Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~9 & 10
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 10th March 2026
%
(9)
+
MAC.APP. 453/2015 & CM APPL. 9931/2015
NATIONAL INSURANCE CO LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Ridhima Gaur & Ms. Ring
Baliyan, Advs. for Ms. Archana
Gaur, Adv. for Insurance Co.
versus
GEETA TRIPATHI & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Manish Maini, Ms. Aastha
Chauhan and Ms. Anjali Singh, Advs.
for R-1 to 5.
(10)
+
MAC.APP. 14/2016
GEETA TRIPATHI & ORS
.....Appellants
Through:
Mr. Manish Maini, Ms. Aastha
Chauhan and Ms. Anjali Singh, Advs.
versus
NATIONAL INSURANCE CO LTD & ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Ridhima Gaur & Ms. Ring
Baliyan, Advs. for Ms. Archana
Gaur, Adv. for Insurance Co.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
These cross-appeals have been filed respectively by the Insurance
Company and the claimant, assailing the impugned award dated 22nd April
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 453/2015 & MAC.APP. 14/2016
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:14:44
2015 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (‘MACT/Tribunal’),
North-west District, Rohini, whereby a compensation of Rs.16,03,790/-,
along with interest at 8% per annum, was awarded to the claimants, who are
legal representatives of the deceased Sh. C. N. Tripathi, who had succumbed
to injuries sustained in a road traffic accident which occurred on 13th June
2011.
2.
Ms. Archana Gaur, Counsel for the Insurance Company, states that the
benchmark income taken at Rs.12,000/- per month was not based on any
documentary proof, and, accordingly, minimum wages ought to have been
taken. On the other hand, Mr. Manish Maini, counsel for the claimant, seeks
enhancement of the said benchmark income on the basis of the Income Tax
Returns (‘ITRs’) which were filed and the testimony of the wife, PW1, Smt.
Geeta Tripathi.
3.
From the record, it can be seen that the MACT assessed the income
on the basis of the testimony of PW1, who stated that her deceased husband
had graduated as a Shastri from Rashtriya Sanskrit Sansthanam, Delhi in the
year 1982 and obtained a post-graduation degree (Acharya) from Rashtriya
Sanskrit Sansthanam in the year 1984. The marksheets, appended as
Ex.PW1/4 before the MACT, were not disputed.
4.
PW1 further stated that the deceased husband was a professional
astrologer and priest and was running a Yagya Shala at Burari Village under
the name and style of Manokamna Sidh Peeth, for which a photocopy of the
sale deed was produced as Ex.PW1/5 before the Tribunal.
5.
She further deposed that he had an astrology office at Wazirpur
Industrial Area under the name and style of Bhagirathi Jyotish Mandir, for
which a copy of the lease deed was appended as Ex.PW1/6.
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 453/2015 & MAC.APP. 14/2016
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:14:44
6.
For the Financial Year 1st April 2010 to 31st March 2011 (Assessment
Year 2011-2012), the year in which the deceased passed away, a ledger
account was produced by PW1, certified by the Chartered Accountant,
stating that there was a net surplus profit of Rs.2,58,204/- in that year.
7.
Further, she deposed that he had deposited cash of Rs.1,52,900/- in
Savings Bank Account in his name State Bank of India and Rs.1,36,900/- in
Canara Bank, thereby depositing a total amount of Rs.2,89,800/- (Rs.
1,52,900 + Rs. 1,36,900) in the Financial Year 1st April 2010 to 31st March
2011 and an amount of Rs. 59,000/- in the Financial Year 1st April 2011 to 4th
July 2011.
8.
She stated that he was contributing Rs.2,40,000/- towards household
expenses and his earnings were increasing every year.
9.
Taking this into account, the MACT assessed that the deceased must
be earning at least Rs.400/- per day. On that basis, Rs.12,000/- per month
was taken as the benchmark income.
10.
On one hand Insurance Company states that there was no basis for
calculating this benchmark income of Rs.12,000/- per month. On the other
hand, there is the testimony of PW1, and the ledger account certified by the
Chartered Accountant.
