Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC010442912026
+
RFA(COMM) 629/2026, CM APPL. 63718/2026, CM APPL.
63719/2026, CM APPL. 63720/2026, CM APPL. 63721/2026,
CM APPL. 63722/2026 & CM APPL. 63723/2026
MS SENATOR WOOD PVT LTD THROUGH ITS AR
JITENDER KEJRIWAL & ANR.
.....APPELLANTS
Through:
Mr. Anshul Sharma and Mr.
Abhishek, Advs.
versus
BABU LAL PATEL & ORS.
Through:
.....RESPONDENTS
Mr. Pranay Trivedi, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C.HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINOD KUMAR
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
17.09.2026
%
VINOD KUMAR, J.
1.
The present appeal has been preferred against a judgment dated
12.08.2026 passed by learned District Judge (Commercial
Court)-02, West District, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi, vide which
she partly decreed the CS (COMM) No. 511/2024.
2.
In the impugned judgment, learned District Judge passed a
decree of possession in favour of plaintiffs (respondents herein)
and against the defendant (appellant herein) in respect of
basement and ground floor of the suit property bearing
no.1/113, Block-1, Ware Housing Scheme, Village Basai
Darapur, Kirti Nagar, New Delhi-110015. This order was
passed by learned District Judge on an application of the
RFA(COMM) 629/2026
KUMAR VATS
14:33:14
respondents-plaintiffs under Order XIII A, which was treated as
an application under Order XII Rule 6 of Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (in short ‘CPC’).
3.
Briefly stated the facts are that the plaintiffs let out the suit
property to the defendant-appellant company for commercial
purpose. A registered lease deed dated 17.02.2021 was executed
between the parties for a fixed period commencing from
01.02.2021 to 31.01.2025. As per the terms of the lease deed,
the defendant was liable to pay monthly rent in advance on or
before 10th day of every rental month. As per clause 12 of the
registered lease deed, if there was default in payment of rent for
consecutive two months, lessor would be entitled to terminate
the tenancy. As per plaint, the defendant company made
defaults in payment of rent for the months of January 2024 and
February 2024. Consequently, the plaintiff issued a legal notice
dated 19.02.2024 terminating the lease and calling upon the
defendant to vacate and handover peaceful vacant possession of
the suit premises.
4.
The appellant-defendant contested the suit by filing a written
statement, in which the defendant admitted the execution of
registered lease deed, relationship of landlord-tenant between
the parties and agreed rate of rent. However, he stated that there
was no default in payment of rent for two consecutive months
and that post dated cheques of the rent have already been
handed over to the plaintiffs at their own request.
5.
After completion of the pleadings, the defence of the appellant
was struck off by the Trial Court in exercise of powers under
Order XV A CPC (Delhi Amendment) vide order dated
RFA(COMM) 629/2026
KUMAR VATS
14:33:14
01.04.2025 and the matter was directed to be listed for
plaintiff’s evidence.
6.
It was at this stage that the respondents-plaintiffs filed an
application under Order XIII A of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 as made applicable to the commercial disputes through the
amendments brought by virtue of Section 16 of the Commercial
Courts Act, 2015. The Trial Court, after hearing the rival
submissions, held that an application for summary judgment
under Rule 2 of Order XIII A can be moved only before
framing of issues. In the present case, as no issues were framed
on account of defence having been struck off, it was held that
there cannot be any bar merely on the ground that case was
fixed for recording of evidence.
7.
The Trial Court, however, treated the application under Order
XII Rule 6 CPC on the request of the respondents-plaintiffs and
conceding the said request, passed the impugned judgment on
the basis of admissions made in written statement and passed a
decree of possession of the premises in question in favour of
plaintiffs directing the defendant to handover the possession of
the suit premises to the plaintiffs.
8.
The appellant company (defendant before the Trial Court) has
come in appeal against the said judgment and argued that the
nature of application under Order XIII A and the application
under Order XII Rule 6 CPC are not only different but also
operate in different spheres. It is argued that he had addressed
arguments on the application under Order XIII A and not on the
application under Order XII Rule 6 CPC.
RFA(COMM) 629/2026
KUMAR VATS
14:33:14
9.
