Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No. 360 of 2025
1. Mrinal Pandey, aged about- 19 years, D/o- Parveen Kumar
Pandey, Residenty of – Manjhgawan, Padma, P.O. & P.S.- Padma,
District- Hazaribagh, Jharkhand.
……Appellant No.1/Petitioner no.7
2. Aiman Yusuf, aged about-20 years, D/o-Shamshad Yusuf,
Resident of Village Amnari Road, Meru BSF Near Beer Shop,
Hazaribag, P.O. Meru BSF, P.S. Muffasil, Kundari DistrictHazaribag. Jharkhand.
……Appellant no.2/Petitioner no.8
3. Anvesha Priya, aged about 19 years, D/o-Bijay Kumar Dubey, R/oShivdayal Nagar, Kadma, P.O.- Kadma, P.S. Katkamdag, DistHazaribagh, Jharkhand.
….. Appellant no.3/Petitioner no.10
4. Sakshi Anand, aged about 20 years, S/o-Late Uday Shankar
Prasad, Resident of-House no. 255 Near Upkar Hotel, DVC
Colony, P.O. Hazaribag, P.S. Sadar, District-Hazaribag,
Jharkhand.
...Appellant no.4/Petitioner no.25
5. Shaviani Bhardwaj, aged about-19 years, D/o-Manoj Kumar Singh,
Resident of House No. 1/3 DOG Scout CTS Colony, Hazaribagh
P.O.-Hazaribagh, P.S. Sadar, District- Hazaribagh, Jharkhand.
....Appellant no.5/Petitioner no.29.
6. Aamra Khanam, aged about 19 years, D/o- Khalid Khan, Resident
of Pelawal, P.O. & P.S.- Pelawal, Hazaribag, District-Hazaribag,
Jharkhand.
.....Appellant no.6/Petitioner no.30
7. Suryakant Raj, aged about-20 years, S/o- Om Prakash Gupta,
resident of Bhagyamani, Emporium, Gola Road, Badam Bazar,
P.O. Hazaribagh, P.S.-Sadar, District- Hazaribagh, Jharkhand.
….. Appellant no.7/Petitioner no.31
8. Nishant Kumar, aged about 20 years, S/o-Subhash Kumar, R/oSinghani, P.O.- Korrah, P.S.- Muffasil, Dist- Hazaribagh,
Jharkhand.
.....Appellant no.8/Petitioner no.32
9. Farhan Ansari, aged about 19 years, S/o-Zahid Hussain, Resident
of Babu Gaon, P.O.-Korrah, P.S. Korrah, District- Hazaribag,
Jharkhand.
.....Appellant no.9/Petitioner no.38
10. Ritul Rani, aged about-19 years, D/o- Ranjan Kumar R/oKishunpur, Mohalla, Near New Petrol Pump, P.O.-Chatra, P.S.Chatra, District-Chatra, Jharkhand
.....Appellant no.10/Petitioner no.54
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand thorugh the Chief Secretary, Department
of Personnel, Administrative Reforms and Rajbhasha, Government
of Jharkhand, having its office at Project Building, Dhurwa, P.O. &
P.S.- Jaganathpur, District-Ranchi, Jharkhand.
2. The Chancellor, through the Officer on Special Duty (Judicial)
O.S.D.J.) to Governor, State of Jharkhand, Governor’s Secretariat,
Governor Office, (Raj Bhawan), P.O. + GPO+ PS – Kanke, District
– Ranchi, Jharkhand.
3. The Vinoba Bhave University, Hazaribagh, through Registrar
Sindoor Ichak, Hazaribagh, P.O. – Hazaribagh, P.S. – Sadar,
District Hazaribagh, Jharkhand – 825301.
4. The University Law College through the Principal, Vinoba Bhave
University, Sindoor Ichak Hazaribagh, P.O.- Hazaribagh, P.S.
Sadar, District-Hazaribagh, Jharkhand-825301.
5. The Bar Council of India, through its Chairman at 21 Rouse
Avenue Institutional Area, New Delhi, P.O. & P.S. Indraprastha,
District Central Delhi. 110002.
