Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Cr.MPM No. 1601 of 2026
Date of Decision: 2.9.2026
_____________________________________________________________________
Narender Singh
……...Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh
…....Respondent
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sandeep Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?
For the Petitioner:
Ms. Ambika Thakur, proxy counsel vice Mr.Prem
Chand Verma, Mr. Aakash Thakur and Mr.
Varun Thakur, Advocates.
For the Respondent: Mr. Rajan Kahol & Mr. Vishal Panwar, Additional
Advocates General and Mr. Ravi Chauhan & Mr.
Anish Banshtu, Deputy Advocates General.
___________________________________________________________________________
Sandeep Sharma, J. (Oral)
Bail petitioner, namely Narender Singh, who is behind the bars
since 05.02.2026, has approached this Court in the instant proceedings
filed under Section 483 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, for
grant of regular bail in case FIR No.12 of 2026, dated 01.02.2026, under
Sections 103 & 61(2) of Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, registered at Police
Station Kasauli, District Solan, Himachal Pradesh.
2.
In terms of order dated 21.08.2026, respondent/State has filed
status report and ASI Sanjeet Kumar, has come present along with record.
Record perused and returned.
3.
Close scrutiny of status report/record reveals that complainant
namely Pooja Sharma, i.e. sister-in-law of the deceased Suman, got her
statement recorded under Section 173 BNSS, alleging therein that on
31.01.2026, while she, along with her husband and father-in-law, had gone
to Ashwani Khad for some personal work, her father-in-law, Sh. Dhyan
Singh, received a call on his mobile at about 4:00 p.m. from bail petitioner
i.e. brother-in-law of deceased Suman that some quarrel had taken place
inter se deceased Suman and her husband, Chattar Singh. She alleged that
bail petitioner also informed them that Suman had attacked her husband
with a knife on his throat and as such, they were required to come to the
matrimonial house of the deceased Suman. She alleged that at around 8:00
p.m., she, along with her husband Sumit and brother-in-law Dhyan Ram
Thakur, reached Shanogi, where matrimonial house of the deceased Suman
was situated, and found the dead body of the deceased Suman lying in a
pool of blood. She alleged that she has suspicion that her sister-in-law
Suman has been murdered by her husband Chattar Singh with a sharpedged weapon. In the afore background, police investigated the case and
arrested the accused namely Chattar Singh, who, at first instance,
attempted to establish that deceased Suman had committed suicide by
inflicting injuries on her throat, but subsequently, admitted to his guilt and
disclosed to the police that on the date of the alleged incident, some
altercation had taken place inter se him and the deceased Suman, who
used to taunt him. He disclosed to the police that immediately after his
marriage with deceased Suman, factum of his suffering sexual disorder
came to the notice of the deceased Suman, who thereafter not only became
distressed, but also changed her behaviour towards him. He alleged that on
31.01.2026, deceased called him impotent and unmanly, as a result
whereof, he became furious and caught hold of the deceased by her throat
and strangulated her until she died. He alleged that once he narrated the
entire incident to bail petitioner and niece Nikita, they, with a view to
conceal the incident of strangulation, concocted a story that deceased had
committed suicide by inflicting injury on her throat with scissors. He
disclosed that he had inflicted an injury on the throat/neck of the
deceased, as a result thereof, blood started oozing out of the same. He also
disclosed to the police that with a view to prove that quarrel had taken
place inter se him and the deceased, he also inflicted injury on the cheek of
his niece Nikita with the same knife and also inflicted injuries upon
himself. In the afore-background, bail petitioner and co-accused Nikita
Tanwar, also came to be named in the FIR and since 05.02.2026, bail
petitioner is behind bars whereas co-accused Nikita Tanwar stands
enlarged on bail vide judgment dated 19.8.2026, passed by this Court in
Cr.MP(M) No. 1520 of 2026.
4.
Since challan stands filed in the competent Court of law and
nothing remains to be recovered from the bail petitioner, petitioner has
approached this Court in the instant proceedings for grant of regular bail.
