Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 09.12.2025
Date of decision: 12.01.2026
W.P.(CRL) 3529/2025 & CRL.M.A. 32015/2025
MR GAUTAM MONDAL THROUGH HIS WIFE MRS ASHIMA
MUKHERJEE MONDAL
....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Kaustub Narendran with Mr.
Rohan Naik, Mr. Aayush Mitruka, Ms.
Lisa
Mishra,
Mr.
Vipulaaksh
Moondra, Mr. Arudhra Rao and Mr.
Marmik Shah, Advocates.
versus
1.
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH ITS STANDING COUNSEL & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Abhishek Gupta, CGSC for UOI
with Mr. Kumar Kartikya, Advocates
for respondent Nos.1 and 2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIVEK CHAUDHARY
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ JAIN
JUDGMENT
The present petition is filed, under Article 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India, for a writ of Certiorari to quash the Detention Order
dated 20.03.2025 passed by the respondent No. 2, Joint Secretary,
Department of Revenue, Ministry of finance, Government of India, as well as
the Memorandum dated 24.09.2025 and subsequent Memorandum dated
15.10.2025, passed by respondent No. 2, whereby the representations of the
petitioner were rejected and for writ in the nature of Habeas Corpus, directing
the respondent authorities to produce him from their custody at Central Jail,
Jaipur, Rajasthan and set him at liberty.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:14:27
W.P.(CRL) 3529/2025
2.
Briefly stated, the petitioner, a resident of West Bengal, was arrested in
the year 2024 in connection with three separate criminal cases, one being
registered at Narcotics Control Bureau, Kolkata Zonal Unit, second at Police
Station Gaighata, Parganas, West Bengal, and third at Police Station
Bhadreswar, West Bengal, under Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1988. During the pendency of said criminal cases, in order to
prevent the petitioner from indulging into further criminal activities and illicit
trafficking of contrabands, proceedings were initiated by respondent No. 3,
Narcotics Control Bureau, Kolkata, under the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in
Narcotics Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988 (“PITNDPS”). The
same culminated in the issuance of impugned Detention Order dated
20.03.2025 by respondent No. 2. Admittedly, the petitioner and his family is
resident of Parganas, West Bengal and the authority, respondent No. 3, who
took the cognizance and has records of the criminal cases, being the root
cause of the matter, is also situated at West Bengal.
3.
Pursuant thereto, the petitioner was taken into preventive custody and
detained at Central Jail, Jaipur, Rajasthan, wherein he was served with the
grounds of detention and other relevant documents. Subsequent thereto, his
case was referred to State Advisory Board (PITNDPS), Rajasthan, which by
its report dated 01.09.2025, found sufficient cause for detention, whereupon
the Central Government confirmed the detention for a period of one year from
25.06.2025.
4.
His representations, in furtherance thereof, were rejected by impugned
Memorandum dated 24.09.2025 and Memorandum dated 15.10.2025, leading
to the filing of the present writ petition.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:14:27
W.P.(CRL) 3529/2025
5.
At the outset, a preliminary objection, as to the maintainability of the
present petition, was raised by the respondent Nos. 1 and 2. Learned Counsel
submitted that the impugned Detention Order was passed in furtherance of all
the offences committed by the petitioner in the territorial jurisdiction of West
Bengal. Moreover, the order was executed in Kolkata, West Bengal and the
petitioner was detained at Jaipur, Rajasthan, where the grounds of detention
were served upon him.
6.
He submitted that merely because the Central Government is situated at
Delhi, and for the said reason the impugned Order and the Memoranda were
passed in Delhi, this Court is not the appropriate forum to exercise its
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. Furthermore,
applying the doctrine of Forum Conveniens, the petition ought to have been
filed at High Court of Calcutta, within whose jurisdiction all the cases against
the petitioner are pending or at High Court of Rajasthan, where the petitioner
is detained. To buttress his arguments, the learned counsel has placed reliance
on Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. vs. Union of India and Another, 2004 6 SCC
254.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner, vehemently opposing the said
objection, submitted that since one of the causes of action has also occurred at
Delhi as the impugned Order and Memoranda were passed at Delhi, the
present petition is maintainable before this Court. Reliance has been placed
on:
i.
Smt. Ramadevi vs. K.A. Gafoor & Ors., 1975 SCC OnLine Del
162.
ii.
