Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 31ST DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S. KAMAL
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.1177 OF 2009 (DEC/INJ)
BETWEEN:
N. RAMASWAMY
SINCE DECEASED, REP. BY LRS.
1.
1(a). ASHIKA
D/O LATE N. RAMASWAMY,
AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS.
1(b). KUM. BEENA R.
D/O LATE N. RAMASWAMY,
AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS.
BOTH ARE R/AT:DODDA BANASWADI
POST OFFICE BUILDING,
ANJANEYA SWAMY TEMPLE STREET,
BENGALURU - 560 021.
…APPELLANTS
Digitally
signed by
SUMA B N
Location:
HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
(BY SRI. S.N. ASHWATHNARAYANA, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI. S.A. SUDHINDRA, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
THE CHIEF SECRETARY
STATE OF KARNATAKA,
VIDHANA SOUDHA,
DR. AMBEDKAR ROAD,
BENGALURU - 560 001.
2.
THE TAHSILDAR
K.R. PURAM,
BENGALURU EAST TALUK.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. H.R. AMARAVATHI, AGA FOR R1 & R2)
-2NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL IS FILED UNDER
SECTION 96 OF CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 21.08.2009 PASSED IN
ORIGINAL SUIT NO.1356 OF 2007 ON THE FILE OF THE XL
ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL JUDGE, BENGALURU, DISMISSING
THE SUIT FOR DECLARATION AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION.
THIS APPEAL COMING ON FOR DICTATING ORDERS,
THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S. KAMAL
ORAL JUDGMENT
This appeal is by the unsuccessful plaintiff aggrieved by
the judgment and decree dated 21.08.2009 passed in Original
Suit No.1356/2007 on the file of the XL Additional City Civil
Judge, Bengaluru (CCH-41) (for short, hereinafter referred to
as 'trial Court').
2.
Subject matter of the suit is land measuring 6
guntas in Survey No.13 situated at Banaswadi Village, K.R.
Puram Hobli, Bengaluru East Taluk bounded on East by: Kana
of Jayarama Reddy; West by: Papaiah's Ashrama Sy.No.2/1;
North by: Kana of Jayarama Reddy and South by: Main Road
(hereinafter referred to as 'suit schedule property').
3.
The
plaintiff
filed
the
above
suit,
seeking
declaration that he is the absolute owner of the suit schedule
property having perfected his title by adverse possession and
-3NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
consequent relief restraining the defendants from interfering
with
his
possession
over
the
suit
schedule
property
contending interalia that
(a)
suit
schedule
property
formed
part
of
the
Government land measuring 9 acres 21 guntas bearing
Sy.No.13 of Banaswadi Village. That plaintiff is in
possession
and
enjoyment
of
the
suit
schedule
property. That his father Thogur Nagappa was in
possession of the suit schedule property for over fifty
years.
He had constructed a residential house in a
portion of suit schedule property and remaining land
was kept vacant. He was in continuous physical and
peaceful possession of the same till his demise on
12.12.1996.
(b) That in the year 1967, the father of the plaintiff
Thogur Nagappa had filed a suit in O.S.No.681/1967
against one Thogur Nanjappa and others for the relief
of
permanent
injunction
restraining
them
from
interfering with his possession over suit schedule
property.
The said suit was decreed. Thus, clearly
establishing the fact that the suit schedule property
was in possession of the father of the plaintiff for over
forty years.
(c) That after the demise of his father, the plaintiff has
been in continuous possession of the suit schedule
-4NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
property without any interruption to the knowledge of
the Government.
(d) That the plaintiff and his father have paid property
taxes to the Government and same was accepted even
during the year 1965-66.
In recognition of the
possession of the father of the plaintiff in the suit
schedule property, the Tahsildar, Bengaluru East Taluk
had even mutated his name in the revenue records.
That suit schedule property has seized to be an
agricultural land as there exists residential building
and shops. Grama Panchayath of Banaswadi has
registered the name of the plaintiff in its revenue
records assigning the house list No.306/1. Plaintiff has
been exercising possessory rights for more than 70
years. He is exercising his rights as evidenced by RTC
extracts, demand register extract and electricity bills
produced in this regard.
(e)
That
recently,
State
Government
initiated
proceedings against the persons who have encroached
the
Government
lands
and
has
constituted
a
Committee in this regard and a paper publication was
issued intending to initiate criminal cases against
persons
in
unauthorized
occupations.
Plaintiff
apprehending the State Government may initiate
action against him was constrained to file the above
suit for declaration and permanent injunction.
-5NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
5. Defendants though served have remained absent and
placed ex-parte.
6.
Plaintiff examined himself as PW-1 and exhibited 9
documents marked as Exhibits P1 to P9.
7.
