Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC013802132018
+
W.P.(C) 11685/2018 and CM APPL. 41898/2024
MRS. SAROJ MINZ
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Saurabh Bhargavan, Mr. Nikhil S
Nair and Ms. Chinju Saurabh,
Advocates.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Chiranjiv Kumar, Mr. Mukesh
Sachdeva, Mr. Dipanshu and Mr.
Durgesh Bharti, Advocates for R-1.
Mr. Amit Gaurav Singh and Mr.
Lakshay Meena Advocates for R-3.
Mr. Purushottam Kumar and Mr.
Mukesh Goel, Advocates for R-4 & 5.
Mr. Janender Kr. Chumbak, Advocate
for R-2/ MCD.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
%
1.
ORDER
05.08.2026
The petition arises out of alleged breaches in a property held under a
Government lease. The property has been partitioned inter se between the
branches of the original co-lessees pursuant to a decree of this Court, while
the Government lease continued to subsist in respect of the property as a
whole. The Petitioner maintains that the unauthorised construction and
commercial use complained of are predominantly confined to the portion of
the property falling to the share and possession of the branch claiming
W.P.(C) 11685/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/08/2026 at 11:44:55
through Late Mr. Kunda Mal Sadhwani. The breach notice dated 31st
January, 2018 was addressed to the legal heirs of both original co-lessees,
although the breaches recorded therein principally concerned the portion
occupied by the Kunda Mal branch. The subsequent breach notice dated 28 th
January, 2020 was issued only to the legal heirs of Late Mr. Kunda Mal. The
distinction between the respective possession and enjoyment of the two
branches, on the one hand, and their obligations towards the lessor under the
common lease, on the other, lies at the heart of the present proceedings.
Factual Background
2.
Plot No. D-II/1 AB, Lajpat Nagar-II, New Delhi, admeasuring 300 sq.
yards, was purchased in a public auction by Late Mr. Deep Chand Sadhwani
and Late Mr. Kunda Mal. A lease deed dated 25th September, 1974 was
executed in their favour by the President of India. The Petitioner, who has
since died and is represented by her legal representatives, claimed through
Late Mr. Deep Chand, while Respondents No. 3 to 5 claim through Late Mr.
Kunda Mal.
3.
Two covenants of the lease are material. Clause 1(vi) prohibits,
without the written consent of the Chief Commissioner of Delhi, the
carrying on of any trade or business or the use of the premises for a purpose
other than the residential use contemplated by the lease. Clause 1(vii)
prohibits sub-division of the land or the building, or any part thereof,
without the prior written permission of the lessor. The lease also
contemplates action for breach, including re-entry, upon issuance of notice
requiring the breach to be remedied.
4.
Disputes between the original co-lessees led to the filing of Suit No.
58/1985, titled Sh. Deep Chand v. Sh. Kunda Mal, before this Court. By
W.P.(C) 11685/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/08/2026 at 11:44:55
judgment dated 24th August, 2001, the share of the Plaintiff, Late Mr. Deep
Chand, was declared as 19,787.73/26,300 and that of the Defendant, Late
Mr. Kunda Mal Sadhwani, as 6,512.27/26,300, corresponding broadly to
75.24% and 24.76%, respectively. This Court also passed a decree of
mandatory injunction directing removal of the shop and store shown in red
in the site plan and a prohibitory injunction restraining further construction
or alteration in the suit property and interference with the Plaintiff's
enjoyment of the portion in his possession.
5.
The matter thereafter reached this Court in RFA (OS) No. 10/2004.
During the appeal, the parties settled the mode of partition by adopting
Alternative 4 of the site plan prepared by the Local Commissioner. Under
the arrangement, the heirs of Late Mr. Kunda Mal were to have 24.76% of
the property, measuring 74.08 sq. yards, on the main road, while the
remaining portion was to fall to the share of Late Mr. Deep Chand. A final
decree pursuant to the settlement was drawn on 29th July, 2006.
6.
