Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
* THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE NYAPATHY VIJAY
WRIT PETITION No.27611 of 2025
% 30.10.2026
# Paravada Ganesh and Others
….
Petitioners
….
Respondents
Versus
$ The State of Andhra Pradesh and Others
! Counsel for the Petitioner(s)
: K.G. Krishna Murthy, Senior Counsel
assisted by K. Raghuveer
! Counsel for the Respondent
: Government Pleader for Services-I
WRIT PETITION No.29972 of 2025
% 30.10.2026
# Y. Nageswari and Others
….
Petitioners
….
Respondents
Versus
$ The State of Andhra Pradesh and Others
! Counsel for the Petitioner(s)
: M. Vijay Kumar, Senior Counsel,
assisted by Sri Manoj Kumar Bethapudi
! Counsel for the Respondent
: Government Pleader for Services-I
WRIT PETITION No.31717 of 2025
% 30.10.2026
# Ramireddy Srinivasarao and Others
….
Petitioners
….
Respondents
Versus
$ The State of Andhra Pradesh and Others
! Counsel for the Petitioner(s)
: Bhagavan Gandhi
! Counsel for the Respondent
: Government Pleader for Services-I
WRIT PETITION No.32771 of 2025
% 30.10.2026
….
# Narikanapu Sunil Kumar
Petitioner
Versus
$ The State of Andhra Pradesh and Others
….
Respondents
! Counsel for the Petitioner(s)
: V. Satyanarayana Nekkanti
! Counsel for the Respondent
: Government Pleader for Services-I
WRIT PETITION No.7016 of 2026
% 30.10.2026
….
# K. Venkata Ramana
Petitioner
Versus
$ The State of Andhra Pradesh and Others
….
Respondents
! Counsel for the Petitioner(s)
: M. Vijay Kumar, Senior Counsel
assisted by Manoj Kumar Bethapudi
! Counsel for the Respondent
: Government Pleader for Services-I
WRIT PETITION No.11918 of 2026
% 30.10.2026
….
# Matta Hareesh and Others
Petitioners
Versus
$ The State of Andhra Pradesh and Others
….
Respondents
! Counsel for the Petitioner(s)
: Shaik Abdul Siddiq
! Counsel for the Respondent
: Government Pleader for Services-I
< Gist:
> Head Note:
? Cases referred: 1) (2017) 14 SCC 797
2) Civil Appeal No.4735 of 2022
3) Civil Appeal No.209 of 2023
4) (2008) 12 SCC 331
5) (2019) 20 SCC 17
6) (2023) 13 SCC 193
7) 2026 INSC 276
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE NYAPATHY VIJAY
WRIT PETITION No.27611 of 2025
# Paravada Ganesh and Others
….
Petitioners
Versus
$ The State of Andhra Pradesh and Others
….
Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.29972 of 2025
# Y. Nageswari and Others
….
Petitioners
….
Respondents
Versus
$ The State of Andhra Pradesh and Others
WRIT PETITION No.31717 of 2025
# Ramireddy Srinivasarao and Others
….
Petitioners
….
Respondents
Versus
$ The State of Andhra Pradesh and Others
WRIT PETITION No.32771 of 2025
# Narikanapu Sunil Kumar
….
Petitioner
….
Respondents
Versus
$ The State of Andhra Pradesh and Others
WRIT PETITION No.7016 of 2026
# K. Venkata Ramana
….
Petitioner
….
Respondents
Versus
$ The State of Andhra Pradesh and Others
WRIT PETITION No.11918 of 2026
# Matta Hareesh and Others
….
Petitioners
….
Respondents
Versus
$ The State of Andhra Pradesh and Others
DATE OF ORDER PRONOUNCED: 30.10.2026
SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE NYAPATHY VIJAY
1. Whether Reporters of Local Newspapers may
be allowed to see the Order?
Yes/No
2. Whether the copies of Order may be marked
to Law Reporters/Journals?
Yes/No
3. Whether Your Lordships wish to see the fair
copy of the Order?
Yes/No
__________________
NYAPATHY VIJAY, J
Date of reserved for orders : 29.09.2026
Date of pronouncement
: 30.10.2026
Date of uploading
: 30.10.2026
APHC010533382025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3460]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE 30th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NYAPATHY VIJAY
WRIT PETITION NO: 27611/2025
Between:
Paravada Ganesh and Others
...PETITIONER(S)
AND
The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1.
