Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 15.01.2026
+
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & CM APPL. 54482/2025, CM APPL.
71347/2025
MS. MUSKAAN AAMIR
.....Petitioner
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANR.
.....Respondent
+
+
+
+
+
W.P.(C) 13309/2025 & CM APPL. 54611/2025
RAJ GUPTA
....Petitioner
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI THROUGH ITS VICE CHANCELLOR
& ORS.
.....Respondent
W.P.(C) 13464/2025 & CM APPL. 55340/2025
AYUSH TIWARI & ANR.
.....Petitioner
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI THROUGH ITS VICE-CHANCELLOR
& ORS.
.....Respondent
W.P.(C) 16037/2025 & CM APPL. 65706/2025
DIVYANSH BANSAL
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ANR.
W.P.(C) 16054/2025 & CM APPL. 65765/2025
FARHAN KHAN
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ANR.
W.P.(C) 19180/2025 & CM APPL. 79900/2025
RUDRA PRATAP SINGH
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ANR.
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
+
W.P.(C) 18051/2025 & CM APPL. 74695/2025
VANSH AGGARWAL
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI THROUGH VICE
CHANCELLOR/DEAN & ANR.
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 18148/2025 & CM APPL. 75095/2025
HARSH MEENA AND ORS
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI AND ORS
W.P.(C) 18174/2025
ABHISHEK KUMAR
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DEL AND ORS
W.P.(C) 14275/2025 & CM APPL. 2349/2026
VIKRANT SINGH GULERIA AND ORS.
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI AND ANR.
W.P.(C) 14286/2025 & CM APPL. 58477/2025
SHREJYA GUPTA AND ANR.
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI AND ORS.
W.P.(C) 15949/2025 & CM APPL. 65316/2025
HARSHVARDHAN AND ORS
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI AND ORS.
W.P.(C) 16026/2025 & CM APPL. 65641/2025
NISHA UJAINWAL
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ORS.
W.P.(C) 16036/2025 & CM APPL. 65702/2025
BHAVYA BUDHIRAJA
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ANR.
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 16038/2025 & CM APPL. 65709/2025
SAURABH KUMAR
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ANR.
W.P.(C) 16039/2025 & CM APPL. 65712/2025
BHAVIKA SINGH
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ANR.
W.P.(C) 16040/2025 & CM APPL. 65715/2025
YIMJUNGJUNGSHI SANGLIR
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ANR.
W.P.(C) 16048/2025 & CM APPL. 65744/2025
AMOGH RAJ SINGH RANA
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ANR.
W.P.(C) 16053/2025 & CM APPL. 65762/2025
RAHUL SHARMA
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ANR.
W.P.(C) 16194/2025
AMAN KUMAR & ORS.
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ANR.
W.P.(C) 16321/2025
JANAK BOORA & ORS.
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ANR.
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
+
+
+
+
+
+
W.P.(C) 16701/2025 & CM APPL. 68579/2025, CM APPL.
68580/2025
ARJUN SINGH
.....Petitioner
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI THROUGH ITS VICE CHANCELLOR
AND ORS
.....Respondent
W.P.(C) 16740/2025 & CM APPL. 68739/2025
AMJAD KHAN
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI AND ORS
W.P.(C) 16746/2025 & CM APPL. 68747/2025
ANISHKA AND ORS.
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI AND ORS.
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
W.P.(C) 17323/2025 & CM APPL. 71296/2025, CM APPL.
71297/2025, CM APPL. 2276/2026
NITIN PANWAR
.....Petitioner
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ANR.
.....Respondent
W.P.(C) 17664/2025 & CM APPL. 72969/2025
DEEPAK MEENA
versus
UNIVERISTY OF DELHI & ANR.
W.P.(C) 17853/2025 & CM APPL. 73772/2025
LOKESH SHARMA
versus
UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ANR.
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
.....Petitioner
.....Respondent
MEMO OF APPEARANCE:
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
PETITIONER(S):
Mr. Shivek Rai Kapoor, Mr. Vansh Bajaj, Mr. Ayush Verma, Mr. Nishant
Shrama and Mr. Vishal Jaswal, Advs in item 94
Mr. Abhay Kumar, Mr. Nirbhay Kumar, Mr. Aditya Soni, Mr. Arun Kumar
Yadav, Mr. Anupam Mishra, Mr. Aman Ranjan, Ms. Pooja Singh, Mr. Jay
Prakash Vidyarthi, Adv. in item 88
Mr. Raman Kapur, Sr Adv with Mr. Kunal Sharma, Ms. Mehaq Rao, Mr.