6. The Jharkhand State Bar Council, Jharkhand, through its
Chairman, at Bangalow No.5 near Kendriya Vidyalay, Shyamali
Colony Doranda P.O. &. P.S. Doranda, District- Ranchi 834002.
Jharkhand.
.......Respondents/Respondents.
--------CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
--------For the Appellants:
Mr. Pratyush Shonikya, Advocate
For the State:
Mr. Gaurav Raj, A.C. to A.A.G.-II
For the University:
Mrs. Indrani S. Choudhary, Advocate
Miss Ishani Sen, Advocate
For the BCI:
Mr. Prashant Kumar Singh, Advocate
Mr. Radha Krishan Gupta, Advocate
For the JSBC:
Mr. Manoj Tandon, Advocate
--------07/Dated: 28.01.2026
1.
Heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties.
2.
This appeal challenges the learned Single Judge’s order dated
19.09.2024 dismissing the appellants’ petitions for quashing the notice
dated 29.11.2023 issued by the Vinoba Bhave University, Hazaribagh,
for conducting the entrance examination/test on 12.12.2023 for fresh/
revised admission for the session 2022-2025 for LL. B and for
sessions 2022-2027 for B.A. LL.B. The appellants/petitioners also
pray that the admissions granted to them in March 2023 for the B.A.
LL.B session 2022-2027 be regularised and continued without any
requirement for them to appear for the Special Entrance Test as
declared by notice dated 29.11.2023.
3.
Mr Pratyush Shonikya, learned counsel for the appellants,
submitted that there was nothing inherently wrong in the admissions
granted to the appellants and, therefore, the insistence by the
University that the appellants appear for the Special Entrance
Examination was illegal and uncalled for. He submitted that the
College had 120 seats, and after it was realised that several seats
were vacant because students like the appellants could not attain the
cut-off marks, the College resolved to admit the students on a ‘firstcome, first-served basis’. He pointed out that this had been the
procedure followed since the academic year 2012-2013, and that
there was nothing inherently wrong with the procedure adopted.
4.
Mr. Shonikya, without prejudice to the above contentions,
submitted that there was no fault whatsoever on the part of the
appellants in this matter. He submitted that the fault, if any, was of the
College and under no circumstances should the appellants be made
to suffer for such faults. He submitted that the appellants were bona
fide students who were duly admitted by the College and continued
with their studies for almost one and a half years, until they were
unseated by the impugned order dated 19.09.2024.
5.
Therefore, invoking the principles of equity, no student should
be made to suffer for faults not attributable to such students or, for
faults attributable to the College/University and on that basis, Mr.
Shonkiya submitted that the appellants’ admissions should be
regularised and the appellants should be permitted to complete the
B.A. LL.B Course for the session 2022-2027 without insisting upon
answering the Special Entrance Test, or, notwithstanding their failure
in the special entrance test which they attended without prejudice to
their rights and contentions in the petition and in this appeal.
6.
Ms. Indrani Sen Choudhary, the learned counsel for the Vinoba
Bhave University, to which the College concerned was affiliated,
submitted that there was everything wrong with the initial admissions
of the appellants for the B.A. LL. B Course. She submitted that the
College was bound by the cut-off percentage prescribed under the
rules and regulations, but the College continued to lower this cut-off
requirement from time to time without lawful authority. She submitted
that despite lowering the cut-off requirement from 40% to 35% for the
general category, the present appellants did not qualify. She
submitted that the College, in breach of all rules and regulations, then
devised their own procedures and admitted the appellants by invoking
the principle of “first-come, first-served “ basis. She submitted that this
was totally illegal and improper.
7.
Ms. Indrani Sen Choudhary submitted that, after this was
noticed by His Excellency, the Governor of Jharkhand, who is also the
Chancellor
of
the
University,
a
lenient
view
was
adopted
notwithstanding the patent illegality. The Chancellor, as is evident
from the communication dated 25.10.2023, directed the conduct of a
special test for students, including the present appellants, who were
admitted through backdoor entry. She submitted that instead of
welcoming this decision and clearing the special entrance test, the
present appellants chose to challenge the holding of such a test. In
any event, she submitted that the appellants answered the special
entrance test but, again, failed to qualify.
