Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:17643
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
WP(C) 6535 OF 2018
…..
M/s Vrindavan Construction, having its office at Devi Mandap Road,
Sukhdeo Nagar, Ratu Road, P.O.-Hehal, Ranchi, through one of its partner
Lal Bivhay Nath Shahdeo aged about 48 years , s/o Late Prayag Nath Shah
Deo, R/o Vrindavan House, Devi Mandap Road, Ratu Road, P.O. Hehal,
P.S. Sukhdeo Nagar, District-Ranchi. ….Petitioner
-versus1. The State of Jharkhand through the Principal Secretary, Rural
Development Department, Government of Jharkhand, Project Building,
Dhurwa, Ranchi, P.O. and P.S. Dhurwa, District-Ranchi.
2. Chief Engineer, Rural Development Special Division, Rural
Development Department, Government of Jharkhand, Project Building,
Dhurwa, Ranchi, P.O. and P.S. Dhurwa, District-Ranchi.
3. Executive Engineer, Rural Development Special Division, Lohardaga,
Government of Jharkhand P.O. & P.S. Lohardaga, District-Lohardaga.
…Respondents
……
CORUM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
For the Petitioner
: Ms. Shalini Shahdeo, Advocate
For the Respondent
: Mr. Suresh Kumar, S.C. (L&C)-II
CAV On: 02/04/2026
Pronounced on:15 /06/2026
1.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
The instant writ petition has been filed seeking the following relief:
For issuance of appropriate writ for quashing of the
order dated 21.6.2018, passed by the Executive Engineer,
Rural Development, Special Division, Lohardaga, whereby
and whereunder the agreement no. F2/83/2010-11 dated
5.7.2011, for the ‘construction of residual work of community
health centre under Kuru block’ with the petitioner has been
cancelled and the security money deposited by the petitioner
has been forfeited by the respondent authorities, in spite of
the orders passed by the Hon’ble Court on 19.6.2018, in
WPC No. 1266 of 2018, where, while disposing of the writ
petition, the Hon'ble Court, directed the Executive Engineer,
Rural Development Special Division, Lohardaga, to take an
appropriate decision in accordance with law on the request
made by the petitioner vide letter dated 12.2.2016 for the
2026:JHHC:17643
3.
foreclosure of the contract, release of the earnest money
deposit/security and for the payment of the admitted dues, if
any, within a period of twelve weeks from the date of the
receipt/production of a copy of the order.
Pass such order/orders as Your Lordships may deem fit
and proper under the facts and circumstances of the case.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has contended that a
notice inviting tender having NIT No. 20/2010-11 was published inviting
bids from eligible and approved tender for the ‘construction of residual
work of Community Health Centre at Kuru block’. The petitioner
submitted its bid and was declared successful vide letter No. 877 dated
8.6.2011. Upon acceptance of the bid, the petitioner was allotted the work
by the respondent. An agreement to this effect was executed on 5.7.2011,
and on the same date, a work order was also issued in favour of the
petitioner. The total contract value was ₹2,16,66,000/- while the earnest
money deposited by the petitioner was ₹11,34,000/-.
4.
It has been further submitted that the dispute between the parties
arose when the petitioner came to know that the work being done by it was
not technically approved by the department, and accordingly, the
petitioner, vide letter dated 16.11.2011, requested the respondent to
provide the sanctioned map and the detailed project report in order to
enable it to execute the work as per the required specification. Upon
receiving no response, another letter dated 27.12.2011 was sent to the
respondent with the same request.
5.
However, instead of providing the sanction map and the detailed
project report, the respondent gave an oral assurance to the petitioner to
2026:JHHC:17643
start the work at the earliest as per the estimate prepared and the bill of
quantity as mentioned in the agreement. However, sans the sanctioned
plan, the petitioner found it difficult to lay the electric pipe and sanitary
equipment and, as such requested the respondent to provide the same on
13.3.2013. A further reminder was also sent on 17.5.2013.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that masonry work was
completed by the petitioner. However, thereafter, the laying of sanitary
equipment and electric pipe, which was to be done prior to plastering of
the walls, could not be done without the sanctioned map. Despite several
letters, the same was not provided to the petitioner.
7.
Apart from the letters mentioned in the above paragraphs, the
petitioner seems to have written further letters on 8.6.2013, 4.7.2013,
25.9.2013, 2.1.2014 and 13.2.2014.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that, due to the
aforesaid reasons, the work completely stopped, and the petitioner on
2.3.2015 and 3.8.2015 informed the respondents about the status of the
work. The petitioner also has categorically stated its inability to execute
the work without the map. The petitioner has further stated that the
material cost and labour cost have increased manifold, and as such, a
revised estimate may be prepared for the remaining work. The petitioner
requested that the map be provided so that the work could be completed
within a period of six months.
9.
