Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010904172018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE 3rd DAY OF AUGUST 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
WRIT PETITION NO: 43824 OF 2018
Between:
1. Mrs. Voola Persis, W/o. Kokkirigadda Vijaya Ratnam, aged 39 years,
resident of Door No 25-11-11, Ganesh Nagar, Raj amahendravaram, East
Godavari District.
...Petitioner
AND
1. Adikavi Nannayya University, Rajamahendravaram, East Godavari District,
Represented by its Registrar.
2. The Executive Council, Adikavi Nannayya University, Rajamahendravaram,
East Godavari District.
...Respondents
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased toto issue an appropriate writ order or direction, more particularly one
in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the proceedings issued by the 1st
respondent in AKNU/29th EC/2017/2, dated 01-12-2017 imposing the
punishment of stoppage of five increments with cumulative effect on the
petitioner, as arbitrary, illegal, violative of the CCCA Rules, Principles of
Natural Justice and Fundamental Rights Guaranteed to the petitioner under
the constitution of India and consequently set aside the same and pass
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the operation of the proceedings in AKNU/29th EC/2017/2 dated 0112-2017 issued by the 1st respondent, pending disposal of the above writ
petition, and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2021
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to vacate the interim orders dated 03.12.2018 in I.A.No.1/2018 in
W.P.No. 43824 of 2018, and dismiss the above writ petition and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner: K RATHANGA PANI REDDY
Counsel for the Respondents: GADDE KOTI NAGULU SC For Adikavi
nannaya University
The Court made the following
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
ORDER:
The present Writ Petition came to be filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India seeking the following relief:“… to issue an appropriate writ order or direction more particularly
one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the proceedings
issued by the 1st respondent in AKNU/29th EC/2017/2 dated
01.12.2017 imposing the punishment of stoppage of three
increments with cumulative effect on the petitioner as arbitrary,
illegal, violative of the CCCA Rules, principles of Natural Justice
and Fundamental Rights Guaranteed to the petitioner under the
constitution of India and consequently set aside the same ….”
2.
Brief facts of the case are as follows:
a) The petitioner possesses an MCA degree and has 5 years and 8
months of experience in teaching. While so, the 1st respondent-University
issued a notification dated 27.04.2008 calling for applications from eligible
candidates for various posts, including the post of Associate Professor in
Computer Sciences. As the petitioner possessed the requisite educational and
other qualifications for the said post, she applied for the same, duly enclosing
all the certificates relating to her educational qualifications, teaching
experience, etc. Pursuant to the said notification, her application was initially
scrutinized by a Committee constituted by the Vice-Chancellor of the
respondent-University,
comprising
Professors
of
Andhra
University.
Thereafter, an Internal Selection Committee, constituted by the Vice-
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
Chancellor of the respondent-University along with five other members,
scrutinized the petitioner's application once again and found her eligible.
b) Subsequently, she was called for an interview to be conducted on
19.10.2008. On the said date, the petitioner was interviewed by a duly
constituted Selection Committee. The said Committee, after verifying all the
relevant aspects and being satisfied that the petitioner possessed the requisite
eligibility and was suitable for appointment to the post in question,
unanimously recommended her name for appointment.
c) Pursuant to the said selection, the petitioner was issued an
appointment order dated 24.10.2008 and accordingly joined duty on
01.11.2008. Thereafter, her services were regularized and her probation was
declared
by
the
1st
respondent-University
vide
proceedings
No.ANU/TS/Regularization and Probation/2011, dated 18.06.2011.
d) While the matter stood thus, one Mr. M.Subba Rao submitted a
representation to the University Grants Commission and various other
authorities, alleging that irregular appointments had been made by the
respondent-University pursuant to the notification dated 27.04.2008 and
requesting an enquiry into the said appointments. The said representation was
allegedly engineered by certain disgruntled faculty members of the
respondent-University. Pursuant to the said representation, a Two-Member
Committee was constituted by the A.P. State Council for Higher Education to
enquire into the allegations made against the petitioner's appointment as well
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
as certain other appointments, vide proceedings dated 19.05.2011. The said
Committee, without affording any opportunity whatsoever to the petitioner,
recorded the following findings against her appointment:
“1) The University mentioned in the proceedings dated 24.10.2008
that the said individual was appointed as Associate Professor in
School of Mathematics and Information Science, whereas the
University advertized the said post for the department of Computer
Science under Group-III. It is observed that the University has not
mentioned in the proceedings in which Department the individual
appointed under that school. It is noticed that School of
Mathematics and Information Science has only one Department
i.e., Department of Mathematics and Computing offering M.Sc.
mathematics and computing with five years integrated programme.
