Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Reserved for judgment on : 08.10.2026
Date of pronouncement
: 16.10.2026
Date of uploading
: 16.10.2026
Whether only operative part
of the judgment is pronounced
or whether full judgment is
pronounced
: FULL.
APHC010825012017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3584]
WRIT PETITION NO: 35108 of 2017
Nagesh Marrimekala
...Petitioner
Vs.
The Registrar (Recruitment), High Court of A.P. and
Others
...Respondent(s)
**********
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
:
16th October 2026
Present:
Advocate for Petitioner:
MR.N ASWARTHA NARAYANA
Advocate for Respondent:
MR.G. VIVEKANAND
***
ORDER: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
Prayer in the present writ petition is as under:
“…. to issue a writ, order or direction, especially one in the nature
of writ of mandamus, (a) directing the Registrar (Recruitment) to produce
the answer sheets of the petitioner (Hall Ticket No. 16016) in the written
examination held in pursuance of notification No.36/16-RC, dated
16.08.2016; (b) declare that petitioner was awarded 2 marks for Q.6(b)
in Part-A and further declare that petitioner secured total 38 marks in the
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.No.35108 of 2017
written examination; (c) consequently, declare the selection of the
petitioner for the post of Civil Judge (Junior Division) in A. P. State Judicial
Service in recruitment by transfer category in preference to respondent
No.2 and 3, consequently, direct the appointment of the petitioner as Civil
Judge (Junior Division), and (d) to pass….”
2.
(a) Petitioner was working as Assistant Public Prosecutor in Judicial
Magistrate of First Class Court, Penukonda, Anantapur District.
1st
respondent issued Notification, dated 16.08.2016, for appointment to the
posts of Civil Judge (Junior Division). As per the said Notification, 43 posts
were to be filled up by direct recruitment, and 10 posts by recruitment by
transfer. Further, the notification also provided breakup of vacancies visa-vis the reservation.
(b) Petitioner applied to the post being filled up through recruitment
by transfer. Clause 5 of the Notification envisaged that candidates would
be first subjected to a screening test, which was objective type, those who
qualify shall be shortlisted in the ratio of 1:10 of available vacancies in each
category, and, thereafter, shall be allowed to take written examination.
Written examination shall carry 80 marks and viva-voce will carry 20
marks. Further, it also envisaged minimum qualifying marks in written
examination as 40% for OCs and BCs, and 30% for SCs/STs.
(c) Petitioner, upon clearing screening test, became eligible to take
written examination, held on 19.02.2017, which he attempted. Petitioner
was called to attend oral interview scheduled on 17.04.2017. Thereafter,
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.No.35108 of 2017
Notification, dated 29.04.2017, was issued, publishing provisional
selection list with list of candidates in which petitioner's name did not figure.
(d) Petitioner made application, dated 01.05.2017, under the
provisions of RTI Act for supply of copy of answer sheets of written
examination, and the same was accordingly furnished. On verification of
answer sheet, it is stated that petitioner was awarded 42 marks, whereas
immediate next candidates were awarded 43.33 and 43.48, who belong to
OC or BC. Further, petitioner also stated to have noticed that, zero marks
were awarded for Question 6 (b), though right answer was given. That
apart, there was clear overwriting, raising any amount of doubt on the
marks awarded. Had full two marks been awarded to the answer to
Question 6(b), petitioner could have secured 16 out of 40 marks in Part-A,
thus, marching ahead of immediate two candidates above him. In those
circumstances, present writ petition came to be filed.
3.
1st respondent filed detailed counter-affidavit by specifically pleading
that answer to Question No.6(b) since was found to be not relevant and on
point, the examiner rightly awarded zero marks. Further, it is also denied
that there was any correction or interpolation of marks awarded, and
evaluation of answer sheet was rightly done by the examiner, which cannot
be subjected to judicial review.
4.
Heard Mr.N.Aswartha Narayana, learned counsel for petitioner and
Mr.G. Vivekanand, learned counsel for 1st respondent.
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.No.35108 of 2017
5.
Learned counsel for petitioner strenuously contended that
evaluation of answer sheet, in particular, answer reflecting against
Question 6(b), was done in erroneous manner.
Learned counsel
contended that firstly, there is a clear overwriting of marks awarded to
aforesaid question, the examiner apparently had awarded two marks
initially, however, the same was made zero later for obvious reasons;
secondly, even otherwise, when the answer given to aforesaid question
was appropriate and on point, there is no reason for awarding zero marks,
thus, present case is one of such exceptional cases, warranting reevaluation. In support of aforesaid submission, learned counsel relied on
the judgment of Hon'ble Apex Court in Ran Vijay Singh v. State of U.P1.
6.
