Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 13th July, 2026.
Uploaded on: 16th July, 2026.
+
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
NARESH KUMAR ANAND
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Abhay Chitravanshi and Ms.
Bhawna Nanda, Advocates.
versus
M/S GOLD SQUARE SALES PVT LTD
Through:
.....Respondent
Ms. Geeta Malhotra, Advocate.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE VIKAS MAHAJAN
Prathiba M. Singh, J. (Oral)
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
The present appeal has been filed by the Appellant under Section 104
read with Order 43 Rule (l)(c) of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (hereinafter,
‘CPC’), inter alia, challenging the impugned order dated 2nd July 2025 passed
by the Trial Court (South), Saket Court, New Delhi (hereinafter 'Trial Court').
3.
Vide the impugned order, the Appellant’s counter claim was dismissed
in default and the application seeking restoration of the counter claim was also
dismissed.
4.
The submission of ld. Counsel for the Appellant is that the date of
hearing was wrongly noted, due to a clerical mistake, and it was only for that
Digitally Signed
By:DEVANSHU JOSHI
18:29:07
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
reason that the Appellant could not appear.
5.
However, ld. Counsel for the Respondent submits that the Appellant
has been deliberately delaying the adjudication of the suit by filing repeated
applications one after the other.
6.
In fact, it is her submission that the counter claim of the Appellant has
been dismissed in default on three occasions earlier as well.
7.
On 8th September, 2025, notice was issued in the present appeal and
Court had directed to requisition the TCR.
8.
A perusal of the TCR would show that the initial suit being CS DJ
239/2018 titled ‘M/s Gold Square Sales Pvt. Ltd. vs Shri Naresh Kumar
Anand’ was filed by the Respondent in March 2018, seeking recovery of
Rs.36,27,302/- along with interest at 18% per annum.
9.
In the said suit, the Appellant filed a counter claim being CS No. 846/18
titled ‘Shri Naresh Kumar Anand v. M/s Gold Square Sales Pvt. Ltd’
against the Respondent seeking recovery of Rs. 10,65,826/- on the ground of
delayed payments and outstanding dues.
10.
The suit is stated to be pending before the Civil Judge and the
counterclaim has been transferred to the Commercial Court.
11.
The Respondent has already filed the evidence in the suit. From 2020
onwards, the counterclaim is being considered by the Commercial Court.
However, the Appellant’s evidence has not been led.
12.
Repeated adjournments have been taken on various dates including on
27th January, 2020, 14th September, 2020, 13th December, 2020.
13.
On 20th March, 2021 in CS No. 846/18, one last opportunity was
granted to the Appellant to lead the evidence.
14.
In disregard of the directions passed by the ld. Trial Court, the
Digitally Signed
By:DEVANSHU JOSHI
18:29:07
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
Appellant did not appear. On 28th May, 2022, the Court dismissed the
counterclaim in default for non-prosecution. The said order reads as under:
“The ld. Counsel for the respondent has filed the
vakalatnama. The AR of the counter-claimant has
been directed to remain present vide orders dated
31.01.2022 as well as 20.03.2021 and a last opportunity
had been accorded to the counter-claimant for
adducing evidence but neither the AR has cared to
appear nor any evidence has been led by the counterclaimant till date although the issue in the present
matter was framed on 15.12.2018.In these
circumstances, the counter-claim is hereby dismissed
in default and for non-prosecution. File be consigned
to record room after necessary compliance.”
15.
Thereafter, the Appellant filed an application under Order IX Rule 9
CPC. By order dated 2nd February, 2024, the said application was allowed,
and the counterclaim was restored to its original number. The said order reads
as under:
“Arguments addressed on application under Order 9
Rule 9 CPC. It is submitted that the main suit as well as
counter claim were pending before Ld. ADJ Court,
however, after the Commercial Courts were created,
the counter claim was transferred to the Commercial
Court, whereas main suit remained pending before Ld.
