Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 10th December 2025
Pronounced on: 05th February 2026
%
+
CRL.M.C. 8799/2024
MRS ASHA BHATIA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Rajinder Singh, Mr.
Shaurya Dogra, Mr. Vibhor
Tyagi, Ms. Pooja Kasana & Mr.
Navjot Birdi, Advocates
versus
STATE GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Satinder Singh Bawa, APP
with SI Ram Kishan, PS
Defence Colony
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA
JUDGMENT
RAVINDER DUDEJA, J.
1.
The present petition has been filed, seeking quashing and
setting aside of the order dated 21st October 2024, passed by the
learned Additional Sessions Judge-05, South-East, Saket District
Courts, New Delhi in Crl. Revision No. 247/2024 titled “Mrs. Asha
Bhatia versus State and Ors.”
Factual Background:
2.
Petitioner’s case is that her mother late Smt. Swaran Kaur
Bhatia, executed a Will dated 05th October 2021 in her favour in
CRL.M.C. 8799/2024
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:38:39
respect of properties bearing Nos. A-19 & A-49, Defence Colony,
New Delhi. She expired on 31st December 2021. The petitioner
applied for mutation of property No. A-49 in her favour, but she could
not get it done as respondent No. 2 Amarjeet Singh propounded a Will
dated 27th September 2017 of late Smt. Swaran Kaur Bhatia, allegedly
executed in his favour. Thereupon, the petitioner filed a probate
petition bearing No. PC-51/2022 before the court of learned Principal
& District Judge, South-East District for grant of Probate/Letter of
Administration in respect of Will dated 05th October 2021, executed in
her favour. The petitioner later came to know that Amarjeet Singh had
got an FIR No. 120/2023, under Section 420/468/471/34 Indian Penal
Code, 1860 [“IPC”] registered against her at Police Station Defence
Colony, alleging forgery of Will dated 05th October 2021. The said
case is still under investigation.
3.
Subsequently, respondent No. 3 Ms. Ravinder Kaur, who is the
wife of Amarjeet Singh (Respondent No. 2) propounded a Will dated
18th November 2021, allegedly executed by late Smt. Swaran Kaur
Bhatia in respect of her other property bearing No. A-49, Defence
Colony. Such Will, according to petitioner, is forged and fabricated to
overcome the precedence of petitioner’s Will, being later in time.
4.
Petitioner filed a complaint under Section 200 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 [“Cr. PC”] against both the respondents
along with an application under Section 156(3) Cr. PC for registration
of FIR under the relevant provisions of IPC. Vide order dated 02nd
April 2024, the application filed by the petitioner under Section 156(3)
CRL.M.C. 8799/2024
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:38:39
Cr. PC was dismissed. However, the learned Metropolitan Magistrate
[“MM”] took cognizance and granted opportunity to the petitioner to
prove her case by leading evidence.
5.
Petitioner preferred revision against the said order before the
learned Sessions Court. Vide order dated 21st October 2024, the said
revision came to be dismissed. Feeling aggrieved, petitioner has filed
the present petition impugning the orders dated 02nd April 2024 and
21st October 2024.
Submissions made on behalf of the petitioner:
6.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner submitted that respondent
Nos. 2 and 3 deliberately suppressed material facts while initiating
proceedings under Section 156(3) Cr. PC, particularly the pendency
and contest of the probate petition. It was argued that although
objections had already been filed by Respondent No. 2 in the probate
proceedings, the same were not disclosed to the Magistrate while
seeking registration of an FIR against the Petitioner. It was further
submitted that such suppression vitiates the entire criminal process
initiated at the behest of the Respondents. On this ground alone, the
registration of the FIR against the Petitioner was stated to be a clear
abuse of the process of law.
7.
It was further submitted that the Petitioner is a 69-year-old
woman and the absolute owner, being the rightful heir to her deceased
mother, of the property in question, who had sought to sell the same
through a lawful agreement to sell. Pursuant thereto, a public notice
CRL.M.C. 8799/2024
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:38:39
was issued in The Hindustan Times by the person who sought to buy
the property inviting objections, in response to which Respondent No.
3 issued a legal notice claiming a Will dated 18th November 2021 in
her favour. It was emphasized that no reference to such alleged Will
was made in the objections filed earlier in the probate petition by
Respondent No. 2. It was on account of this suspicious conduct that
the Petitioner was constrained to approach the Magistrate by filing an
application under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C.
8.
Learned Counsel assailed the reasoning of the Ld. Trial Court in
dismissing the Petitioner’s application on the ground that an FIR had
already been registered on similar facts. It was argued that the cause of
action for the Petitioner’s complaint arose subsequently, nearly two
years later, upon disclosure of a second alleged Will dated 18th
November 2021, which was never disclosed earlier despite all parties
residing in the same household. It was further submitted that the
investigation pursuant to the earlier FIR was conducted only against
the Petitioner, while Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 were not subjected to
any meaningful inquiry. Such selective investigation, it was submitted,
renders the impugned order perverse and unsustainable.
9.
