Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present :- Hon’ble Justice Amrita Sinha
WPA 23837 of 2024
Narayan Chandra Kuiry & Ors.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the writ petitioners
:-
Mr. Rudranil De, Adv.
Mr. Soumo Charan, Adv.
For the State
:-
Mr. Rajarshi Basu, Adv.
Mr. Ananda Dulal Sarkar, Adv.
Heard on
:-
27th March, 2026.
Judgment on
:-
27th March, 2026.
Amrita Sinha, J.:1.
The petitioners, seven in number, were deployed as Special Police
Officers (in short, ‘SPOs’) by the Deputy Superintendent of Police
(Headquarters), Purulia in the year 2012. They were required to guard trains
throughout the day and night, especially in the Left Wing Extremist (in short
‘LWE’) affected areas.
2.
They have filed the instant writ petition in September 2024 with
the allegation that they have been illegally and arbitrarily disengaged from
service with effect from 1st August, 2023. A representation was addressed to
the Officer-in-Charge of Bagmundi Police Station on 19th June, 2024 with a
request to permit them to join service. As there was no response from the
end of the respondent authority, the instant writ petition has been filed.
3.
It has been submitted that thirty SPOs were appointed on the same
day. All thirty of them were demobilized but thereafter the authority, for
reasons best known, permitted nineteen of them to re-join duty but the rest
eleven of them were not allowed to join. Out of the eleven, the instant writ
petition has been filed by seven.
4.
It has been submitted that the reason for not permitting the
petitioners to resume duty has never been disclosed. The State cannot
discriminate between two similarly circumstanced persons. If the authority
permitted nineteen SPOs to re-join duty, the authority ought to have
permitted the balance eleven to re-join on the same date. The petitioners
allege discrimination by the authority.
5.
In support of the submission that the State ought not to
discriminate between two similarly circumstanced persons, learned advocate
for the petitioners relies on the judgment delivered by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the matter of Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi & Ors. v. State of U.P.
& Ors. reported in (1991) 1 SCC 212 wherein the Court held that the
requirement of complying with Article 14 should extend even in the sphere of
contractual matters for regulating the conduct of the State. The requirement
of Article 14 is the duty to act fairly, justly and reasonably.
6.
As regards the issue of regularization, learned advocate for the
petitioners relies on the judgment delivered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the matter of Jaggo v. Union of India & Ors. reported in 2024 INSC 1034
wherein the Court held that it is imperative for Government departments to
lead by example in providing fair and stable employment. Engaging workers
on a temporary basis for extended periods, especially when their roles are
integral to the organization's functioning, not only contravenes international
labour standards but also exposes the organization to legal challenges and
undermines employee morale. By ensuring fair employment practices,
Government institutions can reduce the burden of unnecessary litigation,
promote job security, and uphold the principles of justice and fairness that
are meant to embody.
7.
It has been argued that the petitioners were in service for a
considerable period of time on and from the year 2012 till they were
disallowed to join in September 2024. The work in which they were engaged
is perennial in nature. Instead of regularizing them in service, the authority
has, with mala fide intension, restrained them from joining duty.
8.
The petitioners pray for a direction upon the respondents to permit
them to join their respective duties and to regularize them in service.
9.
Learned advocate representing the State respondents opposes the
prayer of the petitioners. The report filed by the Superintendent of Police,
Purulia signed on 23rd September, 2024 is relied upon.
10.
On a perusal of the report, it appears that the SPOs were deployed
to guard the railway tracks in the interest of passengers’ security on
Kharagpur-Medinipur-Adra and Kharagpur-Tatanagar (West Bengal portion)
rail route. The SPOs were getting their honorarium of Rs.3,000/- per month
from the Security Related Expenditure Scheme of the Ministry of Home
Affairs. The SPOs were engaged among the active sources of the LWE police
stations. They were to provide information about the activities of LWE
throughout the rail route and keep the police informed about the local input
in connection with subversive activities of the relevant area. Their
deployment was purely contractual for a specific purpose to deal with the
situation necessitated at the material point of time.
11.
A report was submitted by the Sub-Divisional Police Officer,
Jhalda, Purulia before the Superintendent of Police, Purulia against thirtysix SPOs deployed under the Bagmundi and Joypur Police Stations. The said
SPOs were found to be indisciplined, reluctant and irregular in their duties.
They were reluctant to perform their assigned task and failed to collect and
provide any information about LWE activities which was their primary duty.
12.
The Sub-Divisional Police Officer, Jhalda, Purulia requested the
Superintendent of Police, Purulia to demobilize them for their unsatisfactory
performance/inactivity of duty and proposed to deploy new local youths
having good reputation in the locality and good connection in ground level
for the same purpose.
13.
