Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 25TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S. KAMAL
WRIT PETITION NO.30620 OF 2009 (GM-RES)
C/W
WRIT PETITION NO.30621 OF 2009 (GM-RES)
IN WRIT PETITION NO.30620 OF 2009
BETWEEN:
1.
SRI. N. R. VENKATA REDDY,
(SINCE DEAD BY LR'S)
1(a). SMT. VARALAKSHMI,
W/O LATE. N. R. VENKATAREDDY,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
R/A. NIMMAKAYALAHALLI VILLAGE,
NANDIGANAHALLI POST,
MURAGAMALLAHOBLI,
CHINTAMANI TALUK,
CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT.
Digitally signed
by MANJANNA E
Location: high
court of
karnataka,
dharwad bench
1(b). SRI. N. V. RAGHUNATHA,
S/O LATE. N. R. VENKATAREDDY,
AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS,
R/A. NIMMAKAYALAHALLI VILLAGE,
NANDIGANAHALLI POST,
MURAGAMALLAHOBLI,
CHINTAMANI TALUK,
CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT.
1(c). SRI. N. V. HARISH,
S/O. LATE. N. R. VENKATAREDDY,
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS,
R/A NIMMAKAYALAHALLI VILLAGE,
NANDIGANAHALLI POST,
MURAGAMALLAHOBLI,
CHINTAMANI TALUK,
-2-
CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT.
1(d). SMT. N. V. SUMA,
D/O LATE. N. R. VENKATAREDDY,
AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS,
R/A. PALAYAKERE VILLAGE & POST,
CHELURHOBLI,
BAGEPALLI TALUK,
CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT.
1(e). SMT. N. V. NAVITHA,
D/O LATE. N. R. VENKATAREDDY,
AGED ABOUT 29 YEARS,
R/A GORAVIMAKALA VILLAGE,
LAKSHMIPURA POST
NELAVANKI HOBLI
SRINIVASAPURA TALUK
KOLAR DISTRICT.
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. SADASHIVA REDDY., Y.R. ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. RAHUL S. REDDY., ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
KARNATAKA STATE KHADI & VILLAGE
INDUSTREIS BOARD
NO.10, JASMA BHAVAN ROAD
BANGALORE
REP BY SPL TAHSILDAR.
2.
MEERA SHERIFF
SINCE DEAD BY LRS
2(a). SMT. ZAHARABI,
W/O. LATE. MEERASHARIEF,
AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS,
2(b). SRI. ZAHEER,
S/O. LATE MEERASHARIEF,
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
-3-
2(c).
SRI. ZAMEER,
S/O. LATE. MEERASHARIEF,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
2(d). SRI. AHMED,
S/O. LATE. MEERASHARIEF,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
2(e). SRI. MOULA,
S/O. LATE. MEERASHARIEF,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
2(f)
SRI. MAQSOOD SHARIEF,
S/O. LATE. MEERASHARIEF,
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS,
3.
PEDDAPPA REDDPPA,
S/O VENKATARAYAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS
RESPONDENTS NO.2 AND 3 ARE
R/AT NIMMAKAYALAHALLI
NANDIGANAHALLI POST
MURUGAMALA HOBLI
CHIN TAMANI TALUK
CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT - 563 125.
4.
G.M.VENKATAREDDY
SINCE DEAD BY LR'S
4(a) AKKALAMMA,
W/O. LATE. G. M. VENKATA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS,
R/A. ALAVATTA NIMMAKAYALAHALLI,
CHINTAMANI TALUK,
CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT.
-4-
4(b) RATHNAMMA,
W/O JAYARAM REDDY,
D/O. LATE. G.M. VENKATA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
R/A. NIMMAKAYALAHALLI VILLAGE,
NANDIGANAHALLI HOBLI,
CHINTAMANI TALUK,
CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT.
4(c) SHAKUNTALAMMA,
W/O. SRINIVASAGOWDA,
D/O. LATE. G.M. VENKATA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
R/A: CHIKKAVALLUR VILLAGE,
BEGUR POST, HOSKOTE TALUK,
BANGALORE RURAL DISTRICT.
4(d) SHIVA REDDY,
S/O. LATE. G.M. VENKATA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
R/A. ALAVATTA NIMMAKAYALAHALLI,
CHINTAMANI TALUK,
CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT.
4(e) MANJUNATH REDDY,
S/O LATE.G.M. VENKATA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
R/A. ALAVATTA NIMMAKAYALAHALLI.
CHINTAMANI TALUK,
CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT.
4(f) DEEPIKA,
D/O. LATE. G.M. VENKATA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS,
R/A. ALAVATTA NIMMAKAYALAHALLI,
CHINTAMANI TALUK,
CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT.
4(g) CHERITH REDDY,
S/O. LATE. G.M. VENKATA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 11 YEARS,
R/A. ALAVATTA NIMMAKAYALAHALLI,
CHINTAMANI TALUK, CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT.
-5-
SINCE RESPONDENT 4(G) IS A MINOR
REPRESENTED BY ITS NATURAL GUARDIAN MOTHER
YASHODAMMA,
W/O. LATE. G.M. VENKATA REDDY,
R/A. ALAVATTA NIMMAKAYALAHALLI,
CHINTAMANI TALUK,
CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. PRAKASH T HEBBAR, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
R2-(A-F) ARE SERVED BUT UNREPRESENTED;
SRI. V. VINOD REDDY., ADVOCATE FRO R3;
R4 (B TO E) ARE SERVED BUT UNREPRESENTED;
R4 (B TO G) ARE LR'S OF R4(A)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO
QUASH THE ANN-E, DATED 30.07.2009, ISSUED BY THE R1, &
ANN-F, DATED 26.08.2009, PASSED BY THE R1; DIRECT THE
R1, TO ACCEPT THE PAYMENT OF THE PETITIONER & PASS
SUCH OTHER ORDER.
IN WRIT PETITION NO.30621 OF 2009
BETWEEN:
R NARAYANASWAMY
AGED ABOUT 42 YEAS,
S/O LATE RAMANNAR/AT NIMMAKAYALAHALLI
NANDIGANAHALLI POST
MURUGAMALA HOBLI
CHINTAMANI TALUK
CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT - 563 125.
