Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:5557
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
Cr. MP (M) No. 2991 of 2025
Date of Decision: 03.03.2026
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Narotma Devi
...Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh
…Respondent
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sandeep Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? 1 Yes
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------For the Petitioner :
Mr. Tara Singh Chauhan Sr. Advocate
with Mr. Surya Chauhan, Advocate
For the Respondent :
Mr.Rajan Kahol, Mr. Vishal Panwar
Additional Advocate Generals and Mr.
Ravi Chauhan and Mr. Anish Banstu,
Deputy Advocates Generals.
Mr. Pranav Sharma, Advocate, for the
complainant.
ASI Vijay Sharma, P.S Barotiwala
present in person.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Sandeep Sharma, J. (Oral)
Sequel to order dated 22.12.2025, whereby the petitioner,
who is teacher by occupation, was ordered to be enlarged on interim
bail in case FIR No.165 of 2025 dated 05.12.2025 registered at Police
Station Barotiwala, Distt. Solan, H.P under Section 108 of the Bharatiya
Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, respondent/State has filed status report and ASI
Vijay Sharma, P.S Barotiwala has come present with record. Petitioner
is also present along with her counsel. Record perused and retained.
2.
Mr. Rajan Kahol, learned Additional Advocate General on
instructions of investigating officer, present in the Court, states that
pursuant to order dated 22.12.2025, petitioner herein has been joining
Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:5557
the
investigation regularly and she has fully cooperated. He further
states that investigation in the case is complete and nothing remains to
be recovered from the bail petitioner and as such, this court may pass
appropriate order and in the event of making the interim order absolute,
this Court may direct
petitioner
to join investigation as and when
directed.
3.
Mr.
Pranav
Sharma,
learned
counsel
representing
complainant, while vehemently opposing the prayer made on behalf of
the petitioner,
submitted that
minor child of complainant committed
suicide after her being subjected to mental torture and harassment by
the petitioner. He states that investigation has been not conducted fairly
because investigating officer did not record the statements of other
students rather gave one questionnaire to the students, which has been
answered as the same in a stereo-typed manner. He states that since
petitioner is still teaching in the school, there is every likelihood of her
committing
same crime and tampering with the evidence, as such,
prayer made on behalf of petitioner for grant of bail deserves outright
rejection.
4.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
the material on record, this Court finds that on 01.12.2025 deceased
namely Rita daughter of Sh. Maan Singh
Hospital, Khera Baddi for treatment.
was brought to Shrikant
Doctors of afore hospital after
having medically examined the deceased discharged her and thereafter
she was taken to home. After two days of her discharge from afore
medical institution, she was taken to PGI Chandigarh but unfortunately,
2026:HHC:5557
she passed away on account of having consumed poison. Father of the
deceased alleged that on 28.11.2025, petitioner herein, had scolded
and humiliated her deceased daughter in the open class for her having
not prepared for test. He disclosed to the police that his son, who is also
studying in the same class, was also humiliated and scolded.
5.
In the afore background, FIR came to be lodged against
the petitioner, who pursuant to order dated 22.12.2025 is on interim bail.
Investigating officer, who is present in the Court, states that
after
passing of order dated 26.02.2025, he again recorded the statements of
11 students but they have again denied factum of their being scolded or
humiliated, if any, by the petitioner. Record of statements brought by
Investigating Officer further
reveals
that students
of the class of
deceased in unison have stated that petitioner, being teacher, had
simply scolded not only the deceased but other students also who had
not scored good marks in the test. Students have also stated that
petitioner treats every student equal and she has never singled out a
student for humiliation or harassment. Besides all of this, this court
finds that medical evidence on record, nowhere suggests, injuries if any
on the deceased person. Though, post mortem report indicates factum
of deceased having consumed poison, but at present, there is no
evidence to suggest that deceased consumed poison on account of her
being scolded/humiliated by the teacher for not having scored good
marks in the test. Admittedly, deceased has not left any suicide note,
rather, information with regard to humiliation or scolding came to the
notice of the father of deceased through his son, who is also studying in
2026:HHC:5557
the same class under same teacher.
6.
