Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 18.09.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 01.10.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 01.10.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010774032024
+
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
MS DEVI ELECTRONICS PVT LTD
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Sunil Dalal Sr. Adv. along
with Mr. Faraz Anees, Mr.
Kartik
Vashisht,
Mr.
Abhimanyu Singh Tomar, Mr.
Ajay Kumar and Mr. Yash,
Advs.
versus
COMMISSIONER CGST DELHI SOUTH AND ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Raj Kumar, CGSC.
Mr. Aditya Singla, SSC.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SHAIL JAIN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
1.
In substance, the present Petition has been filed seeking
issuance of writ in the nature mandamus, to direct the Respondent
No.2 to implement the Order-in-Appeal („OIA‟) dated 19.06.2024 and
expeditiously grant the Petitioner a refund of an amount of
Rs.3,15,30,605/- along with applicable interest. In addition, thereto,
the Petitioner also seeks quashing of the Order dated 24.09.20241
hereinafter referred to as „Impugned Order‟
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
passed under Section 54(11) of the Central Goods and Services Tax,
20172 and consequentially sanction all five refund claims totalling
upto Rs.3,15,30,605/-.
2.
The principal and limited question which has fallen for
consideration of this Court is whether the Respondent No.1 has rightly
invoked Section 54(11) of the Act of 2017 for withholding the amount
of refund claimed by the Petitioner.
A.
BRIEF FACTUAL BACKGROUND:
3.
In order to appreciate the present controversy, the facts in brief
are required to be noticed.
4.
The Petitioner, engaged in the business of exporting
microphones, telephone sets, smartphones, monitors, projectors,
automatic data processing machines and related parts and accessories
was registered under GSTIN 07AAACD0720F2ZB. During the period
from November 2023 to January 2024, the Petitioner exported goods
on payment of IGST, and consequently, filed five (05) refund
applications seeking refund of Rs.1,35,69,527.58/-, Rs.43,11,670.36/,
Rs.34,92,046.08/, Rs.67,97,817/- and Rs.33,59,544.01/- aggregating
to Rs.3,15,30,605.03/-.
5.
The aforesaid refund applications were processed by the
Respondent No.2, Show Cause Notices („SCNs‟) rejecting the refund
also came to be issues in respect of the claims so made, alleging, inter
alia, that the refund applications had been filed without the requisite
supporting documents. The Petitioner submitted detailed replies to the
hereinafter referred to as „Act of 2017‟
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
said notices along with the relevant documents. However, the
Respondent No.2, by way of the Orders-in-Originals („OIO‟) dated
01.03.2024, 27.03.2024, 22.04.2024, 25.04.2024 and 07.06.2024
rejected the refund applications, inter alia, primarily on the ground of
non-submission of complete documents.
6.
Aggrieved by the OIOs, the Petitioner approached the Appellate
Authority, reiterating that the refund applications had been filed along
with the requisite documents and placing on record, inter alia,
screenshots from the GST Portal evidencing the documents submitted
at the time of filing the respective refund applications. Consequently,
the Appellate Authority by way of the OIA dated 19.06.2024, allowed
all five appeals, and held, inter alia, that the Respondent No.2 had
erred in rejecting the refund claims without duly appreciating the
submissions of the Petitioner and the facts of the case.
7.
Thereafter, the Competent Authority reviewed the aforesaid
OIA and vide Review Order dated 23.06.2024, opined that the said
Order was liable to be challenged before the GSTAT under Section
112(3) of the Act of 2017 r/w Rule 111(1) of the CGST Rules, 2017.
The Review Order recorded that an appeal would be filed before the
Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) upon the
Tribunal becoming functional. In the meantime, pursuant to the OIA
dated 19.06.2024, the Petitioner filed a consolidated refund claim vide
ARN No. AA070624070785W dated 25.06.2024, seeking refund of
Rs.3,15,30,605.03/-.
8.
Since the aforesaid refund claim was required to be considered
in the backdrop of the review proceedings, the Respondent No.1
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
proceeded to examine the claim under Section 54(11) of the Act of
2017. In terms of the said provision, the Petitioner was afforded an
opportunity of personal hearing vide letters dated 27.08.2024 and
03.09.2024, with hearings scheduled on 30.08.2024, 05.09.2024 and
09.09.2024.
9.
Thereafter, the Respondent No.1 passed the Impugned Order
under Section 54(11) of the CGST Act, 2017, whereby the refund
arising from the aforesaid OIA dated 19.06.2024 was withheld.
