Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
#
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 24.08.2026
Pronounced on: 15.09.2026
Uploaded on: 15.09.2026
CNR No. DLHC010510902005
CRL.A. 45/2005
NARENDER
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Javed Hashmi, Mr.
Shahnawaz Malik, Ms. Sheetal
Mishra and Mr. Parul Gurudev,
Advocates.
versus
STATE
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Aman Usman, APP for the
State with Mr. Manvendra
Yadav, Advocate and Insp.
Sachin Yadav, PS Gulabhi
Bagh.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA
JUDGMENT
RAVINDER DUDEJA, J.
1.
Vide this appeal, the appellant/accused has taken exception to
the Judgment of conviction dated 18th December, 2004 and the Order
on Sentence dated 21st December, 2004, passed by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge [“Trial Court”] in Sessions Case No.
51/2003, arising out of FIR No. 69/2003, registered under Section 302
of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 [for short “IPC”], PS Pratap Nagar.
Factual Matrix
2.
The prosecution case, as per the charge sheet, is that on 16th
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
May, 2003, PW-23 Dinesh Singh, son of the coach of Kishan Ganj
akhara, came at Police Post, Andha Mughal and informed the police
that a wrestler named Sandeep, had died due to injury caused by
scissor. Such information was reduced into writing vide DD No. 25
(Ex. PW-2/A) at 6:15 PM. On receipt of Ex. PW-2/A, SI Joginder
Singh (PW-24) along with Constable Azad Singh (PW-6) reached at
Railway Akhara Kishan Ganj, where, they found the dead body of
Sandeep, lying on a cot in a room, located in the akhara with an incise
wound on his chest near the heart.
3.
SI Joginder Singh (PW-24) recorded the statement of
complainant Naveen (PW-8) at the spot, wherein, he stated that on 16th
May, 2003 at about 2:00 PM, he along with Neeraj (PW-3), Sandeep
(deceased) and Narender (appellant) were sitting together in a room in
the akhara. In the morning, he (PW-8) and Neeraj had shaved their
heads. Seeing them, Sandeep asked Narender to get his head shaved
off, but Narender refused. Sandeep then brought a scissor and started
cutting the hair of Narender. Narender caught the right hand of
Sandeep and tried to snatch the scissor. Naveen (PW-8) and Neeraj
(PW-3) cautioned Narender not to twist the hand of Sandeep in such a
dangerous manner, lest Sandeep would suffer injury, but Narender did
not loosen the grip, and in the process, the scissor struck on the chest
of Sandeep near his heart and he became unconscious. He was
removed to Malik Nursing Home. Since his condition was serious, Dr.
V.K. Malik (PW-13) advised that Sandeep be shifted to a bigger
hospital for treatment. Sandeep was then shifted to ESI Hospital,
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
where, the doctor declared him “dead”, following which, his body was
brought back to the akhara.
4.
PW-24 made an endorsement on the statement of PW-8 and
sent the rukka to the police station through Constable Raj Singh (PW2) for registration of the FIR. The FIR was initially registered under
Section 304 IPC.
5.
During investigation of the case, the Crime Team and
Photographer were summoned to the spot. The scene of occurrence
was inspected and photographs were taken. The weapon of offence,
that is, scissor, was recovered from the spot, its sketch (PW-6/A) was
prepared and the scissor was taken into possession vide memo Ex.
PW-6/B. The site plan of the place of occurrence (Ex. PW-22/A) was
prepared by PW-22 Sh. Tirath Raj Singh at the request of the IO. The
pieces of cut hair of Narender found at the spot were also lifted and
seized vide memo Ex. PW-6/C. Inquest documents were prepared and
the body of Sandeep was sent for post-mortem at Subzi Mandi
Mortuary.
6.
During investigation, the post-mortem of the victim was
conducted on 17th May, 2003 by PW-19 Dr. Akash Jhanjee, who
prepared the post-mortem report Ex. PW-19/A. The scissor was
produced before the doctor for his opinion. PW-19 gave the opinion
that injury No. 8 could have been caused by the said weapon and that
such injury was neither accidental nor self-inflicted. Pursuant to such
opinion, Section 304 IPC was replaced by Section 302 IPC.
7.