The Trial Court, based on the pleadings on record,
framed following points for its consideration:
"1)
Whether the plaintiff has proved that he has
exercised his right of ownership for over a
statutory period against the defendants and
perfected his title by adverse possession as
alleged?
2)
Whether plaintiff further proves that defendants
have illegally interfered with his lawful
possession over the suit schedule property?
3)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief of
permanent injunction against the defendants as
prayed?
4)
What order?"
8.
On appreciation of evidence, the trial Court,
dismissed the suit filed by impugned judgment and decree
dated 21.08.2009. Being aggrieved by the same, the plaintiff
is before this Court.
-6NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
9.
Sri.
S.N.
Ashwathnarayana,
learned
Senior
counsel on behalf of Sri. S.A. Sudhindra, appearing for the
plaintiff taking this Court through the materials placed on
record submits that there is a clear pleading in the plaint with
regard to the father of the plaintiff being in possession and
after his death, the plaintiff continuing to be in uninterrupted
possession of the suit schedule property. He further submits
that the fact that the father of the plaintiff who was paying
the property taxes later discontinued, would clearly indicate
that suit schedule property was in his possession adverse to
the interest of the Government. That despite non payment of
property tax failure on the part of the Government to initiate
action for their eviction is another indication of they sitting
over the property adverse to the interest of the Government,
which is sufficient enough to grant the relief of declaration as
sought for in favour of the plaintiff.
10.
That undisputed entries in the revenue records
clearly indicate the continuous possession of the plaintiff,
which is the evidence of animus possidendi. Therefore, he
submits that the trial Court erred in not appreciating pleading
-7NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
and the material evidence available on record while dismissing
the suit of the plaintiff.
11.
Additional
Per
contra,
Government
Smt.H.R.Amaravathi,
Advocate
appearing
learned
for
the
respondent-State submits that there is no whisper in the
plaint with regard to ingredients justifying the claim for
adverse possession and mere continuous possession would
not in any manner whatsoever amounts to adverse possession
and therefore, the trial Court having appreciated the same
while answering the points 1 to 3 had come to right
conclusion in declining to accept the case of the plaintiff. She
further submits that, mere stray entries in the revenue
records and even filing of the suit in O.S No.681/1967 and
obtaining decree by the father of the plaintiff to which the
respondent-State is not a party, cannot be a ground to
declare the relief of title in favour of the plaintiff. Accordingly,
she sought for dismissal of the present appeal.
12.
Heard and perused the materials on record.
13.
Points that arise for consideration in the present
appeal is:
-8NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
”1.Whether the plaintiff has proved that he has
perfected his title over the suit schedule property
by way of adverse possession?
2.Whether the trial Court is justified in dismissing
the suit?"
14.
Admittedly suit schedule property forms part of
larger extent of land in Sy.No.13 of Banaswadi Village,
K.R.Puram
Hobli,
Bangalore
respondent-State Government.
East
Taluk,
belonging
to
Perusal of the entire plaint
indicate that except repeatedly stating about the so called
continuous possession of the father of the plaintiff till his
demise and thereafter the plaintiff, there is no statement as
to the date, time and period from which the said possession
became adverse to the true owner namely respondent-State
Government.
15.
It is settled law that "mere possession over a
property for a long period of time does not grant the right of
adverse possession on its own and that the person claiming
adverse possession must show clear and cogent evidence to
substantiate such claim."
The Apex Court in the case of
Kishan Singh v. Arvind Kumar reported in (1994) 6 SCC
591 has held at paragraph 5 as under:
-9NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
“5. … A possession of a co-owner or of a licensee or of an
agent or a permissive possession to become adverse must be
established by cogent and convincing evidence to show
hostile animus and possession adverse to the knowledge of
real owner. Mere possession for howsoever length of time
does not result in converting the permissive possession into
adverse possession.”
Similarly the Apex Court in the case of
Gaya Parshad
Dikshit v. Nirmal Chander reported in (1984) 2 SCC 286
has
held at paragraph 1 as under:
“1. … It is not merely unauthorised possession on
termination of his licence that enables the licensee to
claim title by adverse possession but there must be
some overt act on the part of the licensee to show that
he is claiming adverse title. It is possible that the
licensor may not file an action for the purpose of
recovering possession of the premises from the licensee
after terminating his licence but that by itself cannot
enable the licensee to claim title by adverse
possession. There must be some overt act on the part
of the licensee indicating assertion of hostile title. Mere
continuance of unauthorised possession even for a
period of more than 12 years is not enough.”
The pleading must be clear, specific and categoric
manifesting the intention and conduct to occupy the land
belonging to the true owner adverse to his interest and to his
knowledge.
