Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 22.07.2026
Pronounced on: 16.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010975142024
+
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 439/2024 & CM APPL. 75595/2024
MR BRIJESH RAJKUMAR SUIRI
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr.
Prakash
Advocate
Chandra,
versus
MRS. NAVITA BRIJESH SURI
Through: None.
.....Respondent
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIVEK CHAUDHARY
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE RENU BHATNAGAR
JUDGMENT
1.
The present appeal has been filed under Section 19(1) of the
Family Courts Act, 1984 read with Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage
Act, 1955 (hereinafter referred to as “HMA”) assailing the Order
dated 12.11.2024 passed by learned Principal Judge, Family Courts,
Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi, in HMA No. 165/2021 titled
as Navita Brijesh Suri v. Brijesh Rajkumar Suri, whereby, the
application filed under Section 24 of the HMA was disposed of
directing the appellant husband to pay a sum of Rs. 5,000/- per month
as pendente lite maintenance to the respondent wife from the date of
filing of the application, i.e., from 08.01.2021 till disposal of the
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 439/2024
Signed By:BABINDER
SINGH NEGI
14:21:34
divorce petition.
2.
The brief facts necessary for adjudication of the present appeal
are that the marriage between the parties got solemnized on
25.10.2015 according to Hindu rites and rituals. Out of the said
wedlock, one girl child was born on 26.08.2016 who is in the custody
of the respondent. Due to marital discord, the parties are living
separately
since
11.11.2020.
Subsequently
thereafter,
the
respondent preferred a petition under Section 13 (1)(ia) of the
HMA seeking divorce on grounds of cruelty, along with an
application under Section 24 of the HMA and in the said application,
the impugned order was passed which is under challenge before this
Bench in this appeal.
3.
Learned counsel for the appellant submitted to the effect that
the impugned order is bad in law as well as in facts and circumstances
of the present case. It is submitted that the respondent is financially
stable as admitted by her in her petition seeking custody under Section
25 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, as well as in her complaint
filed under Section 12 of the Protection of Women from Domestic
Violence Act, 2005. It is stated that admittedly, the respondent had
worked in a Bata showroom from the month of March 2020 to June
2024 and hence, the decision of the learned Family Court in granting
interim maintenance of Rs. 5,000/- per month from the date of filing
of the application under Section 24 of HMA, i.e., 08.01.2021,
is erroneous and liable to be set aside.
4.
It
is contended
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 439/2024
Signed By:BABINDER
SINGH NEGI
14:21:34
that
the
learned
Family
Court failed
to acknowledge that the appellant is himself financially dependent on
his father as he is earning a meagre amount of Rs. 16,500/- per month
by working as an Operator at his father’s small photostat shop. It is
further his case that he also has responsibility to take care of his
daughter as she is in the care and custody of the appellant, and her
monthly expenses range from Rs. 8,000/- to Rs. 10,000/- which are
borne entirely by him.
5.
Learned counsel for the appellant also submitted that the
learned Family Court erred in assessing the income of the appellant at
Rs. 22,000/- per month, solely based on Notification dated 26.09.2024
issued by the Government of NCT of Delhi (hereinafter as
“GNCTD”) as the appellant is neither a resident of Delhi nor
employed therein as he is residing in Jagadhari, Haryana and thus,
would not be governed by the minimum wages prevailing in Delhi.
6.
Further, it
is
contended
that the appellant
is
merely
a
matriculate with no professional or technical qualifications and,
therefore, he ought to have been treated as an unskilled worker for the
purpose of income assessment.
7.
It is further contended that the learned Family Court failed
to appreciate the inherent inconsistency in the respondent's own
pleadings. It is submitted that while the respondent claimed to be
employed only on Saturdays and Sundays, earning a monthly income
of merely ₹7,000/-, however, she simultaneously asserted in her
application under Section 24 of the HMA that her monthly expenses
amounted to ₹39,500/-. Thus, the learned Family Court overlooked a
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 439/2024
Signed By:BABINDER
SINGH NEGI
14:21:34
material contradiction which directly impacted the assessment of her
financial status for the purpose of granting a relief under Section 24.