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. PRAKASH M.H., ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
KARNATAKA STATE KHADI & VILLAGE
INDUSTRIES BOARD
NO.10, JASMA BHAVAN ROAD
-6-
BANGALORE
REP BY SPL TAHSILDAR.
2.
MEERA SHERIFF
S/O ABDULLA SHERIFF
AGED ABOUT 70
3.
PEDDA REDDPPA
S/O VENKATARAYAPPA
AGED ABOUT0 42 YEARS
RESPONDENTS NO.2 AND 3 ARE
R/AT NIMMAKAYALAHALLI
NANDIGANAHALLI POST
MURUGAMALA HOBLI
CHINTAMANI TALUK
CHIKBALLAPUR - 563 125.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. SHRIDHAR HEGDE, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
SRI. DIVYA K., ADVOCATE FOR R2;
SRI. VINOD REDDY., ADVOCATE FOR R3)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO
QUASH ANNEXURE-C, DATED 30.07.2009, ISSUED BY THE
R1,VIDE ANNEXURE-D, DATED 26.08.2009, PASSED BY THE
R1; DIRECT THE R1, TO ACCEPT THE PAYMENT OF THE
PETITIONER AND PASS SUCH OTHER ORDER.
THESE WRIT PETITIONS HAVING BEEN HEARD AND
RESERVED ON 08.07.2026 FOR ORDER COMING ON FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY, THIS COURT MADE THE
FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S. KAMAL
-7-
CAV ORDER
1.
Petitioners in these two petitions are before this Court
seeking common reliefs in the nature of:
I. Quashment of the public auction notification issued by
the Respondent No. 1 vide No.KB/VT/RRC 201-208/94/0910 dated 30.07.2009 and the consequent auctions
proceedings dated 26.08.2009 conducted by the
Respondent No.1.
II. Issue Writ or Order or direction to the Respondent No.1
to accept the payment from the Petitioners and pass such
other order as this Hon'ble Court deems fit to grant in the
facts and circumstances of the case, in the interest of
justice and equity.''
2.
Brief facts in both the petitions are as follows:
2.1 That
petitioner-Sri.N.R.Venkata
Reddy
in
W.P.No.30620/2009 is the absolute owner of;
a. land bearing Sy.No.37, measuring 2 acres, out of 6
acres and 16 guntas, situated at Guntapalli Village,
Murugamalai Hobli, Chintamani Taluk.
b. portion of house bearing Khatha No.177, house list
No.111, measuring East to West 18 feet and North to
South 25 feet, situated at Nimmakayalahalli Village,
Murugamalai Hobli, Chintamani Taluk,
having purchased the same from its original owner,
namely Sri. Meera Sheriff-respondent No.2 in terms of
-8-
registered
deeds
of
sale
dated
22.08.1994
and
petitioner-Sri.R.Narayanaswamy,
in
18.11.1996 respectively.
2.2
That
the
W.P.No.30621/2009, is the absolute owner of;
a. Land
bearing
situated
at
Sy.No.20/P24,
Guntapalli
Chintamani Taluk,
measuring
Village,
Which was
acres,
Murugamalai
Hobli,
purchased by his
mother in terms of the deed of sale dated 18.11.1996
the same from its original owner, namely Sri. Meera
Sheriff-respondent
No.2,
thereafter
having
been
released in favor of the petitioner in terms of the deed
of release dated 21.04.2001.
2.3
That the petitioners had verified all the documents, prior
to the purchase of the aforesaid properties. That on
enquiry they had found that in the RTC extract pertaining
to land in Sy.No.37, there was a mention of a mortgage
in favour of VSSN Society. The petitioners accordingly
discharged the said loan of VSSN Society and had
obtained a no-objection certificate, and only thereafter
they purchased the same. Ever since the purchase, the
petitioners have been in peaceful possession.
-9-
2.4
That on 30.09.2009, respondents Nos. 3 and 4 had come
to the village of the petitioners and had told them that
they had purchased the aforesaid properties of the
petitioners in a public auction held at the Divisional Office
of
Chikkaballapura.
The
petitioners
immediately
approached respondent No.1 and learnt that respondent
No.2, who is the vendor of the petitioners, had availed
financial assistance in a sum of Rs.1,10,000/- against the
properties
purchased
by
the
petitioners
without
discharging the said amount and by suppressing these
facts had sold the same in favour of the petitioners.
2.5
That the petitioners obtained copies of the impugned
public auction notice dated 30.07.2009 and the auction
proceedings dated 26.08.2009 and found that the public
auction notice dated 30.07.2009 was not published as
required under law and the auction dated 26.08.2009 was
not conducted in accordance with the law.
2.6
Thus, being aggrieved by the said
public auction
conducted by respondent No.1, in which respondents
Nos.3 and 4 were declared to be the successful bidders;
the petitioners are before this Court seeking the reliefs as
noted hereinabove.
- 10 -
3.
Objection statement has been filed by respondent No.1,
contending inter-alia:
3.1 That respondent No.2 had obtained loan of Rs.1,10,000/on 01.04.1991 for the purpose of establishing Copper,
Brass and Bell Metal Industry.
3.2 That he had executed a simple mortgage in favour of the
respondent No.1 in respect of four items of landed
Properties. That execution of the said mortgage was duly
reflected in the Encumbrance Certificate issued by the
Sub-Registrar, Chintamani Taluk, vide certificate dated
02.04.1991 in W.P.No.30621/2009 and 03.04.1991 in
W.P.No.30620/2009.
3.3 That the respondent No.2 failed to repay the loan amount
and interest accrued thereon. Respondent No.1 had issued
notice dated 22.09.1994 to respondent No.2 in Form
No.37.
3.4 That the respondent No.2 became chronic defaulter. As
such, Chairman of the Karnataka State Khadi & Village
Industries Board, requested the Deputy Commissioner
Kolar to recover sum of Rs.1,36,121/- in terms of Section
22A of the Karnataka Khadi & Village Industries Act, 1956
- 11 -
(hereinafter referred to as 'the Act, 1956').
