Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 08th July, 2026.
+
W.P.(C) 16198/2022 & CM APPL. 50670/2022
MS SHILPA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Ankur Chhibber, Mr. Anshuman
Mehrotra, Advocates.
versus
SOLAR ENERGY CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD., & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Abhinav Singh, Advocate for R-1
& 2.
Mr. Tanveer Ahmed Ansari, SPC for
UOI.
Ms. Neha Tiwari, Advocate with Mr.
Hilal Haider, GP for UOI.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
JUDGMENT
SANJEEV NARULA, J. (Oral):
1.
The Petitioner challenges the communication dated 03rd November,
2022, issued by the Solar Energy Corporation of India Ltd. [“SECI”],
whereby her offer of appointment dated 02nd February, 2022, for the post of
Supervisor (P&A) was withdrawn and cancelled and her services were
“terminated with immediate effect”.
Factual Background
2.
SECI issued Recruitment Notification No. 01/2021 inviting
applications for various posts, including the post of Supervisor (P&A). For
Dgitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
13:07:09
W.P.(C) 16198/2022
the said post, the advertisement prescribed graduation in any discipline and a
minimum of “01 year of post-qualification experience in field of Personnel
& Administration”. The advertisement further stipulated that eligibility
would be assessed with reference to the prescribed conditions and that
candidature would be liable to rejection if the information furnished by a
candidate was found to be false or otherwise not in conformity with the
advertised eligibility requirements.
3.
The Petitioner applied for the post of Supervisor (P&A). In her
application, she claimed experience as a “Junior Assistant” at the National
Institute of Immunology [“NII”]. In describing the nature of her duties, she
stated that she assisted in work relating to administration, meetings of the
Governing Body, Finance Committee and Society, APAR Cell, Hindi
Section, release of funds for projects, establishment and service matters.
4.
The Petitioner appeared in the written examination and was
provisionally selected. By communication dated 19th January, 2022, she was
called upon to appear for document verification and to produce, inter alia,
“Complete and Proper Experience certificates/Documents issued by the
Employer in support of experience details” furnished in her application. The
communication further clarified that her selection remained subject to
“fulfilment of Advertised Specifications” and “other eligibility conditions”.
5.
SECI thereafter issued her an offer of appointment dated 02nd
February, 2022. The offer stipulated that the Petitioner’s appointment was
subject to verification of the information furnished by her and further
provided that, if any information contained in her application or attestation
form was found to be false or incorrect, or if she was found to have wilfully
suppressed any material information, her services would be liable to
Dgitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
13:07:09
W.P.(C) 16198/2022
termination without notice or compensation. The Petitioner joined SECI on
07th February, 2022.
6.
In support of the experience claimed by her, the Petitioner furnished,
inter alia, an appointment letter, an experience certificate and a relieving
letter issued by Alankit Ltd., together with a certificate dated 27 th
November, 2020, issued on the letterhead of NII, stating that she was
working in Administration-I as “Personal Assistant (Outsourced)” through
Alankit Ltd. and drawing a consolidated monthly salary.
7.
Upon receipt of the aforesaid documents, SECI sought verification
from NII. By its response dated 01st November, 2022, NII informed SECI
that the Petitioner had been engaged through Alankit Ltd. as an outsourced
staff in the capacity of a “Junior Assistant”. NII further stated that the
certificate forwarded by SECI had neither been issued by the competent
department nor by an officer authorised to issue such certification, and that
the designation reflected therein did not correspond with the designation
held by the Petitioner. NII also informed SECI that, during the period from
11th July, 2019 to 31st January, 2021, the Petitioner had performed duties
relating to Hindi typing, day-to-day office work and filing.
8.
Following the aforesaid verification, SECI issued the impugned
communication dated 03rd November, 2022, withdrawing and cancelling her
offer of appointment dated 02nd February, 2022.
Petitioner’s Contentions
9.