In
the
case
of
Karnataka
Wakf v. Union of India reported in
the Apex Court
Board
of
(2004) 10 SCC 779
at paragraph 11 as held as under:
“11. … It is a well-settled principle that a party
claiming adverse possession must prove that his
possession is “nec vi, nec clam, nec precario”, that is,
peaceful, open and continuous. The possession must
be adequate in continuity, in publicity and in extent to
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
show that their possession is adverse to the true
owner. It must start with a wrongful disposition of the
rightful owner and be actual, visible, exclusive, hostile
and continued over the statutory period.”
The
Apex
Vedanayagam
Court
in
the
case
of
Annakili Vs A.
reported in (2007) 14 SCC 308 held at
paragraph No.24:
“24. Claim by adverse possession has two elements :
(1) the possession of the defendant should become
adverse to the plaintiff; and (2) the defendant must
continue to remain in possession for a period of 12
years thereafter. Animus possidendi as is well known is
a requisite ingredient of adverse possession. It is now
a well-settled principle of law that mere possession of
the land would not ripen into possessory title for the
said
purpose. Possessor
must
have animus
possidendi and hold the land adverse to the title of the
true owner. For the said purpose, not only animus
possidendi must be shown to exist, but the same must
be shown to exist at the commencement of the
possession.”
The
Apex
Court
in
the
case
of
Chatti
Rao v. Palle Venkata Subba Rao reported in
Konati
(2010) 14
SCC 316 held at paragraph 15:
“15. Animus possidendi as is well known is a requisite
ingredient of adverse possession. Mere possession
does not ripen into possessory title until the possessor
holds the property adverse to the title of the true
owner for the said purpose. The person who claims
adverse possession is required to establish the date on
which he came in possession, nature of possession, the
factum of possession, knowledge to the true owner,
duration of possession and that possession was open
and undisturbed.”
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
16.
Plaintiff in the instant case to prove his case of
adverse possession has produced documents.Ex.P1-RTC for
the period 2006 and 2007 of Sy.No.13 of Banaswadi village,
nothing is emanating from the said document to indicate the
claim of the plaintiff or his father or he being in adverse
possession of the suit schedule property.
17. Ex.P2 is the certified copy of the judgment and
decree passed in OS.No.681/1967, the said Judgment is
apparently passed in a suit filed by the plaintiff against
Thogur Nanjappa, Thogur Ramaiah and Ramaiah and the
state is not a party in the said suit.
The said document
cannot be relied upon by the plaintiff to indicate his hostile
possession of the suit property adverse to the interest of the
State Government.
18. Ex.P3 is the RTC/Pahani of Sy.No.13 for the period
of 1967-68 to 1970-71, Column No.9 of the said property
indicate the land belonging to the Government and no entries
are found at Column No.10 and 11.
19. Similarly Ex.P4 to P6 are the pahani extracts. There
appears to be certain entry at Column No.12 indicating the
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
name of the father of the plaintiff using it as a haystack
backyard.
It is not clear as to the basis on which the said
entries have been made.
20. Ex.P7 is the cash receipt and Ex.P8 is another Tax
paid receipt.
Ex.P9 is the Copy of Representation dated
28.04.1986 given by father of the plaintiff to Tahsildar
seeking registration of khatha in his name. If Ex.P9 and its
contents are accepted to be true and genuine, it only indicate
that
father
of
the
plaintiff
himself
is
requesting
the
respondent-Tahsildar to make out a khatha in his name as he
has been in possession of the suit property for over 50 years.
This unequivocally indicate acceptance and admission of
ownership of the respondent- State by the father of the
plaintiff over the suit property. There is nothing in the said
document to indicate that he has claimed he being in
possession of the suit property having illegally entered upon
and continuing to be in possession openly and adverse to the
interest of respondent-State Government.
The said letter
would only indicate that he is seeking regularization of his
unauthorised occupation. Same cannot be used to term and
prove he being in possession adverse to the true owner.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
21.
The Apex Court in the case of T.Anjanappa Vs
Somalingappa reported in (2006) 7 SCC 570 at paragraphs
12 to 15 has held as under:
12. The concept of adverse possession contemplates a hostile
possession i.e. a possession which is expressly or impliedly in
denial of the title of the true owner. Possession to be adverse
must be possession by a person who does not acknowledge the
other's rights but denies them. The principle of law is firmly
established that a person who bases his title on adverse
possession must show by clear and unequivocal evidence that
his possession was hostile to the real owner and amounted to
denial of his title to the property claimed. For deciding whether
the alleged acts of a person constituted adverse possession, the
animus of the person doing those acts is the most crucial factor.
Adverse possession is commenced in wrong and is aimed against
right. A person is said to hold the property adversely to the real
owner when that person in denial of the owner's right excluded
him from the enjoyment of his property.
