Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision: 14.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010425772026
+
W.P.(C) 13127/2026 & CM APPL. 61048/2026
MRS. MARIAM ALI
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Bharat Gupta, Ms. Sansriti
Trivedi and Mr. Amit Gupta,
Advs.
versus
GOVT. NCT OF DELHI AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Nitika Bhutani, Panel
Counsel for GNCTD.
R-7 in person.
CORAM:
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE SWARANA KANTA SHARMA
JUDGMENT
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J. (Oral)
1.
The present petition has been filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India seeking grant of following reliefs:
“a) appoint the Petitioner as the permanent guardian of Ms.
Rubina Sultan’s person and property, including the
assets/properties mentioned in Annexure A;
b) direct Respondent No.7 to hand over to the Petitioner
physical custody of Ms. Rubina Sultan and all her original
documentation, including her Aadhaar Card, UDID Card and
bank and other financial documents;
c) direct Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 to ensure that Respondent
No.7 hands over to the Petitioner physical custody of Ms.
Rubina Sultan and all her original documentation…”
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:51:46
W.P.(C) 13127/2026
2.
The case set out by the petitioner is that she and respondent
nos. 3 to 7 are the surviving children of late Nawab Sultan Yar Khan.
Respondent no. 10, aged about 70 years, is stated to have been
disabled since birth. Her disability certificate dated 21.03.2024,
issued by respondent no. 8 [Atal Bihari Vajpayee Institute of Medical
Sciences and Dr. Ram Manohar Lohia Hospital], assesses her as
having 50% intellectual disability and 50% locomotor disability, with
an overall impairment of 72%. The assessment dated 27.06.2022
records her mental age as that of a child of nine years. It is stated that,
after the demise of her eldest brother, Mr. Sikander Yar Khan, in July
2011, who had been appointed as her guardian ad litem by order
dated 30.01.2003 in Suit No. 2080/2001, respondent no. 7 removed
her at night from the ancestral premises at 5182, Ballimaran, Delhi,
and took her to his residence at Ghaziabad, where she continues to
reside.
3.
By way of C.M.A. No. 61048/2026, the petitioner seeks
interim custody of respondent no. 10, release of the balance amount
of Rs. 2.19 lakhs lying in Post Office Savings Account No.
1085384924, restraint against dealing with her assets and against
respondent no. 7 holding himself out as her guardian, correction of
her disability certificate, and production of the statements of Bank of
India Account No. 601210110008826 for the preceding seven years.
4.
At the outset, when the matter was taken up, learned counsel
for the respondents raised a preliminary objection regarding the
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:51:46
W.P.(C) 13127/2026
territorial jurisdiction of this Court to entertain the present petition.
5.
The learned counsel for the petitioner argued that this Court
has territorial jurisdiction as the movable and immovable assets of
respondent no. 10, which form the subject matter of the present
petition, are situated at Ballimaran, Delhi. It was submitted that the
permanent address of respondent no. 7, as reflected in her Aadhaar
card, is 5182, Ballimaran, Delhi, and that her presence at Ghaziabad
as of now is neither voluntary nor lawful, since she was taken there
by respondent no. 7 in July 2011 without the permission of any court.
It was contended that respondent no. 7 cannot rely upon his own
alleged wrong to contend that this Court lacks territorial jurisdiction.
It was further submitted that the disability certificate dated
21.03.2024 was issued by respondent no. 8 at New Delhi pursuant to
the directions of respondent no. 2 and this Court in CM(M) No.
1552/2019 and Cont. Cas.(C) No. 1103/2019. Respondent nos. 1, 2, 8
and 9 are also situated in Delhi and the reliefs sought against them
are enforceable within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court. The
learned counsel further contended that various proceedings
concerning respondent no. 10, including Suit No. 2080/2001,
RC.REV. No. 213/2018 and CM(M) No. 75/2020, have been
entertained by this Court and that this Court is, therefore, closely
connected with the dispute. It was lastly submitted that the
jurisdiction exercised by the Court as parens patriae is a
constitutional jurisdiction and ought not to be defeated merely
because respondent no. 10 is presently residing outside the territorial
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:51:46
W.P.(C) 13127/2026
jurisdiction of this Court, particularly when her presence at
Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh itself is under challenge.
6.
Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent
argued that respondent no. 10 has been residing at Ghaziabad, Uttar
Pradesh, continuously since July 2011, i.e. for more than fifteen
years, and that the memo of parties itself records her present address
as Ghaziabad. It was contended that the guardianship sought by the
petitioner is, in substance, guardianship of the person of respondent
no. 10 and that the reliefs sought in this regard, including interim
custody, medical care, her removal from the present household and
appointment of a caregiver, would operate upon a person who resides
beyond the territorial jurisdiction of this Court. It was further
submitted that the reliefs relating to her estate are only consequential
to the relief of appointment of a guardian and cannot, by themselves,
confer territorial jurisdiction upon this Court. The learned counsel
further submitted that no order passed by respondent nos. 1, 2, 8 or 9
has been challenged in the present petition and that their presence in
Delhi does not give rise to any part of the cause of action. It was also
submitted that the location of the assets and the address mentioned in
the Aadhaar card are not material for determining territorial
jurisdiction, as neither forms an integral part of the cause of action. It
was contended that the appropriate forum would be the District Court
or the Local Level Committee at Ghaziabad and, insofar as the writ
jurisdiction is concerned, the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad,
within whose territorial jurisdiction respondent no. 10 has been
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:51:46
W.P.(C) 13127/2026
residing. It was accordingly submitted that no part of the cause of
action has arisen within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court and
that, in any event, this Court is not the forum conveniens.
