Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 02nd April, 2026
Pronounced on: 01st June, 2026
+
RFA 23/2025, CM APPL. 1520/2025&1521/2025
MR. PRADEEP
S/o Sh. Om Prakash,
R/o H. No.258-C, 1st Floor,
Gali No.38, Vipin Garden Extension,
Uttam Nagar, New Delhi.
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Dhruv Chawla, Advocate.
versus
MS. KIRAN NAITHANI
D/o Sh. Shanti Srup Naithani,
R/o 309, Carterpuri, Sector -23,
Gurugram, Haryana.
Through:
....Respondents
Mr. Karan Singh, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
CM APPL. 1521/2025
1.
Application under Section 5 of Limitation Act has been filed on
behalf of the Appellant seeking condonation of delay of 18 days, in filing
the present Appeal.
2.
For the reasons stated in the Application, the delay of 18 days in filing
the Appeal is condoned.
3.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:53
Application stands disposed of.
RFA 23/2025
RFA 23/2025:
4.
The present Regular First Appeals under Section 96 read with Order
XLI Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as
‘C.P.C.’) have been preferred by the Appellant, Mr. Pradeep, assailing the
Judgment and Decree dated 21.08.2024, whereby the Suit for Recovery
preferred by the Plaintiff/Respondent, Ms. Kiran Naithani, has been decreed
in the sum of Rs.4,38,100/- along with interest @ 5% per annum from the
date of institution of this Suit, i.e. 24.09.2021, till realization.
5.
The
Counter
Claim
instituted
by
the
Defendant/Appellant,
Mr.Pradeep, seeking Recovery of Rs.1,50,000/-, was also simultaneously
dismissed, by the same judgement.
6.
The Plaintiff filed CS DJ ADJ No.678/2021, for recovery of
₹4,38,100/- along with pendente lite and future interest @ 18% p.a.
7.
Briefly stated, the case of the Plaintiff was that the Defendant was
known to him, as both were working in the same company, namely M/s
Buoyant Logistics Services Pvt. Ltd., Gurugram, Haryana. On the request of
the Defendant, the Plaintiff had advanced a friendly loan of Rs.1,00,000/without interest, because of the long standing friendly relationship between
them, on 02.06.2016 through self-cheque, which was encashed by the
Defendant.
8.
Thereafter, the Plaintiff made repeated requests for return of the loan
amount, but the Defendant expressed his inability to return the loan.
9.
Thereafter, on 23.02.2017, i.e. after eight months of taking the loan,
the Defendant again approached the Plaintiff seeking further financial
assistance and requested for an additional loan amount. Pursuant thereto, the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:53
RFA 23/2025
Plaintiff allegedly transferred various amounts to the Defendant between
February, 2017 and December, 2017, details whereof are as under:
DATE
23.02.2017
28.02.2017
03.04.2017
04.04.2017
14.04.2017
22.04.2017
19.05.2017
10.08.2017
11.08.2017
07.12.2017
TOTAL
10.
AMOUNT
₹30,000
₹10,000
₹21,500
₹41,600
₹40,000
₹2,000
₹8,000
₹50,000
₹1,50,000
₹1,35,000
₹4,88,100 (Plus ₹1,00,000 = ₹5,88,100)
Thus, a total amount of Rs.5,88,100/- was given to the
Defendant,which he had undertaken to repay within three years, along with
interest @ 4% per annum. However, despite repeated requests of the
Plaintiff, the Defendant repaid only a sum of Rs.1,50,000/- on 19.10.2020
and assured the Plaintiff that he would return the remaining loan amount,on
completion of three years i.e. by December, 2020.
11.
The Plaintiff was shocked to receive a Legal Notice dated 23.03.2021
from the Defendant, wherein the Defendant alleged that it was he who had
advanced a loan of Rs.1,50,000/- to the Plaintiff and called upon her to
repay the said amount. The Plaintiff duly replied to the aforesaid Legal
Notice, denying the contents thereof and calling upon the Defendant to
repay the outstanding amount of Rs.4,38,100/-.
12.
The Plaintiff asserted that despite repeated requests and service of the
Reply to the Legal Notice, the Defendant failed to repay the outstanding
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:53
RFA 23/2025
amount. Consequently, the Plaintiff instituted the Suit seeking recovery of
Rs.4,38,100/- along with pendente lite and future interest @ 18% per
annum.
13.
The Defendant/Appellant Mr. Pradeep, in his Written Statement, took
a preliminary objection that the Suit was barred by limitation and had been
instituted merely as a counterblast to the Legal Notice issued by him,
seeking recovery of Rs.1,50,000/- from the Plaintiff.
14.