There is another aspect of the matter that deceased had
consumed poison on 28.11.2025, but FIR came to be registered on
05.12.2025 after 7 days, of the alleged incident. Once, factum with
regard to the deceased having consumed poison on account of her
being subjected to mental harassment by the petitioner had come to the
knowledge of the parents of the deceased on the same day, there was
no reason, if any, for complainant or other family members to delay the
lodging of FIR, which admittedly came to be lodged after 7 days of the
incident. Though, learned counsel representing complainant vehemently
argued that there was no occasion, if any,
for
petitioner to scold/
humiliate the deceased, as a result of which, deceased consumed
poison, but this Court is not persuaded to agree with the aforesaid
submission of learned counsel representing complainant.
7.
It is the case of the prosecution that the brother of the
deceased
along with other number of students was also scolded, for
his/their having not come prepared for test, but he did not choose to take
extreme step as was allegedly taken by the deceased. Petitioner, who
being teacher, is otherwise responsible to discipline the students, could
have never imagined that scolding given by her, would result in such
tragedy.
8.
Bare perusal of Section 108 (B) of BNS invoked against
the petitioner itself suggests that to attract the
aforesaid provision,
intention of accused to instigate and abate the deceased to commit
suicide, is necessary. Admittedly, in the case at hand, no evidence till
2026:HHC:5557
date has been adduced by the Investigating Officer to prove instigation
or abatement, if any, at the instance of petitioner, rather, she was only
discharging her official duty and to ensure bright future of the students
scolded them, so that next time, they come well prepared for the test.
Whether alleged act of scolding by petitioner, who is teacher, can be
abetment or instigation is a question to be decided by trial Court in
totality of evidence collected by the prosecution but having noticed the
statements given by the students as well as
other attending
circumstances, this Court is not persuaded to accept the submission
made by the complainant that alleged scolding
deceased was to harass and humiliate
by the petitioner to
her. Recently, Hon’ble Apex
Court in case titled Thangavel versus The State, Through Inspector
of Police and Anr Criminal Appeal No.9099 of 2024 decided on
22.05.2025 categorically held that mere act of scolding does not
constitute abetment of suicide and no reasonable person could foresee
that scolding, prompted by a student’s complaint, would lead to such an
extreme outcome.
Relevant paras of the judgment are reproduced as
under:“5.Learned counsel for the appellant submits that
an incident occurred where the appellant being a
correspondent for the management, being incharge of running a school and hostel, where an
incident is said to have been occurred and in
relation to which allegation was made by another
student against the deceased, based on which
the appellant had scolded the deceased due to
which the deceased had locked himself in a
room and hanged himself with a nylon rope. It
was submitted that the response of the appellant
being the correspondent was justified and it was
just a chiding as a guardian to ensure that the
2026:HHC:5557
deceased did not repeat the offence and there
was peace and tranquility in the hostel. It was
further submitted that there was nothing personal
between the appellant and the deceased and
only on a complaint by another student, such
reprimanding was meted out to the deceased. It
was further contended that except for this, no
other role has been attributed to the appellant
and the appellant could not, even in his wildest
dreams, have imagined
that such scolding
would lead to the deceased taking his life and
thus, there was absolutely no criminal intent
much less to cause the deceased to take his life.
6. Learned Senior Counsel for the State of
Tamil Nadu fairly submits that there does not
appear to be any valid ground for charging the
appellant under Section 306 of the IPC.
7. Despite valid service of notice, respondent
No.2, who is the complainant and father of the
deceased student, has not appeared in the
present proceedings.
8. Having considered the matter in its entirety,
we find it a fit case for interference. As has
rightly been submitted by learned Senior
Counsel for the appellant, no normal person
could have imagined that a scolding, that too
based on a complaint by a student, would result
in such tragedy due to the student so scolded
taking his own life. Further, as submitted, such
scolding was the least, a correspondent was
required to do, to ensure that the complaint
made against the deceased by another student
was taken note of and remedial measures
effected. In the considered opinion of this Court,
under such admitted factual position, no mens
rea can be attributed to the appellant much less,
with regard to abatement of suicide committed
by the deceased.