Accordingly,
respondent No.1 passed the order of attachment on
01.10.1996 in respect of the mortgaged properties.
3.5 That the respondent No.2 was thus prohibited from
alienating or transferring the aforesaid properties in any
manner.
3.6 That public auction notice dated 30.07.2009 was issued by
respondent No.1 in accordance with Section 22A of the
Act, 1956. The Deputy Commissioner has been vested
with authority to recover the dues of respondent No.2 as
arrears of land revenue.
3.7 That the petitioners, being third parties, have no right to
challenge when, admittedly, the said amount has not been
paid.
3.8 That the auction notice had been published in "Samyuktha
Karnataka", Kannada daily newspaper, dated 15.08.2009,
and the auction was conducted in accordance with law.
3.9
That
the
petitioners
cannot
challenge
the
auction
proceedings dated 26.08.2009 on the ground of having
purchased the properties from respondent No.2, as they
deemed to have had knowledge of the mortgage deed
- 12 -
executed by respondent No.2 in favour of the Khadi and
Village Industries Board.
3.10 That as many as 11 bidders participated in the auction
proceedings and respondent No.3 became the successful
bidder. The said auction proceedings cannot be set at
naught at the instance of petitioners. Hence, sought for
dismissal of the petition.
4.
Respondent No.3 filed statement of objections contending
inter-alia;
4.1 That respondent No.2, who had defaulted in discharging
the loan liability, did not pay the amount despite service of
notice by respondent No.1.
4.2
That
respondent
No.1
has
therefore
initiated
the
proceedings under the provisions of the Act, 1956 as
recovery of land revenue.
4.3 That an order of attachment was passed on 05.02.2001
under Section 165 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act,
(hereinafter
referred
to
as
"the
Act,
1964").
Subsequently, Special Tahsildar (Recovery), Karnataka
State Khadi and Village Industries Board, Bengaluru
Division, Bengaluru had issued written notice in prescribed
- 13 -
Form No.38 under Sections 113 and 124 of the Karnataka
Land
Revenue
Rules,
1966,
for
sale
of
immovable
properties specified therein at a public auction to realize a
sum of Rs.3,30,530/-, due and payable by respondent
No.2 to respondent No.1.
4.4 That the Special Tahsildar (Recovery), Karnataka State
Khadi and Village Industries Board, Bengaluru Division,
Bengaluru had issued notification of the sale of immovable
properties in "Samyuktha Karnataka", Kannada Daily
Newspaper, dated 30.07.2009, fixing the sale of properties
in public auction on 26.08.2009.
In addition, hand bills
were also circulated and 11 persons had participated.
4.5 That respondent No.3, being the highest bidder, was
declared successful bidder and made the payment in
accordance with law.
4.6 The Special Tahsildar (Recovery), Karnataka State Khadi
and Village Industries Board, Bengaluru Division, had
issued a letter dated 29.10.2009 to the Senior SubRegistrar, Chintamani Taluk, for registration of the sale
certificate and to exempt him from personal appearance.
4.7 That
petitioners
who
claim
to
have
purchased
the
properties in question from respondent No.2 under the
- 14 -
registered deeds of sale five years after the execution of
the
registered
Mortgage
Deed
on
01.04.1991
by
respondent No.2 in favour of respondent No.1.
4.8 That the said deed of mortgage is binding on the
petitioners. The covenants in the mortgage run with the
land and the house property in question, and the deed of
sale would not affect the subject matter of the transaction
under the deed of mortgage dated 01.04.1991.
4.9 That respondent No.2, being the absolute owner of the
property, had created a mortgage of the properties in
favour of respondent No.1. He was under a legal obligation
to clear the loan availed from respondent No.1. As he
became a defaulter in repaying the loan amount, action to
recover the said amount was initiated completely in
accordance with law, warranting no interference at the
hands of this Court.
Hence, sought dismissal of the
petition.
5.
Respondent No.2 filed the statement of objections denying
the claim of the petitioners and contended;
5.1 That the transaction entered into between the petitioners
and
respondent
No.2
under
deeds
of
sale
dated
- 15 -
22.08.1994 and 18.11.1996 was nominal and was only to
secure the loan amount advanced to respondent No.2. It
was never intended to be acted upon, as the sale
consideration mentioned in the said deeds of sale was far
less than the actual market price on the date of the
alleged deeds of sale.
5.2
That
respondent
No.2
had
also
filed
a
suit
in
O.S.No.66/2008 on the file of the Civil Judge (Jr. Dn.),
Chintamani for a direction to the petitioners herein to
execute registered deeds of sale in favour of respondent
No.2 in respect of the aforesaid properties.
5.3 That respondent No.2 had also filed another suit in
O.S.No.243/2008 on the file of the Civil Judge (Jr. Dn.),
Chintamani, seeking a declaration that the alleged deed of
sale dated 22.08.1994, executed by respondent No.2 in
favour of the petitioner, was null and void.
5.4 That the petitioner had also filed a suit in O.S.No.32/2008
on the file of the Civil Judge (Jr. Dn.),
Chintamani,
seeking a declaration only with respect to house property.
5.5 That respondent No.2 had mortgaged the properties in
question in favour of respondent No.1 and due to financial
difficulty, he could not clear the aforesaid loan.
- 16 -
5.6 That respondent No.1 auctioned the same in accordance
with law, and the balance amount which is in excess of the
amount due from respondent No.2 to respondent No.1,
has not been paid to respondent No.2.
In any event,
execution of the deeds of sale in favour of the petitioners
was subject to the terms of the deed of mortgage. It is for
the petitioners to have the mortgage redeemed and
perfect their title, and the petitioners have not taken any
steps in this regard.
Contending as above, respondent
No.2 sought dismissal of the petitions.
6.
Respondent No.4 filed statement of objections contending
that respondent No.4 had purchased the house property in
the said public auction. He reiterated the averments made
by the other respondents.
Submissions:
7.
Sri.Y.R.Sadashiva Reddy, learned Senior Counsel, along
with learned counsel for the petitioners, taking this Court
through the records, submitted;
7.1 That respondent No.1 conducted the auction of the
properties in furtherance to the provisions of Section 22A
- 17 -
of the Act, 1956 which mandates the auction proceedings
to be conducted as per the procedure contemplated under
the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964 (the Act, 1964).