11.
Considering that the assessment of the MACT at Rs. 12,000/- per
month amounts to Rs. 2,40,000/- per year, whereas the claimant asserts an
income of Rs. 2,58,204/- per year, this Court considers it appropriate to
sustain the assessment made by the MACT, since the figures fall within
approximately the same range of Rs. 2,50,000/- per year.
12.
However, as regards the multiplier, which was adopted as 9 by the
MACT, as per the assessment in Smt. Sarla Verma & Ors v. Delhi Transport
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 453/2015 & MAC.APP. 14/2016
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:14:44
Corporation & Anr. (2009) 5 SCC 121 and National Insurance Company
Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. (2017) 16 SCC 680, it ought to be 11 since the
deceased had not completed the age of 56 years but was 55 years 10 months
on that date, therefore, he would fall in the bracket of 51-55 years.
13.
Ms. Gaur, counsel for the Insurance Company, contends that since he
was closer to the age group of 56 years, the multiplier of 9 was correctly
applied.
14.
Countering this submission, Mr. Maini, counsel for the claimant, relies
upon the decision of the Supreme Court in Shashikala & Ors. v. Ganga
Lakshmamma & Anr. 2015 ACJ 1239, where, in paragraph 17, the Court,
while assessing the multiplier, has noted that the deceased had “completed
only 45 years” even though his age was 45 years, 5 months and 28 days on
the date of the accident and therefore, the appropriate multiplier would have
been 14.
15.
In the opinion of this Court, the multiplier has to be applied as per the
defined age bracket provided in the table supplied in Sarla Verma (supra)
and Pranay Sethi (supra), which are categorised on the basis of specific
determined age groups/completed years of age. If courts were to assess age
on the basis of the number of months after completion of a particular year of
age, it would introduce a significant degree of subjectivity.
16.
Age is universally accepted on the basis of completed years and not
on the basis of the number of months which have been completed after the
completion of a certain number of years. For example, if a person who has
completed 55 years and 5 months or in fact 10 months would still be termed
as a 55 years old, and not a 56 year old.
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 453/2015 & MAC.APP. 14/2016
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:14:44
17.
Accepting Ms. Gaur’s submission in this regard would introduce a
large degree of subjectivity in the application of multiplier or, in fact,
assessing compensation.
18.
Accordingly, multiplier of 11 ought to apply.
19.
Ms. Gaur, counsel for the Insurance Company, also raises an issue
regarding the fact that the four children are all major and, therefore, the
deduction towards personal expenses should have been 1/2 rather than 1/4.
20.
To this, Mr. Maini, counsel for the claimant, counters by relying upon
a decision of the Coordinate Bench of this Court in Kamlesh Mittal and Ors
v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. And Ors. 2014:DHC:4389, where a similar
issue was considered, and the Court recorded as under:
“10. Now, coming to the second and last contention of the
appellant regarding deduction of 50% earning towards
personal expenses to assess the loss of dependency. The
tribunal noted that appellant No.2 is a major son and
appellant No.3 is a married daughter of the deceased and
not financially dependent. Hence, based on the judgment
of the Supreme Court in the case of Sarla Verma and Ors
v. DTC and Anr., MANU/SC/0606/2009; AIR 2009 SC
3104 the tribunal took 50% deduction in the earning
towards personal expenses.
11. To appreciate the submission of the learned counsel for
the appellant, reference may be had to some of the relevant
paragraphs of the judgment of the Supreme Court in the
case of Sarla Verma v. DTC (supra). Relevant portion of
paragraph 7 reads as under:
“7. .... The matter of arriving at the damages is to
ascertain the net income of the deceased available
for the support of himself and his dependants, and
to deduct therefrom such part of his income as the
deceased was accustomed to spend upon himself,
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 453/2015 & MAC.APP. 14/2016
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:14:44
as regards both self-maintenance and pleasure,
and to ascertain what part of his net income the
deceased was accustomed to spend for the benefit
of the dependants. Then that should be capitalized
by multiplying it by a figure representing the
proper number of year's purchase.”