Relying on the aforesaid report of the Sub-Divisional Police Officer,
Jhalda, the Superintendent of Police, Purulia disengaged the thirty-six SPOs
from the month of August 2023. After disengagement, the activities of the
said SPOs were reviewed. On review, it was found that only twenty of them
may be reengaged upon caution. Accordingly, twenty SPOs were cautioned to
perform their duty without any negligent attitude. The said twenty SPOs
were specifically briefed about their duties namely:1.
To guard the railway track with a view to ensure safety of
passengers traveling in train as the police station has been
considered as LWE affected.
2.
Collect the intelligence on ground level in connection with safety
and security of railway track in LWE affected areas.
3.
To collect the information of the local area and pass on the same
to the Officer in Charge, Bagmundi police station for safety and
security of railway track.
4.
To track the movement of LWE cadres throughout the railway
route and keep the local police informed accordingly.
14.
Identity cards were issued from the concerned police stations to
the SPOs to avoid harassment from the railways or other authority during
their duty period on the rail route. Rest of the demolilized SPOs was found to
be extremely casual and they lacked required potential to collect information
for prevention of subversive activities along the railway track. Their reluctant
attitude, negligent conduct and irregular presence at the assigned duty do
not suit the performance for which they have been deployed.
15.
It has been submitted that the petitioners fall within the said
twenty SPOs who have been demobilized because of unsatisfactory
performance. It has also been submitted that the petitioners have not made
out any case for regularization of their service. It has been denied that there
has been violation of the principle enshrined in Article 14 of the Constitution
of India.
16.
The respondents pray for dismissal of the writ petition.
17.
I have heard and considered the submissions made on behalf of
both the parties and have perused the materials placed before this Court.
18.
It appears that the petitioners were deployed as SPOs for a
particular purpose. The SPOs were primarily required to collect information
and inputs about the terrorist activities in the railway tracks with the
subject police station. The authority demobilized the petitioners as they were
unable to provide the relevant inputs and they were found to be casual and
irregular in their duties.
19.
There is no reason to engage persons who do not satisfy and/or
perform the duty for which they have been engaged. The SPOs role is very
vital for maintaining public safety and also for maintaining the safety of the
railway tracks. The petitioners have failed to deliver the work that they were
supposed to perform.
20.
Even after demobilization of their service, the authorities reviewed
the performance of the demobilized SPOs and have re-appointed several of
them who, according to the authority, were in a position to serve the purpose
for which they were engaged. Even on review of the performance of the
petitioners, the respondents were not satisfied to re-engage them.
21.
Jaggo (supra) deals with the regularization of temporary or
contractual employees. The petitioners have miserably failed to make out a
case for regularization. The petitioners’ performance has been found to be
absolutely satisfactory for which they were demobilized from service. There is
no question of regularizing any person who has been found to be unfit for
the job for which he has been engaged.
22.
In Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi (supra), the Court emphasized the
role of the State in following the principles of Article 14 of the Constitution.
23.
On a perusal of the facts and circumstances of the instant case, it
does not appear that there has been violation of Article 14 of the
Constitution in any manner whatsoever. It is only because of the
unsatisfactory performance of the petitioners and their indisciplined and
casual attitude during their work that led to their demobilization. The same
cannot be said to be in violation of Article 14 of the Constitution.
24.
The
petitioners
ought
to
appreciate
that
they
were
paid
remuneration for the service they rendered to the State. The petitioners
cannot expect the authority to keep them in the roll of the State without
providing any service. The entire security system of the railway track and the
passengers will be at stake if proper information, in right time, does not
reach the authority. SPOs act as valuable informers to the police.
25.
The area in question is dreaded for its extremist and terrorist
activities. To curb such menace which interferes with the day to day
functioning of the common people and stands in the way of growth and
development of the area, the SPOs were deployed. It makes no sense to pay
somebody without getting any service. As collecting information is essential
to prevent any notorious activity and maintain peace and normalcy in the
area, the authority has rightly demobilized the inefficient ones by retaining
and appointing the better ones.
26.
In view of the discussion made hereinabove, the Court is unable to
accept the prayer of the petitioners to either permit them to re-join or direct
the authority to regularize them in their service. If the Court entertains the
prayer of the petitioners, then the authority will have to depend upon SPOs
who are unable to deliver their work and the very purpose of their
engagement will be defeated. The safety and security of the railway tracks
and the passengers availing such facility will be highly infringed and
valuable life and property will be at peril.
27.
The Court is not inclined to exercise jurisdiction in the matter.
28.
The writ petition fails and is hereby dismissed.
29.
All parties shall act on the basis of a server copy of this order duly
downloaded from the official website of this Court.
30.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance of all requisite formalities.
(Amrita Sinha, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review