The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. The reliance placed by the appellant on the case of other employees is also bereft of any merit as in their case there was no order of rejection of their claim for absorption in the Palika Centralized Services whereas in the case of appellant his case was rejected vide order dated 24.07.2012 which was upheld by the writ court.
19. Thus, viewed from any angle, we do not find any good ground to interfere in the order passed by the learned Single Judge. The appeal fails and is hereby dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
THE HON’BLE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. MANOJ KUMAR GUPTA
AND
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE MR. SUBHASH UPADHYAY
Special Appeal No.329 of 2022
24 March, 2026
Nathu Lal Koli
-----Appellant
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and Others
----Respondents
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Presence:Mr. Amar Murti Shukla, learned counsel for the appellant.
Mr. Puran Singh Bisht, learned C.S.C. along with Ms. Mamta Bisht,
learned Deputy Advocate General for the State of Uttarakhand/
respondent nos.1 to 3.
Mr. Saurabh Budhori, learned counsel holding brief of Mr. Yogesh
Kumar Pacholia, learned counsel for respondent no.4
-------------------------------------------------------------------------JUDGMENT : (per Mr. Subhash Upadhyay, J.)
Delay Condonation Application (IA/1/2022)
1.
Appeal is reported to be beyond time by 82
days. The explanation given for the delay is found to be
satisfactory. Even otherwise, learned counsel for the
respondents
do
not
oppose
the
delay
condonation
application. Accordingly, delay condonation application is
allowed and delay in filing the appeal is condoned.
SPA No.329 of 2022
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
3.
By the present intra-court appeal, the appellant
has assailed the judgment and order dated 06.06.2022
passed by learned Single Judge in WPSS No.2608 of 2019
whereby the writ petition filed by the appellant/writ
petitioner was dismissed.
4.
The appellant had filed the writ petition for the
following reliefs:
“(i) Issue a writ, order or direction in the
nature of certiorari for quashing the impugned
orders dated 21-09-2019 (Annexure-2) & 4-112019 (Annexure-3) passed by the respondent
no.2 i.e. the Director Urban Development
Department Dehradun.
(ii) Issue a writ, order or direction in the
nature of mandamus, directing and commanding
the respondents that they shall absorb to the
petitioner on the post of executive office in the
respondent municipality and thereafter, re-fix
his pensionary benefits treating him as an
retired employee from the post of executive
officer i.e. centralized post from the date of his
retirement and grant all the consequential
benefits to him accordingly.”
5.
By the orders impugned in the writ petition, the
claim of the appellant for absorption of his services in the
Palika Centralized Cadre as Executive Officer and for the
grant of retiral benefits admissible to members of Palika
Centralized Cadre was rejected.
6.
The appellant was appointed as Work Agent
(class-iv post) in Nagar Palika Parisad, Rudrapur, District
Udham Singh Nagar on 03.01.1974 and his services were
later regularized on the said post.
7.
Vide order dated 16.09.1997, appellant was
sent on deputation on the post of Executive Officer at
Nagar Palika Didihat, District Pithoragarh. The appellant
submitted an application on 12.03.2012 for absorption of
his services on the post of Executive Officer (a post under
the Palika Centralized Services Rules) and the said
representation
was
rejected
on
24.07.2012
by
the
Director, Urban Development, Dehradun. By the same
order, the appellant was also repatriated to his original
post of Work Agent and posted at Nagar Palika Parisad,
Rudrapur.
8.
The said order dated 24.07.2012 was put to
challenge in WPSS No.1104 of 2012 in which an interim
order was passed on 14.08.2012, however, the aforesaid
writ petition was decided on 20.11.2015 and the order
dated 24.07.2012 by which claim of the appellant for
absorption on the post of Executive Officer was rejected
was not interfered and the Court further recorded a
finding that the case of the absorption of the petitioner
was rightly rejected and the petitioner /appellant cannot
be regularized on the post of Executive Officer. Paragraph
no.5 and 6 of the said order reads as under:
“5.
The
centralized
Rule
applicable
in
Uttarakhand are known as "The Uttarakhand
Urban Development Directorate (on the posts of
Junior Engineer (Technical) Chief Assistant,
Accounts Clerk, Junior Assistant Cashier and
Peon) Absorption Rules, 2009" (hereinafter
referred to as the "Absorption Rules, 2009). The
petitioner relies upon the rule 4(1) of the
Absorption Rules, 2009. The Rules does not
specify that such posts of Executive Officer can
be regularized or absorption. Moreover, this
Court has already held that the very sending of
the petitioner on deputation in the year 1997
was in the violation of law for the reason that
the petitioner was neither working on the pay
scale of Executive Officer nor he was graduate
at the relevant time. Therefore, as far as the
case of absorption of the petitioner is
concerned, it has rightly been rejected and this
Court is also of the view that the petitioner
cannot be regularized on the post of Executive
Officer/
6. The matter relates to the reversion of the
petitioner. This matter was stayed by this Court.
