Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 15th January, 2026
Uploaded on: 17thJanuary, 2026
+
CRL.A. 1599/2025 & CRL.M.(BAIL) 2317/2025
NARENDER SINGH & ANR.
.....Appellants
Through:
Mr. Chatanya Siddharth, Mr.
Kartikey Chaudhry and Mr. Kartik
Devansh, Advs.
(Mb. 9810661824)
versus
STATE OF NCT OF DELHI
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Ritesh Kumar Bahri, APP
with Ms. Vibha & Mr. Lalit Luthra,
Advs.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
Prathiba M. Singh, J.
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
The present appeal has been filed by the Appellants - Narender Singh
i.e., Appellant No.1 and Balender Singh i.e., Appellant No.2 under Section
415 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (hereinafter, ‘BNSS’)
challenging final judgement and order of conviction dated 2 nd September,
2025 (hereinafter, ‘impugned judgment’) and order on sentence dated 16th
September, 2025 passed by the ld. Additional Sessions Judge-04, North East
District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi in Sessions Case No. 44867/2015.
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
3.
Vide the impugned judgment, the Appellants have been convicted for
offences under Section 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter,
‘IPC’)
4.
The incident leading to the registration of FIR No.236/2012dated
10th September, 2012 registered at P.S. New Usmanpur is that on 10 th
September, 2012 at around 5:00 PM, the Appellant No.1 -Narender Singh,
who was holding a meat cutting weapon i.e.,chhura went to sharpen the
same in front of the shop of deceased person namely, Mr. Harbans where
there was a meat cutting knife sharpening stone.
5.
The deceased had raised some objection to the use of the said stone by
the Appellant No. 1-Narender Singh, which led to dispute between them and
a scuffle. The allegation against the Appellant No.2- Mr. Balender Singhi.e.,
the father of Narender Singh was that he exhorted Appellant No.1 to kill the
deceased person. One stab wound was inflicted upon the deceased using the
meat cutting weapon i.e.,chhura, who passed away after five days due to
septicemic shock in the GTB Hospital.
6.
After registration of the FIR, charges were framed against the
Appellants vide order on charge on 31st January, 2013 in the following
terms:
“1. J.R. Aryan, District Judge-cum-Sessions Judge,
Incharge-NE District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi,
do hereby charge you 1) Narender Singh S/o
Balender Singh & 2) Balender Singh S/o Mam
Chand as follows:That on 10.09.2012 at around 5.00 pm in front of
house no.87, gali no.2, first pusta, Usmanpur,
Delhi, you both in prosecution of common intention
committed murder by intentionally causing death
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
of Harbans wherein you accused Balender caught
hold of Harbans and you accused Narender
inflicted a churra (meat cutting knife weapon) stab
injury in the abdomen of Harbans and you both
thereby committed offences punishable under
Sections 302/34 IPC, and within my cognizance.
And do hereby direct that you both accused be
tried by me for the aforesaid charge”
7.
Both the Appellants had pleaded not guilty before the ld. District
Judge. Thereafter, evidence was led by the prosecution of several witnesses
including eye-witnesses being PW-2- Mr. Jitender, PW-3-Mr. Murari and
PW-4- Mr. Sanjay. The concerned police constable and authorities were also
summoned and their statements were also recorded as PW-1-HC Mukesh
Kumar, PW-5-HC Shri Pal, PW-7-SI Mukesh Jain, PW9-SI Prem Singh,
PW-10-ASI Balender Singh, PW-11-Ct. Mahesh Kumar, PW-12-HC Raj
Kumar, PW-13-Ct. Azad Singh, PW-14-Ct. Mukesh, PW-15-Ct. Ram
Naresh, PW-16-HC Satender, PW-17-Ct. Balbir Singh, PW-18-Ct.
Devender,
PW-19-Ct.
Rinku,
PW-20-Inspector
Arjun&
PW-21-SI
Vishwender.
8.
PW-8-Dr. Anil Singh, who was a Junior Resident at the GTB Hospital
and who had conducted the medical examination of the deceased person,
was also examined along with PW-22 and PW-23 namely Dr. Rahul
Moreshwar Ambulkar and Dr. B. K. Jain respectively. PW-22 had
conducted the postmortem of the deceased person and PW-23 was the
Director Professor of Surgery and Head of Department at the GTB Hospital.
9.
The defence led the evidence of two witnesses i.e., DW-1 Mr.Om
Prakash and DW-2-Appellant No.1 i.e, Narender Singh who examined
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
himself as a defence witness.
10.