K RAGHU VEER
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1.
GP FOR SERVICES I
WRIT PETITION NO: 29972/2025
Between:
Y Nageswari and Others
...PETITIONER(S)
AND
The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. MANOJ KUMAR BETHAPUDI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR SERVICES I
WRIT PETITION NO: 31717/2025
Between:
Ramireddy Srinivasarao and Others
...PETITIONER(S)
AND
The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. BHAGAVAN GANDI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR SERVICES I
WRIT PETITION NO: 32771/2025
Between:
Narikanapu Sunil Kumar
...PETITIONER
AND
The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. V SATYANARAYANA NEKKANTI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR SERVICES I
...RESPONDENT(S)
WRIT PETITION NO: 7016/2026
Between:
K Venkata Ramana
...PETITIONER
AND
The State Of AP and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. MANOJ KUMAR BETHAPUDI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR SERVICES I
WRIT PETITION NO: 11918/2026
Between:
Matta Hareesh and Others
...PETITIONER(
AND
The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. SHAIK ABDUL SIDDIQ
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR SERVICES I
The Court made the following:
Whether the order is :
Speaking Yes/No / Reasoned Yes/No
Reportable Yes/No / Non-Reportable Yes/No
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE NYAPATHY VIJAY
WRIT PETITION Nos.27611, 29972, 31717, 32771 of 2025,
W.P.Nos.7016 and 11918 of 2026
COMMON ORDER:
1.
The Writ Petition No.29972 of 2025 and W.P.Nos.7016 and
11918 of 2026 are filed to declare the action of Respondents in not
considering the candidature of Petitioners for the post of SCT Police
Constables in the un-filled/left over vacancies under the Notification
issued vide Rc.No.161/SLPRB/Rect.2/2022, dated 28.11.2022,
as illegal and arbitrary. While the Writ Petition Nos.27611, 31717
and 32771 of 2025 were filed questioning the validity of Clause
33(ix) of the Notification issued vide Rc.No.161/SLPRB/Rect.2/2022,
dated 28.11.2022.
2.
Introduction:
The State Government vide G.O.Ms.No.153, Home (Services.
IV) Department, dated 20.10.2022 had issued a notification to fill-up
the posts of Sub-Inspectors (Civil), Reserve Sub-Inspectors, Police
Constables (Civil) and Police Constables (APSP) totaling 6511
posts. Pursuant thereto, the State Level Police Recruitment Board
(hereinafter referred to as “Board” for brevity) had issued a
notification vide Rc.No.161/SLPRB/Rect.2/2022, dated 28.11.2022
inviting applications from eligible candidates to fill-up 3580 posts of
Police constables (Civil) (Men and Women) and 2520 posts of Police
Constable APSP (Men).
3.
The Method of Selection is in four (4) stages as under:
i. Preliminary Written Test for 200 marks
ii. Physical Measurements Test (PMT)
iii. Physical Efficiency Test (PET)
iv. Final Written Examination for 200 marks.
4.
Thereafter, final selection of the Candidates (Men and
Women) will be made strictly on relative merit as obtained by them
based on their score in the Final Written Examination for 200 marks
for the Candidates, who qualified in Physical Efficiency Test and as
per the provisions of the A.P. Public Employment (Organization of
Local Cadres and Regulation of Direct Recruitment) Order, 1975.
Special representation for Meritorious Sportspersons, National NCC,
Ex-Servicemen, Home Guards, children of Police Personnel were
also provided a certain quota in the appointments.
5.
After the due selection process, the Petitioners, who were
equally meritorious, were not selected on account of various
selection dynamics. The provisionally selected candidates were
referred for antecedent verification and medical examination. At that
stage, some of the provisionally selected candidates dropped out of
the antecedent verification and medical examination on account of
various
individual
reasons
like
being
selected
in
different
departments, unwillingness to join etc., and that resulted in 400
posts being left un-filled. The Petitioners, being the next meritorious,
and willing to join the Police Department, sought the Respondent
authorities to consider their case for appointment in the leftover
vacancies.
6.
