Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment reserved on: 18.12.2025
Judgment pronounced on: 05.01.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 12.01.2026
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
MUKESH KUMAR
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Ayush, Amicus Curiae
along with the petitioner-inperson.
versus
STATE
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Manoj Pant, APP for the
State
CORAM:
HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE SWARANA KANTA SHARMA
JUDGMENT
Index to the Judgment
FACTUAL BACKGROUND .................................................................. 2
SUBMISSIONS BEFORE THE COURT ............................................. 4
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS ..................................................................... 6
A. Testimonies of the Prosecution witnesses ................................................. 7
B. Recovery of the Alleged Stolen Property ................................................... 9
C. Whether the Ingredients of Robbery Are Made Out ............................ 10
D. Whether the Offence of Theft Is Made Out ......................................... 16
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
1.
The petitioner herein has been convicted, in case arising out of
FIR bearing no. 428/2015, registered at Police Station Saket, Delhi
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
for the commission of offence punishable under Section 392/411 of
the Indian Penal Code, 1860 [hereafter ‗IPC‘], by the learned
ACMM, South District, Saket Courts, Delhi [hereafter ‗Trial Court‘].
He was convicted vide judgment dated 02.01.2016 for offence under
Section 392 of IPC and was sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for a
period of seven years and payment of fine of ₹10,000/- vide order on
sentence dated 04.01.2016 by the learned Trial Court. His appeal
against the conviction, i.e. Criminal Appeal No. 27/2016, was
dismissed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, South District,
Saket, New Delhi [hereafter ‗Appellate Court‘] vide impugned
judgment dated 03.11.2016, however, the sentence was modified to
the extent that he has been directed to undergo rigorous imprisonment
for a period of four years alongwith payment of fine of ₹10,000/-. By
way of this revision petition, he has assailed the judgments and
orders passed by the learned Trial Court and Appellate Court.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
2.
The brief facts of the case, as emerging from the prosecution
version, are that on 07.04.2015 at about 8:15 a.m., the complainant,
namely Arvind Singh, had been travelling in a bus plying on Route
No. 34 from M.B. Road, Lado Sarai to Badarpur, within the
jurisdiction of Police Station Saket. It is alleged that during the said
journey, the petitioner had dishonestly removed the complainant‘s
purse from his pocket without his consent. It is further stated that one
of the co-passengers had alerted the complainant about the removal
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
of the purse. It is further alleged that, in order to retain the stolen
property, the petitioner had threatened the complainant and his friend,
Jitender, with instant harm by using a blade. The purse, which
allegedly contained the complainant‘s driving licence and cash
amounting to ₹100/-, had been recovered from the possession of the
petitioner, who had been apprehended at the spot. Thereafter, the
friend of the complainant had made a call at the 100 number,
pursuant to which the police had reached the spot. The FIR had
thereafter been registered on the basis of the complaint lodged by the
complainant.
3.
During investigation, the recovered purse was seized vide
seizure memo Ex. PW-1/B and a site plan was prepared. The
petitioner was thereafter formally arrested. Chargesheet was filed
after completion of investigation for offence under Sections
379/411/506 of IPC. Charges for offence under Sections 392/411 of
IPC were framed against the petitioner vide order dated 18.06.2015.
4.
During the course of trial, the prosecution examined four
witnesses. The petitioner did not lead any defence evidence;
however, his statement under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 [hereafter ‗Cr.P.C.‘] was recorded, wherein he
claimed that he had been falsely implicated due to a quarrel with the
complainant at the bus stop.
5.
Upon conclusion of trial, the learned Trial Court convicted the
petitioner for the offence punishable under Section 392 of IPC and
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
sentenced him to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of
seven years along with payment of fine of ₹10,000/-.
6.
In appeal, while the learned Appellate Court upheld the
conviction, it reduced the substantive sentence from seven years to
four years, without any alteration in the fine imposed.
7.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner has approached this Court by
way of the present revision petition.
SUBMISSIONS BEFORE THE COURT
8.
