Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
132521
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY HE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION NO: 40238 OF 2025
Between:
Ms. Bhashapaka Pragna Vardhini, D/o Hari Krishna Bhashapaka, Aged - 24 Yrs,
Occ - Student, F/o. H.No. 5-11-48, Flat No. 204, Venkateshwara Apartments
Shantinagar, Nalgonda District.
...PETITIONER
AND
The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary to Govt Higher
Education Department, Dr.BR Ambedkar Telangana
Secretariat,
Hyderabad,Telangana 500 002
2. The Telangana State Council of Higher Education, Mahavir Marg, Hyderabad
500 028. Represented by its Secretary
3. The Commissioner of Technical Education, Telangana State, Nampally'
Hyderabad 500 028.
4. fhe Mahindra University, Bahadurpally, Jeedimetla Hyderabad 500 043 Rep.
by its Chairman and Vice Chancellor.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction, more particularly a Writ of
Mandamus, declaring the action of the 4th Respondent in withholding the
petitioners original educational certificates as illegal, arbitrary, unconstitutional,
and violative of the principles of natural iustice, and further declare that
withholding original certificates on the ground of non-payment of fees is violative
of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of lndia and consequently direct the
Respondents, particularly Respondent No.4, to release all original educational
certificates and documents, including the Marks Sheet and Degree Certificate,
which are unlawfully withheld.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the ci' :umstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Cot'r may be pleased to
direct the Respondents, particularly Respondent No.4, tr forthwith release the
petitioners original educational certificates, including the Mirr <s Sheet and Degree
Certificate pending disposal of the writ petition.
c o u n s e r f o r th e P e ti ti o'
"'' [;:t rt*=/i.t Hl ['oR.,illoRi o,,,
Counsel for the Respondents No.1to3 : GP FOR HIGHER I: )UCATION
Counsel forthe Respondents No.4:
The Court made the following: ORDER
-.
,.}
HON'BLE MRS, JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
IT PETITI NN 4 2
2 2
DATE D: 09.O1.2026
Between:
Ms. Bhashapaka Pragna Vardhini
Petitioner
And
The State of Telangana and Others
....Respondents
ORDER:
Heard Ms. T.Tejaswini Rathod, learned counsel
representing Sri P.Sri Harsha Reddy, learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner on record, and
learned Assistant Government Pleader for Higher
Education, appearing on behalf of respondent Nos.1 to 3,
2.
The oetitio ner aDo roached the Court seekinq Draver
as under:
"....to issue an appropriate writ order or direction more
particularly a Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of
the 4th Respondent in withholding the petitioners
original educational certificates as illegal, arbitrary
u nconstitutiona I and violative of the principles of natural
justice and further declare that withholding original
certificates on the ground of nonpayment of fees is
violative of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of
India and consequently direct the Respondents
particularly Respondent No.4 to release all original
educational certificates and documents including the
Marks Sheet and Degree Certificate which ; re unlawfully
withheld and to pass. ."
3. The case of
h
n
ln
ir f as ptl the
averments made in the affidavit filed bv t I e petitiorrcLin
suDDort of the Dresen t writ Detition is as urr ler:
The petitioner completed B.Tech. in Como rter Science and
Engineering (CSE) from the 4th Respondent tJ riversity, in the
year 2024, bearrng Roll No. SE20UCSE2442. At the time of the
convocation held on 02.08.2024, the petitioner r as issued only a
Provisional/Passed Out Certificate. Despite enquiries and
repeated requests, the petitioner's original rttrks sheet and
degree certificate had not been issued by the - liversity on the
ground of alleged pending fee dues. The petition( r belongs to the
Scheduled Caste (Madiga) community and, lue to severe
financial constraints, is unable to pay the said rlleged pending
fees. The withholding of the original certificat,: ; has adversely
affected the petitioner's prospects of pursuing h r her studies and
securing employment, both in India and abroad.
It is further the case of the petitioner that : Sgrieved by the
action of the 4th respondent, the petition:- submitted a
representation dated 17.LO.2025 before the lelangana State
Human Rights Commission (TSHRC). The C: nmission, vide
J
proceedings dated 03.11.2025 in HRC No. 6816 of 2025, granted
interim relief in favour of the petitioner by recommending to the
Chairman and Vice-Chancellor of Mahindra University to return
the original educational certificates and to issue the Transfer
Certificate, Study Certificate, and Conduct Certificate within
three days. The Commission further directed their personal
appearance before it on 18.11.2025.
