Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA
WRIT PETITION No.28474 of 2026
(CNR No.HBHC010581442026)
DATE OF ORDER: 30.10.2026
Reserved on : 10.09.2026
Pronounced on :
30.10.2026
Uploaded on : 31.10.2026
Between:
Mrs. Prashanthi Gangireddy.
…Petitioner
AND
The Income Tax Officer,
Ward 9(1), Hyderabad, IT Tower, AC Guards, Masab Tank,
Hyderabad, Telangana – 500 004 and 2 Others.
…Respondents
ORDER: (per Hon’ble the Acting Chief Justice P.Sam Koshy)
Heard Mr. P. Madhavan, learned counsel representing
Mr. Godithi Srihar, learned counsel for the petitioner; and
Mr. Kamasani Sudhakar Reddy, learned Senior Standing Counsel for
Income Tax Department representing the respondents.
2.
The instant is a Writ Petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India filed by the petitioner challenging the order
passed by respondent No.2, dated 31.10.2025, for the assessment year
2020-21 under Section 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short the
‘Act’).
3.
Vide the impugned order; the respondent No.2 reopened the
assessment of the petitioner for the assessment year 2020-21 alleging
that the income of the petitioner has escaped assessment.
4.
The facts of the case are that the petitioner derived income
from tuition fees and had not filed her income tax return for the
assessment year 2020-21. Since her income for the relevant year was
only Rs.4,80,000/- and after availing the rebate under Section 87A of
the Act, her tax liability worked out to “Nil” no return of income was
filed for the said assessment year. That the respondent No.1 without
following the mandatory procedure prescribed under the Act, issued
an Enquiry Letter under Section 148A(a) of the Act on 03.02.2024,
for the financial year 2019-20 relevant to the assessment year 202021, without proper approval of the specified authority as required
under Section 151 of the Act.
That the approval accorded by
respondent No.3 for issuance of the said enquiry letter under Section
148A(a) was not valid, having regard to the requirements of Section
149(1)(b) of the Act.
5.
It was submitted that without following the mandatory
procedure referred to above, notices were issued by respondent No.1
under Section 148A(b) of the Act on 22.02.2024 in respect of the
following:
i.
Purchase of immovable property (Form 60/61) amounting to
Rs.1,00,00,000/-.
ii.
Cash deposits in an account other than a current account
maintained
with
Corporation
Bank
amounting
to
Rs.22,29,000/- and the petitioner being called upon to file her
response along with documentary evidence on or before
21.03.2024.
6.
A detailed reply, together with the supporting documents was
filed by the petitioner on 29.03.2024, wherein it was contended that
the
purchase
value
of
the
immovable
property stated
at
Rs.1,00,00,000/- was incorrect, and the relevant property documents
were annexed in support.
It was submitted that the amount of
Rs.1,00,00,000/- as relied upon by respondent No.1 represented an
imaginary transaction that had never taken place, and that a property
had, in fact, been purchased for Rs.1,31,55,000/- on 30.12.2020
jointly with three other persons, which a transaction pertaining to the
succeeding assessment year, namely the assessment year 2021-22
with the petitioner’s share being only 25% of the total consideration,
working out to Rs.32,88,750/-. It was further explained that the sum
of Rs.22,29,000/- as reflected in the Annexure to the show-cause
notice issued under Section 148A(b) of the Act represented an
advance payment made towards purchase of property for the
succeeding year, gifted to the petitioner by her husband — a fact
stated to have been duly and adequately explained in the reply dated
29.03.2024.
7.
That respondent No.1, without giving due consideration to the
purchase document annexed by the petitioner, evidencing purchase of
the
property
on
30.12.2020
for
a
total
consideration
of
Rs.1,31,55,000/-, proceeded on the erroneous premise that the said
transaction pertained to the assessment year 2020-21, when, in fact,
the transaction fell within the assessment year 2021-22 as has been
highlighted by respondent No.2 in the show cause notice issued under
Section 148A(b) of the Act.
8.
