Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
!
""
!
#
$
% ""
&
'
"
"
""
"
"
($
%
&
"
"'
)*& '
"
* $& '
"
'
+
"! !
& !
""
) & ' *$
$
* "
,-
**+!
" .
)
"
/"
12 344255367 138 492:2992; 71<8 344235 3=3<687 712
9;
>?;=@267 A: BA6C<B7<A6 36; A9;29 A6 826726B2 ;372;
* 43882; <6
<C<5 E
A **+ A:
288<A68 ?;=2
) -D 712
;;<7<A635
26=35?9? &:A9 81A97 /712 79<35
A9 712 83F2 A: BA6C26<26B2
712 4397<28 1292<6 392
9<2: :3B78 523;<6= 7A 71<8 344235 392 7137
"39344363
=931393 "A5<B2
B139=2 81227 3=3<687 712 3BB?82;
A::26B28 ?6;29
2B7<A68 *$
A: 712 6;<36 "2635
*
A8
*
<7D
A?970'
92:2992; 7A 38 429 712<9 936F 36; 8737?8 -2:A92 712 79<35
6842B7A9
?=?87
737<A6
A?97
712 "A5<B2
8?-@<772; 712
36;
:A9 BA@@<88<A6 A:
G)
)
$
,
36; )
A;2
7 <8 3552=2; -D 712 49A82B?7<A6 7137 712 BA@453<6367 H38
928<;<6= <6
9<
26F37
3C226
A@26 "
-D 712 82BA6; 3BB?82; 36; 8<7?372; 37
6;
H1<B1 H38 -2<6= 9?6
73=2
52B79A6<B
<7D
:355<6= H<71<6 712 >?9<8;<B7<A6 A: "39344363
737<A6
=931393 "A5<B2
12 BA@453<6367 H1A H38 HA9F<6= <6
<6 712 83<; "
:9A@
+71
?=?87
$71
3@ 712 BA@453<6367 927?962; 7A 712 "
712 9AA@,@372 A: 712 BA@453<6367 &
H38 928<;<6=
?=?87
3:729 129 HA9F
' 13; =A62 :A9 HA9F
712 BA@453<6367 H1A 13; 123;,3B12 7AAF 43<6 F<5529 36; 85247
H<71A?7 5ABF<6= 712 ;AA9 A: 712 9AA@
3@ H126 712
BA@453<6367 H38 <6 3 ;9AH8D 87372 712 3BB?82;
712 9AA@
12 BA@453<6367 38F2; 1<@ <6
A
267292;
3@<5 38 7A H1A 12
H38I 37 7137 7<@2 3BB?82; F247 3 F6<:2 A6 712 719A37 A: 712
BA@453<6367
126 712 BA@453<6367 79<2; 7A 81A?7
3BB?82;
719237262; 7137 12 HA?5; F<55 129
$
BB?82; 38F2; :A9 @A62D 36; 712 BA@453<6367 7A5; 1<@
7137 812 13; A65D
812 13;
!, 36; 7137 812 HA?5; =<C2 H1372C29
2 38F2; :A9 @A92 @A62D :A9 H1<B1 712 BA@453<6367
<6:A9@2; 1<@ <6
3@<5 7137 812 HA?5; =<C2 129
BB?82;
7A9B1
:AB?82;
5<=17
719A37
B39;
A:
BA@453<6367 36; 87?::2; -2; 81227 <67A 712 @A?71 A: 712
BA@453<6367
2 7126 ;93==2; 129 -D 129 13<9 36; 5ABF2; 712
*
;AA9
2 7126 7AAF 129 6239 712 -3719AA@ 36; 8H<7B12; A6 712
5<=17
2 125; 712 :3B2 A: 712 BA@453<6367 ?6;29 712 5<=17
3729 12 4?812; 712 BA@453<6367 7A 712 BA7 36; F<882; 129 A6
129 :3B2
2 79<2; 7A 92@AC2 129 6<=17 4367 36; 38F2; 129 7A
92@AC2 712 83@2
126 712 BA@453<6367 92:?82; 712 83@2 36;
79<2; 7A 28B342 :9A@ 712 453B2 3BB?82; 719237262; 129 H<71 712