12. In para 12, the Supreme Court held as follows:“12. We have already noticed that the personal
and living expenses of the deceased should be
deducted from the income, to arrive at the
contribution to the dependents. No evidence need
be led to show the actual expenses of the
deceased. In fact, any evidence in that behalf will
be wholly unverifiable and likely to be unreliable.
Claimants will obviously tend to claim that the
deceased was very frugal and did not have any
expensive habits and was spending virtually the
entire income on the family. In some cases, it may
be so. No claimant would admit that the deceased
was a spendthrift, even if he was one. It is also
very difficult for the respondents in a claim
petition to produce evidence to show that the
deceased was spending a considerable part of the
income on himself or that he was contributing
only a small part of the income on his family.
Therefore, it became necessary to standardize the
deductions to be made under the head of personal
and living expenses of the deceased. This lead to
the practice of deducting towards personal and
living expenses of the deceased, one-third of the
income if the deceased was married, and one-half
(50%) of the income if the deceased was a
bachelor. This practice was evolved out of
experience, logic and convenience. In fact oneSignature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 453/2015 & MAC.APP. 14/2016
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:14:44
third deduction, got statutory recognition under
Second Schedule to the Act, in respect of claims
under Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 ('MV Act' for short).”
13. The conclusion on the issue of deduction towards
personal and living expenses is given in para 14 and para
15 which read as follows:“14. Though in some cases the deduction to be
made towards personal and living expenses is
calculated on the basis of units indicated in Trilok
Chandra, the general practice is to apply
standardized deductions. Having considered
several subsequent decisions of this Court, we are
of the view that where the deceased was married,
the deduction towards personal and living
expenses of the deceased, should be one-third
(1/3rd) where the number of dependent family
members is 2 to 3, one-fourth (1/4th) where the
number of dependant family members is 4 to 6,
and one-fifth (1/5th) where the number of
dependant family members exceed six. 15. Where
the deceased was a bachelor and the claimants
are the parents, the deduction follows a different
principle. In regard to bachelors, normally, 50%
is deducted as personal and living expenses,
because it is assumed that a bachelor would tend
to spend more on himself. Even otherwise, there is
also the possibility of his getting married in a
short time, in which event the contribution to the
parent/s and siblings is likely to be cut
drastically.”
14. Hence, the Supreme Court has laid down a standard
formula/guideline to ensure consistency in the Awards of
various tribunals. However, a perusal of the guidelines laid
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 453/2015 & MAC.APP. 14/2016
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:14:44
down shows that a situation like this has not been dealt
with namely, where the deceased is married and has
children who are all settled and the widow is the only
person who could be considered as dependent. I may,
however, note that the Supreme Court noted that in case of
a bachelor where deduction of 50% was stated, the Court
noted that this was because it was assumed that a bachelor
would tend to spend more on himself. Further there is a
possibility of his getting married in a short time in which
event the contribution to the parents/siblings was likely to
be cut drastically.
15. In my opinion, in a situation like the present one, the
situation of the deceased cannot be treated at par with a
bachelor. There is merit in the said submission of learned
counsel for the appellant that a man of 54 years of age who
is professionally well qualified with two settled children
and a wife would not be spending 50% of his wages for
personal living expenses. He would be inclined to
accumulate wealth for his old age days and also for the
benefit of his wife and children. One cannot also ignore
that being a father of a married daughter and a son, who
is likely to get married he would have spent on the
marriage of the son, on his grand children after they were
born. These are expenses which a man who has grown to
that age and who is well settled would normally be
incurring. These expenses cannot be ignored. Keeping in
view these facts and circumstances in my opinion, the
appropriate deduction to be made from the income of the
deceased in the facts and circumstances of this case was
1/3rd and not 50% as done by the tribunal. Hence, 1/3rd is
only to be deducted from personal expenses.
16. The loss of dependency would now be Rs.23,83,337
[(325000- 1/3)x11]”
(emphasis added)
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 453/2015 & MAC.APP. 14/2016
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:14:44
21.