However, their cases were not considered. The defence taken
in the Counter-Affidavit was that Clause 33(ix) of the notification
states that the Police Recruitment Board will not maintain a waiting
list for any recruitment process. The list of candidates provisionally
selected as against notified posts shall be final and no waiting list
shall be maintained under any circumstances. The further defence
was that the Petitioners, having participated in the selection process
with open eyes, cannot turn around and question Clause 33(ix) in the
notification.
In view of this Clause, the Respondents justify their
stand of not considering the Petitioners for appointment.
7.
Heard Sri K.G. Krishna Murthy, learned Senior Counsel,
assisted by Sri K. Raghuveer, Sri M. Vijay Kumar, learned Senior
Counsel, assisted by Sri Manoj Kumar Bethapudi on behalf of the
Petitioners as well as learned Assistant Government Pleader for
Services-I, Sri G. Raju appearing for the Respondents.
Issues: The issue that fell for consideration is the validity of
8.
33(ix) of the Notification issued vide Rc.No.161/SLPRB/Rect.2/2022
dated 28.11.2022 and what relief can be granted in these Writ
Petitions?
9.
The Clauses in the notification relevant for adjudication of
these cases are Clauses 20(E), 25 and 33(ix) and they read as
under:
20.
SELECTION PROCEDURE/SCHEME:
A. ….
B. …..
C. …..
D. …..
E. FINAL SELECTION:
i. For Post Code No.21: The final selection of the
candidates (Men & Women) will be made strictly on
relative merit, as obtained by them based on their score in
the Final Written Examination for 200 marks for the
candidates who qualified in Physical Efficiency Test and as
per the provisions of “The Andhra Pradesh Public
Employment (Organization of Local Cadres and Regulation
of Direct Recruitment) Order, 1975” and G.O. (P) No.763,
General Administration (SPE.A) Dept., dated 15.11.1975
as amended from time to time.”
As
per
G.O.Ms.No.8,
General
Administration
(SPF.A) Dept., dated 08.01.2002 while filling up of the
posts under direct recruitment, the first 20% of posts
should be filled following combined merit list of locals and
non-locals and, thereafter, the remaining 80% of the posts
shall be filled up by locals only.
iii. For Post Code No.23: The final selection of the
candidates (Men) will be made strictly on relative merit, as
per marks obtained by them based on their score in the
Final Written Examination (for 100 marks) and Physical
Efficiency Test (for 100 marks), totaling to 200 marks, and
as per the provisions of the “The Andhra Pradesh Public
Employment (Organization of Local Cadres and Regulation
of Direct Recruitment) Order, 1975” according to which the
Rule of Reservation to local candidates is not applicable.
NOTE:
Preference: When two or more candidates in a particular
category obtain equal marks preference will be given to the
candidate who was born earlier.
25.
The
selection
of
the
candidates
will
be
provisional and subject to verification of the original
certificates, antecedents and medical examination.
33.
General Instructions
i) ….
ii) …..
iii) ….
iv) …..
v) …..
vi) ….
vii) ….
viii) ….
ix) There shall be no waiting list for any of the
recruitment processes conducted by SLPRB, AP and
the list of candidates provisionally selected as against
the notified posts shall be final and no waiting list
shall be maintained under any circumstances. The left
over vacancies, if any, due to cancellation of
provisional
adverse
selection
antecedents,
for
any
Lack
of
reasons
medical
including
fitness,
relinquishment, unwillingness by the candidates and
non-joining
at
the
Induction
designated
procedure
etc.,
of
Training
the
as
per
provisionally
selected Candidates, shall be deemed to have lapsed
for the recruitment notified.
10.
The three (3) Clauses extracted above would indicate that the
final selection of candidates based on inter se merit is provisional
and subject to verification of antecedents, original certificates, and
medical examination. Though the selection of the candidates is
provisional, the said selection would not be reviewed by the
Respondents under any circumstances. As this Clause 33(ix) is
under challenge, it would be profitable to understand the reason for
imposing such extreme language of not reviewing even the
provisional list of selectees.
11. Initially, G.O.Ms No.81, General Administration (Ser. A)
Department, dated 22.02.1997 was issued restricting the number of
selectees to the vacancies notified and not to maintain any waiting
list. The fall-out vacancies were to be notified vacancies in the next
recruitment. This executive decision was crystallized in the form of a
Rule
vide
Ad
hoc
Rule
dated
04.12.1998
framed
vide
G.O.Ms.No.544, General Administration (Services-A) Department,
dated 04.12.1998 under the proviso to Article 309 to the same effect.