F6<:2 36; 92@AC2; 1<8 25387<B 793BF 4367
BA@453<6367 A6 712 -2; 36; :255 A6 129
2 4?812; 712
2 8J?22K2; 712 136;8
36; -A;D A: 712 BA@453<6367 36; :A9B2:?55D 9342; 129
2 A6B2
3=3<6 719237262; 7A F<55 129 H<71 712 F6<:2 F<882; 129 -A;D 36;
A6B2 3=3<6 3772@472; 7A 9342 129
1?8 712 3BB?82;
87372; 7A 13C2 BA@@<772; A::26B28 4?6<813-52 ?6;29
*$
*
G)
)
36; $
H1A <8 712 AH629 A: 712 "
,
A: "
A
<8
2B7<A68
BB?82;
A
H1292 712 C<B7<@ H38 928<;<6= ;<;
6A7 <6:A9@ 712 <6B<;267 7A 712 4A5<B2 A9 36D 4?-5<B 829C367
;284<72 13C<6= <6:A9@37<A6 3-A?7 712 83@2
1?8 712 82BA6;
3BB?82; <8 87372; 7A 13C2 BA@@<772; A::26B2 4?6<813-52 ?6;29
2B7<A6 ) A: "
$
:729 :<5<6= 712 B139=2 81227 B382 H38 92=<87292; <6
A
+ A:
A?97 A:
12923:729
712 B382 H38 BA@@<772; 7A 712
288<A68 36; H38 92=<87292; 38
<6B2 712 ;372 A: 399287 3BB?82;
A
9<@2
H38 9252382; A6 -3<5
A
A **+ A:
)
<8 <6 B?87A;D 3BB?82;
12 B139=28 :93@2; 3=3<687 712
3BB?82; :A9 712 3552=2; A::26B28 36; 83@2 H38 923; AC29 36;
2L453<62; 7A 712 3BB?82;
AH629 A: 712 "
A8
36;
3BBA@@A;37<A6
BB?82;
A
H1A <8 712
138 4523;2; =?<57D :A9 712
B139=28 52C2552; 3=3<687 1<@ 36; 12 H38 826726B2; 7A 43D 3 :<62
A:
8$
!,
6 ;2:3?57 A: 43D@267 A: :<62 12 81355 ?6;29=A
8<@452 <@49<8A6@267 :A9
3@A?67
BB?82;
A
;3D8 36; 12 138 43<; 712 :<62
4523;2; 6A7 =?<57D 36; B53<@2; 7A -2
79<2;
)
A 49AC2 712 =?<57 A: 712 3BB?82; <6 355 71<97226 H<7628828
H292 2L3@<62; 38 "
L1<-<78 "
7A
.
* ;AB?@2678 H292 @39F2; 38
7A " * 36; 8<L7226 @3729<35 A->2B78 H292 @39F2; 38
7A
+
6 B5A8?92 A: 49A82B?7<A6 8<;2 2C<;26B2 87372@267 A: 712
3BB?82; ?6;29
2B7<A6
A: 712
A;2 A:
9<@<635 "9AB2;?92
H38 92BA9;2;
12 3BB?82; 138 7A7355D ;26<2; 712 2C<;26B2 A:
49A82B?7<A6 H<7628828 1AH2C29 12 ;<; 6A7 B1AA82 7A 523; 712
;2:26B2 2C<;26B2 A6 1<8 -2135:
G
3C<6= 1239; 712 39=?@2678 A6 -A71 8<;28 79<35
BA6C<B72; 712 3BB?82; :A9 712 A::26B2 ?6;29
*$
36; $
,
A: "
!,
"
D2398 36; 7A 43D 3 :<62
D2398 36; 43D :<62 A:
!, :A9 712 A::26B2 4?6<813-52 ?6;29 82B7<A6 *$
12 3BB?82;
2B7<A6
A
A: 712
!,
?6;29
2B7<A6 $
"
12 3BB?82;
,
36; 826726B2; 7A ?6;29=A 8<@452
!,
?6;29
2B7<A6 * + A:
@A6718 36; 7A 43D 3 :<62 A:
A
<8 358A BA6C<B72; :A9 712 A::26B2
A: 712 "
36; 826726B2; 7A ?6;29=A 8<@452
<@49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A:
A: 712
<8 358A BA6C<B72; :A9 712 A::26B2 ?6;29
