Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:7021-DB
NAFR
ROHIT
KUMAR
CHANDRA
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Digitally signed
by ROHIT
KUMAR
CHANDRA
CRA No. 121 of 2026
Murli Manohar Markam S/o Late Shri Musru Markam Aged About 57
Years R/o Post Silyari, District Raipur (C.G.) (The Complainant)
--- Appellant
versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through - P.S. Dharsiwa, District Raipur
(C.G.)
2 - Vijay Rathore S/o Ramesh Rathore Aged About 20 Years R/o Ward
No. 12, Bajrang Para, Police Chowki Siliyari, Police Station Dharshiwa,
District Raipur (C.G.)
3 - Dinesh Solanki S/o Puran Solanki Aged About 23 Years R/o Ward
No. 12, Bajrang Para, Police Chowki Siliyari, Police Station Dharshiwa,
District Raipur (C.G.)
4 - Rohit Solanki S/o Balchand Solanki Aged About 19 Years R/o Ward
No. 12, Bajrang Para, Police Chowki Siliyari, Police Station Dharshiwa,
District Raipur (C.G.)
5 - Amit Solanki S/o Puran Solanki Aged About 27 Years R/o Ward No.
12, Bajrang Para, Police Chowki Siliyari, Police Station Dharshiwa,
District Raipur (C.G.)
6 - Puran Solanki S/o Late Premji Solanki Aged About 51 Years R/o
Ward No. 11, Bajrang Para, Police Chowki Siliyari, Police Station
Dharshiwa, District Raipur (C.G.)
7 - Hari Rathore S/o Late Mohanlal Rathore Aged About 52 Years R/o
Village Siliyari, Police Chowki Siliyari, Police Station Dharshiwa, District
Raipur (C.G.)
8 - Ratan Solanki S/o Premji Solanki Aged About 42 Years R/o Village
Siliyari, Police Chowki Siliyari, Police Station Dharshiwa, District Raipur
(C.G.)
--- Respondents
CRA No. 1422 of 2025
1 - Vijay Rathore S/o Ramesh Rathore Aged About 20 Years R/o Ward12, Bajrang Para, Police Chowki - Siliyari, Police Station - Dharshiwa,
District - Raipur (C.G.)
2 - Dinesh Solanaki S/o Puran Solanki Aged About 23 Years R/o Ward12, Bajrang Para, Police Chowki - Siliyari, Police Station - Dharshiwa,
District - Raipur (C.G.)
3 - Rohit Solanki S/o Balchand Solanki Aged About 19 Years R/o Ward12, Bajrang Para, Police Chowki - Siliyari, Police Station - Dharshiwa,
District - Raipur (C.G.)
4 - Amit Solanki S/o Puran Solanki Aged About 27 Years R/o Ward-12,
Bajrang Para, Police Chowki - Siliyari, Police Station - Dharshiwa,
District - Raipur (C.G.)
5 - Puran Solanki S/o Late Premji Solanki Aged About 51 Years R/o
Ward-11, Bajrang Para, Police Chowki - Siliyari, Police Station Dharshiwa, District - Raipur (C.G.)
6 - Hari Rathore S/o Late Mohan Lal Rathore Aged About 52 Years R/o
Village - Siliyari, Police Chowki - Siliyari, Police Station - Dharshiwa,
District - Raipur (C.G.)
7 - Ratan Solanki S/o Premji Solanki Aged About 42 Years R/o Village Siliyari, Police Chowki - Siliyari, Police Station - Dharshiwa, District Raipur (C.G.)
---Appellants
Versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through - S.H.O., Police Station - Dharsiwa,
District - Raipur (C.G.)
--- Respondent
(Cause Title taken from Case Information System)
________________________________________________________
For Appellant in CRA 121/2026 : Mr. Shubham Dwivedi,
Advocate
For Appellants in CRA 1422/2025 : Mr. B.P. Singh,
and respondent Nos. 2 to 7
Mr. Vidya Bhushan soni and
in CRA 121/2026
Mr. Shikhar Bakhriyar, Advocates
For Respondent/State
:
Mr. Shailendra Sharma,
Panel Lawyer
________________________________________________________
Hon'ble Mr. Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
09.02.2026
1.