Aggrieved thereby, the Petitioner has approached this Court seeking
our indulgence.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES:
10.
Learned counsel representing the Petitioner has made the
following submissions:
10.1
In substance, the case of the Petitioner is that the refund
sanctioned by the OIA could not have been withheld under
Section 54(11) of the Act of 2017, since on the date of its
passing, no appeal against the OIA or the Impugned Order was
pending before the GSTAT, nor was any other proceeding
pending against the Impugned Order.
10.2
It is argued that the mere possibility or contemplation of
filing an appeal under Section 112 of the Act of 2017 could not,
according to the Petitioner, constitute a pending proceeding so as
to justify withholding of the refund. In this regard, it has also
been argued that an appeal before the GSTAT only came to be
filed on 10.04.2026. Reliance in this regard is placed on Mandy
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
Enterprises v. Deputy Commissioner3 and Alex Tour Tavel v.
Asst. Commissioner CGST4.
10.3
It is further contended that an investigation or inquiry
cannot, by itself, be equated with a proceeding pending under the
Act of 2017 for the purposes of Section 54(11). In this regard,
reliance is placed on Liberty Oil Mills v. Union of India5, G.K.
Trading Company v. Union of India6 and Srico Projects (P.)
Ltd. v. Telangana State Authority for Advance Ruling7.
10.4
It is submitted that, in any event, since there was no order
of any competent court staying the operation or implementation
of the OIA granting the refund, the Respondents could not, in the
absence of a judicial stay, withhold the refund lawfully arising
from the OIA.
10.5
The Petitioner also disputes the reliance placed by the
Department on the alleged pendency of investigation. It is his
case that the SCN dated 24.08.2026, issued by the Additional
Commissioner (AE), CGST, Delhi South Commissionerate, was
not in existence either when the OIA granting the refund was
passed or when the Impugned Order was passed. Accordingly, it
could not have constituted a proceeding pending on the relevant
date for the purposes of Section 54(11).
10.6
Further, it is argued that the said SCN remains
(2024) 22 Centax 534 (Del.)
W.P.(C) No.5722/2023
MANU/SC/0029/1984
2021 (51) G.S.T.L. 288 (All.)
[2022] 142 taxmann.com 5 (Telangana)
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
unadjudicated and cannot, according to the Petitioner, be placed
on the same footing as the quasi-judicial OIA passed in their
favour or be relied upon to defeat or indefinitely keep in
abeyance the rights flowing from that order.
10.7
The Petitioner further contends that the Impugned Order
was passed by the Commissioner in an administrative capacity
and as such is not an adjudication order. In support, it is
submitted that the Act of 2017 draws a distinction between the
expressions Commissioner and Adjudicating Authority. Section
2(4) defines Adjudicating Authority, while Section 2(24) defines
“Commissioner”, and the two expressions are used distinctly in
the statutory scheme.
10.8
Reference is made, inter alia, to Section 56 and Section
107(2) of the Act of 2017, which, according to the Petitioner,
demonstrates that the Commissioner and the Adjudicating
Authority perform distinct statutory functions. Accordingly, the
two
expressions,
cannot
be
treated
as
interchangeable,
particularly in view of the settled principle that a taxing statute
must be strictly construed.
10.9
On that basis, the Petitioner also contends that the
Impugned Order has been passed by the Commissioner in his
administrative capacity and cannot be treated as an order of the
Adjudicating Authority. Consequently, Section 107 of the Act of
2017, does not provide an alternative remedy against the
Impugned Order.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
10.10 In addition, it is also the case of the Petitioner that the
Respondents‟ reliance on the GSTAT appeal acknowledgement,
does not, by itself, establish that a duly instituted appeal was
pending and it is unclear whether the appeal was genuinely
pursued or merely filed as a formality.
10.11 In substance, the Petitioner‟s case is that the refund
sanctioned by the OIA could not have been withheld under
Section 54(11) on the basis of a contemplated or subsequently
instituted appeal, an investigation which did not constitute a
pending proceeding on the relevant date, or an unadjudicated
SCN. In the absence of a judicial stay and there being no
statutory appellate remedy against the Impugned Order itself, the
Petitioner contends that the withholding of the refund was legally
unsustainable.
11.