12.
In Munja Praveen v. State of Telangana1, the peculiar
reason for issuance of G.O.Ms No.81 General Administration
(Ser. A) Department, dated 22.02.1997 was explained in detail at
(2017) 14 SCC 797
Paragraph No.8 thereof and it was also held at Paragraph No.9 that
vacancies can be termed as „fall-out vacancies‟ to be notified in the
next recruitment notification, only when the relinquishment of post
was after issuance of the appointment orders. For the sake of brevity
only Paragraph No.9 is extracted below;
“9. According to us, the High Court has totally
misconstrued the above GOMs. The portion of the GOMs
quoted above clearly lays down that there shall be no waiting
list and the selection shall be made equal to the number of
posts notified. The purpose was that the vacancies arising due
to people leaving the posts must be filled up by subsequent
selection and not on the basis of a waiting list. It was clarified
that after selection of the candidates and after issue of
appointment orders, if the candidate fails to join within the
stipulated period, that vacancy should be notified again. This
portion of the GOMs admits of only one interpretation that after
appointment order is issued and the person appointed does not
join, then the vacancy cannot be filled up on the basis of the
waiting list or by operating the merit list downwards. This is
also clear from Clause 9 of the GOMs, which also clarifies
that fallout vacancies due to relinquishment or non-joining
of the selected candidates may be notified in the next
recruitment. This obviously means that the clause will
apply after issue of letter of appointment. There can be no
relinquishment and non-joining unless an appointment
letter is issued.”
13. The Hon'ble Supreme Court considered a similar issue in
the case of Telangana State Police Recruitment Board v.
Narimetla vamsi2. In that case, a notification was issued on
31.5.2018 to fill 16925 posts of Stipendiary Police Constables.
After selecting a large number of candidates, many did not join,
and the vacancies were not filled by the next meritorious
candidates. The defence taken by the Board was that an Ad
hoc Rule dated 04.12.1998 framed vide G.O.Ms.No.544,
General Administration (Services-A) Department under the
proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India states that
vacancies in a notification on account of relinquishment by the
selected candidates shall be notified in the next recruitment.
This Ad hoc Rule as mentioned above was similar to
G.O.Ms.No.81, dated 22.02.1997, which was considered in the
Munja Praveen case (1 supra), and the Ad hoc Rule as
extracted in the Judgment reads as under;
“Notwithstanding anything contained in the Andhra
Pradesh State and Subordinate Service Rules/ Special Rules or
adhoc rules governing maintenance and operation of waiting list
for all the Direct recruitments for the posts under the State and
Subordinate Services and Last Grade Services that are being
taken up by various recruiting agencies and also through
Employment Exchange, the maintenance and operation of
Civil Appeal No.4735 of 2022
waiting list for all the recruitments shall be dispensed with and
the list of candidates approved/ selected in any recruitment by
any recruiting agency in the State in any department for such
posts shall be equal to the number of vacancies notified for that
recruitment
only
including
those
meant
for
reserved
community/category notified by the Unit Officers. The fallout
vacancies, if any, due to relinquishment and non-joining etc., of
selected candidates shall be notified in the next recruitment.”
14.
As the language in the Ad hoc Rule was similar to the
G.O.Ms.No.81, dated 22.02.1997, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
followed the interpretation in Munja Praveen‟s case (1 supra) and
the relevant portion of the order reads as under;
“We have heard learned counsel for the parties in the
conspectus of the aforesaid submissions and find no reason to
interfere with the concurrent findings of the two Courts below.
The manner of interpreting the rule in question has already
been set out in Munja Praveen case (Supra). If a candidate
has not gone through the process of recruitment, he has not
done what was required to be done by him as set out
hereinabove; it cannot be construed as a vacancy arising which
has to be carried forward to the next recruitment process. As to
the consequences of the large number of vacancies which have
remained on these different accounts, the details of which have
been set out hereinabove, again lend support to this conclusion
that a large part of the process is not frustrated by not filling up
the vacancies. Public employment is an important source of
employability for young people in the country where we are
facing problems of adequacy of jobs; An interpretation of the
kind sought to be propounded by the appellants would go
against the very ethos of providing public employment to
persons eligible and meritorious, by construction of a rule in a
manner leaving a large number of vacancies unfilled.