During the pendency of the writ petition the
petitioner
already
reached
the
age
of
superannuation and retired from service on
31.10.2012. Nothing further needs to be said on
this aspect. It is further made clear that the
pension, as applicable to the petitioner shall be
determined and the same be calculated by
respondent No. 2 within a period of six weeks
from the date of production of a certified copy of
this order. No further relief is granted to the
petitioner.”
9.
The appellant during the pendency of the WPSS
No.1104 of 2012 had retired on 31.10.2012 and he
preferred another writ petition i.e. WPSS No.1586 of 2013
for grant of pensionary benefit on the post of Executive
Officer.
10.
The said writ petition was disposed of on
08.05.2018 by which directions were issued to the
Director, Urban Development to decide the representation
of the appellant.
11.
In
pursuance
to
the
said
direction,
the
representation of the petitioner was rejected vide order
dated 21.09.2019 and 04.11.2019 and the said orders
were impugned in the WPSS No.2608 of 2019 which was
dismissed on 06.06.2022 against which the present
special appeal has been preferred.
12.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that
in case of similarly situated employee, namely, Prakash
Chandra
Harbola,
his
services
were
regularized
as
Executive
Officer
after
his
retirement
whereas
the
appellant who is similarly situated has been discriminated.
He further refers to the case of other employees whose
name has been referred in paragraph no.22 of the writ
petition
to
contend
that
their
services
were
also
regularized in the Palika Centralized Cadre after their
retirement, as such, the rejection of the claim of the
appellant for absorption was unjustified.
13.
Per contra, learned State Counsel supports the
judgment passed by the learned Single Judge and submits
that the case of the appellant for absorption on the post of
Executive
Officer
was
rejected
vide
order
dated
24.07.2012 and the said decision was not interfered by
the Court in WPSS No.1104 of 2012 and in absence of any
challenge to the said order the same has attained finality.
14.
Learned State Counsel further submits that in
pursuance to the order passed in the present special
appeal on 04.09.2024, the services of the appellant for
the period while he was working on deputation has been
considered for the calculation of pension to be paid under
the non-centralized cadre. He refers to paragraph no.5 of
the supplementary affidavit which reads as under:
“5. That in reference to point number 2 of
interim order dated 04.09.2024 of the Hon'ble
High Court, it is requested that in compliance
with the earlier order dated 20.11.2015 passed
by the Hon'ble High Court, as per the provision
of government orders, the calculation chart of
pay fixation of the petitioner from 01.07.1986 to
01.07.2012 is given to the petitioner Shri Nathu
Lal Koli, which also includes the period of
deputation from the year 1997 to 2012. On this
basis, after retirement on 31.10.2012, the
petitioner is being paid pension every month by
the Municipal Corporation Rudrapur.”
15.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties
and on perusal of the records, we find that the learned
Single Judge has held that the orders passed by the
Director, Urban Development rejecting the claim of the
appellant, records valid reasons for denying petitioner’s
claim for grant of benefit as admissible to members of
Palika Centralized Services.
16.
The learned Single Judge also took note of the
orders passed in the earlier writ petitions filed by the
appellant and held that as the services of the appellant
were never absorbed in the Palika Centralized Services,
therefore, his claim for retiral benefits admissible to the
members of the Palika Centralized Services is untenable.
Moreover, facts narrated in the preceding paragraphs of
this judgment reveals that the case of the appellant for
absorption on the post of Executive Officer was rejected
by the Director, Urban Development vide order dated
24.07.2012 and the said decision was not interfered by
the writ court in WPSS No.1104 of 2012 and the finding
recorded by the Court that the appellant cannot be
regularized on the post of Executive Officer has become
final in absence of any challenge to the order dated
20.11.2015 passed in the said writ petition.
17.
As the services of the appellant were not
absorbed on the post of Executive Officer, as such, the
appellant’s claim was rightly rejected by the Director
Urban Development holding that the appellant was not
entitled for the benefit of retiral benefit as admissible to
the members of Centralized Cadre.
18.
The reliance placed by the appellant on the case
of other employees is also bereft of any merit as in their
case there was no order of rejection of their claim for
absorption in the Palika Centralized Services whereas in
the case of appellant his case was rejected vide order
dated 24.07.2012 which was upheld by the writ court.
19.
Thus, viewed from any angle, we do not find
any good ground to interfere in the order passed by the
learned Single Judge. The appeal fails and is hereby
dismissed.
20.
Pending application, if any, also stands disposed
of.
(MANOJ KUMAR GUPTA, C. J.)
(SUBHASH UPADHYAY, J.)
Dated: 24.03.2026
SS
SUKHBANT
SINGH
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH COURT
OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=71978f9c61bfde0ba69967c787b1764ea7bc7dd129a8a6
380d49b1885e628615, postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=2D8B71B8D8E345F6B7F95B1DD4FB4BEBD2B7D7
2C42261361AED33172F152148D, cn=SUKHBANT SINGH
Date: 2026.03.27 14:03:44 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review