Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Non-reportable
IN THE COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
CRP (CRP Art. 227) No. 23 of 2022
1. Shri Naorem Birendra Singh, aged about 65 years S/0 late N. Dwijamani Singh
of Luker, P0:- Langjing and PS: Patsoi, District: Imphal West, Manipur, PIN 795113.
2. Shri Wangkheimayum Somorendro Singh aged about 46 years S/O Late W.
haoba Singh of Wangkhei Lourembam Leikai, PO and PS:Porompat, District:
Imphal East, Manipur. PIN 795005.
... Petitioners/Defendants
-Versus1. Shri Khumukcham Ahanjao Singh aged about 66 years S/o Th. Tombi Singh
of Awangkhunou Mayai Leikai, PO:- Langjing and PS: Patsoi, District: Imphal
West, Manipur, PIN -795113..
2. Shri Naorem Pishak Singh, aged about 62 years S/0 late N. Dwijamani Singh
of Luker, PO:- Langjing and PS: Patsoi, District: Imphal West, Manipur, PIN 795113.
....Respondents/Plaintiffs
BEFORE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Petitioners
: Mr. N. Suresh, Advocate
For the Respondents
: Mr. M. Nabakishore, Mr. S. Jhalajit, Advocates
Date of Hearing
: 13-05-2024/16-12-2024
Date of Order
: 27-12-2024
CRP (CRP ART 227) NO. 23 OF 2022
JUDGEMENT & ORDER [CAV]
1.
This Revision petition under Art. 227 is filed against the order dated 01-
03-2022 passed in Judl Misc Case No. 37 of 2021 of the Ld. Civil Judge Senior
Division, Imphal West, Manipur whereby the application for amendment filed by
the Respondents/Plaintiffs under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 (in short, CPC) was allowed.
2.
The fact of the present Revision Petition is:(I) The Original Suit being No. 91 of 2016 before the Ld. Civil Judge
Senior Division, Imphal West, Manipur was instituted
by the
respondents/plaintiffs against the petitioners/defendants on 5th August,
2016 inter-alia praying for declaration as owner of the suit land,
cancellation of the sale deed of the suit land and for entitlement of
compensation for acquisition of the suit land for development of railway
lines. An amendment petition filed earlier prior to the present application
was also allowed. The recast plaint was also filed on 18 August, 2019.
Issues were framed on 10-09-2019. The plaintiffs also filed Examination
-in Chief of the PW. No. 1 on 21st October, 2019.
(II) The respondents/plaintiffs filed an application being Judl. Misc Case
No. 37 of 2021 on 04- 02-2022 for amendment of the plaint under order
VI Rule 17 C.P.C. for recovery of the compensation award of the
acquisition of the suit land during the pendency of the suit land without
their knowledge.
(III) The present petitioners/defendants who are Ops/respondents in
the said Judl. Misc Case No. 37 of 2021 have filed their Written objection
CRP (CRP ART 227) NO. 23 OF 2022
on 18th February, 2022 stating that the proposed amendment will
change the nature of the suit and heard the matter on the same day.
3.
It is stated that vide the impugned order dated 01-04-2022 in the Judl.
Misc Case No. 37 of 2021, the amendment was allowed after commencement of
trial thereby changing the true character of the suit.
4.
In another Judl. Misc Case No. 292 of 2020, the present Respondents/
Plaintiffs prayed to recover the amount mentioned in the amendment portion.
The Ld. Trial Court decided the case on 19th January, 2021 as " It is also seen
that the question of compensation and others under the Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 2013 does not lies under the jurisdiction of this Court. In any
case, ample measures to ensure the recovery of amount awarded as
compensation if the suit is declared in his favour and he is declared as the owner
of the suit land."
5.
The petitioners/defendants, being aggrieved by the impugned order dated
01/03/ 2022 passed in the J.M. Case No. 37 of 2021 Ref :- 0.S. 91 of 2016, beg
to prefer this revision Petition under Article 227 on the following grounds among
others:GROUNDS
A. for that the Original Suit No. 91 of 2016 before the Ld. Civil Judge
Senior Division, Imphal West is a Declaratory Suit under Section 34 of
the Specific Relief Act, 1963 with consequence relief of Suit Value at Rs.
21,000/- (Rupees Twenty- one Thousand) only.
Whereas, the allowed amendment which to be inserting as Para 17 (IV)
is that "a decree for recovery a sum of Rs. 19,06,896.70p ( Rupees
CRP (CRP ART 227) NO. 23 OF 2022
nineteen lakh six thousand eight hundred ninety six and paise seventy)
only from defendant No. 1 and a sum of Rs.29,06,896.70 p from
defendant No. 2 which was withdrawn by them respectively as
Compensation amount of the suit land."