Since both the above-captioned appeals arise out of a common
factual matrix and common judgment, this Court is disposing of
both these appeals by a common judgment.
2.
CRA No. 121 of 2026 has been filed by the appellant Murli
Manohar Markam for enhancement of sentence awarded to the
accused/ respondent Nos. 2 to 8 by the learned Special Judge
(SC/ST Act), Raipur, District – Raipur (C.G.) vide impugned order
dated 05.07.2025 in Special Sessions Case No. 12/2024,
whereby though the accused/ respondents have been convicted
under Sections 147, 148, 149, 325/149, 307/149 of IPC and
Section 3(2)(va) of the SC and ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act
and the accused/ respondents Dinesh (respondent No.3 and
Puran Solanki (respondent No.6) have also been convicted under
Section 25(1)(d) and 27 of the Arms Act, but they were sentenced
only to five years’ rigorous imprisonment under Section 307/149
and lesser concurrent terms under the other Sections.
3.
CRA No. 1422 of 2025 has been preferred by the convicts/
appellants against the impugned judgment of conviction and
order of sentence dated 05.07.2025 passed by the learned
Special Judge (SC/ST Act), Raipur, District – Raipur (C.G.) in
Special Sessions Case No. 12/2024, by which the appellants
have been convicted and sentenced in the following manner :CONVICTION
U/s 147 of IPC
SENTENCE
RI for 1 year and fine of Rs.1,000/- to
each of the appellant and in default of
payment of fine, additional RI for 1
month
RI for 1 year and fine of Rs.1,000/- to
U/s 148 of IPC
each of the appellant and in default of
payment of fine, additional RI for 1
U/s 325 r/w 149 of
month
RI for 2 years and fine of Rs.2,000/- to
IPC
each of the appellant and in default of
payment of fine, additional RI for 2
U/s 307 r/w 149 of
months
RI for 5 years and fine of Rs.5,000/- to
IPC
each of the appellant and in default of
payment of fine, additional RI for 5
U/s 3(2)(va) of SC &
months
RI for 1 year and fine of Rs.1,000/- to
ST
each of the appellant and in default of
(Prevention
of
Atrocities) Act
payment of fine, additional RI for 1
U/s 25(1)(a) of the
month
RI for 1 year and fine of Rs.1,000/- to
Arms Act
appellant Nos. 2 and 5 and in default
of payment of fine, additional RI for 1
U/s 27 of the Arms
month
RI for 3 years and fine of Rs.3,000/- to
Act
appellant Nos. 2 and 5 and in default
of payment of fine, additional RI for 3
months
with a direction to run all the sentences concurrently
4.
The case of the prosecution in brief is that on 27.12.2023 at 21.30
hrs, informant Murali Manohar Markam lodged a complaint at the
Dehati Nalisi that he is the Director of Gyan Vatika School, Silyari,
on 27.12.2023 at night around 9:30 PM, he was at home, and his
son, Kapish Markam, had gone out to take the dog of the house
for a ride. He called him on his mobile phone and informed him
that Puran Solanki had come in a Hyundai car with his friends,
armed with sticks, batons, and rods, in front of Saraswati Shishu
Mandir on Tresar Road, and were abusing and quarreling with
him over an old rivalry. Therefore, he should come quickly. Upon
receiving this information, the informant, along with his brother
Santosh Markam and son Chandan Singh, went to the spot
where Puran Solanki, Dinesh Solanki, Amit Solanki, Vijay
Rathore, Rohit Solanki, and others, acting in unison and declaring
that they would kill him today, attacked the informant's son,
Kapish, with sticks, batons, rods, and a knife, inflicting fatal
injuries on his left hand and both legs. When the informant, his
brother Santosh Markam, and his son Chandan Markam tried to
intervene, they threatened and assaulted them with sticks, rods,
and knives with the intent to kill them. The informant sustained
injuries to his forehead, near his eye, leg, and ribs, and the
informant's brother sustained injuries to both legs and hands, and
his son Chandan Markam also sustained injuries. The informant's
brother, both sons, and nearby residents witnessed and heard the
incident. The informant and the injured were taken to the
Dharsiwa Community Health Center for treatment by villagers.
