Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:578-DB
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
HON’BLE JUSTICE SRI MANOJ KUMAR TIWARI AND
HON’BLE JUSTICE SRI SIDDHARTHA SAH
Writ Petition No. 482 of 2024 (MB)
M/s Super Construction Associates
--Petitioner
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and others
--Respondents
--------------------------------------------------------------------------Advocates:Mr. DCS Rawat, Mr. Ketan Joshi and Mr. Hemant Singh Mahra, Advocates for
petitioner.
Mr. J.C. Pande, Standing Counsel for the State of Uttarakhand.
Mr. S.S. Chauhan, Advocate for respondent Nos. 2 and 3.
Mr. Shobhit Saharia, Advocate for respondent No. 4
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reserved on: 10.01.2026
Delivered on: 19.01.2026
The Court made the following:
JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Justice Sri Manoj Kumar Tiwari)
1.
Chief Engineer, Uttarakhand Rural Roads Development
Agency issued a Notice Inviting Tender on 02.03.2024,
inviting item rate bids in two bid system for various
construction works under Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojna
(PMGSY). Pursuant to said notice, petitioner submitted bid
in respect of work of up-gradation of Khunt-Kakrighat Motor
Road to Charnbend Motor Road.
2.
Procurement Evaluation Committee recommended to
reject
the
technical
recommendation
was
bid
of
petitioner
accepted
by
the
and
the
said
Bid
Accepting
Authority vide order dated 12.08.2024. Reasons indicated
by the Procurement Evaluation Committee for making
recommendation to reject petitioner’s bid are as follows:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
Same evidences for key machineries are submitted by
other bidders for different works
Certificate of 01 No. diploma holder not readable.
Bank Certificate submitted, but not as required.
2026:UHC:578-DB
(iv)
3.
Authority to seek reference submitted, but not as
required.
Feeling aggrieved by rejection of his technical bid,
petitioner has approached this Court. Petitioner has also
challenged the decision taken by competent authority
whereby technical bid of respondent No. 4 was found to be
responsive. Reliefs sought in the writ petition are extracted
below for ready reference:
4.
i.
Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari
quashing the impugned order / bid evaluation report
12/08/2024 (annexure - 2) issued by respondent department
and impugned order/resolution dated 23/08/2024 (annexure6) qua the respondent M/s Dalip Singh in as much as these
orders declare the technical bid of respondent M/s Dalip
Singh Adhikari as responsive.
ii.
Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari
quashing the impugned order / bid evaluation report
12/08/2024 (annexure-2) issued by respondent department
and impugned order/resolution dated 23/08/2024 (annexure
6) qua the petitioner in as much as these orders declare the
technical bid of the petitioner as non-responsive.
iii.
Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus
commanding the respondent no. 2 to declare the technical bid
of the petitioner as responsive and bid of respondent M/s
Dalip Singh Adhikari as non-responsive and to open the
financial bid of the petitioner.
Sub clause (d), (e), (g) and (h) of Clause 4.2 of
Section 2 of Standard Bidding Documents which was
produced in Court by learned counsel for respondent No. 2,
read as under:
“4. Qualification of the Bidder
4.2 All bidders shall include the following information and
documents with their bids in Section 3, Qualification Information
unless otherwise stated in the Appendix to ITB:
(a) .....
(b) ......
(c) ......
(d) evidence of ownership of major items of construction equipment
named in Clause 4.4 B (b) (i) of ITB or evidence of arrangement of
possessing them on hire/lease/buying as defined therein.
(e) details of the technical personnel proposed to be employed for
the Contract having the qualifications defined in Clause 4.4 B(b) (ii)
2026:UHC:578-DB
of ITB for the construction.
(f) ..............
(g) evidence of access to line(s) of credit and availability of other
financial resources/ facilities (10 percent of the contract value)
certified by banker (the certificate being not more than 3 months
old.)
(h) authority to seek references from the Bidder's bankers;
5.
Sub clause (g) and (h) require every bidder to obtain
certificate /authority letter from a banker and submit the
same with his bid. The format, in which certificate/authority
letter has to be obtained from the bank is also given in the
Standard Bidding Document. The Procurement Evaluation
Committee has found the certificate and the authority letter
issued by the banker not as per the format given in the
Standard Bidding Document.