That, the recovery suit is governed by Section 7 of Specific Relief Act
which a different character of the suit. Thus, the present amendment
has changed the character of the suit.
B. for that the recovery of money, the suit value should be same as the
recoverable amount under Section 7(i) of the Court Fees Act, 1870. In
the said suit, the suit value is only Rs. 21, 000/-, which become
undervalue with the amendment. The Ld. Trial Court adopted such
illegality.
C. for that the amendment portion in the impugned order is an act after
filing of the suit and not a controversy between the parties and need not
to be determine in the suit.
D. for that the amendment portion allowed in the impugned order is
against the order dated 19th January, 2021 passed in Judl. Misc Case
No. 292 of 2020 Ref : Original Suit No 91 of 2016 of the same referred
Original Suit of the impugned order. The Plaintiffs are not declared as
owner of the suit land till date.
E. For that the Ld. Trial Court passed an erroneous and inconsistent order
that is very contrary with the order dated 19th January, 2021 in Judl Misc
Case No. 292/2020 of the same Suit.
F. for that there is no grounds that the Plaintiffs could not have raised
the amendment matter before the commencement of Trial.
CRP (CRP ART 227) NO. 23 OF 2022
6.
Hence this petition to set aside/quash the impugned order in respect of
Judl Misc Case No. 37 of 2021 and an interim order for staying the operation of
impugned order dated 01/ 03/2022 passed in Judl Misc Case No. 37 of 2021.
7.
While issuing notice vide order dated 27-05-2022, this Court stayed
further proceedings of OS No. 91 of 2016 before the court of learned Civil Judge,
Senior Division, Imphal West as there no consideration of the proviso to Order
VI Rule 17 CPC in the impugned order. Relevant portion reads as follows:
“Perusal of the order under revision reflects that the trial court allowed
the amendment of the plaint, ignoring the fact that the trial in the suit
had commenced as long back as in October 2019, No reference was
made to the proviso to Order VI Rule 17 CPC by the trial court . Validity
of the said order therefore requires deeper examination. There shall
accordingly be stay of all further proceedings in O.S. No. 91 of 2016 on
the file of the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Imphal West, pending
further orders”.
8.
Written objection was filed by the respondents/plaintiffs stating that the
respondents No. 1,2,3,4 and 5 are the Legal heirs of Respondent No. 1 Late
Khumukcham Ahanjao Singh who died 02/06/2022 during the pendency of the
present Revision Petition of the above referred CRP (CRP Art. 227) 23 of 2022
and the Respondent No. 2 are the Respondent/ petitioner No. 2 in the above
referred Revision Case.
9.
It is submitted that the respondents/plaintiffs denied the allegation that
the amendment allowed in the Judl. Misc Case No. 37 of 2021 after the
commencement of trial has changed the character of the suit.
10.
The respondents/plaintiffs have submitted that there is a pending suit for
title of the suit land and accordingly the respondent/plaintiffs filed the said Judl.
Misc case for hold in/held up/ to seized the bank account of the Petitioner No.
1 & 2 which was wrongly withdraw the compensation amount during the
CRP (CRP ART 227) NO. 23 OF 2022
pendency of suit for title suit of the said agricultural land and now involved the
subject matter of the case but the Hon'ble Court ample measure to ensure the
recovery of amount awarded as compensation if the suit is decreed in his
(Respondent No. 1) favour and he is declared as the owner of the suit land.
11.
It is submitted that, the suit i.e. O.S 91 of 2016 of Civil Judge Senior
Division lmphal West filed by the respondents/plaintiffs is also suit for a decree
declaring that the compensation amount of the suit land is entitled to the plaintiff
No.1 (Respondent No. 1 in the present case) as well as the plaintiff No. 2
(Respondent no. 2 in the present Case) who are the possessors of the suit land.
Whereas the Respondents filed their suit in the year 2016, the concerned
authority i.e. Land Collector Imphal West released the compensation amount of
the suit land but during pandemic of covid-19 period in the year 2020, the
petitioners and some official staffs of the Land Collector in collusion with and
withdrew the said compensation amount with the strength of a false/ fraud
compromise decree in O.S. No. 83 of 2016 without any right, title or authority
of the suit land, even though there is pending suit as O.S No. 91 of 2016 the
title Suit of the suit land. The petitioners/defendants were also contested the
said suit by filing their written statement. They have full knowledge of the case.