The present proceedings originated in complaints made by the
Petitioner to the Land & Development Office [“L&DO”] concerning shops
being operated in the portion attributed to the Kunda Mal branch. An
inspection was conducted on 19th June, 2017, following which a breach
notice dated 3rd August, 2017 was issued. The notice recorded, inter alia,
commercial use, unauthorised construction and encroachment in the portion
occupied by persons claiming through Late Mr. Kunda Mal. It also recorded
an unauthorised WC and bathroom in the occupation of Bhagwandas
Sadhwani, son of Late Mr. Deep Chand. The Petitioner’s case is that the
latter structure was removed on 12th August, 2017 and that L&DO was
thereafter informed of the rectification.
W.P.(C) 11685/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/08/2026 at 11:44:55
7.
L&DO inspected the property again on 12 th January, 2018. The notice
dated 31st January, 2018, addressed to the legal heirs of both Late Mr.
Kunda Mal and Late Mr. Deep Chand, recorded commercial use by Vishnu
Garments and Vandna Garments, as well as unauthorised construction and
encroachment. The WC and bathroom earlier recorded in the occupation of
Bhagwandas Sadhwani did not figure in this subsequent notice.
8.
The Petitioner sought, inter alia, directions to the authorities to
remove the unauthorised construction and stop the commercial use, to delete
the names of the legal heirs of Late Mr. Deep Chand from the breach notice
dated 31st January, 2018, and to recover misuse charges or damages, if any,
only from Respondents No. 3 to 5. The grievance was that, although the
breaches recorded in the notice principally related to the portion occupied by
the Kunda Mal branch, the notice also named the legal heirs of Late Mr.
Deep Chand.
9.
The writ petition was initially disposed of on 29 th October, 2018 with
a direction to L&DO to pass appropriate orders on the breach notice dated
31st January, 2018. In LPA No. 718/2018, the Division Bench, by order
dated 31st July, 2019, found that merely directing L&DO to decide the
breach notice was insufficient, having regard to the serious ramifications of
any action contemplated thereunder and its potential adverse effect on the
Appellant’s interest in the property. The Division Bench also noted that the
private Respondents had not been heard before the writ petition was
disposed of and that L&DO’s counter affidavit did not disclose whether the
misuse had ceased or whether any fresh inspection had been conducted. It
accordingly directed that the private Respondents be given an opportunity to
respond and that, if necessary, the parties be heard by L&DO and the
W.P.(C) 11685/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/08/2026 at 11:44:55
position on the ground be determined before a decision was taken on the
breach notice. The order dated 29th October, 2018 was accordingly quashed
and the writ petition was restored.
10.
A further inspection was conducted on 17th January, 2020. The breach
notice dated 28th January, 2020 was addressed to the heirs of Late Mr.
Kunda Mal, namely, Rohit Sadhwani, Rajesh Kumar Sadhwani and Deepak
Sadhwani. It recorded commercial use by Vishnu Garments and Vandana
Food Corner, unauthorised construction in the occupation of Vishnu
Garments and encroachments on government land.
11.
L&DO states in its Counter Affidavit that the notice dated 28 th
January, 2020 was issued pursuant to the fresh inspection and that no
response was received. The record presently before the Court does not
disclose any final order determining the status of the breaches, the effect of
the notice dated 31st January, 2018, or the further action, if any, proposed by
L&DO under the lease.
Contentions
12.
Mr. Saurabh Bhargavan, counsel for the Petitioner, submits that the
notice dated 28th January, 2020 is significant because it was addressed only
to the heirs of Late Mr. Kunda Mal and recorded continuing commercial use
and unauthorised construction in the portion occupied by that branch. It is
urged that the heirs of Late Mr. Deep Chand ought not to remain exposed to
re-entry, misuse charges or other adverse consequences on account of
breaches not attributable to them. Mr. Bhargavan contends that the internal
partition and the respective possession of the two branches require the
breaches and their consequences to be separately attributed.
13.
L&DO, on the other hand, maintains that the property continues to be
W.P.(C) 11685/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/08/2026 at 11:44:55
governed by a single lease and that the internal arrangement between the
successors of the original co-lessees does not create separate leasehold
estates. According to L&DO, the respective portions may have been
demarcated pursuant to the compromise and final decree, but the lease
continues to govern the property as a whole and its successors. L&DO
accordingly disputes the Petitioner’s contention that the breaches or the
liability arising therefrom can be separately attributed on the basis of the
internal partition.