ADJ Court. The applicant got to know about the
transfer of the counter claim in September 2022, by
which time, the counter claim had been dismissed in
default and for want of prosecution.
It is submitted by counsel for respondent that applicant
had been regularly appearing in the other matter and in
these circumstances, how he did not get to know about
the transfer of the counter claim, to which, counsel for
Digitally Signed
By:DEVANSHU JOSHI
18:29:07
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
applicant/counter claimant submits that he was under
the impression that his counter claim is also pending in
the same court and his attendance is being marked in
both the cases. It is only in September 2022 that he got
to know about transfer of the counter claim by which
time, counter claim had already been dismissed.
Thereafter he immediately moved application under
Order 9 Rule 9 CPC.
Considering the above submission of Ld. Counsel for
applicant, application under Order 9 Rule 9 CPC
stands allowed. Counter claim is restored back to its
original number and position.
Since as already noted, main suit is pending in other
court, sometime is requested by Ld. Counsel for
applicant/counter claimant to move appropriate
application before Ld. Principal District & Sessions
Judge, South, Saket Courts, Delhi, with request for
clubbing of both the matters.
Be put up for further proceedings on 23.02.2024. On
joint request, date is changed to 14.03.2024.”
16.
In terms of the above order, the Court had noted that the Appellant’s
counter claim was transferred to the Commercial Court, post creation of
Commercial Courts, while the main suit remained pending before the ld. ADJ.
It was also noted that the Appellant acquired knowledge about the same in
September, 2022. Accordingly, the Appellant’s counter claim was restored.
Further, the Court had also directed the Appellant to file an application for
clubbing both the matters.
17.
However, on 1st April, 2024, none appeared on behalf of the Appellant,
and no application seeking clubbing of the matters, as directed in the previous
Digitally Signed
By:DEVANSHU JOSHI
18:29:07
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
order, had been filed.
18.
Upon the matter being taken up in the second call, the counterclaim was
again dismissed for non-prosecution. The order dated 1st April, 2024 reads
as under:“Counsel for respondent was present at first call and
submitted that no application had been moved by the
applicant/counter-claimant in terms of previous
directions. None has rather appeared on behalf of
application/counter-claimant on previous call as well as
on the second call, hence matter stands dismissed in
default.
File be consigned to record room.”
19.
The Appellant again moved an application under Order IX Rule 9 of
CPC, citing death of the previous Counsel as a reason for non-appearance.
The said application was allowed vide order dated 16th May, 2025, which is
set out below:
“Arguments addressed on the application U/o 9 Rule 9
CPC.
Previously, also the matter had been dismissed in
default and the application U/o 9 Rule 9 CPC was
allowed. Applicant had sought time to move appropriate
application before Principal District & Sessions Judge
(South) with request for clubbing of both the matters,
since, it was brought on record that the regular matter
was pending in another Court, whereas, counter-claim
was pending before this Court. Thereafter, none had
appeared for the applicant. Hence, the matter was again
dismissed in default. It was later on submitted that non
appearance in the matter was due to demise of the
previous counsel and subsequently, due to no
information having been received from the office of
previous counsel. Considering the said submission by
Digitally Signed
By:DEVANSHU JOSHI
18:29:07
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
taking lenient view, application U/o 9 Rule 9 CPC is
allowed.
It may be noted that the counter-claim pending before
this Court shall be one of the oldest cases before this
Court warranting expeditious disposal. Counsel for
applicant shall take appropriate steps for clubbing of
both the matters at the earliest. It is made clear that
longer dates would not be permitted for any reasons.
Be put up for further proceedings on 20.05.2025.”
20.
On 20th May, 2025, the Court was informed that the Appellant is
seeking some time to file the application for clubbing of matters. The Court
also observed that the Appellant may consider withdrawing the said
counterclaim. Accordingly, an adjournment was sought.
21.
