Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRM-M-57871 and 72320-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH.
(1)
Sombir
Date of Decision: 10.04.2026.
CRM-M-57871-2025
....Petitioner.
VERSUS
State of Haryana
....Respondent.
WITH
(2)
CRM-M-72320-2025
Mukesh Kumar
VERSUS
State of Haryana
***
....Petitioner.
....Respondent.
CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY VASHISTH
--Present:
Mr. Raman Sihag, Advocate and
Mr. Vishwash Kumar, Advocate for the petitioners.
Mr. Parveen Kumar Aggarwal, Additional Advocate General,
Haryana.
Mr. Arun Kumar, Advocate for the complainant.
****
SANJAY VASHISTH, J. (Oral)
Petitioner-Sombir (in CRM-M-57871-2025) and petitionerMukesh Kumar (in CRM-M-72320-2025), have filed the aforementioned two
petitions under Section 483 BNSS, 2023, seeking regular bail in case FIR
No.02 dated 07.01.2025, under Sections 115, 126, 3(5), 351(3) of BNS, and
Sections 61(2) and 109(1) of BNS added later on), registered at Police Station
Bawani Khera, District Bhiwani.
2.
Present case was registered on the statement of the complainant-
Sonu Sharma s/o Gopal Sharma, and the allegations of the prosecution are
stated as under:
JITENDER
2026.04.10 19:29
I attest to the accuracy of
this document
CRM-M-57871 and 72320-2025
“ that on 06.01.2025, at about 6.22 P.M. he received a call from
an unknown person that his (complainant) brother was lying on
Pur road in injured condition, upon which, the complainant
reached at the spot and found that his brother was lying there in
injured condition and blood was oozing from the injuries. He
shifted his brother to Civil Hospital, Bawani Khera from where
his brother was referred to Bhiwani. His brother disclosed t him
that when he was going for walking ồ towards village Pur, an
Alto car came from behind and directly hit him. When he got up
and started walking, then three persons alighted from the said
car, blocked his way and caused injuries with "Farsa" and iron
rod on his hands, legs and head and also extended threats to kill
him. Thereafter, out of them one stated that Raj Kumar someone
is coming, let's go. After that they left him and went away. His
brother has already having a dispute with his maternal uncle's
sons Jogender and Bhupender and he has suspicion that they got
Naveen injured. Request was made to trace out the culprits and
take appropriate legal action against them. On the basis of
abovesaid complaint, present FIR under Sections 115, 126(2),
351(3) 3(5) of B.N. S., 2023 was registered.”
3.
After hearing learned counsel for the petitioners, following order
was passed on 27.02.2026:“1. The instant petitions have been filed under Section 483 of
BNSS, 2023 (earlier Section 439 Cr.P.C.), for grant of regular
bail to the petitioners, during the pendency of trial, who have
been booked in a criminal case arising out of First Information
Report, as detailed hereunder:Name of
FIR
petitioner(s) No.
Date
Section(s)
Police
Station
District
Sombir
(in CRMM578712025)
07.01.2025 115, 126, 3(5), 351(3) Bawani
of BNS, 2023 (61(2), Khera
109(1) of BNS added
later on)
Bhiwani
Mukesh
Kumar (in
CRM-M723202025)
07.01.2025 115, 126, 3(5), 351(3) Bawani
of BNS, 2023 (61(2), Khera
109(1) of BNS added
later on)
Bhiwani
2.
In the present case, FIR was registered at the instance of
complainant – Sonu Sharma, brother of injured Naveen, which
reads as under:“….. that I am Sonu Sharma, son of Gopal Sharma, resident of
village Siwada. Today on 1 06.01.2025 at 6.22 PM, I received a call
from an unknown person that your brother naveen is lying injured on
Pur Road, someone should reach there with a car. When I reached the
spot, my brother was badly injured. He had injuries on both his hands
and right leg and was bleeding profusely. There was a long cut mark
JITENDER
2026.04.10 19:29
I attest to the accuracy of
this document
CRM-M-57871 and 72320-2025
on his head as well and was bleeding profusely. I immediately took my
brother in the car to Civil Hospital Bhiwani kheda where the doctor
treated him and referred him to Bhiwani. My brother told me that
when I was going towards village Pur for a walk, an Alto car hit me
from behind. When I got up and started walking, three persons came
out of the car, stopped me and hit me hard on both my hands and
head with an axe and Iron Pipe and also threatened to kill me. After
that, one of them said that someone is coming 'Raj Kumar', let's go,
after that they left him there and went away. My brother Naveen is
already having a dispute with my Mosi's sons, Jogendra and
Bhupendra S/o Harishchandra R/o of Siwada, I have suspicion that
my brother Naveen has been beaten because of Jogendra and
Bhupendra. You are requested to find out the persons who injured him
and take appropriate legal action against them. Yours sincerely Sonu
Sharma son of Shri Gopal Sharma village Siwada Mobile No.