We have perused the impugned judgment. Para 13 of the
impugned judgment makes a specific reference that the
plaintiffs themselves had requested that the application should
be treated under Order XII Rule 6 CPC. It is not the case of the
appellant-defendant that this submission was wrongly recorded
by the Trial Court and that they filed any application for the
correction of the aforesaid portion of the impugned judgment
before the Trial Court. Notably, the Trial Court held that the
court can exercise its powers to deliver a judgment on
admissions suo motu also.
10.
Of course, we find substance in the submission of learned
Counsel for the appellant but only to the extent that an
application under Order XIII A for summary judgment in the
disputes covered under the Commercial Courts Act, 2015
cannot be filed when the case has been fixed for recording of
evidence. Here, it would be apposite to have a look at Rule 2 of
Order XIII A, which is reproduced as under:
“2. Stage for application for summary judgment.—An
applicant may apply for summary judgment at any time
after summons has been served on the defendant:
Provided that, no application for summary judgment may
be made by such applicant after the Court has framed the
issues in respect of the suit.”
11.
Thus, as per Rule 2 of Order XIII A, the application for
summary judgment can be filed before framing of issues.
However, there may be situations where issues are not framed
by the Trial Court because of the reason that the defendant has
been proceeded ex-parte or defence has been struck off. Now it
is to be seen as to at which stage the issues are to be framed.
This takes us to Order XV A which prescribes the functions of
RFA(COMM) 629/2026
KUMAR VATS
14:33:14
the Commercial Court, which it has to discharge during Case
Management Hearing (in short ‘CMH’), relevant portion of
which is reproduced as under:
“1. First Case Management Hearing.—The Court shall
hold the first Case Management Hearing, not later than
four weeks from the date of filing of affidavit of admission
or denial of documents by all parties to the suit.
2. Orders to be passed in a Case Management Hearing.—
In a Case Management Hearing, after hearing the parties,
and once it finds that there are issues of fact and law
which require to be tried, the Court may pass an order––
(a) framing the issues between the parties in accordance
with Order XIV of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of
1908), after examining pleadings, documents and
documents produced before it, and on examination
conducted by the Court under Rule 2 of Order X, if
required;
(b) listing witnesses to be examined by the parties;
(c) fixing the date by which affidavit of evidence to be filed
by parties;
(d) fixing the date on which evidence of the witnesses of
the parties to be recorded;
(e) fixing the date by which written arguments are to be
filed before the Court by the parties;
(f) fixing the date on which oral arguments are to be heard
by the Court; and
(g) setting time limits for parties and their advocates to
address oral arguments.
3. Time limit for the completion of a trial.—In fixing dates
or setting time limits for the purposes of Rule 2 of this
Order, the Court shall ensure that the arguments are
closed not later than six months from the date of the first
Case Management Hearing.
4. Recording of oral evidence on a day-to-day basis.—The
Court shall, as far as possible, ensure that the recording
of evidence shall be carried on, on a day-to-day basis until
the cross-examination of all the witnesses is complete.
5. Case Management Hearings during a trial.—The Court
may, if necessary, also hold Case Management Hearings
anytime during the trial to issue appropriate orders so as
to ensure adherence by the parties to the dates fixed under
Rule 2 and facilitate speedy disposal of the suit.
RFA(COMM) 629/2026
KUMAR VATS
14:33:14
6. Powers of the Court in a Case Management Hearing.—
(1) In any Case Management Hearing held under this
Order, the Court shall have the power to—
(a) prior to the framing of issues, hear and decide any
pending application filed by the parties under Order XIIIA;
(b) direct parties to file compilations of documents or
pleadings relevant and necessary for framing issues;
(c) extend or shorten the time for compliance with any
practice, direction or Court order if it finds sufficient
reason to do so;
(d) adjourn or bring forward a hearing if it finds sufficient
reason to do so;
(e) direct a party to attend the Court for the purposes of
examination under Rule 2 of Order X;
(f) consolidate proceedings;
(g) strike off the name of any witness or evidence that it
deems irrelevant to the issues framed;
(h) direct a separate trial of any issue;
(i) decide the order in which issues are to be tried;
(j) exclude an issue from consideration;
(k) dismiss or give judgment on a claim after a decision on
a preliminary issue;
(l) direct that evidence be recorded by a Commission
where necessary in accordance with Order XXVI;
(m) reject any affidavit of evidence filed by the parties for
containing irrelevant, inadmissible or argumentative
material;
(n) strike off any parts of the affidavit of evidence filed by
the parties containing irrelevant, inadmissible or
argumentative material;
(o) delegate the recording of evidence to such authority
appointed by the Court for this purpose;
(p) pass any order relating to the monitoring of recording
the evidence by a commission or any other authority;
(q) order any party to file and exchange a costs budget;
(r) issue directions or pass any order for the purpose of
managing the case and furthering the overriding objective
of ensuring the efficient disposal of the suit.