14.
MCD contends that it is not a party to the lease and that the
enforcement of the lease is essentially a matter between the co-lessees and
L&DO. The Petitioner, in response, relies upon the inter-agency framework
governing coordination between L&DO and the local body and alleges that
MCD failed to act on the breach notices.
15.
Respondents No. 3 to 5 deny the alleged breaches and rely, inter alia,
upon the mixed-use character of the area, municipal trade licences, payment
of conversion/misuse and parking charges, property-tax records and the
protection claimed under the Delhi Laws (Special Provisions) enactments.
The record includes a trade licence issued under Section 417 of the Delhi
Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 in respect of Vishnu Garments, as well as
municipal records relating to the commercial activity. The Petitioner, in
response, contends that such municipal permissions or payments do not
constitute the written consent of L&DO required under the lease.
Questions for Determination
16.
The following questions arise for determination:
(i)
What is the effect of the partition decree upon the Government lease?
(ii)
Can this Court direct the removal of one branch of the co-lessees from
W.P.(C) 11685/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/08/2026 at 11:44:55
the breach notice or confine misuse charges or damages to the other branch?
(iii)
Do municipal licences or protection under the Delhi Laws (Special
Provisions) legislation constitute a defence to the alleged breach of the
lease?
(iv)
What directions are now required from L&DO and MCD?
Analysis
17.
A recent Division Bench decision of this Court provides the
governing principles for the first two questions. In Gautam Tahilramani v.
Union of India1, this Court considered, inter alia, whether a decree for
partition of a leasehold property, passed in proceedings inter se between colessees, could result in a legal severance of the tenancy so as to create
independent and separately enforceable leasehold estates vis-à-vis the lessor.
The Court held that a lease granted by the Government is in the nature of a
Government grant, the terms of which are governed primarily by the grant
itself, and that the rights and obligations of the lessee, as also the incidents
of the leasehold estate, must be gathered from the terms of the lease deed.
18.
The Division Bench further held that a partition decree operates only
inter se the parties and cannot enlarge, alter or bind the rights of the lessor,
who was not a party to the proceedings. While such a decree may regulate
possession and enjoyment between co-lessees, it cannot compel the lessor to
recognise separate leasehold estates or independent tenancies in respect of
different portions of the leased property. The lease, as originally granted,
remains a single and indivisible grant, and the co-lessees cannot, by an
arrangement inter se, impose altered obligations upon the lessor.
19.
That principle applies with full force here. The decree dated 29th July,
W.P.(C) 11685/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/08/2026 at 11:44:55
2006 regulates the respective possession and enjoyment of the two branches.
It does not substitute two leases for the lease dated 25 th September, 1974.
The arrangement between the parties may regulate possession; it does not
divide the grant.
20.
The Petitioner’s grievance is understandable. The record after 2017
repeatedly attributes the commercial activity and unauthorised construction
to persons claiming through Late Mr. Kunda Mal. The notice dated 28 th
January, 2020 is addressed only to that branch. These circumstances are
relevant to the factual enquiry and to the manner in which L&DO exercises
its powers. They do not, however, alter the legal position that, vis-à-vis the
lessor, the property continues to be governed by the common lease.
21.
Gautam Tahilramani also considered the question of liability for
misuse charges between co-lessees. The Division Bench observed that such
liability arises from alleged breaches of the lease and would ordinarily
require consideration of the nature of the breach, the identity of the party
responsible for the breach, the period during which the misuse occurred and
the contractual stipulations governing the consequences of such breach. The
Court held that a dispute concerning allocation of such liability between colessees essentially concerns the allocation of liability arising out of alleged
contractual breaches and falls within the realm of private law. Such a dispute
ordinarily requires examination of evidence, determination of factual
responsibility and interpretation of contractual obligations, and is not
ordinarily amenable to adjudication under Article 226.
22.
The prayer to direct L&DO to remove the names of the heirs of Late
Mr. Deep Chand from the notice dated 31st January, 2018 cannot, therefore,
LPA 522/2022 and connected matters, decided on 22 nd May, 2026.
