was any
premium paid to the extent of the benefit of insurance to
such category of people.=
(emphasis added)
18.
In the present case, the evidence establishes that the deceased was
travelling in the offending vehicle in his capacity as <conductor/helper=
and in connection with the goods being transported. Such presence cannot
be equated with that of a <gratuitous passenger=. The appellant/ Insurance
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:02:55
MAC.APP. 37/2017
Company led no evidence to demonstrate that the deceased was an
unauthorized occupant or that there was any breach of policy conditions.
19.
Recently, this Court, in the matter of Reliance General Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Mohd. Nahid 2026:DHC:1464, reiterated that where the
claimant is travelling in a goods vehicle as the owner of goods or their
authorised representative, or in connection with the goods being
transported, the statutory coverage under Section 147 applies. The Court
further held that in the absence of effective cross-examination or contrary
evidence, the testimony regarding such capacity cannot be disregarded.
Relevant paragraph is extracted as under:
<18. ………. The said section was amended in 1994, to
require a policy of insurance to cover liability towards the
owner of goods carried in a vehicle, or his authorised
representative. It has been thus interpreted in several
decision of the Supreme Court, including inter alia in New
India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Asha Rani & Ors.4 and
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Baljit Kaur & Ors.5 .
19. In the present case, the claimant claimed coverage on
the basis that he was the owner of the goods which were
being carried in the vehicle, or the authorised
representative of the owner. In the claim petition, the
claimant asserted that he was going to HSIDC Balbal,
Haryana, from Dharuhera in the offending vehicle, which
<was loaded with goods which belong with the petitioner.
The claimant also filed an affidavit of evidence before the
Tribunal, which included the statement that the offending
vehicle was loaded with goods belonging to him. With
regard to his vocation, he stated he was a painter
[whitewasher] in the area of East Delhi.=.....
………
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:02:55
MAC.APP. 37/2017
21. ……Although general cross- examination was carried
out as to the purpose of his travel, there was no crossexamination whatsoever, as to the alleged discrepancy
between the Section 161 of the CrPC statement and the
claim petition, or evidence before the Tribunal. The
claimant maintained that he was carrying his goods in the
vehicle, and denied that he was travelling as a gratuitous
passenger. Without his testimony having been challenged
in cross-examination at all, the Tribunal committed no
error in proceeding on the basis of the evidence given by
the claimant. Although the Tribunal has not elaborately
discussed this aspect, its conclusion is recorded in
paragraph 28 of the impugned award, to the effect that
there was nothing on the record to show any violation of
policy conditions.
………
23. In view of the Section 147 of the MV Act, as
interpretated in Baljit Kaur, I am of the view that the
present claimant was covered by the insurance policy in
question.=
(emphasis added)
20.
Ms. Aruna Mehta, counsel for respondent nos.1-4/claimant, points
out to the written statement filed on behalf of respondent nos.5 & 6 [driver
& owner of the offending vehicle], wherein it was stated in paragraph 5
that it was admitted that the deceased was a <conductor/helper= with M/s
Kuber Enterprises, having its office at 10-A, Gali No.2, East Guru Angad
Nagar, Delhi, and was on the offending truck along with the goods of M/s
Kuber Enterprises. This was in response to the claim petition, in which it
was stated in serial no.5 of the table that the deceased was a
<conductor/helper= with M/s Kuber Enterprises. The said having been
admitted by the respondent nos.5 & 6 [driver & owner of the offending
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:02:55
MAC.APP. 37/2017
vehicle], the question of appellant/Insurance Company raising a doubt in
this regard did not arise.
21.
The Court is, therefore, not inclined to sustain the plea of the
appellant/Insurance
Company.
No
steps
were
taken
by
the
appellant/Insurance Company to controvert the evidence given by the
respondent no.5 [driver] and respondent no.6 [owner] or to bring them to
the witness stand in order to challenge the evidence provided in the
affidavits.
22.
Accordingly, this appeal stands dismissed.
23.
This Court notices that there are certain heads of compensation
which are not aligned with the principles enunciated in National
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680.
24.
Accordingly, loss of love and affection granted at Rs.1,00,000/-
shall not be granted in terms of United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v.
Satinder Kaur, (2021) 11 SCC 780; loss of consortium granted at
Rs.1,00,000/- will be Rs.1,60,000/- [40,000 × 4 dependents]; loss of estate
would be at Rs.15,000/-; and funeral expenses will be at Rs.15,000/-.
25.
Accordingly, compensation is re-computed as under:
S. NO.
1.
HEADS
Income of deceased (A)
AWARDED BY
AWARDED BY
THE TRIBUNAL
THIS COURT
Rs. 7020/-
Rs. 7020/-
Rs. 2106/-
Rs. 2106/-
[30%]
[30%]
(less Income Tax)
2.
Add Future Prospects (B)
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:02:55
MAC.APP. 37/2017
3.
Less Personal expenses of
1/4th
1/4th
Rs.6844.5/-
Rs.6844.5/-
Rs.82,134/-
Rs.82,134/-
the deceased (C)
4.
Monthly loss of
dependency
[(A +B)-C = D]
5.
Annual loss of dependency
(Dx12)
6.
Multiplier (E)
7.
Total loss of dependency
Rs.11,49,876/-
Rs.11,49,876/-
(Dx12xE = F)
8.
Medical expenses (G)
Nil
Nil
9.
Compensation for loss of
Rs.1,00,000/-
Rs.1,60,000/-
consortium (H)
10.
Compensation for loss of
[40,000 × 4]
Rs.1,00,000/-
Nil
Rs.10,000/-
Rs.15,000/-
Rs.25,000/-
Rs.15,000/-
Rs. 13,84,876/-
Rs. 13,39,876/-
9%
9%
love and affection (I)
11.
Compensation for loss of
estate (J)
12.
Compensation towards
funeral expenses (K)
Total compensation
(F+G+G+I+J+K = L)
Interest Awarded
Conclusion
26.
According the compensation is adjusted to a total of Rs.13,39,876/-
and a difference of Rs.45,000/- has been arrived at after readjustment of
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:02:55
MAC.APP. 37/2017
the compensation as per the principles enunciated in National Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (supra).
27.
The entire awarded amount along with interest was deposited by the
appellant/Insurance Company pursuant to order dated 13th January 2017.
By order dated 27th March 2017 passed by this Court, 50% of the awarded
amount was released in favour of claimants.
28.
Since the order of the Tribunal stands confirmed, the remaining
amount, shall be disbursed as per the directions passed by the Tribunal in
the impugned award and shall continue to be released, subject to the
readjusted amount of Rs.45,000/-, with which proportionate accrued
interest shall be refunded to the appellant/Insurance Company.
29.
Accordingly, the appeal stands dismissed.
30.
Pending applications (if any) are rendered infructuous.
31.
Statutory deposit (if any) be refunded to appellant.
32.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
ANISH DAYAL
(JUDGE)
FEBRUARY 24, 2026/ak/tk
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
12:02:55
MAC.APP. 37/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review