The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. Further, the petitioner made another representation dated 23.11.2016 requesting to furnish the documents pertaining to the enquiry. The said application was disposed of by order dated 25.11.2016 by observing that the petitioner was furnished with all relevant documents earlier, as seen from the record. The said docket order passed by the Enquiry Officer attained finality, inasmuch as the same was not challenged by way of appeal before the 2nd respondent. Further, the Enquiry Officer also passed order dated 18.02.2017 categorically observing that all the material filed along with the complaint was furnished to the petitioner and the question of furnishing the documents which are not available in the record does not arise. The said docket order was passed on the representation dated 23.01.2017 made by the petitioner. Further, the said order also attained finality inasmuch as it was not assailed before the 2nd respondent. RRR,J & TCDS,J WP_31239_2023
18. From the above, it is evident that the petitioner in order to protract the proceedings before the enquiry Officer made untenable requests, without there being any cause. Further, despite granting ample opportunities, he did not choose to cross examine the witnesses. Apart from the same, the petitioner had collected huge amounts from complainants and in fact he has furnished forged and fabricated list of selected candidates said to have been issued by the Registrar (Admn), High Court of Andhra Pradesh. The collection of amounts by the petitioner is also evident from his bank transactions. Apart from the same, the writ petition is also filed after a lapse of three (03) years from the date of order passed by the 1st respondent and no explanation whatsoever was offered in the affidavit filed in support of the writ petition in that regard. In the absence of any explanation, the present writ petition is also liable to be dismissed on the ground of laches.
19. As can be seen from the record, it is evident that the Articles of charges framed against the petitioner are proved and taking into consideration of the gravity of charges, major penalty of dismissal from service was ordered against the petitioner. RRR,J & TCDS,J WP_31239_2023 Viewed from any angle, there are no merits in the present writ petition and accordingly the same is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs. As a sequel, pending applications, if any shall stand closed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RRR,J & TCDS,J
WP_31239_2023
APHC010604822023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA
PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3529]
SATURDAY,THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE R RAGHUNANDAN RAO
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D.SEKHAR
WRIT PETITION NO: 31239/2023
Between:
1. N V S R MURTHY, S/O. LATE TIRUPATHI RAO AGED
ABOUT 56 YEARS, R/O.PLOT.NO.89, SBI COLONY,
BALAJI NAGAR, VIZIANAGARAM.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE HIGH COURT OF AP, REP.BY ITS REGISTRAR
(ADMINISTRATION),
NELAPADU,
AMARAVATHI,
GUNTUR DISTRICT.
2. THE DISCIPLINARY AUTHORITYCUMDISTRICT JUDGE,
VIZIANAGARAM DISTRICT, VIZIANAGARAM.
3. THE ENQUIRY OFFICER CUM I ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE, VIZIANAGARAM, VIZIANAGARAM DISTRICT.
4. THE PRELIMINARY ENQUIRY OFFICERCUMHEAD OF
THE VIGILANCE, CELL-CUM-SPECIAL JUDGE FOR
TRIAL OF CASES UNDER SCS AND STS (POA) ACT
COURT-CUM- IV ADDITIONAL DISTRICT JUDGE,
VIZIANAGARAM, VIZIANAGARAM DISTRICT.
RRR,J & TCDS,J
WP_31239_2023
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying
that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the
High Court may be pleased topleased to issue a Writ of
Mandamus, or other appropriate writ, order or direction, declaring
the Enquiry File No.02/2016 in Order.P.R.No. 97/2015-A,
dt.16.08.2017 passed by the 2nd respondent and an Order in
D(D)A.No.02/2018,C.4(Con) dated 18-05-2020 passed by the 1st
respondent is illegal, arbitrary, unreasonable, and violative of
Articles 14, 21 and 300-A of the Constitution of India and
consequently direct the respondents to reinstate the petitioner
into service with all consequential benefits and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the
petition, the High Court may be pleased be pleased to suspend
the Enquiry File No.02/2016 in
Order:P.R.No. 97/2015-A,
dt.16.08.201-7 passed bythe 2nd respondent and an Order in
D(D)A.No.02/2018,C.4(Con) dated 18-05-2020 passed by the 1st
respondent, pending disposal of the above writ petition and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the
petition, the High Court may be pleased may be pleased to grant
leave to file the counter affidavit and receive the same in the
above writ petition no. 31239 of 2023 and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. P DURGA PRASAD
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. D V SASIDHAR
RRR,J & TCDS,J
WP_31239_2023
ORDER:- (Per Hon’ble Sri Justice T.C.D. Sekhar)
1.