Per contra, learned counsel representing the Respondents has
made the following submissions:
11.1
At the outset, it has been argued that the present Petition
is not maintainable, inasmuch as the OIA dated 19.06.2024 has
been reviewed by the Competent Authority and a decision has
already been taken to challenge the same before the GSTAT.
Accordingly, it is contended that the Petitioner ought to pursue
the statutory appellate remedy.
11.2
It is argued that Section 54(11) of the Act of 2017
expressly empowers the Commissioner to withhold a refund
where the order giving rise to such refund is the subject matter of
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
an appeal or further proceedings, or where any other proceedings
under the Act of 1017 are pending. Provided that the
Commissioner forms an opinion that grant of the refund is likely
to adversely affect the revenue on account of malfeasance or
fraud. According to the Respondents, both statutory conditions
stand satisfied in the present case.
11.3
In this regard, it is submitted that the OIA giving rise to
the refund claims was reviewed by the Competent Authority,
which directed that the OIA be challenged before the GSTAT.
Therefore, the OIA is subject to further proceedings, and the
refund arising therefrom could validly be withheld under Section
54(11) of the Act of 2017. Such pendency of statutory
proceedings, including the proposed appeal, is contended to be
relevant for the purposes of Section 54(11).
11.4
In furtherance to the aforestated, it has been argued that
an investigation by the Anti-Evasion Wing, CGST, Delhi South
Commissionerate (AEW, Delhi), was ongoing in respect of the
Petitioner and its suppliers. The investigation included
verification of suppliers, physical verification of their premises,
verification of vehicle details, issuance of summons to
transporters and other persons, and recording of statements.
Learned counsel particularly relies upon the physical verification
report concerning M/s Ziavlo India Pvt. Ltd., which according to
him, indicated that the supplier was not functioning from its
registered premises.
11.5
On the basis of the aforesaid investigation and the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
material available on record, the Commissioner formed an
opinion that grant of the refund was likely to adversely affect the
revenue on account of alleged malfeasance or fraud. Therefore,
the Respondents contend that the second statutory requirement
under Section 54(11) was also satisfied, thereby withholding the
refund by order dated 23.09.2024/24.09.2024.
11.6
The Respondents contend that Section 54(11) of the Act
of 2017 confers a specific statutory power upon the
Commissioner, which can be exercised notwithstanding the
absence of a separate judicial order staying the OIA.
Consequently, according to the Respondents, the withholding of
the refund cannot be treated merely as non-compliance with the
OIA.
11.7
Lastly,
distinguishing
the
judgments
in
Mandy
Enterprises (Supra) and Alex Tour and Travel Pvt. Ltd.(Supra)
relied upon by the Petitioner, it has been argued that the same are
distinguishable. Since, the said judgments did not concern
withholding of refund pursuant to a specific order passed under
Section 54(11) of the CGST Act. The Respondents accordingly
contend that those decisions do not govern the present case.
C.
ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION:
12.
Heard learned counsel representing the parties and with their
able assistance perused the paperbook.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
13.
Before proceeding to deal with the rival contentions, it is
necessary to notice the text and scope of Section 54(11) of the Act of
2017, which reads as follows:
“54. Refund of tax.—
(11) Where an order giving rise to a refund is the subject matter of an
appeal or further proceedings or where any other proceedings under
this Act is pending and the Commissioner is of the opinion that grant
of such refund is likely to adversely affect the revenue in the said
appeal or other proceedings on account of malfeasance or fraud
committed, he may, after giving the taxable person an opportunity of
being heard, withhold the refund till such time as he may determine.”
14.
A plain reading of the provision discloses that the said
provision is founded on two distinct, cumulative ingredients: first, the
Order giving rise to the refund must be the subject matter of (a) an
appeal, or (b) further proceedings, or (c) any other proceedings under
the Act of 2017 which are pending. Second, the Commissioner must
independently form an opinion, after affording an opportunity of
hearing, that the grant of refund at that stage is likely to adversely
affect the revenue on account of malfeasance or fraud.
15.
Notably, the width of the expression „any other proceedings
under this Act is pending‟ is deliberate. It is not confined to a formally
instituted appeal; it takes within its fold any proceeding, of whatever
nature, arising under the Act of 2017, that has a bearing on the
correctness or finality of the order from which the refund flows. Thus,
Section 54(11) is a self-contained, statutorily engrafted safeguard for
protection of revenue, operating independently of, and not contingent
upon, any separate stay granted by a court or tribunal.