Harish Taneja vs. Union of India & Ors., 1983 SCC OnLine
Del 237.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:14:27
W.P.(CRL) 3529/2025
iii.
Ramchand Santumal Bhatia vs. Tarun Roy & Ors., 1987 SCC
OnLine Bom 218.
iv.
Jamal Haji Jakaria vs. Union of India& Ors., (1988) ILR 2
Delhi 243.
v.
Malini Mukesh Vora vs. Union of India & Ors., 2009 SCC
OnLine Del 1799.
vi.
Naushad Ali through PerokarSahajad Ali vs. Union of India &
Ors., 2024 SCC OnLine Del 1141.
8.
We have heard the learned counsel for the parties to the extent of
maintainability of the present petition and perused the record.
9.
So far as the judgments relied upon by learned counsel for the
petitioner are concerned, they uniformly hold that any Court within whose
territorial jurisdiction even a part of the cause of action has arisen is
competent to entertain a writ petition. There can be no quarrel with the said
proposition. It is also undisputed that since the impugned order was passed
within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court, this Court does possess the
jurisdiction to entertain the present petition. However, the objection raised is
not to the existence of jurisdiction, but to the exercise thereof, contending that
whether applying the doctrine of forum conveniens, this Court ought to
exercise its discretionary jurisdiction in hearing the present petition or refuse
it.
10.
A single judge bench of this Court, in case of Bharat Nidhi Limited vs.
Securities and Exchange Board of India & Ors., 2023 SCC OnLine Del
8586, has comprehensively examined the scope of Article 226 as under:
“64. A perusal of Clause 2 of Article 226 indicates that
the writ jurisdiction can be exercised by the High Court
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:14:27
W.P.(CRL) 3529/2025
primarily in relation to the territories within which the
cause of action, wholly or in part arises. However, the
location of such Government or authority or residence
of such person, outside the territories of the High Court
will not deter the High Court from issuing the
appropriate writ.
65. The introduction of Clause (2) in Article 226 of the
Constitution of India widened the width of the area for
issuance of writs by different High Courts, however, the
same cannot be construed to completely dilute the
original intent of the Constitution makers which is
succinctly encapsulated in Clause (1) of Article 226.
Rather, Clause (2) is an enabling provision, which
supplements Clause (1) to empower the High Courts to
ensure an effective enforcement of fundamental rights
or any other legal right. Therefore, the power of judicial
review cannot be circumscribed by the location of the
authority against whom the writ is issued, however, the
same does not mean that the constitutional mandate
enshrined under Article 226 (1) can be completely
neglected or whittled down.”
********
“67. Thus, the salient aspects which emerge out of the
aforesaid discussion can be delineated forthwith as: (i)
Article 226(2) does not take away the right of a High
Court to dismiss a case on grounds of forum
non-conveniens.
The
principles
of
forum
non-conveniens and that of Article 226(2) operate in
different field, where Article 226(2) (originally Article
226(1A)) was inserted to solve the problem of a litigant
needing to go to a High Court where the seat of
government authority was present. (ii) In other words,
merely because Article 226(2) allows jurisdiction to be
conferred on a High Court in the absence of the seat of a
government authority being under its jurisdiction; this
does not in itself mean that the presence of a seat shall
automatically grant jurisdiction. (iii) Article 226(2)
allows jurisdiction to be conferred if the cause of action,
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:14:27
W.P.(CRL) 3529/2025
either in part or whole, had arisen in the jurisdiction of
a High Court, however, where the purported cause of
action is so minuscule so as to make a particular High
Court non- convenient, it is then that the concept of
forum non conveniens applies.”
******
92. It is also a settled proposition of the law that the
location
where
the
tribunal/appellate
authority/revisional authority is situated would not be
the sole consideration to determine the situs of the
accrual of cause of action, ignoring the concept of
forum conveniens in toto. Hence, even if a small part of
the cause of action is established, and the same is found
to be nonintegral or non-material to the lis, the court
may invoke the doctrine of forum non-conveniens and
decline to exercise its writ jurisdiction, if an alternative,
more efficacious forum for the same exists.