6.
As
regards
the
first
ground
taken
for
rejecting
petitioner’s bid, learned counsel for petitioner submits that
Standard Bidding Document nowhere provides that owner
of the construction equipment/machinery cannot give the
equipment/machinery on rent to other contractors; all
equipments/machineries
are
not
used
simultaneously
during
executing
the
work
the
course
of
and
the
construction equipments/machineries are used in phases at
different times, therefore leaving machinery idle on the
construction site is not desirable as it would amount to
wastage of resources.
7.
Learned counsel for petitioner further submits that M/s
Sugam
Infratech,
to
whom
the
construction
equipment/machinery was leased out by the owner thereof,
has not participated in the bidding process for the work in
question and M/s Sugam Infratech has not been awarded
any contract pursuant to the bidding process
initiated on
02.03.2024, therefore, the apprehension that the same
2026:UHC:578-DB
equipment
would
be
used
simultaneously
by
two
contractors, is unfounded. He also submits that petitioner
had an understanding with M/s Sugam Infratech that they
will co-ordinate timing of works in such a manner that
machines would be needed by them at different times.
8.
As regards the second ground of rejection, learned
counsel for the petitioner submits that in the resolution
passed by the bid evaluation committee, name of diploma
holder technical person proposed to be employed by
petitioner
for
the
contract
is
mentioned,
therefore
petitioner’s bid could not have been rejected on the ground
that his name is not readable.
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that
the certificate and authority letter in term of clause (g) &
(h) of ITB, were issued in favour of petitioner by Haldwani
Branch of Bank of India, on the letterhead of the concerned
branch, in which phone number of the branch concerned
was clearly mentioned. Thus he submits that petitioner’s bid
could not have been rejected on the ground that it does not
meet the requirement of sub-clause (g) and (h) of Clause
4.2 of Section 2 of Instructions to Bidder (ITB) contained in
Standard Bidding Document for PMGSY.
10. Learned counsel appearing for Pradhan Mantri Gram
Sadak Yojna (PMGSY), however, submits that as per sub
clause (d) of Clause 4.2 of Section 2 of ITB, every bidder is
required to furnish evidence of ownership of major items of
construction equipment or evidence of arrangement of
possessing them on hire or lease.
11. Learned counsel for PMGSY submits that petitioner
furnished a certificate from the owner of construction
2026:UHC:578-DB
equipment that it has been given on rent to the petitioner,
however, another contractor, namely, M/s Sugam Infratech
who submitted bid for some other work pursuant to same
NIT also produced evidence that the same construction
equipment has been given on rent to him by the owner
thereof.
12. He submits that condition mentioned in sub clause (d)
is meant to allay the apprehension of the employer that the
construction work would not be delayed due to lack of
machinery/equipment with the successful bidder, therefore
rejection of petitioner’s bid, is justified as two bidders,
including the petitioner, were claiming that one set of
machinery has been given on rent to them by the same
person.
13. He further submits that if same set of machinery is
leased out to two bidders, then it would not be readily
available to both in times of need and one of them will have
to wait till the other is done with his work. He submits that
since this will affect the quality and pace of work, therefore
employer was well within his right to reject the bid
submitted by petitioner for non-compliance of sub clause
(d) of Clause 4.2 of Section 2 of ITB. He further submits
that ground of rejection is referable to express conditions of
ITB, therefore any interference in the matter would be
uncalled for.
14. Learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 2
further submits that in the Diploma enclosed by petitioner
with his bid, name of technical person proposed to be
employed by him is not readable and the ground of
rejection
also
clearly
indicates
so.
Therefore,
merely
2026:UHC:578-DB
because name of technical person is mentioned in the
resolution passed by the department will not improve the
case of petitioner as his name was mentioned at various
places in petitioner’s bid, and the employer has to be
satisfied about the qualification possessed by the technical
person.
15. He further submits that the person proposed to be
employed
for
contract
must
have
the
qualification
prescribed in Clause 4.4(B)(b)(ii) of Instructions to Bidders
(ITB). He submits that, with a view to substantiate the
claim that the person so employed possess necessary
qualification,
every
bidder
is required
to
submit
the
diploma/degree issued by the competent authority.
