Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 558/2026
MS. ISHA
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. G. D. Verman, Advocate.
versus
STATE BANK OF INDIA AND ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Rajiv Kapur, SC, SBI with Mr.
Akshit Kapur and Ms. Riya Sood,
Advocates for SBI.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
10.07.2026
%
1.
This writ petition seeks a direction to the Respondent Bank to appoint
the Petitioner on compassionate grounds in place of her father, Late Shri
Samey Singh, who died in harness while serving the Respondent Bank. The
Petitioner also assails the communication dated 7 th March, 2025, whereby
her request for compassionate appointment has been rejected.
2.
Late Shri Samay Singh, the Petitioner’s father, was employed as a
Head Messenger with the Respondent Bank and died in harness on 9 th
October, 2014. Nearly ten years thereafter, the Petitioner submitted an
application dated 29 th April, 2024 seeking appointment on compassionate
grounds, followed by representations requesting consideration of her claim.
By impugned communication dated 7 th March, 2025, the Respondent Bank
rejected the said request on the ground that the Petitioner’s case did not fall
W.P.(C) 558/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 16/07/2026 at 12:00:10
within the category of “exceptional cases”. The communication, however,
informed the Petitioner that she was eligible to seek ex gratia compensation
under the prevailing policy and enclosed the prescribed application form for
processing such claim.
3.
Assailing the aforesaid communication, counsel for the Petitioner
submits that the impugned decision is bereft of reasons, inasmuch as it does
not disclose why the Petitioner’s case was not considered to be an
“exceptional case”. Placing reliance upon SBI e-Circular dated 16 th March,
2021 containing the Revised Scheme for Compassionate Appointment, 1 he
contends that the Petitioner’s claim ought to have been considered
thereunder.
4.
He further submits that the Respondent Bank has failed to explain
why the option of claiming ex gratia compensation was extended to the
Petitioner only after the lapse of nearly ten years from the death of the
employee. It is also contended that no official of the Respondent Bank
visited the residence of the deceased employee after his demise to apprise
the family of the availability of compassionate appointment or other benefits
under the applicable policy.
5.
On the other hand, Mr. Rajiv Kapur, counsel appearing for the
Respondent Bank, submits that since the Petitioner’s father died on 9 th
October, 2014, the Petitioner’s claim is governed by SBI e-Circular No.
dated 27 th December, 2014, 2 which was in force on the date of the
employee’s demise. It is submitted that the deceased employee did not
satisfy the eligibility criteria prescribed under the said Scheme. Mr. Kapur
1 “2021 Scheme”
2 “2014 Scheme”
W.P.(C) 558/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 16/07/2026 at 12:00:10
further contends that the Petitioner’s application, having been submitted
nearly ten years after the death of the employee, defeats the very object of
compassionate appointment, which is intended to provide immediate
financial aid to the family of a deceased employee facing financial distress.
It is, therefore, submitted that the Respondent Bank rightly rejected the
Petitioner’s request for compassionate appointment while extending to her
the option of seeking ex gratia compensation in accordance with the
applicable policy.
6.
The Court has considered the rival submissions advanced on behalf of
the parties. The legal position governing compassionate appointment is well
settled. Compassionate appointment is not a vested right. It is a narrowly
tailored exception to the normal rule of public employment under Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. 3 The object of such appointment is
limited and specific, namely, to provide immediate succour to the family of
a deceased employee so as to enable them to tide over a sudden financial
crisis occasioned by the death or incapacitation of the sole breadwinner
while in service.4 The Supreme Court has consistently held that
compassionate appointment cannot be granted in the absence of a governing
scheme, rule, or instruction issued by the Government or the concerned
public authority operating at the relevant time. 5
7.
In the aforesaid backdrop, the Petitioner’s claim is required to be
examined with reference to the scheme governing compassionate
appointment which was in force on the date of the demise of Late Shri
Samay Singh. The Respondent Bank has placed reliance on the 2014
3 SBI v. Anju Jain, (2008) 8 SCC 475.
4 Sushma Gosain v. Union of India, (1989) 4 SCC 468.
W.P.(C) 558/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 16/07/2026 at 12:00:10
Scheme. A copy thereof has been handed over across the board and is taken
on record. The relevant provisions relating to its applicability are extracted
below:
“All branches and offices of
State Bank of India
Madam/ Dear Sir
(I) SBI SCHEME FOR COMPASSIONATE APPOINTMENT IN
EXCEPTIONAL CIRCUMSTANCES
(II) SBI SCHEME FOR PAYMENT OF EX-GRATIA LUMPSUM
AMOUNT IN LIEU OF COMPASSIONATE APPOINTMENT
Please refer to our circular letter No. CDO/P&HRD-PM/28/2005-06
dated 04th August, 2005 and e-circular Nos. CDO/P&HRDPM/20/2011-12, CDO/P&HRD-PM/06/2012-13 and CDO/P&HRPM/75/2013-14 dated 13th May, 2011, 17th April, 2012 and 25th
February, 2014 respectively.