So, it is very much necessary to amend the plaint of the respondents/plaintiffs
for the end of justice. There is no change in the character of the suit.
12.
Mr. N. Suresh, learned counsel for the petitioners/defendants submits that
by the impugned order allowing amendment in the prayer portion, a new cause
has been introduced. It is urged that the relief for recovery of the compensation
award was not pleaded earlier and such a prayer cannot be introduced when
the suit is at the stage of examination of plaintiffs’ witnesses. It is also pointed
out that the valuation of the suit was for only Rs.21,000/- and court fee for this
CRP (CRP ART 227) NO. 23 OF 2022
amount only was paid by the plaintiffs and with the introduction of new prayer,
the valuation of suit has exceeded a sum of rupees nineteen lakhs and hence
the suit become undervalued. It is further pleaded that the impugned order is
against the order dated 19-01-2021 passed by the trial Court in Judl. Misc. Case
No. 292 of 2020 filed by the plaintiffs, where they would have ample opportunity
to recover the compensation amount, if they have been declared as owner of
the suit land. Learned counsel for the petitioners refers to the decision in the
case of LIC v. Sanjeev Builders (P) Ltd., (2022) 16 SCC 1: where Hon’ble
Supreme Court observed that amendment of pleading shall be allowed liberally,
but time barred relief cannot be introduced by way of amendment.
“18. It is well settled that the court must be extremely liberal in granting the
prayer for amendment, if the court is of the view that if such amendment is
not allowed, a party, who has prayed for such an amendment, shall suffer
irreparable loss and injury. It is also equally well settled that there is no
absolute rule that in every case where a relief is barred because of limitation,
amendment should not be allowed. It is always open to the court to allow an
amendment if it is of the view that allowing of an amendment shall really
subserve the ultimate cause of justice and avoid further litigation.”
It is prayed that the impugned order dated 01-03-2022 passed by learned
Civil Judge, Senior Division, Imphal West in Judl. Misc. Case No. 37 of 2021 be
set aside.
13.
Per contra, Mr. M. Nabakishore, learned counsel for the respondents/
plaintiffs draws the attention of this Court to the prayer portion in the plaint
where the plaintiffs have claimed a relief to the effect that they are entitled to
the land compensation award of the suit land at para 17(iii) of the plaint. It is
clarified that at the time of the filing of the suit, the amount of award could not
be ascertained and the petitioners/defendants withdrew the amount during the
pendency of the suit without the knowledge of the petitioners. It is highlighted
CRP (CRP ART 227) NO. 23 OF 2022
that the amendment is sought to bring on record the subsequent development
and if the same is not allowed the plaintiffs will suffer immensely. It is also
clarified that the proposed amendment does not fall within the vice of the
proviso to Order VI Rule 17 CPC. Learned counsel relies a decision of this Court
in the case of Shri Paokholam Kipgen v. Thangjangam Kipgen [Order
dated 24-11-2015 in CRP(CRP ART. 227) No. 17 of 2013 holding that
amendment can be allowed if the same does not change the nature and
character of the suit. It is further explained that the deficient court fees, if any,
can be directed to be paid later on. It is prayed that the present petition under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India be dismissed being devoid of any merit.
14. For ready reference prayer in O.S No. 91/2016 and purpose Amendment of
prayer as made in Judl Misc Case No. 37 of 2021 are reproduced below :
Main prayer in O.S No. 91/2016
17. That, the suit is valued at Rs. 21,000/- for the purpose of jurisdiction
and Ad-valorem Court fee of Rs. 1238.25 is paid here with under section 7
(iv) (c) of the Court Fees Act. 1870 as extended to the state of Manipur.
That the plaintiff therefore claims :
(i) a decree declaring that the plaintiff was the owner of the suit land
under Patta No. 76/18/5. 76/56 (old)/ 421/580 (New) covered by C.S.
Dag No. 34/414/469, measuring an area of .62 acre situated at 76Salam Keikhu and the plaintiff No. 2 is the possessor of the suit land
which was acquired by the State Government secretariat: Revenue
Department vide Notification No. 4/15/LA/2014-Com (Rev) at S.No. 36
of 76-Salam Keikhu Village Sheet No. 1 dated 8th September, 2015 for
the construction of New B.G Railway line between Tupul to Imphal
Section of Jiribam - Imphal Project Phase - I.
(ii) A decree declaring that the Regd. sale deed bearing Regn. No. 2122,
dated 12/6/2014 in the Office of the Sub-Registrar, (HQ) Imphal,
CRP (CRP ART 227) NO. 23 OF 2022
Manipur executed by defendant No. 1 in favour of the defendant No. 2
is illegal and not binding on the plaintiffs and hence cancelled;
(iii) a decree declaring that the compensation amount of the suit land is
entitled to the plaintiff No. 1, as well as the plaintiff No. 2 who is the
possessor of the suit land.