Lastly, it was submitted that the impugned order dated 21st
October 2024 is arbitrary, mechanical, and reflects complete nonapplication of judicial mind. The complaint clearly discloses
cognizable offences of forgery and criminal conspiracy involving two
suspicious Wills dated 27th September 2017 and 18th November 2021,
necessitating police investigation and forensic examination. The Ld.
CRL.M.C. 8799/2024
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:38:39
Trial Court erred in holding that the evidence was within the reach of
the Petitioner, overlooking that such investigation cannot be
effectively undertaken in a private complaint under Sections 200 and
202 Cr.P.C.
Submissions made on behalf of the State:
10.
Learned APP for the State submitted that during the course of
investigation, several notices were issued to the Petitioner calling upon
her to join the investigation and to furnish relevant documents,
including the chain of ownership, which she failed to comply with. It
was argued that the probate proceedings are admittedly pending and
all three alleged Wills have already been placed before the competent
probate court. Furthermore that, the probate court is the appropriate
forum to adjudicate upon the genuineness and validity of the three
Wills, and therefore no separate FIR is warranted on the same subject
matter. It was lastly submitted that the earlier FIR had already been
registered pursuant to an application under Section 156(3) Cr. PC filed
by Respondent No. 2 against the present Petitioner, and in view
thereof, the registration of another FIR was rightly declined.
Submissions made on behalf of the Respondent Nos. 2 and 3:
11.
Learned counsel for the respondents submitted, at the outset,
that all allegations and averments made by the petitioner are false,
misleading, vexatious, and unsustainable in law. It was submitted that
the deceased/testatrix, late Smt. Swaran Kaur Bhatia was not being
looked after by the petitioner, who had been residing separately in
CRL.M.C. 8799/2024
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:38:39
Gurugram, whereas, respondents were taking care of her in her
advanced age. It was submitted that respondent No. 2 inherited
ownership of property No. A-49, Defence Colony, New Delhi through
a registered Will dated 27th September 2017, executed out of love and
affection and has been in possession and running a shop on the ground
floor of the said property since 2014.
12.
It was further submitted that after the death of the testatrix on
31.12.2021, petitioner attempted to usurp the property by setting up a
false and fabricated Will dated 05th October 2021 to counter the
genuine registered Wills in favour of respondents. Furthermore,
petitioner herself admitted that she used to sign on behalf of her
mother, including in bank records and audio and video recordings,
evidencing the same, form part of the probate record.
13.
It was further submitted that all the three Wills are the subject
matter of pending probate proceedings and their genuineness is to be
conclusively determined by the competent probate court, rendering the
registration of a second FIR wholly unnecessary. It was lastly
submitted that one FIR is already under investigation and that all the
three Wills propounded by the parties may be covered under the same
investigation, and in view thereof, the impugned orders do not suffer
from any illegality or infirmity.
Analysis and Conclusion:
14.
The law is well settled that Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. is not to be
invoked mechanically or as a matter of course, particularly where the
CRL.M.C. 8799/2024
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:38:39
complainant is in possession of relevant evidence and the accused are
identifiable. As and when any information is received by a police
officer about the alleged commission of offence, which is cognizable,
it is the duty of the police officer to register an FIR. Sub Section (1) of
Section 156 confers power to the police to investigate a cognizable
offence without the order of the Magistrate. The police may
investigate the cognizable offence either on information under Section
154 Cr. PC or on their own motion, on their own knowledge or from
other reliable information. If a person has the grievance that FIR has
not been registered by the police, the remedy is to approach the
Superintendent of Police under Section 154(3) Cr.PC or other police
officer referred to in Section 36 Cr.PC. If despite approaching the
Superintendent of Police or the officer referred to in Section 36, his
grievance still persists, then he can approach a Magistrate under
Section 156(3) Cr.PC. Moreover, he has a further remedy of filing a
criminal complaint under Section 200 Cr.PC. This statutory right to
investigate the cognizable offence cannot be interfered with or
controlled by the courts.
15.
Sub Section (3) of Section 156 Cr. PC empowers the Magistrate
to direct the police to register the FIR and investigate the cognizable
offence but there is a restriction on the power of the Magistrate before
directing the police to investigate under sub Section (3), inasmuch as,
the Magistrate should form an opinion that the complaint filed by the
complainant before him discloses a cognizable offence. However, the
Magistrate must also ensure that this provision is not misused by the
CRL.M.C. 8799/2024
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:38:39
complainants to get the police case registered in those cases which are
not very serious in nature and do not require the assistance of the
investigating agency for conducting investigation. The use of
expression “may” in sub Section (3) of Section 156 Cr. PC leaves no
room for doubt that the power conferred upon the Magistrate is
discretionary and he is not bound to direct investigation by police even
if the allegations made in the complaint disclose the commission of a
cognizable offence. Thus, if in a given case, the Magistrate feels that
the matter does not require investigation by the police and can be
proved by the complainant himself without any assistance from the
police, in that case, he may instead of directing the investigation by
the police, straight away can take cognizance of the alleged offence
and proceed under Section 200 of the Code by examining the
complainant and his witnesses, if any. The Magistrate ought to direct
investigation by the police only where the assistance of the
investigating agency is necessary and the court feels that the cause of
justice is likely to suffer in the absence of investigation by the police.