Yash Punjabi, Mr. Puneet Rathore, Mr. Himanshu Sharma & Mr. Himanshu
Maru, Advs. in item No. 91 & 106
Mr. Akshay Kumar, Adv. in item 107
Mr. Saurabh Kirpal, Sr. Adv with Mr. Junaid Aamir, Adv in item
61,64,65,66
Mr. Ayush Tiwari, Adv. in item 63
Mr Abhijeet Vikram Singh, Adv & Mr Kshitij Chhabra, Adv in item 102
Mr. Siddhant Soti, Adv, in item 86
Mr. Rajnish Kumar, Advocate. Mr. Umesh Kumar, Advocate. Mr. Shantanu
Sagar, Advocate in item 87
Mr. Junaid Aamir, Mr. Raghav Bhatia, Advs in item 95-100,108
Mr F A Ayyubi ; Ms Akanksha Rai ; Ms Gurneet Kaur ; Mr Satvik, Advs. in
item 92,93,104,105
Mr Sacchin Puri and Ms Kirti Madan, Advs. in item 103
Mr. Kamal Mohan Gupta, Ms. Mehraj Hakim Ali, Ms. Urvi Gupta, Mr.
Amber Shehbaz Ansari, Ms. Kritika Verma, Advs. in item 62
RESPONDENT(S):
Mr. Mohinder Rupal, Mr. Hardik Rupal, Ms. Aishwarya Malhotra, Ms.
Tripta Sharma, Advs. in all matters for University of Delhi
Mr. Ved Prakash Sharma, Mr. Preet Pal Singh, Ms. Tanupreet Kaur, Ms.
Medha Navami, Advs. in item 85-88, 91-108, 63 - 66 for BCI
Mr. Kanav Vir Singh SPC in item 61 for R1
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JASMEET SINGH
:
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
JASMEET SINGH, J (ORAL)
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
1.
The present batch of writ petitions, though couched in differently worded
prayers and seeking varied consequential reliefs, are traceable to a common
and singular fountainhead, namely, the „shortfall in the minimum prescribed
attendance.’
2.
The petitioners before this Court are admittedly students enrolled in and
pursuing the LL.B. Degree Programme conducted under the aegis and
academic supervision of the University of Delhi.
3.
The regulation, control and supervision of legal education in the country
vests statutorily in the Bar Council of India, a body constituted under
Section 4 of the Advocates Act, 1961, which is entrusted with the
responsibility of laying down standards of legal education, prescribing
eligibility norms, and ensuring uniformity and quality in the imparting of
legal instruction across institutions.
4.
The controversy in the present proceedings revolves around the
interpretation and scope of Rules 10 and 12 of the Bar Council of India,
Rules of Legal Education, 2008. The same read as under:
“10. Semester system The course leading to either degree in
law, unitary or on integrated double degree, shall be
conducted in semester system in not less than 15 weeks for
unitary degree course or not less than 18 weeks in double
degree integrated course with not less than 30 class-hours
per week including tutorials, moot room exercise and
seminars provided there shall be at least 24 lecture hours
per week. Provided further that in case of specialized and/or
honours law courses there shall be not less than 36 classhours per week including seminar, moot court and tutorial
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
classes and 30 minimum lecture hours per week. Provided
further that Universities are free to adopt trimester system
with appropriate division of courses per trimester with each
of the trimester not less than 12 weeks.
…
12. End Semester Test No student of any of the degree
program shall be allowed to take the end semester test in a
subject if the student concerned has not attended minimum
of 70% of the classes held in the subject concerned as also
the moot court room exercises, tutorials and practical
training conducted in the subject taken together. Provided
that if a student for any exceptional reasons fail to attend
70% of the classes held in any subject, the Dean of the
University or the Principal of the Centre of Legal
Education, as the case may be, may allow the student to
take the test if the student concerned attended at least 65%
of the classes held in the subject concerned and attended
70% of classes in all the subjects taken together. The
similar power shall rest with the Vice Chancellor or
Director of a National Law University, or his authorized
representative in the absence of the Dean of Law. Provided
further that a list of such students allowed to take the test
with reasons recorded be forwarded to the Bar Council of
India.”
