Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3302 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(SPecial Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY SIXTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
rWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. SARATH
WRIT PETITION N O:29 2680F 2025
Between:
N
mala' R!/o champally
T Reieshwar. S/o Narsimhlu, aqe 60 years, caste
present working as
;iil;;;.-i;i;fthindamandal, distict Nirmal now
lunror
aisiitant in O/o. PAO, (W&P), Nirmal District'
...PETITIONER
AND
State of Telanqana, represented by its principal secretary Finance
department, s6cretariat' Hyderabad, Telangana state'
zone-1 '
2 Office of the Joint Director of works accounts, (W&P) multi
b; iii lolt ttirecto, Karimnagar' kbrimnasar District' relansana
state.
3. Pay and Accounts officer, (W&P) Nirmal, Nirmal District' Telangana state'
6;:,".;;i;i
...RESPONDENTS
praying that in the
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia
High court may be
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the
of writ
pi"*"d t" issue an order or direction more particularly one in the ofnature
respondent
writ (i).Declaring the action
6r-Manoa.us or any other appropriate
'proceedings
IDWAJM ZNo
PToc
dated 22 08 2025
f.fo.Z for. issuing suspension
grounds
of
the
on
i6inOrninlu-rlf] s1-t41t2o25-i6/80 through respondent No.3
respondent
on
miiconOuct without any authority, beyont the powers conferred
(classification,
services
(a)
civil
Telangana
Uo.i"nO in violation oi Rule A if )
of
civil service
Rule
of
violation
controt anO appeal) Rules, 1991 ,' and in
of lndian
of
article
ana. iilegat, arbitrary in. violation
i*"ar"tl nr6i t dO+the
suspJniion procLedings dated 22.o8.2O25 Proc.No.
ttnstitut,on setaside
respondent No 2 a-nd
ioWn",nl.z-urvndmin/U-l/F.88-i48t2o25-26t80 issued by the
benefits
consequently direct the respondent No 2 and 3 to pay all consequential
to the petitioner from the date of suspension'
lA NO: 1 OF 2O2s
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the c rsumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Cot r may be pleased to
Suspension of the suspension proceedings dated t'.'..18.2025 Proc.No'
IDWAJM Z-lll(Admin/U-l tF 88-14812025-26/ issued by the res rr:ndent No 2'
Counsel forthe Petitioner: SRI YAKARAPU SHEELU
Counsel for the Respondents: SMT. B. VAIJAYANTHI, ASST. ( F'FOR SERVICES lll
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SARATH
WRIT PETITION No.2926a of 2025
THE 26TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2026
Between:
N.T.Rajeshwar.
...Petitioner
AND
State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secretary,
Revenue Department and others.
...Respondents
ORDER:
Heard Sri Yakarapu Sheelu, Iearned counsel lor the
petitioner, Smt. B.Vaijayanthi, iearned Assistant Government
Pieader for Services-lll appearing for the respondents zrnd
perused the material available on record
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that this Writ
Petition is filed seeking to declare the action of the
respondent No.2 in issuing suspension proceedings dated
22.O8.2025 uide Proc.No.lDWA/M.2.-IlKlAdmn/U-IlF-8848 12025-26/80, on the grounds of misconduct, without any
authority and beyond the powers conferred on the respondent
j
SIi,.I
\'t.P.No..292a)8 ol 202-
No.2 as illegal, arbitrary and in violation of RL le 8(1)(a) of the
Telangana Civil Scrvices (Ciassitication, Cor-rL o1 and Appeal)
Rules, 199 1 and also in violation of Ruie 3 o[rlLc Civil Service
Conduct Rulcs, 1964
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner furtl: r r sr_rbmits that
the petitioner is working as Junior Assistant n the pay and
