The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. The aforesaid enunciation of law discussed above leads us to the irresistible conclusion that while framing charges under the ND&PS Act, the learned trial Courts would be well advised to sift the material placed before it and keep the weight of the contraband referred in the inventory proceedings, as a basic parameter while framing charges against the accused under Section 228 of the Cr.P.C. (Section 251 of BNSS). Whatever is certified by the learned Magistrate to be the quantity of contraband under Section 52(A) ( 2026:HHC:41983 ) (4) of the ND&PS Act shall be the quantity with which the accused shall be charged. It will also usher in certainty in law, rule out unnecessary ambiguities and bring about predictability and uniformity, which ought to be a basic prerequisite in a country governed by the rule of law.
24. Viewed in the aforesaid perspective, the impugned order dated 02.07.2026, passed by the learned Special Judge Hamirpur, H.P., accused/petitioner framing under charges Section against 20(b)(ii)(c) the cannot be sustained. As a sequel the same is quashed and set-aside. The learned trial Court shall reframe the charges afresh under Section 20(b)(ii)(b) keeping in view the quantity of contraband reflected in the inventory proceedings i.e. 996 grams of charas. The revision petition is disposed of in the aforesaid terms, so also the pending application(s), if any. 29th September, 2026 (subhash sharma) (Chirag Bhanu Singh) Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:41983 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
SHIMLA
Cr. Revision No.554 of 2026
Reserved on 16.09.2026
Decided on 29.09.2026
Uploaded on : 29.09.2026
Munish Kumar
.…Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P.
Coram:
…..Respondent
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Chirag Bhanu Singh, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? Yes 1
For the Petitioner
:
For the Respondent
:
Mr. Rajesh Mandhotra, Advocate.
Mr.
Prashant
Sen,
Deputy
Advocate General.
__________________________________________________________
Chirag Bhanu Singh, Judge
A short but a very important and a germane
question has been raised in the present revision petition, as
to whether the quantity of contraband reflected in the
inventory proceedings prepared under Section 52A (4) of the
Narcotic Drugs & Psychotropic Substances Act, (hereinafter
referred to as the ND&PS Act), or as shown to have been
recovered at the spot by the Investigating Officer, reflected in
the charge sheet shall form the basis of framing charges
against the accused under Section 228 of the Cr.P.C. (Section
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
( 2026:HHC:41983 )
251 of BNSS). The learned trial Courts have been grappling
with this issue for quite some time.
2.
The genesis giving rise to the present revision
petition may be succinctly summarized thus. The petitioner,
who is the accused came to be apprehended with charas.
When the contraband came to be weighed at the spot, which
was inclusive of the polythene and the carry bag, it was
found to weigh 1 Kg and 02 grams.
3.
During the course of the inventory proceedings,
carried out before the learned Magistrate, under Section 52
A(2) of the Act, and while issuing the certificate of
correctness, the learned trial Court found it to be 996 grams
only
4.
It would be apposite to mention at this stage that
the parcel produced before the learned trial Court, during the
inventory proceedings consisted of a pink coloured cloth
carry bag, containing the alleged charas in the shape of
sticks.
wrapped
The contraband was further found to have been
in
transparent/polythene
cellophane.
The
contraband had been made into a homogeneous mixture by
the learned Magistrate and weighed without the carry bag
( 2026:HHC:41983 )
and the transparent polythene. As per the order passed by
the learned trial Court, it was found to be 996 grams. The
question
thus
is,
for
what
quantity
was
the
accused/petitioner to be charged with?
5.
During the course of trial, the learned Special
Judge, Hamirpur, however, framed charges against the
accused for the recovery of the contraband weighing 1 kg. 02
grams and consequently, the petitioner came to be charged
under Section 20 (b) (ii) (c) of the Act.
6.
Feeling aggrieved, the petitioner has assailed the
impugned order dated 02.07.2026, whereby, he stands
charged accordingly.
7.
It is the contention of learned counsel for the
petitioner that initially the contraband came to be weighed at
the spot, along with polythene wrappings and the carry bag.