5.
The factual matrix giving rise to the present batch of writ petitions is not in
dispute. It is an admitted position that the petitioners, for varied and diverse
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
reasons, were unable to secure the minimum prescribed attendance of 70%
of the classes conducted during the relevant academic period.
6.
Learned senior counsels and counsels appearing on behalf of the petitioners
have placed reliance upon the judgment of the Hon‟ble Division Bench of
this Court in Sushant Rohilla, Law Student of I.P. University, In re,1 to
contend that a mere shortfall in attendance, as contemplated under Rule 12
of the Bar Council of India, Rules of Legal Education, 2008, cannot be made
the sole or determinative ground for detaining a student from pursuing or
continuing his or her LL.B. Degree Programme.
7.
Per contra, Mr. Sharma, learned counsel appearing for the Bar Council of
India (“BCI”), submits that the aforesaid judgment of the Hon‟ble Division
Bench is in the process of being assailed before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
and that, until any modification or stay is granted, the BCI has neither
diluted nor relaxed the rigours and mandatory requirements embodied in
Rules 10 and 12 of the Bar Council of India, Rules of Legal Education,
2008.
8.
Learned counsel further submits that owing to certain peculiar and
exceptional circumstances, including the non-holding of an inquiry by the
University/CLC and the consequential permission granted to students to
participate in the examinations on the basis of undertakings furnished by
them, the BCI, as a matter of concession, chose not to oppose the reliefs
sought by some of the students. It is emphasised that such concession was
limited to those exceptional facts and cannot be construed as a general
relaxation or dilution of the statutory rules.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
2025 SCC OnLine Del 7920.
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
9.
The said concession applies to petitioners in writ petition Nos. W.P.(C)
16701/2025,
W.P.(C)
14286/2025, W.P.(C)
14275/2025,
W.P.(C)
17323/2025,
W.P.(C)
15949/2025,
W.P.(C)
16746/2025,
W.P.(C)
16740/2025, W.P.(C) 18148/2025.
10.
Mr. Rupal, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the University of Delhi
states that the challenge to Rule 10 has not been disturbed by the judgment
of the Hon‟ble Division Bench in Sushant Rohilla (supra).
11.
He further states that the University of Delhi has held an inquiry on
22.09.2025 and the operative portion reads as under:“…And whereas, the Committee recommended that the
results in respect of the detainee students provisionally
allowed to appear in the End Semester Examinations be not
declared.
And whereas, the Competent Authority considered the BCI
provisions and the recommendations of the Committee on
18.09.2025, and has decided that result shall not be
declared and examination of such students (previously
detainees subsequently allowed provisionally subject to
outcome of the Enquiry Committee) be treated as cancelled.
Now therefore, all the students provisionally allowed to
appear in the End Semester Examinations May - June 2025
are hereby informed about the decision of the Competent
Authority.
This is issued with the approval of the Competent
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
Authority.”
12.
He states that the said inquiry report also has not been challenged in most of
the writ petitions.
13.
He further draws my attention to the order dated 24.08.2018 in University of
Delhi & Ors. v. Adarsh Raj Singh and Anr,2 and more particularly to
paragraph 5 which reads as under:“5.
We may clarify that this order shall not be treated
as a precedent, it has been passed in the peculiar facts and
circumstances of this case and based on the undertaking
and concession given by the University, and, therefore,
would be applicable only to the petitioners who are before
this Court in these proceedings. It is further made clear
that now no further petitions or any other grievance with
regard to the issue in question would be entertained either
by the University or by this Court in case of any other
candidate/student
similarly
situated
who
has
not
approached the Court.”
14.
Even though the LPA is currently pending, he states that the Hon‟ble
Division Bench observed that no further grievance will be entertained by the
Courts as evident from the above quoted paragraph.
15.
He also draws my attention to a judgment dated 04.11.2025 passed in Vansh
Aggarwal v. University of Delhi through Vice Chancellor/Dean & Anr,3
wherein the Hon‟ble Division Bench did not permit the petitioner therein to
participate in pursuing the LL.B Degree Programme for shortage of
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
LPA 443 of 2018.
