Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
#
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 16.09.2026
CNR No. DLHC010437762026
W.P.(C) 13480/2026
MR. NITIN NARESH
Through:
versus
.....Petitioner
Petitioner in person.
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH THE SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
HOME AFFAIRS AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through:
Mr. Chetan Sharma, ASG along with
Mr. Nishant Gautam, CGSC, Mr.
Amit Kumar Rana, G.P., Mr. Amit
Gupta, Ms. Kavya Shukla, Mr. Vineet
Negi & Mr. Vibhav V. Nath,
Advocates for Respondent Nos.1, 3 &
4.
Mr. Sameer Vashisht, Standing
Counsel (Civil) for GNCTD.
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ. (ORAL)
1.
Heard the petitioner who appears in person.
2.
The petitioner has invoked our jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India ostensibly in public interest, seeking a prayer to issue a
direction to the respondents to consider and dispose of the representation
said to have been made by him on 20.07.2026 by furnishing a reasoned and
speaking reply within a period of two weeks.
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:51:15
W.P.(C) 13480/2026
3.
Another prayer made in the writ petition is that the respondents be
directed to preserve all CCTV footage, body worn camera footage, wireless
logs, control room records, deployment records, detention records and all
other electronic and official records relating to the events of 20.07.2026,
pending disposal of his representation.
4.
The representation dated 20.07.2026 in respect of which a prayer has
been made for issuing a direction to decide the same has been annexed as
Annexure – 10 to the writ petition which is addressed to the Hon‟ble
Lieutenant Governor of Delhi, Hon‟ble Union Minister for Home Affairs,
Union Home Secretary, Commissioner of Police, Delhi. It is also addressed
to the Director General, Central Reserve Police Force, Inspector General,
Rapid Action Force, Director General, Railway Protection Force, Secretary,
Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Chairperson/Secretary, Press
Council of India, Director, Central Forensic Science Laboratory, Editor-inChief/Chief Executive Officer/Grievance Officer, ANI (which appears to be
a news agency), Editors and grievance officers of the media organisations
and Chairperson, National Human Rights Commission.
5.
The representation inter alia states that in relation to certain crowd
control action taken by Delhi Police on 20.07.2026, the Delhi Police
recklessly issued a false and materially misleading statement which
constitutes a grave institutional failure. The representation refers to a
statement published by Delhi Police on its official X account on 20.07.2026
wherein it has been stated that, ―Some segments from media have mentioned
sporadic use of violence/detention at Jantar Mantar by Delhi Police. It is
informed that no such incident has taken place and protest is being handled
professionally. All are requested not to fall prey to any rumour/misgivings,
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:51:15
W.P.(C) 13480/2026
and, to assist Delhi Police in maintaining peace and public order at and
around the site.‖
6.
The petitioner has submitted that the said statement is absolutely false
which is belied by various media reports which reported that a clash
involving RPF personnel took place and further that RPF personnel and
police used lathis for crowd control. Certain other media reports have also
been referred to in the said representation and accordingly, it has been stated
that contradiction by Delhi Police statement published on its official X
account vis-à-vis the media reports is dangerous and accordingly, it has been
prayed that the petitioner be granted personal or virtual hearing by the
authorities while considering the said representation and provide and Action
Taken Report to him within 15 days and further take a reasoned decision on
the prayers made in the said representation.
7.
The very basis of the instant petition are the media reports which
according to the petitioner contradict the statement published by Delhi
Police on its official X account in relation to crowd control measures taken
by the Delhi Police at Jantar Mantar on 20.07.2026.
8.
The statement published on the official Delhi Police X account is
extracted herein below:
―Some segments from media have mentioned sporadic use of
violence/detentions at Jantar Mantar by Delhi Police. It is informed that
no such incident has taken place and protest is being handled
professionally. All are requested not to fall prey to any rumour/
misgivings, and, to assist Delhi Police in maintaining peace and public
order at and around the site.‖
9.
What all has been stated in the said statement by Delhi Police is that
the reporting made by certain segments of media regarding sporadic use of
violence/detentions at Jantar Mantar by Delhi Police was not correct and
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:51:15
W.P.(C) 13480/2026
further that no such incident had taken place and that the protest was being
handled professionally. The statement also records a request made by Delhi
Police to all to not to fall prey to any rumour/misgivings and to assist Delhi
Police in maintaining peace and public order. The foresaid statement made
by Delhi Police in our opinion appears to be a routine statement as a
measure aimed at crowd control management.
