Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1 2026:HHC:30036
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT
SHIMLA
OMP No. 1639 of 2025
in C.S. No. 58 of 2025
Reserved on: 19.6.2026
Decided on : 21.7.2026
Uploaded on: 21.7.2026
Narinder Kumar Seth & anr.
… Applicants
Versus
Dharmender Kumar Seth
…Non-applicant
_____________________________ ______________
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, Judge
Whether approved for reporting? yes
___________________________________________________
For the Applicants:
Mr. Deepak Gupta, Advocate.
For the Non-applicants : Mr. Vishal Mohan, Senior
Advocate, assisted by Mr.
Rohit Shyam, Advocate.
Virender Singh, Judge
The present application has been filed, under
Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC, with a prayer to restrain
the respondent, from interfering in peaceful possession
of the applicants/plaintiffs,
through
his
agents,
either
servants,
personally, or
employees,
family
members, customers etc. over the land comprised in
Khata No. 48, Khatauni No. 59, Khasra No. 1082,
measuring 39.47 sq. meters, 1083 measuring 233-60 sq.
2 2026:HHC:30036
meters and Khasra No. 1089 measuring 08-00 sq.
meters alongwith the land comprised in Khewat No. 28
min, Khatauni No. 37, Khasra Nos. 1220/1088, 1090,
1094, Kitas 3, measuring 219-34 square meters. A
prayer has also been made to restrain the respondent
from interfering in the portion falling in exclusive
possession of plaintiff/applicant No. 1, shown in yellow
and light blue colour, which is common portion of Hotel
Lord’s Grey in Plan Annexure P-1. (The land detailed
above is referred to as ‘the suit land’).
2.
The said application has been filed in Civil Suit
No. 58 of 2025, titled as, Narinder Kumar Seth & anr.
versus Dharminder Kumar Seth.
3.
The said suit has been filed for possession, by
demolition of structure, illegally raised by the respondent
(hereinafter referred to as ‘the defendant’), over a portion
of the suit land, which is shown in Plan Annexure P-1,
and
for
grant
of
decree
of
permanent
perpetual
prohibitory injunction, restraining the defendant from
interfering in the peaceful possession of the petitioner
3 2026:HHC:30036
(hereinafter referred to as ‘the plaintiffs’), over the suit
land.
4.
The suit has been filed, on the ground, that the
suit
property, namely, Hotel Lord’s Grey, is a six
storeyed building. The said Hotel has been constructed
upon Khasra Nos. 1085, 1086, 1087, 1119, 1120, 1121,
1123, Kita 8 measuring 334-13 square meters. The said
property was earlier joint between plaintiff No. 1,
defendant, another brother namely Mohinder Seth in
equal shares. Due to differences, arisen between the
brothers, the said property was partitioned by virtue of
partition deed executed, inter se the co-owners, on
20.5.2013. The same has been annexed with the plaint
as Annexure P-3. As per the terms and conditions of the
said partition deed, different portions of the Hotel were
divided amongst the co-sharers and certain portions
were kept common. In this regard, the plaintiffs have
relied upon the plan, in which, property of all the cosharers have been depicted in different colours.
5.
According to the plaintiffs, the portion, shown in
yellow colour, fell in the share of plaintiff No. 1, the
4 2026:HHC:30036
portion shown in the orange colour fell in the share of
the defendant and the one shown in pink colour fell
within the share of other brother namely Mohinder Seth.
The common passage of plaintiff No. 1 and defendant
was kept joint and depicted in light brown colour in
Annexure P-1. The property which had fallen to the
share of plaintiff No. 2, which has allegedly been
encroached upon by the defendant, has been shown in
dark blue/purple colour in the Plan. Plaintiff No. 2 was
not a party or signatory to the said partition deed.
6.
As per the terms and conditions of the partition
deed, and as per the case set up by the plaintiffs,
defendant has agreed upon to remove the encroachment,
which has been depicted in violet colour. However, he
has failed to do so. The said encroachment has been
described in clause-30 of the partition deed (Annexure P3), depicted in purple colour.
7.
It is further case of the plaintiffs that plaintiff No.