After being referred to Mekahra, they were then taken to DKS
Hospital, where they are currently receiving treatment. The
informant's report has been registered as a zero offense in the
Dehati Nalishi. The injured were medically examined and Crime
No. 615/2023 was registered at Dharsiwa police station and after
complete investigation, the charge sheet was presented before
the Court of Special Judge (SC/ST Act), Raipur, District – Raipur
(C.G.).
5.
When charges were framed against accused Vijay Rathore, Dinesh
Solki, Rohit Solanki, Amit Solanki, Puran Solanki, Jhini Bai Solanki,
Harilal Rathore and Ratan Solanki under sections 147, 148, 149,
325/149 and 307/149 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and section 3
(2) (va) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention
of Atrocities) Act, 1989 and against accused Dinesh Solanki and
Puran Solanki under the said sections along with section 25(1) (a)
and section 27 of the Arms Act, 1959 and when read out and
explained to them, they denied having committed the crime and
when they were examined under section 313 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, they pleaded innocence.
6.
In support of its case, the prosecution has examined Narayan
Prasad Gupta (PW-01), Dr. S.R. Baghel (PW-02), Murali Manohar
Markam (PW-03), Kapish Markam (PW-04), Chandan Singh
Markam (PW-05), Subhashini Markam (PW-06), Santosh Markam
(PW-07), Annapurna Markam (PW-08) Ayub Saifi (PW-09), S.
Tarun Naidu (PW-10), Birbal Sahu (PW-11), Laxmi Narayan Verma
(PW-12), Vibhas Tiwari (PW-13), Dr. Sanjeev Kumar Khunte (PW14), Dr. Ramswaroop Markam (PW-15), Deepak Baghel (PW-16),
Abid Raza (PW-17) Ram Prakash Sahu (PW-18), Krishna Kumar
Yadav (PW-19), Rajendra Kumar Chandrakar (PW-20), Manoj
Kumar Patel (PW-21), Dilendra Yadav (PW-22), Aman Kumar (PW23), Jitendra Dahriya (PW-24), Ganesh Ram Shrey (PW-25),
Ramnath
Khurshyam
(PW-26),
Baleshwar
Lahare
(PW-27),
Manishanker Chandra (PW-28), Rajendra Dewan (PW-29), Dr.
Pranay Srivastava (PW-30), Mahendra Verma (PW-31) and
Shivendra Rajput (PW-32), whereas the defence has not presented
any evidence in support of its case.
7.
The learned Special Judge, after completion of trial and after
appreciating oral and documentary evidences available on record,
by the impugned judgment dated 05.07.2025, convicted and
sentenced the appellants
in the manner mentioned in the
paragraph 03 of this judgment, against which CRA No. 1422 of
2025 has been preferred calling in question the impugned judgment
whereas CRA No. 121 of 2026 has been filed by the complainant
for enhancement of the sentence awarded by the trial Court.
8.
Mr. Shubham Dwivedi, learned counsel for the appellant /
complainant in CRA No. 121 of 2026 vehemently argued that the
sentence awarded to the accused is grossly inadequate
considering the gravity of the offence and the fact that two
persons were grievously injured namely Murli Manohar Markam
and Kapish Markam and one other was injured namely Chandan
Markam and the nature of the injuries caused in the vital part of
body i.e Head to PW-3 and deadly fractures and wounds were
inflicted both upon PW-3 and PW-4. The learned Special Judge
erred in awarding only 5 years RI for an offence under Section
307 IPC read with Section 3(2)(va) of the SC/ST Act, despite
clear findings of intention to kill. He further argued that the
judgment itself records that the accused, with common object,
inflicted fatal blows on Kapish Markam with lathis, rods and
knives with intention of killing him. Such finding mandates life
imprisonment or at least 10 years RI. The learned trial Court
failed to distinguish between mere grievous hurt and attempt to
murder. The nature, number, and location of injuries, coupled with
the use of deadly weapons on a vital part, are déterminative of
homicidal intent. It is also submitted that the statements of PW-3
Murli Manohar Markam, PW-4 Kapish Markam, PW-5 Chandan
Singh Markam and PW-7 Santosh Markam and statement of
independent witness Ayyub Saifi (PW-9) as well as evidences
exhibited establish that the assault was collective, premeditated,
and accompanied by caste abuses, showing hatred-motivated
violence.