93. A perusal of paragraph no. 10 of the decision in the
case of State of Goa (supra), would signify that one of
the prayers related to a challenge against the
notification issued by the State of Sikkim. Also, in the
said case, the petitioner company's office was also
located in the State of Sikkim. However, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court while considering that a slender part of
the action has arisen, held that the High Court of Sikkim
was not clothed with the requisite jurisdiction to
entertain the petition as the major part of the cause of
action has arisen in another High Court. It can be safely
concluded that neither the notification issued by the
concerned government, nor the location of the office
were considered to be the material facts to determine
the cause of action.
11.
The aforesaid decision of this Court in case of Bharat Nidhi was
challenged in LPA bearing No. 47 of 2024, wherein the Division Bench of
this Court has affirmed the view taken by the learned Single Judge as under:
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:14:27
W.P.(CRL) 3529/2025
“21. The High Court while exercising its jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to
entertain a writ petition, in addition to examining its
territorial jurisdiction also examines if the said Court is
the forum conveniens to the parties. The issue of forum
conveniens is seen not only from the perspective of the
writ petitioner but it is to be seen from the convenience
of all the parties before the Court. In the facts of this
case, as is evident from the record that the forum
conveniens for the both the parties is Mumbai. The
Appellants since the year 2020 have been appearing in
Mumbai before SEBI in the SCN proceedings. In
W.P.(C) 15556/2023 (as well as the other writs) the writ
petitioner has sought a direction for summoning the
records of SEBI for examining the legality and validity
of the Impugned Revocation Order. In these facts,
therefore, the objection of SEBI that Mumbai is the
forum conveniens for the parties has merit. The
obligation of the Court to examine the convenience of
all the parties has been expressly noted by the Full
Bench of this Court in Sterling Agro Industries Ltd.
(supra)…”
12.
The aforesaid reveals that the jurisdiction of a High Court is not solely
determined on the basis of the location/situs of the authority. Moreso, even if
the cause of action has arisen within the territorial jurisdiction of a particular
High Court, the High Court may exercise its discretion, applying the doctrine
of forum conveniens.
13.
The concept of forum conveniens was identified in the case of Kusum
Ingots, as under:
“Forum conveniens
30. We must, however, remind ourselves that even if a
small part of cause of action arises within the territorial
jurisdiction of the High Court, the same by itself may
not be considered to be a determinative factor
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:14:27
W.P.(CRL) 3529/2025
compelling the High Court to decide the matter on
merit. In appropriate cases, the Court may refuse to
exercise its discretionary jurisdiction by invoking the
doctrine of forum conveniens. [See Bhagat Singh Bugga
v. Dewan Jagbir Sawhney [AIR 1941 Cal 670 : ILR
(1941) 1 Cal 490] , Madanlal Jalan v. Madanlal
[(1945) 49 CWN 357 : AIR 1949 Cal 495] , Bharat
Coking Coal Ltd. v. Jharia Talkies & Cold Storage (P)
Ltd. [1997 CWN 122] , S.S. Jain & Co. v. Union of India
[(1994) 1 CHN 445] and New Horizons Ltd. v. Union of
India [AIR 1994 Del 126] .]”
14.
The said principle has been reiterated by the Supreme Court in case of
Ambica Industries vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, (2007) 6 SCC
769,the relevant extract of the same is as below:
“41. Keeping in view the expression “cause of action”
used in Clause (2) of Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, indisputably even if a small fraction thereof
accrues within the jurisdiction of the Court, the Court
will have jurisdiction in the matter though the doctrine
of forum conveniens may also have to be considered.
42. In Mussummat Chand Kour v. Partab Singh
[(1887-88) 15 IA 156] , it was held: (IA pp. 157-58)
“[T]he cause of action has no relation whatever to the
defence which may be set up by the defendant, nor does
it depend upon the character of the relief prayed for by
the plaintiff. It refers entirely to the grounds set forth in
the plaint as the cause of action, or, in other words, to
the media upon which the plaintiff asks the court to
arrive at a conclusion in his favour.”
15.