16. Learned counsel for respondent No. 2 submits that if
the name of technical personnel is not legible in the
diploma/degree, then even if name of technical person is
readable elsewhere will not be sufficient and the bidder will
have to satisfy the employer that the technical person
possesses all requisite qualifications for such appointment,
therefore diploma/degree of the person proposed to be
appointed has to be readable.
17. Regarding third and fourth ground of rejection, learned
counsel appearing for respondent No. 2 refers to Annexure8 to the writ petition and submits that the certificate issued
by petitioner’s banker regarding evidence of access to
line(s) of credit in terms of sub clause (g) and authority to
seek references in terms of sub clause (h) of Clause 4.2 of
ITB was not in the format given in Standard Bidding
Document.
18. He has produced in Court the format of bank certificate
2026:UHC:578-DB
and the letter to be issued by the bank regarding authority
to seek references. As per the format, the Senior Bank
Manager is required to issue the authority letter/certificate
on the letterhead of the bank, in which telephone number,
fax number and email details of the bank have to be clearly
mentioned.
19. The documents enclosed as Annexure-8 to the writ
petition were issued by Chief Bank Manager, Bank of India,
Aishbagh Branch, Kaladhungi Road, Haldwani; however, in
the bank certificate, as well as the letter regarding authority
to seek references, fax number and email i.d. of the
concerned branch is altogether missing.
20. Learned counsel for respondent No. 2 contends that
condition mentioned in sub clause (g) and (h) of Clause 4.2
of Section 2 of ITB is meant to protect interest of the
employer in case of need and employer can invoke its
power under these clauses only by a written communication
to the Banker of the Contractor. He thus submits that since
power available to the employer under sub clause (g) and
(h) has to be used by written communication only, therefore
the prescribed format given in the Standard Bidding
Document requires that certificate referred to in sub clause
(g) and the authority letter issued in sub clause (h) must
contain fax number and email i.d. of the concerned branch
of the bank.
21. He submits that in the certificate and authority letter
of his banker submitted by petitioner, fax number and email
i.d. is not mentioned and in the absence of fax number and
email i.d., employer would be prevented from invoking the
powers available to him as per the Standard Bidding
2026:UHC:578-DB
Document. Thus he submits that technical bid of the
petitioner was rightly rejected for not confirming to the
express conditions of the ITB and there is no arbitrariness
or illegality whatsoever in the decision taken by the
competent authority.
22. Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of N.G. Projects
Limited Vs. Vinok Kumar Jain and others, reported as
(2022) 6 SCC 127, after considering the law on the point,
held as under:
21. Since the construction of road is an infrastructure project
and keeping in view the intent of the legislature that
infrastructure projects should not be stayed, the High Court
would have been well advised to hold its hand to stay the
construction of the infrastructure project. Such provision should
be kept in view even by the writ court while exercising its
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
22. The satisfaction whether a bidder satisfies the tender
condition is primarily upon the authority inviting the bids. Such
authority is aware of expectations from the tenderers while
evaluating the consequences of non-performance. In the tender
in question, there were 15 bidders. Bids of 13 tenderers were
found to be unresponsive i.e. not satisfying the tender
conditions. The writ petitioner was one of them. It is not the
case of the writ petitioner that action of the Technical Evaluation
Committee was actuated by extraneous considerations or was
mala fide. Therefore, on the same set of facts, different
conclusions can be arrived at in a bona fide manner by the
Technical Evaluation Committee. Since the view of the Technical
Evaluation Committee was not to the liking of the writ
petitioner, such decision does not warrant for interference in a
grant of contract to a successful bidder.