On merits, the Defendant asserted that it was he who had advanced a
friendly loan of Rs.1,50,000/- to the Plaintiff by way of bank transfer on
19.10.2020, on the request of the plaintiff. It was claimed that despite
repeated demands, the Plaintiff failed to return the said amount on one
pretext or the other. It was denied that any loan had ever been taken by the
Defendant from the Plaintiffand thus, denied the liability to return any
amount.
15.
He further explained that the monetary transactions relied upon by the
Plaintiff, had been misconstrued and were merely part of the financial
arrangements, pertaining to the Company. Certain amounts used to be
deposited in the account of the Plaintiff for meeting day-to-day expenses of
the Company and from the said amounts, transfers were made by the
Plaintiff to the Defendant. It was thus, asserted that the said transactions
could not be construed as advancement of any personal loan by the Plaintiff
to the Defendant.
16.
Furthermore, at times the amounts were transferred/deposited directly
from the account of the Company and at other times through Mr. Rahul
Chaudhary, one of the Directors of the Company, who was actively involved
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:53
RFA 23/2025
in its day-to-day affairs. All the averments made in the Plaint were
accordingly, denied.
17.
The Defendant/Appellant also preferred a Counter Claim No.3637/
2021, seeking recovery of Rs.1,50,000/- from the Plaintiff/Respondent on
the ground that the said amount had been advanced by him as a friendly
loan to the Plaintiff.
18.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the learned Trial Court
vide Order dated 17.10.2022 framed the following common Issues for
adjudication:
“(i) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the recovery of
suit amount, as prayed for?.. OPP
(ii) Whether plaintiff is entitled for interest as prayed
for, if yet, at what rate and for what period?... OPP
(iii) Whether the defendant is entitled to set off a sum
of Rs 1,50,000/- against the plaintiff alongwith the
pendent lite and future interest @ 18 %? OPD
(iv) Relief.”
19.
The Plaintiff appeared as PW-1 and tendered her Affidavit in
Evidence Ex.PW-1/A. She proved her Bank Statements Ex.PW-1/2 and
Ex.PW-1/3;Certificate under Section 65B of Indian Evidence Act Ex.PW1/4; Legal Notice sent by the Defendant and Reply of Plaintiff as Ex.PW-1/5
and Ex.PW-1/6 respectively.
20.
The Defendant, Mr. Pradeep, examined himself as DW-1, and
proved his defence as stated in hisWritten Statement.
21.
The learned Trial Court, on consideration of the respective evidence,
Suit of the Plaintiff was decreed for a sum of Rs.4,38,100/- along with
pendente lite and future interest @ 5% per annum from the date of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:53
RFA 23/2025
institution of the Suit till realization. The Counter Claim preferred by the
Defendant/Appellant seeking recovery of Rs.1,50,000/- was, however
dismissed vide impugned common Judgment and Decree dated
21.08.2024.
22.
Aggrieved by the impugned common Judgment and Decree dated
21.08.2024,
the
present
Appeal
have
been
preferred
by
the
Appellant/Defendant, Mr. Pradeep, challenging the Decree, as well as the
dismissal of his Counter-Claim.
23.
The grounds of challenge are that the alleged transaction of
Rs.1,00,000/- dated 02.06.2016 was an independent transaction and the
alleged transactions dated 02.06.2016, 23.02.2017 and 28.02.2017, were ex
facie barred by limitation, the Suit having been instituted only on
24.09.2021.
24.
It is further contended that there was no Loan Agreement, as alleged
by the Plaintiff, nor was there any cogent proof to establish that all the
transactions formed part of one composite loan transaction. Each transaction
was independent and distinct. The learned District Judge, therefore, erred in
clubbing all the transactions as one continuous transaction, despite there
being neither any common genesis nor any written Agreement between the
parties.
25.
It is further urged that the Plaint was bad in law for misjoinder of
causes of action and the Suit was liable to be dismissed on this ground
alone.
26.
It is further contended that the learned District Judge erred in
concluding that the Appellant had admitted the alleged loan transaction,
though the same had been categorically denied by him. On the contrary, it
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:53
RFA 23/2025
was the Respondent who had availed a loan of Rs.1,50,000/- from the
Appellant. The learned District Judge failed to appreciate that the bank
statements exhibited as Ex.PW-1/2 and Ex.PW-1/3 had been sent to the
Plaintiff by Mr. Rahul Chaudhary, one of the Directors of M/s Buoyant
Logistics Services Private Limited, which is evident from the Certificate
under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, exhibited as Ex.PW1/4.
27.
It is further urged that there was no plausible explanation as to why
the bank statements of the Plaintiff, exhibited as Ex.PW-1/2 and Ex.PW-1/3,
were sent by Mr. Rahul Chaudhary to the learned counsel for the Plaintiff.
The Plaintiff is very close to Mr. Rahul Chaudhary and was also one of the
shareholders of the Company. The impugned Judgment is erroneous, as it
had erred in not appreciating that Mr. Rahul Chaudhary, was managing and
controlling the Bank Accounts of the Company, as the Company belongs to
his family.