7.2 That there was a violation of Section 157(2) of the Act,
1964.
In case of any default by any person who is
primarily liable under the said provision, the land revenue,
including arrears, shall be recoverable from the person
who is in possession of the land. Since the petitioners had
purchased the properties in 1994 and were in possession
of them, and all revenue records, including RTC extracts,
stood in their names, the respondent-Authority had not
issued any notice or intimation to the petitioners before
conducting the public auction.
7.3 That there is a violation of the provisions of Sections 161(a)
and (b) of the Act, 1964, in that the respondentauthorities ought to have proceeded against the movables
of the defaulter; only if the said movables were insufficient
should respondent No. 1 have proceeded against the
immovable properties, which was not followed in the
instant case.
7.4 That the respondent No.1, on the other hand, directly
proceeded against the immovable properties. Thus, there
- 18 -
is a violation of the provisions of Section 161 of the Act,
1964.
7.5 He also pointed out that there is a violation of the
procedure contemplated in publishing Form No.38, as
prescribed under the Karnataka Land Revenue Rules,
1966. In that, it is mandatory to notify the person in
occupation of the subject land and to intimate him
regarding the public auction.
7.6 Though the revenue records, as on the date of the auction,
reflected the name of the petitioners, they have not been
shown
as
persons
in
occupation
in
the
particulars
mentioned in Form No. 38. As such, there is a clear
violation.
7.7 In terms of Section 176 of the Act, 1964, any person
holding an interest in the said property may, at any time
within 90 days of the date of sale, apply for setting aside
the sale. The Authorities concerned were required to
conduct a summary enquiry and pass necessary orders
thereon.
7.8 In the instant case, the auction was conducted on
26.08.2009 and the petitioner made the representation on
12.10.2009, i.e., within 90 days. Since the Deputy
- 19 -
Commissioner had delegated the powers for conducting
the auction to the Tahsildar, representations were also
given to the concerned Tahsildar. However, no enquiry has
been conducted and no order has been passed. The
confirmation of sale made on 12.10.2009 was within 90
days. As such, there is a gross violation of Section 176 of
the Act, 1964.
7.9 As per Section 177 of the Act, 1964 the confirmation can be
made by the Deputy Commissioner only if no applications
were filed even after the expiry of 90 days from the date
of the auction.
7.10 It is also alleged that there is no compliance with the
requirement of Rule 126 of the Karnataka Land Revenue
Rules, 1966 which mandates conducting such auction
within the town or village in which the land is situated.
7.11 He relies upon the judgment of the Division Bench of this
Court in W.A.No.639/2009 passed on 13.01.2023 in the
case of C Rajamallaiah S/o Late Venkaiah
v. State of
Karnataka and sought for allowing of the writ petition.
8.
Sri. Prakash T. Hebbar, learned counsel appearing for
respondent
submitted:
No.1,
referring
to
the
synopsis
filed,
- 20 -
8.1 That the encumbrance certificate dated 03.04.1991 issued
by the Sub-Registrar, Chintamani, reflects the entries of
the mortgage created by respondent No.2 in favour of
respondent No.1. Thus, when the petitioner purchased the
property from respondent No.2 in the year 1994, it was
subject to the prior charge created by respondent No.2 in
favour of respondent No.1.
8.2 He refers to the letter dated 12.10.2009 submitted by the
petitioner to respondent No.1, acknowledging the loan,
requesting waiver of interest and offering to pay the
principal amount, and submitted that the same amounts
to unambiguous admission on the part of the petitioners
regarding
existence
of
mortgage
debt
and
right
of
respondent No.1 to recover the said amount.
8.3 That the petitioners having acknowledged the right of
respondent No.1 to recover the amount through public
auction, cannot now seek to challenge the validity of the
very proceedings as the same amounts to approbate and
reprobate, which is impermissible.
8.4 That the petitioners are strangers and not being parties to
the mortgage. They are neither judgment-debtors nor
- 21 -
borrowers and that they have no contractual relationship
with respondent No.1.
8.5 That respondent No.2, who is the judgment-debtor and the
borrower, has not questioned the public auction conducted
by respondent No.1. The petitioners, who claim to be the
purchasers have no locus-standi to challenge the public
auction.
8.6 That the sale of the land was on 22.08.1994, and the sale
of
the
house
was
on
18.11.1996.
All
these
were
subsequent to the mortgage and the initiation of the
proceedings for recovery. The transaction between the
petitioners and respondent No.2 is voidable under Section
53 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
8.7 That the petitioners are not bonafide purchasers for value,
as the transaction of mortgage deed dated 30.03.1991
was reflected in the Encumbrance Certificate deed dated
03.04.1991, which was notice to the world at large. That
the sale certificate dated 29.10.2009, issued in Form
No.41 in favour of Respondent Nos.3 and 4, who have paid
the consideration by demand drafts and the sale certificate
not having been challenged by the
mortgagor
i.e.,
- 22 -
respondent No.2 or by the petitioners, a validly conducted
public auction cannot be set at naught.
8.8 That the petitioners have not availed themselves of the
statutory remedy available under Section 176 of the Act,
1964, by filing an application before confirmation of the
sale on the alleged grounds of material irregularity of
fraud.
8.9
That
suits
in
O.S.No.32/2008
O.S.No.66/2008, O.S.No.243/2008 and
are
pending
consideration,
and
the
petitioners' rights, if any, could be adjudicated in the said
suits.
That in view of the alternative remedy provided
thereunder, the present petition under Article 226 is not
maintainable.
8.10 That, in terms of Section 177 of the Act, 1964, the sale
shall be confirmed within 90 days from the date of the
auction. In the instant case, the auction was conducted on
26.08.2009, confirmation was accorded on 03.10.2009,
and the sale certificate was issued on 29.10.2009. Thus,
the entire process was completed within a period of 90
days as contemplated under Section 177 of the Act, 1964.