7.
This Court has heard arguments addressed on behalf of the
petitioner as well as the respondents, and has perused the case file.
8.
The question which arises for consideration is whether, in view
of the reliefs sought by the petitioner, including her appointment as
guardian of respondent no. 10, her custody and care, and the
consequential directions concerning respondent no. 10 and her estate,
this Court has the territorial jurisdiction to entertain the present
petition.
9.
Article 226(1) of the Constitution of India empowers every
High Court, within its territorial jurisdiction, to issue appropriate
directions, orders or writs to any person or authority, including the
Government, for enforcement of fundamental rights and for any other
purpose. Article 226(2), on the other hand, permits a High Court to
exercise jurisdiction where the cause of action, wholly or in part,
arises within its territorial jurisdiction. The expression “cause of
action” refers to the bundle of material facts which the petitioner is
required to plead and establish in order to obtain the relief claimed.
The mere existence of a fact having some connection with the dispute
is not sufficient. The fact relied upon must have a nexus with the
subject matter of the challenge and must be material, essential or
integral to the relief sought. This position has been reiterated by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Goa v. Summit Online Trade
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:51:46
W.P.(C) 13127/2026
Solutions (P) Ltd.: (2023) 7 SCC 791, as well as in Alchemist Ltd. v.
State Bank of Sikkim: (2007) 11 SCC 335 and Oil and Natural Gas
Commission v. Utpal Kumar Basu: (1994) 4 SCC 711.
10.
The nature of the reliefs sought in the present petition has,
therefore, to be examined first. The principal relief sought by the
petitioner is her appointment as guardian of respondent no. 10, both
in respect of her person and her property. The petitioner further seeks
a direction to respondent no. 7 to hand over to her the physical
custody of Ms. Rubina Sultan along with all her original documents.
The petitioner also seeks a direction to respondent nos. 1 and 2, i.e.
GNCTD and the State Commissioner for Persons with Disabilities,
Delhi, to ensure that respondent no. 7 hands over physical custody of
respondent no. 10 to the petitioner.
11.
It is not in dispute that the petitioner herein is not a resident of
Delhi, but of Noida, Uttar Pradesh. It is further not in dispute that the
petitioner is seeking her appointment as guardian of respondent no.
10, who has been residing at Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh, since 201112, i.e. for more than fifteen years. The memo of parties itself records
her present residence at Ghaziabad. The fact that the petitioner
alleges that respondent no. 10 was taken to Ghaziabad by respondent
no. 7 in circumstances which, according to her, were unlawful, does
not alter the fact that respondent no. 10 has been continuously
residing there for all these years. Moreover, respondent no. 7, the
brother of the petitioner, against whom the reliefs have been sought,
is also a resident of Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh.
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:51:46
W.P.(C) 13127/2026
12.
Therefore, neither the party seeking the relief, i.e. the
petitioner, nor the party against whom the relief is sought, i.e.
respondent no. 7, nor the person in respect of whom the relief is
sought, i.e. respondent no. 10, is a resident of Delhi.
13.
In the opinion of this Court, grant of the relief of appointment
of the petitioner as guardian of the person and property of respondent
no. 10, as sought in the present petition, would necessarily require an
examination of the circumstances in which respondent no. 10 is
presently residing, the nature of care and support being provided to
her, her medical condition and requirements, her living arrangements
and, to the extent possible, her wishes and preferences. Any enquiry
into these matters would necessarily have to be undertaken at the
place where respondent no. 10 is presently residing, i.e. Ghaziabad,
Uttar Pradesh. For this purpose, if any medical examination or
assessment of her disability is required, the same would necessarily
have to be undertaken by the appropriate hospital/medical board at
Ghaziabad, where respondent no. 10 resides, rather than by the
authorities in Delhi.
14.
Insofar as the argument of the petitioner that respondent no. 10
originally resided at Ballimaran, Delhi, and that certain movable and
immovable assets belonging to her are situated in Delhi is concerned,
the same is unmerited. These facts, by themselves, cannot confer
territorial jurisdiction upon this Court. This Court is conscious of the
fact that the present writ petition is not for determination of title to, or
management of, any particular property situated in Delhi. The relief
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:51:46
W.P.(C) 13127/2026
in respect of the estate of respondent no. 10 is sought as a
consequence of the prayer for appointment of the petitioner as her
guardian. The location of the assets, therefore, cannot be treated as an
integral part of the cause of action for the principal reliefs sought in
the petition, particularly when none of the parties directly concerned
with the principal reliefs is situated within the territorial jurisdiction
of this Court.
15.
The same principle would apply to the reliance placed upon the
disability certificate dated 21.03.2024 issued by respondent no. 8.