<@49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A:
) & '
12 3BB?82; H38 :?97129 826726B2; ?6;29=A
9<=A9A?8 <@49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A:
8$
2B7<A68
36; 43882; 3 826726B2 7A ?6;29=A
9<=A9A?8 <@49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A:
A:
A?97 138
D239 36; 7A 43D 3 :<62 A:
?97129 712 79<35 BA?97 138 43882; 36 A9;29 7137
9"
712 3BB?82;
A
81355 -2 267<752; :A9
3 429<A; A: 827,A:: <6 92842B7 A: 712 429<A; 84267 -D 1<@ <6
)
>?;<B<35 B?87A;D :9A@
$71
2472@-29
7<55 ;372
2<6=
3==9<2C2; -D 712 >?;=@267 A: BA6C<B7<A6 36; A9;29 A: 826726B2
712 344255367 13; 492:2992; 71<8 344235
9<
3>371 523962; BA?6825 :A9 712 344255367 HA?5; 8?-@<7
7137 712 <@4?=62; A9;29 A: BA6C<B7<A6 36; 826726B2 43882; -D
712 79<35
B382
A?97 392 3=3<687 712 53H 49AB2;?92 36; :3B78 A: 712
12 523962;
288<A68
?;=2 2992; <6 1A5;<6= 7137 712
344255367 <8 =?<57D A: 712 3552=2; BA@@<88<A6 A: A::26B28
358A 8?-@<772; 7137 712 523962;
288<A68
7 <8
?;=2 138 2992; <6
-25<2C<6= 712 ?6BA99A-A9372; C298<A6 A: 712 49A82B?7<A6
7 <8
8?-@<772; 7137 712 B382 H38 92=<87292; 3=3<687 A62
;3D 36;
7137 71292 <8 7HA ;3D8 ;253D <6 :<5<6= 712 BA@453<67
12 B139=2
81227 <8 :<52; 3=3<687 712 3BB?82;
* A: 712
9"
;3D 36;
3:729 53482 A:
?935<
C26 ?6;29
2B7<A6
712 C<B7<@ 138 87372; 712 63@2 A: 712 3BB?82;
924A97 H38 :<52; 3:729 :<5<6= 712 B139=2 81227
@A6718
12 BA672678 A:
L1<-<7 "
<7825: <8
;A?-7:?5 36; 92BA9;<6= A: 2C<;26B2 138 -2=?6 35@A87 3:729 53482
A: AC29
D2398 :9A@ 712 ;372 A: :<5<6= 712 :<635 924A97 H1<B1 -D
<7825: 138 C<A5372; 712 836B7<7D A: 79<35
+
" *, 9
?>3713 B52395D 87372; 7137 1D@26 A: 712 C<B7<@
H38 6A7 <673B7 36; 71292 H38 6A 1<87A9D A: 82L?35 3883?57 A6 712
C<B7<@
284<72 71292 <8 ;253D A: 7HA ;3D8 <6 5A;=<6= 712
BA@453<67 <7 <8 2C<;267 7137 712 3552=2; 3883?57 <8 83<; 7A 13C2
-226 B3?82; A6 712 :3B2 A: 712 2C<;26B2 A: ;AB7A9 H1<B1 =A28 7A
49AC2 712 BA67939D
12 BA552B7<A6 A: -5AA; 83@4528 <6 B9<@<635
B3828 <8 C35<; A65D <: <7 :A55AH8 712 4928B9<-2; 52=35 49AB2;?928
H1<B1 @3D <6B5?;2 AC298<=17 -D 3 @3=<879372 A9 92=<87292;
@2;<B35 493B7<7<A629
6 712 4928267 B382 -5AA; 83@452 H1<B1 <8
<@42937<C2 7A 793B2 36; BA6:<9@ 712 <;267<7D A: 712 344255367
1292<6 H38 83<; 7A 13C2 -226 73F26 A6
<635 924A97 <8 :<52; A6
6;
AC2@-29
AC2@-29