9992678981.”
3.
It is admitted position that charge-sheeting the accused
under Section 109 of BNS, 2023, has been assailed by one of the
coaccused, namely, Bhupender in CRR-2524-2025, titled as,
“Joginder v. State of Haryana and others” and therein, vide
order dated 30.10.2025, proceedings before the trial Court have
been directed to be adjourned to the date beyond the date fixed
before this Court (High Court). The relevant operative part of
the order dated 30.10.2025, is reproduced hereunder:“CRR-2524-2025
Petitioner, an accused in case FIR No.02 dated 07.01.2025,
has assailed the order dated 02.06.2025 passed by learned Sessions
Judge, Bhiwani, vide which petitioner was charge sheeted under
Sections 61, 351(3), 126, 109(2), 115, 117(2), 3(5) of BNS.
Notice of motion to respondent No.1 – State only at this stage.
At this stage, Ms. Shweta Nahata, DAG, Haryana, accepts
notice on behalf of respondents No.1-State and prays for time to file
status report in the matter.
Adjourned to 16.12.2025.
In the meantime, learned trial Court is directed to adjourn the
case beyond the date fixed before this Court.”
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner(s) submits that co-
accused – Joginder has been granted bail by this Court vide
order dated 18.09.2025, passed in CRM-M-33740-2025, titled
as, “Jogender v. State of Haryana” (Annexure P-6), it is
clarified that co-accused Jogender was attributed of conducting
recce of the victim/injured and while considering the bail, it was
noticed in the said petition that main accused was Bhupender,
who had got recovered one iron pipe also. Thus, learned counsel
argues that petitioner – Mukesh Kumar (in CRM-M-72320-2025)
JITENDER
2026.04.10 19:29
I attest to the accuracy of
this document
CRM-M-57871 and 72320-2025
was driving the Alto car, which was occupied by the accused
persons, and petitioner – Sombir (in CRM-M-57871-2025) was
though accompanying the accused persons, however, no specific
role has been assigned against him.
5.
At this stage, facts mentioned in the application dated
03.02.2025 (appended as Annexure P-3 along with CRM-M57871- 2025), have been noticed, which are reads as under:“Copy of Medical Opinion dated 03.02.2025 regaring
Injuries of Naveen Police Station: Bawani Khera District: Bhiwani
FIR no. 2 dated 07.01.2025 u/s 115, 126, 3 (5), 351 (3) of Bharatiya
Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) 2023 Polcie Station Bawani Khera, District
Bhiwani.
To
The Medical Officer
GH, Bawani Khera
Sir,
It is stated that Naveen S/o Gopal R/o Siwada, was injured in
fight on 06.01.2025, regarding which MLR no. RC/BK/6/1/25/01
dated 06.01.2025 was issued by GH Bawani Khera. MLR mentioned
6 injuries. Wherein on 27.01.2025 as per medical opinion sought
from you, Injuries no. 1,2,3,4,6 have been stated to be Grievous in
nature but regarding Injury no.5 no opinion was given. Hence by this
application it is requested that "Whether because of Injuries received
by Naveen and blood loss from these injuries, Naveen could have dies
or not", Please provide opinion.
Sd/-SHO
PS Bawani Khera
Dated: 03.02.2025
As per MLR no.RC/BK/6/1/25/01 dated 06.01.2025 and BHT
Gno.258:
Injury no. 5 is Simple in Nature.
Patient could have been died due to bleeding or Trauma from Injury.
Sd/Medical Officer
03.02.2025”
6.
State is directed to verify the health condition of the
injured Naveen, after getting him examined from the
Government hospital.
7.
List again on 25.03.2026.
Photocopy of this order be placed on the file of other
connected case.”