Accounts Olficc, Nirmal District and has been n service since
August 2022 and he previously u,orked as \ itlage Revenue
OIficer of Bellal Viiiage, Kadam Mandal, Nirrr; I District lrom
2Ol7 to 2OIB. While it being so, the respon,l_-nt authorities
issued the impugned Show Causc Notice da1 _-cl 31.O7.2025
on the ground that the office of the respondt:rr No.2 received
a letter from the Superintendent of l) rlice, Nirmal,
recommending disciplinary action against thr petitioner for
allegedly turning hostile to the prosecution wh le deposing in
S.C.(NDPS).No.04 of 2022 before the Court o the principal
District and Sessions Judge, Nirmal.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further :;ubmits that,
in response to the said show cause noticer. the petitioner
submitted a detailed explanation on 11.08.20.5i. In spite of
SK, J
W t'. No.29268 ol2025
the same and without taking the said explanation into
account, the respondent No.2 issued the suspension
proceedings utde Proc.No.tDWAlM.Z. IIK/ Adrrrn/U-I/F.8848/2025-26 l80,
dated 22.O8.2O25 as a measure of
punishment. The respondents have neither initiated any
discipiina5z proceedings against the petitioner nor conducted
any enquiry from the date of the impugned suspension order
to till date. In view of the same, learned counsel for the
petitioner requested this Court to ailou, the Writ petition by
setting aside the impugned suspension proceedings dated
22.08.2025 issued by the respondent No.2 and by directing
the rcspondents [o pa1, a1l t;onsequentierl benefits to the
petitioner lrom the daLe ol suspension.
5.
Learned counsel for thc petitioner lurther submits that
the reasons mentioncd by l.he respondent No.2 in the
impugned suspension proceedings are contrary to the law
laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court and relied upon the
following Judgments:
(i) Inspector Prem Chand os. Gout. of NCT oJ Delhit,
\2007 | 4 SCC 566
SK, J
$.'.1'. i\-o.29 268 of 2025
(ii)Abdut Rauf
Maharashtra,
Khaja ')s. Stqte of
Diuisionol Commis: ioner OfJice,
Mohammed
Aurangabad2.
6.
On thc other hand, learned Assistar 1. Ciovernment
Pleader for Services-lll basing on the counr -.r liled by the
respondent No.2 submits that in view o[ the ri rluest made by
the
District Collector, Nirmal uicle Proceedings
No.Aa/97O12022-60, dared ot.o8.2o?_.) and
the
communication ol the Superintendent of F\>lice, Nirma_l
District to initiatc suitable disciplinary acL ( n against the
petitioner on the grour-rd that thc petitiot-rer t, rrrcd hostile in
NDPS Act case while deposing evidence beforr thc District &
Sessions Court. Nirmal District and in vieu' c, thr: same, the
respondent No.2 passed the impugncr suspensiorr
proceedings.
7.
Learned Assistant Government Pleader irr Services-Ill
lurther submits that the petitioner being a I ,ublic servant,
was expected to depose in accordance ni h his earlier
statement and supporting documents beforc he Court, but
. h" deposed in a manner a-llegedly co.t _rary to the
2 2023
(ll AIRBomR 369
J
SK, J
W.P.No.29268 of 2025
panchanama prepared by his superior ofhcers and thereby
exhibiting gross misconduct in discharge of his legitimate
duties by colluding with ganja cultivators. The District police
authorities and the District Collector, Nirmal District,
recommended stringent action against the petitioner. In view
of the same, the respondent authorities issued a show cause
notice to the petitioner by tollowing due procedure and
subsequently, suspended the petitioner ulde suspension
proceedings dated 22.O8.2025. Therefore, learned Assistant
Government Pleader requested to dismiss the Writ petition as
there are no merits.