It is further the case of the petitioner that challenging the
said proceedings of the Human Rights Commission, the 4th
respondent filed W.P. No. 33657 of 2025 before this Hon'ble
Court, and by order dated 06.11.2025, this Hon'ble Court
granted a stay of the proceedings of the Human Rights
Commission. Due to the subsisting stay, the 4th respondent has
continued to withhold the petitioner's original certificates,
thereby infringing the petitioner's fundamental rights guaranteed
under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India. Aggrieved
by the same, the petitioner has filed the present writ petition.
4.
PERU ED THE RE CORD
(A)
The
letter
vid e
Lr.N o.O5 oal TGCHE/
Refund of Oriqinals/ 2024, dated 05.08.202 4 issued bv
Telan
n
un it
H'
u
tion
era ba
I
dd resse ,l +,a + he Re aa ts
NTU JNAF
TMW is
fou K ll T ll
r cted here
MGU, S U, PU,
C
T:
"Sir,
Sub:- TGCHE Withholding of Original C€ titicates oF the
Students - Instructions to the Ur versities/
Colleges- Regarding.
Ref :- This offlce Lr. No. TGCHE/Fee Reir bursement
12024, dt.23.O2.2024
While referring to the subject and refer e nce cited that rn
continuation of earlier letter, it has come to he notice of the
wt hhold n
Govern ment that certa in orivate co lleoes
the orioinal certifica es of studen on th J pretext of not
recervrn o fee reimbur sement from the Go\ ,,:rnment.
Withholding of original certificit es will have
significant implications for the students, r specially when
they need to present these documents trl join for higher
education, applying or joining for jc bs and other
purposes.
Further, in terms of UGC (Grievar,r e Redr ssal of
students) Requlations 2018, the colleoes rre bar d f rom
oldinq or refusinq o return anv ( t rcument in the
form o certificates o f deoree, diol ma or !; nv othe r award
or other document deDosited with it bv a tudents for the
ourooses of seekino admission in such ins ;l itution.
am by directiorr request the
Universities to address/ instruct to all ,r'filiated Private
Colleges under its iurisdiction not to ir ! ist payment of
Tuition Fee from the students who are eligible for fee
reimbursement and not to deny t suing original
certificates on the pretext of not receiving fee
reimbursement from the Government. It s not a healthy
practice. Such colleges may be blackliste I and shall not
Therefore, I
6e considered for free reimbursement, nrhich will also
affects affiliation of such colleges.
The Colleges shall be directed to follow the i structions of the
Government scrupulously and failure in tl- i i regard will be
viewed seriously and stringent action will be initiated against
such colleges. "
_.--i
(B) UGC quidelines. dated 23.O4.20O7, in oarticular,
oa raq ra Dh No.2 reads a s under:
"2. The Commission is of the view that the
Institutions/U n iversities, by way of retaining the certificate in
original, force retention of admitted students which limits the
opportunities for the candidates from exercising other optrons of
joining other institutions of their choice. However, it would not
be permissible for institutions and Universities to retain the
Cah,r ol In clifrrli^rr
I a. vtn
lic= te
ark
certificate nd other documen ts in orioinal."
5. In pursuance to the directions of this Court dated
31.12.2025, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner had taken out personal notice to the respondent No.4
herein and filed proof of service of the said notice upon
respondent No.4 vide Memo dated 08.01.2026, duly enclosing
the original postal tracking report evidencing the same, duly
bringing on record the fact that the notice was returned with the
endorsement "refused".
6.
The Dlvision Bench of this Court in its ludgment dated
24.01.2O2O passed in W.P. No.21137 of 2019 in D.vaishnavi vs.
State of Telangana had struck down paragraph No.7 (iii) of
G.O.Ms.No.114, dated 05.07.20!7 i.e., original certificates
.t'
l
submitted by the petitioner/candidate shall not t( be returned to
them, till they complete their course of study :nd appear for
the University examination holding it as un-: )nstitutional. A
similar view was taken by this Court in Mahatrr a Gandhi Law
College, NTR Nagar, Hyderabad v. State of I elangana vide
ludgment dated 09.12.2022 passed in W.P.No.2 Z +17 of 2018. A
Similar view was also taken yrde ludgment of : ris Court dated
29.7O.2024 passed in W.P.No.25559 of 20,1. in Lakshmi
Saranya v. The State of Telangana.
7. A Division Bench of this Court vide ts iudqment,
dated 24.O1.2O20 in W.P.No.21137 ot 2Ot9 dealinq with
withholdino of oriqinal academic qualificatil n certificates
of the students obse ed at oaraqraDh Nos .- 29 and 30 as
under
29. We are not expressing any opinion on the r tht of the 3rd
respon dent -College to recover amounts tow;r ls the entire
course fee or the bond amount of Rs.3 lr:hs from the
petitioner / her parent, but we hold that wi! rholdinq her
oriqinal
academic
oualification cert fi cates, is
imoermissible in law.