This would not be an appropriate interpretation.”
15.
The above Judgment was followed in K. Ashok v. The State
of Telangana and others3 regarding the recruitment notification
dated 06.02.2016 for the post of Sub-Inspector of Police (Civil).
16.
In a nutshell, it was held in the above Judgments that
G.O.Ms.No.81, General Administration (Ser. A) Department, dated
22.02.1997 and the Ad hoc Rule dated 04.12.1998 framed vide
G.O.Ms.No.544 under the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of
India, which prohibited maintenance of waiting list under any
circumstances and fall-out vacancies to be notified in the subsequent
recruitment notification, was interpreted to come into play, only to
those vacancies, where the selectee relinquished appointment after
the issuance of appointment orders. The relinquishment even before
issuance of appointment orders was held to be not a “fall-out
vacancy” to be notified in the subsequent recruitment notification.
17.
As the interpretation was not to the liking of the Respondents,
Clause 33(ix) was introduced in the impugned recruitment
Civil Appeal No.209 of 2023
notification to overcome the Judgments referred above, refraining
from even revising the provisional selection list.
18.
There is an inherent and irreconcilable contradiction in the
above Clauses 25 and 33(ix). Clause 25 states that the final
selection is provisional, subject to verification of antecedents, original
certificates, and medical examination, while Clause 33(ix) of general
instructions gives finality to this provisional selection, notwithstanding
the outcome of the verification process. In understanding of
contractual clauses, the earlier clause would prevail over the
repugnant later clause.
19.
Another aspect is that the posts are governed by the Andhra
Pradesh Police (Stipendiary Cadet Trainee) Rules 1999 framed
vide
G.O.Ms.No.315,
Home
(Police-C)
Department,
dated
17.10.1999. As per these Rules, the persons selected for the post of
Police Constable (Civil) after verification of original certificates,
antecedents and medical examination would have to undergo
induction training for (9) months and during this period, they would
be paid stipend and would have to pass tests conducted during the
training period. If the candidates fail in the tests and supplementary
tests, they shall be discharged from training. As the name suggests,
the selected candidates are called "Stipendiary Cadet Trainee Police
Constable,” and the appointment as Police Constable (Civil) would
not materialize until successful completion of induction training.
The Rules 4(iv) and 5 are extracted below;
“4.
Training & Training Period:
(i) ….
(ii) ….
(iii) ….
(iv) Stipendiary Cadet Trainee Police Constables under all
categories shall undergo training for a period of 9 months at
training institutions/centres as notified by the Director General
of Police. They should undergo all indoor and outdoor training
without any break and show satisfactory progress/performance
during the training period.
5.
Test and Evaluation:
The trainees in all the categories shall have to appear for the
tests during training or on completion of training both indoor and
outdoor subjects. The trainees are required to pass all the
subjects on completion of Institutional training as per the
scheme of examination. Those who fail in one or more subjects
shall be retained in the training institutions and they shall be
required to appear in the supplementary examination within a
period of (2) two months from the date of completion of final
examination.
The
Un-successful
candidates
of
supplementary examination shall be discharged from the
training and they shall not be offered any appointment in
the
Department.
The
Chairman,
State
Level
Police
Recruitment Board shall prescribe required test for all the above
categories from time to time and decide the scheme of
examination.”
20.
In the scheme of appointment of Police Constable (Civil),
the provisional selections, after the four (4) stages of selection as
mentioned above, pursuant to the recruitment notification is still at a
nascent stage of selection. From this stage onwards, there are four
to five possibilities from where the candidate included in the
provisional merit list can relinquish or be denied appointment. i.e.,
(i) At the stage of verification of original certificates,
antecedents and medical examination.
(ii) The selected candidate relinquishes before appointment;
(iii) Though provisionally appointed, claim of belonging to a
social group was found to be wrong, disentitling him to public
employment;
(iv) On a successful challenge by another candidate on
eligibility/suitability of a candidate included in the merit
list/appointed to a post.
(v) Failure to complete the induction training.