It was submitted that without considering the petitioner’s reply,
respondent No.1 proceeded to pass an order under Section 148A(d) of
the Act on 23.04.2024, with the approval of respondent No.3, thereby
holding that income amounting to Rs.47,29,000/- chargeable to tax
had escaped assessment in the petitioner’s case for the assessment
year 2020-21 — a figure which, it was contended, was, in any event,
well below the threshold of Rs.50,00,000/- prescribed under Section
149(1)(a) of the Act for reopening of assessment within three years,
and was, in addition, factually incorrect, since no such transaction
had, in fact, taken place during the relevant assessment year 2020-21.
It was contended that the petitioner having placed all the relevant
documents on record along with her reply, respondent No.1 ought to
have examined the purchase deed dated 30.12.2020, which pertained
to the succeeding assessment year, before placing the material before
respondent No.3 for approval; the said placement of material, it was
submitted, was itself grossly illegal and invalid, and the consequent
grant of approval for issuance of notice under Section 148 of the Act
was rendered mechanical and devoid of application of mind.
9.
It was further submitted that respondent No.3, before granting
such approval was required to independently examine the material
available on record including the reply filed by the petitioner, and to
determine whether it constituted a fit case for issuance of notice under
Section 148 of the Act. It was also submitted that respondent No.3
having failed to examine the documents furnished by the petitioner,
had thereby committed an incurable illegality, and had respondent
No.3 duly examined the material on record together with the
petitioner’s reply, the approval for issuance of notice under Section
148 would not have been granted and the proceedings would have
been dropped at that very stage.
10.
That, a cash deposit of Rs.22,29,000/-, made in the Corporation
Bank account on various dates was sourced from a gift received from
the petitioner’s husband for the purchase of the immovable property
registered on 30.12.2020, and that respondent No.2 had correctly
identified and assessed the said cash deposits at Rs.22,29,000/-.
11.
It was contended that as per the provisions of Section 149(1) of
the Act, reopening of assessment beyond three years from the end of
the relevant assessment year is impermissible where the income
alleged to have escaped assessment does not exceed Rs.50,00,000/and that, in the present case, the income alleged to have escaped
assessment being only Rs.22,29,000/- reopening of the assessment
ought to have been effected, if at all, on or before 31.03.2024.
12.
It was further submitted that even assuming, without admitting,
the correctness of the averments contained in the order passed by
respondent No.1 under Section 148A(d) of the Act, the quantum
involved being Rs.47,29,000/- remained well below the threshold
limit of Rs.50,00,000/- prescribed under the Act, and that the
reopening of assessment beyond three years was, on this ground,
illegal, invalid, and void ab initio.
13.
That a notice under Section 148 of the Act came to be issued by
respondent No.1 on 24.04.2024 and the said notice having been
issued on the basis of an invalid approval accorded by respondent
No.3, was likewise invalid, illegal, and void ab initio. It was further
contended that the said notice was barred by limitation, having
exceeded the maximum period of three years prescribed under Section
149(1) of the Act, since the income assessed at Rs.47,29,000/- fell
well within the monetary threshold of Rs.50,00,000/- specified
thereunder and in view of the foregoing, and having regard to the
facts as ascertained by respondent No.1 himself, notice issued under
Section 148 of the Act beyond the statutory period of three years
prescribed under Section 149 of the Act, rendered the assessment
order passed pursuant thereto null and void.
14.
It was accordingly submitted that the impugned assessment
order passed by respondent No.2 under Section 147 read with Section
144B of the Act, for the assessment year 2020-21, along with the
penalty order passed under Section 271AAC(1) of the Act, were
under challenge in the present Writ Petition invoking the jurisdiction
of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, for a Writ
of Certiorari calling for the records pertaining to the impugned
assessment order dated 31.10.2025 and all consequential action
flowing therefrom, and for quashing the same on, among others, the
grounds set out in the writ petition.