10.
Relying on the media reports, an attempt appears to have been made
by the petitioner to make a mountain out of a mole. No official statement by
the central police forces has been enclosed by the petitioner. In any case,
such measures form part of essential exercise by the Delhi Police or any
other police force which is required as a crowd control measure.
11.
We are also of the opinion that in the light of the complexity of the
situation which might have arisen on 20.07.2026 at Jantar Mantar, getting an
inquiry conducted, as to whether the statement made by Delhi Police is
incorrect or not, does not serve any public purpose. As a matter of fact,
larger question is as to whether, the authorities of Delhi Police used force
disproportionate to what the situation warranted on the spot at that particular
time. The concern of the petitioner is confined only in respect of the
statement published by Delhi Police on 20.07.2026 which has been quoted
above.
12.
The jurisprudence surrounding public interest litigation in our country
has evolved over a period of time by Hon‟ble Supreme Court and various
other High Courts in the country; primarily to provide a forum to take up the
issues concerning disadvantaged sections of the society relaxing the rule of
locus.
13.
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:51:15
The primary object of a Public Interest Litigation Petition is to permit
W.P.(C) 13480/2026
a public spirited citizen to take up the issues concerning persons belonging
to disadvantaged sections of the society who for various reasons, such as on
account of poverty, illiteracy etc. are unable to take up their causes before
the Courts. In a way, public interest litigation is a means to provide access to
Courts of law and to justice.
14.
The issue raised in this petition in our opinion does not serve any
larger public interest and such petitions only result in wastage of judicial
time. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of Holicow Pictures (P) Ltd.
v. Prem Chandra Mishra, (2007) 14 SCC 281 has discussed the scope and
purpose of Public Interest Litigation Petition in detail and has also quoted
the judgment in Janata Dal v. H.S. Chowdhary, (1992) 4 SCC 305
extensively. Paragraph 12 of the said judgment observes that while genuine
litigants with legitimate grievances relating to civil matters involving
properties worth hundreds of millions of rupees and criminal cases in which
persons sentenced to death facing gallows under untold agony and persons
sentenced to life imprisonment and kept in incarceration for long years
suffer from undue delay awaiting disposal of their cases, are standing in a
long queue for years with the hope of getting into the Courts and having
their grievances redressed, the busybodies, the meddlesome interlopers and
wayfarers having no public interest except for personal gain either of
themselves or as a proxy for others or for any other extraneous motivation
for glare of publicity etc. break the queue by filing public interest litigation
and get into the Courts by filing vexations and frivolous petitions.
15.
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court goes on to observe that such attempt by
camouflaged Public Interest Litigation Petitions criminally waste the
valuable time of the Courts, as a result of which the queue standing outside
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:51:15
W.P.(C) 13480/2026
the doors of the Courts never move. The observations made in paragraph 12
of the said judgment are extracted herein below:
―12. It is depressing to note that on account of such trumpery proceedings
initiated before the courts, innumerable days are wasted, which time
otherwise could have been spent for the disposal of cases of the genuine
litigants. Though we spare no efforts in fostering and developing the
laudable concept of PIL and extending our long arm of sympathy to the
poor, the ignorant, the oppressed and the needy whose fundamental rights
are infringed and violated and whose grievances go unnoticed,
unrepresented and unheard; yet we cannot avoid but express our opinion
that while genuine litigants with legitimate grievances relating to civil
matters involving properties worth hundreds of millions of rupees and
criminal cases in which persons sentenced to death facing gallows under
untold agony and persons sentenced to life imprisonment and kept in
incarceration for long years, persons suffering from undue delay in
service matters—government or private, persons awaiting the disposal of
cases wherein huge amounts of public revenue or unauthorised collection
of tax amounts are locked up, detenu expecting their release from the
detention orders, etc. etc. are all standing in a long serpentine queue for
years with the fond hope of getting into the courts and having their
grievances redressed, the busybodies, meddlesome interlopers, wayfarers
or officious interveners having absolutely no public interest except for
personal gain or private profit either of themselves or as a proxy of others
or for any other extraneous motivation or for glare of publicity, break the
queue muffing their faces by wearing the mask of public interest litigation
and get into the courts by filing vexatious and frivolous petitions and thus
criminally waste the valuable time of the courts and as a result of which
the queue standing outside the doors of the courts never moves, which
piquant situation creates frustration in the minds of the genuine litigants
and resultantly they lose faith in the administration of our judicial
system.‖
16.