2 had purchased the property by way of two different
sale deeds, executed
in favour of plaintiff No. 2, on
28.7.2007 (Annexures P-4 and P-5). She is the exclusive
5 2026:HHC:30036
owner in possession of those properties
and the
defendant is stated to be the complete stranger to the
said property, owned and possessed by plaintiff No. 2
and has no right to encroach upon the same, damage
the
same,
trespass
or
cause
any
hindrances
or
obstruction in the said property.
8.
According to the plaintiffs, plaintiff No. 2 had
also constructed a house upon a portion of Khasra No.
1220/1088, 1090, 1094, kitas 3, measuring 218-34 sq.
meters. Both the plaintiffs, alongwith their family
members, are residing in the said house. The approach
to the said house is from the remaining vacant land of
the plaintiffs upon Khasra No. 1220/1088, 1090 and
1094. Those Khasra Nos. are exclusively owned by
plaintiff No. 2.
9.
Relying upon the partition deed, Annexure P-3, it
is their further case that the defendant has duly agreed
that he shall not claim any other approach except the
common approach from the Circular Road, leading to his
share in the hotel.
6 2026:HHC:30036
10.
It is the case of the plaintiffs that the plaintiffs,
being senior citizens, in order to protect their property,
from being trespassed, had installed an iron gate on the
entry point of land of plaintiff No. 2, from road leading to
Fingask Estate, which is towards Northern side of the
suit property. However, defendant, alongwith his family
members, in the absence of plaintiff No. 2, trespassed in
the land, exclusively owned by her and vandalized the
iron gate. The matter was also reported to the Police,
where, FIR No. 219 of 2025, under Sections 329(3),
324(4), 351(2) and 3(5) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita,
2023 was registered. Not only this, the defendant has
also started interfering in the exclusive ownership and
possession
of plaintiff No. 2. He has also started
interfering in the portion of the Hotel, which had fallen
to the share of plaintiff No. 1. The defendant not only
failed to abide by the terms and conditions of partition
deed, but also failed to remove the encroachments.
11.
On the basis of above facts, the plaintiffs have
sought the following reliefs:
“i) A decree for possession by demolition of structure illegally
raised by the defendant upon the land comprised in Khewat
7 2026:HHC:30036
No. 48, Khatuni No.59, Khasra No. 1083, measuring 233.60
square meters as duly depicted and earmarked in Plan
Annexure P-1 in violet colour filed alongwith the plaint;
situated at Up Mohal Upper Kaithu, Station ward Bara Shimla,
Tehsil and District Shimla, H.P.
ii) That a decree for permanent prohibitory injunction may
kindly be passed in favour of the plaintiffs and against the
defendant, restraining the defendant either Personally or
through his agents, servants, employees, family members,
customers etc. from interfering in peaceful possession or the
plaintiffs upon the land comprised in Khata No. 48, Khatuni
No. 59, Khasra No. 1082 measuring 39.47 sq Mts, 1083
measuring 233-60 square meters and Khasra No. 1089
measuring 08-00 square meters along with land comprised in
Khewat No. 28min, Khatauni No. 37, Khasra Nos. 1220/1088,
1090, 1094, Kitas 3, measuring 219-34 square meters and also
the portion falling in exclusive share of Plaintiff No 1 shown in
yellow colour and light blue colour (which is common portion of
hotel) in plan annexed as Annexure P-1.”
12.
Alongwith the suit, the present application has
also been filed, seeking relief of injunction, as referred to
above.
13.
When, put to notice, the suit, as well as, the
application has been contested by the defendant. The
defendant has contested the suit by filing written
statement, by taking preliminary objections that the
present suit is not maintainable, as the same has been
filed by suppressing the material facts; the plaintiffs
have not approached the Court with clean hands. The
8 2026:HHC:30036
plaintiffs
have
not
impleaded
the
concerned
Revenue/Municipal authority, despite the fact that the
disputed
gate
and
passage
are
situated
upon
Government land/public land, and not on their private
property and they have also suppressed the material
documents from this Court, including the joint fire safety
plans, submitted by both the parties, before Fire
Department
and the Fire Department issued ‘No
Objection Certificate’, after inspecting the spot. These
facts have been pleaded by the defendant to demonstrate
that there was no encroachment, as alleged.
14.
According to the defendant, the passage is open
and there is no interruption caused by him. The suit is
also stated to be bad for mis-joinder and non-joinder of
the necessary parties, as the State Government and the
Municipal Corporation have not been impleaded as
party.