The present writ petition is filed questioning the
proceedings dated 16.08.2017 issued by the 2nd respondent,
which was confirmed in order dated 18.05.2020 passed by the 1st
respondent under which the petitioner was dismissed from
service as he was found guilty of the charges leveled against him.
2.
It is the case of the petitioner that he was appointed
as Attender, Mobile Court, Vizianagaram on 19.02.1988.
Subsequehntly, he was promoted as Process Server and posted
at Central Nazarath, District Court, Vizianagaram. Further, on
24.04.2015 he was transferred on deputation to Judicial First
Class Magistrate Court, Kurupam. While working in the said
station, the petitioner was issued order in PR No.97/2015-A under
which he was suspended from service for a period of six (06)
months on the complaint submitted by Tanani Ramana, Kilari
Naidu and Dannina Sivaswaroop Kumar, alleging that the
petitioner collected huge amounts representing that he would
secure jobs to them in the Court. Further, a preliminary enquiry
was conducted by the head of the Vigilance cum- Special Judge
for Trial of Cases under SCs & STs (PoA) Act, Vizianagaram.
RRR,J & TCDS,J
WP_31239_2023
Upon enquiry a preliminary report dated 27.04.2015 was
submitted and the District Judge, Vizianagaram ordered regular
departmental enquiry by proceedings in PR No.97/2015-A,
dt.14.08.2015 and the petitioner was asked to submit explanation
within seven (07) days. Thereafter, the petitioner submitted
explanation denying the charges by stating that the amounts were
borrowed from the above named persons for his daughter’s
marriage.
3.
On the very same allegations, a case in Crime No.72
of 2015 was registered on 28.04.2015 for the offences punishable
under Sections 420, 468 and 471 IPC and the petitioner was
arrested in connection with the said crime. In the remand report, it
was mentioned that the appointment orders are issued by forging
the signatures of District Judges, Vizianagaram, Visakhapatnam
and Srikakulam Districts by the petitioner.
4. Thereafter, the period of suspension was extended for a
further period of six (06) months by proceedings dated
28.10.2015 by the 2nd respondent and payment of subsistence
allowance was stopped. Further, the 2nd respondent framed
RRR,J & TCDS,J
WP_31239_2023
articles of charges against the petitioner on 02.11.2015, which
are as follows:
Article-I: That you Sri N.V.S.R. Murthy, while working as Process
Service in the District Court, Vizianagaram, from August, 2008 to
25.04.2015, has made a false representation to several gullible
unemployed youth namely one Tanari Ramana, Dannina Siva
Swaroopkumar and Kilari Naidu and several others to the effect that
you would secure employment to them in the Courts of Vizianagaram
District and Visakhapatnam District and collected huge amounts from
them by got crediting the amounts into your account viz., (1) Canara
Bank, V.T. Agraharam, Vizianagaram, bearing A/c.1661101011994.
(2)
Indian
Overseas
Bank,
Vizianagaram,
bearing
A/c.Nos.03840100021381 and 038401000019588. (3) Central Bank,
Thotapalem, Vizianagaram, bearing A/c. Nos.2141756052 and
2141756029. (4) Karnataka Bank Ltd., Vizianagaram, bearing
A/c.No.7972500100586101. (5) Bank of India, Vizianagaram, bearing
A/c.No.861310110005551. (6) Dena Bank, Vizianagaram, bearing
A/c.No.145610032321. (7) Bank of Baroda, Vizianagaram, bearing
A/c.No.24220100002199. (8) State Bank of India, Cantonment
Branch, Vizianagaram, bearing A/c.No.31718141903 and (9)
Corporation Bank, Vizianagaram, bearing A/c.No.SB/01/005902. This
conduct of yours shows that you have cheated the public and
amassed huge amount which is unbecoming to a Government servant
and contravention of Rule 3 of A.P.C.S (Conduct) Rules, 1964 and
liable for punishment under Rule 9 of A.P.C.S. (CC & A) Rules, 1991.