16.
Learned counsel representing the Petitioner has relied upon
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
Mandy Enterprises (Supra) and Alex Tour Travel (Supra), both of
which lay down the salutary principle that the Revenue cannot
withhold a refund sanctioned by the Appellate Authority merely on
the strength of a proposed or contemplated appeal, unaccompanied by
any stay. In Alex Tour & Travel (Supra), this Court held that the mere
decision of the Revenue to file an appeal, without more, cannot place
a valid appellate order in abeyance. The same principle was reiterated
in Mandy Enterprises (Supra) and in Truth Fashion (Supra), wherein
it was clarified that the mere decision to prefer or institute an appeal
would not qualify Section 54(11) of the Act of 2017.
17.
However, these decisions turned on the singular fact that the
Revenue‟s case rested only on the first limb of Section 54(11) of the
Act of 2017, a proposed appeal, with no independent material of
malfeasance or fraud placed before the Court to justify the
Commissioner‟s opinion under the second limb. It is this distinction
having found it the present case, which distinguishes the present case
to that dealt with hereinabove.
18.
Undisputedly, a case concerning the Petitioner was received by
AEW, Delhi from the Okhla Division on 26.03.2024, i.e., nearly three
months prior to the OIA dated 19.06.2024 and nearly six months prior
to the Impugned Order dated 24.09.2024. This is borne out by the
contemporaneous record and is subsequently reflected in the SCN
dated 21.08.2026, which traces the investigation from the receipt of
adverse verification reports, through physical verification of suppliers,
verification of suppliers, verification of transportation, examination of
the goods purportedly exported, and recording of statements under
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
Section 70 of the Act of 2017, culminating in the quantification of
allegedly inadmissible ITC of Rs. 6,53,08,612/-.
19.
The SCN records the following verification reports, each of
which pre-dates or coincides with the passing of the Impugned Order:
“5.1 A letter dated 24.12.2024 was received from the State Tax Office.
Kanpur (RUD-1), wherein it was informed that M/s Kanpur Mobiles
(GSTIN: 09AARFK|496PIZA), appearing at Serial No. I of the abovementioned Table, was found to be a bogus/non-genuine entity. As per
the said communication, the said entity was found to be engaged in
availing and passing on fraudulent and inadmissible Input Tax Credit
(ITC) without actual receipt/supply of goods. The said information
indicates that the transactions reported by the Noticee with the said
supplier require detailed verification.
5.3 M/s Ziavlo India Private Limited (GSTIN: 07AACCZ07+2RIZT).
appearing at Serial No. 12 of the above table and falling under the
jurisdiction of CGST Delhi South Commissionerate. was found to be
non-existent during the physical verification conducted at its
registered principal place of business situated at Plot No. 133, Shop
No. 3, Greater Kailash-l, Lala Lajpat Rai Marg. Pinky Beauty Salon,
Zamrudpur. Delhi-110048. During the visit. the owner of the premises
was enquired about the said firm. and he stated that the premises had
never been rented or otherwise provided to M/s Ziavlo India Private
Limited. He further informed that officers of DGGI, Surat Zonal Unit.
had also visited the said premises for verification of the companies.
The premises owner also provided a copy of the Panchnaina dated
15.07.2023 prepared by the DGGI officers in this regard (RL'D-3).
Accordingly, a letter dated 15.07.2024 was addressed to the Surat
Zonal Linit, informing them about the statement of the premises owner
and requesting the status of the investigation being conducted by thein
in respect of Mis Ziaslo India Private Limited. In response, the Surat
Zonal Unit informed that the inquiry against Ms Sohan Industry and
10 other entities. including M/s Ziavlo India Private Limited, had been
transferred to DGGI, Hgrs., New Delhi. as the said entities were
being investigated in connection with cases involving a similar modus
operandi relating to fraudulent availment and passing on of Input Tax
Credit (ITC).
5.5 During the processing of the refund claims. the Divisional Office
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
received a Verification Report dated 07.02.2024 from the State GST.