- 23 -
8.11 That the petitioners were required to invoke the provisions
of Section 176 of the Act, 1964, by making an application
before issuance of the sale confirmation certificate . The
petitioners, not having availed themselves of the remedy,
cannot invoke Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
8.12 That even if there were any irregularity, the petitioners
are required to prove substantial injury, which is absent in
the instant case. The objections raised with regard to the
delegation of power by respondent No. 1 by Government
Notification dated 30.08.1969, issued in exercise of the
power under Section 195 of the Act, 1964, are untenable,
as the Tahsildar in charge of Taluks is empowered to
exercise powers under Section 168.
8.13 In addition, the Deputy Commissioner, Kolar District, had
issued specific authorization vide letter dated 17.07.2004,
specifically authorizing the Special Tahsildar (Recovery),
Karnataka State Khadi and Village Industries Board, to
recover the arrears of land revenue within the meaning of
Sections 8 and 190 of the Act, 1964.
8.14 That Section 157(2) of the Act, 1964, pertains to land
revenue liability and not mortgage enforcement notices.
Debt arising from a contractual or mortgage liability
- 24 -
cannot be equated with land revenue. The notice was
issued to all three mortgagors under Section 168(1) of the
Act, 1964.
8.15
That
written
individually
auction
served
on
notices
in
all
mortgagors,
the
Form
No.38
were
namely,
respondent No.2-Meera Sheriff, Smt.Zaharabi W/o Meera
Sheriff and Sri. Mahaboob Pasha. Thus, there is complete
compliance with regard to the provisions of Section 168(1)
of the Act, 1964.
8.16 That the petitioners, though claimed to have purchased
the properties in the year 1994, had not obtained
mutation of their names in the revenue records, at least
until the public auction conducted in the year 2009.
Possession derived under a voidable transfer cannot
override a prior registered mortgage.
8.17 Reliance placed by the learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the petitioners on the judgment of the Division Bench
of this Court passed in W.A.No.639/2009, with regard to
the operation of Sections 168, 169, 174, 175, 176, 177
and Rule 124 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act and
Rules, is not applicable to the facts and circumstances of
the present case. All auction procedures have been
- 25 -
conducted and followed in accordance with the provisions
provided under Sections 168, 169, 174, 175, 176, 177 and
Rule 124 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act and Rules.
Contending as above, sought for dismissal of the petition.
9.
Learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos.3 and 4
adopted the arguments of respondent No.1.
10. Heard and perused the records.
11.
Points that arise for consideration are:
(1) Whether the petitioners are justified in contending that the
sale transactions entered into by them with respondent No.2,
are not affected by the prior mortgage created by respondent
No. 2 in favour of respondent No. 1?
(2) Whether the petitioners have made out a case for quashing the
public auction of the subject immovable properties conducted
on 26.08.2009 by respondent No. 1?
Regarding Point No.1
12. There is no dispute about the fact that respondent No.2
had availed himself of financial assistance from respondent
No. 1 against the security of the aforesaid four landed
properties and one item of residential property created in
terms of the simple deeds of mortgage dated 30.03.1991,
which were registered in the office of the Sub-Registrar,
Chintamani.
Encumbrance certificates produced by the
- 26 -
respondents along with the statement of objections reflect
the
subsistence
of
the
said
mortgage
even
as
on
03.04.1991.
13. The petitioners, however, claim to have purchased the said
properties from respondent No. 2 in terms of deeds of sale
dated 22.08.1994 and 18.11.1996. Thus, the execution of
deeds of sale by respondent No. 2 in favour of the
petitioners, conveying the aforesaid properties admittedly
subsequent
to
the
execution
of
the
mortgage
by
respondent No. 2 in favour of respondent No. 1, would be
subject to the rights created in favour of respondent No.
1.
14.
Though
the
petitioners
have
pleaded
that
before
purchasing the properties they had verified the records
and the documents of title and found that the only
mortgage created over the subject properties was in
favour of VSSN society, which the petitioners claimed to
have
discharged
and
obtained
a
`No
Objection
Certificate'.
15. Learned counsel for the petitioners, however, relied upon
the Encumbrance Certificate dated 12.10.2009, produced
- 27 -
at Annexure-C to contend that the said document is for
the period between 01.04.1986 and 18.11.1996 and did
not reflect the mortgage that was created by respondent
No. 2 in favour of respondent No. 1.
16. There is no dispute about the creation of the mortgage by
respondent No. 2 in favour of respondent No. 1 as per
Annexure-R1 of the writ petition. The said document is
undisputedly a registered document. It is a settled
principle of law that registration of an instrument in
respect of an immovable property is notice to the world at
large. Besides, such execution of a document has indeed
been reflected in the Encumbrance Certificate dated
03.04.1991 produced at Annexure-R2 to the statement of
objection, which fact is not denied.
17.
The
Co-ordinate
Bench
of
this
Court
in
the
case
M Ramakrishna Reddy Vs. The Sub-Registrar and
another reported in ILR 1999 Kar 2033 at paragraphs 5
and 6 has held as under:
5. The petition proceeds on a misconception as to what is
an ‘Encumbrance Certificate’. It proceeds on the assumption
that it is a document of title and an entry therein by itself
affects the title of the owner. An Encumbrance Certificate
neither creates, nor affects title. It is not a document of title,
but a document giving the references of the deeds of title,
and encumbrances. A brief reference to the relevant
- 28 -
provisions of the Registration Act, 1908 (‘the Act’ for short),
the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (‘the TP Act’ for short)
and the Karnataka Registration Rules, 1965 (‘the Rules’ for
short) will be necessary to know the true meaning and effect
of an Encumbrance Certificate.
5.1. The object and intent of providing for registration of
instruments under the Act is to create and maintain a public
record of transactions relating to immovable properties, on
which every person dealing with an immovable property can
rely with confidence, for a full and complete account of the
transactions by which his title to the immovable property,
may be affected. Section 17 of the Act enumerates the
documents of which the registration is compulsory. All
instruments (except wills) which purport or operate to
create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish, whether in
present or in future, any right, title or interest, whether
vested or contingent, in regard to an immovable property,
the value of which is Rs. 100/- or more, and all Gift Deeds as
also leases relating to immovable properties for any term
exceeding one year, are compulsory registerable.