In support of the petition, Mr. Ankur Chhibber, counsel for the
Petitioner, makes the following submissions:
9.1.
The impugned order is arbitrary, stigmatic and punitive. The
Petitioner had worked in Administration-I of NII through Alankit Ltd. as an
Dgitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
13:07:09
W.P.(C) 16198/2022
outsourced Junior Assistant, and the record establishes that she possessed
the requisite experience in the field of Personnel & Administration,
prescribed under the recruitment notification. The Petitioner neither
concealed nor misrepresented any material fact and had throughout
disclosed that she was working as an outsourced Junior Assistant.
9.2.
The experience certificate issued by Alankit Ltd. establishes the
Petitioner’s experience as a Junior Assistant at NII. The certificate dated 27 th
November, 2020 issued by NII was uploaded only to evidence her
consolidated salary, as outsourced employees were not issued salary slips
and the said certificate had originally been obtained for the purpose of
another recruitment process. The reference therein describing the Petitioner
as “Personal Assistant (Outsourced)” was inadvertent, and the Petitioner
never relied upon the said certificate either to establish her designation or to
claim any benefit in respect of her experience.
9.3.
The appointment letter, experience certificate and other supporting
record establishes that the Petitioner discharged duties relating to Personnel
& Administration. Reliance is placed upon the RTI response issued by NII,
as well as office orders and other contemporaneous records, to contend that
the Petitioner had assisted in administrative matters relating to grievances,
RTI, APAR, FR 56(i), allotment of accommodation and other administrative
functions. The RTI response corroborates the nature of duties disclosed by
the Petitioner in her application form and demonstrates that the experience
claimed by her was correctly disclosed.
9.4.
The Petitioner was permitted to join service after physical verification
of her original educational and other supporting documents. Having
accepted the said documents and allowed the Petitioner to join and discharge
Dgitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
13:07:09
W.P.(C) 16198/2022
her duties for several months, SECI could not have subsequently terminated
her appointment, without issuing a show-cause notice or affording her an
opportunity of hearing. The impugned action visits the Petitioner with
serious civil consequences and could not have been taken without
complying with the principles of natural justice.
9.5.
Without prejudice, even assuming any deficiency existed in the
Petitioner’s prior experience, the experience gained by her during her tenure
at SECI cured such deficiency and satisfied the eligibility requirement.
Respondents’ Contentions
10.
Opposing the petition, Mr. Abhinav Singh, counsel for SECI, submits
as follows:
10.1. The Petitioner’s appointment was provisional and remained subject to
verification of her eligibility and the information furnished by her. The post
in question was that of Supervisor (P&A), for which the recruitment
notification specifically prescribed one year’s post-qualification experience
in the field of Personnel & Administration. The verification of the
Petitioner’s credentials was undertaken in accordance with the terms of the
recruitment notification and the offer of appointment.
10.2. None of the documents produced by the Petitioner establish the
prescribed experience. The documents issued by Alankit Ltd., at best, show
that the Petitioner was engaged as a Junior Assistant and deployed at NII,
but do not certify that she possessed experience in the field of Personnel &
Administration. The certificate dated 27th November, 2020 issued on the
letterhead of NII, which described the Petitioner as “Personal Assistant
(Outsourced)”, was subsequently disowned by NII, which clarified that the
certificate had neither been issued by the competent department nor by an
Dgitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
13:07:09
W.P.(C) 16198/2022
authorised officer and that the designation mentioned therein did not
correspond with the Petitioner’s actual designation. Further, according to
NII, the Petitioner’s work comprised Hindi typing, day-to-day office
activities and filing work.
10.3. The Petitioner’s application contained a declaration that she assisted
in matters relating to administration, meetings of the Governing Body,
Finance Committee and Society, APAR Cell, release of funds for projects,
establishment and service matters. However, the verification from NII did
not support the duties so claimed. The incorrect information furnished by the
Petitioner was, therefore, not confined to the experience certificate but also
extended to the particulars disclosed by her in the application form.
