The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Consequently, the present application is allowed. Sh. Rajesh Garg, Addl. District & Sessions Judge (Retd.), resident of House No.-626, Sector 16-A, Faridabad, mobile No.-8558873008, is nominated as the Sole Arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute between the parties, subject to compliance of statutory provisions including Section 12 of the Act.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
ARB-713-2025
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
ARB-713-2025
Date of decision: 17.04.2026
M/S NANDINI POWER SOLUTIONS PVT. LTD.
...Applicant(s)
VERSUS
SHARDA INFRACON PRIVATE LIMITED
...Respondent(s)
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JASGURPREET SINGH PURI
Present:-
Mr. Mukesh Kumar, Advocate for
Mr. Saksham Parmar, Advocate for the applicant.
(Through Video Conferencing)
Ms. Aashima Gautam, Advocate for the respondent.
(Through Video Conferencing)
****
JASGURPREET SINGH PURI, J. (Oral)
1.
The present application has been filed under Section 11(6) of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’)
seeking appointment of an independent Arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes and
differences which have arisen between the parties.
2.
Reply has been filed on behalf of the respondent in the Court today
and the same is taken on record.
3.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the applicant, who has
joined the proceedings through video conferencing, submitted that the
respondent had issued a work order to the applicant with regard to external and
basement electrical supply and installation work of Tower A, B, C, D and E at
NCR Group Housing Project at Sector-95, Gurugram (Haryana), which has
been enclosed with the present arbitration case as Annexure P-3 dated
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.04.21 09:27
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
ARB-713-2025
-2-
06.12.2021. He further submitted that the aforesaid work order was duly
accepted by the applicant and the work was executed and payments were also
made in this regard. He further submitted that the aforesaid work order contains
two Clauses i.e. Clause 20 and Clause 43. As per Clause 20, although its
heading states that it is an arbitration clause but the body of the Clause provides
that all disputes and differences which may arise between the parties under
“Conditions of Engagement and Scale of Charges” with regard to the meaning
or interpretation or matter or things done or to be done in pursuance hereof,
shall be referred to Directors of the respondent. Clause 43 provides for the
settlement of dispute/arbitration. In the said Clause 43, it has been so provided
that with regard to any disputes and differences of any kind whatsoever arising
out of or in connection with the contract, the same shall be resolved by
reference of the same to a Sole Arbitrator. He further submitted that in this way,
there is an arbitration clause contained in Clause 43, whereas Clause 20,
although of which the heading is “arbitration”, but it provides for settlement by
the Directors of the respondent.
4.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the applicant submitted
that due to the existence of an arbitration clause and subsequent dispute which
has arisen between the parties, the applicant invoked the aforesaid arbitration
clause No.20 by issuing a notice dated 16.07.2025 (Annexure P-4) seeking
appointment of an impartial and independent Arbitrator. He further submitted
that the aforesaid notice was received by the respondent, regarding which the
tracking receipt has been attached with the present arbitration case as Annexure
P-5. However, no reply was filed by the respondent to the aforesaid notice and
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.04.21 09:27
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
ARB-713-2025
-3-
since the mechanism for appointment of an Arbitrator has failed, the present
application has been filed under Section 11 of the Act seeking appointment of
an independent Arbitrator. He also submitted that in the aforesaid Clause 43, the
venue of arbitration has been mentioned to be Gurugram.
5.
On the other hand, Ms. Aashima Gautam, learned counsel for the
respondent, who has joined the proceedings through video conferencing, while
referring to the reply filed on behalf of the respondent in the Court today
submitted that there is no dispute with regard to the work order, which has been
attached along with the present arbitration case as Annexure P-3 dated
06.12.2021. However, the respondent has two-fold objections in the present
case. Firstly, with regard to the maintainability of the present arbitration case
and secondly, with regard to the limitation for filing the same.
6.
She further submitted that the present arbitration case is not
maintainable because there is no Clause pertaining to arbitration. While
referring to the notice (Annexure P-4) which was issued by the applicant
seeking invocation of the arbitration clause, she submitted that reference was
made to Clause 20 of the work order but Clause 20 does not relate to any
arbitration process on the face of it and since the aforesaid Clause 20 does not
provide for any mechanism for referring the disputes to arbitration, the
applicant cannot invoke Clause 20. She further submitted that so far as Clause
43 is concerned, it does not reflect any intention of the parties to refer the
disputes to arbitration because the said Clause 43 is totally vague and overlaps
with Clause 20 and since there is no Clause for seeking any arbitral process in
the work order, no Arbitrator can be appointed under Section 11 of the Act.
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.04.21 09:27
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
ARB-713-2025
7.
-4-
On the issue of limitation, learned counsel for the respondent
submitted that the present arbitration case filed under Section 11 of the Act is
also hit by limitation because even as per the applicant, the cause of action has
arisen in the year 2021 and therefore, after a lapse of four years, the present
arbitration case cannot be filed and is liable to be dismissed.
8.
I have heard the learned counsels for the parties.
9.
The work order which has been attached along with the present
arbitration case as Annexure P-3 is not in dispute. The applicant has issued a
notice to the respondent vide Annexure P-4, regarding which tracking receipt
has also been attached as Annexure P-5. There are two Clauses in the
aforesaid work order, which have been referred to by both the learned counsels
for the parties. Clause 20 and Clause 43 of the work order are reproduced as
under:“20. Arbitration:
All disputes or differences which may arise between
both of us under "Conditions of Engagement and Scale of
Charges" with regard to the meaning or interpretation or
matter or things done or to be done in pursuance hereof,
such disputes and differences shall be referred to Directors
of M/s Sharda Infracon Pvt. Ltd. and his decision shall be
firm and binding.