This position has been reiterated by this Court in the case of Skipper
Beverages Pvt. Ltd. vs. State, 2001 (59) DRJ 129. The relevant paras
of the judgment read as under:“7. It is true that Section 156(3) of the Code empowers a
Magistrate to direct the police to register a case and initiate
investigations but this power has to be exercised judiciously on
proper grounds and not in a mechanical manner. In those cases
where the allegations are not very serious and the complainant
himself is in possession of evidence to prove his allegations there
should be no need to pass orders under Section 156(3) of the Code.
CRL.M.C. 8799/2024
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:38:39
The discretion ought to be exercised after proper application of
mind and only in those cases where the Magistrate is of the view
that the nature of the allegations is such that the complainant
himself may not be in a position to collect and produce evidence
before the Court and interests of justice demand that the police
should step in to help the complainant. The police assistance can
be taken by a Magistrate even under Sec. 202(1) of the Code after
taking cognizance and proceeding with the complaint under
Chapter XV of the Code as held by Apex Court in 2001 (1) Supreme
page 129 titled “Suresh Chand Jain v. State of Madhya Pradesh &
Ors.”
10. Section 156(3) of the Code aims at curtailing and controlling
the arbitrariness on the part of the police authorities in the matter
of registration of FIRs and taking up investigations, even in those
cases where the same are warranted. The Section empower the
Magistrate to issue directions in this regard but this provision
should not be permitted to be misused by the complainant to get
police cases registered even in those cases which are not very
serious in nature and the Magistrate himself can hold enquiry
under Chapter XV and proceed against the accused if required.
Therefore a Magistrate, must apply his mind before passing an
order under Section 156(3) of the Code and must not pass these
orders mechanically on the mere asking by the complainant. These
powers ought to be exercised primarily in those cases where the
allegations are quite serious or evidence is beyond the reach of
complaint or custodial interrogation appears to be necessary for
some recovery of article or discovery of fact.”
16.
That being so, the Magistrate is not expected to mechanically
direct the investigation by the police without first examining whether
in the facts and circumstances of the case, investigation by the State
machinery is actually required or not. If the allegations made in the
complaint are straight forward and simple, the court may straight away
proceed to conduct the trial. If the Magistrate decides to proceed under
Section 200 Cr. PC, then also, the Magistrate has the power to call for
a police report before issuing the process under Section 202 Cr. PC.
The Division Bench of Karnataka High Court in the case of Guru Dutt
CRL.M.C. 8799/2024
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:38:39
Prabhu & Ors. Vs. M.S. Krishna Bhat & Ors. 1999 Crl. LJ 3909,
expressed the fear that if every complaint under Section 156 (3) Cr.
PC is sent for police investigation without application of mind, there is
likelihood that the provision would be used as a tool of harassment at
the hands of unscrupulous complainant and the provision can be
highly misused if orders are passed under Section 156 (3) Cr. PC in a
routine manner, even where a complaint is filed under Section 200
Cr.P.C.
17.
Upon consideration of the rival submissions and applying the
aforesaid principles in the facts and circumstances of the present case,
this Court finds no infirmity in the impugned order dated 21st October
2024, warranting interference under Section 528 of Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. It is undisputed that proposed accused are
well known to the petitioner and their identities are not in question.
The dispute essentially revolves around the genuineness of three
Wills, all of which are already placed on record before the probate
court. The evidence required to be adduced is thus within the reach of
the petitioner. In such circumstances, the assistance of the police is not
required for any investigation.
18.
Significantly, the core issue raised by the petitioner pertains to
the validity and genuineness of the disputed Wills, which will be
determined by the probate court. The Will dated 05th October 2021,
propounded by the petitioner, is already a subject-matter of FIR
registered at the instance of respondent No. 2. The learned Magistrate,
vide impugned order dated 02nd April 2024, noted that IO shall
CRL.M.C. 8799/2024
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:38:39
investigate the veracity of claims made by the petitioner in this matter.
Moreover, the trial court has already taken cognizance of offence. If
during evidence of the petitioner under Section 200 Cr. PC, the trial
court still considers it expedient for the ends of justice, it may invoke
the provision of Section 202 Cr. PC for taking assistance of the police
for collecting evidence.
19.
Hence, in view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the
view that learned MM has exercised its judicial discretion properly
and in accordance with law by declining the request of the petitioner
to make over the investigation to the police under Section 156(3) Cr.
PC. Thus, there is no ground to interfere with the well-reasoned and
justified orders passed by the learned MM and the learned Sessions
Judge. Both the courts below have correctly appreciated that
petitioner’s complaint does not warrant registration of a separate FIR.
20.
The petition accordingly stands dismissed.
RAVINDER DUDEJA, J.
05th February 2026/na
CRL.M.C. 8799/2024
Digitally Signed
By:VAISHALI PRUTHI
16:38:39
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review