10.4. Merely because the Petitioner was posted in Administration-I
department of NII did not establish that she possessed the prescribed
experience in the field of Personnel & Administration. Had the correct
nature of the Petitioner’s work been disclosed, she would not have satisfied
the eligibility criteria and, consequently, would neither have been
provisionally selected nor issued the offer of appointment. Accordingly,
SECI was justified in withdrawing the offer of appointment.
10.5. The impugned action does not amount to a punitive or stigmatic
termination but constitutes withdrawal of an appointment obtained on the
basis of an ineligible or non-conforming experience claim. Consequently,
the principles of natural justice were not attracted, and no prior show-cause
notice or opportunity of hearing was required before issuing the impugned
communication.
10.6. Reliance is also placed upon the order dated 05 th May, 2026, passed
Dgitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
13:07:09
W.P.(C) 16198/2022
by this Court in Rajeev Kumar v. Union of India & Anr.1, in support of the
submission that a conditional appointment may be withdrawn upon
verification of eligibility.
Issues for Consideration
11.
On the basis of the pleadings and the submissions advanced, the
following issues arise for consideration:
(i)
Whether the Petitioner possessed the prescribed “01 year of post-
qualification experience in field of Personnel & Administration” as required
under Recruitment Notification No. 01/2021.
(ii)
Whether SECI was justified, in terms of the recruitment notification
and the conditions of the offer of appointment, in withdrawing the
Petitioner’s offer of appointment upon verification of her eligibility and the
documents furnished by her.
(iii)
Whether the Petitioner is entitled to reinstatement or any other relief.
Analysis
12.
The Court must, at the outset, examine the eligibility condition as
prescribed in the advertisement. The post advertised was that of Supervisor
(P&A) and not that of a Junior Assistant. Correspondingly, the experience
requirement was not satisfied merely by demonstrating one year’s
employment after graduation or deployment in an office environment. The
advertisement specifically prescribed “01 year of post-qualification
experience in field of Personnel & Administration”. Thus, what assumes
significance is not merely the duration of service, but the nature and
relevance of the experience acquired.
13.
It is well settled that, in matters of public recruitment, the eligibility
W.P.(C) 1306/2023.
Dgitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
13:07:09
W.P.(C) 16198/2022
criteria prescribed by the employer must be applied as they stand. Neither
the recruiter nor the Court can dilute, expand or substitute an essential
qualification on considerations of equity or perceived equivalence. Where
experience in a specified field is prescribed as an eligibility condition, the
burden lies upon the candidate to demonstrate experience in that field.
14.
The Petitioner’s engagement at NII through Alankit Ltd. is not in
dispute. The appointment letter issued by Alankit Ltd. records that she was
appointed on a contractual basis as a “Junior Assistant” with deployment at
NII. The experience certificate and relieving letter issued by Alankit Ltd.
also establish that she remained deployed at NII as a “Junior Assistant” from
11th July, 2019 to 31st January, 2021. The bank statements placed on record
corroborate receipt of salary from Alankit Ltd. These documents, however,
establish only the Petitioner’s engagement and deployment; they do not, by
themselves, establish that she possessed the experience prescribed in the
advertisement in the field of Personnel & Administration. The determinative
question, therefore, is whether the record establishes that she acquired the
prescribed post-qualification experience.
15.
The appointment letter issued by Alankit Ltd. does not assign to the
Petitioner duties relating to Personnel & Administration. It merely appoints
her as a “Junior Assistant” with deployment at NII. Similarly, the experience
certificate records her deployment as a “Junior Assistant” and certifies that
her services were satisfactory. It does not certify that she handled personnel
matters, service matters, recruitment, establishment, vigilance, APAR,
disciplinary matters, HR administration or any other defined functions
falling within the field of Personnel & Administration.
16.