9.Accordingly, the appeal is allowed. The order
framing charge against the appellant under
Section 306 of the IPC in connection with FIR
No.01/2024 registered by CBCID stands set
aside. The appellant stands discharged in the
said case.”
2026:HHC:5557
9.
Hon’ble Apex Court and this Court in catena of cases
have held that one is deem to be innocent till the time his/her guilt is
not proved in accordance with law.
to be established
Since, guilt of the petitioner is yet
on record by the investigating agency by leading
cogent and convincing evidence, this Court sees no reason to keep her
judicial custody, especially when nothing remains to be recovered from
her. Apprehension expressed by learned counsel representing the
complainant that in the event of bail petitioner being enlarged on bail,
she may flee from justice or may again indulge in such activities, can be
best met by putting bail petitioner to stringent conditions.
10.
Hon'ble Apex Court in Criminal Appeal No. 227/2018,
Dataram Singh vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr decided on 6.2.2018
has held that freedom of an individual cannot be curtailed for indefinite
period, especially when his/her guilt is yet to be proved. It has been
further held by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the aforesaid judgment that a
person is believed to be innocent until found guilty.
11.
Hon’ble Apex Court in Sanjay Chandra versus Central
Bureau of Investigation (2012)1 Supreme Court Cases 49 has held
that gravity alone cannot be a decisive ground to deny bail, rather
competing factors are required to be balanced by the court while
exercising its discretion. It has been repeatedly held by the Hon’ble Apex
Court that object of bail is to secure the appearance of the accused
person at his trial by reasonable amount of bail. The object of bail is
neither punitive nor preventative.
2026:HHC:5557
12.
In Manoranjana Sinh alias Gupta versus CBI, (2017) 5
SCC 218, Hon'ble Apex Court has held that the object of the bail is to
secure the attendance of the accused in the trial and the proper test to
be applied in the solution of the question whether bail should be granted
or refused is whether it is probable that the party will appear to take his
trial. Otherwise also, normal rule is of bail and not jail. Apart from above,
Court has to keep in mind nature of accusations, nature of evidence in
support thereof, severity of the punishment, which conviction will entail,
character of the accused, circumstances which are peculiar to the
accused involved in that crime.
13.
The Apex Court in Prasanta Kumar Sarkar versus Ashis
Chatterjee and another (2010) 14 SCC 496, has laid down various
principles to be kept in mind, while deciding petition for bail viz. prima
facie case, nature and gravity of accusation, punishment involved,
apprehension of repetition of offence and witnesses being influenced.
14.
Consequently,
in view of the above, order dated
22.12.2025 passed by this Court is made absolute subject to his
furnishing bail bonds in the sum of Rs.50,000/- with two local sureties in
the like amount each, to the satisfaction of the learned trial Court,
besides the following conditions:
(a)
She shall make herself available for the purpose of
interrogation, if so required and regularly attend the trial
Court on each and every date of hearing and if prevented
by any reason to do so, seek exemption from appearance
by filing appropriate application;
(b)
She shall not tamper with the prosecution evidence nor
hamper the investigation of the case in any manner
whatsoever;
2026:HHC:5557
15.
(c)
She shall not make any inducement, threat or promises to
any person acquainted with the facts of the case so as to
dissuade him/her from disclosing such facts to the Court or
the Police Officer; and
(d)
She shall not leave the territory of India without the prior
permission of the Court.
It is clarified that if the petitioner misuses the liberty or
violates any of the conditions imposed upon her, the investigating
agency shall be free to move this Court for cancellation of the bail.
16.
Any
observations
made
hereinabove
shall
not
be
construed to be a reflection on the merits of the case and shall remain
confined to the disposal of this petition alone.
The petition stands
accordingly disposed of.
17.
A downloaded copy of this order shall be accepted by the
learned trial Court, while accepting the bail bonds from the petitioner and
in case, said court intends to ascertain the veracity of the downloaded
copy of order presented to it, same may be ascertained from the official
website of this Court.
(Sandeep Sharma)
Judge
March, 03, 2026.
(meera)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review