The Trial Court relied upon the testimony of the eye-witnesses and
came to the conclusion that PW-2 had given a very consistent statement,
which is also corroborated by the contemporary circumstances. The Trial
Court also holds that the statement of PW-2 is fully supported by the
statement of PW-10-ASI Balender Singh as also by the Medico-Legal Case
(hereinafter, ‘MLC’) i.e., Ex PW 8/A. The Trial Court has also analysed the
statements of the doctors, who had prepared the MLC and had conducted the
postmortem of the deceased and came to the conclusion that there is no
difference in the versions given by the doctors in respect of the stab, wound,
etc.
11.
In addition, the Trial Court also considered that all the three eye-
witnesses namely PW-2, PW-3 and PW-4, did not have any history of
enmity with the Appellants and they were living in the same locality in
adjacent houses and, therefore, their testimony cannot be visited with any
suspicion. All three witnesses are close relatives of the deceased person and
therefore, their testimony, being eye witnesses, was fully reliable.
12.
On the strength of the said depositions, the Trial Court convicted the
Appellants under Sections 302/34 of the IPC and final sentence was awarded
in the following terms vide order on sentence dated 16th September, 2025:
“8. Vide judgment dated 02-09-2025, this court
has convicted both the accused Narender and
Balender for the offence punishable u/s 302134 of
IPC for having committed the murder of one
Harbans. The convicts have family to look after.
No adverse report has been received from the jail
authorities regarding their conduct in the jail. No
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
previous conviction report about their involvement
has been received. Therefore, in the opinion of this
court, the present case does not fall in the category
of rarest of rare case
9. Keeping in view the above-mentioned facts and
circumstances, both the convicts namely Balender
and Narender are hereby sentenced to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of
Rs. 40,000/- each for the offence punishable u/s
302134 of IPC. ln default of payment of fine
amount, the convicts shall undergo further simple
imprisonment for a period of three months. Fine
not deposited on behalf of convicts.
10.Out of the entire fine amount, Rs. 60,000/- shall
be given to the LRs of the deceased as
compensation and Rs. 20,0001- shall be given to
the State, as and when same is deposited
11.In view of inadequate paying capacity of
convicts, it is hereby recommended that LRs of
deceased
Harbans
may
receive
further
compensation from the office of DLSA, North-East,
KKD under the Delhi Victim Compensation
Scheme.”
13.
As can be seen from the above order, the Appellantshave been
sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for life along with fine. Some
compensation has also been awarded to the legal heirs of the deceased
person. Further compensation was to be determined by the Delhi State Legal
Services Authority, North-East, Karkardooma.
14.
Today ld. Counsel for the Appellants has taken the Court through the
testimonies of the PW-2, PW-3 and PW-4 and has submitted that all three
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
eye-witnesses have confirmed the events which have taken place, however,
it is the submission on behalf of the Appellants that the same would show
that there was no pre-meditated intention of the Appellants to cause the
death of the deceased person.
15.
Ld. Counsel for the Appellants submits that it was due to the
provocation caused by the deceased person that the scuffle appears to have
taken place leading to his death. Further, ld. Counsel submits that there was
only one stab wound, which also establishes that there was no intention to
cause death of the deceased person.
16.
On behalf of the prosecution, it is submitted by Mr. Bahri, ld. APP
that the weapon used by the Appellant No. 1 was a dangerous weapon being
a meat cutting knife and that the recovery of the same was made at the
instance of the Appellant No. 2-Balender i.e., father of the Appellant No. 1.
Ld. APP further submits that even if it is one stab wound inflicted by the
Appellant No.1 on the deceased person, the same was on a vital part of the
body.Mr. Bahri submits that the knife was also recovered at the instance of
the accused. According to ld. APP, all these facts prove the common
intention between the Appellants to cause death of the deceased person. Ld.
APP submits that in fact, Appellant No.2 exhorted the Appellant No.1 to
commit the crime. Finally, ld. APP submits that the testimony of all three
eye-witnesses is supporting each other and corroborating each other and
there is no inconsistency whatsoever.
17.
Mr. Bahri, ld. APP has placed reliance on the decision of the Supreme
Court in Virsa Singh v. The State of Punjab 1958 AIR 465 to argue that all
the necessary ingredients under Section 300, IPC, i.e. the intention to inflict
the injury that is found to be present and the injury being sufficient in the
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
ordinary course of nature to cause death, were fulfilled in facts of the present
case.
18.