It was found to be 1 Kg 02 grams. The learned trial Court,
while preparing the inventory had however, found the
contraband to be weighing 996 grams only. The said weight
had been recorded after removing the contraband from the
carry bag and after removing the polythene wrappers.
8.
( 2026:HHC:41983 )
The learned counsel for the petitioner thus, would
contend that seeing to be weight of the contraband, the
petitioner should have been charged, under Section 20 (b) (ii)
(b) and Section 29.
framed
charges
Section 20(b)(ii)(c).
The learned trial Court, however, has
against
the
petitioner/accused,
under
The learned counsel for the petitioner
would thus contend that the learned trial Court has failed to
take into consideration the entire material collected by the
police, during investigation, which has cause material
prejudice to the petitioner.
9.
In
this
behalf,
the
learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner has also placed strong reliance upon a judgment of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court, titled as Bharat Aambale versus
State of Chhattisgarh, (2025) 8 Supreme Court Cases 452,
to contend that any inventory cum photographs/samples of
seized substances prepared in compliance of the procedure
laid down under Section 52-A has to be mandatorily to be
treated as primarily evidence and the same thus should form
the basis of framing charges under Section 228 of Cr.P.C.
10.
Per contra, Mr. Prashant Sen, learned Deputy
Advocate General would strenuously contend, no fault can be
( 2026:HHC:41983 )
attributed to the order dated 02.07.2026, as the petitioner
had been apprehended with 1 Kg 02 grams of charas and as
such the petitioner has rightly been charged under Section
20 (b) (ii) (c), as the contraband was commercial in quantity.
11.
I have heard the learned counsels appearing for
the parties and gone through the material placed on record.
12.
Though the word “conscious possession” has not
been explicitly defined under the ND&PS Act, but this
concept
has
interpretations.
evolved
primarily
through
judicial
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in its various
decisions has repeatedly underscored that “possession”
under the NDPS Act, should not only be physical but also
conscious.
The “conscious possession” would thus, imply
that the person knew what quantity of illicit drug or
psychotropic substance was with him.
13.
The expression “conscious possession” is thus, a
polymorphous term, which may assume different colours in
different contexts.
It may also carry different meanings in
contextually different backgrounds. Admittedly, there would
thus, be no completely logical and precise definition of
“possession” uniformly applicable to all situations. Likewise
( 2026:HHC:41983 )
the word “conscious” would also mean awareness about a
particular fact. It would thus be a state of mind, which is
deliberate or intended. The import of the words “conscious
possession” has been discussed in Avtar Singh versus State
of Punjab (AIR) 2002 Supreme Court 3343, Madan Lal and
another versus State of H.P. (2003 SCC 465 and Rakesh
Kumar Raghuvanshi versus State of Madhya Pradesh
(2025) INSC 96. The word “conscious possession” thus has
indeed gained recognition in the aforesaid terms right from
the very inception, i.e. when the ND&PS Act, came to be
enacted in the year 1985. The Courts thus will have to bear
in mind what was the quantity of contraband recovery from
the “conscious possession” of the accused even while framing
charge.
14.
The other important aspect, which requires to be
appreciated is that at the stage of framing charges, under
Section 228 of the Cr.P.C, what the learned trial Courts are
expected to do is, not to act merely as post offices.
The
Courts must indeed sift the material before it. The material
to be sifted would be the material, which is produced and
relied upon by the prosecution.
In this behalf too reliance
( 2026:HHC:41983 )
can profitably be laid to the ratio laid down in Union of India
versus Prafulla Kumar Samal
Cases, 4,
(1979) 3 Supreme Court
which has been further consistently followed in
catena of decisions including P. Vijayan versus State of
Kerala and another (2010) 2 Supreme Court Cases 398
and Ghulam Hassan Beigh versus Mohammad Maqbool
Magrey (2022) 12 Supreme Court Cases 657.
15.
Though while sifting it is not necessary for the
Courts to enter into the pros and cons of the matter on into
weighing an balancing of evidence and probabilities, but it
may evaluate the material to find out, if the facts emerging
therefrom taken at their face value established ingredients
constituting the said offence.
16.
Adverting
to
the
facts
of
the
present
case,
admittedly 1 kg. 02 grams of charas had come to be
recovered at the spot from the petitioner/accused.
