Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Cr.MP(M) No.2109 of 2026
Date of Decision: 05.11.2026
_____________________________________________________________________
Narotam Singh
……...Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sandeep Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?
…....Respondent
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Yash Pal, Advocate.
For the Respondent:
Mr. Rajan Kahol, Additional Advocate General with
Mr. Ravi Chauhan, Deputy Advocate General.
ASI Tilak Raj, PS Banjar, District Kullu present in
person along with record.
___________________________________________________________________________
Sandeep Sharma, J. (Oral)
Bail petitioner namely Narotam Singh, who is behind the bars
since 17.01.2026, has approached this court in the instant proceedings
filed under Section 483 of Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023
(hereinafter ‘BNSS’), for grant of regular bail, in case FIR No. 7/2026 dated
07.01.2026, registered at Police Station Banjar, District Kullu, Himachal
Pradesh,
under Sections 126(2),
115(2),
3(5) and
103(1)
of
BNS.
Respondent-State has filed status report and ASI Tilak Raj has come
present with record. Record perused and returned.
2.
Close
scrutiny
of
status
report/record
reveals
that
on
07.01.2026, complainant made a telephonic call to helpline, intimating
therein that while he was coming to police station along with the deceased
Deepak Jha, two motorcycles came from behind and took his taxi back to
Gada Gusaini, where number of persons gave beatings to Deepak Jha with
fists and kicks and he can identify those persons. Police, after having
received the aforesaid telephonic call, while going towards Gada Gusaini,
had reached near Jibhi, car bearing No. HR-56C-2096, being driven by
complainant, came from opposite side, wherein deceased Deepak Jha was
found to be lying in unconscious condition. Police immediately took
aforesaid person to Civil Hospital, Banjar, from where, deceased Deepak
Jha was referred to Regional Hospital, Kullu. Since deceased at relevant
time was not in a position to give statement, police recorded the statement
of complainant under Section 173 of BNSS, wherein he alleged that on
06.01.2026 at 7:00 PM, deceased Deepak Jha booked his taxi, bearing No.
HR-56C-2096, for going to Jibhi in Himachal Pradesh. He stated that at
9:00 a.m., he started from Chandigarh and reached Kullu at 5:00 PM and
from there, he started at 6:30 PM and reached Jibhi at 9:00 PM. He alleged
that deceased Deepak had stayed in homestay, whereas he had slept in his
vehicle. On 07.01.2026 at 9:00 AM, deceased Deepak Jha told him that he
has to go to Gada Gusaini for bringing his wife and as such, he along with
deceased Deepak Jha reached Gada Gusaini at 10:30 AM. He disclosed that
while he was near his taxi at 11:00 AM, deceased Deepak Jha came there
along with one lady and thereafter they went towards Jibhi, but when
vehicle reached near Bahu, some persons standing on the road stopped his
vehicle and pulled deceased Deepak Jha as well as lady out of the car and
gave beatings to Deepak Jha. He alleged that lady was taken back by local
persons to their village, whereas deceased Deepak Jha was made to sit in
his car and thereafter, he made a telephonic call to the helpline. He alleged
that when he reached Jibhi, two vehicles being driven by persons namely
Sachin and Bittu came from behind and they forcibly took his vehicle back
to Gada Gusaini and at 3:30 PM, deceased Deepak Jha was again given
beatings. Deceased Deepak Jha was stated to be under the influence of
liquor. He alleged that 12 to 15 persons gave beatings to Deepak Jha and
he can recognize them. He alleged that again he took Deepak to Jibhi,
where police met him and Deepak Jha was taken to the hospital. In the
afore background, FIR detailed hereinabove came to be lodged against the
ten persons, including one juvenile, who has already been enlarged on bail.
3.
Present bail petitioner, who never came to be named by
complainant at the time of lodging of FIR, has approached this court in the
instant proceedings for grant of regular bail, on the ground that he has
been falsely implicated.
4.