The Court has considered the matter. The deposition of all three eye-
witnesses i.e., PW-2, PW-3 and PW-4 is crucial. Accordingly the relevant
portions of the said statements are extracted below:
PW-2 -Jitender
“I reside on the above stated address and I work
as a private employee with MCD. Incident is of
10.09.2012. It was around 5pm that I was present
in the gali of my house. Accused Narender present
in court in this case (correctly identified) resides in
our gali and he runs a meat shop in the same gali.
I saw accused Narender holding a meat cutting
weapon chura and proceeded towards the meat
shop of my relative Harbans and there is a meat
shop in the house of Harbans. Narender started
sharpening the chura on the stone which was there
in the meat shop in the house of Harbans and that
stone was just outside that shop. On that issue of
weapon sharpening on that stone earlier also there
had been exchange of words between Narender
and Harbans. On the date of incident Harbans was
present in his shop. Harbans objected to Narender
sharpening his chura on the stone, Narender
started calling abuses to Harbans. Meanwhile
Balender, accused today present in court who is
the father of accused Narender also arrived on the
spot and Balender caught hold of Harbans from his
back side and gave an exhortation "aaj iska kaam
tamam karke roj roj ka jhanjath khamtam karde". I
tried to intervene and then Narender gave me a
push and I fell on the ground. Narende with an
intention to kill Harbans caused Injury by chura as
a stab in the abdomen of Harbans. On hearing the
noise persons from neighbourhood collected. Both
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
accused tried to run away. Narender was caught
by the public persons but Balender succeeded to
run away. I alongwith Murari and Sanjay lifted
Harbans and took him to GTB hospital.”
PW-3 -Murari
“I am employed with MCD. Deceased Harbans
was my brother and he was residing in my
adjoining house 487. Incident is of 10.09.2012 and
it was around 5pm. I am employed with MOD.
Deceased Harbans was my brother and he was
residing in my adjoining house A87. Incident is of
10.09.2012 and it was around 5pm. I was sitting
under a tree which was around 5 to 10 paces from
my house and there was no electricity in the area
at that point of time. I saw an exchange of words
between Narender and Harbans over the issue of
sharpening of knife on the stone which was there
just outside the shop of Harbans and I identify
accused Narender today in court ( correctly
identified ). Meanwhile Balender accused today
present in court ( correctly identified ) arrived and
caught hold of Harbans from his back side.
Accused Narender then with an intention to kill
Harbans gave a stab blow by that weapon chura
which he was holding in the abdomen of Harbans.
Narender and Balender then tried to run away but
Narender was caught hold by public persons and
Balender succeeded in running away from the spot.
Myself,Sanjay and Jitender then took Harbans to
GTB hospital and he was got admitted there.
Police arrived there and inquired facts from us and
statement of Jitender was recorded. Police then
brought me and Sanjay to the spot and there also
police inquired facts on the spot and our statement
was recorded.”
PW-4- Sanjay
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
“I am safai karamchari employed with MCD and
deceased Harbans was my cousin. Incident is of
10.09.2012 and it was around 5pm. There was no
electricity in the area at that point of time and
accordingly I was present in gali and I was sitting
under a tree. I saw accused Narender today
present in court ( correctly identified ) resident of
my locality was indulging in exchange of abuses
with my cousin Harbans. There used to be earlier
such kind of exchanges on the issue of sharpening
of weapon chura on the stone which was there
outside the shop of Harbans. Meanwhile Balender
accused today present in court (correctly
identified) also arrived there and Balender caught
hold of Harbans from back side. Narender then
with an intention to kill Harbans inflicted stab
injury by meat cutting weapon chura in the
abdomen of Harbans. Myself and other persons
ran towards the scene of the crime. Narender was
caught by the public and Balender succeeded to
run away. Myself, Murari and Jitender took
Harbans to GTB hospital and Harbans was got
admitted. After sometime police arrived and police
inquired facts from Jitender and recorded his
statement. Police then took me and Murari and we
reached the place of incident and police inquired
facts from us and our statement was recorded by
the police. I may not identify weapon chura as in
fact I had not seen it from close.”
19.
A perusal of the above extracted testimonies would show that when
the Appellant No.1 was sharpening his meat cutting knife using the stone in
front of the shop of the deceased person, the deceased picked up a quarrel by
using some abusive language which then appears to have led the Appellant
No. 2 i.e., the father of the Appellant No. 1 to exhort Appellant No. 1 to stab
the deceased person.
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
20.
Moreover, there was only one stab wound in the abdomen of the
deceased person and the MLC also proves this fact. The MLC records that
there was one wound which is described as under:
“Incised wound over centre abdomen measuring
3x1 cm, epigastrium region.”