The certificate dated 27th November, 2020, issued on the letterhead of
Dgitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
13:07:09
W.P.(C) 16198/2022
NII, also does not advance the Petitioner’s case. The certificate merely
describes her as “Personal Assistant (Outsourced)” in Administration-I and
records the consolidated salary being drawn by her. It is not a certificate
certifying experience in the field of Personnel & Administration. More
importantly, upon verification sought by SECI, NII clarified that the
certificate had neither been issued by the competent department nor by the
officer authorised to issue such certification, and that the designation
mentioned therein did not correspond with the Petitioner’s actual
designation. The evidentiary value of the said certificate, therefore, stands
substantially undermined.
17.
The office orders relied upon by the Petitioner also merit
consideration. One office order dated 17th June, 2020 records that, in
addition to her existing responsibilities, the Petitioner was required to assist
in matters relating to the “allotment of accommodation”. Another office
order dated 29th July, 2020 pertains to redistribution of work amongst
outsourced Junior Assistants in Administration-I and indicates that certain
office responsibilities were assigned amongst them.
18.
These documents, however, must be viewed in their proper context.
They indicate that the Petitioner was entrusted with assisting in certain
administrative
functions
and
was
exposed
to
work
relating
to
accommodation, RTI matters, grievances, APARs and FR 56(j). However,
they do not establish that Personnel & Administration constituted the
Petitioner’s primary or substantive sphere of engagement, nor do they
demonstrate that her engagement as an outsourced Junior Assistant assumed
the character of one year’s post-qualification experience in the specialised
field prescribed under the recruitment notification. Mere proof of
Dgitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
13:07:09
W.P.(C) 16198/2022
engagement for the requisite duration cannot substitute proof of experience
in the prescribed field. These documents are, therefore, insufficient to
establish compliance with the essential experience requirement for the post
of Supervisor (P&A).
19.
Much emphasis is placed on the Petitioner having “assisted” in
several administrative functions. Assisting in an administrative office or
rendering assistance in particular office functions may provide exposure to
administrative processes. However, the advertisement required experience in
the field of Personnel & Administration. Such experience cannot be inferred
merely from exposure to, or assistance in, certain administrative activities.
There must be reliable contemporaneous record demonstrating the nature,
substance and duration of the prescribed experience. The record relied upon
by the Petitioner falls short of establishing the same.
20.
The Petitioner’s application form presents a further difficulty.
Therein, she stated that she had assisted in work relating to administration,
meetings of the Governing Body, Finance Committee and Society, APAR
Cell, Hindi Section, release of funds for projects, establishment and service
matters. However, during the verification exercise, NII informed SECI that,
during the relevant period, the Petitioner’s work comprised Hindi typing,
day-to-day office activities and filing work. In these circumstances, SECI
was justified in taking the verification furnished by NII into account while
assessing whether the experience claimed by the Petitioner satisfied the
eligibility requirement prescribed under the recruitment notification.
21.
The Petitioner’s contention that any deficiency in her prior experience
stood cured by the experience gained after joining SECI also cannot be
accepted. Eligibility for appointment must be determined with reference to
Dgitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
13:07:09
W.P.(C) 16198/2022
the date prescribed under the recruitment notification. A candidate who does
not satisfy the prescribed eligibility on that date cannot cure the deficiency
by acquiring the requisite experience thereafter. The terms of the
advertisement are binding both upon the candidates and the recruiting
authority, and the eligibility conditions cannot be diluted after the
recruitment process has commenced. The Supreme Court has consistently
held that eligibility must be assessed with reference to the prescribed cut-off
date, unless the advertisement itself provides otherwise.2
22.
Equally untenable is the Petitioner’s contention that, having been
permitted to join service after document verification, SECI was precluded
from
subsequently
withdrawing
the
offer
of
appointment.