8.
Neither the respondent is appearing nor has he filed a reply
despite grant of opportunity.
9.
Heard learned counsel for the appellant and perused the record.
10.
The principles governing the grant of interim maintenance are
well-settled. It is often seen that the spouses do not reflect their true
and correct income, making the task of Family Court difficult to
assess the correct income of the spouses and as such, the Family Court
has to make the assessment of income on some guess work.
11.
In the case of Jasbir Kaur Sehgal v. District Judge Dehradun
& Ors., reported as (1997) 7 SCC 7, the Supreme Court has
recognized the fact that the spouses in the proceedings for
maintenance do not truthfully disclose their true income and therefore,
some guess work on the part of the Court is permissible. Further, the
Supreme Court has also observed that considering the diverse claims
made by the parties, one inflating the income and the other
suppressing, an element of conjecture and guess work does enter for
arriving at the income of the husband. It cannot be done by any
mathematical precision. Relevant extract of the aforesaid case is
reproduced hereinbelow:
“7. The husband has filed his counter-affidavit
in the appeal before us and on our direction
both the parties have filed additional
affidavits. On one date when this appeal came
up for hearing we were told that the husband
had left that morning itself for Canada for
further treatment after his bypass surgery in
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 439/2024
Signed By:BABINDER
SINGH NEGI
14:21:34
India and that his expenses for visiting
Canada as well as the expenses for treatment
there were being met by his friend. In his
affidavit the husband has stated that his friend
Santokh Singh who is a resident of Canada
paid his fare. He is, however, silent about the
expenses, if any, met by Santokh Singh for his
treatment in Canada. A copy of the statutory
declaration of Santokh Singh which is dated
21-3-1997 has also been filed. In this Santokh
Singh does say that he has undertaken to bear
the cost of passage and maintenance of the
respondent during his stay in Canada and
North America. It is a matter of common
knowledge that medical treatment in Canada
is high and an ordinary person cannot afford
the expenses which are met by taking medical
insurance. As to what expenses the husband
incurred for his bypass surgery in India has
not been disclosed. On our query as to how
much foreign exchange the husband obtained
while going to Canada, it was stated that 1350
U.S. Dollars were obtained at a cost of about
Rs 50,000. From where all these monies came
from we are left in the dark. The husband has
not filed any certificate of his salary from his
present employer though the wife has
contended that both the firms, Mukul Overseas
Pvt. Ltd. and Mukul International Pvt. Ltd. are
owned by the husband himself which fact the
husband has denied. Though we are not
concerned with the income of his son which is
stated to be Rs 7500 per month, it would have
been better if the husband had given complete
details as to the perquisites enjoyed by his son,
the rent he is paying for his rented
accommodation at Safdarjung Enclave and the
like. The claim of the husband that though his
house in NOIDA fell vacant in January 1996,
it has neither been further let nor is the
husband himself living there because of
certain repairs and on that account he is
residing with his son does not appeal to us. It
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 439/2024
Signed By:BABINDER
SINGH NEGI
14:21:34
does appear to us from the affidavit of the
husband that it conceals more than what it
tells of his income and other assets. Attempt
has been made to conceal his true income and
that leads us to draw an adverse inference
against the husband about his income that it is
much more than what is being disclosed to us.
The claim of the husband that from an income
of Rs 4750 per month which he is getting from
Mukul International Pvt. Ltd. he has to
maintain himself, his two sons and daughter is
absurd particularly when the eldest son is
earning more than the husband and it is the
husband who is living with him. The husband
has also not disclosed retiral benefits, if any,
from ONGC and the amount of provident fund
he obtained from there. The husband has
interest income from the Unit Trust of India
and also from the fixed deposit receipts but
again he has not disclosed the number of units
he is holding and the amount of the fixed
deposits in his name. From all this we have to
hold that the annual income of the respondenthusband is even on a modest estimate to be Rs
2,40,000 annually which would come to Rs
20,000 per month. Considering the diverse
claims made by the parties, one inflating the
income and the other suppressing, an
element of conjecture and guesswork does
enter for arriving at the income of the
husband. It cannot be done by any
mathematical precision.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
12.