8. After hearing both sidcs and perusing the materia,l
available on record, Lhis Court is of thc considered view that
while the petitioner was working as Junior Assistant in the
Pay and Accounts Office, Nirmal District, the respondent
authorities issued a show cause notice to him on the ground
that he had turned hostile as a witness in S.C.(NDpS).No.04
of 2022 on the file of the principal District and Sessions
Judgc, Nirmal District. The Superintendent of police, Nirma,l
addressed a letter to the District Collector, Nirmal to take
SK, J
!,' P. \o.2(l2aS ot 2025
appropriate action against the petitioner anrl based on the
said letter, the District Collcctor directed the r r spondent No.2
to take action agair-rst the petitioner. In view o the sarne, the
respondent No.2 issued a show cause notice 1( the petitioner
or-r 31.O7.2025. In response to the sam<:. l.he petitioner
submitted his explanation on ll.Oa.2025, btrt u,,ithout taking
into account of the samc, the respondent ll r .2 issued the
suspension proceedings dated 22.08 .2025.
9. The entire basis in the impugrrt'I suspcnsion
proceedings issued by the respondent No.2 is' rvith regard to
the deposition of the petitioner in S.C.(NDPS lio.04 ol 2022
on the lile of the Principal District and St s;siot-ts Judge,
Nirmal and also the communication ltetu.eett the
Superintendent of Police, Nirmal and the Dis trict Collector,
Nirmal and basing on the directions givcn lty them, the
respondent No.2 passed the
impugnc r
suspension
proceedings. It clearly shou/s that the rc::ondent No.2,
without any independent application of mir cl and merely
basing on the directions of the District (l') lector, Nirmal
issued the impugned suspension proceedings : nd the same is
SK, J
W. P.No.292613 of 2o25
arbitrary, illegal and contrary to the Telangana Civil Services
(Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 199 1.
10. The respondent authorities have not initiated any
disciplinary proceedings or enquiry against the petitioner as
on this date and passed the impugned suspension
proceedings as a measure of punishment and the same is
impermissible and contrary to the Rule 9 of the Telangana
Civil Services (Classification, Controi and Appeal) Rules,
1991.
I 1.
Learned counsel for the petitioner relied on the
Judgment of the Honble Apex Court in Inspector Prem
Chqnd (supra -1) and the relevant portion of the said
Judgment reads as under:
" 13. The Tribunal opincd rhat thc acts of omission on the
part of the appellant was not a mcrc error of judgment. On
what premise the said opinion q'as arrived at is not clear. We
have noticed hereinbe[ore that the appellate authority,
namely, the Commissioncr ol Policc, Delhi, u'hile passing the
order dated 29.8.2OO3 categorically held that the appellant
being a raiding olhcer should have seized the tainted money
as case property. In a given case, what should have been
done, is a matter which u'ould depend on the facts and
circumstances of each case. No hard and fast rule can be laid
dou,n therefor."
SIi, .,
\\' P.No 292t>8 ot 2O2i
14. Thc Criminal Court ld6iglcdly did n ) ! pass any
adverse romarks against thc appellant. Some aclr trse retnzrrks
\vere pas:scd agalnst the [nvcstigating Otficer, ,\ t(] cxamined
himscll as PW 4 as hc had hancled ovcr thc ta r r r:d moncv to
thc complair.tztnL PW 2.
16. Wc. therefore, are of the opjnion that in ltre pectrliar
facts and circumstances of this case, the appell:. )t cannot be
said lo havc r.ommittcd anv misconcluct.,'
12. The above findings of the Honbie Su: ^eme Court in
Inspector Prem Chand (supra-1) have beetr ollou,ed by thc
Division Bench of the Honble High Corr.t_ ol Bombay
(;\urangabad Bench)
1n
Abdul Rauf Mohe mtned Khaja
(supra-2) and the relevant portion of the Judl rnent re acls as
undcr:
"7. Having hcard thc learned counscl for the p:u ics, rvc [irst
cxamine Pr:titioner's contenlion that thc act o[ tr
n ing hostile
r
docs not amount lo misconduct. Perjury is zLn offfencc
ptrnishablc rrndcr Scction 191 of the Indian Pcr I Codc llor
sh.rrt "[. t,. Code"). If the pciitioncr had commrl cl o llcncc of
pcrjury, thc Scssions Judge ought to have issr r:l nolice to
r
,
r
:
I-rim and tricd him for that offence. Whcther he lt I I committed
olfence of p<:rjury or not can be establisl-red bv
l:
e Sessiorrs
.lrrdge alonc.'l'he same cannot be established in r clisciplinrtry
cnquiry,. Tl-rc lall provides for. a complete rnr :hanism to
punish a person committing cffice of pcrjury. Ti,r - ring hostile,
bv itself, is not an offence. The only- Court compc r nt to record
a linding of commisston of perjury r,r,as the Sc ss ons Judge.
