The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. The judgment of Associate Builders (supra) relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioner on the proposition that a perverse award should be set aside under Section 34 of the Act is of no avail.
18. No case is made out for interference under Section 34 of the Act. The petition is dismissed. The award is upheld.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 19.05.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 25.05.2026
+
O.M.P. (COMM) 448/2024
NANDINI ENTERPRISING
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Bipin Kr. Prabhat, Mr.
Ashok Kr. Verma, Mr. Kislaya
Prabhat & Ms. Rinku Kumari,
Advs.
versus
RAJASTHAN CO OPERATIVE GROUP HOUSING
SOCIETY LTD AND ANR
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Karunesh Tandon, Mr.
Sarthak Mittal & Mr. Prabin
Mohan, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN
JUDGMENT
1.
This petition is filed under Section 34 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short „the Act‟) impugning the award
dated 30.05.2024.
2.
The relevant facts, discerned from the record, reveal that the
respondent in May 2017, invited tenders for building repairing and
paint of exterior surface and rainwater harvesting pits at its premises at
Plot No. 36, Sector-4, Dwarka, New Delhi vide order dated
11.05.2017 (for short 'the work order').The petitioner was the
successful bidder and Letter of Award (LOA) dated 23.06.2017 was
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 448/2024
ARORA
15:04:48
issued for total contract value of Rs.48,00,000/-(forty-eight lakhs).The
work was to be completed within six months from 01.07.2017, i.e., by
31.12.2017. It was agreed between the parties that the work was to be
jointly measured and payment was to be made on the basis of joint
measurement.
2.1
As on 30.12.2017, the petitioner had raised its first Running
Account bill (for short 'RA bill') for Rs.9,58,591/-, which on
verification and joint measurement stood reduced to Rs.7,98,320/-.
Vide letter dated 24.01.2018, the respondent intimated the petitioner
that the progress of work was slow on account of under-deployment of
labour and called upon to expedite completion. Vide letter dated
05.02.2018, the petitioner sought extension of time for completion till
31.05.2018 but time was extended till 01.03.2018. The extended
deadline was also not met. In all, the petitioner raised five RA bills
aggregating
to
Rs.59,37,023/-
against
which
payments
of
Rs.49,19,907/- (forty-nine lakhs nineteen thousand nine hundred and
seven) were made on the basis of jointly measurement.
2.2
The respondent terminated the contract on 10.04.2019 and got
the remaining work completed through third parties. The petitioner
submitted a sixth final RA bill dated 16.04.2019 for Rs. 2,58,78,656/(two crores fifty-eight lakhs seventy eight thousand six hundred and
fifty-six). Dispute arose between the parties and the petitioner on
24.07.2020 invoked arbitration as per clause 28 of the work order.
Arbitration proceedings culminated in the award dated 30.05.2024,
dismissing the claims of the petitioner. Hence, the present petition.
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 448/2024
ARORA
15:04:48
3.
Learned counsel for the respondent appearing on advance notice
submits that no reply is required to be filed and the learned counsel for
the parties requested to hear the matter on merits.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner argues that the arbitrator
erred in holding that the sixth final RA bill for an amount of
Rs.2,58,78,656/- was improbable. It is contended that Clause 21 of the
work order stipulates that quantity shown in the schedule of items is
tentative and payment will be made on the basis of actual work done
and joint measurement. It is submitted that despite submission of the
final bill, no measurement was undertaken by the respondent. It is
argued that production of bill is an evidence of the work done.
4.1
The contention is that the arbitrator wrongly concluded in
respect of claim nos. 2&3 that breach of contract was attributable to
the petitioner. Reliance is on the decision in Associate Builders v.
Delhi Development Authority (2015) 3 SCC 49 to contend that the
award was passed without considering evidence on record and thus
suffers from perversity and is liable to be set aside under Section 34 of
the Act.
5.
Per contra, against the total contract value of Rs.48,00,000/-
(forty-eight lakhs), the petitioner received payments aggregating to
Rs.49,19,907/- (forty-nine lakhs nineteen thousand nine hundred and
seven). It is submitted that respondent carried out measurements of the
work done and after quantifying the work done the amount was paid.
It is canvassed that the petitioner raised claim in counterblast to
termination of work by the respondent.
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 448/2024
ARORA
15:04:48
5.1
The plea is that the arbitrator rightly rejected the claim no.1 for
Rs.2,58,78,656/- and no evidence was adduced by the petitioner to
show that additional work was done.
6.
Before proceeding further it would be apposite to reproduce
Clauses 7, 17 and 21 of the work order:“Clause 7: Tenderer are requested to visit the society
before quoting their offer. Conditional tenders will not be
entertained / accepted.