21.
In the light of the elaborate procedure for appointment of
Police Constable (Civil), would it be appropriate for the recruiting
Board to rely on Clause 33(ix) of the notification to deny
consideration for appointment in vacancies caused on account of
relinquishment at the stage of further verification of original
certificates, medical examination and antecedents? Though there
would be some justification in denying consideration of the next
meritorious on relinquishment of the selected candidate, after he is
sent for induction training or failure of the selected candidate in the
induction training, but at a stage well before that i.e., at the stage of
verification, it would be unfair to deny consideration of the next
meritorious in the line.
22.
It is a matter of common knowledge that the recruitment
process starts with the issuance of a public notification calling for
applications to fill-up notified vacancies and ends with the
appointment of the eligible and meritorious. In the present
notification, this logical culmination of the recruitment process is
interdicted at the stage of provisional selection itself and a hands-off
approach is adopted in the middle of the recruitment process.
This goes against the very concept of recruitment notification and,
in the opinion of this Court, appears to be an arbitrary condition.
Though employers have the discretion to impose conditions in the
recruitment notification, they must remain within the bounds of
non-arbitrariness.
23.
The candidates who are meritorious and have gone through
the rigour of the selection process and miss out being included in the
provisional selection list do aspire for consideration of their cases in
all fairness. It is quite ironic that persons interested in joining the
Police Department, notwithstanding the hard life, are not being
considered for persons who relinquished and are uninterested in
joining the service.
24.
Public employment opportunities are limited, and recruitment
notifications come occasionally; aspirants to the post of Police
Constables, apart from preparing for the written examinations, must
also be at their physical prime to qualify in the Physical Efficiency
Tests (PET). The conditions in the recruitment notifications cannot
be arbitrary as the right to be considered for public employment is a
fundamental right and the denial of consideration for public
employment should be on valid reasons, which substantially should
relate to merit and not whimsical grounds.
25.
Apart from that, what is the rationale that is sought to be
achieved by imposing such a clause is not discernible in the
Counter-Affidavit. At best, Clause 33(ix) provides some ease to the
Respondents for closure of the recruitment process, but that can
hardly be a ground and in matters of recruitment, the Clauses in the
recruitment notification should aid the objective of the notification i.e.,
appointments to the notified vacant posts. A condition that runs
contrary to this objective of the notification can only be termed to be
arbitrary, irrational and violative of Article 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India. At this stage, it would be apt to refer to the
observation in the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Man
Singh v. State of Haryana4;
“20. We may reiterate the settled position of law for the
benefit of the administrative authorities that any act of the repository
of power whether legislative or administrative or quasi-judicial is
open to challenge if it is so arbitrary or unreasonable that no fairminded authority could ever have made it. The concept of equality
as enshrined in Article 14 of the Constitution of India embraces the
entire realm of State action. It would extend to an individual as well
not only when he is discriminated against in the matter of exercise
of right, but also in the matter of imposing liability upon him. Equals
have to be treated equally even in the matter of executive or
administrative action. As a matter of fact, the doctrine of equality
is now turned as a synonym of fairness in the concept of
justice and stands as the most accepted methodology of a
governmental action. The administrative action is to be just on
the test of “fair play” and reasonableness.”
26.
In the Counter-Affidavit filed by the Respondents, the only
defence taken was that the Petitioners, having participated in the
selection process, cannot question the same. It is to be noted that
(2008) 12 SCC 331
the clauses in the recruitment notification, which are arbitrary, can
always be struck down, notwithstanding the mere participation of the
aspirants in the selection process, as their mere participation cannot
amount to validation of arbitrary clauses. At this stage, it would be
apt to refer to the Judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Meeta
Sahai v. State of Bihar5, as a similar contention urged by the
Respondents was distinguished;
“16. It is well settled that the principle of estoppel
prevents a candidate from challenging the selection process
after having failed in it as iterated by this Court in a plethora of
judgments including Manish Kumar Shahi v. State of Bihar,
observing as follows:
“16. We also agree with the High Court that after
having taken part in the process of selection knowing
fully well that more than 19% marks have been
earmarked for viva voce test, the appellant is not entitled
to challenge the criteria or process of selection. Surely, if
the appellant‟s name had appeared in the merit list, he
would not have even dreamed of challenging the
selection. The [appellant] invoked jurisdiction of the High
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India only
after he found that his name does not figure in the merit
list prepared by the Commission. This conduct of the
appellant clearly disentitles him from questioning the
(2019) 20 SCC 17
selection and the High Court did not commit any error by
refusing to entertain the writ petition.”