Thereafter, on 5th June, 2025, the Appellant failed to appear, despite
repeated calls and accordingly, the counter claim was dismissed for want of
prosecution by the said order. The order dated 5th June, 2025 is set out below:
“Application U/o 9 Rule 9 CPC moved by
counterclaimant had been allowed. However, it was
noted that counterclaim pending before this Court is one
of the oldest cases warranting expeditious disposal. Ld.
Counsel for counter-claim sought time to take
appropriate steps for clubbing of both the matters. Steps
thereafter had not been taken despite opportunity
permitted. It was rather submitted by counter-claimant
that they shall consider withdrawal of the counter-claim
for which consideration, adjournment was requested.
Today, none has appeared. Counter-claim stands
dismissed in default and for want of prosecution.
File be consigned to record room.”
22.
In respect of the third dismissal, the Appellant filed an application
under Order IX Rule 9 of CPC on the ground that the incorrect date was noted
Digitally Signed
By:DEVANSHU JOSHI
18:29:07
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
and the same was a clerical mistake.
23.
The aforesaid application was dismissed vide the impugned order dated
2nd July, 2025. Hence, the present appeal.
24.
Ld. Counsel for the Respondent submits that the evidence in the main
suit was filed by the Respondent way back on 16th December, 2023.
25.
Thereafter, an application under Order VII Rule 10 of the CPC was
filed by the Appellant seeking dismissal of the suit. The said application was
dismissed on 25th August, 2025 by the Trial Court.
26.
The Appellant then filed a revision petition assailing the order dated
25th August, 2025, being C.R.P. 319/2015 titled ‘Naresh Kumar Anand v.
M/s Gold Square Sales Pvt. ltd.’.
27.
Vide order dated 17th November, 2025 in C.R.P. 319/2015 , the Court
had directed as under:
“1. The petitioner, who is the defendant in CS DJ
239/2018 pending before the Court of the learned
District Judge-03, South District, Saket Court, has
challenged an order dated 25.08.2025, by which his
application under Order VII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908, was dismissed.
2. The petitioner has sought return of the plaint to the
respondent– plaintiff on the ground of lack of territorial
jurisdiction.
3. After some hearing, Mr. Abhay Chitravanshi,
learned counsel for the petitioner, seeks permission to
withdraw this revision petition, without prejudice to
the petitioner’s rights and contentions before the Trial
Court, including the right to seek framing of an
additional issue on the question of jurisdiction.
4.
The
revision
petition,
alongwith
pending
Digitally Signed
By:DEVANSHU JOSHI
18:29:07
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
applications, is dismissed as withdrawn, with liberty as
aforesaid.
5. It is made clear that this Court has made no
observation on the merits of any remedy that may be
sought by the petitioner before the Trial Court.”
28.
Further, ld. Counsel for the Respondent submits that the issue on
territorial jurisdiction was already framed.
29.
However, after the order dated 17th November, 2025 passed in the
revision petition, the Appellant moved another application under Order XIV
Rule 5 of CPC seeking framing of an additional issue on territorial jurisdiction
and for considering the same as a preliminary issue. The said matter is also
continuing to be adjourned.
30.
Heard the ld. Counsel for the parties. The Court has considered the
matter and perused the records. The chronology of events would show that
the Appellant has not been diligent in pursuing the counterclaim.
31.
In fact, over the last eight years, the counterclaim has been dismissed
on three separate occasions.
32.
The Appellant has repeatedly sought restoration of the counterclaim by
filing successive applications, resulting in considerable delay in the
adjudication of the proceedings.
33.
Moreover, on each occasion, the Appellant has sought restoration by
attributing the default to one reason or another. On previous occasions, the
explanation pertained to the difficulty by the ld. Counsel, whereas on the
present occasion, the explanation is the erroneous noting of the date of hearing
by the ld. Counsel.
34.