Further, the said principle was authoritatively reiterated by a Full
Bench of this Court in Sterling Agro Industries Ltd. vs. Union of India, 2011
SCC OnLine Del 3162, wherein it has been held that even if a minuscule part
of the cause of action arises within the jurisdiction of the Court, the same is
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:14:27
W.P.(CRL) 3529/2025
not determinative, and the doctrine of forum conveniens must be applied
depending upon the factual matrix of each case. The relevant extract of the
said case is reproduced as under:
“35. In view of the aforesaid analysis, we are inclined to
modify the findings and conclusions of the Full Bench in
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Union of India, AIR
2010 Delhi 43 ; [2011] 166 C-C 87 (Delhi) and proceed
to state our conclusions in seriatim as follows:
(a) The finding recorded by the Full Bench that the
sole cause of action emerges at the place or
location
where
the
Tribunal/appellate
authority/revisional authority is situate and the
said High Court (i.e., Delhi High Court) cannot
decline to entertain the writ petition as that would
amount to failure of the duty of the court cannot be
accepted inasmuch as such a finding is totally
based on the situs of the Tribunal/appellate
authority/revisional authority totally ignoring the
concept of forum conveniens.
(b) Even if a minuscule part of cause of action
arises within the jurisdiction of this court, a writ
petition would be maintainable before this court,
however, the cause of action has to be understood
as per the ratio laid down in the case of Alchemist
Ltd. v. State Bank of Sikkim (2007) 136 C-C 665 ;
(2007) 11 SCC 335.
(c) An order of the appellate authority constitutes a
part of cause of action to make the writ petition
maintainable in the High Court within whose
jurisdiction the appellate authority is situated. Yet,
the same may not be the singular factor to compel
the High Court to decide the matter on merits. The
High Court may refuse to exercise its discretionary
jurisdiction by invoking the doctrine of forum
conveniens.
(d) The conclusion that where the appellate or
revisional authority is located constitutes the place
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:14:27
W.P.(CRL) 3529/2025
of forum conveniens as stated in absolute terms by
the Full Bench is not correct as it will vary from
case to case and depend upon the lis in question.
(e) The finding that the court may refuse to
exercise jurisdiction under article 226 if only the
jurisdiction is invoked in a mala fide manner is too
restricted/constricted as the exercise of the power
under article 226 being discretionary cannot be
limited or restricted to the ground of mala fide
alone.
(f) While entertaining a writ petition, the doctrine
of forum conveniens and the nature of cause of
action are required to be scrutinised by the High
Court depending upon the factual matrix of each
case in view of what has been stated in Ambica
Industries v. CCE (2007) 213 ELT 323 ; [2009] 20
VST 1 (SC) and Union of India v. Adani Exports
Ltd. (2002) 1 SCC 567.
(g) The conclusion of the earlier decision of the
Full Bench in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v.
Union of India, AIR 2010 Delhi 43 ; (2011) 166
C-C 87 (Delhi) (page 115) :".. . that since the
original order merges into the appellate order, the
place where the appellate authority is located is
also forum conveniens" is not correct.
(h) Any decision of this court contrary to the
conclusions enumerated hereinabove stands
overruled.”
16.
From the cumulative perusal of the aforesaid precedents, it emerges
that the litigant, being dominus litis, is entitled to approach the jurisdiction of
his choice, where cause of action arises in two or more jurisdictions, however,
it is upon the Court’s discretion to exercise such jurisdiction, while keeping in
mind whether it constitutes an appropriate and convenient forum for
adjudication or not.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:14:27
W.P.(CRL) 3529/2025
17.
Applying the aforesaid settled legal principles to the facts of the present
case, it is evident that both the petitioner and the State Authority (respondent
No. 3), on whose report the criminal cases and impugned proceedings were
initiated, are situated in the State of West Bengal. The criminal cases forming
the predicate offences for issuance of the impugned Detention Order are
pending within the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court of Calcutta, and
the relevant records pertaining to the petitioner, his alleged criminal
antecedents, and the said cases are also located in West Bengal. Furthermore,
the petitioner has failed to disclose any cogent reason justifying invocation of
the jurisdiction of this Court.
18.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court refuses to exercise its
discretionary extraordinary jurisdiction, applying the doctrine of forum
conveniens, and disposes of the present petition with liberty to the petitioner
to approach the appropriate Court/forum.
19.
Pending application(s), if any, also stand(s) disposed of.
20.
Needless to state that notwithstanding dismissal of the present writ
petition by this Court, it will be open to the petitioner to raise his dispute and
seek redressal of his grievances by instituting appropriate proceedings before
any other Court/forum including before the jurisdictional High Court.
VIVEK CHAUDHARY
(JUDGE)
MANOJ JAIN
(JUDGE)
JANUARY 12, 2026/kp/ht
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:14:27
W.P.(CRL) 3529/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review