The learned amicus curiae appearing for the petitioner submits
that the prosecution has failed to establish its case beyond reasonable
doubt and that the findings recorded by the learned Trial Court as
well as the learned Appellate Court are vitiated by a misapplication
of law. It is contended that the purse of the complainant was not
recovered from the possession of the petitioner. It is further argued
that neither was the alleged blade, stated to have been used by the
petitioner, recovered, nor did the complainant or PW-2 sustain any
injury in the alleged incident. The learned amicus curiae further
argues that the prosecution failed to examine any independent public
witness, despite the incident having allegedly taken place in a public
bus in the presence of several passengers, which casts serious doubt
on the prosecution version. According to the learned amicus curiae,
the essential ingredients of the offence of robbery are not made out in
the present case. It is argued that even if the prosecution version is
accepted at face value, the conviction of the petitioner under Section
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
392 of IPC is unsustainable, as no weapon was recovered and no
injury was caused either to the complainant or to PW-2, and at best,
the allegations would constitute an offence of theft. The learned
amicus curiae has also pointed out various inconsistencies and
investigative lapses. It is also stated that no bus ticket was recovered
from or produced by the complainant, PW-2, or any other copassenger; no effort was made by the Investigating Officer (I.O.) to
verify the presence of the complainant and the petitioner inside the
bus; and no call detail records were placed on record to support the
prosecution case. It is further contended that although the prosecution
claims that all concerned persons had alighted at Saket Metro Bus
Stand, which is a CCTV-covered public place, no CCTV footage was
collected or produced during trial. Additionally, it is argued that the
purse was not recovered from the possession of the petitioner, as the
prosecution witnesses have categorically deposed that the purse was
handed over to the police by PW-1 himself. This aspect, according to
the learned amicus curiae, stands corroborated by the testimonies of
PW-2, PW-3, and PW-4. On these grounds, it is argued that the
present revision petition be allowed.
9.
Per contra, the learned APP appearing for the State submits
that the offence in question is of a serious nature. It is argued that the
petitioner had initially committed theft of the complainant‘s purse in
a moving bus and, upon being apprehended, had taken out a blade
and threatened the complainant with the intention of causing harm,
thereby attracting the offence of robbery. The learned APP submits
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
that PW-1 and PW-2 have categorically deposed against the
petitioner and have remained consistent in their version that the
petitioner had stolen the purse of PW-1 and had threatened them by
using a blade. The learned APP further argues that the petitioner has
previous involvement in similar offences and that as many as nine
FIRs have been registered against him, which clearly indicates that he
is a habitual offender. It is also argued that although the petitioner
was initially sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for a period of
seven years along with payment of fine of ₹10,000/-, with a default
sentence of two months‘ simple imprisonment, the learned Appellate
Court had already taken a lenient view by reducing the substantive
sentence to four years‘ rigorous imprisonment while maintaining the
fine amount. In view of the overall facts and circumstances of the
case, and since all the prosecution witnesses have supported the
prosecution version, the learned APP submits that the present
revision petition deserves to be dismissed.
10.
This Court has heard arguments addressed by the learned
amicus curiae appearing for the petitioner and the learned APP for
the State, and has perused the material available on record.
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
11.
The principal issue that has emerged for consideration in the
present case, upon a careful examination of the rival contentions
advanced on behalf of the parties, is whether the offence alleged to
have been committed by the petitioner constitutes the offence of
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
robbery, or whether the facts on record disclose only an offence of
theft simpliciter.
A. Testimonies of the Prosecution witnesses
12.
It is a matter of record that the prosecution examined four
witnesses in support of its case. PW-1 is the complainant, PW-2 is
the complainant‘s friend, namely Jitendra, and PW-3 and PW-4 are
the police officials associated with the investigation. No independent
public witness was examined by the prosecution
13.
The statement of the complainant (PW-1) was initially
recorded under Section 161 of the Cr.P.C., on the basis of which the
FIR came to be registered. Thereafter, the complainant was examined
as a prosecution witness before the Court. One of the principal
submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioner is that the
complainant has made material improvements in his testimony. It is,
therefore, necessary to examine and compare the statements of the
complainant to assess the merit of this contention.
14.
In his statement recorded under Section 161 of Cr.P.C., the
complainant stated that one person, i.e. the present petitioner/
accused, had been standing near him in the bus and had removed his
purse from his pocket and attempted to flee. He further stated that the
accused was apprehended by the passengers of the bus and that the
purse was recovered from the accused by the complainant himself. It
was also stated that the accused had threatened the complainant and
his friend, Jitendra (PW-2), and attempted to escape. In the
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
complaint, the complainant specifically stated that “mujhe aur mere
dost Jitendra ko blade se marne ki dhamki de raha tha aur bhagne ki
koshish kar raha tha.”
15.