The petitioner has, inter alia, in CM APPL 61048/2026, sought
correction of the said certificate on the ground that the assessment
recorded therein is incorrect. However, the issuance of the said
certificate in Delhi is, at best, an antecedent fact. No independent
challenge has been laid to any order passed by respondent no. 8
which constitutes the principal subject matter of the present petition.
In fact, no substantive relief against respondent no. 8 has been sought
in the main writ petition. More importantly, any fresh medical
assessment, if required, for determining the present condition and
extent of disability of respondent no. 10 would necessarily have to be
carried out at the place where she resides. The mere fact that an
earlier disability certificate was issued in Delhi cannot, therefore,
make Delhi the appropriate forum for adjudication of the prayers
sought by the petitioner.
16.
The petitioner has also relied upon the presence of respondent
nos. 1, 2, 8 and 9 in Delhi. However, mere impleadment of
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:51:46
W.P.(C) 13127/2026
authorities situated within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court
cannot confer jurisdiction where the substantive dispute does not
arise from any action or order of such authorities. Territorial
jurisdiction has to be determined with reference to the cause of action
and not merely the situs of one or more of the respondents. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court has repeatedly held that facts having no
material or integral connection with the lis cannot be relied upon to
confer territorial jurisdiction.
17.
The reliance placed upon the fact that certain earlier
proceedings concerning respondent no. 10 were entertained by this
Court is also of no assistance to the petitioner. Territorial jurisdiction
has to be determined with reference to the cause of action arising in
the proceedings before the Court. The fact that an earlier proceeding
concerning the same person was entertained by this Court cannot, by
itself, confer jurisdiction in a subsequent proceeding where the nature
of the relief and the material facts giving rise to the cause of action
are different.
18.
In Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India: (2004) 6
SCC 254, the Hon’ble Supreme Court examined the scope of
territorial jurisdiction under Article 226(2) of the Constitution of
India and held that the mere location of the seat of the Union
Government or the authority concerned does not, by itself, confer
territorial jurisdiction upon a High Court. It was observed that
jurisdiction under Article 226 is determined by whether any part of
the cause of action has arisen within the territorial limits of the High
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:51:46
W.P.(C) 13127/2026
Court concerned. Further, the concept of forum conveniens was
explained by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the said decision by way
of following observations:
“Forum conveniens
30. We must, however, remind ourselves that even if a small
part of cause of action arises within the territorial jurisdiction
of the High Court, the same by itself may not be considered to
be a determinative factor compelling the High Court to decide
the matter on merit. In appropriate cases, the Court may refuse
to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction by invoking the
doctrine of forum conveniens.”
19.
Furthermore, the Full Bench of this Court in Sterling Agro
Industries Ltd. v. Union of India: 2011 SCC OnLine Del 3162, has
held that even where a part of the cause of action arises within the
territorial jurisdiction of a High Court, the Court is required to
consider the doctrine of forum conveniens. The mere existence of a
part of the cause of action within the jurisdiction of a High Court
does not, by itself, compel the Court to entertain the petition. The
Court is required to consider which forum is more appropriate having
regard to the nature of the lis, the convenience of the parties, the
examination of facts and other circumstances necessary for an
effective adjudication.
20.
The present case is one where the petitioner, respondent no. 7
and respondent no. 10 are all residing in Uttar Pradesh. The principal
relief concerns the person, custody, care and welfare of respondent
no. 10. The factual enquiry concerning her present living conditions
would necessarily have to be undertaken at Ghaziabad; any medical
assessment or examination, if required, would have to be conducted
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:51:46
W.P.(C) 13127/2026
by the appropriate medical authorities there; and any order
concerning her custody or care would necessarily have to be
implemented at Ghaziabad. The authorities and the forum having
jurisdiction over Ghaziabad would, therefore, be the appropriate
forum to undertake the necessary factual enquiry and to ensure
effective implementation of any order that may ultimately be passed.
21.
This Court is, therefore, of the considered view that the
principal and material facts relevant for adjudication of the reliefs
sought by the petitioner pertain to the residence, custody, care,
medical condition and welfare of respondent no. 10, all of which are
connected with Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh. The facts relied upon by
the petitioner to establish a connection with Delhi do not constitute
an integral part of the cause of action for the principal reliefs sought
in the present petition. Even assuming that some connection with
Delhi can be demonstrated, this Court would decline to exercise its
discretionary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, as the competent court or authority having territorial
jurisdiction over Ghaziabad would be the appropriate forum for
adjudication of the present dispute.
22.
Accordingly, the present petition is dismissed on the ground of
territorial jurisdiction. The pending applications, including C.M.A.
No. 61048/2026, also stands disposed of.
23.
It is clarified that this Court has not expressed any opinion on
the merits of the allegations or on the entitlement of the petitioner to
be appointed as guardian, and the petitioner shall be at liberty to avail
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:51:46
W.P.(C) 13127/2026
of such remedies as may be available to her before the competent
court or authority having jurisdiction over Ghaziabad, in accordance
with law.
24.
The judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith.
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026/zp
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:51:46
W.P.(C) 13127/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review