21.
A perusal of the post mortem report also shows that while the alleged
history of physical assault is mentioned in the postmortem report, the wound
was in fact stitched and the cause of death is mentioned as:
“Cause of Death: septicemic shock due to intra
abdominal infection consequent upon stab injury.
Injury no. 1 is sufficient to cause death in ordinary
cause of nature”
22.
The MLC and the postmortem report read together would show that
the stab wound was in fact surgically dealt with at the hospital, however, the
wound had developed infection which then eventually led to the death of the
deceased person five days after the incident.
23.
In the opinion of the Court, there was no pre-meditated plan of the
Appellants to kill the deceased person. The provocation appears to have
happened due to some abusive language used by the deceased person against
the Appellant No. 1.
24.
The present case would, therefore, be one where the evidence would
show that it was due to the altercation which took place between the
Appellant No.1 and the deceased person that the stabbing occurred. In the
opinion of the Court, the same was due to a grave and sudden provocation.
25.
The settled position of law, as is clear from the principles highlighted
in the judgment of PulicherlaNagaraju v. State of A.P. (2006) 11 SCC 444,
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
is that the intention of the accused is a pivotal question in deciding whether
the case falls under Sections 302, 304 Part I or 304 Part II of IPC. Further, to
gather the accused’s intention to cause death, a perusal of the following
circumstances are essential:
“29. Therefore, the court should proceed to decide
the pivotal question of intention, with care and
caution, as that will decide whether the case falls
under Section 302 or 304 Part I or 304 Part II.
Many petty or insignificant matters — plucking of
a fruit, straying of cattle, quarrel of children,
utterance of a rude word or even an objectionable
glance, may lead to altercations and group clashes
culminating in deaths. Usual motives like revenge,
greed, jealousy or suspicion may be totally absent
in such cases. There may be no intention. There
may be no premeditation. In fact, there may not
even be criminality. At the other end of the
spectrum, there may be cases of murder where the
accused attempts to avoid the penalty for murder
by attempting to put forth a case that there was no
intention to cause death. It is for the courts to
ensure that the cases of murder punishable under
Section 302, are not converted into offences
punishable under Section 304 Part I/II, or cases
of culpable homicide not amounting to murder,
are treated as murder punishable under Section
302. The intention to cause death can be gathered
generally from a combination of a few or several
of the following, among other, circumstances: (i)
nature of the weapon used; (ii) whether the
weapon was carried by the accused or was picked
up from the spot; (iii) whether the blow is aimed
at a vital part of the body; (iv) the amount of force
employed in causing injury; (v) whether the act
was in the course of sudden quarrel or sudden
fight or free for all fight; (vi) whether the incident
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
occurs by chance or whether there was any
premeditation; (vii) whether there was any prior
enmity or whether the deceased was a stranger;
(viii) whether there was any grave and sudden
provocation, and if so, the cause for such
provocation; (ix) whether it was in the heat of
passion; (x) whether the person inflicting the
injury has taken undue advantage or has acted in
a cruel and unusual manner; (xi) whether the
accused dealt a single blow or several blows. The
above list of circumstances is, of course, not
exhaustive and there may be several other special
circumstances with reference to individual cases
which may throw light on the question of intention.
Be that as it may.”
26.
As per the judgment discussed above if there is no premeditation, the
case would get covered under Exception 4 of Section 300 IPC. This position
of law is further reiterated in a judgment of the Supreme Court in Ankush
Shivaji Gaikwad v. State of Maharashtra, (2013) 6 SCC 770, wherein the
death was caused by an iron pipe due to exchange of hot words in a heated
situation. The Supreme Court in the said judgment held that whenever there
is a sudden fight without premeditation, it cannot be held to be an offence
under Section 302. The relevant portion of the judgment has been extracted
below:
“3. The prosecution story is that the appellant,
Ankush Shivaji Gaikwad accompanied by Madhav
Shivaji Gaikwad (Accused 2) and Shivaji Bhivaji
Gaikwad (Accused 3) were walking past the field of
the deceased when a dog owned by the deceased
started barking at them. Angered by the barking of
the animal, the appellant is alleged to have hit the
dog with the iron pipe that he was carrying in his
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
hand. The deceased objected to the appellant
beating the dog, whereupon the appellant started
abusing the former and told him to keep quiet or
else he too would be beaten like a dog. The
exchange of hot words, it appears, led to a scuffle
between the deceased and the accused persons in
the course whereof, while Accused 2 and 3 beat the
deceased with fist and kicks, the appellant hit the
deceased with the iron pipe on the head.
xxxx
11. It was argued that the incident in question
took place on a sudden fight without any
premeditation and the act of the appellant hitting
the deceased was committed in the heat of passion
upon a sudden quarrel without the appellant
having taken undue advantage or acting in a
cruel or unusual manner. There is, in our
opinion, considerable merit in that contention.