Article-2: “That you Sri N.V.S.R. Murthy, while working as Process
Server in the District Court, Vizianagaram, from August, 2008 to
25.04.2015, have cheated the public namely Tanari Ramana, Dannina
Siva Swaroopkumar and Kilari Naidu and several others gullible
unemployed youth and collected the huge amount from them by
promising to secure jobs for them in the Courts of Vizianagaram
District and Visakhapatnam District and that too impress the above
said persons that you have fabricated a letter in the name of
Sri P.Muthyala Naidu, the then Administrative Registrar of Hon’ble
High Court of Andhra Pradesh, under which directing the District
Judge, Vizianagaram to give employment to 90 persons and also
directing the District Judge, Visakhapatnam, to give employment to 87
persons nominated in the said letter and thereby fabricated those
appointment letters in the name of Registrar of Administration, Hon’ble
High Court of Andhra Pradesh and you have committed an offence of
fabrication of letters which is unbecoming to a Government servant
and contravention of Rule 3 of A.P.C.S (conduct) Rules, 1964 and
liable for punishment under Rule 9 of A.P.C.S. (CC & A) Rules, 1991.
RRR,J & TCDS,J
WP_31239_2023
5.
The
petitioner
submitted
written
statement
on
05.12.2015 to the articles of charges and requested to supply all
the material papers that are mentioned in the preliminary enquiry
report. It is further case of the petitioner that the disciplinary
authority supplied only copy of the complaint submitted by Tanani
Ramana through PR No.97/2015-A, dt.28.12.2015 and did not
furnish the other documents.
6.
It is further case of the petitioner that, he made
another representation dated 27.01.2016 requesting to furnish all
other documents filed along with the complaint and preliminary
enquiry report. It was further requested to revoke the suspension
as the enquiry is not concluded even after a period of one (01)
year. The said request of the petitioner was rejected by the 2nd
respondent through order dt.28.04.2016. Thereafter, the 2nd
respondent appointed the 3rd respondent as ‘Enquiry Officer’
through proceedings dated 30.04.2016 and departmental enquiry
was started on 01.06.2016. It is further case of the petitioner that,
since the requisite material is not supplied by the Enquiry Officer,
he filed petitions seeking adjournments during the enquiry period
from 24.08.2016 to 12.11.2016.
RRR,J & TCDS,J
WP_31239_2023
7.
It is the specific case of the petitioner that, the
enquiry was not conducted as per CCA Rules, 1981 and the 3rd
respondent submitted its report dated 18.04.2017 by concluding
that the charges framed against the petitioner are proved
inasmuch as he has contravened rules 3 & 9 of APCS (Conduct)
Rules, 1964. The 2nd respondent thereafter called for written
explanation on the proposal of punishment of dismissal from
service through proceedings dated 05.06.2017. The petitioner
submitted application dated 23.06.2017, requesting the 2nd
respondent to extend 20 days time for filing written explanation
and the same was allowed by extending the time till 01.07.2017
and
thereafter
the
petitioner
submitted
explanation
on
06.07.2017, requesting the 2nd respondent to reopen the enquiry
and to submit all documents.
8.
It is further case of the petitioner, instead of
furnishing the documents sought for by the petitioner, the 2nd
respondent passed final order in PR No.97/2015-A, dated
16.08.2017 imposing major penalty of dismissal from service.
Aggrieved by the said order, the petitioner filed appeal before the
RRR,J & TCDS,J
WP_31239_2023
1st respondent and the same was dismissed by order dated
18.05.2020 by the 1st respondent. Questioning these orders, the
present writ petition is filed.
9. The respondent Nos.2 to 4 filed counter affidavit denying
the averments made in support of the writ petition by contending
that the petitioner supplied forged and fabricated list of selected
candidates as if it is addressed by Registrar (Admn.) to the
Principal District Judge, Vizianagaram in proceedings dated
27.01.2014. As per the preliminary report, a case in Crime No.72
of 2015 was registered against the petitioner and the same is
being investigated by CID. After, the conclusion of the preliminary
enquiry, a report dated 27.04.2015 was submitted stating that the
petitioner has deceived the individuals, who gave complaint
against him by playing fraud. Subsequently, he was placed under
suspension and took up the departmental enquiry.
10.
It is further averred in the counter affidavit that, after
following the procedure contemplated under A.P. Civil Services
(CCA) Rules, 1964, the 2nd respondent passed order of removal
of the petitioner from service and appeal preferred by him was
also dismissed by order dated 18.05.2020. It is further contended
RRR,J & TCDS,J
WP_31239_2023
that after a lapse of three (03) years from the order of the 1st
respondent, the present writ petition is filed.
11.