During investigation, the Investigating Officer [“IO”] recorded
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
the statements of witnesses. Supplementary statement of PW-8 was
also recorded on 05th August, 2003, wherein, he took a somersault, by
stating that on 16th May, 2003, he and Neeraj had shaven off their
heads, and at about 12:30 PM, he along with Neeraj, Narender and
two other wrestlers, went to the room of Sandeep and asked him to cut
off his hair, but he refused, saying that there was a marriage in his
family. Neeraj then tried to cut the hair of Sandeep, but was stopped
by him. He further stated that he asked everybody not to cut the hair of
Sandeep, and when they started walking out of the room, Narender
snatched the scissor from Neeraj, saying that he would see how
Sandeep can stop him from getting his hair cut. When Narender tried
to cut the hair of Sandeep, he gave him a slap. In response, Narender
gave 1-2 slaps to Sandeep. A scuffle took place between both of them.
He further stated that they separated them and while they were leaving
the room, out of anger, Narender exhorted that he would teach
Sandeep a lesson for slapping him and then picked up the scissor and
struck on the chest of Sandeep, due to which, he immediately sat on
the cot and was thereafter rushed to Malik Nursing Home in an auto.
8.
Appellant/accused
was
arrested.
Upon
completion
of
investigation, charge sheet was filed under Section 302 IPC against
the appellant/accused Narender and he was sent to Court for trial.
Proceedings before the Trial Court
9.
Charge under Section 302 IPC was framed against the
appellant/accused on 08th October, 2003, to which, he pleaded not
guilty and claimed trial.
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
10.
In order to prove its case, prosecution examined 27 witnesses.
Statement of appellant/accused was recorded under Section 313 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 [“Cr.P.C.”], wherein, he denied all
the incriminating evidence appearing on record against him. He
claimed that he was innocent. No injury was caused by him to
Sandeep, and he was falsely implicated in this case. He refused to lead
any evidence in his defence.
11.
The learned Trial Court vide judgment dated 18th December,
2004, concluded as under:“(i) Accused Narender and deceased Sandeep
were involved in a scuffle;
(ii) Only these two persons were involved in
scuffle and there is no evidence of any third
person involved in that scuffle;
(iii) Scuffle was over cutting of hair;
(iv) Hair were being cut with a pair of
scissors;
(v) In the scuffle deceased Sandeep sustained
injuries on account of which he became
unconscious and died shortly
afterwards;
(vi) The injuries were caused with a pair of
scissors recovered from the spot;
(vii) All injuries i.e. injuries no. 1 to 8 are
result of scuffle between two parties and are of
the same duration. Injury no.8 is of the depth
of 13 cm which proved fatal being sufficient to
cause death in ordinary course of nature and
is not possible accidentally or by self-infliction
; and
(viii) There is no explanation from the accused
as to how the injuries were suffered by the
deceased when he and he alone was having a
scuffle with him (deceased) with a pair of
scissors in hand.”
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
12.
On the basis of such conclusion, the learned Trial Court drew
the inference that it was the accused and none else who had caused the
death of the deceased, Sandeep by intentionally giving him fatal
wound on his chest with a pair of scissors and accordingly convicted
him under Section 302 IPC and vide Order on Sentence dated 21st
December 2004, sentenced the appellant/accused to undergo
imprisonment for life for the offence under Section 302 IPC with fine
of Rs. 1000/-, in default, to undergo imprisonment for three months.
13.
Feeling aggrieved, the appellant/accused Narender preferred the
present appeal.
Submissions on behalf of the appellant
14.
The learned counsel for the appellant assailed the impugned
judgment of conviction, stating that the learned Trial Court failed to
appreciate the evidence in its proper perspective and convicted the
appellant merely on conjectures and surmises. It was contended that
the prosecution had failed to establish that the appellant intentionally
caused the death of Sandeep.
15.
It was submitted that as per the admitted case of the prosecution
itself, there was no prior enmity or dispute between the appellant and
the deceased. There was no motive for the appellant to kill or cause
injury to the deceased. In fact, appellant neither had any intention to
inflict any injury nor had any knowledge that by just trying to stop the
deceased from cutting his hair, the deceased would apply so much
force that would result in a jerk, and in turn injuring himself from the
scissor.
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
16.
It was further argued that at no point of time, the scissor came
into the hand of the appellant nor he was negligent in his act. He had
just tried to stop the appellant and did not use any excess force nor
tried to snatch the scissor. He had only tried to defend himself and did
not attack the deceased in any manner.
17.
It was submitted that the two prosecution witnesses, that is,
PW-3 and PW-8 turned hostile and did not support the case of
prosecution. They were cross examined by the learned APP, and even
in cross examination, nothing came out. In fact, in cross examination
by the learned Prosecutor, contradictory suggestions were made,
thereby, reflecting that there was no clear stand of the State.