Clause 17: The name and address of the skilled/ unskilled workers deployed should be insured and the
contractor will have to submit a copy of the same to the
Society. All the labourers and supervisors may have to
keep Identity Cards at the site.
Clause 21: Quantity shown in the column of the schedule
of items of all sections are tentative. The payment shall
be made on actual measurement‟s to be carried out jointly
with the authorized member by the Management
Committee and Project Committee.”
7.
The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the
arbitrator erred in rejecting the claim for additional work done and that
the production of a bill is evidence for the work done lacks merit.
Reliance on clause 21 of the work order to argue that quantities shown
therein are tentative does not enhance the case of the petitioner. No
evidence was produced to establish that the scope of work was varied
and the petitioner executed additional work.
8.
The petitioner claimed a final bill of more than two crores
against a contract value of rupees forty-eight lakhs and this claim was
raised after receiving an amount of more than rupees forty-nine lakhs
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 448/2024
ARORA
15:04:48
towards five RA bills.
9.
The arbitrator recorded a factual finding that the chart of
statement of claim inspired no confidence and was not supported by
the record. It would be relevant to note that the petitioner claimed
additional work to the tune of 627.63 sq. metres for 15 mm cement
plaster on rough side of single or half brick wall. This work was
specifically denied by the respondent and the defence set up was that
the petitioner was supposed to cover the execution with a
waterproofing compound but had not executed this work. The defence
of the respondent was neither addressed to in the rejoinder nor
contradicted by documents. The arbitrator after considering the facts
and circumstances of the case recorded detailed findings for rejecting
the claim for sixth RA bill.
10.
A chart tabulating additional quantities and extra items
produced before the arbitrator remains unsubstantiated. No evidence
was adduced for the cost incurred towards procurement of these items,
no tax invoices or bills were produced and most importantly no prior
approval of the respondent or the confirmation of the work done was
placed on record. The claim for additional work thus rested entirely on
a self-serving chart unsupported by documentary proof.
11.
The work order provided for the joint measurement of the work
done. The petitioner failed to produce the joint measurement in
support of the claim made. During the proceedings on a specific query
by the arbitrator, the petitioner admitted that joint measurement
register was not maintained. The petitioner miserably failed to prove
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 448/2024
ARORA
15:04:48
that the scope of work was varied or increased and the additional work
was done by the petitioner. The rejection of the claim by the arbitrator
suffers from no factual or legal error much less perversity.
12.
The challenge that the arbitrator erred in holding that the
petitioner breached the contract is noted to be rejected. The breach
was attributable to the petitioner is a factual finding recorded by the
arbitrator and it is a well settled law that the award cannot be
interfered with for every legal or factual error unless it is vitiated by
perversity.
13.
It was considered that the clause 7 of the work order stipulated a
visit to the society by the bidder before quoting the offers and that
conditional tenders will not be accepted. Though there was no
stipulated minimum number of labour to be deployed but the work
awarded was to be completed within 180 days. The issue of nondeployment of sufficient labour was highlighted by the respondent
vide letters dated 02.11.2017 and 24.01.2018. It was further
highlighted that since 26.12.2017 no civil labour was provided and
earlier to that only one and two individuals were engaged. The
grievance was re-agitated by the respondent on 14.03.2018. The
arbitrator provided an opportunity to the petitioner for proving day-today deployment of the labour but the petitioner failed to do so and
took a stand that the data was with the respondent. The arbitrator
noted that the labour was deployed by the petitioner and it is stated
that there is no record with the petitioner and data is available with the
respondent.
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 448/2024
ARORA
15:04:48
14.
The petitioner was found in breach of clause 17 of the work
order, whereunder it was obligated to provide to respondent the details
of insurance policy taken for skilled and unskilled labour deployed but
the needful was not done.
15.
The witness of the petitioner CW-1 admitted that the work was
commenced in November 2017 whereas the work was allotted on
23.06.2017. The view taken by the tribunal that delay in completion of
the work was attributable to the petitioner is plausible, moreover, that
an inadequate number of labourers was deployed is well founded and
calls for no interference.
16.
No case is made out for claiming damages towards loss of
overhead and profits due to prolongation of contract and deployment
of machinery for completion of project.
17.
The judgment of Associate Builders (supra) relied upon by the
learned counsel for the petitioner on the proposition that a perverse
award should be set aside under Section 34 of the Act is of no avail.
18.
No case is made out for interference under Section 34 of the
Act. The petition is dismissed. The award is upheld.
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J
MAY 25, 2026
„ha‟/Anjali
Reportable:- Yes
Signed By:HONEY O.M.P. (COMM) 448/2024
ARORA
15:04:48
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review