W.P.(C) 11685/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/08/2026 at 11:44:55
be granted as framed. Nor can this Court declare that misuse charges must
be imposed only upon Respondents No. 3 to 5. The latter relief, in particular,
would require this Court to determine the allocation of contractual liability
between the co-lessees on the basis of their respective possession and
responsibility for the alleged breaches. Such an exercise falls outside the
permissible scope of writ jurisdiction.
23.
This does not render the petition without purpose. Article 226 remains
available to require L&DO and MCD to perform their public duties fairly,
within a reasonable time and in accordance with law. Gautam Tahilramani
itself recognises that writ jurisdiction is primarily designed to ensure that
statutory and constitutional authorities act within the bounds of law, while
cautioning that it is not a forum for adjudication of purely private disputes or
enforcement of contractual obligations inter se private parties.
24.
The order dated 31st July, 2019 had already identified what fairness
required in the present case. The authority had to determine the existing
position at the site, hear both branches and then decide the breach notice.
The inspection and notice of January, 2020 completed only part of that
exercise. No reasoned determination followed.
25.
Six years have elapsed since that inspection. A decision today cannot
safely rest upon the physical position recorded in January 2020. Structures
may have changed, commercial activities may have ceased, altered or
expanded, and possession may have passed to other persons. A fresh
inspection is therefore necessary before any final action under the lease.
26.
The partition judgment and decree dated 24th August, 2001 does not
alter this conclusion. The decree directing removal of the shop and store
binds the parties and persons claiming through them according to law. If the
W.P.(C) 11685/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/08/2026 at 11:44:55
decree remains unexecuted, the remedy lies in execution or other
proceedings before the civil court. Article 226 cannot be employed as a
substitute for execution. The decree may nevertheless be taken into
consideration by L&DO and MCD, to the extent relevant to the respective
statutory functions of the two authorities, while determining the legality and
history of the structures.
27.
The municipal record relied upon by the private Respondents answer
a different question. A trade licence permits the licensee to carry on the
specified trade subject to municipal law. Payment of conversion charges,
parking charges or property tax may bear upon municipal regulation or fiscal
liability. None of these documents constitutes the written consent of L&DO
required under the lease for the commercial use complained of or for any
subdivision of the leasehold property.
28.
The private Respondents also rely upon Sushil Kumar Chauhan v.
MCD2. That case concerned a property situated in an unauthorised colony,
where the construction had been booked in September, 2014. On a
consideration of Section 3(2) of the National Capital Territory of Delhi
Laws (Special Provisions) Second (Amendment) Act, 2014, this Court noted
that, in respect of unauthorised colonies, where construction had taken place
up to 1st June, 2014, action against such unauthorised construction had been
kept in abeyance. Taking note of the submission that the construction in that
case had taken place before the cut-off date, the Court found a prima facie
case for protection under the Delhi Laws (Special Provisions) legislation and
directed that no coercive action be taken against the property until the appeal
pending before the Appellate Tribunal, MCD, was heard.
W.P.(C) 11685/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/08/2026 at 11:44:55
29.
The decision does not hold that construction covered by the statutory
protection thereby becomes authorised or regularised. The Court was
concerned with the availability of protection against coercive municipal
action in the facts of that case, and proceeded on a prima facie assessment
that the construction fell within the statutory cut-off. The judgment does not
consider the effect of such statutory protection upon covenants contained in
a Government lease. Whether the present property and the structures in
question fall within the protection contemplated by the Delhi Special Laws
Act is, therefore, a matter to be considered by MCD on the relevant facts
and in accordance with law. Even if municipal action against the
construction is required to remain in abeyance, that circumstance does not,
by itself, amount to the written consent contemplated by the lease or
preclude L&DO from examining whether the terms of the lease have been
breached.
30.
MCD’s submission that it is not a party to the lease does not conclude
the matter. Its powers and obligations arise under the Delhi Municipal
Corporation Act, the applicable building regulations and the planning
regime. As held by the Supreme Court in K. Ramadas Shenoy v. Chief
Officers, Town Municipal Council, Udipi3, a municipal authority cannot act
in disregard of the applicable planning scheme and owes a statutory duty to
ensure that the scheme is not violated by unauthorised construction. The
Municipality acts in aid of the planning scheme and, where the exercise of
building rights is regulated in the interest of the community, it must act
within the powers conferred upon it by law. MCD must, therefore, examine
W.P.(C) 12173/2025, decided on 13th August, 2025.
