Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/FA/3392/2013
(GJHC240400502013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 3392 of 2013
With
R/CROSS OBJECTION NO. 31 of 2014
In
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 3392 of 2013
With
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 3393 of 2013
==========================================================
NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD.
Versus
NAFISA RAJU BAROT & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR PALAK H THAKKAR(3455) for the Appellant(s) No. 1
MR GC MAZMUDAR(1193) for the Defendant(s) No. 4
MR HG MAZMUDAR(1194) for the Defendant(s) No. 4
MR MTM HAKIM(1190) for the Defendant(s) No. 1
RULE SERVED for the Defendant(s) No. 2,5
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.S.SANJAY GOWDA
and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE J. L. ODEDRA
Date : 30/09/2026
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.S.SANJAY GOWDA)
1. The occurrence of an accident between a truck and a car is
not in dispute. As a result of this accident, two of the
occupants
in
the
car
were
grievously
injured.
The
occupants, therefore, proceeded to file a claim petition.
2. The Tribunal, in consideration of the evidence adduced
before it, came to the conclusion that both the driver of the
truck as well as the driver of the car, were responsible and
C/FA/3392/2013
(GJHC240400502013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
apportioned negligence to the ratio of 50:50. It, thereafter,
came to the conclusion that the claimant Nafisa Rajubhai
Barot had suffered a grievous injury and assessed the
disability at 40%. It also assessed the monthly income at
Rs.10,000/- per month and taking into consideration her
age, ultimately awarded the following sums:Rs.6,72,000/Rs.1,20,000/Rs.0,50,000/Rs.0,50,000/Rs.0,25,000/Rs.0,25,000/Rs.9,42,000/-
For future loss of income.
For actual loss of income (12
months)
For pain, shock and suffering
For medical expenses
(lumpsum)
For special diet, transportation
and attendant charges.
For enjoyment of life and other
amenities.
Total Awardable Amount
3. As far as the other occupant, i.e. the claimant Dipti Gagan
Shethi is concerned, the Tribunal found that she has
suffered, multiple fractures and assessed the disability at
35%. The Tribunal, thereafter, concluded that her income
was Rs.8000/- per month and awarded the following
sums:Rs.4,70,400/Rs.0,96,000/Rs.1,00,000/-
For future loss of income.
For actual loss of income (12
months)
For pain, shock and suffering
C/FA/3392/2013
(GJHC240400502013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
Rs.1,00,000/-
For medical expenses
(lumpsum)
For special diet, transportation
and attendant charges.
For enjoyment of life and other
amenities.
Total Awardable Amount
Rs.0,25,000/Rs.0,25,000/Rs.8,41,400/-
4. Being aggrieved by this award, the Insurer is in appeal
both on quantum and on negligence. The claimant Nafisa
Rajubhai Barot has filed a cross-objection to the appeal of
the
Insurer
and
seeking
for
enhancement
of
the
compensation awarded.
5. As far as negligence is concerned, it is the case of the
Insurer that there was clear evidence that the driver of the
truck has come out on the wrong side of the road and had
a collision with the car and it is, therefore, sought to the
contended that the apportionment of negligence to the
ratio of 50:50 was incorrect and the negligence ought to
have been apportioned only on the driver of the truck.
6. At the outset, it is to be stated here that the Insurer of the
truck has not preferred any appeal against the negligence
imputed to the driver of the truck. It is only the Insurer of
the car, who is contending that the negligence was solely
on the part of the driver of the truck. The Insurer, for the
C/FA/3392/2013
(GJHC240400502013)
reasons
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
best
known
to
it,
has
not
produced
the
chargesheet nor has it alleged that the driver of the truck
alone was chargesheeted. The Insurer basically seeks to
place reliance on the evidence of the claimants, who have
indicated that the truck had come on to the wrong side of
the road. However, if the Panchnama were to be examined,
it indicated that there was damage to the right side of the
truck as well as to the right side of the car. If this is the
resultant position, the argument that the truck had come
on to the wrong side of the road, completely cannot be
accepted. The damages indicated in the Panchanama
would indicate that there was a collision on the right side
of the respective vehicles and this would, therefore, justify
the finding of the Tribunal that both the driver of the truck
and the driver of the car were responsible in equal
measure. Consequently, the finding regarding negligence,
is affirmed.
7. As far as the quantum in relation to the compensation
payable to Nafisa Rajubhai Barot is concerned, the
Tribunal has assessed the disability at 40%.
8. The case of the claimant Nafisaben was that as a result of
the
accident,
she
had
suffered
paraplegia
and
her
C/FA/3392/2013
(GJHC240400502013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
functional disability was 100%.
9. The Tribunal has refused to accept this version on the
ground that the medical documents, which were produced,
indicated that she also had earlier problems relating to her
kidneys and ovarian cancer and, therefore, the assertion
that she had suffered 100% disability cannot be accepted.
10.