Conversely, learned counsel for 1st respondent contended that, in
the absence of any specific allegations of mala fides or fraud attributable
to the examiner, the wisdom of examiner in awarding marks to a particular
question, that too, if answer is on subjective consideration, cannot be
called in question. It is further submitted that the answer provided to
Question 6(b) is not relevant to the question, therefore, examiner rightly
awarded zero marks. Further, it is also denied that the examiner initially
awarded two marks and later overwrote the same as zero, thus pleaded
for dismissal of the writ petition. In support of aforesaid submissions,
reliance is placed on the very same judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in
(2018) 2 SCC 357
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.No.35108 of 2017
Ran Vijay Singh1, and judgment of Division Bench of Delhi High Court in
Prerna Gupta v. Registrar General of Delhi High Court2, appeal against
which has been dismissed by Hon’ble Apex Court in Petition for Special
Leave to Appeal (C) No.12677 of 2026, dated 08.05.2026.
7.
We have given our anxious consideration to the submissions made
by learned counsels and perused the record.
8.
The question and answer, which are subject matter of present writ
petition read as under:
“Q.6(b) How is Easement by Prescription acquired?”
“Ans: Sec.15 of easement Act deals with the Easement by prescription.
This kind of easement can be acquired by adverse possession
which create a title.
20 years for private property.
30 years for Government property.
It is enjoyed as matter of right without permission of owner.
Peacefully, openly without any interruption.”
9.
While evaluating aforesaid answer, petitioner was awarded zero
marks. Two contentions are raised - one, that there is rewriting of marks
awarded from two as zero, and the other, that examiner has awarded zero
marks despite answer being opt and on point.
10.
In order to appreciate aforesaid contentions, the scope of judicial
intervention in matters like this needs to be kept in mind. In Ran Vijay
Judgment, dt.06.02.2026, in W.P.(C) No.10517 of 2025 of Delhi High Court.
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.No.35108 of 2017
Singh1, Hon'ble Apex Court, after noticing the exposition of various
pronouncements on the subject, has summarised as under:
“30. The law on the subject is therefore, quite clear and we only
propose to highlight a few significant conclusions. They are:
30.1. If a statute, Rule or Regulation governing an examination
permits the re-evaluation of an answer sheet or scrutiny of an answer
sheet as a matter of right, then the authority conducting the examination
may permit it;
30.2. If a statute, Rule or Regulation governing an examination does
not permit re-evaluation or scrutiny of an answer sheet (as distinct from
prohibiting it) then the court may permit re-evaluation or scrutiny only if it
is demonstrated very clearly, without any “inferential process of
reasoning or by a process of rationalisation” and only in rare or
exceptional cases that a material error has been committed;
30.3. The court should not at all re-evaluate or scrutinise the answer
sheets of a candidate—it has no expertise in the matter and academic
matters are best left to academics;
30.4. The court should presume the correctness of the key answers
and proceed on that assumption; and
30.5. In the event of a doubt, the benefit should go to the examination
authority rather than to the candidate.”
11.
Applying aforesaid principles, at the outset, we find that nowhere in
the pleadings or even, for that matter, arguments advanced by learned
counsel for writ petitioner, there are any specific allegations of fraud, bias
or mala fides, attributable to the examiner. The principal grievance is that
examiner, having awarded two marks initially, later rewrote the same as
zero, and in support of the same, much pains were taken in drawing our
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.No.35108 of 2017
attention to the relevant part of answer sheet. The follow-up grievance
being, though, answer given was apt and correct, examiner incorrectly
awarded zero marks.
In our considered opinion, while exercising
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the grievances
raised above cannot be gone into and determined. It is a settled principle
of law that Courts must exercise restraint in academic matters and refrain
from substituting their own assessment for that of expert examiners.
12.
Further, the scope of judicial review, even with regard to re-
evaluation or scrutiny of answer sheet, is very restrictive, subject to
relevant rules governing the field. In rest of the cases, unless it is
demonstrated very clearly, without any inferential process of reasoning or
by a process of rationalization, and only in rare or exceptional cases that
a material error has been committed, then alone, such course of action is
permissible.
13.
Division Bench of Delhi High Court, in Prerna Gupta2, had an
occasion to consider a similar case dealing with allegations of unlawful
interpolation leading to reduction of marks at final stage of evaluation. By
following the principles laid down in Ran Vijay Singh1, contentions were
repelled; and appeal against said judgment stood dismissed vide Petition
for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No.12677 of 2026.
14.
We also notice that in the writ petition, there is no prayer made for
re-evaluation of the marks, rather, direction was sought for awarding two
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.No.35108 of 2017
marks to Question No.6(b).
This Court is not an expert to evaluate
answers and award marks, which is essentially function of academician.
15.
In view of above observations, this Court finds no justification to
award marks, having regard to autonomy of examiner, besides limitations
of judicial review. Further, as there is no provision for re-evaluation, no
direction for re-evaluation of answer sheet can be granted.
16.
Thus, writ petition is devoid of merit, and accordingly, it is dismissed.
No order as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J
cs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review