(2) When the Court passes an order in exercise of its
powers under this Order, it may—
(a) make it subject to conditions, including a condition to
pay a sum of money into Court; and
(b) specify the consequence of failure to comply with the
order or a condition.
(3) While fixing the date for a Case Management Hearing,
the Court may direct that the parties also be present for
RFA(COMM) 629/2026
KUMAR VATS
14:33:14
such Case Management Hearing, if it is of the view that
there is a possibility of settlement between the parties.”
12.
It shows that an application for summary judgment has to be
disposed of during CMH. As soon as the case is put for
recording of evidence, it goes beyond the stage of CMH and
thereafter, the application under Order XIII A would not be
maintainable. In the present case, even though issues have not
been framed, still as the case had reached the stage of recording
of evidence, it means that the case has crossed the stage of
framing of issues during CMH. Therefore in the present case,
the application for summary judgment under Order XIII was not
maintainable.
13.
However, the plaintiffs had themselves requested the Trial
Court that the application should be treated under Order XII
Rule 6 CPC. Even if the plaintiffs had not made such
submission, there was no hindrance upon the Trial Court to
consider the admissions and pass a decree as per Order XII Rule
6 CPC. The impugned judgment, therefore, is nothing but a
judgment on admissions. Accordingly, we do not find any
substance in the arguments of learned Counsel for the appellant
that the appellant had addressed arguments on an application
under Order XIII A CPC and not on an application under Order
XII Rule 6 CPC. Learned Counsel for the appellant fairly
admitted that a court can pass a judgment on admission under
Order XII Rule 6 CPC suo motu at any stage of the suit.
14.
In order to answer the argument by learned Counsel for the
appellant-defendant appropriately and sufficiently, we take this
opportunity to discuss the stage, sphere, scope and sweep of
RFA(COMM) 629/2026
KUMAR VATS
14:33:14
Order XIII A and Order XII Rule 6 CPC.
15.
Rule 2 of Order XIII A of CPC provides that an application for
summary judgment can be filed and decided before framing of
issues, which takes place during CMH. On the other hand,
decree can be passed on the basis of admissions at any stage of
the suit. Therefore, stage of filing an application for summary
judgment is quite restricted.
16.
Moreover, these provisions operate in different spheres. An
application for summary judgment under Order XIII A, which is
a complete Code in itself, can be made exclusively in
commercial disputes under the Commercial Courts Act, 2015.
On the other hand, Order XII Rule 6 CPC applies to all the civil
suits including commercial disputes. Further, under Order XIII
A, the initiative is with the parties exclusively to move
application for summary judgment and the court cannot suo
motu pass a summary judgment. See Division Bench judgment
of Delhi High Court cited as Surya Food and Agro Limited vs.
Om Traders and Another, (2023) 7 High Court Cases (Del)
350. However, under Order XII Rule 6 CPC not only the parties
but also the court can pass judgment on admission under Order
XII Rule 6 CPC suo motu.
17.
The scope of these provisions is also different. Order XIII A is
bigger in scope than Order XII Rule 6 CPC, which is limited to
the admissions only. To be more precise, a judgment under
Order XII Rule 6 CPC can be passed only when the admissions
are absolutely clear, categorical and unconditional. We refer to
the latest judgment of the Supreme Court in Pushpa & Ors. vs
Dayawati & Ors, 2026 INSC 603. If there are no clear cut
RFA(COMM) 629/2026
KUMAR VATS
14:33:14
admissions, the powers of the court under Order XII Rule 6
CPC cannot be exercised. On the other hand, the scope of Order
XIII A is wider. Even if there are no admissions, the court can
give a summary judgment if it considers that the plaintiff has no
real prospect of succeeding or the defendant had no real
prospect of successfully defending the claim.