The
accused
surrounded
the
victims,
attacked
simultaneously, and fled only after the victims collapsed. The
medical findings as deposed by Dr. SR Baghel (PW-2),
Dr.Sanjeev Kumar Khunte (PW-14) and Dr. Pranay Shrivastava
(PW-30), of multiple fractures and deep wounds inflicted upon the
injured victims confirm the brutality. He also submitted that the
learned trial Court correctly held that all accused shared a
common object under Section 149 IPC, but failed to proportion
the sentence to that joint criminality. It is settled proposition of law
that each participant in an unlawful assembly is equally liable for
the full consequence of the common object, including attempted
murder.
9.
Mr. B.P. Singh, learned counsel for convicts/appellants in CRA
No. 1682 of 2024 vehemently argued that the prosecution case,
particularly for the purpose of sentencing under Section 307 IPC,
heavily relies upon the alleged grievous injuries and fractures
sustained by PW-3 Murali Manohar Markam and PW-4 Kapish
Markam. However, it is respectfully submitted that no X-ray report
or radiological evidence has been exhibited or proved in
accordance with law to substantiate the claim of fractures. In the
absence of X-ray plates or reports, the alleged fractures remain
uncorroborated; the oral testimony of doctors, unsupported by
radiological evidence, cannot conclusively prove the nature or
extent of the injuries as grievous within the meaning of Section
320 IPC; the prosecution version regarding “deadly fractures” is
rendered medically doubtful. He further submitted that although
Dr.S.R. Baghel (PW-2), Dr. Sanjeev Kumar Khunte (PW-14), and
Dr. Pranay Shrivastav (PW-30) have referred to fractures and
serious injuries, no X-ray films, reports, or radiologist’s opinion
have been brought on record. It is settled law that where fracture
is alleged, X-ray evidence is the best and primary evidence, and
in its absence, the benefit must go to the accused, especially at
the stage of sentencing. He also submitted that though medical
witnesses have opined that the injuries sustained by the victims
were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death,
but all injured persons survived, recovered, and were discharged
after treatment. This significantly weakens the prosecution’s
contention of homicidal intent warranting a higher or enhanced
sentence.
10.
Mr. Singh contended that even assuming the prosecution case at
its highest, the absence of conclusive medical proof places the
case closer to Section 325 IPC rather than Section 307 IPC. The
learned Trial Court has already taken a strict view by sustaining
conviction under Section 307 IPC. In such circumstances
enhancement of sentence is impermissible and a lenient view in
sentencing is fully justified.
He further contended that while
Section 149 IPC fastens vicarious liability, it does not dilute the
prosecution’s burden to prove the nature and gravity of injuries.
When the foundational medical evidence itself is deficient, the
appellants cannot be subjected to prolonged incarceration on
presumptions or exaggerations.
He also contended that the
appellants Vijay, Dinesh, Rohit and Amit are in jail since
28.12.2023, appellant Puran Solanki is in jail since 29.12.2023,
appellant Hari Rathore is in jail since 19.03.2024 and appellant
Ratan Solanki is in jail since 19.09.2024 as such, have already
undergone a substantial portion of the sentence during trial and
pendency of the appeal. They have faced the trauma of criminal
prosecution for a prolonged period, therefore, it is prayed to
reduce the substantive sentence awarded to the appellants to the
period already undergone, particularly in view of the absence of
X-ray reports and inconclusive proof of grievous injuries.
11.
On the other hand, learned State counsel supports the impugned
judgment and submitted that looking to the seriousness of crime,
the appellants are not at all entitled for any sympathy by this
Court, therefore, the appeal deserves to be dismissed.
12.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties, considered their
rival submissions made herein-above and went through the
records with utmost circumspection.
13.
Learned counsel for the complainant has submitted that the
sentence imposed by the trial Court is grossly inadequate,
considering the brutality of assault, use of deadly weapons,
common object of the accused, and the nature of injuries suffered
by the victims. The medical evidence on record, in fact, shows
that PW-2 Dr. S.R. Baghel, PW-14 Dr. Sanjeev Kumar Khunte,
and PW-30 Dr. Pranay Srivastava have opined that the injuries
sustained by PW-3 Murali Manohar Markam and PW-4 Kapish
Markam were grievous in nature and sufficient in the ordinary
course of nature to cause death.