18.
It was submitted that if the appellant had tried to hit the
deceased with the scissor, then the deceased must have suffered some
injuries on his hand, but no such injuries were found, which proves
that the appellant did not inflict any injury to the deceased.
19.
It was argued that the deceased himself was the aggressor, he
had the scissor in his hand and wanted to cut the hair of the appellant
forcibly. The appellant was just trying to prevent the deceased from
cutting his hair and in trying to get his hand released, the deceased
may have gotten a jerk, resulting in injury on his person.
20.
It was further submitted that as per information recorded vide
DD No. 25, Sandeep had died due to injuries from the scissor and the
information received was not regarding his murder. However, later on,
the statements of the witnesses were manipulated to falsely implicate
the appellant.
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
21.
The learned counsel further submitted that there was admittedly
no prior enmity between the appellant and the deceased. The
occurrence took place on a trivial issue, concerning the cutting of hair.
There was a complete absence of any motive.
22.
It was further submitted that the conduct of the appellant
immediately after the occurrence was wholly inconsistent with an
intention to cause death to the deceased. The appellant along with PW3 and PW-8, removed the injured Sandeep first to Malik Nursing
Home and thereafter to ESI Hospital. The learned counsel contended
that this conduct demonstrated the appellant's bona fide and his
concern for the injured, rather than an intention to cause or facilitate
his death. The evidence shows that the appellant accompanied the
injured to the hospital and thereafter returned with others to the
Akhada.
23.
Referring to the testimony of PW-13 Dr. V.K. Malik, it was
further submitted that even Sandeep had just informed the doctor that
the injuries were caused by the scissor in a scuffle, but did not name
the appellant or attribute any injury specifically to him. It was argued
that such statement by the deceased to the doctor, substantially
corroborated the defence version that the injury was sustained during a
scuffle and was not an intentional assault by the appellant.
24.
It was further argued that there was delay in passing the
information to the police, inasmuch as, the incident took place at about
2:00 PM, while DD No. 25 was recorded at about 6:15 PM. The delay
of several hours in recording the DD entry was a circumstance, which
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
creates doubt on the prosecution case. It was also argued that the
statement of PW-3 Neeraj was recorded after an unexplained and
substantial delay of approximately 02 months and 21 days. Such delay
in recording the statement of a witness, who was allegedly present at
the scene of crime, materially affects the evidentiary value of his
testimony.
25.
The learned counsel submitted that the prosecution case, at best,
established that a sudden scuffle had taken place between the appellant
and Sandeep, and that Sandeep sustained a fatal injury with the
scissors. It is not established beyond reasonable doubt that the
appellant had the intention to inflict such a fatal injury.
26.
It was urged that the judgment of conviction suffers from an
erroneous appreciation of evidence and that the appellant was entitled
to the benefit of doubt. In support of his submissions, the learned
counsel for the appellant relies on the following judgments:i.
Tunda Vs. Rex, AIR 1950 ALL 95;
ii.
Rakesh Dutt Sharma Vs. State of Uttarakhand, Order in CRL.A.
No. 1461/2012 dated 28th August, 2025;
iii.
Arvind Kumar Vs. State of NCT Delhi, Judgment in CRL.A. No.
2390/2010 dated 17th July, 2023.
Submissions on behalf of the State
27.
Per contra, Mr. Aman Usman, learned APP for the State,
supported the impugned judgment and submitted that the learned Trial
Court duly appreciated the evidence and rightly convicted the
appellant under Sections 302 IPC. It was contended that the
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
prosecution
has
established
a
complete
chain
of
evidence,
demonstrating the presence of the appellant during the scuffle and the
fatal injury suffered by Sandeep at the behest of the appellant.
28.
The learned APP submitted that the evidence of PW-3 Neeraj
and PW-8 Naveen consistently placed the appellant and the deceased
together at the relevant time and proved the scuffle between them. The
mere fact that PW-3 and PW-8 did not specifically depose as to the
precise manner in which Sandeep got injured by the scissors, is not
sufficient to discard the remaining part of their testimonies, which
clearly establish that the appellant and Sandeep were fighting just
before the infliction of the fatal injury.
29.