Further, in the case of Rajnesh v. Neha, (2021) 2 SCC 324, the
Apex Court streamlined the disclosure of norms by mandating
comprehensive affidavits of assets and liabilities to minimize blind
guess work. The Apex Court, referring to the judgment of Bharat
Hedge v. Saroj Hedge, 2007 SCC OnLine Del 622, had held to take
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 439/2024
Signed By:BABINDER
SINGH NEGI
14:21:34
into account the following aspects while assessing the income of the
husband. Relevant extract has been reproduced hereinbelow:
“ 84. The Delhi High Court in Bharat Hegde
v. Saroj Hegde [Bharat Hegde v. Saroj Hegde,
2007 SCC OnLine Del 622 : (2007) 140 DLT
16] laid down the following factors to be
considered for determining maintenance :
(SCC OnLine Del para 8)
“1. Status of the parties.
2. Reasonable wants of the claimant.
3. The independent income and property
of the claimant.
4. The number of persons, the nonapplicant has to maintain.
5. The amount should aid the applicant
to live in a similar lifestyle as he/she
enjoyed in the matrimonial home.
6. Non-applicant's liabilities, if any.
7. Provisions for food, clothing, shelter,
education, medical attendance and
treatment, etc. of the applicant.
8. Payment capacity of the nonapplicant.
9. Some guesswork is not ruled out while
estimating the income of the nonapplicant when all the sources or correct
sources are not disclosed.
10. The non-applicant to defray the cost
of litigation.
11. The amount awarded under Section
125 CrPC is adjustable against the
amount awarded under Section 24 of the
Act.”
13.
Accordingly, a Court, while disposing an application under
Section 24 HMA, is required to consider the income, earning capacity,
education, qualifications, liabilities as well as standard of living
enjoyed during the subsistence of marriage. Mathematical precision is
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 439/2024
Signed By:BABINDER
SINGH NEGI
14:21:34
secondary as the provision aims at delivering justice to the
aggrieved party which has no financial support.
14.
A bare perusal of the impugned order reveals that the learned
Family Court duly considered the income affidavits of both the
parties and arrived at the conclusion that the while the respondentwife was working in a Bata showroom from March 2020 till June
2024, earning a monthly sum of Rs. 7,000/-, the income of
the appellant-husband was assessed at Rs. 22,000/- per month. Taking
into consideration the aforesaid assessment, principles governing grant
of interim maintenance as well as the income disparity between the
parties, the learned Family Court deemed it fit to direct the appellant
to pay Rs. 5,000/- per month as interim maintenance to the
respondent from the date of filing of the application i.e. 08.01.2021 till
the final disposal of the Divorce Petition.
15.
For adjudication of the present appeal, this Court shall examine
whether
the
impugned
order
suffers
from
any
regard
to
infirmity warranting interference by this Court.
16.
Insofar
as
the
appellant’s
plea
with
wrong assessment of appellant’s income by the learned family court
is concerned, it is a well-settled principle that proceedings under
Section 24 HMA are summary in nature, and the Court is required
to arrive at a prima facie assessment of the income as well as financial
status of the parties. Further, learned counsel for the appellant has also
challenged the Family Court’s reliance on the Notification dated
26.09.2024 which prescribes the minimum wages in respect of
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 439/2024
Signed By:BABINDER
SINGH NEGI
14:21:34
unskilled, semiskilled and skilled employees in Delhi. It is his case
that the appellant is neither a resident of Delhi nor is he employed
there and therefore, the reliance on this notification for his income
assessment was wholly untenable.
17.
We find no merit in the aforesaid contention. Though, the
appellant is stated to be residing and working in Jagadhari, Haryana,
the prevalent minimum wages notified for the State of Haryana are
broadly similar to those in Delhi. Further, due to absence of any
credible evidence which establishes a lower income capacity of the
appellant, the assessment of his monthly income at Rs. 22,000/- for
the purpose of Section 24 HMA does not warrant any interference.
18.