2) The service certificate of the individual has not indicated the pay
scale drawn, procedure followed for appointment and ratification of
the appointment by the respective University etc. Hence, the
Committee felt that such service certificate cannot be considered
for the post of an Associate Professor.
3) According to AICTE guidelines, he has to obtain P.Hd. Degree
within seven years from the date of appointment as Associate
Professor. But the University has not mentioned in the same
appointment orders of the individuals. Hence, a suspicion has
arisen whether the individual is appointed under AICTE or not.
4) There is no proven school record to the individual in the areas of
research/publications/books.”
e) It is pertinent to point out that the said Committee did not comprise
any subject experts. Apart from the same, the said Committee recorded the
aforesaid findings without considering the documentary evidence on record
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
and the requisite eligibility criteria. In fact, in response to a communication
sent by the A.P. State Council for Higher Education calling for remarks with
respect to her appointment, the respondent-University categorically stated
that, as per the norms, the petitioner possessed a first-class MCA degree with
five years of teaching experience and that, as per the norms, NET was not a
prerequisite for selection to the post of Associate Professor and that she had
qualified in the Pre-Ph.D. examination and her research work was in progress.
Even the said document was not considered by the Two-Member Committee
before recording the aforesaid findings.
f) Thereafter, the respondent-University constituted a Five-Member
Committee to enquire into the matter. The said Committee recorded the
following findings:
1) The Committee is of the view that if she was appointed through a
properly constituted selection committee and ratified by the affiliating
University, her services as Assistant Professor may be taken into
consideration by condoning NET requirement.
2) On scrutiny of the application and other documents the committee
did not find any evidence in support of properly constituted selection
committee for her appointment as Assistant Professor and its
ratification by the affiliating University.
g) It is submitted that NET was not prescribed as a qualification in the
notification issued by the respondent-University for the post of Associate
Professor. Insistence upon the qualification prescribed for the post of Assistant
Professor is not legally sustainable. Nevertheless, in the year 2003, certain
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
clarifications were issued by the AICTE dated 10.09.2003, one of which
related to the qualification prescribed for appointment to the post of Lecturer
(Assistant Professor), wherein the AICTE clarified that a first-class MCA
degree was sufficient for the post of Lecturer. It is further submitted that the
requirement of ratification of experience, as noted by the Five-Member
Committee, was beyond the scope of the advertisement.
h) Pursuant to the report of the Five-Member Committee, the 1st
respondent-University issued a charge sheet bearing No.AKNU/Legal
Matters/2010-12, dated 16.09.2013, framing the following charge and calling
upon the petitioner to submit her explanation:
“That Mrs. V.Persis, Associate Professor without having NET/SLET as
on the last date of submission of application and without having five
years
teaching
experience
as
Assistant
Professor,
procured
employment as Associate; that the experience certificate produced is
not true, valid and genuine. Thus the public employment obtained
contrary to the qualifications and experience prescribed by the UGC
and also the University in its advertisement is illegal and void.”
i) The petitioner submitted her written explanation on 09.10.2013,
denying the charges. Thereafter, the 1st respondent-University issued
proceedings dated 18.11.2014 appointing a retired Judge of the Hon’ble High
Court as the Enquiry Officer. The petitioner submitted her written submissions
before the Enquiry Officer on 11.04.2015. Pursuant thereto, the Enquiry
Officer conducted an enquiry and held the charge to be proved. Thereafter, a
show-cause notice dated 20.01.2017 was issued, enclosing only an extract of
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
the enquiry report and calling upon the petitioner to submit her explanation.