SK, J
w .P .No .29268 of 2025
a-
The appointing authority, not being an expert, would
otherwise not be in a position to gauge the factors leading to
hostility of the witness. After considering the testimony of the
petitioner, the Sessions Judge has thought it appropriate not
to issue notice to him for trial for the offence punishable
U/Sec. 191 of the I. P. Code. Therefore, it is difficult to hold
that the act of giving testimony bcfore Sessions Judge as
misconduct and to punish the petitioner for the same.
The principles laid down
1n
the aforementioned
Judgments squarely apply to the facts of the instant case as
the competent Criminal Court did not pass any adverse
remarks against the petitioncr.
13. The petitioner has been suspended as a measure of
punishment without conducting any enquiry and the
respondent authorities have no power to record a finding that
the petitioner did not follow conduct rules and also is liable
for punishment basing on the deposition of the petitioner in
the Crimina-I Court. The respondent No.2 is not a competent
authority to decide the validity of the deposition given by the
petitioner before the competent Crimina-l Court and the
respondent No.2 being a disciplinary authority, without
following any rules and basing on the directions of the
District Collector, issued the impugned suspension orders as
SK,.)
\V.l'.No 29268 of 2O25
a measure of punishment. The said action of , re respondents
is illegal, arbitrary, contrary to the Telangant Civil Services
(Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 19' I and the said
suspension proceedings are liable to be set asr< t:
With the above findings, this Writ Petitio i is allowed by
14.
setting aside the impugned suspension I roceedings
1n
Proc. No. IDW A I M.Z. -l / K / Admn / U -l / F .88- 48 I )- )25 -26 I 80
dated 22.O8.2025 and thc respondents i. o directed to
reinstate the petitioner into service forthwith
15. Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pendinl in this Writ
Petition shall stand closed. There shali be ro order as to
costs
Sd/-C.DEEPIKA
,,-:ASI; S,TANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
I
SECTION OFFICER
l
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble SRI JUSTICE K. SA
(For His Lordships kind perusal)
J
To,
. 'l LR Copies
2. The Under Secretary, Union of India, Ministry of Law. . rstice and Company
Affairs, New Delhi
3. The Secretary, Telangana Advocates Association,
Buildings, Hyderabad.
-ibrary, High Court
4. The principtsecretary Finance department, State of Telangana, secretariat,
Hyderabad, Telangana state.
5. Office of the Joint Director of works accounts, (W&p) multi zone-1.
represented by its Joint director Karimnagar, kirimnigar District, Telangana
state.
Ac!qq!!g.ofger, (W-&P)Nirmat, Nirmat District, Telangana stare.
lry qn!
7. One
CC to SRI YAKARAPU SHEELU, Advocate [OpUC]
8. Two CCs to GP FOR SERVICES il|, High Court f6r the State of Tetangana.
lourl
9. Two CD Copies
BN
PMK
.L 1-
SL
''i'i'
i'
,T
.;
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED:2G lO2t2O26
1E L4
T5
(.)
w
s
F
ORDER
otJ.
a
*
o
tu
\
WP.No.29268 of 2025
r-l t-l t
u_.
!t
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
ny
l
:
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review