43. Settlement of Dispute/Arbitration: - With regards to any
disputes and differences of any kind whatsoever arising out
of or in connection with this Contract the same shall be
resolved by reference of the same to a sole Arbitrator. The
contractor agrees and confirms that the arbitrator shall be
appointed by Authorised Signatory of R.R. Infrastructures.
The person to be appointed as sole Arbitrator shall not be
below the rank of retired Add. Distt. Judge, The Renew of
Arbitration shall be at Gurugram only and proceedings shall
be conducted as per the Arbitrator and Conciliation Act,
1996.”
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.04.21 09:27
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
ARB-713-2025
10.
-5-
A perusal of Clause 20 would show that the heading of the same is
“Arbitration” and as per the said Clause, it is very clear that it does not reflect
any intention of the parties to arbitrate in case any dispute arises because it
clearly provides that the disputes and differences shall be referred to the
Directors of the respondent and therefore, Clause 20 does not pertain to
arbitration clause at all notwithstanding that the heading of the said Clause is
stated to be “Arbitration”.
11.
So far as Clause 43 is concerned, its heading is “Settlement of
Dispute/Arbitration”. A perusal of Clause 43 of the work order, which is not in
dispute, shows that in the event of any disputes or differences of any kind
whatsoever arising out of or in connection with the contract, the same shall be
resolved by reference of the same to a Sole Arbitrator. Thereafter, it so provides
that the Arbitrator shall be appointed by the authorized signatory of R.R.
Infrastructures, which means that an authority was mentioned as to who will
appoint the Arbitrator and it is further clarified by stating that the person to be
appointed as Sole Arbitrator shall not be below the rank of a retired Additional
District Judge. Even the seat of arbitration is mentioned to be Gurugram and the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, is also stated to be applicable to the
parties. Therefore, the objection raised by the learned counsel for the
respondent that even the aforesaid Clause 43, being vague, does not convey any
intention of the parties to refer the matter is totally misconceived. Rather on the
other hand, a bare perusal of Clause 43 would clearly show that the intention of
the parties was to refer the matter to a Sole Arbitrator and even it has been so
agreed between the parties that the Arbitrator shall not be below the rank of a
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.04.21 09:27
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
ARB-713-2025
-6-
retired Additional District Judge and also the seat and applicability of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 was also provided. Therefore, this Court
is of the considered view that clearly the intention of the parties was to refer the
matter to a Sole Arbitrator.
12.
So far as the second objection raised by the learned counsel for the
respondent that the present arbitration case under Section 11 of the Act is hit by
limitation of three years is concerned, the same is also misconceived. The law
with regard to limitation has been settled by Hon’ble Supreme Court in SBI
General Insurance Co. Ltd. versus Krish Spinning, 2024 SCC OnLine SC
1754. The notice issued by the applicant vide Annexure P-4 is dated 16.07.2025
and the present arbitration case has been filed on 05.11.2025 and therefore, it is
well within the period of three years and is also within the period of limitation.
Therefore, the aforesaid objection raised by the learned counsel for the
respondent is misconceived and liable to be rejected.
13.
In the notice which has been issued by the applicant vide Annexure
P-4, reference was made to Clause 20, although the notice was issued for
invocation of the arbitration clause, which is clear from paragraph No.9 of the
notice, wherein it is mentioned that respondent be called upon to appoint an
impartial and independent Arbitrator. This Court is of the considered view that
mentioning of Clause 20 in the aforesaid notice instead of Clause 43 would not
be fatal for filing the arbitration case under Section 11 of the Act. Mere
mentioning of a wrong Clause cannot non-suit the applicant from filing the
present arbitration case under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996.
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.04.21 09:27
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
ARB-713-2025
14.
-7-
In the aforesaid totality of facts and circumstances, this Court is
satisfied that both the essential conditions sine qua non for filing the arbitration
case under Section 11 of the Act i.e. prima facie existence of the arbitration
clause and its invocation by issuance of a notice, are satisfied in the present
case.
15.
Consequently, the present application is allowed. Sh. Rajesh Garg,
Addl. District & Sessions Judge (Retd.), resident of House No.-626, Sector
16-A, Faridabad, mobile No.-8558873008, is nominated as the Sole Arbitrator
to adjudicate the dispute between the parties, subject to compliance of statutory
provisions including Section 12 of the Act.
16.
Parties are directed to appear before the learned Arbitrator on date,
time and place to be fixed and communicated by the learned Arbitrator at his
convenience.
17.
Fee shall be paid to the learned Arbitrator in accordance with the
Fourth Schedule of the Arbitration Act, as amended.
18.
Learned Arbitrator is also requested to complete the proceedings as
per the time limit prescribed under Section 29-A of the Act.
19.
A request letter alongwith a copy of the order be sent to Sh. Rajesh
Garg, Addl. District & Sessions Judge (Retd.).
(JASGURPREET SINGH PURI)
JUDGE
17.04.2026
Chetan Thakur
Whether speaking/reasoned
Whether reportable
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.04.21 09:27
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
:
:
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review