Subsequently, the impugned proceedings dated 01.12.2017 were issued,
holding the charge against the petitioner to be proved and, taking into
consideration the seriousness of the charge, the length of service and the
observations of the Enquiry Officer, imposing the punishment of stoppage of
three increments with cumulative effect. Aggrieved thereby, the present Writ
Petition has been filed.
3.
When the matter came up for admission on 03.12.2018, this Court
granted an interim order suspending the operation of the impugned
proceedings in AKNU/29th EC/2017/2, dated 01.12.2017 issued by the 1st
respondent, pending disposal of the writ petition.
4.
A counter-affidavit has been filed by the 1st respondent-University,
wherein it is stated as follows:
a) Pursuant to Lr.No.2851/U.E1/A.1/2011.1, dated 05.05.2012, issued
by the Higher Education Department, the A.P. State Council of Higher
Education was requested to enquire into the allegations regarding
irregularities in the recruitment of Professors, Associate Professors and
Assistant Professors in certain departments of the respondent-University and
submit a detailed report. Accordingly, the A.P. State Council of Higher
Education constituted a Two-Member Committee vide Lr.No.APSCHE/UM754/AKNU-Allegations/2012, dated 19.05.2012, to scrutinize the material
available on record, the University's reply and the qualifications prescribed by
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
the UGC and AICTE. The Committee reported that, though the petitioner did
not possess the requisite qualifications prescribed for the post of Associate
Professor, she applied for and secured appointment to the said post. It was
further reported that she did not possess NET/SLET as on the last date of
submission of applications and did not have five years of teaching experience
as an Assistant Professor and that the experience certificate produced by her
was not valid or genuine.
b) It is further stated that, as per the UGC norms, the qualification
prescribed for the post of Associate Professor was a First Class Master's
Degree in Computer Science/Information Technology/Computer Technology
or
a
First
Class
MCA
degree,
with
five
years'
experience
in
teaching/industry/research at the level of Lecturer or equivalent. It is further
stated that, the petitioner did not possess the requisite qualifications and
experience and, therefore, her appointment was contrary to the UGC
Regulations.
c) The report of the Two-Member Committee was placed before the
Executive Council, which, in its meeting held on 14.02.2013, resolved to
constitute a Five-Member Committee to examine the allegations of
irregularities in the recruitment process. The said Committee, after examining
the material available on record and the witnesses, reported that the petitioner
did not possess the qualifications prescribed in the advertisement. It was
further stated that an external scrutiny committee had initially found her
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
ineligible for interview, but a subsequently constituted internal committee
declared her eligible, pursuant to which she was interviewed on 19.10.2008
and recommended for appointment. Accordingly, she was appointed as
Associate Professor on 24.10.2008 and joined duty on 01.11.2008. Her
services were subsequently confirmed on 18.06.2011.
d) Based on the report of the Five-Member Committee, a charge memo
dated 16.09.2013 was issued to the petitioner alleging that she had secured
appointment as Associate Professor without possessing NET/SLET and the
requisite five years' teaching experience as an Assistant Professor and that
the experience certificate produced by her was not valid or genuine. The
petitioner submitted her explanation denying the charge.
e) Thereafter, a retired Judge of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh was
appointed as the Enquiry Officer. After conducting the enquiry, the Enquiry
Officer submitted a report holding the charge to be proved. The enquiry report
was furnished to the petitioner, who submitted her representation dated
03.02.2017. The Executive Council, after considering the enquiry report, the
petitioner's explanation and the other material on record, accepted the findings
of the Enquiry Officer and held the charge to be proved. Taking into
consideration the seriousness of the charge and the length of service of the
petitioner, the Executive Council imposed the punishment of stoppage of three
increments with cumulative effect vide proceedings No.AKNU/29th EC/2017/2,
dated 01.12.2017. It is, therefore, contended that the charge against the
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
petitioner was proved after following due process and that the punishment
imposed upon her is justified.
5.
An additional counter-affidavit has also been filed by the 1st respondent,
wherein it is stated that the certificates furnished by the petitioner were fake.
However, no material has been placed on record in support of the said
allegation, which also appears to be contrary to the stand taken in the
impugned proceedings.