15.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner argued that the
impugned assessment order passed by respondent No.2 under Section
147 read with Section 144B of the Act, on 31.10.2025, is against
Law, Cannons of Revenue Jurisprudence, erroneous, illegal and is
liable to be quashed on the ground that the respondent No.1 without
following the mandatory procedures issued an enquiry letter under
Section 148A(a) of the Act, on 03.02.2024 for the financial year
2019-20, i.e. assessment year 2020-21, without proper approval of the
specified authority as per the provision of Section 151 of the Act.
16.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner further argued that
the impugned assessment order passed by the respondent No.2 under
Section 147 read with Section 144B of the Act, on 31.10.2025 is
liable to be quashed on the ground that it was passed based on the
invalid notice under Section 148 which was ought to have been issued
with prior approval of the Principal Chief Commissioner of Income
Tax, wherein the time limit of 3 years had already expired on
31.03.2024. Since in the instant case, the approval had been accorded
by respondent No.3 who is not the competent specified authority
under Section 151 of the Act, all consequential actions emanating
from issuance of notice under Section 148 of the Act, are all illegal,
invalid and without jurisdiction.
17.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner also contended that
the impugned assessment order passed by respondent No.2 is liable to
be quashed on the ground that granting of approval for issuance of
notice under Section 148 in a mechanical fashion without any
application of mind by respondent No.3 in view of the fact that before
granting approval ought to have decided on the basis of the material
available on record including the reply of the assessee whether or not
it is a fit case to issue a notice under Section 148 of the Act. Absence
of the same on the part of respondent No.3 has resulted in improper
and illegal approval and therefore liable to quashed.
18.
Au contraire, the learned Senior Standing Counsel for Income
Tax Department relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court which upheld the decision of the Delhi High Court in the case
of BKR Capital (P) Ltd. vs. CIT1 wherein it was held that the
2026 SCC OnLine SC 1609
Assessing Officer acted within jurisdiction and that the period
consumed in granting opportunity under Section 148A(b) stands
excluded as per the fifth proviso to section 149 of the Act.
19.
Learned Senior Standing Counsel for Income Tax Department
further relied on the judgment of the Delhi High Court in the case of
Sunil Bhalla vs. CIT2 wherein it was held against the assessee that
the notice issued under Section 148A(d) of the Act stood valid as it
was within the four corners of the time limit envisaged under the fifth
and sixth proviso of Section 149 of the Act.
20.
Having heard the contentions put forth on either side and on
perusal of records, the question that falls for our consideration in this
case is “whether in a case where the income alleged to have escaped
assessment, as quantified by the Assessing Officer himself in the
order passed under Section 148A(d) of the Act falls below the
threshold of Rs.50,00,000/- prescribed under Section 149(1)(b) of the
Act, the notice under Section 148 of the Act, issued beyond the
ordinary three year period prescribed under Section 149(1)(a), can be
sustained by recourse to the exclusion of time available under the fifth
2026 SCC OnLine Del 4379
and sixth provisos to Section 149(1) of the Act, and where the
sanctioning authority neither examined the quantum involved nor
recorded any application of mind to the availability of such
exclusion?”
21.
It would be trite at this juncture to refer to the fifth and sixth
proviso of Section 149 of the Act, which for ready reference are
reproduced hereunder:
“Time limit for notice.
149. (1) No notice under section 148 shall be issued for the relevant
assessment year,
……
Provided also that for the purposes of computing the period of
limitation as per this section, the time or extended time allowed to
the assessee, as per show-cause notice issued under clause (b) of
section 148A or the period during which the proceeding under
section 148A is stayed by an order or injunction of any court, shall
be excluded:
Provided also that where immediately after the exclusion of the
period referred to in the immediately preceding proviso, the period
of limitation available to the Assessing Officer for passing an order
under clause (d) of section 148A30[does not exceed seven days], such
remaining period shall be extended to seven days and the period of
limitation under this sub-section shall be deemed to be extended
accordingly.
Explanation.—For the purposes of clause (b) of this sub-section,
"asset" shall include immovable property, being land or building or
both, shares and securities, loans and advances, deposits in bank
account.
