Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 3rd February, 2026
Uploaded on: 5th February, 2026.
+
RFA(COMM) 585/2025 &CM APPL. 65725/2025
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI
.....APPELLANT
Through: Mr. Siddhant Nath, SC, Mr. Bhavishya
Makija, Mr. Amaan Khan, Advs. with
Mr. Sudhir Raj Singh, EB(P).
versus
M/S RAM NIWAS GOEL
.....RESPONDENT
Through: Mr. Avnish Trivedi, Mr. Anurag
Kaushik & Mr. Rahul Aggarwal,
Advs.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
Prathiba M. Singh, J. (Oral)
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
The present appeal has been filed challenging the judgement and decree
dated 13th February, 2025 passed by the ld. District Judge, (Commercial-08),
Tis Hazari Courts, Central Delhi in Commercial Case No. 1156/2022. The
said commercial suit had been preferred by the Plaintiff/Respondent seeking
permanent injunction and recovery of Rs. 1,90,31,582/- along with interest.
3.
Vide the impugned order the said suit has been decreed in the following
terms:
“19. In view of my findings given on the above said issues, the
plaintiff shall be entitled to a decree for a sum of Rs.12,970,562/(
Rs.50,000/- i.e. withheld amount of 1st RA bill,
Rs.32,16,805/towards 2nd RA Bill, Rs.62,53,152/- towards 3rd
RA Bill, Rs.15,24,105/- towards 4th RA Bill, Rs.18,75,500/towards earnest money and Rs.51,000/- towards reserve
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
15:23:17
RFA(COMM) 585/2025
amount). Plaintiff shall also be entitled to interest@ 6% per
annum on the amount of Rs.12,970,562/- from the date of filing
of the suit till realization.”
4.
The brief facts of the case are that the Respondent/Plaintiff was
awarded a works contract dated 25th July, 2019 for construction of
classrooms, store rooms, computer rooms etc. for SDMC Pre School Lal Kuan
Chungi No. 2 in Ward No. 94-S, Central Zone. The total contractual amount
of the said work was Rs. 5,27,48,941/- and the same was to be completed
within 18 months. The Appellant/Defendant had cleared three RA Bills raised
by the Respondent/Plaintiff for various amounts on 26th May, 2020, 30th
September, 2020 and 12th March, 2021. However, the Appellant/Defendant
did not pay any amount in respect of the said RA Bills. Further, the grievance
of the Respondent/Plaintiff was that there were several hindrances being
created by the Appellant/Defendant in completion of the work.
5.
Thereafter, the contract came to an end on 3rd February, 2021, and
considering the dispute between the parties, the Respondent/Plaintiff had filed
the subject suit for recovery.
6.
The Trial Court had considered the matter and vide the impugned order
had decreed the suit in favour of the Respondent/Plaintiff.
7.
Today, the ld. Counsel for the Respondent has raised serious objection
to the Appellant - MCD filing the present appeal. It is his submission that the
present case is already covered by the settled law and that the filing of the
present appeal mechanically is nothing but abuse of process by the Appellant
Department. In support of this, he has brought to the notice of this Court the
order of the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court dated 11th July, 2024 passed in
RFA(Comm.) 188/2024 titled Municipal Corporation of Delhi vs. M/s. Ram
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
15:23:17
RFA(COMM) 585/2025
Niwas Goel, wherein the Court had directed for formulation of a protocol to
ensure that matters which stand covered by the judgements of the Courts are
not re-agitated. The relevant portion of the said judgment reads as under:
“6. We have heard learned counsel for the parties.
Given the fact that the appellant/Corporation has paid
the decretal amount in the instant case, we intend to give
the appellant/Corporation one more opportunity to
ensure that a system is put in place so that pleadings are
scrutinized by the Chief Law Officer before they are
filed in courts.
7. The Chief Law Officer shall ensure that the issues
which already stand covered by the judgments rendered
by the superior courts are not taken up without due
application of mind concerning the facts obtaining in a
particular case. Therefore, the appeal is disposed of
with the following directions:
(i) The Deputy Commissioner (Law), Municipal
Corporation of Delhi (MCD) with the assistance of the
Chief Law Officer, will evolve a protocol whereby
pleadings are scrutinized so that the assertions or
averments made in the pleadings are aligned with the
law of the land.
(ii) A copy of the protocol devised by the Deputy
Commissioner (Law) will be placed on this Court’s
record.
(iii) The burden of costs of Rs. 20,000/- imposed by the
trial court which was to be deposited with the Delhi
Legal Services Authority (Central) will be borne by the
appellant/Corporation.”
8.
According to ld. Counsel for the Respondent, the MCD has now
formulated a policy as per which they ought not to be pursuing these appeals
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
15:23:17
RFA(COMM) 585/2025
as the legal issues already stand settled by a catena of judgments including
RFA 160/2017 titled North Delhi Municipal Corporation v. Vipin Gupta.