(iv) to issue a perpetual injunction restraining the defendant No. 1 and
the defendant No. 2 and their men and privies from withdrawal of
compensation amount of the suit land with an ex- parte temporary
injunction of the same matter while pending of the suit;
(v) a decree of such other reliefs as this Hon'ble Court deems fit and
proper from time to time.
"Purpose Amendment" in Judl. Misc. Case No. 37/2021
"That During the pendency of the suit the defendant No.1 and the
defendant No.2 without any right, title and/or authority and also without
any order/orders of the Hon'ble Court if any for withdrawal of the
compensation amount of Rs. 48,13,794.40p. of the said agricultural land
mentioned above (suit land in the present case) was withdrawn by
concealing the real fact of the case through their bank account being
account No. 0484011103890 of UBI Paona Bazar, Imphal of Naorem
Birendra Singh Defendant No.1 of Rs. 19,06,896.70p and bank account
being Account No. 909010039192340 of Axis Bank Thangal Bazar,
Imphal of W. Somendro Singh (Defendant No.2) of Rs. 29,06,896.70 p.
total a sum of Rs. 48,13, 794.40p. by and an order dated 19th
September, 2020 of the collector Land Acquisition, Imphal West,
Manipur."
The Hon’ble Court be pleased further to allow the relief claim(VI) in para
No.17 by inserting as para No 17 (VI) that "a decree for recovery a sum
of Rs. 19,06,896.70 p. (Rupees nineteen lakh six thousand eight hundred
ninety six and paise seventy) only from defendant No.1 and a sum of Rs.
29,06,896.70 p from defendant No.2 which was withdrawn by them
respectively as compensation amount of the suit land."
CRP (CRP ART 227) NO. 23 OF 2022
15.
This Court considers the materials on record, the submissions made at
bar and the relevant law in this regard. The short question involved in the
present case is whether the impugned order allowing new prayer for recovery
of compensation award withdrawn by the defendants during the pendency of
the suit would change the nature and character of the suit.
16.
From a bare reading of the plaint specially the prayer portion at para 17,
it is seen that the plaintiffs have made a relief at para 17(iii) for a decree
declaring them entitle to the compensation amount of the suit land under their
possession. At the time of the filing of the suit, the amount was not ascertained
nor did the defendants withdraw the same. It is an admitted fact that the
compensation award was withdrawn by the defendants during the pendency of
the present suit without the knowledge of the plaintiffs on the basis of a
compromise decree between the defendants, in which the plaintiffs were not
impleaded. In such circumstances and due to the subsequent event of
withdrawal of the award, the plaintiffs filed the amendment application for
introduction of the new relief for recovery of compensation amount from the
defendants. Otherwise, the plaintiffs will not have any opportunity of recovering
the said amount.
17.
This Court is of the view that the proposed amendment will not be covered
by the proviso to Order VI Rule 17 CPC, as the relief prayed for by way of
amendment for recovery of compensation amount from the defendants was not
in existence at the time of filing of the suit. Hence, the plaintiffs could not have
raised this relief at the time of filing of the suit.
18.
On close scrutiny of the proposed amendment of prayer for recovery of
compensation amount and the main prayer for declaration to entitlement of
compensation to the plaintiffs for the acquisition of suit land under their
CRP (CRP ART 227) NO. 23 OF 2022
possession, there is no doubt that the nature of the suit will not be changed
drastically. Rather, it is an ancillary relief to the main relief at para 17(iii) of the
plaint.
19.
In view of the settled position of law that amendment can be allowed
under Order VI Rule 17 CPC for doing complete justice, if the same does not
change the nature of the suit, this Court is of the opinion that there is no error
in the impugned order. Accordingly, the petition under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India is dismissed. Interim order dated 27-05-2022 passed by
this Court staying the proceedings of OS No. 91 of 2016 pending before the
court of learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Imphal West is vacated. The suit
may be proceeded expeditiously without affecting other pending cases. No cost.
20.
Send a copy of this order to the court of learned Civil Judge, Senior
Division, Imphal West for information and proceeding as per law.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
suchitra
signed by
RAJKUMAR Digitally
RAJKUMAR PRIYOJIT
PRIYOJIT SINGH
Date: 2024.12.27
SINGH
13:53:03 +05'30'
CRP (CRP ART 227) NO. 23 OF 2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review