When examined before the Court as PW-1, the complainant
broadly reiterated the incident. However, he made a further statement
to the effect that the petitioner had threatened him and his friend by
taking out a blade and by saying, “Agar najdeek aaoge toh mar
dunga.” It is pertinent to note that this specific statement did not find
mention in the complainant‘s statement recorded under Section 161
of Cr.P.C.
16.
PW-2, Jitendra, the friend of the complainant, is the only
eyewitness examined in the present case. Upon a careful perusal of
his testimony, it is evident that he has substantially supported the
version of PW-1. He has deposed that on 07.04.2015 at around 8:15
a.m., he and the complainant had boarded a bus from Lado Sarai and
were travelling towards Saket Metro Station, when the petitioner had
removed the purse of PW-1 from his pocket. He further stated that
the accused was apprehended by other passengers in the bus and that
the accused attempted to threaten them by using a blade.
17.
PW-3 and PW-4 are the police witnesses, being the constable
and the I.O., respectively. Both witnesses deposed that they had
received DD No. 11-A regarding a thief who had been apprehended
at Saket Metro Station. Upon reaching the spot, they found PW-1 and
PW-2 present along with the petitioner. They stated that PW-1 and
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
PW-2 narrated the incident that had taken place in the bus and
produced the purse, which contained a driving licence in the name of
the complainant and a ₹100 currency note. The purse was seized by
PW-4 vide seizure memo Ex. PW-1/B. PW-3 further deposed that
10–15 public persons were present at the spot at that time. The
personal search of the petitioner was conducted vide memo Ex. PW1/D; however, nothing was recovered from his person.
18.
Before proceeding further, it is also pertinent to note that the
complainant (PW-1) and his friend (PW-2) have consistently stated in
their respective testimonies that the petitioner had threatened them by
using a blade. However, it is an admitted position on record that
neither the complainant nor PW-2 sustained any injury in the alleged
incident.
19.
On the other hand, the medical record of the petitioner is
available on record. The MLC of the petitioner reflects that he had
sustained injuries, which stand corroborated by the testimonies of
PW-1 and PW-2, wherein it has been stated that the petitioner was
apprehended by the passengers of the bus and was beaten by them.
The injuries noted in the MLC of the petitioner are as follows:
●
Abrasion on the left side of the nose measuring 0.5 cm.
●
Swelling on the right lower forearm measuring 3 × 2 cm,
accompanied by swelling and redness.
B.
Recovery of the Alleged Stolen Property
20.It is evident from the prosecution evidence that the purse in
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
question had already been recovered by the complainant and
his friend prior to the arrival of the Investigating Officer at the
spot. The said purse was thereafter handed over to the
Investigating Officer upon his arrival.
21.The recovered purse was seized by the Investigating Officer
vide seizure memo Ex. PW-1/B. As per the seizure memo and
the deposition of the prosecution witnesses, the complainant
handed over a black-coloured purse containing a ₹100
currency note and the driving licence of the complainant,
which was stated to have been recovered from the pocket of
the pants of the petitioner.
C.
Whether the Ingredients of Robbery Are Made Out
22.
One of the core issues requiring consideration in the present
case is whether the offence alleged against the petitioner satisfies the
statutory ingredients of robbery. For this purpose, it is necessary to
examine the definition of robbery as contained in Section 390 of the
IPC, which reads as under:
―390. Robbery.— In all robbery, there is either theft or
extortion.
When theft is robbery — Theft is ―robbery‖ if, in order to the
committing of the theft, or in committing the theft, or in
carrying away or attempting to carry away property obtained
by the theft, the offender, for that end, voluntarily causes or
attempts to cause to any person death or hurt or wrongful
restraint, or fear of instant death or of instant hurt, or of instant
wrongful restraint.
When extortion is robbery — Extortion is ―robbery‖ if the
offender, at the time of committing the extortion, is in the
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
presence of the person put in fear, and commits the extortion
by putting that person in fear of instant death, of instant hurt, or
of instant wrongful restraint to that person or to some other
person, and, by so putting in fear, induces the person, so put in
fear then and there to deliver up the thing extorted.‖
23.
To determine whether the offence of robbery is attracted, it is
necessary to examine when an act of theft assumes the character of
robbery within the meaning of Section 390 IPC. In cases where the
foundation offence is theft, every theft does not ipso facto amount to
robbery. Theft is elevated to the offence of robbery only when it is
accompanied by violence, or threat of violence. of a particular nature,
and at a particular stage.
24.