[(1A) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), where
the income chargeable to tax represented in the form of an asset or
expenditure in relation to an event or occasion of the value referred
to in clause (b) of sub-section (1), has escaped the assessment and
the investment in such asset or expenditure in relation to such event
or occasion has been made or incurred, in more than one previous
years relevant to the assessment years within the period referred to
in clause (b) of sub-section (1), a notice under section 148 shall be
issued for every such assessment year for assessment, reassessment
or recomputation, as the case may be.]
(2) The provisions of sub-section (1) as to the issue of notice shall be
subject to the provisions of section 151.]”
A plain reading of Section 149(1) of the Act makes it clear that
Section 149(1) draws a clear and deliberate distinction between two
classes of cases. Clause (a) thereof bars issuance of a notice under
Section 148 once three years have elapsed from the end of the
relevant assessment year, save where the case falls within clause (b).
Clause (b) in turn, extends this outer limit to ten years but only where
the Assessing Officer is in possession of books of account,
documents, or evidence revealing that income chargeable to tax,
represented in the form of an asset, an item of expenditure, or an entry
in the books of account, has escaped assessment “to the extent of or is
likely to amount to fifty lakh rupees or more”.
22.
Moreover, the aforesaid two provisos disclose that they operate
to exclude from the computation of the period of limitation, two
specific and narrowly defined categories of time: first, the time or
extended time allowed to the assessee under a show cause notice
issued under Section 148A(b); and second, any period during which
the proceedings under Section 148A stood stayed by an order or
injunction of a Court. The sixth proviso operates only as a corollary
to the fifth proviso, ensuring that where, after excluding such time, the
residual period available to the Assessing Officer to pass an order
under Section 148A(d) does not exceed seven days, that residual
period is deemed extended to seven days. Neither proviso purports to
enlarge the substantive threshold prescribed under clause (b) of
Section 149(1), nor do they operate to convert a case that never
crossed the Rs.50,00,000/- threshold into one governed by the
extended period, but their function is confined to computing time, not
to expanding jurisdiction.
23.
The threshold of Rs.50,00,000/- is not a matter of procedural
detail, but it is the very jurisdictional gateway through which the
extended period of limitation becomes available at all. In the absence
of such satisfaction of that threshold, a case remains, for all purposes
of Section 149 governed by the ordinary three year period under
clause (a), and the machinery of clause (b) together with whatever
exclusions the provisos to the sub-section may afford in aid of that
machinery simply does not come into play.
24.
On the facts before us, this threshold question answers itself
from the Revenue’s own record. Respondent No.1 in the order dated
23.04.2024 passed under Section 148A(d) of the Act itself quantified
the income alleged to have escaped assessment at Rs.47,29,000/-, a
figure admittedly and demonstrably below the statutory threshold of
Rs.50,00,000/-.
This is not a matter of the petitioner’s own
computation or a disputed figure requiring adjudication, but it is the
Revenue’s own finding recorded in its own order. Once that figure is
taken at face value and there is no basis on this record to take it
otherwise, the case could never have fallen within clause (b) of
Section 149(1), and the only period available to the Revenue for
issuance of a notice under Section 148 was the ordinary three year
period under clause (a) which is expiring on 31.03.2024, being three
years from the end of the assessment year 2020-21.
25.
On the facts of the present case, it is not disputed and indeed
cannot be disputed that no order or injunction of any Court stayed the
proceedings under Section 148A at any point in time. The second
limb of the fifth proviso, therefore, has no application whatsoever.
Even granting the Revenue the fullest benefit of this exclusion
computed from the outer limit of 31.03.2024, the extended date could
not, on any view of the matter, travel far beyond the closing days of
April, 2024 and even so this exercise is one that presupposes a case
otherwise falling within clause (b), a premise that as we have already
found does not exist here at all since the escaped income being
admittedly below Rs.50,00,000/-. The provisos cannot be pressed into
service to rescue a notice that was never within the extended period to
begin with, merely because a fortuitous handful of days might
otherwise be salvaged by their arithmetic.