6.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and the learned Standing
Counsel for respondents.
7.
The facts of the case are not in dispute. It is an admitted fact that,
pursuant to the notification issued by the 1st respondent on 27.04.2008 calling
for applications from eligible candidates for various posts, the petitioner also
applied for the post of Associate Professor in Computer Sciences. Pursuant to
the said notification, the petitioner's application was initially scrutinized by a
Committee constituted by the Vice-Chancellor, comprising Professors of
Andhra University. Thereafter, an Internal Committee constituted by the ViceChancellor of the respondent-University along with five other members
scrutinized her application and found her eligible. Subsequently, the petitioner
was called for an interview on 19.10.2008. On the same day, she was
interviewed by a duly constituted Selection Committee. The said Selection
Committee, after considering the relevant aspects and satisfying itself that the
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
petitioner possessed the requisite eligibility and was suitable for appointment
to the post in question, unanimously recommended her candidature.
8.
Thereafter, the petitioner was issued an appointment order dated
24.10.2008 and joined duty on 01.11.2008. Her services were subsequently
regularized and her probation was declared by the 1st respondent vide
proceedings dated 18.06.2011. However, based on a complaint submitted by
one Mr. M.Subba Rao alleging irregularities in the appointments made
pursuant to the notification dated 27.04.2008, the matter was subjected to
further enquiry. The said complaint was made nearly three years after the
appointments were made pursuant to the selection conducted by the duly
constituted Selection Committee and approved by the competent authorities.
Pursuant to the said complaint, the A.P. State Council for Higher Education
constituted a Two-Member Committee to enquire into the allegations vide
proceedings dated 19.05.2011. The said Committee, inter alia, recorded the
following observations:
“1) The University mentioned in the proceedings dated 24.10.2008
that the said individual was appointed as Associate Professor in
School of Mathematics and Information Science, whereas the
University advertized the said post for the department of Computer
Science under Group-III. It is observed that the University has not
mentioned in the proceedings in which Department the individual
appointed under that school. It is noticed that School of
Mathematics and Information Science has only one Department
i.e., Department of Mathematics and Computing offering M.Sc.
mathematics and computing with five years integrated programme.
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
2) The service certificate of the individual has not indicated the pay
scale drawn, procedure followed for appointment and ratification of
the appointment by the respective University etc. Hence, the
Committee felt that such service certificate cannot be considered
for the post of an Associate Professor.
3) According to AICTE guidelines, he has to obtain P.Hd. Degree
within seven years from the date of appointment as Associate
Professor. But the University has not mentioned in the same
appointment orders of the individuals. Hence, a suspicion has
arisen whether the individual is appointed under AICTE or not.
4) There is no proven school record to the individual in the areas of
research/publications/books.”
9.
Thereafter, the respondent-University constituted a Five-Member
Committee to enquire into the matter. The said five men committee recorded
the following findings.
1) The Committee is of the view that if she was appointed through a
properly constituted selection committee and ratified by the affiliating
University, her services as Assistant Professor may be taken into
consideration by condoning NET requirement.
2) On scrutiny of the application and other documents the committee
did not find any evidence in support of properly constituted selection
committee for her appointment as Assistant Professor and its
ratification by the affiliating University.
10.
Based on the said report, the 1st respondent issued a charge memo
dated 16.09.2013. The petitioner submitted a detailed explanation denying the
charge. Subsequently, 1st respondent issued the impugned proceedings dated
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
01.12.2017, imposing the punishment of stoppage of three increments with
cumulative effect.
11.
It is also relevant to notice the observations made by the Enquiry
Officer, namely, Justice A.Gopal Rao, former Judge of the High Court of
Andhra Pradesh, who conducted the enquiry into the charge, observed as
follows:
“In view of the above facts and circumstances, the genuine grievances
of the Teachers, who have rendered loyal and unblemished service
from the inception of the University and in the absence of any evidence
that they procured these employments by illegal means, deserved
consideration.”
12.