30. Therefore, the Writ Petition is allowed; th€ action of the
3rd respon dent-College in not returning the or < inal academic
qualification certificates of the petitioner who h,r discontinued
study of f'1.8.8.S. I year course in the said colk:, s, is declared
as illegal, arbitrary and violative of Article 14 and 300-A of the
Constitution of India; Para no.7(iii) of G.O.MS.No.114, Health,
Medical and Family Welfare (C.1) Department, dt.05.07.2017
rs declared to be ultra vires the powers oF the State
Government under the Telangana Educational Institutions
(Regulation of Admissions and Prohibition of Capitation Fee)
Act, 1983 (Act 5 of 1983); and the 3rd resoondent is
forthwith directed to return the oriqinal academic
oualification certif icates of th e Det tioner to her. No
costs
clearlv observed that
The Division Bench ve
withholdinq the oraqina I academic oualification
certificates of the students is imoermissible in law.
8. The High Court of Madras in K.Palanisamy Vs.
Correspondent, Vidya Vikash Matriculation School and
Others of Madurai Bench in WP (MD) 20726 of 2O19
decided on 17.1O.2019 reported in MANU/TN/6538/2OL9,
held that certificates of students could not be held back by
educational institutions citing financial dues.
9.
In the Judqment of the Hiqh Court of Delhi an Court
on its own Motion Vs. Directorate of Education & Ors. in
WP (C) 6658 of 2019 & CM APPL.30816.O of 2019, dated
11.O7.2019, it was held as under:"8. There are methods of recovering the outstanding school
fees with the school. Even a suit could have been filed
N .2
are t
fth
students. whic h has not been d o n e so far. J o such suit
has been instituted by Respondent School for I 1e recovery
of outstanding fees.
9. In view of these facts. this C ourt is of I he opinion
that the school Leavinq Ce rtificates :annot be
with hel d bv the resoond ents
In S.Muth ukamatchi vs. Th e Direator of Te chnical
Educat ion. Anna Un iversitv in W.P .fMD'l NO.14394 of
20L2, dated 18.12. 2OL2. the M dras tl oh Cour tat
10.
Madurai Bench cateooricallv held that
( ertificates of
studen is her/ his oro Dertv. Colleoe ca nnot c etain the said
certifi
tes at anv rate. Even if the co ll eoe has anv
moneta rv
claim. th e refusal to
handor er the
sa id
certific tes to the stu ents is not th metho 1 bv which the
claim
n be enforced. There is no li enonl .l re certificates
of the s tudents.
11. The Madras High Court in R.Pr:r leep Rai v.
Commissioner, the Directorate of Techni :al Education
reported in 2O19 SCC Online Mad.9385, anr this Court in
Kaluri Shiva Sai Teja vs' The State of Telangana in
W.P.No.293O ot 2022, dated 24.O6.2022 anl D.Vaishnavi
vs. State of Telangana, represented by its Principal
Secretary Health Medical and Family Welf;r e, Hyderabad
in W.P.No.2LL37 ol 2O19, dated 24.OL.2O2( and also the
o
High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Amaravati in Andrha
Pradesh Private Unaided Schools Management Association
v. The State of Andhra Pradesh in W.p.No.96OG of 2O21,
dated 27.LO.2O2L directed the coltege concerned
authorities to return the certificates of the students and
granted liberty to the college to claim fee by availing legal
remedies in similar circumstances.
L2. Based on the Division Bench Judgment of this Court
dated 24.O1.2O2O passed in W.p.No.2ttg7 of 2O19, this
Court had allowed W.P.No.34185 oI 2(J23 vide its order
dated 03.06.2024 granting identical relief as granted in
W.P.No.21137 ot 2019.
13. . This Court opines that UGC by its guidelines (referred to
and extracted above) had directed the Universities, to which the
colleges like the 4th respondent are affiliated, to initiate action
when such instances are brought to their notice and in spite of
the aforesaid guidelines issued by the UGC, no action is being
taken, and on the other hand, students, like the petitioner, are
forced to approach this Court seeking return of originals and only
after orders are passed by this Court, the originals are being
returned to the students, notwithstanding the fact that the
l0
institutions like the respondent No.4 Univesity, )ave any claim
towards fee, the said institutions are reqrt red to initiate
proceedings for recovery of fee dues and r:, nnot resort to
withholding of all certificates of the students in violation of the
UGC guidelines.