5.2. Section 3 of TP Act defines the terms “registered”
and “a person is said to have notice”. The word ‘registered’
means registered under the law for the time being in force
regulating registration of documents. ‘A person is said to
have notice’ of a fact, when he actually knows that fact, or
when, but for willful abstention from an inquiry or search
which he ought to have made, or gross negligence, he would
have known it. Explanation I, II and III to the said definition
refer to three classes of constructive notice. What is relevant
is, Explanation I [to Section 3 of the TP Act] which provides
that where any transaction relating to any immovable
property is required by law to be and has been effected by a
registered instrument, any person acquiring such property
(or part or share or interest in such property) shall be
deemed to have notice of such registered instruments,
provided (i) such instrument has been registered and its
registration completed in the manner prescribed by the Act
and the Rules thereunder; (ii) the instrument has been duly
entered or filed in the books kept under Section 51 of the
Act; and (iii) the particulars regarding the transaction to
which the instrument relates have been correctly entered in
the indexes kept under Section 55 of the Act. Thus, any
person who wants to deal with an immovable property is
deemed to have knowledge of all duly registered instruments
relating to the said immovable property.
5.3. Section 51 of the Act requires four books to be kept
and maintained in all registration offices, of which ‘Book No.
1’ is the Register of non-testamentary documents relating to
immovable property (registered under Section 17, 18 and 89
- 29 -
of the Act). Once the documents registered are copied/filed,
they have to be entered in current indexes. Section 54, of
the Act requires every registration office to prepare and
maintain current indexes of the contents of ‘Book No. 1’ and
that entries shall be made in such indexes immediately after
the registering office has copied/filed the documents. Section
55 requires two indexes to be maintainec regarding Book No.
1. Index No. 1 shall contain the names of persons executing
the document and persons claiming under every document
entered/filed in Book No. 1. Index No. II shall contain the
particulars (description with boundaries, etc.) of the property
and other particulars relating to every such document as
may be directed by the Inspector General from time to time.
Rule 125 prescribes the manner of preparing Indexes. Form
No. 16 relates to Index No. 1 (Nominal Index to Book No. 1).
Forms 17 and 17A relates to Form of Index No. 11
(Descriptive Index to Book No. 1).
5.4. Section 57 of the Act provides that subject to the
payment of prescribed fee, Book No. 1 and the indexes
relating to Book No. 1 shall be at all times open to inspection
by any person applying to inspect the same; and copies of
entries made therein shall be given to all persons applying
for such copies. Rule 148 of the Rules relates to issue of
Encumbrance Certificates. It provides that when an
application is made for a search for encumbrance in respect
of any immovable property and for issue of a Certificate of
Encumbrance should be furnished to him, the request should
be complied with by the Registering Officer and a certificate
should be issued in the prescribed form. Rule 151 provides
that a certificate of encumbrance shall contain a complete
list of all acts and encumbrances affecting the property in
question. The encumbrance certificate is issued in Form No.
15 when there are entries relating to the property and in
Form No. 16 when there are no entries. While issuing a
certificate in Form No. 15, the Registering Authority has to
mention in regard to each entry (transaction which has been
registered) the description of the property, date of
execution, nature and value of the documents, name of
executants, name of claimants under the documents and the
particulars of registration (Registration Number of the
document with year of registration and volume and page, of
Book No. 1 at which it is copied). The certificate contains a
caveat that though the requisite search has been made by
the office as carefully as possible, the Registration
department will not, on any account, hold itself responsible
for any errors in the results of the search embodied in the
certificate.
5.5. When an application for search of Book No. 1 and it
Indexes is made, the registration office goes through the
Indexes (I and II) and lists all transactions relating to the
property during the period for which such search has been
- 30 -
sought, in the form of Encumbrance certificate. Where no
entries are found in the Indexes, a nil encumbrance
certificate is issued. Thus; a certificate of Encumbrance
issued by a Registering Office is nothing but a list of
references/extract of entries relating to the specified
property, from Index Nos. I and II of Book No. 1 maintained
in the Registration Office.
6. In this context, it should be noticed that the term
‘encumbrance’ occurring in the ‘Encumbrance Certificate’ is
some what misleading. The term ‘encumbrance’ in law refers
to a burden, a charge, a legal claim, lien or liability attached
to or upon a property. In the strict sense of the word, a sale
or partition or release is not an encumbrance. Mortgage is an
encumbrance. An Encumbrance Certificate relating to an
immovable property issued by the Registration Office is not
only of encumbrances, but of “all acts and encumbrances
affecting such property”. It is an enumerations of all
documents relating to the specified immovable property,
which have been registered and entered in Book No. 1 (and
the Indexes relating to Book No. 1), during the period for
which search is sought. As an Encumbrance Certificate is
nothing but an extract of the entries in the Indexes relating
to Book No. 1, it is not a document of title.
18. In the instant case execution of deeds of sale by
respondent No.2 in favour of the petitioners, conveying
the aforesaid properties, appears to have taken place on
22.08.1994 and 18.11.1996, respectively, which is much
subsequent to the creation of the mortgage. Therefore,
merely because the encumbrance certificate obtained by
the petitioners as per Annexure-C did not mention the
mortgage created by
respondent No.2
in favour of
respondent No.1, petitioners cannot claim not to be bound
by the said mortgage.
- 31 -
19. An encumbrance certificate is basically a certificate that is
issued by the concerned Sub-Registrar, reflecting the
transactions that have taken place during a particular
period in respect of the immovable property concerned. It
is only in the nature of information; if there is any error in
the issuance of such a certificate, the same cannot be read
to
undo
the
effect
of
otherwise
valid
registration
contemplated under the Indian Registration Act and the
Transfer of Property Act.
20. The petitioners therefore cannot take advantage of the
non-reflection
of
the
mortgage
in
the
encumbrance
certificate produced by them as per Annexure-C, when the
document at Annexure-R2 produced by respondent No. 1,
as well as similar documents produced by respondent
Nos.3 and 4, reflect the execution of a simple mortgage by
respondent No.2 in favour of respondent No.1.