The underlying objective of this principle is to prevent
candidates from trying another shot at consideration, and to
avoid an impasse wherein every disgruntled candidate, having
failed the selection, challenges it in the hope of getting a
second chance.
17. However, we must differentiate from this
principle insofar as the candidate by agreeing to
participate in the selection process only accepts the
prescribed procedure and not the illegality in it. In a
situation where a candidate alleges misconstruction
of statutory rules and discriminating consequences
arising there from, the same cannot be condoned
merely because a candidate has partaken in it. The
constitutional scheme is sacrosanct and its violation
in any manner is impermissible. In fact, a candidate
may not have locus to assail the incurable illegality
or derogation of the provisions of the Constitution,
unless he/she participates in the selection process.”
27.
Even otherwise, at the stage of participation in the selection
process, no cause of action is available for the aspirants to challenge
the clause in question i.e., Clause 33(ix), until they successfully
qualify in the four stages of selection as mentioned supra and be
included in the provisional selection list. In the absence of cause of
action to question Clause 33(ix), the Petitioners could not be
non-suited from challenging the same.
28.
Another aspect is that the Ad hoc Rule dated 04.12.1998
framed vide G.O.Ms.No.544 under the proviso to Article 309 of the
Constitution of India as interpreted in Munja Praveen‟s case
(1 supra) as well as in Narimetla Vamsi and K. Ashok‟s cases
(2 & 3 supra) by the Hon’ble Supreme Court is in vogue and Clause
33(ix) of the notification runs contrary to the Ad hoc Rule.
29.
The Vallampati Satish Babu v. State of Andhra Pradesh
and Others6
cited by the learned Government Pleader is
distinguishable on facts. In the said case, notification was issued for
recruitment of Teachers termed as ‘DSC-2012’. After drawing of final
seniority list, one individual did not turn up for counselling and the
next meritorious person sought for appointment in the said category
and in that context, the next meritorious person sought for
consideration of his case for appointment. The procedure for
preparation of final selection list for conduct of counselling for
issuance of appointment orders were provided by the State vide
G.O.Ms.No.91, dated 03.11.2012 in the said case and the procedure
is distinctly different.
(2023) 13 SCC 193
30.
As per the selection procedure contemplated therein,
a provisional merit list would be drawn up and the persons in the
said list were to attend for verification of original certificates.
It is pertinent to note here that the said guidelines provided for
re-drawing of the provisional selection list by the DSC to the extent
necessary in the event of a provisionally selected candidate fails to
attend
the
verification
of
certificates/production
of
original
certificates, by inclusion of the next meritorious candidate.
After verification, the final selection list would be prepared. This final
selection list did not provide for any waiting list and in the event the
candidate included in the final selection list does not claim
appointment, the vacancy remains unfilled and would be carried
forward to the next recruitment. Paragraphs 14 and 15 of
G.O.Ms.No.91, dated 03.11.2012 are extracted below:
“14. The Guidelines have been issued by the State Government
for selection f process including the preparation of selection list,
conduct of counselling and issue of appointment and posting orders
to the selected candidates under GOMS No. 91 dated 3-11-2012.
Para 8 of the said Guidelines is relevant for our purpose, which reads
as under:
"8. Verification of Certificates.
(a) The District Educational Officer shall prepare with the
approval of the District Selection Committee a provisional list to
the extent of vacancies notified, for each category of post
notified in DSC-2012 on the basis of the merit list and publish
the same on the notice boards of the offices of the District
Collector and District Educational Officer and also on the
designated website, along with the date, time and venue fixed
for verification of certificates. The District Educational Officer
shall also issue a press note in the local newspapers for wide
publicity in this regard.
(b) As the processing of applications for DSC-2012 is made
online so far, the process of verification of certificates of
candidates included in provisional list may, in certain cases,
also result in.
(i) Failure of the candidate to attend for verification of
certificates.
(ii) Failure of the candidate to produce the original
certificate/s relevant to his/her eligibility and selection.