8.
Ms. Indrani Sen Choudhary submitted that the initial admissions
of the appellants were patently illegal, and even the attempts to
regularise their admissions by holding a special entrance test met with
no success because the appellants failed to qualify in the special
entrance test. She submitted that the appellants have been out of
College since November 2024 and still insist on continuing the B.A.
LL.B course for the session 2022-2027, which is completely
impermissible.
9.
Ms. Indrani Sen Choudhary, therefore, submitted that there is
no error in the view taken by the learned Single Judge and this appeal
should be dismissed.
10.
The rival contentions now fall for our determination.
11.
In this case, the facts are quite gross, and it is apparent that the
appellants have been put forward by the College to invoke the
sympathy of this Court by urging that the appellants, not being
responsible for any wrongdoing, ought not to suffer. However, it is well
settled that on such a basis, no relief can be granted to the appellants
where the record unmistakably establishes that their very admissions
were patently contrary to law and the regulations which govern the
prescribed admission procedures.
12.
In this case, the College conducted an entrance examination
with a 40% cut-off percentage. On the grounds that few students
could meet the cut-off percentage, the College approached the
University, which lowered the cut-off percentage from 40% to 35% for
general category students. We are uncertain whether the University
was justified in lowering that percentage. However, since that is not
the subject matter of the challenge before us, we leave the matter at
that.
13.
Notwithstanding the lowering of the cut-off percentage long after
the admission process had commenced, the present appellants could
not qualify because they had obtained less than 35% marks, which
was the cut-off percentage for general category students. Learned
counsel for the appellants admitted that the appellants had secured
around 27% to 34% marks in the entrance examination. Given the
above admitted position, the College should not have admitted the
appellants simply because some seats would otherwise remain
vacant. Such admission was only to earn money from these students,
with complete disregard for the rules and regulations for admission.
14.
It appears that the college did not inform the University of the
admission of these students, even though they had secured a score
below the lowered cut-off percentage in the entrance test. At the stage
when admit cards had to be issued, the University realised what had
happened, and His Excellency the Chancellor of the University took
cognisance of the entire matter.
15.
The
decision
of
His
Excellency
the
Chancellor
was
communicated to the Vice Chancellor of the Vinoba Bhave University
for onward transmission to the College. This is contained in the
communication dated 25.10.2023. The contents of this communication
are self-explanatory. The contents are transcribed below for the
convenience of reference: Letter No.- VBU-12/2023-330/G.S
From,
To,
Dated:-25.10.2023
Through-E-maill
Mukesh Chandra Narain,
O.S.D. (Judicial) to Governor.
I/c Vice Chancellor,
Vinoba Bhave University,
Hazaribagh.
Sub: Necessary action relating to illegal admission in University
Law College, Hazaribagh.
Ref:- Your letter no.- VBU/VC/678/2023 dated- 21.09.2023.
Madam,
With reference to the subject and letter referred above, I am
directed to inform you that His Excellency the Governor-cumChancellor of the Universities has been pleased to order:(i)
To
initate
departmental
proceeding
against
Dr.
Kaushlendra Kumar and Dr. Jaydeep Sanyal without
any delay and ensure that the same be concluded within
a month.
(ii)
To return Dr. Kaushlendra Kumar to his parent posting
(teaching work).
(iii)
To ensure that in future no key post be given/assigned to
Dr. Kaushlendra Kumar except teaching work.
(iv)
To conduct a special test for the students who are
allowed admission through backdoor entry.
(v)
To allow further study of only those students who qualify
in the special test.
This is for information and compliance.
Your’s faithfully,
Sd/- Illegible
O.S.D (Judicial) to Governor,
Jharkhand, Ranchi.”
16.