The Court resonates with the opinion taken by the Coordinate Bench
of this Court in Kamlesh Mittal (supra).
22.
The submission of Ms. Gaur that 50% deduction ought to have been
applied is not tenable. As noted in the said judgment, referring to Sarla
Verma, the 50% deduction principle applies primarily to bachelors, on the
assumption that a bachelor would spend more on himself.
23.
In the present case, the deceased is survived by a widow and four
major children. Some contribution, apart from providing for the wife, would
naturally be made towards the children as well.
24.
However, since they were major, the MACT ought not to have treated
them as falling within 4-6 dependants and then deducted 1/4th towards
personal expenses.
25.
It will be appropriate that the deduction would be taken at 1/3 to align
with the principles enunciated by the Supreme Court in Sarla Verma (supra).
26.
A number of other alignments have to be done as per the principles
enunciated in Pranay Sethi (supra):
(i) Loss of consortium, which was awarded at Rs.1,00,000/-, would be
at Rs.2,00,000/- (Rs.40,000/- x5), towards four children and one
widow.
(ii) Loss of love and affection at Rs.1,00,000/- ought to be nil in terms
of United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satinder Kaur (2021) 11
SCC 780.
(iii) Funeral expenses at Rs.25,000/-, ought to be reduced to
Rs.15,000/-.
(iv) Loss to estate, which was not awarded, ought to be granted at
Rs.15,000/-.
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 453/2015 & MAC.APP. 14/2016
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:14:44
27.
As regards the plea on interest rate, which was granted at 8% per
annum, this Court is not inclined to enhance the same to 9% per annum.
28.
Accordingly, the revised compensation be recomputed as under:
S.
Heads
No.
Income of deceased (A) (less
Income Tax)
Add Future Prospects (B)
Awarded by the
Tribunal
Rs. 12,000/-
Awarded by this
Court
Rs. 12,000/-
15% of Rs. 12,000/=Rs. 13,800/1/4 of Rs. 13,800/- =
Rs 3,540/Rs. 10,350/-
15% of Rs. 12,000/=Rs. 13,800/1/3 of Rs. 13,800/=Rs. 4,600/Rs. 9,200/-
Rs. 1,24,200/-
Rs. 1,10,400
Rs. 11,17,800/-
Rs. 12,14,400
Rs. 2,60,990/Rs. 1,00,000/Rs. 1,00,000/-
Rs. 2,60,990/Rs.40,000/- x5 = Rs.
2,00,000/NIL
NIL
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 25,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 16,03,790/-
Rs. 17,05,390/-
8% per annum
8% per annum
Less Personal expenses of the
deceased (C)
Monthly loss of dependency
[(A +B)-C = D]
Annual loss of dependency
(Dx12)
Multiplier (E)
Total loss of dependency
(Dx12xE = F)
Medical expenses (G)
Compensation for loss of
consortium (H)
Compensation for loss of care
and guidance to children (I)
Compensation for loss of
estate (J)
Compensation towards
funeral expenses (K)
Total compensation
(F+G+H+I+J+K = L)
Rate of Interest Awarded
29.
In terms of the order dated 25th May 2015, directions had been issued
for the deposit of 60% of the awarded amount along with interest, and a sum
of Rs. 2,00,000/- had been directed to be released.
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 453/2015 & MAC.APP. 14/2016
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:14:44
30.
As per the revised computation, the balance amount along with
accrued interest from the date of filing of petition be deposited before the
Registry of this Court.
31.
Out of the fresh deposited an amount of Rs.5,00,000/- be released as
per the directions of the MACT in paragraph 10 of the award. The balance
shall also be released as per the direction of MACT in paragraph 10 of the
award.
32.
Copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned MACT.
33.
Appeal stands disposed of with above directions.
34.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
35.
Statutory deposit, if any, be refunded to appellant.
36.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
MARCH 10, 2026/mk/bp
Digitally Signed
MAC.APP. 453/2015 & MAC.APP. 14/2016
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:14:44
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review