Kanpur (RUD-6), wherein it was reported that M/s Almec Trading
(GSTIN: 09KXJPS6728 |ZS) was found to be non-existent at its
registered Principal Place of Business (POB). The repon further
indicated that the suppliers of M/s Almec Trading had allegedly
obtained GST registration for the purpose of passing on fake bogus
Input Tax Credit (ITC) through circular trading. It was also reported
that such allegedly bogus ITC was further passed on by M/s Almec
Trading to M/s Devi Electronics Pvt. Ltd. and, accordingly. blocking
of the ITC availed by the Noticee was recommended. Further, the
Divisional Office also received a physical verification report from the
State GST Office, Ward-6, Faridabad (East) (RUD-7), wherein it was
reported that M/s Balaji Mobile Hub (GSTIN: 06EFLPM8246C229)
was found non-existent at its registered Principal Place of Business.
These reports raised serious doubts regarding the genuineness of the
supplies and the corresponding ITC passed on to the Noticee.
6.3 From the above investigation and verification, it is observed that
the actual movement of goods corresponding to the supplies reported
by the Noticee could not be established. The vehicle owners whose
vehicles were shown in the relevant e-way bills, in their statements
recorded under Section 70 of the CGST Act 2017, denied having
transported the goods from the concerned suppliers to the Notice.
Some of them also stated that they had no knowledge of the Noticee
or the suppliers mentioned in the e-way bills. Further, some
summonses issued to vehicle owners were returned back. These
facts, taken together, indicate that the vehicles mentioned in the eway bills were not established to have transported the goods.
Accordingly. the genuineness of the reported supplies and the
corresponding availment of ITC by the Noticee is doubtful.
7. Whereas, during the course of investigation. a letter dated
15.05.2025 (RUD-13) was issued to the Noticee requiring it to
furnish relevant documents in support of the exports. including
shipping bills, tax invoices, packing lists, details of IMEl numbers of
the mobile phones exported and purchase invoices corresponding to
the said shipping bills. In response, the Noticee, vide its letter dated
30.05.2025 (RUD-14), furnished details of 3,697 mobile phones,
stated to be iPhones. along with the relevant IMEl numbers. In
order to independently verify the genuineness and supply chain of
the mobile phones claimed to have been exported by the Noticee, the
IMEl details were examined and relevant information was sought
from M/s Apple India Private Limited. In response, M/s Apple India
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
Private Limited provided details in respect of 3.623 mobile phones.
On examination of the information so provided, it was observed that
all the said mobile phones had been sold by Mi Apple India Private
Limited in B2B transactions to nine different companies. Further,
out of the said nine companies. information in respect of seven
companies has been received and examined. The details received
from these companies indicate that M/s Devi Electronics (the
Noticee) does not appear anywhere in the supply chain of the said
mobile phones, which were claimed by the Noticee to have been
purchased and subsequently exported.”
20.
Put summarily, the record establishes that, prior to the passing
of the Impugned Order, (i) six suppliers of the Petitioner were found
non-existent or non-operational at their registered principal places of
business by the jurisdictional GST authorities; (ii) independent
verification of the relevant e-way bills with the concerned transporters
elicited categorical denial of movement of the goods; and (iii) the
manufacturer‟s sales records did not reflect the Petitioner in the supply
chain of the mobile phones stated to have been exported.
21.
Notably, these are not matters that surfaced for the first time in
2026; they already formed part of the investigation which, on the
Petitioner‟s own showing, had commenced with the reference dated
26.03.2024. Thus, the SCN was the culmination of an investigation
already underway when the Impugned Order was passed.
22.
It is also necessary to notice that the Commissioner, while
passing the Impugned Order itself, did not act on a mere
apprehension; he examined, in some detail, the tier-wise (L1, L2 and
L3) supply chain of the Petitioner‟s suppliers and their status on the
GST portal. The relevant findings read as under:
“13.6 Further in respect of M/S ALMEC TRADING (GSTIN:
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
09KXJPS6728DIZS), L-1 supplier verification of M/s Almee Trading
(GSTIN- 09KXJPS6728D1ZS was carried out by Deputy
Commissioner (SIB) SGST, Sector-D, Kanpur wherein vide letter 31e/
RI. 47 ReT 79/Kanpur dated 20.09.2023 has informed that the
Physical verification of the principle place of business 543, Faithful
Ganj Cantt, Kanpur Nagar, Kanpur Nagar, Uttar Pradesh, 208004 of
M/s Almec Trading was conducted en 20.09.2023 and no business
activities was found and also no stock was found in the said premises.
Also the GSTN portal is still reflecting the GST registration status of
M/s Almec Trading as 'Cancelled suo moto? Accordingly, the unit was
found to be non-existent at their registered address.