15.
As per the further stand of the defendant, the
plaintiffs have no cause of action; the suit is not properly
valued for the purpose of Court fee and jurisdiction; the
plaintiffs are estopped from filing the suit, on account of
9 2026:HHC:30036
their acts and conduct. The plaintiffs are stated to have
deliberately concealed the document dated 28.11.1991,
whereby both the parties have lawfully created and
purchased the portion of the land, exclusively for use as
a passage. As per the said document, a strip of land,
measuring
about 33.75 sq. yards, was agreed to be
purchased only for the specific purpose of constructing a
pucca passage only with a clear stipulation that no
construction would be raised thereupon.
16.
On merits, the suit has been contested by
denying that property of plaintiffs has been encroached
by the defendant. According to him, at the time of
execution of partition deed in the year 2013, the land
bearing khasra Nos. 1082, 1083 and 1089 was vacant
and the so-called encroachments shown in violet colour,
in the map attached with the partition deed, were in fact,
situated on the property of plaintiff No. 2 and in terms of
Clause-30 of the partition deed, all such encroachments
were duly removed and thereafter, proper construction
was raised after obtaining approval of building plans
from the competent authorities.
10 2026:HHC:30036
17.
It is the further case of the defendant that
plaintiff No. 2 was also signatory to the partition deed
and
personally
appeared
before
the
Registering
Authority. He has also denied that he has encroached
upon the portion shown in the site plan with dark
blue/purple colour.
18.
Re-asserting the fact that the passage in dispute
is situated over the government land, a prayer has been
made to dismiss the suit.
19.
On the similar grounds, application under Order
39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC has been contested.
20.
The plaintiffs have filed the suit for possession by
demolition of the structure, illegally raised by the
defendant over land comprising khasra No. 1083,
measuring 233.60 sq. meter, as shown in the site plan.
The said relief has been sought on the ground that
partition deed has been executed between the co-owners
on 20.5.2013. The relief under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2
CPC has been sought against the defendant, restraining
him from interfering in the peaceful possession over the
land bearing khasra Nos. 1082, 1089, 1220/1088, 1090,
11 2026:HHC:30036
1094 and also portion falling in the exclusive share of
plaintiff No. 1, shown in yellow colour and light blue
colour (common portion of the hotel shown in site plan
Annexure P-1). The said relief has been sought by both
the plaintiffs.
21.
As stated above, the factum of private partition,
as pleaded in para-2 of the plaint, has been contested by
pleading that the portion in exclusive possession of
plaintiff No. 2, has not been encroached upon by the
defendant and according to the defendant, at the time of
partition, in the year 2015, land comprising in khasra
Nos. 1082, 1083 and 1089 was vacant, and the so-called
encroachment shown in violet colour, was, in fact,
situated in the property of plaintiff No. 2, and as per
clause-30 of the partition deed, all such encroachments
were duly removed. Thereafter, the proper construction
was raised after obtaining approval of building plan from
the municipal authorities.
22.
Heavily relying upon the building plan, it has
been asserted that no encroachment subsisted on the
said land. The stand that plaintiff No. 2 was not a party
12 2026:HHC:30036
or signatory to the partition deed, has also been
contested by pleading that plaintiff No. 2 willingly signed
the map attached to the partition deed and personally
appeared before the Registering Authority. As such, she
has
fully
consented
to
the
demarcation
and
arrangements made therein.
23.
The primary purpose of the relief, under Order
39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC, is to protect the subject matter of
the lis, till the rights of the parties are decided, after the
full fledged trial. The relief is protective in nature to
maintain status quo qua the lis, as it exists at the time
of inception of the lis. However, in order to succeed in an
application, filed under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC, the
plaintiffs have to prove three ingredients, i.e. prima-facie
case, balance of convenience and irreparable loss of
injury, which cannot be compensated in terms of money.
24.
The relief of injunction is equitable relief and the
party approaching the Court must disclose all the
material facts. A person, who seeks equity, must do
equity. In the above backdrop, now this Court would
proceed further to determine whether the plaintiff has
13 2026:HHC:30036
successfully proved three ingredients, as well as, the fact
that they have approached the Court with clean hands.
25.