In the present case, the appellant has also relied upon a salary
certificate issued by his father which reflects a monthly salary of Rs.
16,500/- which is at par with the Minimum Wages Act, 1948. From
this salary certificate, the appellant had tried to show that he is getting
the salary as per minimum wages, not more not less, from the business
of his father. We find that the said document, cannot by itself, act as a
conclusive
proof
to
establish the
appellant’s
case
as
it remains unsupported by any other cogent documentary proof. The
appellant has failed to bring on record any other documentary
evidence which supports his plea of his alleged income of Rs. 16,500/per month. Accordingly, this Court finds the quantum of interim
maintenance fixed by the learned Family Court at Rs. 5,000/- per
month to be just, fair and reasonable.
19.
Parties contesting an application filed under Section 24 HMA
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 439/2024
Signed By:BABINDER
SINGH NEGI
14:21:34
tend to conceal their real income and earning capacity. A Court is not
duty bound to accept the alleged income of a party and may draw
adverse inferences from other relevant circumstances and on the basis
of material placed before it.
20.
In Bharat Hegde v. Saroj Hegde (Supra), this Court observed
that, in the case of self-employed persons or persons employed in the
unorganised sector, truthful income may not always surface, and
therefore the Court has to take a general view while assessing
financial capacity. The relevant portion has been reproduced as under:
“8. Unfortunately, in India, parties do not
truthfully reveal their income. For self
employed persons or persons employed in the
unorganized sector, truthful income never
surfaces. Tax avoidance is the norm. Tax
compliance is the exception in this country.
Therefore,
in
determining
interim
maintenance, there cannot be mathematical
exactitude. The court has to take a general
view…”
21.
In view of the above, we do not find any infirmity with the
learned Family Court’s approach in assessing the appellant’s income.
22.
However, at this stage, it is imperative to note that the learned
counsel
for
the
appellant
has
also challenged the
impugned
order insofar as the monthly maintenance of Rs. 5,000/- per month has
been awarded to the respondent from the date of filing of her
application, i.e., from 08.01.2021. The challenge is on the ground that
the respondent herself has admitted
that she was employed as
a sales helper in Bata showroom till June 2024 and thus, the finding of
the learned Family Court in awarding maintenance w.e.f. 08.01.2021
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 439/2024
Signed By:BABINDER
SINGH NEGI
14:21:34
is erroneous and liable to be set aside.
23.
This Court finds merit in the aforesaid contention. Apart from
the petition filed under Section 25 of the Guardian and Wards Act,
1860 on 08.01.2021 by the respondent/wife, wherein, she had
stated that she is financially independent and thus capable of securing
a future for her daughter, even as per the respondent’s affidavit dated
05.11.2024 filed before the learned Family Court, she stated that while
she was employed as a sales helper in a Bata showroom on Saturdays
and Sundays for an income of Rs. 7,000/- per month, she was ousted
from her job in June 2024, as the owner of the showroom did not
require extra staff. Hence, admittedly, at the time of filing of the
maintenance application in 2021, the respondent was employed and
earning.
24.
Keeping in view the respondent’s employment from the period
of March 2020 till June 2024, it is held that she is not entitled to
the interim maintenance with effect from the date of filing of her
application, i.e., 08.01.2021 up till June 2024 as granted by the
learned Family Court.
25.
Accordingly, the present appeal is allowed to the extent that the
monthly maintenance shall be awarded to the respondent w.e.f.
01.07.2024, i.e., from the date that she became unemployed.
The appellant is thus, directed to continue paying the interim
maintenance of Rs. 5,000/- per month to the respondent, in terms of
the order of the learned Family Court w.e.f. 01.07.2024. Other terms
and conditions imposed in the impugned order by the learned Family
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 439/2024
Signed By:BABINDER
SINGH NEGI
14:21:34
Court shall continue.
26.
The present appeal, along with pending applications, stands
disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
VIVEK CHAUDHARY, J.
RENU BHATNAGAR, J.
SEPTEMBER 16, 2026/p/sm/KZ
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 439/2024
Signed By:BABINDER
SINGH NEGI
14:21:34
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review