Section 390 of IPC makes it clear that theft becomes robbery
if, the offender – for the purpose of committing the theft, or while
committing the theft, or while carrying away or attempting to carry
away the stolen property – voluntarily:
●
causes or attempts to cause death, hurt, or wrongful restraint;
or
●
induces fear of instant death, instant hurt, or instant wrongful
restraint.
25.
Thus, two essential requirements must coexist for theft to
amount to robbery. First, there must be use of violence or threat of
instant violence of the nature contemplated under Section 390 of IPC.
Second, such violence or threat must be directly connected with the
theft, that is, it must be employed to facilitate the commission of theft
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
or the carrying away of the stolen property.
26.
In the present case, the sole basis on which the offence has
been treated as robbery, and not as theft, is the allegation that the
petitioner had threatened the complainant and his friend with a blade
and attempted to cause harm to them.
27.
However, the evidence on record does not lend support to this
allegation. It is an admitted position that when the personal search of
the petitioner was conducted in the presence of the complainant and
PW-2, no incriminating article was recovered from his possession.
Notably, the alleged blade, which is stated to have been used by the
petitioner to threaten the complainant and his friend, was never
recovered.
28.
Further, the allegation of threatening with a blade itself suffers
from material inconsistencies. In the FIR as well as in the statements
recorded under Section 161 of Cr.P.C., the complainant and PW-2
had merely stated that the accused had threatened to cause injury with
a blade. There was no specific assertion that the accused had actually
taken out or shown any blade. However, while deposing before the
learned Trial Court, PW-1 introduced the allegation that the accused
had taken out a blade and threatened him and his friend by saying,
“agar najdeek aaya toh maar dunga.” PW-2, on the other hand, did
not depose to any such specific threat or utterance by the accused. He
neither stated that the accused had taken out a blade nor that the
accused had threatened to kill him if he came close. His testimony is
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
confined to the statement that “the accused threatened us to give
injury with the help of a blade.”
29.
Thus, the version of PW-1 before the Court, to the extent it
pertains to taking out a blade and threatening him and PW-2, does not
find corroboration either from the earlier statements or from the
testimony of PW-2.
30.
Even if the testimony of PW-1 is accepted at its face value, the
sequence of events remains unclear as to whether the alleged threat
with the blade was extended before the petitioner was apprehended
and the purse recovered, or thereafter. This ambiguity is discernible
clearly from the testimonies of PW-1 and PW-2 themselves.
31.
PW-1, inter alia, has deposed as under:
―Some passenger had seen him while he was taking out my
purse. They apprehended him. The said person took out blade
and threatened me and my friend by stating that "Agar
Najdeek Aaya Toh Mar Dunga". Passengers caught held
him…….I got recovered the said purse from the said person
inside the said bus.‖
32.
PW-2, however, has stated:
―...I alongwith my friend and public persons apprehended the
accused inside the said bus. We searched the accused and
found the said purse inside his left pocket of his pant. The
accused threatened us to given injury with the help of a blade.
Thereafter, the public persons started to beat him…‖
33.
If the version of PW-2 is taken into consideration, a clear
possibility emerges that by the time the alleged threat was extended,
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
the stolen property had already been recovered from the possession of
the petitioner. Once the stolen property stood recovered and the
petitioner had been apprehended by the passengers, any subsequent
threat could not have been for the purpose of committing the theft or
for carrying away the stolen property. At best, such conduct may be
construed as an attempt to threaten so as to escape from the custody
of the passengers, but it does not satisfy any of the ingredients of
Section 390 of IPC for elevating theft to the offence of robbery.
34.
To reiterate, it must be noted that the specific allegation of
“taking out a blade and threatening with hurt” finds mention only in
the testimony of PW-1 recorded before the learned Trial Court. It
does not find place either in the FIR or in the statement under Section
161 of Cr.P.C. of PW-1, nor is it supported by the statement under
Section 161 of Cr.P.C. or the testimony of PW-2.
35.
It is also pertinent to note that no independent public witness
was examined in the present case and the prosecution case rests
solely on the testimonies of the complainant and his friend. The
alleged incident is stated to have occurred in a public place, namely a
moving bus, where the petitioner was apprehended not only by the
complainant but also by several co-passengers. It further emerges
from the testimony of PW-1 that when they alighted from the bus at
Saket Metro Station along with the petitioner, they were accompanied
by approximately 10–15 passengers. The relevant portion of the
testimony of PW-1 reads as under:
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
―Around 10–15 passengers were alighted from the said bus at
Saket Metro Station with us. All passengers i.e. 10–15 in
number, were caught held and alighted accused Mukesh from
bus.‖
36.