13.7 Moreover, the other major L1 supplier and 12 level suppliers i.e.
Mis ZIAVLO INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED (07AACCZ0742RIZT), M's
AMULOR TRADEX PRIVATE LIMITED (07AAUCA480B1ZK) & M/s
Swastik International Co (07EGNPA0570A1ZX) are being reflecting
as 'Cancelled suo moto' on the GST portal. Therefore, it can be
inferred that only fake/bogus ITC have been passed to M/s Devi
Electronics Private Limited by their suppliers without actual supply of
goods.
13.9 From the perusal of the above facts, fraud and malfeasance on
the part of the taxpayer is clearly evident as that L1, L2 and I.3
suppliers of the taxpayer were found to be missing during physical
verification. Further, it is evident from the panchnama dated
13.07.2023 and physical verification report dated 08.05.2024 and also
from the testimony of the owner of the premises, that no such firm by
the name of M/s Ziavlo India Private Limited (GSTIN:
07AACCZ0142R1ZT) ever functioned on that premises. Further, all
othe major Ll, L2 and L3 suppliers of the taxpayer ie. M/s ZIAVLO
INDIA PRIFATE LIMITED (07AACCZ0742R1Z1), M/s AMULOR
TRADEX PRIVATE LIMITED (07AAUCA5480B1ZK) & M/s Swastik
International Co (07EGNPA0570AIZX) are being reflecting as
Cancelled suo moto on the GST portal. Further, all these major
suppliers
including
Mis
KANPUR
MOBILES
(GST:
09AARFK1496PIZA), were have been found to be non-functional.
Hence, it cannot be ascertained as to whether any underlying supply
of goods has taken place in terms of Section 7 of CGST Act, 2017.”
23.
Having recorded the above, the Commissioner proceeded to
examine the requirements of Section 16(2) of the Act of 2017,
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
reproducing the provision in extenso, and concluded:
13.10 Whereas, Section 16(2) of the CGST Act, 2017 provides the four
conditions 10 availment of the ITC which are re-produced below:Section 16 (2)
(2). Notwithstanding anything contained in this section, no
registered person shall
be entitled to the credit of any input tax in respect of any supply of
goods or services or both to him unless,—
(a). he is in possession of a tax invoice or debit nate issued by a
supplier registered under this Act, or such other tax paying
documents as may be prescribed:;
(b). he has received the goods or services or both.
Explanation—For the purposes of this clause, it shall be deemed
that the registered person has received the goods where the goods
are delivered by the supplier 1o a recipient or any other person
on the direction of such registered person, whether acting as an
agent or otherwise, before or during movement of goods, either
by way of transfer of documents of title to goods or otherwise;
(c). subject to the provisions of section 41, the tax charged in
respect of such supply has been actually paid to the Government,
cither in cash or through wiilisation of input tax credit admissible
in respect of the said supply; and
(d.) he has furnished the return under section 39:
Provided that where the goods against an invoice are received in
lots or instalments, the registered person shall be entitled to take
credit upon receipt of the last lot or instalment:
Provided further that where a recipient fails to pay to the supplier
of goods or services or both, other than the supplies on which tax
is payable on reverse charge basis, the amount towards the value
of supply along with tax payable thereon within a period of one
hundred and eighty days from the date of issue of invoice by the
supplier, an amount equal to the input tax credit availed by the
recipient shall be added to his output tax liability, along with
interest thereon, in such manner as may be prescribed:
Provided also that the recipient shall be entitled to avail of the
credit of input tax on payment made by him of the amount
towards the value of supply of goods or services or both along
with 1ax payable thereon.
13.11 From the plain reading of the sub-clause (b) of Section 16(2), it
is evident that mere issuance of tax invoice is not sufficient for
availment of ITC, all the conditions as mentioned under Section 16(2)
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
also needs to satisfied by the taxpayer to be eligible for availment of
ITC.
13.12 In the instant case, the taxpayer M/s Devi Electronics Private
Limited has shown purchases from non-existent suppliers. It is on
record that when the enquiry was initiated against some of the
suppliers, the suppliers were either found missing or non-existent.
13.13 Moreover, no proof to substantiate the actual transaction and
physical movement of goods in the form of vehicle number, payment of
freight charges, acknowledgment of taking delivery of goods have
been furnished by the taxpayer. Therefore it clearly manifests that the
said suppliers have taken GST registration only for passing on
fake/bogus ITC to their recipients through circular trading among
themselves.