The view taken in Vipin Gupta has been upheld by various Coordinate
Benches in RFA(COMM) 5/2021 titled North Delhi Municipal Corporation
v. Garg Construction Company decided on 15th March, 2021. The Vipin
Gupta (supra) judgment has also been upheld by the Supreme Court in a batch
of matters being SLP(C) No. 355/2019 titled North Delhi Municipal
Corporation vs. Vipin Gupta where the SLPs were dismissed on 3rd January,
2019. In Vipin Gupta (supra), one of us, sitting as a Single Bench had
observed that once RA bills are cleared and the same are not disputed by the
Corporation, payment cannot be withheld. The observations in Vipin Gupta
(supra) read as under:
“The present guidelines are being issued in all the
appeals. The Court has had the opportunity of perusing
the trial court records in all these 43 appeals. A perusal
of the records reveals the following:1. In most cases, the Contractors who are
awarded the work orders do not submit the
interim or final bills to the Engineer-in-Charge
for approval;
2. The final measurement recordal is done by the
Engineer-in-Charge;
3. The final bill is also prepared and passed by
the Engineer-in-Charge on his own accord and
the Contractor then accepts it;
4. The procedure for obtaining labour clearance
certificate from the Labour Officer is not
followed;
5. Once the bills are passed, Contractors are
made to wait endlessly for their payments on the
ground of non-availability of funds;
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
15:23:17
RFA(COMM) 585/2025
6. Even for refunds of Security Deposit and
Earnest money deposits, the Contractor is made
to wait till the final payment is made;
7. The measurement books and the photographs
of work, actually carried out, are not produced
in evidence.
The above process is contrary to the General Conditions
of Contract. It is therefore, necessary and important that
all the steps of the Contract are followed by the
Contractors and the Corporations. The following
guidelines are being passed:
1. Along with the work order, all the Clauses of the
General Conditions of Contract should be attached;
2. On the award of the Work order, periodic inspections
of the work being carried out should be done by the
Engineer-in-Charge;
3. If possible, photographs of the works at different
stages should be taken and maintained on the record;
4. Interim bills should be submitted by the Contractor –
duly certifying the work which has been carried out;
5. Final bills should be submitted by the Contractor –
duly certifying the work carried out along with
photographs;
6. The Bill should be scrutinised by the Engineer-inCharge, works should be recorded in the measurement
book and thereafter, the bill should be passed;
7. Once the Bill is passed, the payment schedule of 6
months and 9 months should be adhered to. Delay in
payments would result in Interest being levied;
8. For refunds of Security deposit and Earnest Money
deposit, the Contractor should unscrupulously comply
with the conditions in Clauses 17 and 45. For refunds
to be made, payment of final bill need not be awaited.
Once the conditions of Clauses 17 and 45 are complied
with and the final bill is passed, refunds ought to be
made;
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
15:23:17
RFA(COMM) 585/2025
9. In suits relating to recovery of Contractor’s dues, all
the evidence including the NIT, General Conditions of
Contract, periodic inspection reports, Final bill as
submitted, Final bill as passed, Measurements carried
out, Photographs etc., should be produced and duly
exhibited.
10. IT infrastructure ought to be created to maintain
records of the work orders, inspection reports, final
bills, photographs etc., digitally, as it is noticed that the
trial court record does not contain all the relevant
documents and in several cases, different versions of
clauses are relied upon by both sides, bills are not
properly understandable and there is no evidence of
actual inspections or measurements having been taken.
Maintenance of digital records will make it more
transparent and easily accessible for the officials and
for production in the Court in case of future litigation.
Adherence to the above shall ensure that the works are
duly carried out as per the quality standards prescribed
and there is proper record of work being done. Once the
work is carried out payments ought not to be delayed,
inasmuch as delay in payments compromises on
availability of quality civil work for the Corporations,
who take care of basic amenities for citizens such as
roads, pavements, civil works, sewerage lines etc.
These guidelines shall be read along with the
judgments pronounced today in these appeals.”
9.
Even in the present case, a decree has been granted by the ld.
Commercial Court on the ground that the RA bills have been proved on
record. A perusal of the evidence also revealed that the witness for the MCD
who was the Assistant Engineer, PR-II Central Zone had admitted the RA
bills. The relevant portion of the evidence of the said witness is as under:
“Q. Can you bring the copy of complete set of
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
15:23:17
RFA(COMM) 585/2025
agreement and passed running bills (1 to 4) of this
work?
Ans. I have admitted 3 passed running bills which are
already on record exhibited as Ex.PW1/22 to
Ex.PW1/24. Today I have brought the IVth bill, which is
Ex.DW1/P1.”
10.
Further, the ld. Counsel for the MCD has pointed to the Respondent’s
evidence wherein it is accepted by the Respondent that the work was
incomplete and only 35% was completed. The relevant portion of the same
reads as under:
“The bill in relation to the work order pertaining to
which I have filed the instant suit has already been
passed by the MCD. However, I admit that the work is
incomplete. Work more than 35 percent is complete. It
is correct that the time schedule as per GCC has not
been submitted by me. Vol., the department refused to
accept the same. It is incorrect to suggest that I am not
entitled to claim the suit amount. It is incorrect to
suggest that I have not completed work order on the
given site even after lapse of more than 36 months,
though the work was to be completed within 18 months.
It is incorrect to suggest that since the department has
prepared the bill on its own, I am not entitled for any
interest.”
11.
The stand of the MCD is that only 35% of the work was completed.
This Court is of the view that if there was any breach by the Contractor, it was
for the MCD to avail of its remedies. Once the RA bills for the work which
was completed has been admitted and approved by the MCD, the grant of the
decree cannot be faulted.
12.
Under these circumstances, since the decree has been passed based on
these very RA bills, no interference is called for in this matter. Even the award
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
15:23:17
RFA(COMM) 585/2025
of interest is reasonable @ 6% from the date of filing of the suit.
13.
As per the directions passed on 16th October, 2025, the entire decretal
amount has been deposited and is lying in FDR. Let the same be released to
the Respondent along with the accrued interest after deducting the TDS on
the interest amount.
14.
The appeal is disposed of in the above terms. Pending applications, if
any, are also disposed of.
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
MADHU JAIN
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 3, 2026
dj/msh
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
15:23:17
RFA(COMM) 585/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review