Mr. Yash Pal, learned counsel for the petitioner, states that
bare perusal of statement of the complainant recorded under Section 173 of
BNSS, on the basis of which FIR came to be lodged, nowhere suggests that
present bail petitioner had given beatings to Deepak Jha, rather, he came
to be named in the FIR subsequently on the basis of statement made by
one Sh. Teja Singh, who alleged that bail petitioner, after his having arrived
at the spot at Dugga in a separate vehicle and being the last person to
reach there, also gave beatings to deceased Deepak Jha, but before the
incident, deceased Deepak Jha was allegedly given beatings on two
occasions by large number of people at Bahu and Gada Gusaini. Mr. Yash
Pal states that though no cogent and convincing evidence has been
adduced on record to demonstrate the involvement of the petitioner in the
alleged incident, but even otherwise, there is no evidence to connect the
bail petitioner with the injuries allegedly suffered by the deceased on his
head. He states that bare perusal of postmortem report though reveals that
multiple injuries were seen on the body of deceased Deepak Jha, but cause
of death has been shown to be injury on the head of the deceased Deepak
Jha. He states that statements of Sanjay Dutt and Nutan Singh recorded
under Section 180 of BNSS do not disclose the name of the present
petitioner or attribute any specific role to him. He states that since before
alleged arrival of deceased Deepak Jha at Dugga, he was given merciless
beating by group of persons at two places, coupled with the fact that
complainant, who claimed to be eyewitness, never named bail petitioner, he
deserves to be enlarged on bail.
5.
While fairly acknowledging factum with regard to filing of
challan in the competent Court of law, Mr. Rajan Kahol, learned Additional
Advocate General, stated that though nothing remains to be recovered from
the bail-petitioner, but keeping in view the gravity of offence alleged to have
been committed by them, he does not deserve any leniency, rather his
prayer for grant of regular bail deserves outright rejection. Mr. Kahol states
that though at the time of making statement under Section 173 of BNSS,
complainant Lovely did not mention the name of the petitioner, but once
subsequently in investigation, one of the eyewitnesses disclosed that
present bail petitioner had also given beatings to the deceased Deepak Jha
at Dugga, no illegality can be said to have been committed by the
investigating agency while naming bail petitioner in the alleged commission
of offence. He states that though postmortem report reveals that deceased
died on account of his having suffered injury on his head, but multiple
injuries were also seen on the person of the deceased. Mr. Kahol states that
once persons named in the FIR were found to have given beatings to the
deceased in the alleged incident, they all are equally responsible for his
death and as such, cannot escape liability on the ground that injury, if any,
caused on the head of the deceased was not caused by them. Mr. Kahol
states that since bail petitioner is accused of heinous crime punishable
under Sections 126(2), 115(2), 3(5) and 103(1) of BNS, coupled with the fact
that statements of complainant as well as other material prosecution
witnesses are yet to be recorded, it may not be in the interest of justice to
enlarge them on bail because in that event they may not only flee from
justice, but may tamper with the prosecution evidence.
6.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
material available on record, this court finds that deceased Deepak Jha, on
the date of alleged incident, was allegedly given beatings at three different
places. Firstly, he was given beatings at Bahu, where deceased had alighted
from the taxi being driven by the complainant for bringing his so-called
wife, but before he could leave Bahu, some persons stopped the vehicle and
gave beatings to Deepak Jha and lady accompanying him was made to go
back to her village. While complainant was taking Deepak Jha in injured
condition to Jibhi, allegedly two persons, Sachin and Bittu, came from
behind and took car of the complainant back to Gada Gusaini, where again
allegedly Deepak Jha was given beatings. After giving merciless beating to
the
deceased
Deepak
Jha,
persons
namely
Sachin,
Bittu,
Tikam,
Gopichand along with other co-accused gave beatings and made the
complainant Lovely to take deceased Deepak Jha back to Jibhi, but before
complainant could reach Jibhi, allegedly group of persons again stopped
him at Dugga and started giving him beatings. While group of persons were
giving beatings to deceased Deepak Jha at Dugga, present bail petitioner,
Nartoam Singh, arrived at the spot at Dugga in a separate vehicle and
allegedly gave beatings to the deceased.
7.
True it is that on account of injuries suffered by the deceased
Deepak Jha in the alleged incident as detailed hereinabove, he died at
Regional Hospital, Kullu and Postmortem report adduced on record also
suggests that multiple injuries were noticed on the body of the deceased
Deepak Jha, but cause of death was opined to be intracranial hemorrhage
leading to compression of vital centers of brain caused by blunt force
trauma. No poison/ethyl alcohol was detected in the blood and viscera of
the deceased.
8.
In nutshell, case of the petitioners, as has been highlighted in
the grounds of bail petitions and further canvassed by Mr. Yash Pal,
learned counsel for the petitioner, is that person, before whom all three
incidents of beatings happened, never named present bail petitioner,
rather, he specifically named accused other than bail petitioner. Mr. Yash
Pal states that it is only the statement of independent witness Teja Singh
that bail petitioner, after his having arrived at the spot at Dugga in a
separate vehicle, also gave beatings to Deepak Jha, but such allegation
never came to be corroborated by the complainant, who specifically named
co-accused Sachin, Bittu and Gopichand.