In spite of the aforesaid observation of the Enquiry Officer, the 1st
respondent proceeded to hold that the charge framed against the petitioner
was proved and, taking into consideration the seriousness of the charge, the
length of service and the observations of the Enquiry Officer, imposed the
punishment of stoppage of three increments with cumulative effect. However,
the said conclusion does not appear to be consistent with the findings and
observations recorded by the Enquiry Officer.
13.
It is significant to note that it is not the case of the respondents in the
impugned proceedings that the petitioner had produced fake certificates or
had obtained the appointment by making any misrepresentation or by
adopting any illegal means. On the contrary, before issuing the appointment
order, the petitioner's application was scrutinized by a Committee constituted
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
by the Vice-Chancellor, comprising Professors of Andhra University, and
thereafter by an Internal Selection Committee constituted by the ViceChancellor of the respondent-University along with five other members. Both
Committees found the petitioner eligible. Further, the petitioner was
interviewed by a duly constituted Selection Committee. The Selection
Committee, after verifying all the relevant aspects and having satisfied that the
petitioner possessed the requisite eligibility criteria and that she was suitable
for appointment, unanimously recommended her candidature.
14.
Learned counsel for the petitioner, during the course of arguments,
submitted that the departmental enquiry conducted without furnishing the
relevant documents relied upon against the petitioner amounted to violation of
the principles of natural justice and that the consequential punishment
imposed upon the petitioner is therefore liable to be set aside.
15.
Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, this Court is
of the view that the petitioner was appointed pursuant to a selection conducted
by a duly constituted Selection Committee, which consisted of the ViceChancellor, statutory nominees and external subject experts. The Selection
Committee, after considering the petitioner's qualifications, experience,
publications and expertise, unanimously recommended her candidature. Her
appointment was thereafter approved by the competent authority, her services
were regularized and her probation was declared. There is no specific finding
that the petitioner had misrepresented her qualifications, produced any false
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
or fabricated certificates, or obtained the appointment by fraud or any other
illegal means.
16.
In this regard, the Hon’ble High Court of Punjab and Haryana at
Chandigarh, in Varinder Hans vs. Union of India and Ors.,
C.W.P.No.30737 of 2018, dated 31.07.2019, held as follows:
15. Hon'ble Supreme Court in Dr. M.S. Mudhol v. Shri S.D. Halegkar
1993 (3) SCC 591 held that where there was no misrepresentation
by a candidate, and despite his not possessing the qualifications he
had been appointed and had worked for considerable time it would
be iniquitous to disturb him. It was observed as under:
"6. Since we find that it was the default on the part of the
2nd respondent, Director of Education in illegally approving
the appointment of the first respondent in 1981 although
he did not have the requisite academic qualifications as a
result of which the 1st respondent has continued to hold
the said post for the last 12 years now, it would be
inadvisable to disturb him from the said post at this late
stage particularly when he was not at fault when his
selection was made. There is nothing on record to show
that he had at that time projected his qualifications other
than what he possessed. If, therefore, in spite of placing
all his cards before the selection committee, the Selection
Committee for some reason or the other had thought it fit
to choose him for the post and the 2nd respondent had
chosen to acquiesce in the appointment, it would be
iniquitous to make him suffer for the same now. Illegality,
if any, was committed by the Selection Committee and the
2nd respondent. They are alone to be blamed for the
same."
in
VS,J
W.P.No.43824 of 2018
17.
Even in the case on hand, in the absence of any such finding, the
subsequent view that the petitioner did not possess the prescribed
qualification, by itself, cannot establish that she had illegally obtained the
appointment, particularly when her candidature had been duly scrutinized and
recommended by the competent Selection Committee. Further, the Enquiry
Officer himself recorded that, in the absence of any evidence that the teachers
had procured their employment by illegal means, their genuine grievances
deserved consideration. However, the impugned proceedings does not explain
how the charge framed as against the petitioner was held to be proved despite
the aforesaid observation.
18.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the impugned proceedings imposing the punishment of stoppage
of three increments with cumulative effect cannot be sustained.
19.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is allowed and the impugned proceedings
bearing No.AKNU/29th EC/2017/2, dated 01.12.2017, issued by the 1st
respondent, are set aside.
As a sequel, Interlocutory Applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
Dated: 03.08.2026
KGR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review