JITENDER
2026.04.10 19:29
I attest to the accuracy of
this document
CRM-M-57871 and 72320-2025
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that, as per the
information provided by injured-Naveen, to his brother-Sonu Sharma, there
was a dispute involving his uncle’s sons, namely Jogender and Bhupender.
Said Jogender has already been granted bail by the co-ordinate Bench of this
Court vide order dated 18.09.2025 (P-6) passed in CRM-M-33740-2025,
whereas Bhupender has also been extended the concession of bail by this
Court, vide order dated 07.04.2026 passed in CRM-M-6326-2026. The role
assigned to co-accused-Jogender was limited to conducting reki of injuredNaveen. Counsel further submits that, as per FIR, no specific injury has been
attributed to any of the accused. The role attributed to the petitioner is of
giving Danda blow, however, there is no specific injury attributed to the
petitioner. Rather, on the basis of suspicion against two of the accused,
namely Jogender and Bhupender, the FIR was registered, and petitioner’s
name surfaced thereafter during the course of investigation. The injuries
allegedly suffered by Naveen, as noticed in the order granting bail to coaccused Jogender, read as under:
“i) Laceration of 0.5 cm and 0.2 cm over left leg adv xray left
leg ortho opinion.
ii)
Swelling over right leg adv xray right leg ortho opinion.
iii) Swelling of 4*4 cm over left forearm and wrist adv xray
left forearm ortho opinion.
iv) Swelling of 5*4 cm over right forearm with bone
protruding out adv xray right forearm with wrist ortho opinion.
v)
Laceration of 6*2 cm over right side of forehead adv ncct
head sr opinion.
vi) Laceration of 03.0*2 cm with swelling over right arm adv
xray right arm ortho opinion."
5.
JITENDER
2026.04.10 19:29
I attest to the accuracy of
this document
On being asked by the Court, learned State Counsel informed
CRM-M-57871 and 72320-2025
that injured-Naveen, has already been examined in Court and has fully
supported the case of the prosecution. However, counsel submits that out of
the total six injuries, five, though inflicted on non-vital parts, were declared
grievous. Since injured has supported the case of the prosecution while
appearing in the witness box, counsel contends that there is no ground for
extending the concession of bail to the petitioner.
Status report dated 05.04.2026 has been filed in Court today,
which is taken on record. Registry to tag the same at an appropriate place. As
per the status report, the health condition of injured-Naveen has been detailed
which appears to be of a normal condition as on day.
6.
I have considered the submissions made and have gone through
the record, along with the appended documents.
7.
Considering the fact that petitioner-Sombir is aged 38 years and
petitioner-Mukesh Kumar is aged 37 years and are in custody since
24.02.2025 (i.e., for more than one year), and are not involved in any other
case, and further noticing that the injured has already been examined in Court
and as per status report, his health condition is normal as on day, as well as
co-accused namely Jogender has already been granted bail by the co-ordinate
Bench of this Court vide order dated 18.09.2025 (P-6) passed in CRM-M33740-2025, whereas Bhupender has also been extended the concession of
bail by this Court, vide order dated 07.04.2026 passed in CRM-M-6326-2026,
this Court does not find any substantial reason to continue the detention of the
petitioners in jail any longer.
8.
With the aforementioned observations and without expressing
any opinion on the merits of the case, both the petitions are allowed.
Petitioner-Sombir and petitioner-Mukesh Kumar are ordered to be released on
JITENDER
2026.04.10 19:29
I attest to the accuracy of
this document
CRM-M-57871 and 72320-2025
bail, subject to their furnishing bail/surety bonds to the satisfaction of the
learned trial Court/ Chief Judicial Magistrate/Illaqa Magistrate/ Duty
Magistrate concerned, if not required in any other case.
9.
Any of the discussion done and recorded hereabove, shall not be
construed as an expression of opinion on the facts of the case. Therefore, trial
Court is expected to decide the case by taking an independent view, on the
basis of evidence available on record, as expeditiously as possible in
accordance with law.
10.
Accordingly, both the petitions stand disposed of.
11.
Photocopy of this order be placed on the connected file.
(SANJAY VASHISTH)
JUDGE
10.04.2026
jitender
Whether speaking/ reasoned
Whether Reportable
JITENDER
2026.04.10 19:29
I attest to the accuracy of
this document
:
:
Yes/ No
Yes/ No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review