The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
2. Considering the grievance of the petitioner, the nature of the order impugned and the order being passed hereinafter, there is no necessity to call for reply from the respondents. Matter has accordingly been heard at this stage. CWP No. 11846 of 2025 was preferred by the petitioner seeking applicability of Inder Singh Thakur and Others vs. State of H.P. 2 The Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? CWP No. 4830 of 2023 decided on 07.04.2025 ( 2026:HHC:39444 ) writ petition was disposed of on 24 th July 2025 with direction to the respondents to consider and decide the representation of the petitioner preferred in that regard in accordance with law within timelines indicated therein. Pursuant to the directions issued, Deputy Director School Education (Elementary), Chamba, passed order on 10.03.2026 rejecting the case of the petitioner on the grounds that: (i) Letters Patent Appeal has been filed by the department against the decision rendered in Inder Singh Thakur, therefore, the decision cannot be applied to the petitioner as the aforesaid decision cannot be held applicable to the petitioner as the same has not yet attained finality; (ii) In terms of Revised Pay Rules 2022, first amendment carried out under notification issued on 06.09.2022, the petitioner is not entitled for revised pay as he was already granted grade pay in the revised pay sca…
3. It is well-settled that mere filing or pendency of Letters Patent Appeal does not amount to stay of the judgment against which Letters Patent Appeal has been preferred. Impact of mere pendency of Letters Patent Appeal upon the grant of benefits accruing to a person in terms of judgment was considered by Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in Hans ( 2026:HHC:39444 ) Raj versus State of Himachal Pradesh and others3. The Hon’ble Division Bench held that “an impression has been left on our minds that the concerned authorities failed to reinstate and to pay arrears of salary to the petitioner soon after the decision of the learned Single judge, even though at the material time no stay order was operative, as they appeared to be entertaining the belief that since a Letters Patent Appeal was preferred, the matter had once again become sub judice and that, therefore, there was no legal obligation to grant the benefits accruing due to the petitioner pursuant to the decision of the learned Single Judge. This belief, which appears to have been entertained by the concerned authorities, is wholly unwarranted. Once a case is decided, it is the bounden duty of the State and its subordinates to implement with the utmost expedition the said decision. In a Government which is ruled by law, there must be complete awareness to carry out faithfully and honestly the decisions rendered by Courts of …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:39444 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH SHIMLA
CWP No. 16077 of 2026.
Decided on :16th September, 2026
Narender Singh Sharma
...Petitioner.
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
....Respondents.
Coram:
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Devender K. Sharma, Advocate.
For the respondents:
Mr. Rajat Chaudhary, Assistant Advocate
General.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge.
Notice.
Mr. Rajat Chaudhary, learned Assistant Advocate
General appears and waives service of notice on behalf of
the
respondents.
2.
Considering the grievance of the petitioner, the nature of the
order impugned and the order being passed hereinafter, there is no
necessity to call for reply from the respondents. Matter has accordingly
been heard at this stage.
CWP No. 11846 of 2025 was preferred by the petitioner
seeking applicability of Inder Singh Thakur and Others vs. State of H.P. 2 The
Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
CWP No. 4830 of 2023 decided on 07.04.2025
( 2026:HHC:39444 )
writ petition was disposed of on 24 th July 2025 with direction to the
respondents to consider and decide the representation of the petitioner
preferred in that regard in accordance with law within timelines indicated
therein.
Pursuant to the directions issued, Deputy Director School
Education (Elementary), Chamba, passed order on 10.03.2026 rejecting
the case of the petitioner on the grounds that: (i) Letters Patent Appeal
has been filed by the department against the decision rendered in Inder
Singh Thakur, therefore, the decision cannot be applied to the petitioner as
the aforesaid decision cannot be held applicable to the petitioner as the
same has not yet attained finality; (ii) In terms of Revised Pay Rules 2022,
first amendment carried out under notification issued on 06.09.2022, the
petitioner is not entitled for revised pay as he was already granted grade
pay in the revised pay scale.
3.