It was further submitted that the post-mortem examination
conducted by PW-19 Dr. Akash Jhanjee proves that Injury No.8 was
sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. The doctor
opined that the said injury was caused by a sharp, penetrating and
cutting pointed weapon. The medical evidence further receives
material corroboration from the examination of the weapon recovered
from the place of occurrence. After examining the said weapon, the
doctor opined that Injury No. 8 was possible with the said pair of
scissors. The compatibility between the recovered weapon and the
fatal injury provides independent corroboration to the version of the
prosecution. The recovery of scissors from the place of occurrence,
when read along with the medical opinion, constitutes an important
incriminating circumstance against the accused.
30.
It was further submitted that the ocular evidence materially
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
corroborates the medical circumstances surrounding the death of
deceased Sandeep. The prosecution evidence establishes that deceased
Sandeep, appellant/accused Narender and witnesses Neeraj and
Naveen were present together at the wrestling ground. A dispute arose
in relation to cutting of the hair, resulting in a scuffle between the
appellant and the deceased, and during such scuffle, the deceased
suffered a fatal penetrating injury with the scissor, resulting in his
death. The evidence of PW-3 and PW-8 regarding the presence of the
accused and the deceased together coupled with the scuffle between
them receives substantial corroboration from the medical evidence.
31.
The learned APP further submitted that the appellant's
subsequent conduct of taking the injured to the hospital, could not by
itself exonerate him. Such conduct could not negate the evidence
establishing the appellant's participation in the scuffle and the medical
evidence regarding the nature of the fatal injury. As regards the delay
in lodging of the FIR, it was submitted that the mere fact that the first
information of the occurrence was recorded several hours after the
occurrence, could not demolish the prosecution’s case, particularly
when, the deceased had first been taken for medical treatment and
thereafter his body was brought to the Akhada.
32.
The learned APP has thus argued that the prosecution has been
able to establish a complete and cogent chain of circumstances
connecting the appellant Narender with the fatal injury and the
resultant death of the deceased Sandeep. The initial registration of the
FIR under Section 304 IPC stands duly explained by the subsequent
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
investigation and the medical opinion obtained thereafter, pursuant to
which, the offence was altered to Section 302 IPC and the charge
sheet was filed accordingly. The ocular evidence regarding the
presence of the appellant and the deceased, the scuffle between them,
recovery of the weapon and ruling out the possibility of accidental or
self-inflicted injuries materially corroborates the prosecution case.
33.
On the basis of the aforesaid submissions, it was argued that the
circumstances proved on record when appreciated in their entirety and
in a proper perspective, points towards the involvement of the
appellant Narender in the occurrence and proves the prosecution
charge under Section 302 IPC beyond doubt. It was accordingly
submitted that the appeal being devoid of merits, deserves to be
dismissed.
34.
In support of his arguments, the learned APP placed reliance
upon the following judgments:i.
Abdul Sayeed Vs. State of M.P., (2010) 10 SCC 259;
ii.
Gura Singh Vs. State of Rajasthan, (2001) 2 SCC 205;
iii.
Lokendra Singh Vs. State of M.P., (2019) 3 SCC 676;
iv.
Trimukh Maroti Kirkan Vs. State of Maharashtra, (2006) 10
SCC 681.
Reasoning and Analysis
35.
We have considered the arguments advanced by the learned
counsel for the appellant and the learned APP on behalf of the State
and have carefully perused the material on record.
36.
While exercising appellate jurisdiction in a criminal appeal
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
against conviction, this Court may re-appreciate the evidence to
ascertain whether the findings recorded by the learned Trial Court
suffer from any perversity, material illegality, or result in miscarriage
of justice.
37.
The present case is one of a sudden scuffle which occurred
between the appellant and the deceased Sandeep over a trivial issue,
which unfortunately resulted in the demise of Sandeep. The question
for determination is whether the prosecution has been able to prove
beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant was the person who
inflicted the fatal injury and had the requisite intention to cause the
death of Sandeep.
38.
The post-mortem of the deceased was conducted by PW-19 Dr.
Akash Jhanjee, who found eight injuries on the person of Sandeep.
Injury No.8 was a penetrating incise wound measuring 1.2 cm x 0.4
cms and having a depth of approximately 13 cms. The doctor opined
that the said injury was sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to
cause death and that the death had resulted from cardiac tempunade
consequent upon the said injury. He further opined that injury No.8
had been caused by a sharp, penetrating and cutting pointed weapon
and that the injury was possible by the scissors recovered from the
spot. The medical evidence thus leaves no room for doubt that
Sandeep had died as a result of a fatal chest injury. PW-19 ruled out
the possibility of Injury No.8 being accidental nor self-inflicted.