Learned Counsel representing the petitioner, states that no case much less
case under Sections 103 & 61(2) of Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita is made out
against the petitioner because as per own case of the prosecution, deceased
Suman died after being strangulated by her husband Chattar Singh. He
states that though factum with regard to concoction of false story, if any,
propagated by the co-accused Chattar Singh, is yet to be established on
record by the prosecution by leading cogent and convincing evidence, but
even otherwise, deceased Suman had already died prior to the alleged
hatching of the conspiracy by co-accused Nikita,
Chattar Singh and
present bail petitioner to conceal the alleged incident of strangulation. He
states that there is nothing in the status report, suggestive of the fact that
injury of any kind was ever inflicted by the present bail-petitioner on the
person of the deceased, rather, as per own statement given by the coaccused Chatar Singh, he, after the death of the deceased, inflicted injuries
on her throat/neck with the help of scissors, to prove that the deceased
had committed suicide by inflicting injury on her throat/neck. He states
that it is yet to be established on record by the prosecution that petitioner
herein was a part of conspiracy, if any, hatched by the main accused
Chattar Singh, who otherwise has admitted his guilt.
5.
To the contrary, Mr. Rajan Kahol, learned Additional Advocate
General, while fairly admitting factum of filing of challan in the competent
Court of law, states that though nothing remains to be recovered from the
bail-petitioner, but keeping in view the gravity of offence, alleged to have
been committed by him, he does not deserve any leniency, rather needs to
be dealt with severely. He states that there is overwhelming evidence
adduced on record suggestive of the fact that bail-petitioner hatched
criminal conspiracy with the co-accused Chattar Singh and Nikita Tanwar
to conceal the death of the deceased Suman, who was allegedly
strangulated to death by co-accused Chattar Singh. He states that since at
the time of alleged incident, both Chattar Singh and bail petitioner were
present on the spot, it cannot be said that bail petitioner had no knowledge
about the incident. While referring to the post-mortem report, Mr. Kahol
states that the definite cause of death of the deceased cannot be attributed
solely to strangulation, as the injuries inflicted thereafter have also been
opined to have contributed to death. Lastly, Mr. Kahol states that since
petitioner is accused of a heinous crime punishable with life imprisonment,
prayer made on behalf of the petitioner for grant of bail deserves outright
rejection.
6.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
material available on record, this court finds that husband of the deceased,
namely Chattar Singh, in his statement given to the police, admitted that
on the date of alleged incident, there was a quarrel inter se him and his
deceased wife, whereafter he strangulated her. He also admitted that to
cover up his crime, he concocted a story that deceased Suman had
committed suicide by inflicting injuries on her throat/neck, whereas he,
after his having informed co-accused Nikta and present petitioner, had
inflicted injuries on the neck/throat with the help of scissors. Though the
statement of co-accused is not admissible insofar as the culpability of other
co-accused is concerned, but even if statement made by Chattar Singh is
perused in its entirety, as has been recorded in the status report, it
nowhere suggests that present bail-petitioner ever inflicted any injury on
the body of the deceased, rather, Chattar Singh inflicted injury on the
cheek of the co-accused Nikita to prove that deceased Suman, after
attacking him, had also attempted to attack bail petitioner as well as Nikita.
7.
Though precise case of the prosecution is that present bail-
petitioner hatched criminal conspiracy with the main accused Chattar
Singh to conceal the killing of the deceased Suman by Chattar Singh, but it
is also admitted case of the prosecution that deceased had actually died
prior to inflicting of injuries on her neck/throat by Chattar Singh. Best case
of the prosecution against the present bail-petitioner is that he made an
attempt to conceal alleged murder of the deceased by Chattar Singh, which
fact is yet to be established on record by the prosecution by leading cogent
and convincing evidence.
8.
Since there is no direct evidence adduced on record to prove
infliction of injury, if any, by the petitioner on the body of deceased,
coupled with the fact that co-accused Chattar Singh has admitted factum
of his having killed his wife by strangulation, there appears to be no
justification to keep present bail-petitioner behind bars for an indefinite
period during trial, conclusion thereof may take considerable time. It is
none of the case of the prosecution that in past, bail petitioner has
committed an offence punishable with death, imprisonment for life, or
imprisonment for seven years or more, or that he has previously been
convicted on two or more occasions for a cognizable offence punishable
with imprisonment for three years or more but less than seven years.
Petitioner herein is a first offender and, as such, his prayer for bail deserves
to be accepted.
9.