There is yet another reason why we are not inclined to entertain this
writ petition. The issue regarding alleged excessive and disproportionate use
of force by Delhi Police, paramilitary and other security agencies, against
the protesters assembled at Jantar Mantar and at various other locations
across the country is already engaging the attention of the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court in W.P.(Crl.) 280/2026, Shailendra Mani Tripathi Vs. Union of
India along with other connected writ petitions. Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:51:15
W.P.(C) 13480/2026
the said matter vide order dated 18.08.2026 has constituted a High Powered
Enquiry Committee (hereinafter referred to as the „HPEC’) which is
chaired by an Hon‟ble retired judge of the Supreme Court, Hon‟ble Mr.
Justice R.Subhash Reddy, the HPEC also comprises of a former Chief
Justice of Punjab and Haryana High Court, Hon‟ble Mr. Justice Ravi
Shankar Jha and Hon‟ble Ms. Shalinder Kaur a former judge of this Court
along with other members. The said order also outlines the issues to be
considered by the HPEC which are extracted here under:
“b. Issues to be considered by the HPEC
12. On the issues to be deliberated upon by the HPEC, the parties were
afforded wide latitude to place before us their respective suggestions.
Having perused the material placed on record by all the parties, we have
been able to broadly segregate the issues emphasised by the Petitioners
that call for consideration as follows:
i. The use of excessive force and violence against protestors by police
authorities and other agencies, including the deployment of pellet
guns, electric batons, lathi charges, and tear gas without adequate
warning or proportionality, resulting in severe bodily harm and
injuries, some of which are alleged to be of a grievous and lasting
nature;
ii. The question of ensuring a proportionate and measured police
response during protests, public gatherings, and peaceful assemblies,
so as to strike an appropriate balance between the maintenance of
public order and the constitutional right to peaceful dissent;
iii. The desirability of banning the use of metallic kinetic projectiles or
pellets fired from pump-action rifles or projectile-action guns, having
regard to the grave and, at times, irreversible bodily harm occasioned
by their deployment against protestors;
iv. The necessity of ensuring that police and security personnel wear
proper uniforms and visible nameplates at the time of effecting arrests
or using force during crowd- control operations, so as to secure
accountability and enable the identification of individual officers;
v. An enquiry into the allegations pertaining to the monitoring and
surveillance of protestors by police personnel, and the extent to which
such measures, if undertaken, were consistent with the protestors’
constitutional rights to privacy and free assembly
vi. The alleged incidents of targeted violence, harassment, molestation
and/or any secondary victimisation directed against female protestors,
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:51:15
W.P.(C) 13480/2026
which, given the gravity and sensitivity of the allegations, warrant a
focused and expeditious enquiry;
vii. The provision of medical and other requisite support, including award
of compensation, to victims of alleged police abuse, including the
manner and adequacy of such support extended thus far;
viii. Regulation of the issuance of blanket prohibitory orders under Section
163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, so as to
prevent their use as a routine or pre-emptive measure that forecloses
the exercise of the right to peaceful assembly rather than as a
genuine, proportionate response to a real and imminent threat to
public order; and
ix. The establishment of strict constitutional thresholds and safeguards to
prevent Section 152 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 from being
invoked as an instrument to stifle political dissent and peaceful
protest, thereby ensuring that the provision remains confined to its
intended purpose and is not permitted to operate as a chilling
restraint upon constitutionally protected speech and assembly.”
17.
Having regard to the nature of prayer made in this petition which is
confined to certain statement made by Delhi Police in relation to crowd
control measures, we are of the opinion, as already observed above, that the
petition does not evoke any larger public interest. While we make such
observation, we do not intend to trivialise the issue raised herein, however,
such matters can better be left to the authorities while reviewing such
actions in introspection.
18.
For all the aforesaid reasons, we are not inclined to entertain this
Public Interest Litigation Petition, which is hereby dismissed.
19.
There will be no order as to costs.
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ
TEJAS KARIA, J
SEPTEMBER 16, 2026/MJ
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
10:51:15
W.P.(C) 13480/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review