H1<B1 HA?5; A65D
;2@A6879372 7137 267<92 49AB2;?92 A: BA552B7<6= 36; @37B1<6=
-5AA; 83@4528 H38 A65D 7A <@45<B372 712 344255367 36; 6A7 7A
38B2973<6 712 79?71
12 523962;
288<A68
?;=2 :3<52; 7A
34492B<372 712 2C<;26B2 36; @3729<358 A6 92BA9; 36; 7A 6A72 7137
712 49A82B?7<A6 138 :3<52; 7A 49AC2 712 B382 -2DA6; 355
9238A63-52 ;A?-7
71<8 344235
6 355 71282 =9A?6;8 12 8A?=17 :A9 355AH<6=
G
5729637<C25D 712 523962; BA?6825 HA?5; 8?-@<7 7137 <: 712
A?97 BA@28 7A 712 BA6B5?8<A6 7137 712 A9;29 A: BA6C<B7<A6 43882; -D
712 79<35 A?97 <8 <6 3BBA9;36B2 H<71 53H 712 826726B2 43882; -D 712
79<35 A?97 @3D -2 @A;<:<2; 38 712 79<35 A?97 138 43882; 36 A9;29 7A
9?6 712 826726B2 BA682B?7<C25D 36; :?97129 12 HA?5; 8?-@<7 7137
3BB?82; <8 6A7 <6 3 4A8<7<A6 7A 43D :<62 3@A?67 38 <@4A82; -D 712
79<35
A?97
2=35
<;
6 712 79<35
A?97 712 3BB?82; H38 9249282672; 719A?=1
A?6825
12 4928267 344235 <7825: <8 :<52; 3:729 53482 A:
@A92 7136 3 D239
12 3BB?82; <8 <6 >?;<B<35 B?87A;D :A9 @A92 7136 G
D2398 36; $ @A6718
6 355 71282 =9A?6;8
12 8A?=17 :A9
@A;<:<B37<A6 A: 826726B2
8 3=3<687 71<8
"523;29
9<
712 523962;
<=1
A?97
3F81@36 HA?5; 8?-@<7 7137 712 79<35
AC296@267
A?97 138
49A4295D 34492B<372; 712 @3729<358 A6 92BA9; <6 3BBA9;36B2 H<71
53H 36; :3B78
1A?=1 712 63@2 A: 712 3BB?82; <8 ;<::29267 <6 712
36; 712 B139=2,81227 712 C<B7<@ 138 <;267<:<2; 712 3BB?82;
<6 712 7287 <;267<:<B37<A6 4393;2
;<8@<8835 A: 712 344235
BBA9;<6=5D
12 8A?=17 :A9
*
3C<6= 1239; 712 39=?@2678 A6 -A71 8<;28 36; A6 429?835
A: @3729<358 453B2; -2:A92 71<8
A?97 712 :A55AH<6= 4A<678 HA?5;
39<82 :A9 @D BA68<;2937<A6
<'
127129 712 79<35
A?97 <8 >?87<:<2; <6 BA6C<B7<6= 712
3BB?82; :A9 712 A::26B28 4?6<813-52 ?6;29
*$
<<'
) 36; $
2B7<A68
, A: 712 " I
127129 712 344255367 <8 267<752; :A9 @A;<:<B37<A6 A:
826726B2I
<<<'
137 A9;29I
!"
$
A?97
!"#
$%
13C2 B392:?55D 2L3@<62; 712 @3729<358 453B2; -2:A92 71<8
6842B7A9 "39344363
=931393 "A5<B2
737<A6 138 53<;
B139=2,81227 3=3<687 712 3BB?82; :A9 712 A::26B2 4?6<813-52
?6;29
2B7<A68 *$
A;2
12 79<35
?6;29
2B7<A68 *$
)
$
,
36;
)
A: 6;<36 "2635
A?97 138 BA6C<B72; 712 3BB?82; :A9 712 A::26B2
) 36; $
,
A: 6;<36 "2635
A;2
2628<8 A: 712 B382 39<82 :9A@ 712 BA@453<67 :<52; -D
" C<B7<@ 38 429 2L1<-<7 " <6 H1<B1 <7 <8 87372; 38 ?6;29
/
!
"#$
%&
%
' '
(
)
' '
!
