Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision: 23rd January, 2026
+
CS(OS) 154/2018 & I.A. 4920/2018, I.A. 11587/2018, I.A.
11588/2018, I.A. 11589/2018, I.A. 11590/2018, I.A. 11592/2018, I.A.
11593/2018, I.A. 11594/2018, I.A. 11595/2018, I.A. 11596/2018
MR. PRANAV GUPTA
Through:
.....Plaintiff
Dr. Anurag Kumar Agarwal, Mr.
Ram
Gupta,
Advocates
(M:9891050987)
versus
ADEESH GUPTA & ORS
Through:
.....Defendants
Mr. Rakesh K. Khanna, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Rajiv K. Garg, Mr. Ashok Rana,
Ms. Ritu Dhingra, Mr. Shiven Banga,
Ms. Arushi Jindal, Advocates for D 15, 19, 20, 28 to 33, 36, 37, 40, 42 to
47 and 50 to 53 (M:9810002830)
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MINI PUSHKARNA
MINI PUSHKARNA, J (ORAL):
1.
The present is a suit for partition, declaration, dissolution of
partnership firms, rendition of accounts and mandatory and permanent
injunction with respect to various immovable and movable properties
mentioned in Schedule A, Schedule B, Schedule C and Schedule D, filed on
behalf of the plaintiff, who is the son of defendant no.1.
2.
This Court notes that vide order dated 06th May, 2019, the plaintiff
had agreed that all the disputes, which are subject matter of the present suit,
can be referred to arbitration.
3.
Further, by way of the Will dated 10th November, 1998 of Late Shri
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:45:36
CS(OS) 154/2018
Dharam Pal Gupta, i.e., grandfather of the plaintiff, the estate of Late Shri
Dharam Pal Gupta, had been bequeathed upon the plaintiff, some defendants
and his wife Mrs. Rehti Devi.
It is also noted that vide order dated 06th May, 2019, the parties had
4.
made the statement that there is no dispute or challenge with regard to the
aforesaid Will. The relevant portion of order dated 06 th May, 2019, is
reproduced as under:
“xxx xxx xxx
16. The counsels state that there is no dispute amongst the parties of
the validity of the documents claimed to be the Will, though the Will
has not been probated.
xxx xxx xxx”
(Emphasis Supplied)
5.
It is further noted that the aforesaid Will envisages reference of
disputes in relation to the Will to a resolution process, as indicated therein.
The relevant portion of Will dated 10th November, 1998 is reproduced as
under:
“xxx xxx xxx
In case, any dispute arises amongst my legal heirs after my death, the
following three Deciles (SAALAS) shall settle the dispute as per the
WILL. Docile (SAALAS) No.1, Shri Purushottam Das Gupta son of
Late Shri Lijja Ram Gupta resident of Liberty House, Railway Road,
Karnal, Docile (SAALAS) No.2, Shri Rajkumar Bansal son of Late
Shri Madan Mohan Bansal resident of Saraswati Bhawan, Vikram
Marg, Karnal and Docile (SAALAS) No.3 Shri Adeesh Kumar Gupta
son of Shri Dharampal Gupta resident of Liberty House, Railway
Road, Karnal. In case, any of the above Docile's expires than the
remaining two Docile's can appoint the third Docile out of the family
members.
The decision of the above Docile's shall be binding on all the legal
heirs in whose favour the WILL has been executed and all my legal
heirs will be bound by the said decision. The WILL has been written
down so that it remain authenticated.
xxx xxx xxx”
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:45:36
CS(OS) 154/2018
6.
In regard to the partnership deeds, it is noted that Late Shri Dharam
Pal Gupta during his lifetime was the partner/shareholder/director of the
business entity, i.e., M/s Liberty Footwear Company and held 3% share in
the said partnership firm, in relation to which, several partnership deeds
were executed. The said partnership deeds, latest of which is dated 08th
September, 2003, contains separate and identical arbitration clauses, that
provides for a mechanism to resolution of disputes by way of arbitration.
The arbitral clause, i.e., Clause 14 of the latest Partnership Deed dated 08 th
September, 2003, is reproduced as under:
“xxx xxx xxx
14. ARBITRATION
That in case of any dispute between the parties with regard to the
interpretation of this deed or any other matter relating to the affairs of
the firm, the same shall be referred to an arbitrator mutually agreed
upon between the parties in accordance with the provisions of the
Indian Arbitration Act.
xxx xxx xxx”
7.
The parties are ad idem that all the disputes, including, the disputes
arising out of the Will dated 10th November, 1998, all partnership deeds as
aforesaid, and the Hindu Undivided Family (“HUF”), and all other disputes
related to partition between the parties, be referred to arbitration.
8.