23. In view of the above judgments of this Court, the writ court
should refrain itself from imposing its decision over the decision
of the employer as to whether or not to accept the bid of a
tenderer. The Court does not have the expertise to examine the
terms and conditions of the present day economic activities of
the State and this limitation should be kept in view. Courts
should be even more reluctant in interfering with contracts
involving technical issues as there is a requirement of the
necessary expertise to adjudicate upon such issues. The
approach of the Court should be not to find fault with
magnifying glass in its hands, rather the Court should examine
as to whether the decision-making process is after complying
with the procedure contemplated by the tender conditions. If
the Court finds that there is total arbitrariness or that the
tender has been granted in a mala fide manner, still the Court
2026:UHC:578-DB
should refrain from interfering in the grant of tender but instead
relegate the parties to seek damages for the wrongful exclusion
rather than to injunct the execution of the contract. The
injunction or interference in the tender leads to additional costs
on the State and is also against public interest. Therefore, the
State and its citizens suffer twice, firstly by paying escalation
costs and secondly, by being deprived of the infrastructure for
which the present day Governments are expected to work.
23. In the case of Jagdish Mandal Vs. State of Orissa and
others, reported as (2007) 14 SCC 517, Hon’ble Supreme
Court summarised the legal position as follows:
22. Judicial review of administrative action is intended to
prevent arbitrariness, irrationality, unreasonableness, bias and
mala fides. Its purpose is to check whether choice or decision is
made “lawfully” and not to check whether choice or decision is
“sound”. When the power of judicial review is invoked in
matters relating to tenders or award of contracts, certain special
features should be borne in mind. A contract is a commercial
transaction. Evaluating tenders and awarding contracts are
essentially commercial functions. Principles of equity and
natural justice stay at a distance. If the decision relating to
award of contract is bona fide and is in public interest, courts
will not, in exercise of power of judicial review, interfere even if
a procedural aberration or error in assessment or prejudice to a
tenderer, is made out. The power of judicial review will not be
permitted to be invoked to protect private interest at the cost of
public interest, or to decide contractual disputes. The tenderer
or contractor with a grievance can always seek damages in a
civil court. Attempts by unsuccessful tenderers with imaginary
grievances, wounded pride and business rivalry, to make
mountains out of molehills of some technical/procedural
violation or some prejudice to self, and persuade courts to
interfere by exercising power of judicial review, should be
resisted. Such interferences, either interim or final, may hold up
public works for years, or delay relief and succour to thousands
and millions and may increase the project cost manifold.
Therefore, a court before interfering in tender or contractual
matters in exercise of power of judicial review, should pose to
itself the following questions:
(i) Whether the process adopted or decision made by the
authority is mala fide or intended to favour someone;
or
Whether the process adopted or decision made is so arbitrary
and irrational that the court can say: “the decision is such that
no responsible authority acting reasonably and in accordance
with relevant law could have reached”;
(ii) Whether public interest is affected.
If the answers are in the negative, there should be no
interference under Article 226. Cases involving blacklisting or
imposition of penal consequences on a tenderer/ contractor or
distribution of State largesse (allotment of sites/shops, grant of
2026:UHC:578-DB
licences, dealerships and franchises) stand on a different footing
as they may require a higher degree of fairness in action.
24. In the case of Uflex Limited Vs. Government of Tamil
Nadu and others, reported as (2022) 1 SCC 165, in para 42
following observation is made:
42. We must begin by noticing that we are examining the case,
as already stated above, on the parameters discussed at the
inception. In commercial tender matters there is obviously an
aspect of commercial competitiveness. For every succeeding
party who gets a tender there may be a couple or more parties
who are not awarded the tender as there can be only one L-1.
The question is should the judicial process be resorted to for
downplaying the freedom which a tendering party has, merely
because it is a State or a public authority, making the said
process even more cumbersome. We have already noted that
element of transparency is always required in such tenders
because of the nature of economic activity carried on by the
State, but the contours under which they are to be examined
are restricted as set out in Tata Cellular [Tata Cellular v. Union
of India, (1994) 6 SCC 651] and other cases. The objective is
not to make the Court an appellate authority for scrutinising as
to whom the tender should be awarded. Economics must be
permitted to play its role for which the tendering authority
knows best as to what is suited in terms of technology and price
for them.
25. From the judgments referred to above, it is evident
that in tender matters, the satisfaction whether a bidder
satisfies the conditions of tender, is primarily upon the
authority which invites tender. Scope of judicial review is
very limited in such matters.