28.
It is further alleged that the amounts reflected in the bank statements
Ex.PW-1/2 and Ex.PW-1/3 as having been transferred to the account of the
Defendant/Appellant, were merely transfers made out of amounts earlier
deposited into the account of the Plaintiff/Respondent, either by Mr. Rahul
Chaudhary or by the Company, of which the Defendant/Appellant was one
of the Directors.
29.
Learned District Judge erred in relying upon the bank statements
Ex.PW-1/2 and Ex.PW-1/3 without the same being formally proved by
summoning the relevant witness from the concerned Bank. It is contended
that the learned Trial Court erroneously treated the said Bank Statements as
conclusive proof, without appreciating that the Plaintiff was not merely an
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:53
RFA 23/2025
employee of the Company, but was also associated with its management and
was one of its shareholders along with Mr. Rahul Chaudhary.
30.
The Respondent, in connivance with Mr. Rahul Chaudhary, had
conspired against him. It is alleged that whenever the Appellant required
money towards expenses incurred in the running of the restaurant or
transport business of the Company, Mr. Rahul Chaudhary or some other
representative of the Company, would transfer the amount into the account
of the Respondent, who would thereafter, transfer the same to the Appellant
with the sole intention of subsequently creating false evidence of personal
loan transactions against him. It is further contended that during her crossexamination, the Respondent failed to satisfactorily answer the questions put
to her regarding Mr. Rahul Chaudhary and gave evasive replies.
31.
It is, therefore, prayed that the impugned Judgment and Decree
dated 21.08.2024 be set aside and the Counter Claim preferred by the
Appellant be decreed.
32.
Per contra, learned counsel for the Respondent has argued that the
advancement of the loan amount stood duly proved from the testimony of
the Plaintiff as well as the admitted bank transactions between the parties
and that the learned District Judge has rightly decreed the Suit and dismissed
the Counter Claim of the Defendant/Appellant.
33.
Learned counsel for the Appellant has argued substantially on the
same lines as urged in the grounds of Appeal and has vehemently contended
that a substantial part of the alleged loan was barred by limitation.
Submissions heard and record perused.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:53
34.
It is the admitted case of the parties that both were working in the
same
Company
RFA 23/2025
and
shared
cordial
relations.
According
to
the
Plaintiff/Respondent, on the request of the Defendant/Appellant, she had
advanced an interest-free loan of Rs.1,00,000/- on 02.06.2016. Thereafter,
on the request of the Defendant/Appellant for a further loan of Rs.5,00,000/on 23.02.2017, she transferred various amounts from time to time, between
23.02.2017 till 07.12.2017, aggregating to Rs.4,88,100/-, which the Plaintiff
asserted was the Loan Amount.
35.
A perusal of the details of the amounts transferred between
23.02.2017 and 07.12.2017, reflect that varying amounts ranging from
Rs.2,000/- to Rs.1,35,000/- were transferred on different dates, during the
year 2017. The nature, frequency and quantum of these transfers,
particularly amounts such as Rs.41,600/-, Rs.2,000/- and Rs.8,000/-, do raise
a question regarding the exact nature of these transactions and the
circumstances under which such amounts came to be transferred to the
Defendant/Appellant.
36.
However, the Defendant/Appellant, both in his Written Statement as
well as in his evidence, has not denied receipt of the aggregate amount of
Rs.4,88,100/- between 23.02.2017 and 07.12.2017. The explanation
furnished by him is that the Plaintiff/Respondent was working in the
Accounts Department of the Company and that amounts used to be
transferred into her account by the Company or through Mr. Rahul
Chaudhary, whereafter the Plaintiff/Respondent used to further transfer the
said amounts, into the account of the Defendant/Appellant, towards day-today expenses of the Company.
37.
The aforesaid explanation does not inspire confidence for the reason
that the Defendant/Appellant himself was one of the Directors of the
Company, whereas the Plaintiff/Respondent was merely working in the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:53
RFA 23/2025
Accounts Department. It does not appeal to common sense that an employee
of a Company, would repeatedly transfer varying amounts from her personal
account into the personal account of one of the Directors, for meeting
Company expenses. There is also no explanation forthcoming as to why
such amounts could not have been directly transferred to the account of the
Defendant/Appellant, if they were genuinely towards Company expenditure.
38.
The rationale behind routing the amounts through the account of the
Plaintiff/Respondent may not be fully comprehensible, however, the
admitted position remains that the aggregate amount stood transferred from
the account of the Plaintiff/Respondent into the account of the
Defendant/Appellant. Once receipt of the said amounts is admitted and no
cogent explanation has been furnished by the Defendant/Appellant regarding
the nature of these transfers, the inevitable conclusion is that the
Defendant/Appellant had received the said amount Rs.4,88,100/- from the
Plaintiff/Respondent and is liable to return the same.