2.
Following receipt of recent communication from Ministry of
Finance, GOI, vide letter F.No. 18/2/2013-IR dated 5th December,
2014 that all Public Sector Banks can have both the options i.e.
compassionate appointment or payment of lumpsum ex-gratia amount,
the Executive Committee of the Central Board of the Bank in its
meeting held on 23rd December, 2014 has approved continuation of
following two schemes duly modified as under:
A. Scheme for Compassionate Appointment in exceptional
circumstances (As per Annexure-I and 'B-1', 'B-2').
B. Scheme for payment of ex-gratia lumpsum amount in lieu of
Compassionate Appointment with following modifications:
…..xxx…..xxx……xxx……
C. The dependants of deceased employees falling under Scheme (A)
i.e. where death is treated as in "Exceptional Circumstances" will
have the option to chose either compassionate appointment or exgratia lump sum amount as per the eligibility under the scheme.
However, in all other cases of death as also in case of premature
retirement due to incapacitation before reaching the age of 55 years,
only ex-gratia lumpsum amount will be paid as per the eligibility
and no compassionate appointment will be considered.
3.
All other instructions relating to the scheme for Payment of Exgratia lumpsum amount shall remain unchanged.
4.
Both the modified schemes will be effective from 05.08.2014
and all cases of death/premature retirement on medical ground
5 Haryana SEB v. Krishna Devi, (2002) 10 SCC 246.
W.P.(C) 558/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 16/07/2026 at 12:00:10
occurred before 05.08.2014 will be dealt with as per the respective
old schemes.”
8.
The Petitioner, however, places reliance upon the 2021 Revised
Scheme for Compassionate Appointment. Since the applicability of the
scheme itself is in issue, the relevant provisions of the said Scheme are also
extracted below:
“All branches and offices of
State Bank of India
Madam/ Dear Sir
REVISED SCHEME FOR COMPASSIONATE APPOINTMENT
Please refer to our e-Circular Nos. CDO/ P&HRD-PM/ 20/ 2011-12
dated 13th May, 2011 & CDO/ P&HRD-PM/ 65/ 2014-15 dated 27th
December 2014.
2.
We advise that the Central Board in its meeting held on 24th
February, 2021 has approved the “Revised Scheme for
Compassionate Appointment”. The scheme will be applicable to a
dependent family member of confirmed regular permanent employee
of State Bank of India, who;
(i) dies while in service (including death by suicide) or
(ii) is retired on medical grounds due to incapacitation before
reaching the age of 55 years.
(incapacitation is to be certified by a duly appointed Medical Board in
a Government Medical College/Government District Head Quarters
Hospitals/Panel of Doctors nominated by the Bank for the purpose).
3.
Recently, the Bank has revised the Ex-gratia scheme effective
from 01st April, 2020 vide our e-Circular No. CDO/P&HRDPM/33/2020 - 21 dated 04th September, 2020. The dependents of the
deceased employee can exercise option to choose between "Revised
Scheme for Compassionate Appointment" or "Scheme for payment of
Ex-gratia in lieu of Compassionate Appointment" at their choice
subject to fulfilling the prescribed eligibility criteria.
4.
The “Revised Scheme for Compassionate Appointment” will
be effective from the date of this Circular. However, the scheme will
W.P.(C) 558/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 16/07/2026 at 12:00:10
also cover the death due to COVID-19 with retrospective effect from
24.03.2020 (i.e. the date of announcement of first nationwide
lockdown) and the benefit of retrospective implementation will be
extended only to the dependents of employees who expired due to
COVID-19. During this period, the dependent family members of
some of the deceased employees who died due to COVID-19 on or
after 24.03.2020 have received Ex-gratia under “Scheme for payment
of Ex-gratia in lieu of Compassionate Appointment”. In such cases,
the dependent family member, if opts for the “Revised” Scheme for
Compassionate Appointment”, will have to refund the entire amount
so received under “Scheme for payment of Ex-gratia in lieu of
Compassionate Appointment”, subject to his / her application for
appointment is approved under the “Revised Scheme for
Compassionate Appointment”.