21. As rightly contended by the learned counsel for respondent
No.1, petitioners have neither disputed nor questioned the
mortgage deeds executed by respondent No.2 in favour of
respondent
No.1.
On
the
other
hand,
as
seen
at
Annexures-G and H, the petitioners themselves have
issued
a
communication
to
the
Special
Tahsildar
- 32 -
(Recovery), Karnataka State Khadi and Village Industries
Board, Bengaluru Division, Bengaluru, on 12.10.2009,
admitting and acknowledging the prior mortgage created
by their vendor, respondent No.2, in favour of respondent
No.1, and acknowledging that they had purchased the land
and residential property on 22.08.1994 and 18.11.1996.
Thus, there is a categorical admission on behalf of the
petitioners regarding the prior mortgage created by
respondent No.2 in favour of respondent No.1.
22. That apart, the petitioners themselves have expressed their
intention and readiness to settle the matter and have also
requested that the khatha not be affected in favour of the
auction bidder, besides seeking waiver of the interest
accrued on the principal borrowed amount.
23. This also indicates that the petitioners were completely
aware
of
the
mortgage,
conducted,
and
the
the
property
consequent
being
auction
purchased
by
respondent Nos.3 and 4 in the said auction proceedings.
Regarding Point No.2
24. Learned Senior counsel appearing for the petitioners,
sought to canvass that the auction proceedings conducted
- 33 -
by respondent No.1 are in violation of the provisions of
Sections 157(2) and 161 of the Karnataka Land Revenue
Act and Rule 126 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Rules,
1966.
25. In the instant case, what is sought to be recovered is the
loan amount which was lent by respondent No.1 in terms
of the mortgage deed, under the provisions of the
Karnataka Khadi and Village Industries Act, 1956.
26.
Section 22A of the Act, 1956 reads as under:
"22A. Recovery of money due to the Board as arrears of land
revenue.
(1) Where any sum of rupees one lakh and above is payable to the
Board under any agreement, express or implied or otherwise, however,
by any person, is not paid on or before the due date and remaining in
arrears after fifteen days from the date of service of a notice of
demand on such person by the Chief Executive Officer or any other
officer authorised by the Board in that behalf, may be recovered in any
one or more of the following ways namely:(a)
As an arrear of land revenue, on the written application of
Chief Executive Officer or any officer authorised by the Board in
this 'behalf certifying under his hand indicating the sum due' to
the Board to the Deputy Commissioner of any district in which
proceedings are required to be taken.
(b)
By destraint and sale of the movable and immovable property
of such person by any Officer authorised under the Karnataka
Land Revenue Act 1964 and rules made there under."
27. Sections 157(2) and 161 of the Karnataka Land Revenue
Act, 1964 reads as under;
" 157. Liability for revenue.—
(2) In the case of default by any person who is primarily liable
under this section, the land revenue including arrears as
aforesaid shall be recoverable from any person in possession of
- 34 -
the land: Provided that where such person is a tenant, the
amount recoverable from him shall not exceed the demands for
the year in which the recovery is made: Provided further that
when the land revenue is recovered under this section from any
person who is not primarily liable for the same, such person shall
be allowed credit for any payment which he may have duly made
to the person who is primarily liable, and shall be entitled to
credit, for the amount recovered from him in account with the
person who is primarily liable."
" 161. Process for recovery of arrears.— An arrear of land
revenue may after serving a written notice of demand on the
defaulter under section 162 be recovered by any one or more of the
following processes, namely:—
(a) by forfeiture of the occupancy or alienated holding in respect
of which the arrear is due, under section 163;
(b) by distraint and sale of the defaulter’s moveable property
including the produce of the land under section 164;
(c) by attachment and sale of the defaulter’s immoveable
property under sections 165 to 168;
(d) in the case of alienated holdings consisting of entire villages
or shares of villages, by attachment of the said villages or shares of
villages and taking them under Government management, under
sections 183 to 187."
28. Thus Section 157(2) of the Act, 1964, provides that in case
of default by any person who is primarily liable under this
Section, the land revenue including arrears as aforesaid
shall be recoverable from any person in possession of the
land.
As rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for
respondent No. 1, it is only for procedural convenience that
the provisions of Section 157(2) of the Act, 1964, are
required to be followed, while the amount to be recovered
is strictly under Section 22A of the Act, 1956.
29. Petitioners therefore cannot equate the mortgage due with
the land revenue. Further, even if the provisions under
Section 157(2) of the Act, 1964, are applied, in the event
- 35 -
of failure on the part of the person primarily liable to make
the payment, it is the person who is in possession of the
property who would become liable to make the payment.
Even on that count, the petitioners cannot seek to evade
the liability.
30.The auction notice has admittedly been served on the
borrower/mortgagors as required under Section 168(1) of
the Act, 1964, and there is no dispute with regard to
service of the notice on the actual borrowers, namely,
respondent No.2, and there is no claim of non-compliance
with the provisions of Section 161 of the Act, 1964.
31.The reliance placed by the learned Senior counsel appearing
for the petitioners, on the judgment of the Division Bench
of this Court passed in W.A.No.639/2009 is not applicable,
as
rightly
contended
by
learned
counsel
for
the
respondents. Also, in the said writ appeal, it was the
borrower who had approached the Court challenging the
procedure adopted in auctioning his property, whereas, in
the present proceedings, the borrower, namely, respondent
No.2, has not challenged the auction proceedings. It is only
the petitioners who claim to be the purchasers are seeking
- 36 -
to dispute the procedure adopted by the respondent No.1
in auctioning the subject properties.
32. That apart, respondent No.2 has disputed the nature of the
transaction that he had entered into with the petitioners,
contending that the said transaction was only as security
for the loan borrowed by respondent No.2 from the
petitioners and was never intended to be acted upon.
33. He also, as noted, referred to certain suits filed by him
against the petitioners, which are stated to be pending
consideration. Thus, if at all any person was aggrieved by
the public auction, it was respondent No.2 and not the
petitioners.
34. Petitioners having voluntarily made a representation on
12.10.2009 agreeing to pay and clear the outstanding
amount, have indeed confirmed and recognized the public
auction conducted by the respondent authorities and the
conveyance of the property in favour of respondent Nos.3
and 4. The petitioners have not chosen to challenge the
auction process by filing an application under Section 176
of the Act, 1964.