9.
If the statement of Teja Singh recorded under Section 183
BNSS is perused in its entirety, it suggests that third incident of alleged
beatings happened at Dugga, where Teja Singh stopped the vehicle on the
telephonic information shared by his brother-in-law Santosh Kumar, who
disclosed that some unknown person has fled away with his niece in his
car. As per Teja Singh, he, after having stopped vehicle, asked deceased
Deepak Jha to leave while leaving behind lady brought by him from Gada
Gusaini, but he refused to do the same and in the meantime, persons
including Santosh Kumar came from behind and gave him beatings.
10.
It is ample clear from the statements of Teja Singh as well as
other witnesses that present bail petitioner had no information with regard
to incident, rather, he, after his having alighted from a separate vehicle at
Dugga, went towards the vehicle where group of persons already present
was giving beatings to deceased Deepak Jha.
11.
Since before third alleged incident of beatings at Dugga,
deceased Deepak Jha was already given merciless beatings on two
occasions at Bahu and Gada Gusaini, as stated by the complainant Lovely
Kumar, by the persons detailed hereinabove, coupled with the fact that
cause of death of the deceased was opined to be intracranial hemorrhage
leading to compression of vital center of brain, this court is persuaded to
agree with learned counsel representing the petitioner that at present, there
is no direct evidence adduced on record qua petitioner to connect him with
the actual cause of death of the deceased.
12.
No doubt, admittedly in the case at hand, large number of
persons gave beatings to deceased Deepak Jha at three different places.
There is no direct evidence that persons, who gave beatings to deceased
Deepak Jha at three places, had some kind of meeting prior to the alleged
date of incident.
13.
Firstly, vehicle was stopped at Bahu by the family members of
woman, who was being taken by the deceased Deepak Jha in the taxi being
driven by the complainant. Persons, who gave beatings to Deepak Jha at
Bahu and Gada Gusaini were named and identified by the complainant,
and as such, at first instance, were named as accused in the FIR.
14.
Second incident happened at Gada Gusaini at the house of the
woman, who was being taken by the deceased Deepak Jha, where family
members of woman gave beatings.
15.
Third incident happened when Teja Singh stopped the vehicle
at Dugga on the basis of telephonic call made by his brother-in-law
Santosh. Admittedly, when Teja Singh signaled vehicle to stop at Dugga,
present bail petitioner was not present, rather he at relevant time was
traveling in a separate vehicle and being the last person to reach there.
Before petitioner’s arrival at Dugga, group of persons came from Gada
Gusaini and gave beatings to deceased Deepak Jha.
16.
Teja Singh disclosed to the police that person namely Narotam
Singh i.e. bail petitioner herein, who had come in a separate vehicle at
Dugga, also gave beatings, but there is nothing in his statement that what
kind of beatings were given by him and whether injury, if any, was caused
by him on the head of the deceased, which ultimately became reason of the
death of the deceased. This court is unable to find out anything in the
record suggestive of the fact that after recording of statement of Teja Singh,
effort, if any, was made by the investigating agency to get present bail
petitioner identified from the complainant Lovely, who is an eyewitness and
had named other co-accused, who had given beatings to the deceased
Deepak Jha. Complainant, while giving his statement under Section 173 of
BNSS, specifically stated that he can identify the persons, who gave
beatings to the deceased, but record nowhere suggests that present bail
petitioner was got identified from the complainant.
17.
There is no evidence adduced on record that accused named in
the FIR, who allegedly gave beatings had any prior meeting of mind and
they, in furtherance of common intention to kill the deceased, gave
beatings, rather deceased suffered injuries in three different incidents.
Though in first-two incidents most of the accused can be said to be
common, but admittedly in third incident, accused, who had given beatings
in Gada Gusaini and Bahu, were not present at Dugga.
18.
Vehicle at Dugga was stopped by Teja Singh that too on the
askance of Santosh Kumar. Since present bail petitioner, prior to his
having alighted from his own vehicle at Dugga, had no intimation with
regard to alleged incident, as has been taken note hereinabove, it would be
too premature to conclude complicity of the petitioner in the case at hand.
19.
To accomplish complicity, if any, of the petitioner, especially
with regard to his knowledge of gathering persons at Dugga for giving
beatings to Deepak Jha, there is no sufficient evidence available on record,
rather such fact otherwise can be proved by prosecution by leading cogent
evidence during the trial. Similarly, this court is persuaded to agree with
learned counsel for petitioner that there is no direct evidence to connect the
present bail petitioner with the injury suffered by the deceased, which
ultimately became cause of his death.