5.
In case an application for compassionate appointment is
rejected under the “Revised Scheme for Compassionate
Appointment”, the same may be considered under the “Scheme for
payment of Ex-gratia in lieu of Compassionate Appointment”.
6.
Application for employment under the scheme in respect of
eligible cases of death shall be obtained by the branch/office where
the deceased employee had last worked. The concerned branch/office
shall immediately contact the family of the deceased employee and
provide them prescribed applications and complete all necessary
formalities in this regard. We enclose, the “Revised Scheme for
Compassionate Appointment” as per Annexure-I for your information
and necessary action.
Please bring the contents of the circular to the knowledge of all
concerned.
Yours faithfully
(Rana Ashutosh Kumar Singh)
Dy. Managing Director (HR) &
Corporate Development Officer”
9.
A plain reading of the 2021 Scheme leaves no doubt that the Revised
Scheme operates prospectively from the date of its issuance. The only
exception carved out is in respect of employees who died due to COVID-19,
in whose case the benefit of the Scheme has been extended retrospectively
with effect from 24 th March, 2020. Save and except this limited class of
cases, the Circular contains no indication that the Scheme was intended to
W.P.(C) 558/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 16/07/2026 at 12:00:10
operate retrospectively or to extend its benefit to claims arising from deaths
preceding its commencement.
10.
In the present case, the Petitioner’s father died in harness on 9 th
October, 2014. His demise, therefore, falls outside the limited category of
cases to which retrospective benefit under the 2021 Scheme has been
extended. Consequently, the Petitioner’s reliance upon the 2021 Scheme is
misconceived. The claim cannot, therefore, be tested on the touchstone of
the Revised Scheme of 2021, which was introduced nearly six years after the
death of the employee and has not been given retrospective operation in
cases such as the present.
11.
On the other hand, the 2014 Scheme expressly stipulates that the
modified schemes would come into force with effect from 5 th August, 2014
and would govern all cases of death occurring on or after the said date. Since
Late Shri Samay Singh died on 9 th October, 2014, the Petitioner’s
entitlement, if any, necessarily falls to be determined under the 2014
Scheme alone.
12.
Having held that the Petitioner’s claim is governed by the 2014
Scheme, it becomes necessary to examine the eligibility conditions
prescribed therein. The relevant provisions of the Scheme are extracted
below:
“SCHEME
OF
COMPASSIONATE
APPOINTMENT
ON
COMPASSIONATE GROUNDS IN EXCEPTIONAL CASES IN
STATE BANK OF INDIA”
2. BACKGROUND :
On the direction of Government of India, Bank introduced “Scheme
for Payment of Ex-gratia lumpsum amount” w.e.f. 04.08.2005 in lieu
of compassionate appointment. Subsequently, the Indian Banks'
Association came out with another scheme for providing
W.P.(C) 558/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 16/07/2026 at 12:00:10
compassionate appointment in following exceptional cases and our
Bank also adopted the same w.e.f. 04.08.2005 as a parallel scheme for
payment of Ex-gratia lumpsum amount.
a) Where an employee died while performing official duty, as a result
of violence, terrorism, robbery or dacoity; or
b) Where an employee died within five years of first appointment or
before reaching the age of 30 years, whichever was latter, leaving a
dependent spouse and/or minor children.
5. COVERAGE
5.1. To a dependent family member of permanent employee of the
Bank who
i) dies while performing official duty, as a result of violence,
terrorism, robbery or dacoity.; or
ii) dies within five years of first appointment or before reaching the
age of 30 years, whichever is latter, leaving a dependent spouse and
/or minor children.
5.2 For the purpose of the Scheme, “employee” would mean and
include only a confirmed regular permanent employee who was
serving full time or part-time on scale wages, at the time of death
under the exceptional circumstances and does not include any one
engaged on contract/temporary/casual or any person who is paid on
commission basis.
11. TIME LIMIT FOR CONSIDERING APPLICATIONS
11.1 Application for employment under the Scheme from eligible
dependant will be considered upto five years from the date of death.