We say so for three distinct reasons:
xxxx
27. Coming back to the case at hand, we are of
the opinion that the nature of the simple injury
inflicted by the accused, the part of the body on
which it was inflicted, the weapon used to inflict
the same and the circumstances in which the
injury was inflicted do not suggest that the
appellant had the intention to kill the deceased.
All that can be said is that the appellant had the
knowledge that the injury inflicted by him was
likely to cause the death of the deceased. The case
would, therefore, more appropriately fall under
Section 304 Part II IPC.
xxxx
68. In the result, we allow this appeal but only to
the extent that instead of Section 302 IPC the
appellant shall stand convicted for the offence of
culpable homicide not amounting to murder
punishable under Section 304 Part II IPC and
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for
a period of five years. The fine imposed upon the
appellant and the default sentence awarded to
him shall remain unaltered. The appeal is
disposed of in the above terms in modification of
the order passed by the courts below. A copy of
this order be forwarded to the Registrars General
of the High Courts in the country for circulation
among the Judges handling criminal trials and
hearing appeals.”
27.
A similar situation was examined by the Supreme Court in Khuman
Singh v. State of M.P., (2020) 18 SCC 763, where a sudden quarrel over a
trivial issue led to a fatal injury. In that context, the Supreme Court
observed:
8. The question falling for consideration is whether
the appellant-accused intentionally caused the
death of deceased Veer Singh? The entire incident
occurred when the appellant had taken his
buffaloes for grazing in the field of the deceased
for which the deceased objected and drove all the
buffaloes out of his field. It is in these
circumstances, the appellant became furious and
abused the deceased and caused injuries on his
head in a sudden fight with axe. There was no
premeditation for the occurrence and because of
the grazing of the cattle, in a sudden fight, the
occurrence had taken place.
9. The question to be considered is whether the
act of the appellant-accused would fall under
Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC? Exception 4 to
Section 300 IPC can be invoked if death is caused
: (a) without premeditation; (b) in a sudden fight;
(c) without the offender having taken undue
advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual manner;
and (d) the fight must have been with the person
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
killed. In the present case, the appellant-accused
and the deceased exchanged wordy abuses on
which, the appellant gave the deceased blows on
his head causing six head injuries. Where the
occurrence took place suddenly and there was no
premeditation on the part of the accused, it falls
under Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC.
10. As discussed earlier, the entire incident was in
a sudden fight in which the appellant-accused
caused head injuries on the deceased with an axe.
There was no prior deliberation or determination
to fight. The sudden quarrel arose between the
parties due to trivial issue of grazing the buffaloes
of the appellant for which, the deceased raised
objection. In a sudden fight, the appellant had
inflicted blows on the head of the deceased with an
axe which caused six head injuries. Though the
weapon used by the appellant was axe and the
injuries were inflicted on the vital part of the body
viz. head, knowledge is attributable to the
appellant-accused that the injuries are likely to
cause death. Considering the fact that the
occurrence was in a sudden fight, in our view, the
occurrence would fall under Exception 4 to
Section 300 IPC. The conviction of the appellantaccused under Section 302 IPC is therefore to be
modified as conviction under Section 304 Part II
IPC.
28.
In view of the above discussion, since there was no pre-meditation to
cause death of the deceased person and considering the evidence in this
matter as also the cause of death in the postmortem report and there being
only one stab wound, this Court is of the opinion that in the facts of the
present case, while the Appellants are guilty of causing death of the
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
deceased person, the same would constitute culpable homicide not
amounting to murder.
29.
Accordingly, the conviction of the Appellants is converted to Section
304 Part II of the IPC and the sentence of the Appellant No. 1 is reduced to
7 (seven) years and the sentence of the Appellant No. 2 is reduced to 5 (five)
years.
30.
The Appellants shall serve the remainder of the sentences awarded
today as per law.
31.
The Appeals are disposed of in the above terms. Pending applications,
if any, are also disposed of.
32.
A copy of this order be sent to the concerned Jail Superintendent by
the Registry.
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
MADHU JAIN
JUDGE
JANUARY 15, 2026
dk/b/ck
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
10:52:02
CRL.A. 1599/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review