Hon’ble Apex Court as well as this Court in catena of cases
have repeatedly held that one is deemed to be innocent till the time guilt, if
any, of his/her is not proved in accordance with law. In the case at hand
also, guilt, if any, of the accused is yet to be proved in accordance with law,
by leading cogent and convincing material on record, as such, her
incarceration in jail for indefinite period is clear cut violation of
fundamental rights guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of
India. Apprehension expressed by the learned Additional Advocate General
that in the event of petitioner’s being enlarged on bail, she may flee from
justice, can be best met by putting the bail petitioner to stringent
conditions as has been fairly stated by the learned counsel for the
petitioner.
10.
Needless to say, object of the bail is to secure the attendance of
the accused in the trial and the proper test to be applied in the solution of
the question whether bail should be granted or refused is whether it is
probable that the party will appear to take his trial. Otherwise, bail is not to
be withheld as a punishment. Otherwise also, normal rule is of bail and not
jail. Court has to keep in mind nature of accusations, nature of evidence in
support thereof, severity of the punishment which conviction will entail,
character of the accused, circumstances which are peculiar to the accused
involved in that crime.
11.
Hon'ble Apex Court in Criminal Appeal No. 227/2018,
Dataram Singh vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr decided on 6.2.2018 has
held that freedom of an individual cannot be curtailed for indefinite period,
especially when his/her guilt is yet to be proved. It has been further held by
the Hon'ble Apex Court in the aforesaid judgment that a person is believed
to be innocent until found guilty.
12.
Hon’ble Apex Court in Sanjay Chandra versus Central Bureau
of Investigation (2012)1 Supreme Court Cases 49 has held that gravity
alone cannot be a decisive ground to deny bail, rather competing factors are
required to be balanced by the court while exercising its discretion. It has
been repeatedly held by the Hon’ble Apex Court that object of bail is to
secure the appearance of the accused person at his trial by reasonable
amount of bail. The object of bail is neither punitive nor preventative.
13.
In Manoranjana Sinh alias Gupta versus CBI, (2017) 5 SCC
218, Hon'ble Apex Court has held that the object of the bail is to secure the
attendance of the accused in the trial and the proper test to be applied in
the solution of the question whether bail should be granted or refused is
whether it is probable that the party will appear to take his trial. Otherwise
also, normal rule is of bail and not jail. Apart from above, Court has to keep
in mind nature of accusations, nature of evidence in support thereof,
severity of the punishment, which conviction will entail, character of the
accused, circumstances which are peculiar to the accused involved in that
crime.
14.
The Apex Court in Prasanta Kumar Sarkar versus Ashis
Chatterjee and another (2010) 14 SCC 496, has laid down various
principles to be kept in mind, while deciding petition for bail viz. prima facie
case, nature and gravity of accusation, punishment involved, apprehension
of repetition of offence and witnesses being influenced.
15.
In view of above, bail petitioner has carved out a case for
himself, as such, present petition is allowed. Bail petitioner is ordered to be
enlarged on bail, subject to furnishing bail bonds in the sum of
Rs.1,00,000/- with one surety in the like amount, to the satisfaction of the
learned trial Court, besides the following conditions:
a. He shall make himself available for the purpose of interrogation, if so
required and regularly attend the trial Court on each and every date of
hearing and if prevented by any reason to do so, seek exemption from
appearance by filing appropriate application;
b. He shall not tamper with the prosecution evidence nor hamper the
investigation of the case in any manner whatsoever;
c. He shall not make any inducement, threat or promises to any person
acquainted with the facts of the case so as to dissuade him/her from
disclosing such facts to the Court or the Police Officer; and
d. He shall not leave the territory of India without the prior permission of
the Court.
16.
It is clarified that if the petitioner misuses the liberty or violates
any of the conditions imposed upon him, the investigating agency shall be free
to move this Court for cancellation of the bail.
17.
Any observations made hereinabove shall not be construed to be a
reflection on the merits of the case and shall remain confined to the disposal of
this application alone. The petition stands accordingly disposed of.
18.
The bail petitioner is permitted to produce copy of the order
downloaded from the High Court Website and the trial court shall not insist for
certified copy of the order, however, it may verify the order from the High Court
website or otherwise.
September 2, 2026
(manjit)
(Sandeep Sharma),
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review