13. Possession to be adverse must be possession by a person
who does not acknowledge the other's rights but denies them:
“24. It is a matter of fundamental principle of law that where
possession can be referred to a lawful title, it will not be
considered to be adverse. It is on the basis of this principle that
it has been laid down that since the possession of one co-owner
can be referred to his status as co-owner, it cannot be
considered adverse to other co-owners.”
(See Vidya Devi v. Prem Prakash [(1995) 4 SCC 496] , SCC p.
504, para 24.)
14. Adverse possession is that form of possession or occupancy
of land which is inconsistent with the title of the rightful owner
and tends to extinguish that person's title. Possession is not held
to be adverse if it can be referred to a lawful title. The person
setting up adverse possession may have been holding under the
rightful owner's title e.g. trustees, guardians, bailiffs or agents.
Such persons cannot set up adverse possession:
“14. … Adverse possession means a [hostile
possession] which is expressly or impliedly in denial
of title of the true owner. Under Article 65 [of the
Limitation Act,] burden is on the defendants to
prove affirmatively. A person who bases his title on
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
adverse possession must show by clear and
unequivocal evidence i.e. possession was hostile to
the real owner and amounted to a denial of his title
to the property claimed. In deciding whether the
acts, alleged by a person, constitute adverse
possession, regard must be had to the animus of
the person doing those acts which must be
ascertained from the facts and circumstances of
each case. The person who bases his title on
adverse possession, therefore, must show by clear
and unequivocal evidence i.e. possession was
hostile to the real owner and amounted to a denial
of his title to the property claimed. …
15. Where possession can be referred to a lawful title, it will not
be considered to be adverse. The reason being that a person
whose possession can be referred to a lawful title will not be
permitted to show that his possession was hostile to another's
title. One who holds possession on behalf of another, does not
by mere denial of that other's title make his possession adverse
so as to give himself the benefit of the statute of limitation.
Therefore, a person who enters into possession having a lawful
title, cannot divest another of that title by pretending that he
had
no
title
at
all.
(See Annasaheb
Bapusaheb
Patil v. Balwant [(1995) 2 SCC 543, p. 554 : AIR 1995 SC 895,
p. 902] , SCC p. 554, paras 14-15.)
22.
As rightly taken note of by the trial Court, even if
there are certain entries made in the revenue records, that by
itself do not become the basis/ground to seek relief of
declaration of title based on adverse possession. The Apex
Court in the case of Vishwa Vijay Bharati Vs. Fakhrul
Hassan and Others reported in (1973) 3 SCC 642
paragraphs 14 and 15 has held as under:
14. It is true that the entries in the revenue record ought,
generally, to be accepted at their face value and courts should
not embark upon an appellate inquiry into their correctness.
But the presumption of correctness can apply only to genuine,
not forged or fraudulent, entries. The distinction may be fine
at
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
but it is real. The distinction is that one cannot challenge the
correctness of what the entry in the revenue record states but
the entry is open to the attack that it was made fraudulently or
surreptitiously. Fraud and forgery rob a document of all its
legal effect and cannot found a claim to possessory title.
23.
Adverting to claim made for declaration of title by
adverse possession based on tax paid receipts the Apex Court
in the case of Kurella Naga Druva Vudaya Bhaskara Rao
Vs. Galla Janikamma reported in (2008) 15 SCC 150 at
paragraph 19 has held as under:
19. The defendant claimed that he had perfected his title by
adverse possession by being in open, continuous and hostile
possession of the suit property from 1957. He also produced
some tax receipts showing that he has paid the taxes in regard
to the suit land. Some tax receipts also showed that he paid
the tax on behalf of someone else. After considering the oral
and documentary evidence, both the courts have entered a
concurrent finding that the defendant did not establish adverse
possession, and that mere possession for some years was not
sufficient to claim adverse possession, unless such possession
was hostile possession, denying the title of the true owner. The
courts have pointed out that if according to the defendant, the
plaintiff was not the true owner, his possession hostile to the
plaintiff's title will not be sufficient and he had to show that his
possession was also hostile to the title and possession of the
true owner. After detailed analysis of the oral and
documentary evidence, the trial court and the High Court also
held that the appellant was only managing the properties on
behalf of the plaintiff and his occupation was not hostile
possession.
24. Thus, even the documentary evidence produced by the
plaintiff as per Exs.P1 to P9 are of no avail. The plaintiff has
failed to prove he having perfected title over the suit property
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:5522
RFA No.1177 of 2009
HC-KAR
for adverse possession and the trial Court has committed no
error.
Points are answered accordingly.
25.
For the aforesaid reasons and analysis, the appeal
fails, the trial court has rightly dismissed the suit of the
plaintiff
and
accordingly
the
Regular
First
dismissed.
Sd/(M.G.S. KAMAL)
JUDGE
ARK
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 1
Appeal
is
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review