LPA 736 of 2025.
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
attendance. Reliance is placed on the following paragraphs:
“5. On a query by this Court, learned counsel could not
offer any explanation as to why the appellant did not attend
the classes of III semester. All that is stated by the counsel
for the appellant was that the respondent no.1/university
authorities had promised that the inquiry committee would
give its report and thereafter the respondent no.1/university
would consider permitting them to attend classes. It would
be pertinent to note that the detention order was passed on
24.05.2025, and the enquiry committee report dated
19.09.2025 filed by the respondent no.1/university before
this Court. Yet, the appellant did not approach any Court of
law for redressal of his grievances. Having not taken timely
steps to redress his grievances and remaining a fence sitter,
the appellant cannot be permitted to seek parity,
particularly, in view of the fact that he has not attended
even a single class.
6. It is pertinent to note, and is undisputed that the cut-off
date for filing the examination forms is over and no relief
can be granted at such a belated stage.
7. We may also note that permitting a student to sit for
examinations who has not attended even a single class,
would not augur well in the public perception. In fact, it
may be discouraging to all those sincere students who not
only attended their classes but also ensured that they are
not short of attendance. Permitting such students would also
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
be a premium to clear indiscipline and insincerity. The
appellant being a student of law, ought to have been more
sincere in attending classes and its unfathomable as to how
the student who has not attended even a single class would
be able to sit for the examination.”
16.
I have heard the learned senior counsels/counsels for the parties and perused
the material on record.
17.
The observations of the Hon‟ble Division Bench in Sushant Rohilla,
(supra) are relevant and read as under:“X. Directions With Respect To Mandatory Attendance
Norms:
249. In view of the above discussion in respect of
attendance norms, the following directions are issued:
(1) The Bar Council of India shall undertake a reevaluation of the mandatory attendance norms for the 3year and 5-year LLB courses in India in line with the above
observations as also in line with the NEP, 2020 and also the
2003 UGC Regulations which contemplate flexibility in
attendance requirements. As part of this process, the BCI
shall also incorporate modification of attendance norms to
enable giving credit to moot courts, seminars, model
parliament, debates, attending court hearings etc. In
addition, ameliorative measures as contained below shall
also be discussed and incorporated. BCI shall undertake a
stakeholder consultation including students, student bodies,
parents, teachers etc., for this purpose in an expeditious
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
manner.
(2) In order to safeguard the life and mental health of
students, keeping in mind the debilitating impact on students
that detention or non-appearance in examinations, due to
mandatory attendance requirements can have, while the
consultations by the BCI are underway, it is directed in the
interregnum, as under:
a. No student enrolled in any recognized law college,
University or institution in India shall be detained from
taking examination or be prevented from further academic
pursuits or career progression on the ground of lack of
minimum attendance;
b. No law college, University or institution shall be
permitted to mandate attendance norms over and above the
minimum percentage prescribed by the BCI under the Legal
Education Rules;
c. Insofar as the mandatory attendance norms fixed by the
BCI are concerned, all law colleges, Universities and
institutions recognized which impart 3 years and 5 years
LLB degree courses shall with immediate effect, implement
ameliorative measures includingi. Weekly notification of attendance of students through an
online portal/a mobile app including on the notice board;
ii. Monthly notice to parents/legal guardian/family members
regarding any shortage in attendance; iii. Conducting extra
physical or online classes for such students, who do not
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
fulfil the minimum attendance norms;
iv. Home assignments to be completed in lieu of shortage of
attendance;
v. Stringent practical work in legal aid clinics or similar
such bodies, duly certified, which can cover up the shortage
of attendance during the semester itself. Such steps shall
thus be taken during the semester itself.
vi. In terms of Rule 12 of Legal Education Rules, 2008, the
attendance percentage shall be calculated on the basis of
ACTUAL CLASSES HELD by the teachers.
vii. If at the end of a semester, a student still does not
qualify
the
prescribed
attendance
norms,
the
college/University cannot bar the student from taking the
examination. The student shall be permitted to take the
semester examination, however, in the final result for the
semester, the grade of the student would be permitted to be
reduced by a maximum of 5%, in case of marks being
awarded and by 0.33% in case of the CGPA system being
followed. Merely on shortage of attendance, promotion to
the next Semester shall not be withheld.