In this appeal, we are not concerned with the action taken
against the Principal and the Director of the College who were
involved in granting illegal admissions, inter alia, to the present
appellants. One of the directions issued by His Excellency, the
Chancellor, was to conduct a special test for students admitted
through backdoor entry. Again, we are unsure whether this direction
meets the requirements of law and regulations, but, as explained by
learned counsel Ms Indrani Sen Choudhary, such a direction was
issued out of compassion for the appellants’ plight and to determine
whether their admissions could be regularised.
17.
The appellants, instead of welcoming the decision to hold the
special test, chose to institute a writ petition to challenge the direction
to hold the special test. The appellants’ case was that their initial
admissions were themselves regular and, therefore, requiring them to
appear in a special test was improper.
18.
Mr. Shonikya contended that for the special test, a cut-off
percentage of 35 was provided. He submitted that if the appellants
could secure this percentage of marks, they would have secured
admission in the first round without having to undergo this entire
process. Though Mr. Shonikya has argued the matter very ably, this
argument, we are sorry to say, is entirely misconceived.
19.
The appellants should have appreciated that His Excellency the
Chancellor, out of compassion, decided to provide the appellants with
an additional opportunity to regularise their admissions. Instead of
welcoming this move, studying hard and securing the prescribed 35%,
the appellants, possibly on legal advice, chose to challenge the
examination itself.
20.
In any event, the appellants, without prejudice to their
challenge, appeared in the special entrance examination. However,
they failed to obtain the prescribed cut-off percentage of 35. As a
result, the University and the College had no option but to discontinue
their admissions. This decision was challenged before the learned
Single Judge. The learned Single Judge dismissed all the petitions,
holding that the admissions initially granted to the appellants were
unlawful. In any event, the appellants failed to take advantage of the
indulgence extended to them by His Excellency the Chancellor, who
held a special test. The learned Single Judge noted that, despite all
opportunities, since the appellants had failed to qualify, no relief could
be granted to the appellants.
21.
We are not persuaded to take any view different from that which
has been taken by the learned Single Judge in this matter. Learned
that the Single Judge has analysed the issue from all perspectives,
including compassion and sympathy. However, we agree with the
learned Single Judge that this is not a case in which any relief can be
granted to the appellants, and, further, the grant of relief to the
appellants would set up a very unhealthy precedent in relation to
admissions to professional law colleges.
22.
The issue is not merely about the grant or regularisation of
admission to the appellants, but the issue is whether students, who
failed to even get 35% marks as prescribed under the rules and
regulations in the entrance test, should be admitted to law colleges,
merely because, otherwise, the seats would remain vacant. Any
relaxation at this core level would constitute a relaxation of the
profession’s standards. Therefore, much is at stake, and even after
extending indulgence to the appellants, they have failed to pass
muster.
23.
The argument that the appellants were not at fault does not
persuade us. This is a usual argument that the college management
puts up through the students. If the appellants, i.e., the students, are
not at fault, they should perhaps sue the College, which has wrongly
granted them admission, and recover damages. Learned counsel for
the University points out that the appellants have already filed a
separate writ for this purpose. The learned counsel for the appellants
denies that any such separate writ is filed. However, he points out
that, by the impugned order, there is a direction for the refund of fees
and documents, and that the College has not complied with that
direction; accordingly, a Contempt Petition has been filed.
24.
Be that as it may, if the appellants indeed feel that they have
been wronged by the College, it is left to them to seek appropriate
remedies against the College. However, on the ground that they are
not at fault, the appellants cannot insist upon lowering the standards
of admission as have been statutorily prescribed and continuing in the
Law College. This is more so because from November 2024 onwards,
the appellants are already out of the College and at this stage, it
would be most inequitable to direct their readmission to the College
and allow them to continue and complete their course.
25.
There is no error in the impugned order warranting any
interference in this appeal. Accordingly, we dismiss this appeal
without any order for costs.
26.
Pending interim application, if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
January 28, 2026
N.A.F.R.
Manoj/Cp.2
Uploaded on 30.01.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review