11.2 Request for compassionate appointment under exceptional
circumstances may be considered even when the death of the
employee took place long back. While considering such belated
requests, it should be kept in view that the concept of compassionate
appointment under exceptional circumstances is largely related to the
need for immediate assistance to the family of the employee in order
to relieve it from economic distress. The very fact that the family has
been able to manage somehow all these years should normally be
taken as adequate proof that the family had some dependable means
of subsistence. Therefore, examination of such cases would call for a
great deal of circumspection. However, five years shall be the outside
limit in all cases and no proposals for compassionate appointment of
a dependent will be considered after five years from the date of
death.”
13.
A plain reading of Clauses 5 and 11 of the Scheme makes it
abundantly clear that compassionate appointment is not available in every
case where an employee dies in harness. The Scheme consciously restricts
W.P.(C) 558/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 16/07/2026 at 12:00:10
its applicability to narrowly defined “exceptional circumstances”, namely,
where the employee dies while performing official duty as a result of
violence, terrorism, robbery or dacoity, or where the employee dies within
five years of his first appointment or before attaining the age of thirty years,
whichever is later, leaving behind a dependent spouse and/or minor children.
Equally significant is Clause 11, which prescribes that an application for
compassionate appointment must ordinarily be considered within five years
from the date of death and expressly stipulates that five years shall be the
outer limit beyond which no proposal for compassionate appointment shall
be entertained.
14.
Tested against the aforesaid parameters, the Petitioner’s claim clearly
falls outside the ambit of the Scheme. It is neither pleaded nor demonstrated
that Late Shri Samay Singh died while performing official duty as a result of
violence, terrorism, robbery or dacoity. On the contrary, the petition itself
states that he succumbed to a heart attack while in service. Further, as
pleaded by the Petitioner, Late Shri Samay Singh joined the services of the
Respondent-Bank in September, 1985 and died on 9 th October, 2014, nearly
twenty-nine years after his appointment. Consequently, it is not, and indeed
cannot be, the Petitioner’s case that he died within five years of his first
appointment or before attaining the age of thirty years, whichever was later.
The Petitioner’s case, therefore, does not satisfy either of the eligibility
conditions prescribed under Clause 5 of the 2014 Scheme and is, thus,
outside the scope of compassionate appointment contemplated thereunder.
15.
Furthermore, the application seeking compassionate appointment was
submitted on 29 th April, 2024, nearly ten years after the death of the
employee. This was well beyond the outer limit of five years prescribed
W.P.(C) 558/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 16/07/2026 at 12:00:10
under Clause 11 of the Scheme. Such an inordinate delay is fundamentally
inconsistent with the very rationale underlying compassionate appointment,
namely, the provision of immediate financial assistance to enable the family
to tide over the sudden crisis occasioned by the death of the breadwinner.
16.
In these circumstances, the Respondent Bank was justified in
declining the Petitioner’s request for compassionate appointment and in
advising her to avail the alternative benefit of ex gratia compensation under
the applicable policy.
17.
The Petitioner’s further contention that the Respondent Bank offered
the option of claiming ex gratia compensation only after nearly ten years
from the death of the employee is also of no assistance. The record indicates
that there was correspondence between the parties regarding grant of ex
gratia compensation even prior to the impugned communication dated 7 th
March, 2025. Equally, the submission that no official of the Respondent
Bank visited the residence of the deceased employee to apprise the family of
the benefits available under the applicable policy cannot advance the
Petitioner’s case. Even assuming either of these contentions to be correct,
the same cannot confer upon the Petitioner a right to compassionate
appointment contrary to the express eligibility conditions contained in the
2014 Scheme.
18.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds no infirmity in
the impugned communication dated 07 th March, 2025, rejecting the
Petitioner’s request for compassionate appointment.
19.
However, since the Respondent Bank has itself extended to the
Petitioner the option of seeking ex gratia compensation, this Court deems it
appropriate to clarify that the dismissal of the present writ petition shall not
W.P.(C) 558/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 16/07/2026 at 12:00:10
preclude the Petitioner from availing the said benefit. Accordingly, in the
event the Petitioner submits the requisite application for grant of ex gratia
compensation within a period of eight weeks from today, the Respondent
Bank shall consider and decide the same in accordance with the applicable
policy and communicate its decision to the Petitioner within a further period
of eight weeks thereafter.
20.
With the above directions, the petition is disposed of, along with
pending application(s), if any.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
JULY 10, 2026/hc
W.P.(C) 558/2026
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 16/07/2026 at 12:00:10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review