The respondent, in response to the letter dated 3.8.2015, finally
provided the map as well as the detailed project report for laying the
2026:JHHC:17643
electric wiring and directed the petitioner to execute the work as per the
plan. However, the plea of the respondents pertaining to the revision of
cost remains unanswered. The petitioner was again given a verbal
assurance by the Executive Engineer, Rural Development Special
Division, Lohardaga, that the same would be discussed by the higher
officials. Until such time, the petitioner was asked to continue with the
work.
10.
However, the petitioner was unable to execute the work at the
original cost. It is the contention of the petitioner that the security
money/earnest money, which was a significant sum, ought to have been
refunded, as the petitioner was unable to complete the work within the
stipulated time owing to the fault of the respondent to provide it with a
sanctioned map and the detailed project report. The petitioner visited the
respondent several times, but there was no response with respect to the
division of the estimated cost. When the petitioner lost all hope, it, by letter
dated 12.2.2016, requested the respondent to foreclose the contract and
refund its security/earnest money.
11.
When the petitioner did not receive any response, it knocked the
door of this Court by filing a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India, which was registered as WP(C) No. 1266 of 2018. This writ
petition was disposed of by order dated 19.6.2018, directing the Executive
Engineer, Rural Development Special Division, Lohardaga, to take an
appropriate decision in accordance with law on the representation dated
12.2.2016.
2026:JHHC:17643
12.
It is the contention of the petitioner that, despite a specific order
dated 19.6.20218, passed by this court in WP(C) No. 1266 of 2018, the
respondent authority on 21.6.2018 passed an order annulling the contract
and withholding the security deposit of the petitioner in the most arbitrary
fashion.
13.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the action of the
respondent is not only arbitrary but also contemptuous. He further submits
that the aforesaid facts show that the concerned respondent failed in its
obligation to provide the sanctioned map and the detailed project report to
the petitioner. The sanction map and the detailed project report were
provided to the petitioner only after a lapse of almost five years. As such,
it is apparent that the project could not be successfully completed owing
to fundamental breaches and lapses on the part of the respondent.
14.
It was further contended that the respondent, instead of acting in a
fair manner and refunding the security/earnest money, chose to act with
utter high-handedness and cancelled the contract while withholding the
security/earnest money of the petitioner. This action on the part of the
respondent is not only arbitrary but also violates the fundamental right of
the petitioner guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. The
aforesaid action was taken against the petitioner in order to hide their own
latches.
15.
Per contra, the Ld. counsel for the respondents submits that, as the
work was not completed by the petitioner within the stipulated time, it was
2026:JHHC:17643
well within its right to withhold and forfeit the earnest money/security
deposit.
16.
Having gone through the records of the case and the submissions
made by the Ld. counsel for the parties, this Court deems it fit to mention
that on 26.3.2026, this Court gave an opportunity to the respondent to
verify the records of this case.
17.
Such verification was imperative considering that the respondents,
in their counter-affidavit, have not replied to the averments made by the
petitioner in paragraphs 11, 12 and 15 of the writ petitions.
18.
In paragraphs 11 and 12 of the writ petition, the petitioner has, in
categorical words, stated that the petitioner was not provided with the
sanctioned map as well as the detailed project report and proceeded with
the work on the oral assurance given by the Executive Engineer. The same
has been replied to in paragraphs 12 and 13 of the counter affidavits,
wherein it has been stated that the averments made in the paragraphs are
"matter of fact, which require no further comment”.
19.
Similarly, in paragraph 15 of the writ petition, it has been stated that
the sanctioned map was provided to the petitioner only on 26.08.2015, i.e.,
after a lapse of almost five years since the parties entered into a contract,
i.e., on 05.07.2011. In reply to the averment made in paragraph 15, the
respondent in paragraph 13 of its counter affidavit has not denied the same
but has merely deflected by stating that the “same has been replied to in
the above paragraphs of the present affidavit”.
2026:JHHC:17643
20.
After due verification, the Ld. counsel for the respondents on 24-
02-2026 has stated that he cannot controvert the fact that the map was
supplied to the petitioner only on 26.08.2015.
21.
Considering the aforesaid facts, this Court frames the following
issues for the purpose of adjudication of the instant lis:
Whether this court, exercising its jurisdiction under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India, may adjudicate contractual disputes?
Whether, in light of the governing facts, the petitioner is entitled to
the relief as prayed for?
22.
So far as the first issue is concerned; this court is conscious of the
fact that while exercising its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, it should refrain from adjudicating contractual
disputes between parties. This restraint is because contractual disputes
generally involve adjudication of complicated and hotly contested
questions of fact as well as interpreting the terms of the contract. However,
when a dispute does not require the courts to delve into questions of fact
or interpret the terms of the contract and the matter pertains to admitted
dues, an application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India can very
well be entertained. Reference is made to the case of Rajasthan State
Electricity Board v. Union of India (UOI) and Ors (2008) 5 SCC 632,
wherein the Hon'ble Apex Court has held that the restraint of adjudicating
disputes pertaining to contractual issues under Article 226 of the
Constitution is essentially self-imposed; there is no restriction to exercise
the extraordinary jurisdiction in cases of admitted dues.