- 37 -
35. Though the learned Senior counsel sought to contend that
the
representations
dated
12.10.2009,
produced
at
Annexures-G and H, were such applications, this Court is
not persuaded to accept the same, inasmuch as the
petitioners herein have merely expressed their intention to
pay and settle the amount and have not sought to dispute
the auction proceedings, as now sought to be contended.
Appropriate to extract the applications at Annexures-G and
H filed by the petitioners which read as under:
ANNEXURE-G
Dt: 12.10.2009
From:
HARISH.N.V.,
S/o N.R.Venkatareddy,
R/at Nimmakayalahalli Village,
Murugamale Hobli, Chintamani Taluk,
Chikkaballapura.
To:
The Special Tahsildar,
Karnataka Khadi Board,
Behind Congress Office,
Bangalore.
Sir/Madam,
Sub: Regarding the payment of the Loan Amount borrowed by one
Mr.Meera Shariff resident of Nimmakayalahalli Village.
- 38 -
With reference to the above I submitted that my father
Sri.N.R.Venkatareddy had purchased Land property bearing
Sy.No.37, for an extent of 2 Acres situated at Guntapalli
Village, Murugamalai Hobli, Chintamani Taluk from one
Meera Shariff on 22.08.1994, but prior to that said Meera
Shariff have pledged the above mentioned property in your
board by way of Simple Mortgage dt: 13.03.1991.
Subsequently, on 26.08.2009 Khadi Board has auctioned
the said property. My father being the absolute owner in
possession has got no knowledge regarding the auction
proceedings. It is hereby submitted that we are ready to
settle the above matter by way of one time settlement. Till
then I request your goodselves to not to effect Khata in the
name of auction bidders and also request your goodself to
waive the interest amount accrued from the Principal
borrowed by said Meera Shareef, Kindly do the needful and
oblige.
Thanking you,
Yours faithfully,"
ANNEXURE-H
Dt: 12.10.2009
From:
HARISH.N.V.,
S/o N.R.Venkatareddy,
R/at Nimmakayalahalli Village,
Murugamale Hobli, Chintamani Taluk,
Chikkaballapura.
To:
The Special Tahsildar,
Karnataka Khadi Board,
Behind Congress Office,
Bangalore.
Sir/Madam,
Sub: Regarding the payment of the Loan Amount borrowed by
one Mr.Meera Shariff resident of Nimmakayalahalli Village.
- 39 -
With reference to the above I submitted that my father
Sri.N.R.Venkatareddy had purchased house property
No.177, House List No.111 measuring 18X25 out of 38X26,
situated at Nimmakayalahalli Village, Murugamalai Hobli,
Chintamani Taluk from one Meera Shariff on 18.11.1996,
but prior to that said Meera Shariff have pledged the above
mentioned property in your board by way of Simple
Mortgage dt: 13.03.1991.
Subsequently, on 26.08.2009 Khadi Board has auctioned
the said property. My father being the absolute owner in
possession has got no knowledge regarding the auction
proceedings. It is hereby submitted that we are ready to
settle the above matter by way of one time settlement. Till
then I request your goodselves to not to effect Khata in the
name of auction bidders and also request your goodself to
waive the interest amount accrued from the Principal
borrowed by said Meera Shareef, Kindly do the needful and
oblige.
Thanking you,
Yours faithfully,
36. Sections 176 and 177 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act,
1964 reads as under;
"176. Setting aside sale.
(1) Where immovable property has been sold under this Chapter,
the defaulter or any person owning such property or holding an
interest therein may, at any time within ninety days of the date of
sale, apply in the prescribed manner to the Deputy Commissioner
to have the sale set aside,(a) on the ground of some material irregularity or mistake or
fraud resulting in loss or injury to him; or
(b) on his depositing in the Deputy Commissioner's office the
amount of the arrear specified in the proclamation of sale the
cost of the sale, and for payment to the purchaser a sum equal
to five per centum of the purchase money.
(2) On an application made under clause (a) of sub-section (1), the
Deputy Commissioner shall, if he is satisfied after a summary
enquiry that there has been some material irregularity, mistake or
fraud in publishing or conducting the sale set aside the sale and
direct a fresh sale provided that no sale shall be set aside on the
ground of any irregularity or mistake unless it is proved that the
applicant has sustained loss or injury as a result of such irregularity
or mistake.
- 40 -
(3) on an application with the required deposit being made under
clause b of sub section 1 within the period specified therein the
deputy commissioner shall make an order setting aside the sale
provided that if more persons than one have made deposits and
applied under this section the application of the first depositor or in
case all the depositors agree to the application of any other
depositor being accepted the application of such depositor shall be
accepted."
" 177. Confirmation of sale.— If, on the expiration of ninety days
from the date of sale of any immoveable property, no application
has been made for setting aside the sale or if any such application
has been made and rejected, the Deputy Commissioner shall make
an order confirming the sale:
Provided that for reasons to be recorded, the Deputy
Commissioner may set aside the sale subject to such conditions as
he may deem proper, notwithstanding that no application therefor
has been made, or on grounds other than those alleged in any
application which has been made and rejected."
37. Section 176 of the Act, 1964 as noted above, operates in a
completely different context, which is not the case at hand.
Applications
filed
by
the
petitioners
as
extracted
hereinabove do not meet the requirement of law noted
above. Since no such applications were filed seeking to set
aside the sale deed, the confirmation of the sale made by
respondent No.1 in favour of respondent Nos.3 and 4
cannot be found fault with.
38. Under the aforesaid facts and circumstances of the case,
the reliance placed by the learned Senior counsel appearing
for the petitioners on the judgment of the Division Bench of
- 41 -
this Court passed in W.A.No.639/2009 is distinguishable
and is of no avail to the case of the petitioners.
39. Points raised above are answered accordingly.
40. For the aforesaid reasons and analysis, the following:
ORDER
(i) Writ petitions are dismissed.
Sd/(M.G.S. KAMAL)
JUDGE
RL
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review