18.
The sweep of Order XII Rule 6 CPC is very limited. The parties
and the Court have to identify the clear and unequivocal
admissions.
However,
while
addressing
arguments
on
application for summary judgment under Order XIII A, the
parties can draw the attention of the Court to every pleading and
every document on record. Nothing is beyond boundaries for
the court provided it forms part of judicial record. Therefore,
the sweep of Order XIII A is expansive as compared to Order
XII Rule 6 CPC.
19.
The next issue argued by learned Counsel for the appellant is
that once the defence of the appellant was struck off, it meant
that written statement filed before the Trial Court was taken off
the record and it was no longer a part of the judicial record.
Therefore, it is argued that the Trial Court erred in taking
admissions from the written statement.
20.
We are of the opinion that the aforesaid submission is devoid of
any basis. The defence is struck off when the defendant does
not comply with an order or direction of the Court. Learned
Counsel for the respondents-plaintiffs has drawn our attention
to para 34 of the impugned judgment, which is reproduced as
under:
“The Court also cannot lose sight of the subsequent
RFA(COMM) 629/2026
KUMAR VATS
14:33:14
developments during the pendency of the suit. Vide order
dated 21.12.2024, this Court directed the defendant to pay
the admitted monthly rent in accordance with the lease
deed. Thereafter, on 01.04.2025, it was recorded that no
arrears of rent had been paid despite the show cause
notice dated 31.01.2025 and the defence of the defendant
was struck off. Subsequently, vide order dated 02.08.2025,
the application of the defendant seeking review of the
order dated 21.12.2024 was dismissed and the earlier
order was modified to the extent that the defendant was
granted three months' time from that date to clear the
arrears of rent with effect from 01.03.2024 and was
directed to pay monthly rent as per the registered lease
deed. However, the defendant is admittedly not paying the
rent since long resulting in persistent default in payment
of rent.”
21.
Thus it is clear that the defence was struck off under Order XV
A (Delhi Amendment) on 01.04.2025 because the defendant
had not cleared the arrears of admitted rent despite repeated
directions of the court. Nothing has been shown by learned
Counsel for the appellant-defendant (i.e. lessee) that he had
made payment of rent for the months of January and February,
2024 and thereafter. We are of the opinion that effect of striking
off the defence starts onwards and it does not have any
retrospective effect. Therefore, the pleadings and documents
filed before striking off the defence cannot be taken off the
record as argued by learned Counsel for the appellant.
22.
The Trial Court passed the impugned judgment taking note of
the admissions in the written statement by the defendant
admitting the relationship of landlord and tenant, execution of
registered lease deed dated 17.02.2021, the agreed rate of rent
and prolonged non-payment of rent. Therefore, we are of the
considered opinion that on the basis of such admissions, the
court was fully justified in passing the impugned judgment. We
RFA(COMM) 629/2026
KUMAR VATS
14:33:14
accordingly, find absolutely no substance in the appeal, which
we dismiss in limine and at threshold.
23.
For removal of the confusion, it is necessary to observe that
there are two different Chapters under the heading “Order
XVA”.
Vide
High
Court
of
Delhi
Notification
No.
324/Rules/DHC, dated 12th November, 2008, published in Delhi
Gazette, Extra., Pt. IV, No. 179 dated 14th November, 2008, an
Order XV A was inserted in the year 2008. Under this Order
XV A, a court can direct a lessee to deposit the arrears of rent
and in default of making the deposit, the court is empowered to
strike off the defence. It is necessary to mention here that in the
present case defence of the appellant was struck off under this
Order XV A. Thereafter, through Commercial Courts Act,
2015, an Order XV A was inserted in CPC, which provides the
procedure of Case Management Hearing. This Order XV A
brought through amendment in CPC is a general provision but
in force within local limits of jurisdiction of the High Court of
Delhi. On the other hand, Order XV A inserted through
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 is applicable to the whole of
India but only to commercial disputes under the Commercial
Disputes Act, 2015.
24.
Pending applications are also dismissed.
VINOD KUMAR, J
C.HARI SHANKAR, J
SEPTEMBER 17, 2026
VB
RFA(COMM) 629/2026
KUMAR VATS
14:33:14
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review