*
%
' '
* )
(%
)*
*
*
)
+%
' '
' '
*
%&
)
'
*
'
',
*
)
)
-
)
*
.
*
)
'
* )
)
)
)
' "
)
*
)
**
)
)
*
'
*
*
*
** )
)
**
%
'
*
*
* )
'
/
*
'
'
)
',
)
' '
*
)
*
)
) '
*
1 *
)
*
)
*
/
*
' $
)
)
*'
*
'
*
)
*
)
'0
)71
12 BA@453<67 H38 :<52; A6
1A?98
9<@2
)
)
) *
)
*
?=?87
G
6 712 -38<8 A: 712 BA@453<67 B382 H38 92=<87292; <6
A
+ A:
3=3<687 3BB?82;
A::26B2 4?6<813-52 ?6;29
A: 6;<36 "2635
?=?87
2B7<A68 *$
A;2 36;
;3D :A9 BA@@<88<A6 A:
)
$
,
36; )
H38 8?-@<772; 712 BA?97 A6
4@ 38 429
L1<-<7 "+
)71
:729 92=<87937<A6
A: 712 B382 4A5<B2 13C2 C<8<72; 712 84A7 36; BA6;?B72; 84A7
436B1363@3 A6
492826B2
A:
+71
"36B138
436B1363@3 38 429
A-73<62;
@2;<B35
?=?87
"A5<B2
13C2
L1<-<7 "*
B297<:<B372
38 429
L1<-<7 "
<6 712
358A
BA673B72;
82<K?92
12 <6C287<=37<6= A::<B29 138
:9A@
@2;<B35 A::<B29
36;
92BA9;2; 712 87372@267 A: H<7628828 36; 8?-@<772; B139=2,
81227
+
38 "
A 8?-87367<372 712 B382 49A82B?7<A6 138 2L3@<62; C<B7<@
12 138 ;24A82; <6 129 2C<;26B2 38 :A55AH8
/
#
$
2 /
"#$
*
!'
#'7'
6*
)#
'
' #'7'&
' #'7'8
) *
'
!'
'
(
!
)*
)
'&
(
*
*
)
'
)
)
'
)*
#'7'
)
)
* )
**
' 9
'
'
*
'&
)
)
)
*
) '
*
)
*
'
"
))
)
'
"9
'
**
*
' $
*
)
' "
**
)
) '
:'
*
*
)
*
*
) '
'"
)
* )
' " **
*
) ' ,
&;
<
)*
**
' ,
*
' "
)
*
'
)
*
)
))
*
*
) '
'
'"
* )
)
**
'
*
)
)
=
*
'
*
' "
*
' 5
)
**
' "
'
* )
) ** #'7'&
=
'
(
* )
#'7' )
*
)
*
'
)
*
+
+' '
)
*)
* ) '
)
G
!'
*
) '
,
) 2
*
*
'0
12 BA@453<67 <8 @39F2; 38
L1<-<7 "
?97129 812 138
;24A82; 38 7A 712 @313K39 BA6;?B72; -D 712 "A5<B2 38 429
L1<-<78 "
36; "
36; 358A 82<K?92 A:
7A
?97129 812
138 ;24A82; 7137 812 =3C2 129 87372@267 ?6;29 82B7<A6
"
3:729 :<:7226 ;3D8 A: :<5<6= 712 BA@453<67
@A671 3:729 5A;=<6= 712 BA@453<67
267935
3<5
26=35?9?
* A:
6; 3:729 A62
4A5<B2 B3552; 129 7A 712
12 H267 71292 36; <;267<:<2; 712
$
3BB?82; <6 7287 <;267<:<B37<A6 4393;2 A6 712 -38<8 A: BA5A?9
12<=17 36; A7129 41D8<B35 <;267<7D H1<B1 812 92@2@-292;
"
, A?;13@<6< 138 ;24A82; <6 129 2C<;26B2 38 :A55AH8
/
#
$
' /
"#$
*
!'
6*
)#
'7' '
' #'7'&
' 9
+
(
)
(
)
)
)*
)
* )
)
**
'>
(
!' '
!
)
)
'&
?
, 9>?6
)
'
*
)
+
)
) '0
+'
'
!'