20.
No doubt, petitioner herein is accused of heinous crime
punishable under Sections 126(2), 115(2), 3(5) and 103(1) of BNS, but such
fact alone may not be sufficient to dissuade this court from considering bail
petitions filed at the behest of the bail petitioner, for the reasons noticed
hereinabove.
21.
No doubt, gravity of offence alleged to have committed by the
bail-petitioner is required to be taken into consideration, while considering
the prayer, if any, made on his/her behalf for bail, but it is also settled that
the gravity of offence cannot be sole criteria to decide the bail petition,
rather other competing factors are required to be taken into consideration.
Reliance in this regard is placed upon the judgment passed by this Court
in Jeet Ram v. State of H.P., Latest HLJ 2003(HP) 23, wherein it has been
held as under:“7. As is the case of the prosecution, the only role attributed to the
accused persons is that they caught hold of the deceased and their
co-accused Savitri and Bimla pelted stones at him and thereafter
Bhupender gave him the fatal blow with a 'Draft'. Prima facie it is
difficult to believe that when a person is caught hold of by three
persons two other persons are pelting stones at him, then such
person and those persons who have caught hold of him will not
sustain any injury. Therefore, the version regarding pelt ing of
stones and holding of the deceased is prima facie clouded by
suspicion as none of the accused persons who are alleged to have
caught hold of the deceased while co- accused Savitri and Bimla
were pelting stones at the deceased did not receive any injury
whatsoever and no injury caused by the pelting of stones was found
on the per son of the deceased. Mere catching hold of the deceased
by the accused persons may not necessarily lead to the conclusion
that they haw the common object of killing the deceased as the
applicability of Section 149, IPC, In the facts of the ease, is a
debatable question.
8. In Thakar Singh v. State of Punjab, 1969 Cur LJ 810 (relied
upon by the learned Counsel for the accused persons to
substantiate his contention) wherein the case of the prosecution was
that accused Niranjan Singh 10 caught hold of the deceased and fell
him down and accused Thakar Singh throttled his neck, the Punjab
and Haryana High Court held as under :
"........ It is not a case in which it can be legitimately
contended on behalf of the prosecution that there was any
pre-planned common intention on the part of both Niranjan
Singh and his father Thakar Singh in throttling the deceased.
There could be no such intention on the part of Niranjan
Singh even in executing his act of catching hold of the boy by
the arms and throwing him down on the ground. The act of
throttling by Thakar Singh followed per se and was
independent of the act of throwing the boy down by Niranjan
Singh. Thus, there is no community of intention in the act
performed by Niranjan Singh and that executed by Thakar
Singh. The two are distinct ones and one has nothing to do
with the other. No intention on the part of Niranjan Singh
from his act could be inferred in common with the intention of
throttling by Thakar Singh, which followed later on. It is not a
case in which it could be held that throwing down was
committed by Niranjan Singh in furtherance of the common
intention of throttling by Thakar Singh. Thus, the applicability
of Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code is uncalled for.
Niranjan Singh appellant could not be held vicariously liable
by virtue of that Section. This is additional ground of his being
entitled to acquittal."
9. In Jaspal Singh v. State of Haryana, 1986 (2) Recent CR 582 (2)
wherein one of the accused caught hold of the deceased while armed
with a stick but did not cause any injury to the deceased whereas
his co-accused caused injuries to the deceased which resulted in his
death, the Punjab and Haryana High Court granted bail to the
accused who had only caught hold of the deceased while on the
following premise :
"Though the motive was with the petitioner and he caught
hold of the deceased while armed with a stick, he did, not
cause any injury to the deceased. Rather his co-accused did
cause injuries to the deceased which resulted in his death. In
this situation, applicability of Section 34 Indian Penal Code is
a moot point. It would thus be apt that the petitioner gets the
concession of bail."
10. In Kuldip Singh v. State of Punjab, 1994 (3) Rec Cri R 137 :
(1994 Cri LJ 2201) (SC) where one of the accused inflicted the injury
on the head of the injured with sharp edged weapon and the second
accused gave 'Lathi' blow on his shoulder causing simple injury
allegedly with the common intention of accused in an attempt to
commit the murder of the injured, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held
that the injury on the head of the injured was serious one and
proved to be grievous, therefore, the offence under Section 307,
I.P.C. is made out against Kuldip Singh who caused 11 such injury
but in so far as the other co-accused is concerned, he inflicted only
one blow on the shoulder with the 'Lathi' causing swelling, therefore,
it could not be said that he shared the common intention along with
the Kuldip Singh in attempt to commit the murder of the injured.”