13.14 The refund claim filed by the taxpayer on the strength of nonexisting, non-functional and non-operational fictitious/fake firms/
companies does not support the genuineness of the supplies and
bonafide of their actions, and granting refund to the taxpayer based
on orders dated 19.06.2024 of the Appellate Authority at this juncture
does not seem to be just and proper in view of the elements of fraud
and malfeasance brought out in detail herein above.
24.
Therefore, the Impugned Order was not founded on a solitary
transaction or an isolated supplier. It proceeded upon a cumulative
examination of the supply chain, including suppliers at the L1, L2 and
L3 levels, several of whom were reflected on the GST portal as
cancelled suo moto, together with physical verification reports, the
panchnama recorded by DGGI, Surat, and the statement of the
premises owner denying any tenancy in favour of the alleged supplier.
These circumstances were relevant to the requirement under Section
16(2)(b) of the Act of 2017, that the recipient must have actually
received the goods or services. Thus, the Commissioner upon finding
that the requirements hereinabove were not met, rightly passed the
Impugned Order.
Examination of the Petitioner’s contentions
25.
Turning to the specific contentions urged on behalf of the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
Petitioner, it was argued that on the date of the Impugned Order, no
appeal against the OIA or the Impugned Order was pending before the
GSTAT, the appeal having been filed only on 10.04.2026, and that
mere contemplation of an appeal could not satisfy the first limb of
Section 54(11). The contention, even if accepted, does not conclude
the matter, since the Impugned Order was not founded upon the first
limb alone.
26.
The second limb of Section 54(11), namely, the pendency of
any other proceedings coupled with the Commissioner‟s opinion of
fraud or malfeasance, was invoked on the basis of the AEW
investigation which had commenced by 26.03.2024. Thus, even in the
absence of a pending appeal on 24.09.2024, an investigation
concerning
the
Petitioner
was
admittedly
underway.
The
Commissioner formed his opinion in the context of invoices allegedly
issued by non-existent suppliers, without corresponding movement or
receipt of goods, and the consequent availment of ITC for payment of
IGST on the exports for which refund was claimed.
27.
The Petitioner next contended that the SCN dated 21.08.2026
could not constitute a pending proceeding on 24.09.2024, as it had not
then been issued. The contention overlooks the distinction between the
pendency of an investigation and the subsequent issuance of an SCN.
The material relied upon by the Commissioner shows that the
investigation was already in progress when the Impugned Order was
passed. The SCN subsequently crystallised the allegations arising
from that investigation. Paragraph No.13.8 of the Impugned Order
itself records that the AEW investigation was “still under process” as
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
on 24.09.2024.
28.
The Petitioner further contended that the Impugned Order,
having been passed by the Commissioner in an administrative
capacity, was not an order of an “Adjudicating Authority” and was
therefore not appealable under Section 107 of the Act of 2017. This
contention does not require extended consideration. Section 54(11)
expressly confers the power to withhold refund upon the
“Commissioner”. The power is distinct from the adjudicatory
mechanism under Sections 73 and 74 of the Act of 2017 and the
appellate remedy under Section 107 of the Act of 2017. The absence
of an appeal under Section 107 does not exclude judicial review under
Article 226 of the Constitution.
29.
At this stage, it must be highlighted that it is an admitted
position that an appeal against the Impugned Order already stands
filed before the GSTAT. As such, this Court does not consider it
appropriate or necessary, in writ jurisdiction, to adjudicate upon
disputed questions concerning the genuineness of the suppliers, actual
movement of goods, or the correctness of the findings in the
Impugned Order and the SCN.
30.
The Petitioner shall be at liberty to raise all such contentions,
including those concerning Section 54(11) of the Act of 2017, before
the GSTAT, which shall consider them uninfluenced by any
observation made herein.
D.
CONCLUSION:
31.
For the foregoing reasons, the challenge to the Impugned Order
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
cannot be sustained. The material on record discloses that an AntiEvasion investigation was already pending when the Impugned Order
was passed and that the Commissioner had formed the requisite
opinion of fraud or malfeasance on the basis of contemporaneous
material.
32.
Accordingly, the present Petition is dismissed, with liberty to
the Petitioner to agitate all further issues before the GSTAT.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
SHAIL JAIN, J.
OCTOBER 01, 2026
s.godara/hr
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:39:04
W.P.(C) 15557/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review