2026:JHHC:17643
23.
In the case at hand, the respondents have not disputed the fact
despite being given several opportunities that it did not provide the
sanctioned map as well as the detailed project report to the petitioner
within the stipulated time. As these requirements were essential for
successful completion of the contract and were provided to the petitioner
only after a lapse of more than five years from the date of the agreement,
the petitioner could not complete the contract within the stipulated period.
24.
In light thereof, this court is having no hesitation in holding that the
instant writ petition is maintainable and can be entertained by this Court.
25.
Now, coming to the second issue, the facts of this case categorically
show that despite several representations made by the petitioner, it was not
provided with the sanctioned map and the detailed project report. The
petitioner, acting on oral assurances given by the respondent, completed
the masonry work. However, could not proceed further due to the absence
or lack of the sanctioned map. This sanctioned map was provided to the
petitioner only on 26.8.2015, i.e., after a lapse of almost 5 years of the
agreement, which was signed between the parties on 5.7.2011.
26.
It is also a fact that the petitioner had approached this Court earlier
by filing a writ petition being WP(C) No. 1266 of 2018, wherein this Court
on 19.6.2018, directed the respondent to pass a reasoned order with respect
to the grievances raised by the petitioner. However, instead of adhering to
the order passed by this court, the respondent chose to annul the agreement
dated 05.07.2011 on 21.6.2018 and forfeit the security/earnest money of
2026:JHHC:17643
the petitioner. This action, in the considered view of this court, amounts to
a display of high-handedness on the part of the respondent.
27.
Further, on perusal of the order dated 19.6.2018, it is evident that
the respondents have not considered the admitted fact that the sanctioned
map was provided to the petitioner only on 26.8.2015 and has annulled the
contract on the ground that the work could not be completed by 4.7.2012.
28.
At this stage, it would be profitable to refer the case of Haryana
Financial Corporation and another v. Rajesh Gupta (2010) 1 SCC 655,
wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India held that an instrumentality
of the State (such as the respondent) is required to act in a fair and
transparent manner.
29.
In the case at hand, the concerned respondents, despite an
opportunity given by this court, was not able to bring on record any cogent
material or evidence to show that it had handed over the sanctioned map
to the petitioner or provided any detail which could assist the petitioner in
completing the work within the stipulated time. In fact, the counteraffidavit discloses that the respondents continued to be apathetic to the
plight of the petitioner and did not give any response to several
representations made by it.
30.
The respondents have not disputed the specific averments made by
the petitioner in its writ petition that sans the sanctioned plan, it could not
have proceeded beyond the masonry work.
31.
On perusal of the order dated 19.6.2018, it is evident that the
respondent has not considered the admitted fact that the sanctioned map
2026:JHHC:17643
was provided to the petitioner only on 26.8.2015 and has annulled the
contract on the ground that the work could not be completed by 4.7.2012.
32.
In absence of the sanctioned plan, the petitioner could in no possible
scenario execute the agreement within the stipulated time. It is a fit case to
apply the principle of Lex non cogit ad impossibilia (law cannot call upon
anybody to do something which is impossible).
33.
Considering the above, this court is having no hesitation in holding
that the contention of the respondents that the work was annulled on the
ground that it was not completed within the stipulated time of one year, is
completely unreasonable, arbitrary and devoid of any merit and therefore
requires to be set aside.
34.
Consecutively, the action of the respondents to forfeit the
security/earnest money and not pay the admitted dues, if any, of the
petitioner is also bad in the eye of the law.
35.
In light thereof, the instant writ petition is allowed with the
following directions:
(a)
The security money and/or earnest money shall be
refunded to the petitioner within four weeks from the date of
receipt/production of copy of this order. The respondents are
further directed to pay simple interest at the rate of 6% per
annum on the above amount, from 21.6.2018 till the day of
disbursement to the petitioner.
(b)
If the petitioner has any other claim apart from
security/earnest money; liberty is granted to it to file such a
claim before the respondents along with supporting
documents, within the aforesaid stipulated period.
2026:JHHC:17643
(c)
The concerned respondent is directed to consider such
a claim and pass a reasoned order within two weeks thereafter.
It goes without saying that if the respondents find that any
amount is payable to the petitioner; the same shall be paid
within a period of two weeks from the date of such reasoned
order.
36.
Accordingly, the instant writ application stands allowed. Pending
I.A.s, if any, also stands disposed of. Though it is a fit case for imposing
cost, however, this court in its discretion refrains from doing so.
(Deepak Roshan, J)
Dated:15 /06/2026
Amardeep/
A.F.R
Uploaded on
19.06.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review