BCI shall take into consideration the above measures as
part of its consultation process while finalizing its norms for
legal education.
(3) In terms of the assurance given by the BCI on 10th
January, 2020, read with Rule 26 of Schedule III to the
Legal Education Rules, the BCI shall also take steps to
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
enable internships to be made available to all students,
especially those students belonging to economically weaker
background, remote areas, specially-abled students etc. who
do not have resources to arrange the same. Accordingly, the
list of senior advocates, advocates, law firms, regulatory
bodies, government organizations, etc. who are willing to
provide internships to students, shall be published by the
BCI and the State Bar Councils on their respective websites
within three months. The said list shall be periodically
updated and published city wise by the BCI and State Bar
Councils so that the students can apply for and obtain
internships.
(4) The Circular No. BCI:D:5186/2024 dated 24th
September, 2024 issued by the Bar Council of India in
respect of Biometric attendance, installation of CCTV
cameras etc. in all centres of legal education across India,
shall not be given effect to.”
(Emphasis added)
18.
Sub para 2A is most relevant and the Hon‟ble Division Bench in Sushant
Rohilla (supra) has categorically held that no student shall be prevented
from further academic pursuance on account of lack of minimum
attendance.
19.
It is also necessary to appreciate that the Hon‟ble Division Bench has
examined the issue of mandatory attendance in law programmes in
considerable detail, specifically with reference to Rules 10 and 12 of the
Legal Education Rules, 2008. The Hon‟ble Division Bench undertook an
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
extensive analysis of the submissions advanced, examined the scheme of the
Rules, and considered their interplay with the National Education Policy,
2020 (NEP, 2020).4
20.
The core question before the Hon‟ble Division Bench was not confined to
the individual grievance raised in the petitions, but extended to a broader,
systemic issue affecting the larger student population namely, “whether
mandatory physical attendance constitutes a non-negotiable component of
the teaching and training of students of law.” The said question was
answered in the negative.
21.
In addressing this issue, the Court undertook an expansive examination of
the UGC Regulations5, the nature and dimensions of legal education6, and
the evolving pedagogical framework governing higher education. The
analysis, thus, transcended the facts of the individual petitions and
culminated in the conclusion that while holistic legal education is
undoubtedly essential, rigid insistence on mandatory physical attendance
does not necessarily advance that objective.
22.
The Hon‟ble Division Bench also directed the Bar Council of India to
reconsider Rule 12 of the Legal Education Rules, 2008, observing that the
said provision was not indispensable to the achievement of the intended
educational outcomes. The relevant observations read as under:
“172. Considering the above position, and since the Court
is dealing with a professional course i.e., legal education,
which is designed to not only teach students but also to train
them for the practice of law, the question that needs to be
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
Supra n. 1, Paragraph Nos. 166-172.
Supra n. 1, Paragraph Nos. 175-179.
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
addressed by the Court would be as to whether mandatory
physical attendance is a non-negotiable component for the
teaching and training of students of law.
…
199. This Court had also directed the BCI to re-consider
Rule 12 of the Legal Education Rules, 2008.
…
203. The Court has considered the above stated judgments
relied upon by BCI. However, it is necessary to note that the
said judgments were passed prior to the NEP coming into
force. As discussed at length above, the NEP lays greater
emphasis on holistic learning and overall well-being of
students.
204. Having examined the intent of the NEP at length, this
Court is of the view that here is no doubt that facing the
consequences of non-appearance in the examination and
detention would be an extreme step for a student, especially
when considered in the light of repeated student suicide and
mental health issues. These issues have also been recently
taken note of by the Supreme Court in two judgments cited
above namely Amit Kumar (supra) and Sukdeb Saha
(supra).”
23.
The Hon‟ble Division Bench, upon a conjoint reading of Rules 10 and 12 of
the Legal Education Rules, 2008, observed that the semester system
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
Supra n.1, Paragraphs 185-189.
