The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. In view of the aforesaid, the point of sentence is considered. It seems that the appellant has suffered approximately eight months of his incarceration out of 04 years. That apart. the appellant has suffered the ordeal of criminal case since 2014. There is no minimum sentence prescribed in this regard. On this aspect, the law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court, in the case of R. Kumarawal (supra) as well as the settled propositions of law endorsed by Co-ordinate bench of this court, has been perused.
15. In view of the aforesaid legal proposition regarding non-commercial quantity so also considering the ailment of kidney and the fact that there is no criminal record/antecedents of the appellant, therefore, this Court finds it expedient to partly allow this appeal.
16. Accordingly, this Criminal Appeal is partly allowed and the sentence under Section 18 of the NDPS Act awarded to the appellant is hereby reduced to nine months R.I. from Four years R.I. by enhancing the fine from Rs.25,000/- to Rs.1,00,000/-. In case of failure to deposit the fine amount, the appellant shall further undergo for three months Simple Imprisonment.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PREM NARAYAN SINGH
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 13340 of 2023
BETWEEN:MUKESH S/O MOTILAL DAMAMI, AGED ABOUT 39
Y E A R S , OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURIST VILLAGE
DOLATPURA, P.S. TAAL, DISTRICT RATLAM (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(SHRI ABHAY SARASWAT, ADVOCATE) .
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH STATION HOUSE
OFFICER THROUGH POLICE STATION NARCOTIC CELL
INDORE, CIRCLE MANDSAUR, DISTRICT MANDSAUR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
( SHRI SURENDRA GUPTA, GOVT. ADVOCATE) .
Reserved on :24.01.2024
Pronounced on : 29..01.2024
This criminal appeal having been heard and reserved for judgments,
coming on for pronouncement this day, the court passed the following:
JUDGMENT
1. This criminal appeal is preferred under section 374 of Cr.P.C. by the
appellant being aggrieved by the judgment dated 15.09.2023, passed by learned
Special Judge, NDPS Act, Neemuch, in S.T. No.24/2019, whereby the
appellant has been convicted for the offence punishable under Section 18 of
NDPS Act and sentenced to undergo 4 years RI with fine of Rs.25,000/-, with
default stipulation.
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 31-01-2024
16:11:34
2. The appellant was tried and charged under Section 8/18 of NDPS Act.
The learned trial Court, after considering the evidence and material available on
record has convicted the appellant, as stated above in para No. 1 of this order.
3. As per prosecution story dated on 02/06/2014, SI Dashrath Singh
Cho uhan received secret information from informant about one person
transporting illegal contraband Opium and is standing opposite to Passenger
waiting area on Bhuniyakhedi Fanta near Mandsaur Krashi Mandi with illegal
opium to give the same to some smuggler. Thereafter police party prepared
necessary punchnamas, called two independent witnesses and reached at
Bhuniyakhedi Fanta and saw one person sitting which matches the description
as that of secret information, Police successfully intercept the said person who
revealed his name as appellant Mukesh. During search, police found total 1.5 kg
Opium from the possession of accused appellant. Thereafter police registered
the crime and arrested the accused person.
4 . It is submitted by the counsel for the appellant that the appellant
deserves some leniency as he is a kidney patient. The appellant has preferred
this criminal appeal on several grounds but during the course of arguments,
learned counsel for the appellant did not press this appeal on merits and not
assail the finding part of judgment. He confines his arguments on the point of
sentence. .Counsel for the appellant assures that the appellant will not involve in
s uc h criminal activities in future. He also submitted that the appellant has
suffered approximately eight month's custody period. He further submitted
that he is having regard to all circumstances which resulted in appellant's
conviction and further keeping in view the fact that the appellant was facing the
trial before the concerned Court for more than 04 years, therefore, he prayed
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 31-01-2024
16:11:34
that the appeal be partly allowed and the sentence awarded to the appellant be
reduced to the period already undergone.
5. In support of his contention, counsel for the appellant has placed
reliance over the judgment passed in CRA No.7063/2022 (Mukesh Kumar
Jatav Vs. The State of Madhya Pradesh) decided on 12.05.2023 wherein
co-ordinate Bench of this Court has reduced and undergone the sentence of the
appellant in only 09 months out of 10 years. Similarly, in this Bench in the case
of Tulsiram vs. State of M.P. passed in CRA No.12105/2023 decided on
01.12.2023 wherein this Bench has passed the sentence of six months out of
four years of imprisonment by enhancing the fine from Rs.30000/- to
Rs.100000/-.
6. Learned Govt. Advocate has opposed the prayer. He supported the
judgment and order by submitting that there is clear evidence against the
appellant, therefore, he prays for dismissal of the appeal.
7. I have considered rival contentions of the parties and have perused the
record.