Thus, the conviction under
Section 307 IPC is supported by the medical evidence. However,
while considering enhancement of sentence, this Court must
keep in view the overall scheme of sentencing, the mitigating
circumstances,
and
established
principles
of
criminal
jurisprudence.
14.
It is noteworthy that no X-ray reports or radiological evidence
have been produced on record in support of the alleged fractures,
although oral medical evidence has been led. While absence of
X-ray evidence does not necessarily vitiate conviction, it is a
relevant factor in assessing the severity of injuries for the purpose
of sentence enhancement.
15.
It is well settled that enhancement of sentence is not automatic
merely because a higher punishment is permissible in law. The
Supreme Court in State of Rajasthan v. Kashi Ram, (2006) 12
SCC 254, observed that the extent of sentence must be guided
by the nature of the offence, circumstances of the case, and other
mitigating factors, and that interference in sentencing is
warranted only where there is perversity or irrationality.
16.
In Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab, (1980) 2 SCC 684, the
Supreme Court expounded that sentencing requires a principled
approach, balancing aggravating and mitigating circumstances,
and that the Court should avoid unduly harsh sentences where
such balance is not warranted by the facts.
17.
In view of the above, and having regard to the fact that the victims
survived the incident; the absence of X-ray reports corroborating
the extent of fractures; the sentence of five years’ rigorous
imprisonment already imposed; and no criminal antecedents of
the appellants being proved, this Court finds no compelling
reason to enhance the substantive sentence.
18.
Accordingly, CRA No. 121 of 2026 filed by the complainant
seeking enhancement of sentence is dismissed.
19.
So far the appeal preferred by the accused is concerned, this
Court has given anxious consideration to the nature of the
offence, medical evidence, and the facts and circumstances of
the case.
20.
As noted, the medical witnesses have opined that the injuries
were grievous in nature and sufficient in the ordinary course of
nature to cause death, and therefore, conviction under Section
307 IPC is maintained.
21.
At the same time, sentencing is not a mechanical exercise;
instead, it is a matter of judicial discretion rooted in both
aggravating and mitigating circumstances. The Supreme Court, in
Dalbir Singh v. State of Haryana, (2020) 5 SCC 719, upheld
reduction of sentence even in cases involving severe injuries,
observing that the purpose of sentencing is not merely retribution
but also reformation and social rehabilitation of the offender,
provided the offence does not manifest extreme depravity.
22.
In the present case, the following mitigating factors deserve
consideration:
➢ the incident arose out of prior rivalry and a sudden quarrel
without premeditation;
➢ the victims, though grievously injured, survived;
➢ no X-ray or radiological evidence has been produced to
corroborate the fractures;
➢ the appellants Vijay, Dinesh, Rohit and Amit are in jail since
28.12.2023, appellant Puran Solanki is in jail since 29.12.2023,
appellant Hari Rathore is in jail since 19.03.2024 and appellant
Ratan Solanki is in jail since 19.09.2024 as such, they have
already undergone a substantial portion of the sentence during
trial and pendency of the appeal. They have faced the trauma
of criminal prosecution for a prolonged period.
23.
In view of the above, and in exercise of discretionary jurisdiction
to temper justice with mercy, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the ends of justice would be met by reducing the
substantive sentence imposed upon the appellants for offence
under Section under Sections 147, 148, 149, 325/149, 307/149 of
IPC and Section 3(2)(va) of the SC/ST Act and upon appellants
Dinesh and Puran Solanki for offences under Section 25(1)(d)
and 27 of the Arms Act to the period already undergone by them.
24.
In view of the foregoing discussion CRA No. 1422 of 2025 is
partly allowed, and while maintaining the conviction of the
appellants under aforesaid Sections, the substantive sentence
awarded to them is reduced to the period already undergone by
them.
25.
The appellants shall be released forthwith, if not required in
connection with any other case.
26.
Let a copy of this judgment and the original records be
transmitted to the trial Court concerned forthwith for necessary
information and compliance.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Chandra
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review