Notwithstanding such opinion, the prosecution still needs to prove that
the appellant had the necessary intent. It is settled position in law that
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
merely on medical opinion, it may not be safe to convict the accused.
39.
The prosecution case, insofar as the appellant’s involvement is
concerned, rests substantially upon the testimonies of PW-3 Neeraj
and PW-8 Naveen. Both these witnesses were admittedly present in
the Akhada at the relevant time and knew the appellant and the
deceased. Their testimonies require careful scrutiny, more so, because
neither of them deposed to have seen the appellant inflicting the fatal
injury.
40.
PW-8 Naveen deposed that on the relevant date, he along with
Neeraj, Narender and Sandeep were sitting in a room adjoining the
Akhada. Sandeep asked Narender to get his head shaved, to which,
Narender replied that Sandeep should first get his own head shaved.
Sandeep then told him that there was marriage in his family and so he
would get his head shaved later on. Sandeep thereafter picked a scissor
and cut some hairs of Narender. Narender tried to stop him, and in the
process, Sandeep suffered injuries. Significantly, PW-8 stated that he
did not see how Sandeep suffered injuries, as he and Neeraj were
sitting on a side and his attention was drawn towards Sandeep only
when he started feeling giddiness.
41.
PW-8 further stated that the police recorded his statement Ex.
PW-8/A, bearing his signatures at point A, however, the same was not
read over to him and he had only signed it. He further deposed about
the recovery of scissor from the same room, but could not tell as to
whether the hairs were also seized by the police.
42.
PW-8 was declared hostile and was cross examined by the
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
learned APP with the permission of the Trial Court. In such cross
examination, he reiterated that statement Ex. PW-8/A was not read
over to him, and that his signatures on Ex. PW-6/A to Ex. PW-6/C
were obtained on blank papers. He feigned ignorance to the suggestion
that at the time of cutting the hair, Narender had caught hold of the
right hand of Sandeep in which he was holding the scissor. He denied
the suggestion that Narender twisted the right hand of the deceased in
which he was holding the scissor. He stated that he did not hear
Sandeep requesting Narender not to twist his hand in such a dangerous
manner as the same may result in injury. He further stated that he did
not see if on account of non-release of the hand of the deceased by
Narender, the scissors struck the left side of the chest of the deceased.
He denied the suggestion that the IO had lifted few cut hairs lying in
the same room or if any scissor was also lifted and its sketch Ex. PW6/A was prepared. He denied that the scissor was kept in a parcel,
which was sealed with the seal of JS and seized vide memo Ex. PW6/B. He denied having given any supplementary statements Mark X
and Mark Y to the police. He did not identify the scissor.
43.
In cross examination by the defence, PW-8 re-confirmed that he
was not aware about the content of the statement Ex. PW-8/A as the
same was not written on his dictation and was also not read over to
him. He took further somersault by stating that he had not seen the
incident in which the deceased and the appellant Narender were trying
to cut the hairs of each other, but heard about the same subsequently.
He categorically stated that he does not know how the deceased
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
suffered injuries.
44.
The second eye witness projected by the prosecution is PW-3
Neeraj. He deposed that Narender and Sandeep were desirous of
getting their heads shaved. However, deceased Sandeep later refused,
though, appellant Narender was insisting for shaving off his hair. PW3 then made an improvement by stating that it was Sandeep who was
asking Narender to get his head shaved, whereas, Narender was
insisting Sandeep to get his hair shaved. On this issue, both of them
had a scuffle with each other, and in that scuffle, Sandeep suffered an
injury on his chest with a scissor. However, according to him, he does
not know how Sandeep received that scissor injury. He could not even
tell as to where the scissor was at the time of incident.
45.
PW-3 was also declared hostile and was cross examined by the
learned APP with the permission of the learned Trial Court. In such
cross examination, he was confronted with the previous statements
Mark X and Mark Y, but he stated that such statements were not made
by him to the police. He admitted the suggestion that on the day of
incident, deceased Sandeep was insisting Narender to get his head
shaved like him and that of Naveen. He admitted that the appellant
was refusing for the same. However, he expressed his ignorance as to
whether on such refusal of Narender, Sandeep had picked up the
scissor from a box lying in the room and cut some hair of Narender
with that scissor. He could not tell that due to this reason, Narender
got enraged and entered into a scuffle with Sandeep. He could not tell
if Narender had stabbed into the chest of Sandeep with the same
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
scissor.