Vide the impugned order, the Trial Court has observed as under:
Digitally Signed
By:DEVANSHU JOSHI
18:29:07
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
“[...]10. Again after lapse of more than seven months,
another application under Order 9 Rule 9 CPC was
moved on 28.11.2024 and the ground for non
appearance was mentioned as due to demise of the
previous counsel and subsequently due to no
information having been received from the office of the
previous counsel. By taking lenient view, application
under Order 9 Rule 9 CPC was allowed vide order dated
16.5.2025. Parties were informed that the counter claim
pending before this court shall be one of the oldest
cases, warranting expeditious disposal. Counsel for
applicant sought time to take appropriate steps for
clubbing of both the matter at the earliest. It was made
clear to the parties that longer dates would not be
permitted. Despite that, requisite steps were not taken
by applicant and further opportunity was sought to
move appropriate application. It was also stated that
applicant may consider withdrawal of the counter claim
for which consideration also, some time was requested.
Matter was fixed up for further proceedings on
04.06.2025 and on the request of counsel for applicant
himself, date was changed to 05.06.2025. Counsel for
applicant was also informed that if steps were not taken
by next date of hearing, necessary consequences shall
follow.
11. On next date of hearing i.e. 05.06.2025, which was
given as per the request of the counsel for applicant
himself, none appeared. Hence, the counter claim for
the third time was dismissed in default and for want of
prosecution. Submission of Ld. counsel for applicant
that to ascertain the exact status of the matter and to
verify whether the next date of hearing was correctly
noted as 06.06.2025, he had checked the official online
portal and found that no order after 01.04.2024 had
been uploaded on the online portal is not only
misplaced but is contrary to the factual position. Date
was not only given in the presence of counsel for
Digitally Signed
By:DEVANSHU JOSHI
18:29:07
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
applicant but was changed to 05.06.2025 on his
specific request. All the orders are duly, regularly are
uploaded on the same date. Confirmation was sought
from the Reader of the court who confirmed the same
and also placed on record the status with regard to
uploading of the orders which was on the same date of
pronouncement of the orders. Besides that, date of
hearing is always notified on the registered mobile
number of the counsel. Yet, counsel for applicant has
audacity to furnish false submissions on record.
Besides that, when the date was given in presence of
counsel for applicant, there was no occasion or reason
with this court to change the date in the absence of
counsel for parties, therefore, there was no occasion
even for the counsel for applicant to check whether
any change in the hearing date had been ordered by
the court.
12. Conduct of the applicant, as noted above, indicates
callous attitude intelligent approach which led to
dismissal of the counter claim on three occasions.
Even the lenient view taken by this court in allowing
the previous applications seem to have been misutilized by the applicant. Conduct of applicant does not
warrant any further lenient view to be taken in the
matter and rather this court is restraining itself from
imposition of the heavy cost upon the applicant
considering the conduct of the applicant and also the
audacity to mention the false submission on court
record. Instant application accordingly stands
dismissed. File be consigned to record room after
completion of necessary formalities.”
35.
In the overall analysis of the proceedings, it is clear that substantial
judicial time has been spent on account of the suit and the counterclaim being
heard in two different Courts.
36.
The Appellant has repeatedly failed to pursue the counterclaim
Digitally Signed
By:DEVANSHU JOSHI
18:29:07
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
diligently, resulting in its dismissal on three occasions.
37.
The Appellant has also caused delays by filing applications seeking
consideration of the issue of territorial jurisdiction as a preliminary issue,
despite the said issue having been framed way back, vide order dated 18th
November, 2022. The relevant portion of the said order is set out below:
“Affidavit of admission denial of documents filed. Be
taken on record. Copy supplied to Ld. Counsel for
Defendant. On completion of pleadings, the following
issues were framed:
a) Whether this court has territorial jurisdiction to try
and adjudicate the present suit? OPD.
b) Whether the present suit has been filed without any
cause of any action?OPD
c) Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of Rs.
36,27,302/- from the Defendant?
d) If issue no. (c) is decided in affirmative, at what rate
and for what period? OPP.
e) Relief.