*)
66<F9<81636 138 ;24A82; 38 7A 712 @313K39
BA673B72; -D 712 4A5<B2 38 429
-536F27
*
)
*
*
*
'
'7'
"
)*
'
)*
'
L1<-<7 "
36; 358A 82<K?92 A:
"
, 9
4@
)71
?>3713 138 ;24A82; 7137 A6
?=?87
B3@2 H<71 712 1<87A9D A: 82L?35 3883?57 36; 138
;24A82; 38 7A 712 2L3@<637<A6 A: 712 C<B7<@
12 138 A4<62;
7137 71292 <8 6A 92B267 82L?35 3883?57 A6 712 -A;D A: 712 C<B7<@
36; 812 138 ;24A82; 38 7A @3729<35 A->2B78
7A *
" $, 3F3443 83<; 7A -2 712 37728729 7A @313K39
L1<-<7
"* 138 6A7 8?44A972; 712 B382 A: 49A82B?7<A6
*
"
, 9 "93;224
?@39 138 ;24A82; <6 1<8 2C<;26B2 38 7A
712 <88?36B2 A: @2;<B35 B297<:<B372 42973<6<6= 7A 712 3BB?82;
$
" ), 9
1<2:
2;<B35
12662=A6;3443
D3@3=A6;3443
::<B29 138 ;24A82; 7137 A6
12 138 73F26 712 83@452 -5AA; A: 3BB?82;
A
35383=AH;3
AC2@-29
36; 136;2; AC29
712 83@2 7A 712 "A5<B2
" +,
1<C3F?@39
262935
363=29
H1A H38
318<5;39 138 ;24A82; 38 7A 712 7287 <;267<:<B37<A6 4393;2
36; <88?36B2 A: 3 924A97 38 429 L1<-<7 ")
)
)
" , 3-?
3-?
"A5<B2
?-, 6842B7A9 A: "A5<B2 36; "
"9381367
6842B7A9 13C2 ;24A82; 38 7A 712<9 92842B7<C2
<6C287<=37<A6
+
"
, 9
<88?36B2 A:
2243 138 ;24A82; <6 129 2C<;26B2 38 7A
A9268<B
B<26B2
3-A937A9D 924A97 38 429
L1<-<7
"
G
"
,
363=29
"?9?81A773@
A9268<B
88<87367
B<26B2 3-A937A9D
<92B7A9 36;
2B16<B35
36=35A92 138 ;24A82; <6
1<8 2C<;26B2 38 7A 712 2L3@<637<A6 A: 397<B528
7A
36;
<88?36B2 A: B297<:<B372 L1<-<7 " *
"
, 9<8163
?@39
138 ;24A82; 38 7A 1<8 4397 A:
<6C287<=37<A6
6 B392:?5 2L3@<637<A6 A: @3729<35 2C<;26B2 A: " 8
L1<-<7 "
924A97
L1<-<7 "
7A *
924A97 <7 <8 B5239 7137
71292 <8 8?::<B<267 2C<;26B2 7A BA687<7?72 712 3552=2; BA@@<88<A6
A: A::26B2
12 63@2 A: 3BB?82; <8
1<8 63@2 <8 81AH6 38
;3D
?935<
7 712 7<@2 A: :<5<6=
C26 <6 712 87372@267 ?6;29
+
2B7<A6
* A:
38 429
L1<-<7 "
3BB?82; H38
A;2 A:
9<@<635 "9AB2B;?92 @3;2 -D 712 C<B7<@
712 C<B7<@ 138 87372; 7137 712 63@2 A: 712
?935<
7137 1<8 63@2 <8
126 12 H38 38F2; 3-A?7 1<8 63@2 12 83<;
;3D
?7 3:729 399287 A: 712 3BB?82; <7 <8
3552=2; -D 712 49A82B?7<A6 7137 712 63@2 A: 712 3BB?82; <8
?935<
12 3BB?82;
?935< 138 -226 <;267<:<2; -D 712 C<B7<@
1292:A92 @292 83D A: 712 3BB?82; 7137 1<8 63@2 <8
7<@2 A: :<5<6=
;A28 6A7 @236 7137 3BB?82;
BA@@<772; 36D A::26B2
BA@@<77<6= 9342
C<B7<@
"
;3D 37 712
?935< 138 6A7
138 B52395D 87372; 7137 3:729
712 3BB?82; H38 BA67<6?A?85D F<88<6= 712
126 812 873972; BA6C29837<A6 H<71 1<@