46.
During cross examination by the defence, PW-3 stated that he
gave the statement voluntarily without any pressure, threat or
coercion.
47.
On an analysis of the testimonies of PW-3 and PW-8, it is
evident that both these witnesses have turned hostile and have not
supported the prosecution case. There can be no doubt to the
proposition that the entire testimony of a hostile witness is not to be
discarded or effaced from the record, and it is the duty of the Court to
separate the grain from the chauff, and therefore so much of the
testimonies of the hostile witnesses which inspire confidence, can still
be relied upon. At the same time, the testimonies of PW-3 and PW-8
only established the presence of the appellant and the deceased at the
place of occurrence, the scuffle between the two on a trivial issue of
cutting of the hair of each other and the resultant injury on the chest of
Sandeep with the scissor. Their testimonies further prove that it was
Sandeep who was forcibly trying to cut the hair of the appellant, who
was resisting the same. Appellant was therefore not the aggressor. In
fact, if the testimony of PW-8 is to be believed, it was the deceased
Sandeep who himself picked up the scissor and started cutting the hair
of the appellant against his wishes and consent. There is no evidence
that the scissor was in the hand of the appellant at the time of
delivering the fatal scissor blow. Mere recovery of the scissor also
does not materially advance the prosecution case. The scissor was
recovered from the spot and not from the possession of the appellant.
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
What remains unproved is the crucial fact that the appellant had the
scissor in his hand at the relevant moment and intentionally inflicted
the injury.
48.
PW-3 and PW-8 have deposed that after the injury was suffered
by Sandeep, they both along with the appellant, removed the victim to
Malik Nursing Home and from there to ESIC Hospital. The conduct of
the appellant of accompanying the injured to the hospital is not a
disputed circumstance.
49.
PW-13 Dr. V.K. Malik examined Sandeep upon being
brought to Malik Nursing Home, and as per his testimony, Sandeep
told him that the injury was suffered by him by a scissor in a scuffle.
What is significant is that Sandeep did not attribute the scissor injury
to the appellant. While such omission cannot by itself exonerate the
appellant, it certainly assumes relevance when considered alongside
the failure of PW-3 and PW-8 to depose exactly how the fatal injury
was inflicted.
50.
There is no evidence on record to suggest that there was any
previous enmity or ill-will between the appellant and the deceased,
which may have prompted the appellant to commit the murder of the
deceased.
51.
We are of the view that the prosecution has failed to prove that
the appellant had either any intention of causing death of the deceased
or the intention of causing such bodily injury to the deceased, which
was likely to cause his death. Merely because the appellant was trying
to stop the deceased from cutting his hair, it is not possible to attribute
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
knowledge to him that by his act of stopping the deceased, he was
likely to cause the death of the deceased. Thus, by no stretch of
imagination, it is a case of culpable homicide as defined under Section
299 of IPC, as the existence of none of the three ingredients
incorporated therein has been proved by the prosecution.
52.
We are also unable to accept the argument that the appellant's
failure to explain the exact manner in which Sandeep suffered the fatal
injury can, by itself, complete the prosecution case. The prosecution
must first establish the foundational circumstances from which the
guilt of the appellant can reasonably be inferred. Section 106 of the
Evidence Act, 1872 cannot be employed to relieve the prosecution of
its primary burden.
53.
At the highest, prosecution has been able to prove that Sandeep
suffered an injury with scissor accidently in a scuffle with the
appellant without any criminal intention or knowledge on the part of
the appellant. Thus, no offence was committed by the appellant in
view of Section 80 of the IPC, as the death was purely accidental.
54.
We find no clinching evidence on record to hold the appellant
guilty of any offence, much less, Section 302 IPC. Consequently, we
are of the considered opinion that the prosecution has miserably failed
to prove its case against the appellant.
55.
Accordingly, the appeal deserves to be allowed. The Judgment
of Conviction dated 18th December, 2004 and the Order on Sentence
dated 21st December, 2004 are hereby set aside. The appellant
Narender is acquitted of the charge framed against him.
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
56.
The bail bond furnished by the appellant shall remain valid for
another period of three months.
57.
Copy of this judgment be sent to the learned Trial Court and the
Superintendent Jail for information.
RAVINDER DUDEJA, J.
NAVIN CHAWLA, J.
SEPTEMBER 15, 2026/AK
CRL.A. 45/2005
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:45
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review