We have perused the discharge summary issued by
Bombay Hospital and Medical Research Centre in which
Nafisaben
was
admitted
between
13.03.1998
and
24.03.1998, i.e. about two months after the accident. The
notes of this discharge summary indicate that Nafisaben
had complained of an history of pain in the neck and
dragging of left foot immediately after the accident.
It is
also noticed in the notes that for the past four or five days,
she had difficulty in passing urine and radiating pain to
left shoulder. This past history recorded and the notes
would, therefore, indicate that she did suffer a serious
injury, which had a debilitating effect on her movement. In
fact, the final diagnosis indicates post disc herniation at
C3,C4 to C7 and D1, canal with stenosis most at C5 and
C6. This final diagnosis would, therefore, indicate that she
did suffer a spinal injury and it is a well known fact that if
C/FA/3392/2013
(GJHC240400502013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
there is a spinal injury, there is a resultant loss of
movement and mobility. The finding of the Tribunal that
she also had earlier medical issues and, therefore, the
accident did not relate to her immobility cannot be
accepted in the light of this final diagnosis. The earlier
history of illness was in relation to her kidneys and due to
her ovarian cancer. Obviously, these two medical issues
will not result into loss of mobility to her.
11.
We are, therefore, of the view that the disability assessed at
40% cannot be sustained and we accordingly hold that she
will be disabled to the extent of 70%.
12.
As far as the income in concerned, in the light of the
evidence adduced, the Tribunal has concluded that she
was earning a sum of Rs.10,000/- per month. In our view,
this assessment of her monthly income cannot be found
fault with and it is accordingly maintained. As Nafisaben
was aged 47 years, a Multiplier of 13 will have to be
applied and consequently towards Loss of Future Income,
since she has suffered 70% Disability, Future Prospects of
25% will have to be added to the said income, which comes
to Rs.12,500/-(Rs.10,000+25% Future Prospects). While
calculating 70% of her Disability,
the income comes to
C/FA/3392/2013
(GJHC240400502013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
Rs.8750 (12,500x0.70). Consequently, towards Loss of
Future Income the claimant would be entitled to the sum
of Rs. 13,65,000.
13.
It is brought to our notice that though certain medical bills
were produced, the Tribunal has awarded only a sum of
Rs.50,000/- on the ground that the claimant had earlier
had an history of ailments. We are satisfied that the bills
that produced are pursuant to the accident that she
suffered and the treatment that she secured after the
accident, the sum total of the medical bills will be
Rs.1,50,000/-.Therefore, in substitution of the sum of Rs.
50,000/-, a sum of Rs.1,50,000/- is awarded towards
medical expenses. The claimant was hospitalized on more
than one occasion. In all the claimant was hospitalized for
about three months. In our view, she would, therefore, be
entitled to a sum of Rs. 75,000/- towards Food, Nutrition
and Attendant Charges.
14.
Since the claimant has suffered a loss of mobility to the
extent of 70%, it would be appropriate to award a sum of
Rs.1,00,000/-towards Loss of Amenities.
15.
In all, the claimant would be entitled to the following sums:
C/FA/3392/2013
(GJHC240400502013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
Sr. Particulars
No.
1 Monthly income of the Claimant
Rs.10,000+25% Future Prospects,
comes to Rs.12,500/-.
Calculating 70% disability, the
income is determined at Rs.8750.
Taking Multiplier at 13,
the Future Loss of Income
(8750x13x12)
2 Medical Bills
3 Pain, Shock and Suffering
4 Actual Loss of Income (12 months)
3 Food, Nutrition and Attendant
charges
4 Loss of Amenities
Total Amount of compensation
Amount of compensation awarded
by the Tribunal
Enhanced amount of
Compensation
16.
Amount of
Compensation
13,65,000
1,50,000
50,000
1,20,000
75,000
1,00,000
18,60,000
9,42,000
9,18,000
As far as the quantum of compensation in respect to the
other land, i.e. the claimant Dipti Gagan Shethi is
concerned, there is no appeal by the claimant and,
therefore, the compensation awarded need not be gone
into. The appeals of the Insurer are, therefore, dismissed
and the cross-objection of the claimant Nafisa Rajubhai
Barot is allowed in part.
17.
The amounts and deposit as well as the enhanced
compensation will be made over to the claimant Nafisa
C/FA/3392/2013
(GJHC240400502013)
JUDGMENT DATED: 30/09/2026
Rajubhai Barot by way of NEFT/RTGS.
18.
The Tribunal had awarded interest at the rate of 8% per
annum. In our view, interest at the rate of 9% per annum
would be just and proper.
19.
Hence, the enhanced amount of compensation to claimant
Nafisa Rajubhai Barot, i.e. Rs.9,18,000/- shall carry
interest of 9% per annum from the date of the claim
petition till the date of payment. Eight (08) weeks time is
granted to the Insurance Company to deposit the said
amount from the date of receipt of the copy of this order.
20.
Consequently, the appeal is allowed in part.
21.
R &P, if any, be sent back to the concerned Tribunal
forthwith.
(N.S.SANJAY GOWDA,J)
(J. L. ODEDRA, J)
SUDHIR
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review