In regard to resolution of disputes by way of arbitral mechanism for
all issues between the parties, even where there is no arbitration
agreement/clause, the parties with their consent, can be relegated to the
arbitral mechanism. Further, it is the intention of the parties which has to be
given effect to in relation to the mechanism of resolution of disputes, and it
is the duty of a Court to make the same workable, within the permissible
limits of law. Thus, the Supreme Court in the case of Mahanagar
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:45:36
CS(OS) 154/2018
Telephone Nigam Limited Versus Canara Bank and Others, (2020) 12
SCC 767, held as follows:
“xxx xxx xxx
9.3. Section 7(4)(b) of the 1996 Act, states that an arbitration
agreement can be derived from exchange of letters, telex, telegram or
other means of communication, including through electronic means.
The 2015 Amendment Act inserted the words “including
communication through electronic means” in Section 7(4)(b). If it can
prima facie be shown that parties are ad idem, even though the other
party may not have signed a formal contract, it cannot absolve him
from the liability under the agreement [Govind Rubber Ltd. v. Louis
Dreyfus Commodities Asia (P) Ltd., (2015) 13 SCC 477: (2016) 1
SCC (Civ) 733].
9.4. Arbitration agreements are to be construed according to the
general principles of construction of statutes, statutory instruments,
and other contractual documents. The intention of the parties must
be inferred from the terms of the contract, conduct of the parties,
and correspondence exchanged, to ascertain the existence of a
binding contract between the parties. If the documents on record
show that the parties were ad idem, and had actually reached an
agreement upon all material terms, then it would be construed to be
a binding contract. The meaning of a contract must be gathered by
adopting a common sense approach, and must not be allowed to be
thwarted by a pedantic and legalistic interpretation. [Union of
India v. D.N. Revri & Co., (1976) 4 SCC 147]
9.5. A commercial document has to be interpreted in such a manner
so as to give effect to the agreement, rather than to invalidate it. An
“arbitration agreement” is a commercial document inter partes, and
must be interpreted so as to give effect to the intention of the parties,
rather than to invalidate it on technicalities.
xxx xxx xxx
9.7. In interpreting or construing an arbitration agreement or
arbitration clause, it would be the duty of the court to make the same
workable within the permissible limits of the law. This Court
in Enercon (India) Ltd. v. Enercon GmbH [Enercon (India)
Ltd. v. Enercon GmbH, (2014) 5 SCC 1: (2014) 3 SCC (Civ) 59], held
that a common sense approach has to be adopted to give effect to the
intention of the parties to arbitrate the disputes between them. Being
a commercial contract, the arbitration clause cannot be construed
with a purely legalistic mindset, as in the case of a statute.
xxx xxx xxx”
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:45:36
CS(OS) 154/2018
(Emphasis Supplied)
9.
In the present case, the parties are ad-idem and have provided their
consent to resolve all the inter-se disputes by way of arbitration, thereby,
clearly demonstrating their intention. Thus, there is no impediment in
referring the parties to arbitration.
10.
Accordingly, with the consent of the parties, the following directions
are issued:
i.
Justice Gita Mittal (Retd.), former Chief Justice of High Court of
Jammu and Kashmir, (Mobile No.: 9818000220) is appointed as a Sole
Arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes between the parties.
ii.
The remuneration of the Arbitrator shall be in terms of Schedule IV of
the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (“Arbitration Act”).
iii.
The Arbitrator is requested to furnish a declaration in terms of Section
12 of the Arbitration Act prior to entering into the reference. In the event
there is any impediment to the Arbitrator’s appointment on that count, the
parties are given liberty to file an appropriate application before this Court.
iv.
It shall be open to the defendants to raise counter-claims, if any, in
arbitration proceedings.
v.
It is made clear that all the rights and contentions of the parties,
including, the arbitrability of any of the claims and/or counter-claims, any
other preliminary objection, as well as claims on merits of the dispute of
either of the parties, are left open for adjudication by the learned Arbitrator.
vi.
The parties shall approach the Arbitrator within two (2) weeks from
today.
11.
Needless to state, nothing contained in this order shall be construed as
an expression of this Court on the merits of the case.
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:45:36
CS(OS) 154/2018
12.
This Court notes that vide order dated 13th April, 2018, an interim
order was passed in favour of the plaintiff, in the following manner:
“xxx xxx xxx
Issue notice of the suit and application to the defendants by all modes
on filing of PF/RC returnable for 27.08.2018 before the Joint
Registrar and in the meanwhile the status quo qua title of the
properties mentioned in Schedule A, B and C be maintained.
xxx xxx xxx”
13.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the contesting defendants
submits that the parties are part of a company, which is a viable and thriving
company. He, thus, submits that the aforesaid interim order dated 13 th April,
2018 be vacated. He submits that the contesting defendants are ready to
deposit security to the satisfaction of the learned Arbitrator.
14.
Accordingly, it is directed that the status quo order dated 13th April,
2018 stands vacated, subject to deposit of security by the defendants before
the learned Arbitrator, to the extent of Rs. 20,00,00,000/- (Rupees Twenty
Crores), to the satisfaction of learned Arbitrator.
15.
With the aforesaid directions, the present suit, along with pending
applications, stands disposed of.
MINI PUSHKARNA, J
JANUARY 23, 2026/au
Digitally Signed
By:HARIOM SHARMA
19:45:36
CS(OS) 154/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review