No other issue either arises or is pressed. List of
witnesses and affidavits along with documents to be
filed within two weeks from today. The plaintiff is
directed to supply advance copy of affidavits to the
opposite party. Put up for PE on 07.02.2023.”
38.
Furthermore, no attempt was made by the Appellant to have both the
proceedings i.e., the counter claim and the main suit be clubbed, by availing
of appropriate remedies under Section 24 of the CPC.
39.
It is seen that on the one hand the suit is being adjudicated before the
Digitally Signed
By:DEVANSHU JOSHI
18:29:07
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
District Judge and the counter claim stands dismissed, merely on default and
not on merits. The suit was filed way back on 7th March, 2018 and the counter
claim was initially filed on 4th September, 2018. Both sides are suffering due
to the recalcitrant conduct of the Appellant.
40.
Considering that the main suit and the counter claim have remained
pending before the different Courts since 2018 and have not yet been
considered on merits, the Court is of the view that the counter claim shall be
restored and heard on merits.
41.
Accordingly, this Court is of the view that this is fit case to exercise
powers under Section 24 of CPC.
42.
Under these circumstances, in order to ensure the efficient and
expeditious disposal of the entire dispute and to avoid any further delays, the
following directions are issued:
i)
The counter claim being CS No. 846/18 titled Shri Naresh
Kumar Anand v. M/s Gold Square Sales Pvt. is restored to its original
number.
ii)
In exercise of powers under Section 24 CPC, the civil suit being
CS DJ 239/2018 titled ‘M/s Gold Square Sales Pvt. Ltd. vs Shri
Naresh Kumar Anand’ shall now stand transferred to the District
Judge Commercial Court 01, South Saket Courts, New Delhi where the
counterclaim of the Appellant being CS No. 846/18 titled Shri Naresh
Kumar Anand v. M/s Gold Square Sales Pvt. Ltd was being
adjudicated. The proceedings shall henceforth be governed by the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015.
iii)
Issues have already been framed in the suit as well as in the
counterclaim, and the matter is now at the stage of leading evidence.
Digitally Signed
By:DEVANSHU JOSHI
18:29:07
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
The Respondent has already filed affidavits by way of evidence.
However, the Respondent, being the Plaintiff in the suit, is permitted to
file fresh affidavits by way of evidence in both the suit and the
counterclaim. Similarly, the Appellant, being the Defendant in the suit
and the counterclaimant, shall file common affidavits by way of
evidence in both the suit and the counterclaim.
iv)
The said affidavits shall be exchanged between the parties within
four weeks from the date when the matter is first listed before the
Commercial Court.
v)
The witnesses shall lead common evidence in both the suit and
the counterclaim.
vi)
After leading of common evidence, all the issues framed in the
suit as also in the counterclaim shall be adjudicated comprehensively
together.
43.
Since the counterclaim has already been dismissed and considering the
past conduct of the Appellant, who has been negligent in pursuing the
counterclaim, as a condition for restoration of the counterclaim and for
permitting evidence to be led, it is directed that the counterclaimant shall
deposit a sum of Rs.5,00,000/-.
44.
Out of the said deposit, Rs.50,000/- shall be treated as costs and paid to
the Respondent.
45.
The remaining sum of Rs.4,50,000/- shall be kept in a Fixed Deposit
Receipt with the Commercial Court and shall abide by the final adjudication
of the suit.
46.
The present appeal is disposed of in these terms. Pending applications,
if any, are also disposed of.
Digitally Signed
By:DEVANSHU JOSHI
18:29:07
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
47.
Parties to appear before the Commercial Court i.e., District Judge
Commercial Court 01, South Saket Courts, New Delhi on 5th August, 2026.
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
VIKAS MAHAJAN
JUDGE
JULY 13, 2026/MR/SM
Digitally Signed
By:DEVANSHU JOSHI
18:29:07
FAO (COMM) 253/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review