It had
come to be weighed along with the carry bag and the
polythene wrapper. The perusal of the order passed by the
learned trial Court, who prepared the inventory clearly shows
that the parcel was consisting of a pink coloured carry bag
which was carrying charas in the shape of sticks further
wrapped in transparent polythene.
( 2026:HHC:41983 )
The learned trial Court
had weighed the contraband without the carry bag and the
polythene wrapping and found the contraband to be 996
grams only.
17.
Since the inventory proceedings were also part of
the material placed before the learned trial Court.
It was
incumbent upon the learned trial Court to have taken note of
the same, while sifting the material at least for the purpose of
framing the charge.
For it is by now well settled that a
person can be charged only for the contraband found in his
conscious and exclusive possession. The contraband having
been weighed without the carry bag and the polythene
wrapping, thus, was the quantity which can be said to have
been in the conscious and exclusive possession of the
accused.
18.
It further gain significance because Section 52-A of
the Act, inter-alia provides that every Courts trying an offence
under this Act, shall treat the inventory proceedings, the
photographs of drugs and any list of samples drawn under
sub-section (2) of the said section and certified by the learned
( 2026:HHC:41983 )
trial Court, as a primary evidence in respect of the said
offence.
19.
It may useful to refer to Section 52-A(4), which
reads thus:
“52 A. Disposal of seized narcotic drugs and
psychotropic substances…………
(4). Notwithstanding anything contained in the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of 1872) or the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974), every
court trying and offence under this Act, shall treat
the inventory, the photographs of [narcotic drugs,
psychotropic substances, controlled substances or
conveyances] and any list of samples drawn under
sub-section (2) and certified by the Magistrate, as
primary evidence in respect of such offence].
20.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court has also reiterated the
said view recently in a judgment titled as Bharat Aambale
versus State of Chhattisgarh (2025 8 Supreme Court
Cases 452).
21.
May be the ratio of the aforesaid judgment may not
be directly applicable in the facts and circumstances of this
case.
However, it does conclusively lays down that
presumption
of
truth
is
attached
to
the
proceedings
conducted before the learned Magistrate during the inventory
proceedings.
22.
( 2026:HHC:41983 )
It has been, inter-alia, held that the entire
procedure envisaged under Section 52A of the ND&PS Act, is
meant to inject fair play in the investigation and it has also
been held to be a mandatory rule of evidence and when there
is non-compliance of the same it would not constitute
primary evidence. Since the inventory proceedings have been
held to be primary evidence, it would otherwise be conducive
and in the interest of justice and fair play that the
contraband certified by the learned Magistrate during the
inventory
proceedings
is
considered,
as
the
quantity
recovered from the accused and consequently, he is charged
accordingly.
23.
The aforesaid enunciation of law discussed above
leads us to the irresistible conclusion that while framing
charges under the ND&PS Act, the learned trial Courts would
be well advised to sift the material placed before it and keep
the weight of the contraband referred in the inventory
proceedings, as a basic parameter while framing charges
against the accused under Section 228 of the Cr.P.C. (Section
251 of BNSS). Whatever is certified by the learned Magistrate
to be the quantity of contraband under Section 52(A)
( 2026:HHC:41983 )
(4) of the ND&PS Act shall be the quantity with which the
accused shall be charged. It will also usher in certainty in
law, rule out unnecessary ambiguities and bring about
predictability and uniformity, which ought to be a basic prerequisite in a country governed by the rule of law.
24.
Viewed in the aforesaid perspective, the impugned
order dated 02.07.2026, passed by the learned Special Judge
Hamirpur,
H.P.,
accused/petitioner
framing
under
charges
Section
against
20(b)(ii)(c)
the
cannot
be
sustained. As a sequel the same is quashed and set-aside.
The learned trial Court shall reframe the charges afresh
under Section 20(b)(ii)(b) keeping in view the quantity of
contraband reflected in the inventory proceedings i.e. 996
grams of charas. The revision petition is disposed of in the
aforesaid terms, so also the pending application(s), if any.
29th September, 2026
(subhash sharma)
(Chirag Bhanu Singh)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review