“12.There is no doubt that offence punishable under Section
302, I.P.C. is a grave offence for which the extreme penalty of death
has been provided in law. However, the mere gravity of the offence
and the severity of punishment is no ground for rejection of bail,
while deciding the question of grant or refusal of the bail, other
factors such as the nature of evidence, the part played by the
accused in the commission of the 6f-fence and the likelihood of the
accused absconding or, tampering with prosecution evidence has
also to be taken into account”.
22.
Hon'ble Apex Court and this Hon'ble Court have held in a
catena of judgments that one is deemed to be innocent, till the time,
his/her guilt is proved in accordance with law. In the case at hand, guilt, if
any, of the bail petitioner is yet to be proved in accordance with law, as
such, this court sees no reason to let the bail petitioner incarcerate in jail,
for an indefinite period, especially when, he is behind the bars.
23.
Apprehension expressed by of learned Additional Advocate
General that in the event of the bail petitioner being enlarged on bail, he
may flee from justice, can be best met by putting the bail petitioner to
stringent conditions.
24.
Hon'ble Apex Court in Criminal
Appeal No. 227/2018,
Dataram Singh vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr decided on 6.2.2018 has
held that freedom of an individual cannot be curtailed for indefinite period,
especially when his/her guilt is yet to be proved. It has been further held by
the Hon'ble Apex Court in the aforesaid judgment that a person is believed
to be innocent until found guilty.
25.
Hon’ble Apex Court in Sanjay Chandra versus Central Bureau
of Investigation (2012)1 Supreme Court Cases 49 has held that gravity
alone cannot be a decisive ground to deny bail, rather competing factors are
required to be balanced by the court while exercising its discretion. It has
been repeatedly held by the Hon’ble Apex Court that object of bail is to
secure the appearance of the accused person at his trial by reasonable
amount of bail. The object of bail is neither punitive nor preventative.
26.
In Manoranjana Sinh alias Gupta versus CBI, (2017) 5 SCC
218, Hon'ble Apex Court has held that the object of the bail is to secure the
attendance of the accused in the trial and the proper test to be applied in
the solution of the question whether bail should be granted or refused is
whether it is probable that the party will appear to take his trial. Otherwise
also, normal rule is of bail and not jail. Apart from above, Court has to keep
in mind nature of accusations, nature of evidence in support thereof,
severity of the punishment, which conviction will entail, character of the
accused, circumstances which are peculiar to the accused involved in that
crime.
27.
The Apex Court in Prasanta Kumar Sarkar versus Ashis
Chatterjee and another (2010) 14 SCC 496, has laid down various
principles to be kept in mind, while deciding petition for bail viz. prima facie
case, nature and gravity of accusation, punishment involved, apprehension
of repetition of offence and witnesses being influenced.
28.
In view of the aforesaid discussion as well as law laid down by
the Hon’ble Apex Court, bail-petitioner has carved out a case for grant of
bail, accordingly, the petition is allowed and the bail-petitioner is ordered to
be enlarged on bail in aforesaid FIR, subject to his furnishing personal
bonds in the sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- with two local sureties in the like
amount to the satisfaction of concerned Chief Judicial Magistrate/trial
Court, with following conditions:
a. He shall make himself available for the purpose of interrogation, if so
required and regularly attend the trial Court on each and every date of
hearing and if prevented by any reason to do so, seek exemption from
appearance by filing appropriate application;
b. He shall not tamper with the prosecution evidence nor hamper the
investigation of the case in any manner whatsoever;
c. He shall not make any inducement, threat or promises to any person
acquainted with the facts of the case so as to dissuade from from disclosing
such facts to the Court or the Police Officer; and
d. He shall not leave the territory of India without the prior permission of the
Court.
29.
It is clarified that if the petitioner misuses the liberty or violates
any of the conditions imposed upon him, the investigating agency shall be
free to move this Court for cancellation of the bail.
30.
Any observations made hereinabove shall not be construed to
be a reflection on the merits of the case and shall remain confined to the
disposal of this application alone. The petition stands accordingly disposed
of.
31.
A downloaded copy of this order shall be accepted by the
learned trial Court, while accepting the bail bonds from the petitioner and
in case, said court intends to ascertain the veracity of the downloaded copy
of order presented to it, same may be ascertained from the official website
of this Court.
(Sandeep Sharma),
Judge
November 05, 2026
(sunil)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review