BA67<6?A?85D BA@<6= 7A 129 36; 9342 129 3=3<6 36; 3=3<6
2 H38
812 7A5; 1<@ 7A BA@2 62L7 ;3D 8737<6= 7137 ;AA9 H<55 6A7 -2
537B12;
126 358A 12 H38 6A7 523C<6=
63@2 A: 712 3BB?82;
2 83<; 1<8 63@2 38
13C2 7A5; 1<8 63@2 38
<;267<7D
126 812 38F2; 712
;3D
BB?82; @<=17
;3D <6 A9;29 7A 3CA<; 1<8 A9<=<635
?7 8?-82J?2675D 4A5<B2 13C2 3992872; 36; 7126 712
3BB?82; <;267<:<2; -D 712 C<B7<@
1292:A92 <6 71<8 92=39; 712
39=?@2678 3;C36B2; A6 -2135: A: 712 3BB?82;!344255367 B366A7
-2 3BB2472;
12 79<35 BA?97 138 49A4295D 34492B<372; 712
G
@3729<358 A6 92BA9; <6 49A429 429842B7<C2 36; 13; BA@2 7A 712
BA6B5?8<A6 7137 3BB?82; 138 BA@@<772; 712 3552=2; A::26B2
6 2L3@<637<A6 36; 92,34492B<37<A6 A: 712 267<92 2C<;26B2
A6 92BA9; <6;2426;2675D
;A 6A7 :<6; 36D :3B7?35 A9 52=35 299A9
<6 712 <@4?=62; >?;=@267 A: BA6C<B7<A6 43882; -D 712 79<35
BA?97
26B2
368H29 "A<67
!"
!"#
A
<6 712 3::<9@37<C2
%
*
<71 92=39; 7A @A;<:<B37<A6 A: 826726B2 <8 BA6B2962; 712
79<35
A?97 138 43882; 712 826726B2 3=3<687 712 3BB?82; 38
?6;29
@ )
)
4 '
)
)
#
)
&+!A B >
' 2
&(A B
)
))
)
#
*
)
*2
*
)
#2
)
**
* '
))
4 '
*
)
)
'( 2
)
8(
#
*2
)
)
*
=
)
)
)
**
* '
))
4 '
)
*
)
)
)
& &
)
* )
*
&
'
*
*
)
**
)
)
))
4 '
*
)
* '
)
( ! /
)
*
#
)
*
' 2
*
*
**
)
)
* '
)
**
$ )
#
#2
))
*
4 '
)
)
)
(C
!
** 1
A+
B'
>
*
Rs. 2( 2
)
' D
)
)
4 5$ E
> )
)
'
*
)
)
)
)
2 5
15$
*
'
9>(
)
*
)
' 9>
982 9!
!
*
*
D
))
'
)
-
**
)
/
*
4 ' '
> )
$
)
*
#
*
)
)
'F
7 <8 8?-@<772; -D 712 523962; BA6B297 :A9 712 344255367
7137 712 3BB?82; 13<58 :9A@ 4AA9 :3@<5D 36; 2C26 H38 6A7 <6 3
4A8<7<A6 7A 492:29 36 344235
C26 3:729 53482 A: A62 D239 :9A@
712 ;372 A: >?;=@267 <7 H38 A65D 719A?=1 52=35 3<; BA?6B<5
1<8
344235 H38 <687<7?72; 36; 712 3BB?82; <8 <6 <6;<C<;?35 B?87A;D :A9
@A92 7136 6<62 D2398 8<L @A6718
12 3BB?82; <8 6A7 <6 3
4A8<7<A6 7A 43D :<62 3@A?67 38 <@4A82; -D 712 79<35 BA?97
A68<;29<6= 355 71282 5<7<=37<6= B<9B?@8736B28 12 8A?=17 7A 4388
3 826726B2 A65D :A9 3 429<A; A:
9?6 712 826726B2 BA6B?992675D
D2398 36; 4388 712 A9;29 7A
A68<;29<6= 712 8?-@<88<A6 A: 712
<6729627 BA?6B<5 :A9 712 344255367!3BB?82; 36; 358A 712 :<636B<35
8737?8 A: 712 3BB?82; 36; 429<A; A: ;27267<A6 35923;D ?6;29=A62
-D 712 3BB?82; <7 <8 >?87 49A429 7A @A;<:D 712 826726B2 <@4A82;
-D 712 79<35 BA?97
BBA9;<6=5D
368H29 4A<67 6?@-29 7HA 43975D
<6 712 3::<9@37<C2
!"