8. So for as the contentions on merits of the case raised in appeal memo
by learned counsel for the appellant is concerned, the learned trial Court has not
committed any error in appreciation of evidence available on record. Further, it
is found that the Court below considered the evidence available on record and
correctly found that the case of the prosecution is well supported by the
witnesses and documentary testimony. The procedure was well followed by the
prosecution and the witnesses of prosecution have profoundly supported the
prosecution case. The Court below has well considered the material available on
record, hence, no infirmity is found in the impugned order of conviction passed
by the Court below, accordingly, the same is upheld.
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 31-01-2024
16:11:34
9 . In so far as
the sentence is concerned, learned counsel for the
appellant has alternatively prayed only on the part of sentence and submitted
that since the appellant has already suffered approximately eight months of his
jail incarceration out of four years, he may be released only with the undergone
sentence by enhancing the fine amount. It is also submitted that the appellant is
a patient of kidney and he cannot be properly treated in the jail hospital, hence,
he may be released for undergone period by enhancing fine amount.
10. In this regard, earlier also the Hon'ble Apex Court as well as this
Court has also considered the prayer and reduced the incarceration period of
the accused persons to the period already undergone in the cases where the
quantity of the contraband is found to be of non-commercial or lesser than the
commercial quantity.
11. On this aspect, the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of R. Kumaravel
vs. Inspector of Police NIB CID (RA No.1056/2019) decided on
15.07.2019 has observed as under:"As per Section 20(b)(ii) (b) of minimum punishment is prescribed
for involvement of the quantity lesser than commercial quantity, by greater
than the small quantity.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant has submitted
that the appellant has no criminal antecedents. The appellant has already
undergone imprisonment for about 206 days. Considering the facts and
circumstances of the case, the sentence of imprisonment of two years
imposed upon the appellant is reduced to one year."
12. Further, on this aspect, the case of Mangilal Vs. Central Narcotics
Bureau 2006 Law Suit (MP)111 is worth referring here wherein the Court has
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 31-01-2024
16:11:34
partly allowed the appeal and as the case was related to 2 kg opium i.e. non-
commercial quantity, passed a conviction for 3 years RI with fine of Rs. 1000/instead of 5 years. Similarly, in the case of Kamal Vs. State of M.P. 2012
Law Suit (M.P. 2298 (CRA No.10/2011), Baba @ Akash Sonkar vs.
State of M.P. 2020 Law Suit MP 1645 (CRA No.426/2000), Bhagwat
Patel Vs. State of M.P. 2022 Law Suit 789 (CRA No.674/2022), Munna
@ Munnu Pandit 2022 Law Suit 789 (CRA No.2494/2022) the co-ordinate
Bench have reduced to the sentences of the accused persons respectively in
non-commercial quantities. In the case of Kamal (supra), the co-ordinate
Bench has undergone the punishment in approximately two years out of five
years for non-commercial quantity, in the case of Baba @ Akash Sonkar
(supra), undergone the sentence in one year out of seven years imprisonment,
in Bhagwat Patel (supra) the Bench has reduced the sentence to the period
already undergone in 8 months and similarly in in the case of Munna (supra) in
seven months.
13. So far as the fact that the appellant is a kidney patient, learned
counsel has submitted that this thing at bar but not filed any relevant document,
however, in this regard, no objection was pleaded by the Government
Advocate.
14. In view of the aforesaid, the point of sentence is considered. It seems
that the appellant has suffered approximately eight months of his incarceration
out of 04 years. That apart. the appellant has suffered the ordeal of criminal
case since 2014. There is no minimum sentence prescribed in this regard. On
this aspect, the law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court, in the case of R.
Kumarawal (supra) as well as the settled propositions of law endorsed by
Co-ordinate bench of this court, has been perused.
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 31-01-2024
16:11:34
15. In view of the aforesaid legal proposition regarding non-commercial
quantity so also considering the ailment of kidney and the fact that there is no
criminal record/antecedents of the appellant, therefore, this Court finds it
expedient to partly allow this appeal.
16. Accordingly, this Criminal Appeal is partly allowed and the sentence
under Section 18 of the NDPS Act awarded to the appellant is hereby reduced
to nine months R.I. from Four years R.I. by enhancing the fine from
Rs.25,000/- to Rs.1,00,000/-. In case of failure to deposit the fine amount, the
appellant shall further undergo for three months Simple Imprisonment.
17. The judgment of learned trial Court regarding disposal of the seized
property stands affirmed.
18. A copy of this order be sent to the concerned trial Court for
necessary compliance.
(PREM NARAYAN SINGH)
JUDGE
VD
Signed by: VARSHA DUBEY
Signing time: 31-01-2024
16:11:34
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review