39.
The Defendant/Appellant has alleged collusion between the
Plaintiff/Respondent and Mr. Rahul Chaudhary. However, except for
making bald allegations of connivance, no material has been placed on
record, to substantiate the nature or manner of the alleged collusion. Such
vague allegations, unsupported by any cogent evidence, cannot be accepted.
40.
Learned counsel for the Defendant/Appellant has further argued that
the bank statements Ex.PW-1/2 and Ex.PW-1/3 could not have been relied
upon, since the Certificate under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act,
1872 appended thereto, had been issued by Mr. Karan Singh, Advocate of
the Plaintiff. The said Certificate merely records that the bank statements
had been received by him from Mr. Rahul Chaudhary through WhatsApp
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:53
RFA 23/2025
and is clearly not a Certificate of authentication of Bank Statements of the
Plaintiff.
41.
Moreover, Mr. Rahul Chaudhary was never examined, either to prove
the bank statements or to explain the nature of the transactions reflected
therein.
42.
While this contention has merit, however, even dehors the said bank
statements, the amounts transferred by the Plaintiff/Respondent have been
specifically pleaded, and receipt thereof has substantially been admitted by
the Defendant/Appellant. Even in his evidence, the Defendant/Appellant has
not denied having received an aggregate amount of Rs.4,88,100/- in his
account, during the year 2017.
43.
In
the
absence
of
any
plausible
explanation
from
the
Defendant/Appellant regarding the receipt of these amounts in his account,
it necessarily follows that the Plaintiff/Respondent, from whose account the
said amounts stood transferred, is entitled to seek recovery thereof.
44.
Aplea has been taken by the Defendant that the Suit having been
instituted on 24.09.2021, the alleged loan transaction of Rs.1,00,000/- dated
02.06.2016, as well as the amounts of Rs.30,000/- and Rs.10,000/transferred on 23.02.2017 and 28.02.2017 respectively, were barred by
limitation. This contention merits consideration.
45.
From the testimony of the Plaintiff/Respondent, it emerges that the
initial transaction dated 02.06.2016 of Rs.1,00,000/-, was an independent
transaction. Furthermore, the subsequent amounts were transferred on
different dates and the explanation that all such payments constituted
instalments towards one composite loan transaction demanded by the
Defendant/Appellant on 23.02.2017,does not appear wholly convincing.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:53
RFA 23/2025
These transactions are, therefore, liable to be treated as separate and
independent transactions. Consequently, the amount of Rs.1,00,000/allegedly advanced on 02.06.2016, as well as the amounts of Rs.30,000/and Rs.10,000/- transferred on 23.02.2017 and 28.02.2017 respectively,
totaling Rs.1,40,000/-, are held to bebarred by limitation.
46.
However, insofar as the amounts transferred from 03.04.2017
onwards are concerned, the limitation period for instituting recovery
proceedings expired during the period affected by the COVID-19 pandemic.
The Supreme Court in Suo Motu Writ Petition (Civil) No.3 of 2020,
directed exclusion of the period from 15.03.2020 till 28.02.2022 for the
purposes of limitation. Consequently, after extending the benefit of the
aforesaid orders, the present Suit insofar as it pertains to the amounts
transferred from 03.04.2017 onwards, is within limitation.
47.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, it is held that a sum of
Rs.1,40,000/- was barred by limitation and could not have been decreed in
favour of the Plaintiff/Respondent.
48.
The Appeal is accordingly partly allowed and the decree is modified
for a sum of Rs.2,98,100/- along with interest @ 5% per annum.
49.
Insofar as the Counter Claim preferred by the Defendant/Appellant
seeking
recovery
of
Rs.1,50,000/-,
allegedly
advanced
to
the
Plaintiff/Respondent on 19.10.2020 is concerned, the same does not merit
acceptance. In view of the admitted transfers consistently made by the
Plaintiff/Respondent to the account of the Defendant/Appellant, since the
year 2016, the claim that the Defendant/Appellant independently advanced a
friendly loan of Rs.1,50,000/- to the Plaintiff/Respondent despite having
received amounts totaling to Rs.5,88,100/-, in the absence of any
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:53
RFA 23/2025
documentary evidence or surrounding circumstances substantiating the
same, does not inspire confidence.
50.
The learned District Judge has thus, rightly disbelieved the same
and dismissed the Counter Claim.
Conclusion:
51.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the Appeal is partly allowed to
the extent that the decretal amount stands reduced from Rs.4,38,100/- to
Rs.2,98,100/- along with interest @ 5% per annum.
52.
Pending Applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JUNE 01, 2026/R
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:53
RFA 23/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review