!"#
%
A9 712 9238A68 3:A9287372; 36; ;<8B?88<A68
49AB22; 7A
4388 712 :A55AH<6=
<'
44235 <8 355AH2; <6 4397.
<<'
?;=@267 A: BA6C<B7<A6 ;372;
9;
43882; <6
) -D 712
;;<7<A635
A **+ A:
<7D
<C<5
E
?=?87
288<A68
*
?;=2
26=35?9? <8 BA6:<9@2;.
<<<'
26726B2 ;372;
A **+ A:
<C<5 E
38 ?6;29
9;
?=?87
) -D 712
288<A68 ?;=2
* 43882; <6
;;<7<A635
<7D
26=35?9? <8 @A;<:<2;
BB?82;!344255367
81355
?6;29=A
9<=A9A?8 <@49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A:
726 D2398 36; 7A 43D :<62 A:
!,
:A9 712 A::26B2 ?6;29
2B7<A6
) & ' A:
81355
?6;29=A
" .
-
BB?82;!344255367
9<=A9A?8 <@49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A:
7HA D2398 36; 7A 43D :<62 A:
!,
4?6<813-52
?6;29
BB?82;!344255367 81355 ?6;29=A
<@452
:A9
A::26B2
2B7<A6 *$ A: " .
B
@49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A: 71922
@A6718 36; 7A 43D :<62 A:
:A9 712 A::26B2 ?6;29
!,
2B7<A6
A:
" .
;
BB?82;!344255367 81355 ?6;29=A 8<@452
<@49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A: A62 D239
36; 7A
43D :<62
A::26B2 ?6;29
BA6B?992675D.
A:
2B7<A6 $
,
826726B28
!, :A9
" .
81355
9?6
*
:
BB?82;!344255367 <8 267<752; :A9 827,A::
:A9 712 429<A; A: ;27267<A6 35923;D
?6;29=A62 <6 >?;<B<35 B?87A;D 38 429
2B7<A6 * + A:
<C'
2=<879D 7A 826; 712 BA4D A: 71<8 >?;=@267 35A6=
H<71 79<35
C'
9" .
A?97 92BA9;8 7A 712 BA6B2962;
A?97.
2=<879D <8 ;<92B72; 7A 826; 712 BA4D A: 712
@A;<:<2; BA6C<B7<A6 H399367 38 429 @A;<:<B37<A6
A:
826726B2
43882;
?429<6726;267
=931393
C<'
-D
71<8
267935
A?97
"9<8A6
7A
"39344363
26=35?9?.
2=<879D <8 358A ;<92B72; 7A 826; BA4D A: 71<8
>?;=@267 :922 A: BA87 7A 712
267935
"9<8A6
"39344363
?429<6726;267
=931393
H<71
;<92B7<A6 7A :?96<81 712 83@2 7A 712 3BB?82; 38
3BB?82; <8 <6 >?;<B<35 B?87A;D.
C<<'
<B7<@
<8
712 79<35
267<752;
:A9
A@426837<A6
A?97
BA@426837<A6
?6;29
B12@2 38 A9;292; -D
2=<879D 7A 826; 712 BA4D A: 71<8
$
>?;=@267 7A 712
2=35
29C<B28
2@-29
?71A9<7D
2B92739D
<879<B7
36=35A92 & 9-36'
<879<B7 7A 3H39; 8?<73-52 BA@426837<A6 7A 712
<B7<@ ?6;29
<B7<@
A@426837<A6
)
B12@2
& '(
* &
+
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review