(iii) Inclusion of a candidate in the provisional list of more
than one category.
(c) As regards (b)(i) above, the District Educational Officer shall
send a personal intimation to the address furnished by the
candidate, to attend along with all relevant original certificates
on the date fixed for the said purpose, as a final chance.
(d) In case the candidate fails to attend even on the date so
fixed, he/she shall forfeit his/her right to be considered for
selection.
(e) In the event of (b)(ii) & (b)(iii) and (d) above, the
provisional list shall be redrawn by the District Selection
Committee drawing next candidate/s from the merit list to
the extent necessary, however, subject to the condition
that the number of candidates included shall not be more
than the number of vacancies notified for that particular
category. Insofar as the candidate is covered by b(iii)
above, this exercise shall be done only after obtaining the
option of such candidate at the time of verification of
certificates itself.
(f) The further verification of certificates, if any required as
under (e) above shall be done, after due intimation to the
candidates concerned, on the date fixed for the said purpose.
(g) After due completion of the above exercise the District
Selection Committee shall prepare the final selection list of
the candidates for all categories of the teachers. Once the
final selection list is prepared, there shall be no waiting list
and posts if any unfilled for any reason whatsoever shall
be carried forward for future recruitment as per sub-rule (5)
of Rule 16 of the Andhra Pradesh Direct Recruitment for
the posts of Teachers (Scheme of Selection) Rules, 2012.
15. On a fair reading of Rule 16 of the 2012 Rules read with the
Guidelines referred to hereinabove, once the final selection list is
prepared, there shall be no waiting list and posts, if any, are unfilled
for any reason whatsoever, shall be carried forward for future
recruitment as per sub-rule (5) of Rule 16 of the 2012 Rules.”
31.
In the present case, Clauses (e) and (g) quoted above are
absent and even if the candidate provisionally selected did not turn
up for certificate verification, the provisional merit list is not being
re-drawn
as
done
in
the
above
case
by
relying
on
Clause 33(ix) of the notification. The guidelines framed vide
G.O.Ms.No.91, dated 03.11.2012 in the above case, if followed in
the present case, no cause of action would arise.
32.
The State of Karnataka and Others v. Santhosh Kumar C 7
cited by the Learned Government Pleader, was the case where the
Karnataka Public Service Commission had issued a notification
inviting applications for recruitment to 362 posts of Karnataka
Gazetted Probationers in Group A and Group B Services under the
Karnataka Recruitment of Gazetted Probationers (Appointment by
Competitive Examinations) Rules, 1997.
33.
In the said case, the Respondent i.e., Santhosh Kumar C had
participated in the selection process and was selected to the post of
Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes Group A vide
notification dated 05.05.2022 and the said individual joined duty on
09.05.2022. On the ground that one Aiyappa M.A selected to the
post of Assistant Commissioner of Karnataka Administrative Service,
Group A, Junior Scale, did not undergo medical examination and
police verification, the Respondent sought appointment in the said
post. In that context, the Hon’ble Supreme Court negatived the
claim, as the Respondent, Santhosh Kumar C, had joined the post of
2026 INSC 276
Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes and as Rules were
not under challenge. The case is distinctly different to the facts of
this case.
34.
Relief:In the light of the above discussion, the Writ petitions are
disposed of, with the following directions;
(i) The clause 33(ix) of the recruitment notification issued vide
Rc.No.161/SLPRB/Rect.2/2022 dated 28.11.2022 is declared
to be arbitrary and unfair.
(ii) The Respondents shall take steps for appointment in the
left
over
vacancies
under
the
notification
vide
Rc.No.161/SLPRB/Rect.2/2022 dated 28.11.2022 by adhering
to merit as well as reservations.
(iii) The above exercise shall be completed within a period of
(04) months from the date of receipt of the copy of the order.
(iv) No order as to costs.
As a sequel, pending applications, if any, shall stand closed.
__________________
NYAPATHY VIJAY, J
Date: 30.10.2026
IS
Note: L.R copy be marked.
(B/o)
IS
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE NYAPATHY VIJAY
WRIT PETITION Nos.27611, 29972, 31717, 32771 of 2025,
W.P.Nos.7016 and 11918 of 2026
Date: 30.10.2026
IS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review