It is the specific case of the respondents that, the
petitioner was supplied with all copies of documents and he was
also permitted to engage retired government servant to defend
his case. Despite giving several opportunities, the petitioner did
not secure retired employee and the same is evident from the
proceedings recorded by the Enquiry Officer. Further, the Enquiry
Officer after recording the evidences of witnesses directed the
petitioner to cross examine them, but the petitioner protracted the
matter on one pretext or the other.
12.
It is further averred that there are no grounds to
interfere with the orders passed by the respondents and to
dismiss the writ petition on the ground of laches inasmuch as the
writ petition was filed after a period of three (03) years from the
date of order passed by the 1st respondent.
13.
Heard counsel for the petitioner and learned
Standing Counsel appearing for respondents.
14.
Perused the record.
RRR,J & TCDS,J
WP_31239_2023
15.
It is the specific case of the petitioner that, the
respondents without furnishing the documents which are basis for
initiating the disciplinary proceedings against him passed orders
under challenge. He would further submit that, he made several
representations to the respondent Nos.2 & 3 in that regard. On
the other hand, the counsel for the respondents would
strenuously contend that all the documents were furnished to the
petitioner at the time of enquiring, despite the same, the petitioner
kept on filing representations.
16.
In order to verify the contention of the petitioner, this
Court by order dated 06.01.2026 called for the record pertaining
to the case of the petitioner and the same is produced before this
Court. On perusal of record, it is evident that the enquiry was
posted from time to time i.e., on 24.08.2016, 03.09.2016,
13.09.2016, 17.09.2016, 26.09.2016, 04.10.2016 and 07.10.2016
at the request of the petitioner. Despite granting ample
opportunities, the petitioner did not choose to cross examine the
witnesses. Further, the petitioner also made application to
transfer the departmental enquiry initiated against him. In this
regard, the Enquiry Officer submitted a detailed communication
dated 13.10.2016 to the 2nd respondent and on perusal of the
RRR,J & TCDS,J
WP_31239_2023
same, it is evident that the disciplinary authority furnished all
copies
to
the
petitioner
before
commencement
of
the
departmental enquiry and he did not request any other copies
from the Enquiry Officer.
17.
Further, the petitioner made another representation
dated 23.11.2016 requesting to furnish the documents pertaining
to the enquiry. The said application was disposed of by order
dated 25.11.2016 by observing that the petitioner was furnished
with all relevant documents earlier, as seen from the record. The
said docket order passed by the Enquiry Officer attained finality,
inasmuch as the same was not challenged by way of appeal
before the 2nd respondent.
Further, the Enquiry Officer also
passed order dated 18.02.2017 categorically observing that all
the material filed along with the complaint was furnished to the
petitioner and the question of furnishing the documents which are
not available in the record does not arise. The said docket order
was passed on the representation dated 23.01.2017 made by the
petitioner. Further, the said order also attained finality inasmuch
as it was not assailed before the 2nd respondent.
RRR,J & TCDS,J
WP_31239_2023
18.
From the above, it is evident that the petitioner in
order to protract the proceedings before the enquiry Officer made
untenable requests, without there being any cause. Further,
despite granting ample opportunities, he did not choose to cross
examine the witnesses. Apart from the same, the petitioner had
collected huge amounts from complainants and in fact he has
furnished forged and fabricated list of selected candidates said to
have been issued by the Registrar (Admn), High Court of Andhra
Pradesh. The collection of amounts by the petitioner is also
evident from his bank transactions. Apart from the same, the writ
petition is also filed after a lapse of three (03) years from the date
of order passed by the 1st respondent and no explanation
whatsoever was offered in the affidavit filed in support of the writ
petition in that regard. In the absence of any explanation, the
present writ petition is also liable to be dismissed on the ground
of laches.
19.
As can be seen from the record, it is evident that the
Articles of charges framed against the petitioner are proved and
taking into consideration of the gravity of charges, major penalty
of dismissal from service was ordered against the petitioner.
RRR,J & TCDS,J
WP_31239_2023
Viewed from any angle, there are no merits in the present writ
petition and accordingly the same is dismissed.
There shall be no order as to costs. As a sequel, pending
applications, if any shall stand closed.
________________________________
JUSTICE RAO RAGHUNANDAN RAO
________________________
JUSTICE T.C.D. SEKHAR
31.01.2026
DR
RRR,J & TCDS,J
WP_31239_2023
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE R RAGHUNANDAN RAO
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D. SEKHAR
WP No.31239 of 2023
Date 31.01.2026
U
DR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review