First of all, coming to the first ingredient ‘prima-
facie’ case, is concerned, the said term, is nowhere
defined in the Code of Civil Procedure, however,
according to the settled proposition of law, the case,
which requires mature consideration and which is not
liable to be thrown away at the threshold of the
litigation, falls within the definition of ‘prima-facie case’.
26.
Here, the plaintiffs are asserting their claim for
possession by demolition of structure, illegally raised by
the defendant over khasra No. 1081, as shown in plan
Annexure P-1, on the basis of partition deed, which has
been admittedly executed between the co-owners on
20.5.2013. The execution of the partition deed has not
been disputed by the defendant and a plea has been
taken by the defendant that, so called, encroachments
have already been removed, as per clause-30 of the
partition deed. When, the partition deed has been relied
upon by both the parties, then clause-30 of the same
has to be read in the light of the stand, as taken by both
14 2026:HHC:30036
the parties and the same cannot be ignored. It is not the
case
of
the
plaintiff
that
clause
of
the
settlement/partition deed has not been complied with.
27.
As per para-9 of the suit, cause of action is
stated to be accrued to the plaintiffs by filing the suit
recently, when, defendant, his wife, son and their
employees and hotel staff have broken the iron gate and
started harassing the guests and tourists, staying in the
Hotel, whereas, defendant is asserting that all the
encroachments have already been removed, as per
Clause-30 of the partition deed. The suit, as well as, the
application is totally silent about the fact when that the
alleged encroachments were made by the defendant.
Plaintiff No. 2 is signatory to the document (partition
deed dated 20.5.2013) and as per clause-30, defendant
D.K. Seth would remove the encroachment, abutting to
the land of Ms. Asha Seth, plaintiff No. 2. It is not the
case of the plaintiffs that the defendant has not complied
with clause No. 30 of the document, governing their inter
se relationship.
15 2026:HHC:30036
28.
The plaintiffs are seeking relief of possession, as
well as, permanent prohibitory injunction. The relief of
possession is confined to Khasra No. 1083, measuring
233.60 sq. meters and they are also seeking relief
regarding suit property, comprising in Khasra Nos. 1082,
1083, 1089, 1220, 1088 and 1090 and also, qua
the
portion falling in exclusive share of the plaintiffs in
yellow colour and light blue colour, which has been
described as common portion of the Hotel.
29.
From the above stand, it appears that the
plaintiffs themselves are not sure about their case, as,
on one hand, they have asserted that private partition
had taken place, whereas, nothing is there in the
pleadings, as to when, the defendant has allegedly made
efforts to interfere in their possession. The term ‘recently’
nowhere leads the case of the plaintiffs. As such, it can
be said that plaintiffs have no prima-facie case, in their
favour, at this stage.
30.
Similarly, it cannot be said that balance of
convenience lies in favour of the plaintiffs, especially
when, defendant has taken the specific plea that as per
16 2026:HHC:30036
Clause-30, all the encroachments have been removed.
Moreover, when, the specific stand has been taken by
the defendant, qua the fact that the passage and gate are
not situated over the government land, as such, no relief
could be granted to the plaintiffs, until or unless, it has
been established by the plaintiffs that the passage and
gate are not situated over the government land.
31.
When, the plaintiffs are asserting the fact that
there is interference over the peaceful possession, it is
for them to, prima-facie, prove this fact by pleading the
necessary ingredients, as the defendant has taken the
plea that there is no interruption in the common use of
the area, kept joint between the parties.
32.
In para-6 of the preliminary objections, it has
been asserted by the defendant that vide document
dated 28.11.1991, parties to the lis have purchased a
portion of the land, for being used as passage measuring
33.75 sq. meters.
33.
In the replication, the existence of the said
document has not been disputed, however, it has been
alleged that the same does not create any right upon the
17 2026:HHC:30036
parties, but, from the said fact, it can be said, at this
stage, that the material facts have been concealed by the
plaintiffs from the scrutiny of the Court. As such, they
are not entitled for any equitable relief of injunction, in
their favour, at this stage.
34.
Considering
all
these
facts,
the
present
application is dismissed.
35.
Any of the observations, made herein above,
shall not be taken as an expression of opinion, on the
merits of the case, as these observations, are confined,
only, to the disposal of the present application.
(Virender Singh)
Judge
21.7.2026
Kalpana
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review