The
communication dated 19th January, 2022 calling upon the Petitioner to
appear for document verification, the declaration furnished by her in the
application form, and the offer of appointment dated 02 nd February, 2022
unequivocally stipulated that the appointment was subject to verification of
the information furnished by her and fulfilment of the prescribed eligibility
conditions. The appointment was, therefore, expressly conditional and
subject to such verification.
23.
The legal effect of such a conditional appointment is well settled. In
Satish Chandra Yadav v. Union of India3 and Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut
Prasaran Nigam Ltd. v. Anil Kanwariya4, the Supreme Court recognised
that where an appointment is expressly made subject to verification of the
information furnished by the candidate, the employer is entitled to act upon
the result of such verification. A candidate does not acquire an indefeasible
See Rakesh Kumar Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi) & Ors. (2013) 11 SCC 58.
(2023) 7 SCC 536.
Dgitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
13:07:09
W.P.(C) 16198/2022
right to appointment or continuance in service merely because she has been
provisionally selected or permitted to join pursuant to such a conditional
appointment.
24.
It is true that the aforesaid decisions arose in differing factual
contexts, involving suppression or non-disclosure of material information.
The principle that emerges, however, is applicable to the present case. The
Petitioner’s appointment was expressly made subject to verification of the
information furnished by her. Once the verification undertaken by SECI
revealed that the prescribed experience was not established, the Petitioner
could not claim a right to continue in service merely because she had been
permitted to join pursuant to the conditional appointment.
25.
Mr. Abhinav Singh, counsel for SECI, also relied upon the order
dated 05th May, 2026 passed by this Court in Rajeev Kumar. That decision
likewise arose from a recruitment process conducted by SECI, albeit in the
context of a different post and on its own facts. It cannot, therefore, be
applied as a precedent on the issues arising in the present case. Nevertheless,
the Court therein recognised that where an appointment is expressly made
subject to verification of the candidate’s credentials and eligibility, SECI is
entitled to undertake such verification even after the candidate has joined
service and to act upon the outcome thereof in accordance with the terms
governing the appointment. To that extent, the decision lends support to the
Respondents’ submissions.
26.
The contention that the impugned action is punitive or stigmatic is
equally unpersuasive. The Petitioner’s services have not been discontinued
on account of any misconduct committed during the course of her
(2021) 10 SCC 136.
Dgitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
13:07:09
W.P.(C) 16198/2022
employment. The impugned action is founded upon the verification
undertaken by SECI in relation to the eligibility material furnished by the
Petitioner at the threshold of the recruitment process. A conclusion that a
candidate did not possess the prescribed experience, or that the experience
claimed was not borne out by the verified record, may undoubtedly have
adverse consequences. However, such a conclusion does not, by itself,
render the action punitive or stigmatic in nature.
27.
The plea founded upon breach of the principles of natural justice also
does not merit acceptance. The Respondents have consistently maintained
that the Petitioner’s appointment was conditional and subject to verification
of her eligibility. In the facts of the present case, the impugned action is
founded upon documentary verification and not upon any disputed
allegation of misconduct warranting a disciplinary inquiry. In any event,
even assuming that a prior opportunity ought to have been afforded, the
Petitioner has had full opportunity before this Court to demonstrate that she
possessed the prescribed experience in the field of Personnel &
Administration. As discussed above, the record does not establish such
experience. In these circumstances, remanding the matter merely for
issuance of a formal notice would serve no useful purpose, particularly when
no prejudice has been shown to have been caused by its absence.
Conclusion
28.
For the foregoing reasons, the Petitioner has failed to establish that
she possessed the prescribed post-qualification experience in the field of
Personnel & Administration. Once that conclusion is reached, no
enforceable right to appointment or continuation in service survives.
Accordingly, this Court finds no ground to interfere with the communication
Dgitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
13:07:09
W.P.(C) 16198/2022
dated 03rd November, 2022.
29.
The writ petition is, accordingly, dismissed. Pending applications, if
any, also stand disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
JULY 8, 2026/ab
Dgitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
13:07:09
W.P.(C) 16198/2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review