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
prescribes a minimum duration of 15 weeks for unitary degree courses and
18 weeks for integrated double degree courses. Rule 10 mandates the
minimum number of class hours and working days to be conducted by law
institutions. However, the Court took notice of the prevalent practice of
lectures being cancelled at short notice, often resulting in institutions failing
to meet the mandatory requirements prescribed under Rule 10. The relevant
observations read as under:
“210. A conjoint reading of Rules 10 & 12 of the Legal
Education Rules, 2008 shows that there is prescription of
semester system, which requires the following:
• 15 weeks for unitary degree course
• 18 weeks for double degree integrated course
Each of these weeks shall have a minimum of 30 class
hours. These class hours include tutorials, moot court
exercise and seminars. Out of 30 class hours, at least 24
lecture hours per week are compulsory. In case of
specialized or honours law courses, 36 class hours per week
would be mandatory and out of these 36 hours, 30 minimum
lecture hours are compulsory. Colleges and universities are
free to adopt trimester system with each trimester having 12
weeks…
211. As is evident from the table produced above, Rule 10 of
the Legal Education Rules, 2008 stipulates the mandatory
minimum number of class hours and working days to be
conducted by law colleges, Universities and institutions.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
However, it is a common practice across educational
institutions for professors/teachers to cancel lectures at the
last moment, without providing prior notice to the students.
This leads to failure to meet the mandatory requirement for
minimum number of class hours and working days, as
prescribed.
212. Despite such deficiency on part of the law colleges,
Universities and institutions to meet the mandatory
requirement under Rule 10, the institutions still insist upon
the mandatory attendance norms under Rule 12 being given
effect to. This often creates an imbalance between the
obligation of the institutions to provide sufficient classes to
the students on one hand and the onus on the students to
meet the mandatory attendance norms on the other hand.”
(Emphasis added)
24.
The Court observed that despite institutional shortcomings, law colleges
continue to rigidly enforce attendance norms under Rule 12, resulting in an
imbalance between the institutions‟ duty to provide adequate instruction and
the burden imposed on students to meet attendance requirements. In this
context, reliance was placed on the decision of a Single Bench of this Court
in Adarsh Raj Singh v. Bar Council of India & Ors.,7 wherein it was
recognised that institutions frequently fail to conduct the statutorily
mandated minimum number of classes, thereby depriving students of a
meaningful opportunity to make up any shortfall in attendance before the
conclusion of the semester.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
25.
The Court further noted that Rule 12 of the Legal Education Rules, 2008
operates as a strict pre-condition, providing that a student “shall not be
allowed” to appear in the end-semester examination unless 70% of the
classes held are attended across lectures, moot courts, classroom exercises,
tutorials, and practical training. Though a limited relaxation of up to 5% is
permissible in exceptional circumstances, subject to intimation to the Bar
Council of India, the language of Rule 12 was found to be unduly rigid.
26.
The Court opined that, such inflexibility is bound to have a cascading and
disproportionate impact on students, as barring a student from appearing in
examinations cannot be justified even as a measure of last resort, having
regard to its severe consequences on mental health, academic progression,
and future career prospects. The relevant paragraphs read as under:
“214. Hence, this Court is of the opinion that it is
incumbent upon the BCI to ensure that all stakeholders
involved in imparting of the legal education, including the
dean of the universities, head of various departments, as
also the professors, ensure that the obligations that rest
upon them in terms of the BCI Rules, 2008 are met in a way
that the students get sufficient opportunity to make up for
the attendance that they might lose out on during the course
of the semester. By holding lesser number of classes than
those are prescribed, students in effect are compelled to
attend 100% of all classes taken by teachers – in effect
taking away the flexibility of 30% which is available to
them.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
2018:DHC:3933.
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
…
217. In the opinion of this Court, the language of Rule 12 of
the Legal Education Rules, 2008, is extremely strict in
nature and leaves little room for relaxation. In fact, the
wording of the Legal Education Rules, 2008 is stringent to
the extent that if the students do not attend 70% of the
classes, the only consequence shall be to bar them from
taking examinations altogether – there are no ameliorative
measures of making up the attendance.
…
219. In the opinion of the Court, such an inflexible
approach is bound to have a cascading effect, thereby
resulting in extreme consequences to students. Barring the
student from sitting in an examination cannot even be the
last resort undertaken by the concerned institutions –
considering the debilitating consequences for the student
including mental health and career prospects.