26. We find substance in the submission made by learned
counsel for respondent No. 2 that petitioner’s bid failed to
meet the conditions mentioned in sub clause (d), (e), (g)
and (h) of Clause 4.2 of Instructions to Bidders contained in
Standard Bidding Document. Thus the decision taken by
competent authority of rejecting bid of the petitioner,
cannot be faulted.
27. In view of the law of the land, we do not find any
2026:UHC:578-DB
scope for interference with the decision taken by the
employer of rejecting petitioner’s bid.
28. Petitioner has also challenged the decision taken by
competent authority of declaring respondent No. 4 as
technically qualified.
29. It is alleged that respondent No. 4 has not disclosed
his litigation history in his bid and the technical personnel
alleged to have been employed by him is also claimed to be
employed by another contractor, namely, Roop Singh
Kathayat.
30. This Court is not inclined to go into the question, as to
whether respondent No. 4 was rightly declared to be
technically qualified for the following reasons:
i)
Decision
taken
by
the
employer
regarding
eligibility of a bidder has to be respected, as the
employer, having authored the tender document, is the
best
person
to
understand
and
appreciate
its
requirements and interpret its documents.
This view is supported by a judgment rendered by
Hon’le Apex Court in the case of Afcons Infrastructure
Limited Vs. Nagpur Metro Rail Corporation Limited and
another, reported as (2016) 16 SCC 818. Para 13 and 15 of
said judgment are reproduced below:
13. In other words, a mere disagreement with the
decision-making process or the decision of the
administrative authority is no reason for a constitutional
court to interfere. The threshold of mala fides, intention to
favour someone or arbitrariness, irrationality or perversity
must be met before the constitutional court interferes with
the decision-making process or the decision.
15. We may add that the owner or the employer of a
project, having authored the tender documents, is the
best
person
to
understand
and
appreciate
its
2026:UHC:578-DB
requirements
and
interpret
its
documents.
The
constitutional courts must defer to this understanding and
appreciation of the tender documents, unless there is
mala fide or perversity in the understanding or
appreciation or in the application of the terms of the
tender conditions. It is possible that the owner or
employer of a project may give an interpretation to the
tender documents that is not acceptable to the
constitutional courts but that by itself is not a reason for
interfering with the interpretation given.
ii)
Against the decision taken by Bid Accepting
Authority on 12.08.2024, whereby technical bid of
petitioner was rejected and that of respondent No. 4
was
accepted, petitioner made representation on
18.08.2024, within the window period provided to
every
bidder
representation
who
was
made
by
declared
him
was
ineligible.
The
rejected
and
rejection order is also challenged in this petition. In his
representation, petitioner did not raise this issue that
the technical personnel proposed to be employed by
respondent No. 4 is claimed as employee by another
bidder (Roop Singh Kathayat), even though petitioner
raised various other issues against acceptance of
technical bid of respondent No. 4. Thus petitioner
cannot be permitted to raise an issue at this belated
stage which was not canvassed by him before the
competent authority.
iii)
Petitioner’s technical bid was rejected for certain
grounds as discussed above. Upon rejection of his
technical
bid,
petitioner
became
disqualified
to
participate in the next stages of bidding process. This
Court has declined to interfere with the decision taken
by
competent
technical
bid,
authority
therefore
of
rejecting
the
issue
petitioner’s
regarding
qualification of respondent No. 4 to participate in the
2026:UHC:578-DB
bidding process raised by petitioner would be of
academic interest only. Petitioner loses locus standi
also after rejection of this technical bid. Thus, we are
not inclined to go into the question of eligibility of
respondent No. 4, as raised by petitioner.
31. Thus we do not find any merit in the writ petition. The
writ petition therefore fails and is dismissed.
______________________________
MANOJ KUMAR TIWARI, J.
Dt: 19th January, 2026
Mahinder
MAHINDER SINGH
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=da6212e6e78d94ed3134842bc6a8d6ca168979ca7b8c2f031a92d1a18b08923c, postalCode=263001,
st=UTTARAKHAND, serialNumber=AB77B7C5B240908B392BE84F5CDD4C2AF35DC4626D305B1BC9EA4BABA43D2B8F,
cn=MAHINDER SINGH
Date: 2026.01.19 11:56:42 +05'30'
________________________
SIDDHARTHA SAH, J.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review