It is well-settled that mere filing or pendency of Letters Patent
Appeal does not amount to stay of the judgment against which Letters
Patent Appeal has been preferred. Impact of mere pendency of Letters
Patent Appeal upon the grant of benefits accruing to a person in terms of
judgment was considered by Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in Hans
( 2026:HHC:39444 )
Raj versus State of Himachal Pradesh and others3. The Hon’ble Division
Bench held that “an impression has been left on our minds that the
concerned authorities failed to reinstate and to pay arrears of salary to the
petitioner soon after the decision of the learned Single judge, even though
at the material time no stay order was operative, as they appeared to be
entertaining the belief that since a Letters Patent Appeal was preferred,
the matter had once again become sub judice and that, therefore, there
was no legal obligation to grant the benefits accruing due to the petitioner
pursuant to the decision of the learned Single Judge. This belief, which
appears to have been entertained by the concerned authorities, is wholly
unwarranted. Once a case is decided, it is the bounden duty of the State
and its subordinates to implement with the utmost expedition the said
decision. In a Government which is ruled by law, there must be complete
awareness to carry out faithfully and honestly the decisions rendered by
Courts of Law after effective adjudication. Then only will private
individuals, organizations, and institutions learn to respect the decisions
of the Court. In absence of such attitude on the part of all concerned,
1985 Criminal Law Journal, 1030
( 2026:HHC:39444 )
chaotic conditions might arise and the functions assigned to the Courts of
Law under the Constitution might be rendered a futile exercise. It requires
to be emphasized in this connection that mere preferment of an appeal
does not automatically operate as a stay of the decision under appeal, and
that till an application for stay is moved and granted by the Appellate
Court, or in the alternative, the Court which rendered the decision is
moved and grants an interim stay of its decision pending the preferment
of the appeal and grant of stay by the Appellate Court, the decision
continues to be binding. Indeed, noncompliance with the decision on the
mere ground that an appeal is contemplated to be preferred or is actually
preferred, and that, therefore, the matter is sub judice, may amount to
contempt of Court, punishable under the Contempt of Courts Act”. The
Court held as under:“Before parting with the matter, we regard it to be expedient to
observe that an impression has been left on our minds that the
concerned authorities failed to reinstate and to pay arrears of
salary to the petitioner soon after the decision of the learned ingle
Judge, even though at the material time no stay order was
operative, as they appeared to be entertaining the belief that since
a Letters Patent Appeal was preferred, the matter had once again
become sub judice and that, therefore, there was no legal
obligation to grant the benefits accruing due to the petitioner
( 2026:HHC:39444 )
pursuant to the decision of the learned Single Judge. This belief,
which appears to have been entertained by the concerned
authorities, is wholly unwarranted. Once a case is decided, it is the
bounden duty of the State and its subordinates to implement with
the utmost expedition the said decision. In a Government which is
ruled by law, there must be complete awareness to carry out
faithfully and honestly the decisions rendered by courts of law
after effective adjudication. Then only will private individuals,
organizations, and institutions learn to respect the decisions of the
courts. In absence of such attitude on the part of all concerned,
chaotic conditions might arise and the functions assigned to the
courts of law under the Constitution might be rendered a futile
exercise. It requires to be emphasized in this connection that mere
preferment of an appeal does not automatically operate as a stay
of the decision under appeal, and that till an application for stay is
moved and granted by the appellate court, or in the alternative,
the court which rendered the decision is moved and grants an
interim stay of its decision pending the preferment of the appeal
and grant of stay by the appellate court, the decision continues to
be operative. Indeed, non-compliance with the decision on the
mere ground that an appeal is contemplated to be preferred or is
actually preferred, and that, therefore, the matter is sub judice,
may amount to contempt of court punishable under the Contempt
of Courts Act, 1971. The decision of the Supreme Court in
Baradakanta Mishra vs. Bhimsen Dixit, AIR 1972 SC 2466: (1973 Cri
LJ 19), places the matter beyond dispute, doubt or debate as
regards this aspect.”
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sanjeev Kumar Singh vs. State of
Bihar and Others4 held that unless an appeal is listed and there is an
interim order mere filing of an appeal does not operate as a stay of the
judgment. Portion relevant to the context as under:4
Special Leave to Appeal (C) Nos. 19038/2022
( 2026:HHC:39444 )
“Though, such contention is put forth by the respondents, keeping
in view the provisions as contained in Order 41 Rule 5 of CPC,
unless the appeal is listed and there is an interim order, the mere
filing of the appeal would not operate as a stay. If that be so, the
judgment and decree dated 25.08.2021 would enure to the benefit
of the petitioner as on today and the rejection of the NOC only on
the ground that the appeal has been filed, would not be justified.
In that view, the High Court was also not justified in rejecting the
petition. Accordingly, the Order dated 18.08.2022 passed by the
High Court of Patna in Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 11593 of
2022 is set aside. Consequently, the rejection of the NOC by the
District Magistrate is held unjustified and the District Magistrate is
directed to take note of the decree passed on 25.08.2022 and issue
the NOC within a period of two weeks from this day to the
petitioner, which shall however, remain subject to the result of the
appeal pending before the High Court.”
The court can also take judicial notice of the fact that
respondents have implemented Inder Singh Thakur2 in several cases.
Therefore, on account of mere pendency of LPA, not applying the decision
in Inder Singh Thakur2 to the case of the petitioner amounts to
overreaching the judgment rendered in Inder Singh Thakur2. The second
reason assigned by the respondents for not allowing the benefit of revised
scale to the petitioner on the ground that petitioner has already availed
the grade pay in the revised scale is also based upon misconception. This
is probably for the reason that respondent, that is the Deputy Director
( 2026:HHC:39444 )
School Education (Elementary), Chamba, has refused to look into the
decision rendered in Inder Singh Thakur2, which has dealt with the
aforesaid aspect as well. It is not expected of the concerned authorities to
mechanically turn down the representations of the employees by
assigning frivolous reasons, compelling them to come to court over and
over again seeking redressal of the same relief. Such action not only
causes harassment to the litigant but in turn also results in frittering away
the time of the Court in avoidable litigation.
4.
In view of the above, this writ petition is allowed. Impugned
office order dated 10.03.2026 (Annexure P-9) is quashed and set aside
with costs of Rs. 20,000/- to be deposited by respondent No.3 in the Chief
Justice Disaster Relief
Fund, 2025.
Fresh consideration order be now
passed keeping in view the directions already issued in CWP No. 11846 of
2025 within a period of four weeks from today. Copy of the decision so
arrived at be communicated the petitioner. Pending applications, if any,
also stand disposed of.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
( 2026:HHC:39444 )
16th September, 2026.
(jai)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review