…
225. Consequences of non-appearance in examination and
hence, detention, which is prescribed as the first and the
only consequence of lack of attendance reveals an extremely
non-pragmatic approach towards the study of law. Studying
judgments in a library while engaging in discussions with
the peers, moot court practise exercises and competition
participations, internships and sharing of such experiences
are all integral parts of legal education. In fact, moot courts
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
and debate competitions themselves are so competitive in
nature that if a student is selected for national and
international level moot court, such student may not be able
to attend the classes for a whole semester, despite being
amongst the brightest students.”
(Emphasis added)
27.
That being the legal position, this Court is bound by the order of the Hon‟ble
Division Bench. Admittedly, till date, the judgment has neither been
stayed/varied/modified and hence is a binding precedent upon this Court.
28.
Additionally, the arguments of Mr. Rupal, learned counsel do not impress
me. My reasons are that the order dated 22.09.2025 of the inquiry committee
was passed by the University of Delhi before the judgment of the Hon‟ble
Division Bench in Sushant Rohilla (supra). Once the Hon‟ble Division
Bench has clearly opined that the student cannot be detained for lack of
attendance, the observations of the University are in contradiction to the said
findings which hold the ground. The judgment in Sushant Rohilla (supra)
will be applicable to all the petitions as the students are not being permitted
to proceed further with their academic careers due to shortage of attendance.
29.
Reliance on the judgment of Adarsh Raj Singh (supra) in LPA 443/2018 is
misplaced as the observations of the Hon‟ble Division Bench would only
pertain to the factual matrix existing at that point in time and cannot be
construed to mean that a student, upon accrual of a cause of action, is barred
from approaching a competent court of law for redressal, subsequently.
30.
The judgment of Vansh Aggarwal (supra) is also distinguishable as in that
case, the appellant did not attend a single class which is not the case in the
present petitions.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
31.
Much emphasis was sought to be placed by the respondents on the
undertakings furnished by the petitioners, whereby they had agreed to abide
by the decision of the Committee. It is, however, not in dispute that such
undertakings were obtained prior to the pronouncement of the judgment of
the Hon‟ble Division Bench in Sushant Rohilla (supra).
32.
To the extent such undertakings operate contrary to the law subsequently
declared by this Court, they cannot be permitted to prevail. It is a settled
principle of law that an undertaking which is contrary to a statutory
provision or runs counter to the law declared by a constitutional court is
unenforceable and cannot be sustained.
33.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, all the writ petitions are allowed. The
respondents are directed not to detain any of the petitioners on the ground of
lack of attendance.
34.
Once lack of attendance is held not to constitute a valid ground for
detention, all consequential benefits flowing therefrom shall necessarily
follow. These shall include, but not be limited to, promotion to the next
semester, declaration of results, permission to attend classes, and conferment
of the LL.B. Degree, in accordance with law.
35.
At this juncture, Mr. Rupal, learned counsel for the University of Delhi,
states that the specific order cancelling the results has not been expressly
challenged by the petitioners.
36.
The said contention also cannot be accepted. Once this Court declares the
very foundation or fountainhead of the impugned action namely, “lack of
attendance” to be illegal, this Court, in exercise of its powers under Articles
226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, is fully empowered to mould the
relief so as to do complete justice between the parties. Such power would
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
necessarily include the grant of appropriate consequential directions,
including permission to appear in supplementary examinations, where the
facts so warrant.
37.
The same is in consonance with the judgment in Nestle India Limited &
Anr v. Union of India & Ors.8 Relevant paragraph reads as under:
“15. The approach of the Court in granting relief must be
flexible and liberal and not rigid or hyper technical. The
Court has a very wide discretion in granting relief under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The Supreme Court
in Charanjit Lal vs. Union of India, AIR 1951 SC 41 held
that a petition under Article 226 should not be thrown away
merely on the ground that proper relief is not asked for.
Thus, under Article 226 relief can be granted by the Court
even by moulding the relief, if justice so requires.”
(Emphasis added)
38.
If there is any result given in sealed cover, the same shall be declared
expeditiously and not later than 2 weeks from today.
39.
The petitions are allowed in the above-mentioned terms.
40.
The documents handed over in Court today are taken on record.
41.
Dasti.
JASMEET SINGH, J
JANUARY 15, 2026 / (MS)
(Corrected and released on 20.01.2026)
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
10:30:38
W.P.(C) 4832/1995.
W.P.(C) 13273/2025 & connected matters
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review