(1974) 2 SCC 506.
W.P.(C) 11685/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/08/2026 at 11:44:55
the construction and its conformity with the statutory and planning regime
governing it. The fact that L&DO is the lessor does not, by itself, absolve
MCD of its statutory responsibilities or preclude such examination.
31.
Equally, the Court should not direct removal of the construction or
stoppage of the commercial use without allowing the statutory authority to
determine whether the construction is unauthorised, whether any protection
or regularisation provision applies, and what process must precede coercive
action. The prayer seeking removal of the unauthorised construction and
stoppage of commercial use must therefore be answered by directing a
lawful determination, rather than by issuing a demolition order from the writ
court.
32.
The subsequent civil suit, CS(OS) No. 923/2024, concerns disputes
among the heirs of Late Mr. Deep Chand and allegations relating to
possession, transfer and creation of third-party rights. None of those
questions requires decision here. The present order will not affect the rights
or contentions of the parties in that suit.
33.
The petition is accordingly disposed of in the following terms:
a.
L&DO and MCD shall conduct a joint inspection of Plot No. D-II/1
AB, Lajpat Nagar-II, New Delhi within four weeks from today. At least
seven days’ written notice of the inspection shall be furnished to the legal
representatives of the Petitioner, Respondents No. 3 to 5 and any person
found to be in occupation of the relevant portions.
b.
The inspection report shall separately identify each existing
construction, its measurements, the current user, the person found in
occupation, any encroachment beyond the leased land and the municipal or
lease permission, if any, produced at the site. The report shall be
W.P.(C) 11685/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/08/2026 at 11:44:55
accompanied by dated photographs and a site sketch.
c.
Copies of the inspection report shall be supplied to the parties within
seven days. The parties may file their responses and documents within two
weeks thereafter.
d.
L&DO shall afford a hearing to the affected parties and pass a
reasoned order within eight weeks of receiving their responses. The order
shall state whether any breach presently subsists, the status and effect of the
notices dated 31st January, 2018 and 28th January, 2020, and the action, if
any, warranted under the common lease.
e.
While doing so, L&DO shall keep in view that the final decree dated
29th July, 2006 regulates possession and enjoyment between the parties but
does not create separate leasehold estates. Nothing in this order requires
L&DO to apportion liability in a manner contrary to the lease or to recognise
a subdivision of the grant.
f.
MCD shall, on the same material and after hearing the affected
occupants, pass a separate reasoned order under the Delhi Municipal
Corporation Act, the applicable planning and building regulations and the
Delhi Laws (Special Provisions) legislation. If it concludes that coercive
action is required to remain in abeyance, it shall identify the statutory
provision, the construction to which it applies and the period of such
protection.
g.
L&DO shall not effect re-entry solely on the basis of the notice dated
31st January, 2018 until the reasoned order directed above is passed and
eight weeks have elapsed from its communication to the affected parties.
This protection does not restrain MCD from taking action authorised by
municipal law, nor does it prevent either authority from issuing directions
W.P.(C) 11685/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/08/2026 at 11:44:55
necessary to stop fresh construction or a new encroachment.
h.
The prayer to remove the names of the heirs of Late Mr. Deep Chand
from the breach notice and the prayer to confine misuse charges or damages
exclusively to Respondents No. 3 to 5 are declined. The rights of the parties
to seek contribution, indemnity or other inter se relief before the competent
civil forum remain open.
i.
Nothing stated in this order amounts to a finding on the validity of
any transfer, agreement, possession or third-party right forming the subject
matter of CS(OS) No. 923/2024. The civil court shall decide those issues
uninfluenced by the present order.
34.
The present writ petition, along with any pending application(s),
stands disposed of in the above terms.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
AUGUST 5, 2026/ar
W.P.(C) 11685/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/08/2026 at 11:44:55
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review