26.
What weighs still more heavily against the Revenue is that
neither the order dated 23.04.2024 under Section 148A(d), nor the
approval accorded by respondent No.3 under Section 151 of the Act,
record any application of mind whatsoever to the fifth or sixth
provisos, to the exclusion of any period, or to the question of whether
the quantum found Rs.47,29,000/- was at all capable of sustaining
action beyond the ordinary three year period.
27.
The decisions relied upon by the learned Senior Standing
Counsel for Income Tax Department are distinguishable on this very
ground.
In each of those cases, the record disclosed a
contemporaneous
and
reasoned
invocation
of
the
extended
computation by the authority itself, at the time the impugned action
was taken and not a post-facto justification constructed for the first
time before the Writ Court to salvage an admittedly delayed notice.
28.
It is also a well settled principle of administrative law that the
validity of an order must be judged by the reasons recorded therein
and cannot be supplemented or improved upon by reasons found for
the first time in a counter affidavit or urged for the first time at the
Bar. Respondent No.3 in granting approval under Section 151 of the
Act was obliged to independently satisfy itself on the material placed
before it, including the petitioner’s detailed reply dated 29.03.2024
with its supporting documents, both as to the correctness of the
quantum alleged to have escaped assessment and as to whether the
notice proposed to be issued fell within the time permitted by law.
The material on record discloses no such application of mind.
However, what it discloses instead is a mechanical endorsement of a
proposal that was, on its own admitted facts, both factually erroneous
(the property purchase of Rs.1,31,55,000/- pertaining to the
succeeding assessment year 2021-22, and not to the year under
consideration) and legally unsustainable on the ground of limitation.
29.
Therefore, we are unable to accept the Revenue’s contention
that the fifth and sixth provisos to Section 149(1) can be invoked for
the first time before this Court to cure what was on the face of the
Revenue’s own record a notice issued beyond the period permitted
under Section 149(1)(a) of the Act, in a case that never satisfied the
threshold prescribed under clause (b) thereof. A sanctioning authority
cannot mechanically accord approval without examining whether the
case falls within the ordinary or the extended period of limitation and
then seek shelter after the event behind provisos that were never
considered, never invoked, and never applied at the time the impugned
action was taken. Such an approach reduces the safeguard of Section
151 which is intended to interpose an independent, informed check
upon the reopening of a concluded or time-barred assessment to an
empty formality, and this Court would be failing in its duty if it
permits such a mechanical exercise of power to stand merely because
a technical argument on limitation is later found capable of being
mounted in defence of it.
30.
In view of the foregoing reasons, we hold that the notice dated
24.04.2024 issued under Section 148 of the Act, and the approval
accorded by respondent No.3, under Section 151 of the Act, are barred
by limitation under Section 149(1)(a) of the Act since it was not able
to satisfy the threshold prescribed under Section 149(1)(b), and the
benefit of the fifth and sixth provisos to Section 149(1) being
unavailable to the Revenue in the facts and circumstances discussed
above.
The consequent order dated 23.04.2024 under Section
148A(d) of the Act, the notice dated 24.04.2024 under Section 148 of
the Act, the impugned assessment order dated 31.10.2025 passed
under Section 147 read with Section 144B of the Act, and the penalty
order under Section 271AAC(1) of the Act, are all rendered void ab
initio and unsustainable in law. The instant Writ Petition accordingly
stands allowed and the order dated 23.04.2024 passed under Section
148A(d) of the Act, the notice dated 24.04.2024 issued under Section
148 of the Act, the assessment order dated 31.10.2025 passed under
Section 147 read with Section 144B of the Act, and the penalty order
passed under Section 271AAC(1) of the Act for the assessment year
2020-21, are hereby set aside and quashed.
31.
The question of law framed in the instant case is therefore
answered in favour of the petitioner and against the Revenue.
32.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending if any, shall stand
closed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
____________________
P. SAM KOSHY, ACJ
_______________________________
NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA, J
Date: 30.10.2026
GSD
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review