Similarly, PW-3, while deposing before the Court, stated that
upon reaching the spot, around 10–15 public persons were present
there. The relevant portion of the testimony of PW-3 is reproduced
hereinbelow:
―We met the complainant at bus stand near Metro Station. Ten–
fifteen public persons were present at the spot when we
reached at the spot.‖
37.
It is well settled that when an alleged incident of robbery is
alleged to have taken place in a public place such as a bus, road,
market, or train, the passengers or bystanders present at the spot are
the most natural and independent witnesses. Where, despite their
admitted presence, the prosecution fails to examine such witnesses
and no plausible explanation is forthcoming for their nonexamination, such omission constitutes a notable lapse in the
investigation. In the present case, none of the public witnesses, i.e.
any other passenger travelling in the bus, was made a witness.
Neither were their statements recorded under Section 161 of Cr.P.C.,
nor were they eventually examined before the learned Trial Court.
38.
This lapse assumes more significance in the facts of the present
case, where there is non-recovery of the alleged weapon of offence
i.e. blade, the absence of any injury on the complainant or PW-2, and
where the conviction rests solely on the testimonies of the
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
complainant and his friend, which themselves suffer from inter se
contradictions with respect to the alleged use of a blade for
threatening them.
39.
In such circumstances, the prosecution evidence is required to
be scrutinised with greater circumspection, and in the considered
opinion of this Court, the petitioner is entitled to the benefit of doubt
as the offence punishable under Section 392 of IPC has not been
proved beyond reasonable doubt.
D.
Whether the Offence of Theft Is Made Out
40.
As discussed hereinabove, the petitioner is entitled to benefit
of doubt insofar as the offence of robbery is concerned. The question
that remains for consideration is whether the acts attributed to the
petitioner constitute the offence of theft.
41.
The definition of theft is contained in Section 378 of the IPC,
which reads as under:
―Whoever, intending to take dishonestly any movable property
out of the possession of any person without that person‘s
consent, moves that property in order to such taking, is said to
commit theft.‖
42.
The essential ingredients of the offence of theft under Section
378 of IPC are:
(i)
a dishonest intention to take movable property;
(ii)
such property being taken out of the possession of any
person without that person‘s consent; and
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
(iii) movement of the property in order to effect such taking.
43.
To constitute the offence of theft, it is not necessary that the
offender should succeed in carrying away the movable property. The
offence is complete the moment the property is moved with a
dishonest intention and without the consent of the person in
possession thereof.
44.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present
case, it is evident that the offence of theft is clearly made out against
the petitioner. The prosecution evidence establishes that the
petitioner, with a dishonest intention, had removed and moved the
complainant‘s purse from his pocket without his consent. The fact
that the petitioner was apprehended immediately and was unable to
carry away the purse does not dilute the commission of theft, as the
act of moving the property itself is sufficient to attract the offence
under Section 378 of IPC.
45.
Accordingly, the acts attributed to the petitioner squarely fall
within the ambit of theft as defined under Section 378 of the IPC.
46.
Section 379 of IPC provides for punishment of theft, which is
as under:
―379. Punishment for theft. —Whoever commits theft shall
be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term
which may extend to three years, or with fine, or with both.‖
47.
A plain reading of Section 379 of IPC makes it evident that the
offence of theft is punishable with imprisonment which may extend
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
up to three years, or with fine, or with both; thus conferring
discretion upon the Court to award an appropriate sentence
depending upon the facts and circumstances of the case.
48.
In the present case, it is not in dispute that the petitioner has
already remained in judicial custody for a period of about two years
and seven months. Having regard to the nature of the offence, the
period of incarceration already undergone by the petitioner, and the
fact that the incident in question pertains to the year 2015, this Court
is of the considered opinion that the ends of justice would be met by
sentencing the petitioner to the period of imprisonment already
undergone by him.
49.
Accordingly, while the conviction of the petitioner under
Section 392 of IPC is set aside, the petitioner is convicted for the
offence punishable under Section 379 of IPC and is sentenced to
undergo imprisonment for the period already undergone.
50.
The revision petition is disposed of in the above terms.
51.
Before parting with the judgment, this Court places on record
its appreciation for the able assistance rendered by the learned amicus
curiae, Mr. Ayush, who argued the matter on behalf of the petitioner
and assisted this Court in the effective adjudication of the case.
52.
The judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith.
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
JANUARY 05, 2026/zp
TD/RB
CRL.REV.P. 495/2017
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
13:17:52
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review