14, The learned counsel appearing on tehalf of the
petitioner submits that the subject issue n the present
writ petition is squarely covered by the order of this
Court, dated 27.LL.2O25 passed in W.P. No.32480 of
2025. The learned Assistant Governmen: Pleader for
Higher Education, appearing on behalf of respondent
Nos.1 to 3 do not dispute the said submissi,l n made by the
learned counsel appearing on behalf of the p etitioner.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION:
15. This Court opines that the responden No.4 cannot
withhold the petitioner's original educati() ral certificates
(documents including the Marks Sheet and De:r ree Certificate)
under any pretext. There is no lien on the r:r rtificate of the
students since the certificate of the student is .T s/her property.
This Court opines that the right of students to obtain their
Certificates from one institution to join another ir stitution cannot
l1
be denied by the concerned authorities merely because the
tuition fee is due and if any amount is due from the petitioner
towards such fees, the proper course available to the
respondents is to initiate appropriate proceedings against the
petitioner for recovery before the competent Court and coercive
tactics cannot be adopted by the respondents to make the
petitioner to pay the tuition fee. This Court opines that there is
no justification on the part of the respondent No.4 in withholding
all originals educational certificates and documents, including
Marks Sheet and Degree Certificate of the petitioner for nonpayment of tu ition Fee.
16. A bare perusal of the record indicates that specific
instructions vide 1r.No.0508/TGCHE/Refund of Originals/2024
dated 05.08.2024 had been issued by the Secretary, Telangana
Council of Higher Education, Hyderabad addressed to all the
Registrars of Universitles (referred to and extracted above)
instructing all the affiliated Private Colleges within its jurisdiction
not to insist on payment of tuition fee by the students who are
eligible for the fee reimbursement from the State Government.
Further as per the guidelines of UGC, colleges cannot withhold or
refuse to return any document such as of certificates of degree,
diploma or any other award or other document deposited with it
!
I
by students for the purpose of seeking ac r .rission in such
institution. Therefore duly taking into consider::ion the view of
the various High Courts on the subject : sue in various
Judgments, referred to and extracted above, : )is Court opines
that petitioner is entitled for grant of relief as t rayed for in the
present writ petition.
L7. Takinq into c onsideration:
(a) The aforesaid facts and circunr itances of the
case,
(b) The submissions of the le; rned counset
appearing on behalf of the petitioner, ar d the learned
Assistant Government Pleader for Hill rer Education
appearing on behalf of the respondent Nos. . to 3.
(c) The
specific
instruct ons
vide
Lr.No.OSO8/TGCHE/Refund of Originals/2024 dated
05.04.2024 issued by the Secretary, Telanl ana Council of
Higher Education, Hyderabad addressr: I to al! the
Registrars of Universities (referred to and extracted
above),
(d) The observations made an var (,us Judgments
(referred to and extracted above),
l3
(e) The UGC Guidelines dated 23'O4'2OO7' in
particular, paragraph No.2 (referred to and extracted
above),
The writ petition is disposed of directing the
respondent No,4 to return all the originat educationat
certificates, and documents, including the Marks Sheet
and Degree Certificate of the petitioner, which are in the
custody of the respondent No'4, duly taking into
consideration the observations made in various
ludgments (referred to and extracted above), and the
specific instructions vide Lr.No.O508/TGCHE/Refund of
Originals/2O24 dated 05.O8.2024 issued by the Secretary,
Telangana Council of Higher Education, Hyderabad
addtessed to all the Registrars of Universities (referred to
and extracted above), and also the UGC Guidelines
(referred to and extracted above) forthwith. However,
there shall be no order as to costs.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this Writ
Petition, shall stand closed
SD/. P. PONNA KRISHNA
AS STANT REGISTRAR
/ITRUE COPY//
To,
gher Education De
CTION OFFICER
rtment, Dr.BR
1. The Princ rp al Secretary to Govt Hi Tela ngana State, H yderabad,Telangana
Ambedka rT elangana Secretariat,
500 002
of Higher Education' Mahavir Marg'
2 The Secretary, Telangana State Council
Hyderabad 5O0 028
_-_-.:1:
3- The Commissioner of Technical Education, Telangana I tate, Nampally,
Hyderabad 500 028.
4 The chairman and Vice_chance[or, Mahindra Universi r, Bahadurpafly,
Jeedimetla Hyderabad 500 043.
5. One CC to SRI P.SRt HARSHA REDDY, Advocate. [OI] JCI
l
6 Iwo CCs to GP FOR HtcHER EDUCATTON, High Cour for the State of
l
Telangana. [OUT]
7. Two CD Copies.
BSK
\
HIGH COURT
DATED:0910112026
CC TODAY
o r 1EL4
,(.""
a
o
u-
\
\
.s
s
,lcr !
TO!H *
fr
I
ORDER
WP.No.40238 of 2025
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
\J"
n'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review